Diagnostic sensitivity and specificity of pulmonary cytology: comparison of techniques used in conjunction with flexible fiber optic bronchoscopy

We examined the accuracy of pulmonary cytology in 224 consecutive patients being evaluated for lung cancer. The diagnostic yeild of specimens obtained by various methods, including flexible fiber optic bronchoscopy (FFB), was compared. Among 69 patients with lung cancer, a cytologic diagnosis was made in 87%, including 73% with peripheral tumors. Prebronchoscopy sputa were positive in 50%, bronchial washings in 63%, postbronchoscopy sputa in 82% and bronchial brushings in 59% of the patients. In only one patient was the bronchial brush specimen the only positive cytologic specimen. Normal FFB and small cell undifferentiated cancer were found with increased frequency (P less than 0.05) among the nine patients (13%) with false-negative cytology. Among 155 patients with nonmalignant lung disease, 16 (10%) had false-positive specimens; this finding was significantly related (P less than 0.05) to necrotizing pneumonia in 13 of the 16 patients (81%). The overall diagnostic accuracy of cytology showed 87% sensitivity and 90% specificity, and the predictive value of a positive specimen was 79%. In the absence of necrotizing pneumonia these values exceeded 95%.     

Cytologic evaluation of bronchoalveolar lavage specimens in immunosuppressed patients with suspected opportunistic infections

The role of bronchoalveolar lavage cytology in the diagnostic evaluation of immunosuppressed patients with suspected opportunistic pulmonary infections was evaluated by comparing two groups of patients who underwent fiberoptic bronchoscopy. Bronchoalveolar lavage specimens were compared with other available diagnostic techniques, including bronchial washings, bronchial brushings, transbronchial lung biopsies and open lung biopsy. Prior to the initiation of a protocol for bronchoalveolar lavage, a specific etiology for the pulmonary infiltrate using the above combined modalities was identified in 23 of 47 cases, for an overall diagnostic rate of 49%. The combined bronchial washings and brushings (cytologic procedures) identified a specific etiology in 9 of 47 (19%) of the cases. There were ten cases in which a cytologically identifiable organism (Pneumocystis, virus or fungus) was not present in the bronchial washings and brushings and one missed case of malignancy, for a false-negative rate of 23%. With the addition of the lavage technique and better sampling of the distal airways, a specific etiology for the pulmonary infiltrate was identified in 32 of 48 (67%) of the cases. This is comparable to the values of 40% to 65% cited in the literature for diagnosis of infectious disease by open lung biopsy. The lavage cytologic procedure identified a specific etiology in 22 of 48 (46%) of the cases, and the false-negative rate was reduced to 6%. With the excellent sampling of the bronchoalveolar lavage and the improved cytology results, the need for transbronchial or open lung biopsy has been eliminated in immunosuppressed patients with suspected opportunistic pulmonary infections. This allows these patients to be studied on an outpatient basis.     

Fine needle aspiration biopsy versus sputum and bronchial material in the diagnosis of lung cancer. A comparative study of 168 patients

A group of 168 consecutive lung cancer patients in whom a definitive diagnosis of primary lung cancer was established either in a conventional cytologic specimen of sputum or bronchial material or in a specimen obtained by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was reviewed to compare the relative accuracies between the modalities of sputum and bronchial material on one hand versus FNA cytology on the other in the diagnosis of lung cancer. The patients included in the study were selected from a total of 1,093 patients who had been diagnosed and treated for lung cancer at Duke University Medical Center over the five-year period of January 1, 1980, through December 31, 1984. In 325 (29.8%) of the 1,093 patients, a definitive cancer diagnosis was established from histopathologic study alone, without any cytologic diagnoses. In 420 patients (38.4%), both histologic and cytologic material had been interpreted as being conclusively diagnostic for lung cancer. In 348 patients (31.8%), a cytologic diagnosis of lung cancer was made without a histologic confirmation. Thus, in a total of 768 (70.3%) of the 1,093 cases, a definitive cytologic diagnosis of cancer had been made. Of these 768 patients, 168 had been evaluated by both conventional respiratory cytologic methods (examination of sputum and bronchial material) and with FNA biopsy cytology. In 9 patients (5.4%), only conventional respiratory cytologic specimens were conclusively diagnostic for cancer. In 122 patients (72.6%), only the FNA biopsy specimen was diagnostic. In 37 patients (22.0%), both conventional respiratory specimens and FNA specimens yielded a definitive lung cancer diagnosis. The FNA specimen was the only positive cytologic specimen in 90.2% of large cell undifferentiated carcinomas, 79.5% of adenocarcinomas, 66.7% of small cell undifferentiated carcinomas and 58.2% of squamous cell carcinomas. In 26.5% of the patients, a diagnosis of cancer could have been established on conventional cytologic specimens, without the necessity of proceeding to percutaneous FNA biopsy. From this study, it is concluded that the techniques of conventional respiratory cytology and FNA biopsy cytology are complementary in the diagnosis of lung cancer. While the percentage of lung cancers diagnosed by FNA biopsy cytology alone is much greater than that obtained by conventional respiratory cytology alone, more than one-fourth of these cancers could be detected by the less invasive techniques of sputum collection and bronchoscopy.     

