A conserved anti-DNA antibody idiotype associated with nephritis in murine and human systemic lupus erythematosus

In order to identify unique structural features of pathogenic autoantibodies to DNA in SLE, a murine anti-anti-DNA (anti-Id) mAb (mAb 1C7) was produced in response to immunization of lupus mice with a syngeneic anti-DNA mAb (mAb 3E10). Immunization of lupus mice with mAb 3E10 inhibited production of native anti-DNA antibodies, suppressed development of lupus kidney disease (nephritis), and induced production of anti-anti-DNA (anti-Id) antibodies. mAb 1C7 bound F(ab')2 fragments of mAb 3E10, and it bound other murine anti-DNA mAb, but not murine mAb or polyclonal serum antibodies unreactive with DNA. Moreover, binding of mAb 1C7 anti-Id to mAb 3E10 was inhibited by DNA, suggesting anti-Id binding within or near the binding site for DNA. Furthermore, mAb 1C7 bound serum IgG immunoglobulins from 9/12 patients with lupus nephritis and serum anti-DNA antibodies compared to only 3/12 SLE patients with comparable serum levels of anti-DNA antibodies, but without nephritis (p = 0.04), and only 1/53 SLE patients without serum anti-DNA antibodies, 0/49 patients with rheumatoid arthritis, and 1/47 healthy subjects (p less than 0.001). These results provide evidence that mAb 1C7 identifies a conserved Id associated with anti-DNA antibodies in murine and human SLE and may be useful as a structural probe to characterize pathogenic anti-DNA antibodies in SLE.     

Failed self-tolerance and autoimmunity in IgG anti-DNA transgenic mice.

Transgenic mice were generated that express both the H and L chain genes derived from a hybridoma secreting an IgG2a mAb specific for ds- and ssDNA. This hybridoma is derived from a lupus mouse and can accelerate nephritis in young NZB x NZW F1 female mice and induce clinical nephritis in BALB/c mice. Some transgenic B cells did not exhibit allelic exclusion; they expressed both transgene-derived IgG and endogenous IgM intracellularly. Most of the B cells in transgenic mice expressed endogenous IgM, some of them expressed low levels of IgG on cell membranes. The transgenic mice, created in a strain not prone to SLE, expressed elevated serum IgG anti-DNA, and some developed clinical nephritis. The affinity of the spontaneously secreted IgG antibodies for dsDNA were similar in nephritic NZB x NZW F1 and transgenic mice. In contrast to the nontransgenic littermates, immunization of transgenic mice with murine DNA further enhanced serum levels of IgG anti-DNA in transgenic mice. Therefore, expression of transgene-encoded IgG anti-DNA mainly in the secreted form does not provide the signals necessary for allelic exclusion or self-tolerance. Expression of this Ig is sufficient to induce a mild form of autoimmune disease.     

Differential L chain expression in the antibody responses to phosphorylcholine of adult bone marrow or peritoneum-derived B lymphocytes

Lethal irradiation of adult BALB/c mice followed by reconstitution with autologous bone marrow results in loss of T15 Id and IdX expression in the responses to phosphorylcholine (PC) and alpha(1-3)-dextran, respectively. T15 Id, but not IdX expression can be reconstituted with low numbers of syngeneic, T cell-depleted peritoneal resident cells. All three groups of mice produce comparable titers of specific anti-PC and anti-dextran antibodies. The inability of adult bone marrow-reconstituted BALB/c mice to produce T15 Id+ antibodies is not due to differential VH-gene expression in bone marrow or peritoneum-derived B cells. Thus, the levels of T15 VH in total serum Ig and in anti-PC antibodies are similar in all groups of mice. Furthermore, IEF patterns of T15 VH-associated L chains directly demonstrate differential Vk repertoire expression in bone marrow and peritoneum-derived B cells.     

