Oxygen binding properties of non-mammalian nerve globins

Oxygen-binding globins occur in the nervous systems of both invertebrates and vertebrates. While the function of invertebrate nerve haemoglobins as oxygen stores that extend neural excitability under hypoxia has been convincingly demonstrated, the physiological role of vertebrate neuroglobins is less well understood. Here we provide a detailed analysis of the oxygenation characteristics of nerve haemoglobins from an annelid (Aphrodite aculeata), a nemertean (Cerebratulus lacteus) and a bivalve (Spisula solidissima) and of neuroglobin from zebrafish (Danio rerio). The functional differences have been related to haem coordination: the haem is pentacoordinate (as in human haemoglobin and myoglobin) in A. aculeata and C. lacteus nerve haemoglobins and hexacoordinate in S. solidissima nerve haemoglobin and D. rerio neuroglobin. Whereas pentacoordinate nerve globins lacked Bohr effects at all temperatures investigated and exhibited large enthalpies of oxygenation, the hexacoordinate globins showed reverse Bohr effects (at least at low temperature) and approximately twofold lower oxygenation enthalpies. Only S. solidissima nerve haemoglobin showed apparent cooperativity in oxygen binding, suggesting deoxygenation-linked self-association of the monomeric proteins. These results demonstrate a remarkable diversity in oxygenation characteristics of vertebrate and invertebrate nerve haemoglobins that clearly reflect distinct physiological roles.     

Structure and reactivity of hexacoordinate hemoglobins

The heme prosthetic group in hemoglobins is most often attached to the globin through coordination of either one or two histidine side chains. Those proteins with one histidine coordinating the heme iron are called "pentacoordinate" hemoglobins, a group represented by red blood cell hemoglobin and most other oxygen transporters. Those with two histidines are called "hexacoordinate hemoglobins", which have broad representation among eukaryotes. Coordination of the second histidine in hexacoordinate Hbs is reversible, allowing for binding of exogenous ligands like oxygen, carbon monoxide, and nitric oxide. Research over the past several years has produced a fairly detailed picture of the structure and biochemistry of hexacoordinate hemoglobins from several species including neuroglobin and cytoglobin in animals, and the nonsymbiotic hemoglobins in plants. However, a clear understanding of the physiological functions of these proteins remains an elusive goal.     

Surprising differences in the respiratory protein of insects: A spectroscopic study of haemoglobin from the European honeybee and the malaria mosquito

Only recently it was discovered that haemoglobin (Hb) belongs to the standard gene repertoire of insects, although their tracheal system is used for respiration. A classical oxygen-carrying function of Hb is only obvious for hexapods living in hypoxic environments. In other insect species, including the common fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, the physiological role of Hb is yet unclear. Here, we study recombinant haemoglobin from the European honeybee Apis mellifera (Ame) and the malaria mosquito Anopheles gambiae (Aga). Spectroscopic evidence shows that both proteins can be classified as hexacoordinate Hbs with a strong affinity for the distal histidine. AgaHb1 is proposed to play a role in oxygen transport or sensing based on its multimeric state, slow autoxidation, and small but significant amount of five-coordinated haem in the deoxy ferrous form. AmeHb appears to behave more like vertebrate neuroglobin with a complex function given its diversified distribution in the genome.     

Characterization of nonsymbiotic tomato hemoglobin

The nonsymbiotic tomato hemoglobin SOLly GLB1 (Solanum lycopersicon) is shown to form a homodimer of approximately 36 kDa with a high affinity for oxygen. Furthermore, our combined ultraviolet/visible, resonance Raman, and continuous wave electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements reveal that a mixture of penta- and hexacoordination of the heme iron is found in the deoxy ferrous form, whereas the ferric form shows predominantly a bis-histidine ligation (F8His-Fe(2+/3+)-E7His). This differs from the known forms of vertebrate hemoglobins and myoglobins. We have successfully applied our recently designed pulsed-EPR strategy to study the low-spin ferric form of tomato hemoglobin. These experiments reveal that, in ferric SOLly GLB1, one of the histidine planes is rotated 20 degrees (+/-10 degrees ) away from a N(heme)-Fe-N(heme) axis. Additionally, the observed g-values indicate a quasicoplanarity of the histidine ligands. From the HYSCORE (hyperfine sublevel correlation) measurements, the hyperfine and nuclear quadrupole couplings of the heme and histidine nitrogens are identified and compared with known EPR/ENDOR data of vertebrate Hbs and cytochromes. Finally, the ligand binding kinetics, which also indicate that the ferrous tomato Hb is only partially hexacoordinated, will be discussed in relation with the heme-pocket structure. The similarities and differences with other known nonsymbiotic plant hemoglobins will be highlighted.     

