Resistance of Bacillus subtilis Spores to Inactivation by Gamma Irradiation and Heating in the Presence of a Bactericide: III. Factors Affecting Rates of Inactivation by Phenylmercuric Nitrate

Aqueous suspensions of Bacillus subtilis NCTC 8236 spores, surviving gamma irradiation from a cesium-137 source, exhibited an enhanced rate of inactivation compared to nonirradiated spores when heated with 0.04% phenylmercuric nitrate. The enhanced rate of inactivation, observable from survival curves, was noted when spores were irradiated with 150,000 rad under air in either the presence or absence of the bactericide. The magnitude of the enhanced inactivation rate increased as the irradiation dose under air increased from 150,000 to 300,000 rad. The inactivation rates of spores surviving irradiation with 150,000 rad under either oxic or anoxic conditions did not exhibit a simple quantitative relationship. The enhancement effect was observed when the severity of the heat treatment was increased by either reducing the pH from 8 to 6 or raising the temperature from 70 to 90 C.     

Resistance of Bacillus subtilis Spores to Inactivation by Gamma Irradiation and Heating in the Presence of a Bactericide: I. Suitability of Viable Count Procedures

A statistical evaluation of viable count procedures utilized for obtaining treatment survival curve data for Bacillus subtilis NCTC 8236 spores is described. Within the various recovery conditions tested, incubation on nutrient agar containing 1% dextrose for 48 hr at 37 C was found to promote the highest count of viable spores surviving a variety of bactericidal treatments involving gamma irradiation, heat, and chlorocresol. The count of viable spores on the medium was not significantly altered when the dextrose was added to the nutrient agar either before autoclaving or aseptically at 50 to 55 C from a solution sterilized by filtration. The volume of medium which promoted the highest count of viable spores was 20 ml per 85 mm of diameter in disposable plastic plates. Counts of viable spores were reproducible on successive batches of media. The carry-over of variable concentrations of chlorocresol into the medium from serial dilutions affected the count of viable spores. Spores in the aqueous stock suspension used for all experiments were uniformly distributed after shaking and did not diminish significantly in viability after 16 months of storage at 5 C. Grouping of indexes of dispersion, calculated from quintuplicate plate colony counts, indicated that the suitability of the viable count procedures, employed for the enumeration of spores surviving the various bactericidal treatments, tended to diminish as the level of spore inactivation exceeded 95%.     

Resistance of Bacillus Spores to Combined Sporicidal Treatments

S ummary . Moist heat at 82° (100° for Bacillus stearothermophilus ) and solutions of 0.2% w/v chlorocresol or 0.01% w/v benzalkonium chloride at 24° separately showed no sporicidal activity against B. pumilis, B. stearothermophilus, B. subtilis and B. subtilis var. niger . Spores of the last organism were the most sensitive to γ radiation, the D value being 0.16 Mrad. Prior irradiation with a dose of 0.16 Mrad brought about only a slight increase in the sensitivity of the spores to moist heat. The presence of bactericide during irradiation did not affect radiation resistance. Inactivation rates were greater when the spores were heated in the presence of a bactericide than in aqueous suspension and benzalkonium chloride was more active than chlorocresol. Chlorocresol enhanced the heat activation of B. stearothermophilus at 100°. Irradiation in the presence of 0.2% w/v chlorocresol or 0.01% w/v benzalkonium chloride had no effect on the subsequent resistance of the spores when heated in the presence of these bactericides. It is concluded that it is unlikely that combinations of moist heat, radiation and bactericides, each less severe than when used in an accepted sterilization process, will lead to an alternative process which, while less damaging to the materials being sterilized, would still maintain the accepted standards of freedom from contamination.     

Inactivation of Clostridium perfringens Type A Spores at Ultrahigh Temperatures

The inactivation of Clostridium perfringens type A spores (three strains of different heat resistances) at ultrahigh temperatures was studied. Aqueous spore suspensions were heated at 85 to 135 C by the capillary tube method. When survivors were enumerated on the standard plating medium, the spores appeared to have been rapidly inactivated at temperatures above 100 C. The addition of lysozyme to the plating medium did not affect the recovery of spores surviving the early stages of heating, but lysozyme was required for maximal recovery of spores surviving extended heat treatments. The percentage of survivors requiring lysozyme for colony formation increased greatly with longer exposure times or increasing treatment temperature. Time-survivor curves indicated that each spore suspension was heterogeneous with respect to the heat resistance of spore outgrowth system or in the sensitivity of the spores to lysozyme. Recovery of survivors on the lysozyme containing medium revealed greater heat resistance for one strain than has been reported for spores of many mesophilic aerobes and anaerobes. The spores of all three strains were more resistant to heat inactivation when suspended in phosphate buffer, but a greater percentage of the survivors required lysozyme for colony formation.     