The NZB X SWR model of lupus nephritis. II. Autoantibodies deposited in renal lesions show a distinctive and restricted idiotypic diversity

The F1 progeny (SNF1) derived from crossing autoimmune NZB with normal SWR mice uniformly develop lethal glomerulonephritis in marked contrast to the NZB parents. In the preceding paper we found qualitative and idiotypic differences between the anti-DNA antibodies produced by the SNF1 mice and their NZB parents. We identified two clusters of interrelated cross-reactive idiotypic (CRI) families among the SNF1-derived autoantibodies. Here we analyzed the idiotypic profile of the broad spectrum of immunoglobulins deposited in the nephritic kidneys of SNF1 mice and found a restricted idiotypic diversity. To establish that the autoantibody idiotypes detected in the renal lesions were not there as a result of nonspecific trapping, five separate batches of kidney eluates obtained from 100 SNF1 kidneys were analyzed. Both during early and late stages of nephritis, the predominant and consistent idiotypic markers of antibodies in the renal lesion of SNF1 mice were those shared by the two clusters of anti-DNA CRI families. We have termed these nephritogenic idiotypic markers collectively as idiotypes-lupus nephritis-SNF1 or IdLNF1. The Id564 family that encompasses a set of SNF1-derived highly cationic anti-DNA antibodies bearing the normal SWR parent's allotype was more prominently represented in the SNF1 kidneys with early nephritis. Although cationic antibodies were prevalent, the IdLNF1 markers were present on both cationic and anionic or neutral antibodies in the renal lesions of SNF1 mice, and the Ig allotypes of both parents were equally represented in those nephritogenic antibodies. The IdLNF1 positive family of antibodies were also found in high levels in the sera of old SNF1 mice, but they could not be detected in the sera of NZB or SWR mice, nor were they present in the immunoglobulins deposited in the kidneys of rare old NZB mice. The results suggest that select families of nephritogenic idiotypes that are dormant in the autoimmune NZB and the normal SWR parents become expressed in the SNF1 progeny due to genetic and immunoregulatory defects.     

Spontaneous shift of anti-DNA antibody idiotypes in systemic lupus erythematosus

Spontaneous shift in Id expression of polyclonal anti-DNA antibodies in a patient, BS, with SLE was investigated. BS had active lupus nephritis in 1982 and developed central nervous system lupus in 1986 without evidence of active nephritis. Two rabbit polyclonal anti-Id (BS-82 and BS-86 R-anti-Id) were raised against affinity-purified anti-DNA antibodies prepared from 1982 serum (BS-82) and 1986 serum (BS-86), respectively. In addition, murine monoclonal anti-Id was prepared against BS-82 Id. Direct binding assays showed that all three anti-Id had preferential binding to the immunizing anti-DNA antibodies (the homologous Id) and poor binding to anti-DNA antibodies prepared from the different dated sample of BS. This was confirmed by inhibition assays of binding of anti-Id to the homologous Id by various Id. Moreover, inhibition assays of binding of various Id to DNA by the R-anti-Id showed that the R-anti-Id was the most effective inhibitor for the homologous Id. Testing for Id expression in serial (1982 to 1986) serum samples of BS with the R-anti-Id as probes showed that BS-82 Id declined and was undetectable after October, 1984, whereas BS-86 Id was first detectable in July, 1985, and increased by June, 1986. These results clearly demonstrate spontaneous shifts in Id expression of human anti-DNA antibodies. The phenomenon of Id shift should be considered in any future strategy for the diagnosis and therapy of human autoimmune disease by anti-Id.     

Anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. II. Expression of individual and cross-reactive idiotypes on syngeneic and homologous anti-idiotype antibodies

Syngeneic anti-(anti-Id) antibodies were prepared against BALB/c anti-A48Id antibodies, BALB/c anti-460Id monoclonal antibodies, and A/J anti-J558 IdI monoclonal antibodies. With these anti-(anti-Id) antibodies we identified cross-reactive idiotypes on syngeneic and homologous anti-A48Id and anti-460Id antibodies. By contrast, tbe idiotypic determinants of A/J anti-J558 IdI monoclonal antibodies were not shared by other syngeneic, homologous, or xenogenic anti-J558 IdI or IdX antibodies. These results suggest that idiotype-antiidiotype reactions that serve as regulatory controls within the immune system are characteristic for each particular antigen system, strain, or species and that such interactions make the system self-limited with respect to the whole antild repertoire.     