Zebrafish reveals different and conserved features of vertebrate neuroglobin gene structure, expression pattern, and ligand binding

Neuroglobin has been identified as a respiratory protein that is primarily expressed in the mammalian nervous system. Here we present the first detailed analysis of neuroglobin from a non-mammalian vertebrate, the zebrafish Danio rerio. The zebrafish neuroglobin gene reveals a mammalian-type exon-intron pattern in the coding region (B12.2, E11.0, and G7.0), plus an additional 5'-non-coding exon. Similar to the mammalian neuroglobin, the zebrafish protein displays a hexacoordinate deoxy-binding scheme. Flash photolysis kinetics show the competitive binding on the millisecond timescale of external ligands and the distal histidine, resulting in an oxygen affinity of 1 torr. Western blotting, immune staining, and mRNA in situ hybridization demonstrate neuroglobin expression in the fish central nervous system and the retina but also in the gills. Neurons containing neuroglobin have a widespread distribution in the brain but are also present in the olfactory system. In the fish retina, neuroglobin is mainly present in the inner segments of the photoreceptor cells. In the gills, the chloride cells were identified to express neuroglobin. Neuroglobin appears to be associated with mitochondria-rich cell types and thus oxygen consumption rates, suggesting a myoglobin-like function of this protein in facilitated oxygen diffusion.     

Ethylisocyanide equilibria of hemoglobins M Iwate, M Boston, M Hyde Park, M Saskatoon, and M Milwaukee-I in half-ferric and fully reduced states.

The ethylisocyanide equilibria of all the five known hemoglobins M, namely Hb M Iwate (alpha287 Tyrbeta2), Hb M Boston (alpha258 Tyrbeta2), Hb M Hyde Park (alpha2beta292 Tyr), Hb M Saskatoon (alpha2beta263 tyr), and Hb M Milwaukee-I (alpha2beta267 Glu), were studied both in the half-ferric and fully reduced heme states. In the half-ferric state, no heme-heme interaction was observed for Hb M Iwate, Hb M Boston, and Hb M Hyde Park, but Hb M Saskatoon and Hb M Milwaukee-I show small but definite heme-heme interaction with Hill's n of 1.3. The beta chain mutants, Hb M Hyde Park and Hb M Saskatoon, have almost normal affinity for ethylisocyanide and a normal Bohr effect, whereas the alpha chain mutants, Hb M Iwate and Hb M Boston, have abnormally low affinity and almost no Bohr effect. Hb M Milwaukee-I showed a large Bohr effect and low affinity. These results are consistent qualitatively with those on oxygen equilibria reported previously. In the fully reduced state, in which all four hemes were in the ferrous state and capable of binding ethylisocyanide distinct differences were found in the extent of heme-heme interaction. Namely, the n values for proximal histidine mutants, Hb M Iwate and Hb M Hyde Park, were 1.1 and 1.0, respectively, whereas the distal histidine mutants, Hb M Boston and Hb M Saskatoon, showed high n values of 2.4 and 1.6, respectively. Hb M Milwaukee-I also exhibited a high n value of 2.0 The ethylisocyanide affinity of the four histidine mutants was high compared with that of Hb A, while that for Hb M Milwaukee-I was almost normal. All five Hbs M had approximately normal magnitudes of Bohr effect. In the half-ferric state, the proximal and distal histidine mutants of the same chain showed similar affinity for ethylisocyanide and Bohr effect, rather different from those of the mutants of the opposite chain. These differences seem to be derived from the difference of abnormal bonding of ferric iron to tyrosine or glutamic acid. On the other hand, the reduction of iron, which abolished the abnormal bonding and made all of the chains capable of binding ligand, extinguished the differences of alpha and beta chains, and the effect of amino acid side chains close to iron on ligand binding properties became clear. Proximal histidine, which is considered to trigger the transition between the T and R states, seems to be essential to the heme-heme interaction.     