Sensitization of Clostridium perfringens spores to heat by gamma radiation.

Spores of Clostridium perfringens, type A, were given separate or sequential treatments of gamma radiation (0 to 0.7 Mrad) and/or high temperature (93 to 103 degrees C). Prior heating, sufficient to inactivate 40 to 99% of the viable spores, had no effect on the subsequent radiation inactivation rate. Prior irradiation had a sensitizing effect on subsequently heated spores. The degree of sensitization to heat, as measured by thermal inactivation rate, increased with increased radiation pretreatment dose.     

Sensitization of Clostridium perfringens spores to heat by gamma radiation.

Spores of Clostridium perfringens, type A, were given separate or sequential treatments of gamma radiation (0 to 0.7 Mrad) and/or high temperature (93 to 103 degrees C). Prior heating, sufficient to inactivate 40 to 99% of the viable spores, had no effect on the subsequent radiation inactivation rate. Prior irradiation had a sensitizing effect on subsequently heated spores. The degree of sensitization to heat, as measured by thermal inactivation rate, increased with increased radiation pretreatment dose.     

Inactivation of Geobacillus stearothermophilus spores by high-pressure carbon dioxide treatment

High-pressure CO2 treatment has been studied as a promising method for inactivating bacterial spores. In the present study, we compared this method with other sterilization techniques, including heat and pressure treatment. Spores of Bacillus coagulans, Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus cereus, Bacillus licheniformis, and Geobacillus stearothermophilus were subjected to CO2 treatment at 30 MPa and 35 degrees C, to high-hydrostatic-pressure treatment at 200 MPa and 65 degrees C, or to heat treatment at 0.1 MPa and 85 degrees C. All of the bacterial spores except the G. stearothermophilus spores were easily inactivated by the heat treatment. The highly heat- and pressure-resistant spores of G. stearothermophilus were not the most resistant to CO2 treatment. We also investigated the influence of temperature on CO2 inactivation of G. stearothermophilus. Treatment with CO2 and 30 MPa of pressure at 95 degrees C for 120 min resulted in 5-log-order spore inactivation, whereas heat treatment at 95 degrees C for 120 min and high-hydrostatic-pressure treatment at 30 MPa and 95 degrees C for 120 min had little effect. The activation energy required for CO2 treatment of G. stearothermophilus spores was lower than the activation energy for heat or pressure treatment. Although heat was not necessary for inactivationby CO2 treatment of G. stearothermophilus spores, CO2 treatment at 95 degrees C was more effective than treatment at 95 degrees C alone.     

Inactivation of Bacillus piliformis spores by heat and certain chemical disinfectants

The inactivation of Tyzzer's organism (Bacillus piliformis) spore isolated from rats by heat and various chemical disinfectants was studied. The spores were from B. piliformis-infected rat liver tissues. The spore suspension (10(4) 50% of rat liver lesion producing dose with prednisolone treatment/ml) was treated with heart or disinfectants. Inactivation of the spores was examined in experimentally infected rats. Rats were inoculated perorally with a treated spore suspension and injected subcutaneously with prednisolone. On the sixth day after inoculation, rats were examined grossly for liver lesions. Spores were inactivated at 80 degrees C for 15 min but not at 60 degrees C for 30 min. Spores were inactivated by 0.4% peracetic acid, 0.015% sodium hypochrolite, 1% iodophol, 5% phenol. Alcide and 0.37% formaldehyde solution, but not by 0.037% formaldehyde solution, 70% ethanol, 0.3% benzethonium chloride solution, 3% cresol and soap solution, or 4% chlorhexidine digluconate. These findings suggest that B. piliformis spores are relatively sensitive to heat and certain chemical disinfectants.     