Pathogenic idiotypes of autoantibodies in autoimmunity: lessons from new experimental models of SLE

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is considered a classical autoimmune disease that involves many biological systems. Similar to other autoimmune conditions, its etiology is multifactorial entailing genetic, environmental, hormonal, and immunologic factors. In this review we demonstrate that by using a pathogenic idiotype of anti-DNA autoantibodies, it is possible to explain some of the pathogenesis and diversity of clinical and serological manifestations reported by SLE patients. The 16/6 idiotype (Id) is a representative pathogenic idiotype of anti-DNA autoantibodies. The serum titers of 16/6 Id in SLE patients correlate with clinical activity of the disease, and are deposited in afflicted tissues in SLE patients. SLE was experimentally induced in naive mice after immunization with 1 microgram of the Id. The disease is characterized clinically (proteinuria), serologically (e.g., anti-dsDNA, anti-Sm antibodies), and by pathological findings (e.g., deposition of 16/6 Id in the kidneys). The condition can be induced by other human and mouse antibodies carrying the 16/6 Id, as well as by mouse antimonoclonal-16/6 Id and by T cell lines and clones specifically reactive with 16/6 Id. There are strain-dependent differences in susceptibility to the induction of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Induction of SLE is directly correlated with the ability to respond to the 16/6 idiotype (or 16/6 Id)2 by anti-Id antibody production. It is easier to induce the disease in females, and it can be modulated by manipulation of sex hormones. Being able to identify the pathogenic idiotype allowed us to generate T suppressor (Ts) cells specific for the 16/6 Id. Treatment of mice with these T cells abrogated the disease. Our studies point to the importance of pathogenic idiotypes of autoantibodies in autoimmunity, which suggests that SLE may represent a dysregulation of a functional network of idiotypes-anti-idiotypes interactions among autoreactive B cells, T helper cells, and T suppressor cells.     

Suppression of murine lupus nephritis by administration of an anti-idiotypic antibody to anti-DNA

The suppression of pathogenic antibodies to DNA in NZB/NZW f1 female mice was achieved by repeated inoculation of the mice with a monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody (anti-Id). The anti-Id, an IgG1, kappa, was directed against a major cross-reactive idiotype (Id) on NZB/NZW IgG antibodies to DNA. One hundred micrograms of the anti-Id were inoculated i.p. every 2 wk, beginning at 6 wk of age (nondiseased mice--no circulating anti-DNA or proteinuria) or 20 wk of age (diseased mice--all with circulating anti-DNA, one-third with proteinuria). As controls, littermates received an IgG, kappa non-DNA-binding myeloma or no treatment. In the young mice, nephritis and anti-DNA antibodies appeared at the same time in all groups, and their circulating antibodies to DNA did not bear the target Id. In the older (20-wk-old) mice, survival was significantly prolonged because of delay in the onset of nephritis; the total quantities of antibodies to DNA were diminished, and the target Id, initially present on circulating IgG, was deleted. These benefits were transient; the suppression of antibodies was followed by the appearance of large quantities of anti-DNA that did not bear the major Id. Therefore, although administration of anti-Id was effective in reducing an undesirable antibody response after the target Id was present on circulating antibodies, the benefits were limited, probably by Id "switch" or by increased synthesis of pathogenic antibodies bearing a minor Id.     

The role of the idiotypic network in the induction of experimental systemic lupus erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) has been induced in C3H.SW mice by their immunization with a human monoclonal anti-DNA antibody that bears a common idiotype-16/6 Id. Following immunization, high levels of murine anti-16/6 and anti-anti-16/6 antibodies were detected in the sera of the immunized mice. Elevated titers of autoantibodies reacting with ssDNA, dsDNA, poly(I), poly(G), RNP, Ro, and La were also observed. The serological findings were associated with significant proteinuria, leukopenia, and elevated erythrocyte sedimentation rate. Immune complex deposition in the glomerular mesangium and sclerosis of the glomeruli were demonstrated. To study whether or not anti-idiotype antibodies are involved in the induction of the disease, a murine monoclonal antibody against the 16/6 Id was prepared and injected into C3H.SW mice. The anti-16/6 Id antibody induced experimental SLE similarly to the 16/6 Id with an accelerated kidney pathology. A study performed on different mouse strains indicated that the susceptibility to the induction of SLE by the 16/6 Id is strain dependent and directly correlates to their ability to produce anti-16/6 Id specific antibodies.     

IgA isotype-restricted idiotypes associated with T15 Id+ PC antibodies

Idiotypes are believed to be due to the structural conformation of the variable region of immunoglobulins (Ig). We have found an idiotype (C3-24) that requires both variable and constant regions of the heavy chain to be expressed. C3-24 Id is associated with both the T15 variable region from anti-phosphorylcholine (PC) antibodies and the constant region for the alpha-heavy chain. High titer anti-PC serum from a variety of inbred strains of different Ig haplotypes failed to express C3-24 Id. However, when IgA but not IgG or IgM fractions were isolated from a pool of anti-PC serum from BALB/c mice, more than 70% of the molecules expressed C3-24 Id. The high frequency of the expression of C3-24 Id in IgA anti-PC hybridoma proteins from mice of different Ig haplotypes and in the IgA fraction of normal anti-PC antibodies from BALB/c and presumably other strains of mice suggests that idiotypic determinants produced by the three-dimensional product of VH and CH regions may not be unusual.     