Plant hemoglobins may be maintained in functional form by reduced flavins in the nuclei,and confer differential tolerance to nitro‐oxidative stress

The heme of bacteria, plant and animal hemoglobins (Hbs) must be in the ferrous state to bind O₂ and other physiological ligands. Here we have characterized the full set of non‐symbiotic (class 1 and 2) and ‘truncated’ (class 3) Hbs of Lotus japonicus. Class 1 Hbs are hexacoordinate, but class 2 and 3 Hbs are pentacoordinate. Three of the globins, Glb1‐1, Glb2 and Glb3‐1, are nodule‐enhanced proteins. The O₂ affinity of Glb1‐1 (50 pm ) was the highest known for any Hb, and the protein may function as an O₂ scavenger. The five globins were reduced by free flavins, which transfer electrons from NAD(P)H to the heme iron under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Class 1 Hbs were reduced at very fast rates by FAD, class 2 Hbs at slower rates by both FMN and FAD, and class 3 Hbs at intermediate rates by FMN. The members of the three globin classes were immunolocalized predominantly in the nuclei. Flavins were quantified in legume nodules and nuclei, and their concentrations were sufficient to maintain Hbs in their functional state. All Hbs, except Glb1‐1, were expressed in a flavohemoglobin‐deficient yeast mutant and found to confer tolerance to oxidative stress induced by methyl viologen, copper or low temperature, indicating an anti‐oxidative role for the hemes. However, only Glb1‐2 and Glb2 afforded protection against nitrosative stress induced by S‐nitrosoglutathione. Because this compound is specifically involved in transnitrosylation reactions with thiol groups, our results suggest a contribution of the single cysteine residues of both proteins in the stress response.     

Steric factors moderate conformational fluidity and contribute to the high proton sensitivity of Root effect hemoglobins

The structural basis of the extreme pH dependence of oxygen binding to Root effect Hbs is a long-standing puzzle in the field of protein chemistry. A previously unappreciated role of steric factors in the Root effect was revealed by a comparison of pH effects on oxygenation and oxidation processes in human Hb relative to Spot (Leiostomus xanthurus) and Carp (Cyprinodon carpio) Hbs. The Root effect confers five-fold increased pH sensitivity to oxygenation of Spot and Carp Hbs relative to Hb A(0) in the absence of anionic effectors, and even larger relative elevations of pH sensitivity of oxygenation in the presence of 0.2M phosphate. Remarkably, the Root effect was not evident in the oxidation of the Root effect Hbs. This finding rules out pH-dependent alterations in the thermodynamic properties of the heme iron, measured in the anaerobic oxidation reaction, as the basis of the Root effect. The alternative explanation supported by these results is that the elevated pH sensitivity of oxygenation of Root effect Hbs is attributable to globin-dependent steric effects that alter oxygen affinity by constraining conformational fluidity, but which have little influence on electron exchange via the heme edge. This elegant mode of allosteric control can regulate oxygen affinity within a given quaternary state, in addition to modifying the T-R equilibrium. Evolution of Hb sequences that result in proton-linked steric barriers to heme oxygenation could provide a general mechanism to account for the appearance of the Root effect in the structurally diverse Hbs of many species.     

Plants,humans and hemoglobins

New developments have forced a re-evaluation of our understanding of the structure and function of hemoglobins. Leghemoglobins regulate oxygen affinity through a mechanism different from that of myoglobin using a novel combination of heme pocket amino acids that lower the oxygen affinity. The hexacoordinate hemoglobins are characterized by intramolecular coordination of the ligand binding site at the heme iron, and were first identified in plants as the 'non-symbiotic plant hemoglobins'. They are now known to be present in animals and bacteria. Many of these proteins are upregulated in both plants and animals during hypoxia or similar stresses. Therefore, there might be a common physiological function for hexacoordinate hemoglobins in plants and animals.     

Allosteric water and phosphate effects in Hoplosternum littorale hemoglobins.