Inactivation of Bacillus spores in reconstituted skim milk by combined high pressure and heat treatment

AIMS: To determine the resistance of a variety of Bacillus species spores to a combined high pressure and heat treatment; and to determine the affect of varying sporulation and treatment conditions on the level of inactivation achieved. METHODS AND RESULTS: Spores from eight Bacillus species (40 isolates) were high pressure-heat treated at 600 MPa, 1 min, initial temperature 72 degrees C. The level of inactivation was broad (no inactivation to 6 log10 spores ml(-1) reduction) and it varied within species. Different sporulation agar, high pressure equipment and pressure-transmitting fluid significantly affected the response of some isolates. Varying the initial treatment temperature (75, 85 or 95 degrees C) shifted the relative order of isolate high pressure-heat resistance. CONCLUSIONS: The response of Bacillus spores to combined high pressure-heat treatment is variable and can be attributed to both intrinsic and extrinsic factors. The combined process resulted in a high level of spore inactivation for several Bacillus species and is a potential alternative treatment to traditional heat-only processes. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: Sporulation conditions, processing conditions and treatment temperature all affect the response of Bacillus spores to the combined treatment of high pressure and heat. High levels of spore inactivation can be achieved but the response is variable both within and between species.     

Thermoradiation Inactivation of Naturally Occurring Bacterial Spores in Soil

Samples of soil collected from the Kennedy Space Center near the spacecraft assembly facilities were found to contain microorganisms very resistant to conventional sterilzation techniques. The inactivation kinetics of the naturally occurring spores in soil were investigated by using dry heat and ionizing radiation, first separately and then simultaneously. Dry-heat inactivation kinetics of spores was determined at 105 and 125 C; radiation inactivation kinetics was determined for dose rates of 660 and 76 krads/h at 25 C. Simultaneous combinations of heat and radiation were then investigated at 105, 110, 115, 120, and 125 C, with a dose rate of 76 krads/h. Combined treatment was found to be highly synergistic, requiring greatly reduced radiation doses to accomplish sterilization of the population.     

Combined Effects of High Hydrostatic Pressure and Temperature for Inactivation of Bacillus anthracis Spores

Spores of Bacillus anthracis are known to be extremely resistant to heat treatment, irradiation, desiccation, and disinfectants. To determine inactivation kinetics of spores by high pressure, B. anthracis spores of a Sterne strain-derived mutant deficient in the production of the toxin components (strain RP42) were exposed to pressures ranging from 280 to 500 MPa for 10 min to 6 h, combined with temperatures ranging from 20 to 75°C. The combination of heat and pressure resulted in complete destruction of B. anthracis spores, with a D value (exposure time for 90% inactivation of the spore population) of approximately 4 min after pressurization at 500 MPa and 75°C, compared to 160 min at 500 MPa and 20°C and 348 min at atmospheric pressure (0.1 MPa) and 75°C. The use of high pressure for spore inactivation represents a considerable improvement over other available methods of spore inactivation and could be of interest for antigenic spore preparation.     

Pressure Inactivation of Bacillus Endospores

The inactivation of bacterial endospores by hydrostatic pressure requires the combined application of heat and pressure. We have determined the resistance of spores of 14 food isolates and 5 laboratory strains of Bacillus subtilis, B. amyloliquefaciens, and B. licheniformis to treatments with pressure and temperature (200 to 800 MPa and 60 to 80°C) in mashed carrots. A large variation in the pressure resistance of spores was observed, and their reduction by treatments with 800 MPa and 70°C for 4 min ranged from more than 6 log units to no reduction. The sporulation conditions further influenced their pressure resistance. The loss of dipicolinic acid (DPA) from spores that varied in their pressure resistance was determined, and spore sublethal injury was assessed by determination of the detection times for individual spores. Treatment of spores with pressure and temperature resulted in DPA-free, phase-bright spores. These spores were sensitive to moderate heat and exhibited strongly increased detection times as judged by the time required for single spores to grow to visible turbidity of the growth medium. The role of DPA in heat and pressure resistance was further substantiated by the use of the DPA-deficient mutant strain B. subtilis CIP 76.26. Taken together, these results indicate that inactivation of spores by combined pressure and temperature processing is achieved by a two-stage mechanism that does not involve germination. At a pressure between 600 and 800 MPa and a temperature greater than 60°C, DPA is released predominantly by a physicochemical rather than a physiological process, and the DPA-free spores are inactivated by moderate heat independent of the pressure level. Relevant target organisms for pressure and temperature treatment of foods are proposed, namely, strains of B. amyloliquefaciens, which form highly pressure-resistant spores.     