Analysis of the anti-alpha 1 leads to 3 dextran response with monoclonal anti-idiotype antibodies

The antibody response to alpha 1 leads to 3 dextran (DEX) in BALB/c mice consists of a family of closely related yet highly heterogeneous molecules. Although these antibodies have been previously characterized both idiotypically and structurally, detailed analysis of responding clones has not been possible using conventional anti-idiotype antibodies. Monoclonal syngeneic and allogeneic anti-idiotype antibodies (MAIDs) specific for anti-DEX antibodies were used in this study to dissect the serum antibody response to DEX in BALB/c mice. The constructed MAIDs showed considerable heterogeneity by isoelectric focusing and by their binding characteristics to a series of DEX specific myeloma and hybridoma proteins. The predominant heavy chain isotype of these MAIDs was gamma 1. These antibodies were used to identify individual idiotypic structures (IdI) on J558, or M104E as well as cross-reactive determinants common to both (IdX). Although both IdX and IdI MAIDs were obtained, IdI specific antibodies were obtained more frequently. BALB/c mice immunized with DEX produced antibodies expressing both IdI but in highly variable amounts. A large percentage of, but not all DEX specific antibody, could be accounted for by IdX bearing antibodies. Suppression of adult and neonatal mice by IdI specific MAIDs was effective with precise elimination of only those clones expressing IdI determinants leaving the total lambda bearing anti-DEX response intact. Suppression of adults and neonates by an IdX specific MAID resulted in a temporary and partial suppression of the total lambda bearing anti-DEX response along with total suppression of the IdX portion of the response. Unlike other systems these monoclonal antibodies produce only suppression, and under a variety of conditions enhancement of anti-DEX responses has not been observed.     

Independent expression of a regulatory idiotype on heavy and light chains. A further immunochemical analysis with anti-heavy and anti-light chain antibodies

The heavy (H) and light (L) chains of murine monoclonal autoantibody 62 reacting with thyroglobulin independently express idiotypic (Id) determinants that are very similar if not identical with the Id62 expressed on the intact protein. In this report, we describe the production and characterization of rabbit antibodies to isolated H62 and L62 chains to further prove that individual chains express Id62 in an immunogenic form. The results demonstrate that both chains are capable of eliciting antibodies that, after appropriate adsorption, behave like conventional anti-Id62 antibodies prepared against the intact antibody molecule. By direct radioimmunoassay binding, competition of Id binding and Western blot anti-H62 and anti-L62 antibodies identify as Id-positive the same group of IgG1, bind in a reciprocal fashion to H- and L-chains of parental monoclonal antibody 62, and detect Id62-positive polyclonal serum autoantibodies to thyroglobulin. We conclude that monoclonal antibody 62 expresses independently a similar Id on both polypeptide chains and the intact antibody molecule, or its isolated chains, induce qualitatively similar anti-Id responses. These results are discussed in light of the possible structure/function implication such autoantibodies may have within the Id network.     

A study of auto-anti-idiotypes to BSA

In order to study the idiotypic relationships between the antibody populations produced in different species during normal immune responses to ordinary protein Ag, we raised immune sera in mice and chickens by using three protein Ag: BSA, keyhole limpet hemocyanin, and diphtheria toxoid. An avidin-biotin ELISA was used to measure idiotypic binding between antibody populations from these sera. We found that the chicken sera contained auto-anti-idiotypes (AAI) against Ag-specific antibodies that were present in the same serum and that co-purified with those antibodies on Ag-Sepharose columns. These AAI were present in secondary response chicken anti-BSA serum at levels comparable with those of the anti-BSA antibody. The chicken AAI also react specifically with Id in mouse anti-BSA serum. The mouse anti-BSA serum completely inhibits the binding between the chicken Id and AAI. This similarity between the Id of whole populations of antibodies produced in two distantly related species, in the absence of any manipulation with idiotypic or anti-idiotypic reagents, suggests that the AAI detected in this way are internal image antibodies. It indicates there is positive selection for such AAI to be internal images.     