This paper reports the results obtained using the osmotic stress method applied to the purified cathodic and anodic hemoglobins (Hbs) from the catfish Hoplosternum littorale, a species that displays facultative accessorial air oxygenation. We demonstrate that water potential affects the oxygen affinity of H. littorale Hbs in the presence of an inert solute (sucrose). Oxygen affinity increases when water activity increases, indicating that water molecules stabilize the high-affinity state of the Hb. This effect is the same as that observed in tetrameric vertebrate Hbs. We show that both anodic and cathodic Hbs show conformational substrates similar to other vertebrate Hbs. For both Hbs, addition of anionic effectors, especially chloride, strongly increases the number of water molecules bound, although anodic Hb did not exhibit sensitivity to saturating levels of ATP. Accordingly, for both Hbs, we propose that the deoxy conformations coexist in at least two anion-dependent allosteric states, T(o) and T(x), as occurs for human Hb. We found a single phosphate binding site for the cathodic Hb.     

Modulation of the oxygen affinity of cobalt-porphyrin by globin

We have combined two extreme effects which influence the oxygen affinity to obtain a cobalt-based oxygen carrier with an affinity similar to that of human adult hemoglobin (HbA). The goal was to obtain an oxygen transporter with a lower oxidation rate. Exchange of the heme group (Fe-protoporphyrin IX) in Hb with a cobalt-porphyrin leads to a reduction in oxygen affinity by over a factor of 10, an oxygen affinity too low for use as a blood substitute. At the other extreme, certain globin sequences are known to provide a very high oxygen affinity; for example, Hb Ascaris displays an oxygen affinity 1000 times higher than HbA. We demonstrate here that these opposing effects can be additive, yielding an oxygen affinity similar to that of HbA, but with oxygen binding to a cobalt atom. We have tested the effect of substitution of cobalt-porphyrin for heme in normal HbA, sperm whale (SW) Mb (Mb), and high affinity globins for leghemoglobin, two trematode Hbs: Paramphistomum epiclitum (Pe) and Gastrothylax crumenifer (Gc). As for HbA or SW Mb, the transition from heme to cobalt-porphyrin in the trematode Hbs leads to a large decrease in the oxygen affinity, with oxygen partial pressures for half saturation (P(50)) of 5 and 25 mm Hg at 37 degrees C for cobalt-Pe and cobalt-Gc, respectively. A critical parameter for Hb-based blood substitutes is the autoxidation rate; while both metals oxidize to an inactive state, we observed a decrease in the oxidation rate of over an order of magnitude for cobalt versus iron, for similar oxygen affinities. The time constants for autoxidation at 37 degrees C were 250 and 100 h for Pe and Gc, respectively.     

Site-specific cross-linking of human and bovine hemoglobins differentially alters oxygen binding and redox side reactions producing rhombic heme and heme degradation

Chemically modified human or bovine hemoglobins (Hb) have been developed as oxygen-carrying therapeutics and are currently under clinical evaluation. Oxidative processes, which are in many cases enhanced when modifications are introduced that lower the oxygen affinity, can limit the safety of these proteins. We have carried out a systematic evaluation of two modified human Hbs (O-R-polyHbA(0) and DBBF-Hb) and one bovine Hb (polyHbBv). We have both measured the oxidative products present in the Hb preparations and followed the oxidative reactions during 37 degrees C incubations. Autoxidation, the primary oxidative reaction which initiates the oxidative cascade, is highly correlated with P(50) (R = 0.987; p < 0.002). However, when the results for the other oxidative processes are compared, two different classes of oxidative reactions are identified. The formation of oxyferrylHb, like the rate of autoxidation, increases for all modified Hbs. However, the subsequent reactions, which lead to heme damage and eventually heme degradation, are enhanced for the modified human Hbs but are actually suppressed for bovine-modified Hbs. The rhombic heme measured by electron paramagnetic resonance, which is the initial step that causes irreversible damage to the heme, is found to be a reliable measure of the stability of ferrylHb and has the tendency to produce degradation products. DBBF-Hb, a Hb-based oxygen carrier (HBOC) for which toxic side effects have been well documented, has the highest level of rhombic heme (41-fold greater than for HbA(0)), even though its rate of autoxidation is relatively low. These findings establish the importance of these secondary oxidative reactions over autoxidation in evaluating the toxicity of HBOCs.     

Trematode hemoglobins show exceptionally high oxygen affinity.