Increased inactivation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by protraction of UV irradiation.

The principle of equi-effectivity of the product of intensity and exposure time (principle of Bunsen-Roscoe) of UV irradiation has been assumed to be valid for the inactivation of microorganisms in general. Earlier studies claimed higher survival of Escherichia coli B/r with fractionated irradiation compared with single-exposure survival. However, data on the inactivation effect of protraction of UV irradiation are not available. By means of a specially designed UV irradiation apparatus which secured absolute UV dose measurements throughout the experiments, the effects of variation of UV irradiation intensities (253.7 nm) and exposure times were tested on the inactivation of a bacterial virus (Staphylococcus aureus phage A994), a vegetative bacterial strain (E. coli ATCC 25922), and bacterial spores (Bacillus subtilis ATCC 6633) as well as three haploid laboratory strains (RC43a, YNN281, and YNN282) and two diploid strains (commercial bakery yeast strain and laboratory strain YNN281 x YNN282) or yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and spores of the latter diploid yeast strain. Each test organism was exposed to three UV intensities (0.02, 0.2, and 2 W/m2), with corresponding exposure times resulting in three dose levels for each intensity. Differences in inactivation rates were tested by analyses of variance and Newman-Keuls tests. Virus and bacteria showed no differences in inactivation rates by variation of intensities and exposure times within selected UV doses; hence, the principle of Bunsen-Roscoe could not be rejected for these strains. However, in the eukaryotic test strains of S. cerevisiae longer exposure times with lower intensities led to enhanced inactivation in both haploid and diploid strains, with a more pronounced effect in the diploid yeast strains, whereas in yeast spores in this dose rate effect could not be observed.     

Initiation of Germination and Inactivation of Bacillus pumilus Spores by Hydrostatic Pressure

The effect of hydrostatic pressures as high as 1,700 atm at 25 C on the heat and radiation resistance of Bacillus pumilus spores was studied. Phosphate-buffered spores were more sensitive to compression than spores suspended in distilled water. Measurements of the turbidity of suspensions, the viability, refractility, stainability, dry weight, and respiratory activity of spores, and calcium and dipicolinic acid release were made for different pressures and times. Initiation of germination occurred at pressures exceeding 500 atm and was the prerequisite for inactivation by compression. The rate of initiation increased with increasing pressure at constant temperature. This result is interpreted as a net decrease in the volume of the system during initiation as a result of increased solvation of the spore components.     

Inactivation of Geobacillus stearothermophilus Spores by High-Pressure Carbon Dioxide Treatment

High-pressure CO₂ treatment has been studied as a promising method for inactivating bacterial spores. In the present study, we compared this method with other sterilization techniques, including heat and pressure treatment. Spores of Bacillus coagulans, Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus cereus, Bacillus licheniformis, and Geobacillus stearothermophilus were subjected to CO₂ treatment at 30 MPa and 35°C, to high-hydrostatic-pressure treatment at 200 MPa and 65°C, or to heat treatment at 0.1 MPa and 85°C. All of the bacterial spores except the G. stearothermophilus spores were easily inactivated by the heat treatment. The highly heat- and pressure-resistant spores of G. stearothermophilus were not the most resistant to CO₂ treatment. We also investigated the influence of temperature on CO₂ inactivation of G. stearothermophilus. Treatment with CO₂ and 30 MPa of pressure at 95°C for 120 min resulted in 5-log-order spore inactivation, whereas heat treatment at 95°C for 120 min and high-hydrostatic-pressure treatment at 30 MPa and 95°C for 120 min had little effect. The activation energy required for CO₂ treatment of G. stearothermophilus spores was lower than the activation energy for heat or pressure treatment. Although heat was not necessary for inactivationby CO₂ treatment of G. stearothermophilus spores, CO₂ treatment at 95°C was more effective than treatment at 95°C alone.     