A public idiotypic determinant is present on spontaneous cationic IgG antibodies to DNA from mice of unrelated lupus-prone strains

A monoclonal anti-idiotypic antibody (anti-Id) to a public idiotype (Id) present on spontaneous IgG antibodies to DNA from NZB/NZW F1 mice recognized similar determinants on polyclonal and monoclonal IgG anti-DNA antibodies from mice of the unrelated MRL/lpr and BXSB strains. Incubation of the anti-Id with four of five monoclonal Id in solid phase inhibited their ability to bind DNA; however, different Id+ antibodies recognized different epitopes within the DNA molecule. Therefore, the public Id was located close to the antigen-binding regions but did not comprise all of those regions. Analysis of multiple polyclonal and monoclonal antibodies to DNA showed the Id on all subclasses of IgG. However, antibodies bearing the Id carried a neutral or cationic charge (10 of 10 monoclonals with pI greater than 7 were Id+); the presence of the Id on anionic IgG (pI less than or equal to 7) was infrequent (one of 21 serums, one of eight monoclonal antibodies). Therefore, IgG autoantibodies to DNA are constructed from closely related public idiotypes in several mouse strains that spontaneously develop lupus, and that Id is restricted to antibodies with a pI of 7 or greater.     

The NZB X SWR model of lupus nephritis. I. Cross-reactive idiotypes of monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies in relation to antigenic specificity, charge, and allotype. Identification of interconnected idiotype families inherited from the normal SWR and the autoimmune NZB parents

The incidence of lupus nephritis is low in autoimmune NZB mice, but when they are crossed with normal SWR mice, almost 100% of the female F1 hybrids (SNF1) develop lethal glomerulonephritis. In a previous study we showed that anti-DNA auto-antibodies produced by the SNF1 mice were qualitatively different from those made by the NZB parents with respect to their isotype, charge, and antigenic specificity patterns. Here we studied idiotypic cross-reactions among the 65 monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies that were derived from four NZB and seven SNF1 mice. A library of 15 anti-idiotypic antibodies were prepared by immunizing rabbits with 15 monoclonal anti-DNA antibodies selected from the panel of 65. We identified 10 cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) families among this large collection of autoantibodies. Five of these CRI families were restricted to cationic anti-DNA antibodies that were exclusively of SNF1 origin, and the strongly cross-reacting members were predominantly IgG2b auto-antibodies with the allotype of the normal SWR parent. The cationic anti-DNA CRI families could be grouped into an interrelated cluster called the Id564 cluster. The other five anti-DNA CRI families were not restricted to any particular parental allotype or charge, although two of these CRI were shared exclusively by SNF1-derived autoantibodies and four of these CRI families could also be grouped into an idiotypically interrelated cluster called the Id512 cluster. In the case of seven out of the 10 CRI families, the idiotypic determinants detected were close to the antigen-binding site of the anti-DNA antibodies. The results indicate that the idiotypic repertoire of anti-DNA autoantibodies produced by the SNF1 mice is different from the NZB parents, and potentially pathogenic (cationic) antibodies produced by the SNF1 mice that are encoded by genes from the normal SWR parent can be identified as distinct CRI families. In the accompanying paper we demonstrate the role of these anti-DNA CRI families in the development of lupus nephritis.     

Shared idiotope on monoclonal anti-Ia.7 antibodies reactive with determinants in a structural domain of the I-E molecules

In previous studies, heterologous anti-idiotypic (anti-Id) antisera against the C3H.SW 14-4-4S or the A.TH 41.A anti-Ia.7 monoclonal antibodies (mAb) were shown to identify an interstrain cross-reactive idiotypic specificity (IdX.Ia.7) expressed on monoclonal or conventional anti-Ia.7 alloantibodies. The objective of the present investigation was to characterize further this IdX at the idiotopic level. To this end, 11 hybridomas producing IgG1, IgG2a, or IgM anti-Id mAb were derived from a rat immunized with a mixture of 10 A.TH or A.BY anti-Ia.7 mAb. The specificity of the latter anti-Id mAb was determined by direct Id binding radioimmunoassay (RIA) with the use of a panel of 52 anti-Ia mAb derived from hybridomas produced in various inbred mouse strains. These rat anti-Id mAb recognized idiotopes expressed on i) all anti-Ia.7 mAb against determinants in the topographic domain I of the I-Ek molecule but not on 18 other anti-I-Ek mAb directed at epitopes in domains II or III; ii) three of 19 anti-I-Ak mAb; and iii) one A.TL-derived anti-I-As mAb. Competitive Id binding assays revealed that among the 14 IdX+ anti-Ia.7 mAb, one (81.B) was bound to a lesser extent by various rat anti-Id mAb, suggesting that heterogeneity probably exists in this antibody family. By contrast, two isologous (B10.S(7R)) anti-Id mAb to the IdX.Ia.7+ mAb 41.A displayed a specificity restricted to 41.A individual idiotopes (IdI). Rat anti-IdX.Ia.7 and mouse anti-41.A IdI mAb inhibited the binding of 125I-labeled mAb 41.A to CBA spleen cells. These two sets of mAb bound in a noncompetitive fashion to mAb 41.A-coated plates, indicating that their corresponding public or private idiotopes were spatially distinct. These data may have implications for in vivo manipulations of anti-Ia immune responses.     