Ligand binding studies were made with hemoglobin (Hb) isolated from trematode species Gastrothylax crumenifer (Gc), Paramphistomum epiclitum (Pe), Explanatum explanatum (Ee), parasitic worms of water buffalo Bubalus bubalis, and Isoparorchis hypselobagri (Ih) parasitic in the catfish Wallago attu. The kinetics of oxygen and carbon monoxide binding show very fast association rates. Whereas oxygen can be displaced on a millisecond time scale from human Hb at 25 degrees C, the dissociation of oxygen from trematode Hb may require a few seconds to over 20 s (for Hb Pe). Carbon monoxide dissociation is faster, however, than for other monomeric hemoglobins or myoglobins. Trematode hemoglobins also show a reduced rate of autoxidation; the oxy form is not readily oxidized by potassium ferricyanide, indicating that only the deoxy form reacts rapidly with this oxidizing agent. Unlike most vertebrate Hbs, the trematodes have a tyrosine residue at position E7 instead of the usual distal histidine. As for Hb Ascaris, which also displays a high oxygen affinity, the trematodes have a tyrosine in position B10; two H-bonds to the oxygen molecule are thought to be responsible for the very high oxygen affinity. The trematode hemoglobins display a combination of high association rates and very low dissociation rates, resulting in some of the highest oxygen affinities ever observed.     

Cyanide binding to hexacoordinate cyanobacterial hemoglobins: hydrogen-bonding network and heme pocket rearrangement in ferric H117A Synechocystis hemoglobin

The truncated hemoglobin (Hb) from the cyanobacterium Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803 is a bis-histidyl hexacoordinate complex in the absence of exogenous ligands. This protein can form a covalent cross-link between His117 in the H-helix and the heme 2-vinyl group. Cross-linking, the physiological importance of which has not been established, is avoided with the His117Ala substitution. In the present work, H117A Hb was used to explore exogenous ligand binding to the heme group. NMR and thermal denaturation data showed that the replacement was of little consequence to the structural and thermodynamic properties of ferric Synechocystis Hb. It did, however, decelerate the association of cyanide ions with the heme iron. Full complexation required hours, instead of minutes, of incubation at optical and NMR concentrations. At neutral pH and in the presence of excess cyanide, binding occurred with a first-order dependence on cyanide concentration, eliminating distal histidine decoordination as the rate-limiting step. The cyanide complex of the H117A variant was characterized for the conformational changes occurring as the histidine on the distal side, His46 (E10), was displaced. Extensive rearrangement allowed Tyr22 (B10) to insert in the heme pocket and Gln43 (E7) and Gln47 (E11) to come in contact with it. H-bond formation to the bound cyanide was identified in solution with the use of (1)H(2)O/(2)H(2)O mixtures. Cyanide binding also resulted in a change in the ratio of heme orientational isomers, in a likely manifestation of heme environment reshaping. Similar observations were made with the related Synechococcus sp. PCC 7002 H117A Hb, except that cyanide binding was rapid in this protein. In both cases, the (15)N chemical shift of bound cyanide was reminiscent of that in peroxidases and the orientation of the proximal histidine was as in other truncated Hbs. The ensemble of the data provided insight into the structural cooperativity of the heme pocket scaffold and pointed to the reactive 117 site of Synechocystis Hb as a potential determinant of biophysical and, perhaps, functional properties.     

Heme Orientation of Cavity Mutant Hemoglobins (His F8 → Gly) in Either α or β Subunits: Circular Dichroism, 1H NMR,and Resonance Raman Studies

Native human adult hemoglobin (Hb A) has mostly normal orientation of heme, whereas recombinant Hb A (rHb A) expressed in E. coli contains both normal and reversed orientations of heme. Hb A with the normal heme exhibits positive circular dichroism (CD) bands at both the Soret and 260‐nm regions, while rHb A with the reversed heme shows a negative Soret and decreased 260‐nm CD bands. In order to examine involvement of the proximal histidine (His F8) of either α or β subunits in determining the heme orientation, we prepared two cavity mutant Hbs, rHb(αH87G) and rHb(βH92G), with substitution of glycine for His F8 in the presence of imidazole. CD spectra of both cavity mutant Hbs did not show a negative Soret band, but instead exhibited positive bands with strong intensity at the both Soret and 260‐nm regions, suggesting that the reversed heme scarcely exists in the cavity mutant Hbs. We confirmed by ¹H NMR and resonance Raman (RR) spectroscopies that the cavity mutant Hbs have mainly the normal heme orientation in both the mutated and native subunits. These results indicate that the heme Fe‐His F8 linkage in both α and β subunits influences the heme orientation, and that the heme orientation of one type of subunit is related to the heme orientation of the complementary subunits to be the same. The present study showed that CD and RR spectroscopies also provided powerful tools for the examination of the heme rotational disorder of Hb A, in addition to the usual ¹H NMR technique. Chirality 28:585–592, 2016. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Structural studies on a low oxygen affinity hemoglobin from mammalian species: Sheep (Ovis aries)