Inactivation of Lactobacillus Bacteriophage PL-1 by Microwave Irradiation

The effect of microwave irradiation on the survival of bacteriophage PL-1, which is specific for Lactobacillus casei, was studied using a commercial 2,450 MHz microwave oven. The phages were inactivated by microwave irradiation according to almost first-order reaction kinetics. The rate of phage inactivation was not affected by the difference in the continuous or intermittent irradiation, nor by the concentrations of phages used, but was affected by the volume of phage suspensions, which prevented the loss of generated heat. Microwave irradiation of phage suspensions produced a number of ghost phages with empty heads, but fragmentation of the tail was hardly noticed. The breakage of phage genome DNA was primarily caused by the heat generated by microwave irradiation, whereas the phage DNA was not affected by the same temperature achieved by heat from outside. Thus we concluded that the phage-inactivating effect of microwave irradiation was mainly attributed to a thermal microwave effect, which was much stronger than a simple thermal exposure.     

Inactivation of bacteria and spores by pulse electric field and high pressure CO2 at low temperature

The common methods for inactivation of bacteria involve heating or exposure to toxic chemicals. These methods are not suitable for heat-sensitive materials, food, and pharmaceutical products. Recently, a complete inactivation of many microorganisms was achieved with high-pressure carbon dioxide at ambient temperature and in the absence of organic solvent and irradiation. The inactivation of spores with CO(2) required long residence time and high temperatures, such as 60 degrees C. In this study the synergistic effect of pulsed electric field (PEF) in combination with high-pressure CO(2) for inactivation was investigated. The bacteria Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus aureus, and Bacillus cereus were suspended in glycerol solution and treated in the first step with PEF (up to 25 KV/cm) and then with high-pressure CO(2) not higher than 40 degrees C and 200 bar. The inactivation efficiency was determined by counting the colony formation units of control and sample. Samples of the cells subjected to PEF treatment alone and in combination with CO(2) treatment were examined by scanning electron microscopy to determine the effect of the processes on the cell wall. Experimental results indicate that the viability decreased with increasing electrical field strength and number of pulses. A further batch treatment with supercritical CO(2) lead to complete inactivation of bacterial species and decreased the count of the spores by at least three orders of magnitude, the inactivation being enhanced by an increase of contact time between CO(2) and the sample. A synergistic effect between the pulsed electric field and the high-pressure CO(2) was evident in all the species treated. The new low temperature process is an alternative for pasteurization of thermally labile compounds such as protein and plasma and minimizes denaturation of important nutrient compounds in the liquid media.     

The Effect of Freezing on the Radiation Sensitivity of Bacterial Spores

S ummary : Bacillus pumilus spores, irradiated under aerobic conditions, were inactivated exponentially at the same rate whether they were at room temperature (10–13°) in phosphate buffer or at -79° in phosphate buffer or in heart infusion broth.
Clostridium welchii spores were irradiated in Robertson's cooked meat medium under anaerobic conditions. With unheated spores, and those subjected to a heat shock before irradiation, the inactivation rate was the same at room temperature and -79°. The same applied to spores heat shocked after irradiation for doses up to 450 Krads, but above this dose level the spores irradiated frozen were more sensitive.
The effect of the heat shock, whether applied before or after irradiation, was to increase the number of survivors, and the proportionate increase appeared to vary with dose.     

Heat-induced temperature sensitivity of outgrowing Bacillus cereus spores

Inactivation of Bacillus cereus spores during cooling (10 degrees C/h) from 90 degrees C occurred in two phases. One phase occurred during cooling from 90 to 80 degrees C; the second occurred during cooling from 46 to 38 degrees C. In contrast, no inactivation occurred when spores were cooled from a maximum temperature of 80 degrees C. Inactivation of spores at a constant temperature of 45 degrees C was induced by initial heat treatments from 80 to 90 degrees C. The higher temperatures accelerated the rate of inactivation. Germination of spores was required for 45 degrees C inactivation to occur; however, faster germination was not the cause of accelerated inactivation of spores receiving higher initial heat treatments. Repair of possible injury was not observed in Trypticase soy broth (BBL Microbiology Systems), peptone, beef extract, starch, or L-alanine at 30 or 35 degrees C. Microscopic evaluation of spores outgrowing at 45 degrees C revealed that when inactivation occurred, outgrowth halted at the swelling stage. Inhibition of protein synthesis by chloramphenicol at the optimum temperature also stopped outgrowth at swelling; thus protein synthesis may play a role in the 45 degree C inactivation mechanism.