A pathogenic monoclonal antibody, G8, is characteristic of antierythrocyte autoantibodies from Coombs'-positive NZB mice.

With age, NZB mice develop anti-RBC autoantibodies resulting in the development of autoimmune hemolytic anemia. We now have evidence that this spontaneous autoantibody response consists of antibodies that are similar in specificity and Id expression to a pathogenic autoantibody (G8) that was cloned from an autoimmune NZB mouse. Similar to autoantibodies eluted from Coombs'-positive mouse E (MRBC), the G8 mAb recognizes native (unmodified) MRBC but not RBC from other species. Interestingly, G8 and four additional mAb bind with a higher titer to bromelain-treated MRBC than to native MRBC. Nucleotide sequence analysis reveals, however, that unlike "natural" antibodies that react solely with bromelain-MRBC, G8 is encoded by a J558 VH gene and a V kappa 12,13 L-chain gene. Thus G8 is clearly distinct from antibodies to bromelain-MRBC which are encoded by unrelated V genes. Instead, the sequence of the G8 VH chain was found to be nearly identical to that of an anti-DNA mAb derived from an MRL-lpr/lpr mouse. The results suggest Coombs'-positive autoantibodies from NZB mice are not derived from "natural" antibodies, but rather, consist of a restricted set of autoantibodies expressing the G8 IdX.     

Monoclonal anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of Igha BALB/c and Ighb C.B20 mice display striking similarities

Allotype Ighb congenic C.B20 mice when immunized with dextran B1355S are unable to produce anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies that express the VH-associated cross-reactive IdX idiotype. This intrastrain-specific idiotype is normally associated only with the anti-dextran response of Igha mice of which BALB/c is a prototype strain. In this study we have obtained monoclonal hybridoma antibodies specific for the alpha (1----3) glucosidic linkage of dextran from C.B20 mice that were presensitized with rabbit anti-IdX antibodies. These antibodies display the light chain isotype distribution, the H chain amino terminal sequence, share VH-associated IdX idiotypic determinants, and finally the similar fine specificity for dextrans observed for anti-alpha (1----3) dextran antibodies of BALB/c mice.     

Idiotope structure and genetic diversity in anti-streptococcal group A carbohydrate antibodies

Three cross-reactive idiotopes(Id), termed IdX, IdI-1, and Id5, that are present on free L chains from murine anti-group A streptococcal carbohydrate antibodies have been mapped; these Id distinguish between products of three homologous V kappa genes. For each determinant, sequence analysis of anti-streptococcal group A carbohydrate antibody V domains yielded small numbers of amino acids invariably associated with Id expression. Flow micro-fluorimetry was used to isolate three IdI-1- spontaneous mutants of the IdI-1+ hybridoma GAC 39; all had single amino acid changes in the L chain at position 60 and 77, all retained other Id, and all bound group A carbohydrate. Computer modeling was used to examine spatial relationships between Id. A number of the conserved Id5 and IdX residues cluster in the L chain framework region 1 around the first back loop connecting strands of the beta pleated sheets, and overlap at residue 15 (Id5, proline; IdX, leucine). This overlap accords with the mutually exclusive expression of Id5 and IdX. The IdI-1 loss variants have mutations of residues 60 or 77 on adjacent back loops, approximately 7.5 and 14 A from residue 15. Competitive inhibition of anti-IdX and anti-IdI-1 binding to antibodies expressing both Id can be attributed to steric hindrance. The framework back loops may be favored sites for cross-reactive Id expressed by products of a single V region gene. IdI-3a, an individual Id not associated with use of a particular gene segment, has been localized in part to residue 31 (hypervariable region 1) of the H chain.