Hemoglobin (Hb) is in equilibrium between low affinity Tense (T) and high affinity Relaxed (R) states associated with its unliganded and liganded forms, respectively. Mammalian species can be classified into two groups on the basis of whether they express ‘high’ and ‘low’ oxygen affinity Hbs. Although Hbs from former group have been studied extensively, a limited number of structural studies have been performed for the low oxygen affinity Hbs. Here, the crystal structure of low oxygen affinity sheep methemoglobin (metHb) has been determined to 2.7 Å resolution. Even though sheep metHb adopts classical R state like quaternary structure, it shows localized quaternary and tertiary structural differences compared with other liganded Hb. The critical group of residues in the “joint region”, shown as a major source of quaternary constraint on deoxyHb, formed unique interactions in the α1β2/α2β1 interfaces of sheep metHb structure. In addition, the constrained β subunits heme environment and the contraction of N-termini and A-helices of β subunits towards the molecular dyad are observed for sheep metHb structure. These observations provide the structural basis for a low oxygen affinity and blunt response to allosteric effector of sheep Hb.     

Rice hemoglobins. Gene cloning, analysis, and O2-binding kinetics of a recombinant protein synthesized in Escherichia coli.

Although nonsymbiotic hemoglobins (Hbs) are found in different tissues of dicots and monocots, very little is known about hb genes in monocots and the function of Hbs in nonsymbiotic tissues. We report the cloning and analysis of two rice (Oryza sativa L.) hb genes, hb1 and hb2, that code for plant Hbs. Rice hb1 and hb2 genes contain four exons and three introns, as with all of the known plant hb genes. At least three copies of the hb gene were detected in rice DNA, and analysis of gene expression shows that hb1 and hb2 are expressed in leaves but only hb1 is expressed in roots. A cDNA for rice Hb1 was expressed in Escherichia coli, and the recombinant Hb (rHb1) shows an unusually high affinity for O2 because of a very low dissociation constant. The absorbance spectra of the ferric and deoxyferrous rHb1 indicate that, in contrast to symbiotic Hbs, a distal ligand is coordinated to the ligand-binding site. Mutation of the distal His demonstrates that this residue coordinates the heme Fe of ferric and deoxyferrous rHb1 and stabilizes O2 in oxy-rHb1. The biochemical properties of rice rHb1 suggest that this protein probably does not function to facilitate the diffusion of O2.     

Control of the allosteric equilibrium of hemoglobin by cross-linking agents

The kinetics of ligand rebinding have been studied for modified or cross-linked hemoglobins (Hbs). Several compounds were tested that interact with alpha Val 1 or involve a cross-link between alpha Val 1 and alpha Lys 99 of the opposite dimer. By varying the length of certain cross-linking molecules, a wide range in the allosteric equilibrium could be obtained. Several of the mono-aldehyde modified Hbs show a shift toward the high affinity conformation of Hb. At the other extreme, for certain di-aldehyde cross-linked Hbs, the CO kinetics are typical of binding to deoxy Hb, even at low photodissociation levels, with which the dominant photoproduct is the triply liganded species; in these cases the hemoglobin does not switch from the low to high affinity state until after the fourth ligand is bound. Although each modified Hb shows only two distinct rates, the kinetic data as a function of dissociation level cannot be simulated with a simple two-state model. A critical length is observed for the maximum shift toward the low affinity T-state. Longer or shorter lengths of the cross-linker yielded more high affinity R-state. Unlike native Hb, which is in equilibrium with free dimers, the cross-linked Hbs maintain the fraction slow kinetics, which is unique to Hb tetramers, even at 0.5 microM (total heme). Addition of HbCN to unmodified HbCO solutions results in dimer exchange, which decreases the relative fraction of slow bimolecular kinetics; the cross-linked Hbs did not show such an effect, indicating that they do not participate in dimer exchange.