Giant-cell carcinoma of the lung. A cytologic study

A case of giant-cell carcinoma of the lung, confirmed at autopsy, is presented. The cytologic features seen in sputum samples, bronchial washings and brushings and fine needle aspiration biopsy material as well as the histologic findings are described. The possible relationship to bronchioloalveolar carcinoma is discussed. The cytologic features of giant-cell carcinoma of the lung, when seen in the context of the clinical and radiologic setting, should allow the cytologic identification of the tumor prior to surgical intervention.     

Bronchial brushing cytology features of primary malignant fibrous histiocytoma of the lung. A case report

BACKGROUND: Malignant fibrous histiocytoma (MFH) of the lung is rare. Early diagnosis is very important because of its poor prognosis. Long-term survivors of pulmonary MFH are patients who had surgical resection. When the patient can undergo surgery after a prompt diagnosis, the prognosis improves more than with other therapy. However, it is not easy to establish the diagnosis of thoracic MFH. In general, the small fragments from bronchial or percutaneous transthoracic fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies are inadequate for cytologic or pathologic analysis. Bronchial brushing cytology is greatly superior to FNA cytology because one can obtain a large amount of cells. Therefore, bronchial brushing cytology may play a useful role in diagnosis when endobronchial involvement is found. CASE: A 65-year-old female was admitted with a cough, yellow sputum and exertional dyspnea. A chest roentgenogram showed a 12 x 12-cm mass in the left lung field. Bronchial brushing cytology revealed many fibroblastlike, histiocytelike, bizarre and multinucleated giant cells in a background of necrosis. Atypical mitotic figures were also found. The cytologic findings strongly suggested MFH. Although the pathologic findings from FNA biopsy showed storiform clusters structured by pleomorphic, fibroblastlike cells with bizarre nuclei and mitotic figures, the material was too small to diagnose it definitively. Six months later the patient died. An autopsy confirmed the diagnosis of MFH: the typical storiform clusters were composed of many fibroblastlike and histiocytelike cells that were positive for CD68 (PGM1) antibody. CONCLUSION: Bronchial brushing cytology may be a useful method for early, definitive diagnosis of MFH. The presence of pleomorphic, spindle-shaped fibroblastlike and histiocytelike cells with the clusters showing a storiform pattern may permit the diagnosis of MFH.     

Positive predictive value of fine needle aspiration cytology of breast lesions

The predictive value of fine needle aspiration (FNA) was assessed in 1,181 consecutive cases of breast lesions in which cytologic abnormalities were reported. The positive predictive value (PPV) of an FNA cytologic report of atypia, suspicious or positive was 0.49, 0.95 or 0.996, respectively. In the presence of a suspicious/positive report by both physical examination and mammography, the PPV of a cytologic report of suspicious was 0.99. The PPV was directly correlated with age, partly due to the incidence of fibroadenomas among younger patients; fibroadenomas were present in 53 of 146 cases with a false FNA report of atypia, in 10 of 19 cases with a false FNA report of suspicious and in 2 of 2 cases with a false FNA report of positive. Overall, 93 cases reported as benign by physical examination and mammography were biopsied on the basis of the FNA cytologic report; cancers were diagnosed in 33 of these 93 cases (6 cancers among 42 women less than 40 years old and 27 cancers among 51 women greater than 39 years old). The widespread use of FNA cytology to study breast lesions is thus recommended, without regard to patient age and even in the presence of clinically benign findings, since the increase in the rate of cancer detection is worth the excess of unnecessary biopsies. The predictive value of a positive report of FNA cytology, or even of a suspicious report in the presence of clinical suspicion, is so high that an intraoperative frozen section biopsy might be spared in such cases.     

Renal fine needle aspiration cytology

OBJECTIVE: To audit and evaluate the pitfalls in renal fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective analysis of 180 renal FNAs from 163 patients, encountered at Canberra Hospital, Australian Capital Territory, between June 1989 and July 1997 was undertaken. The FNA procedures had been performed by radiologists under computed tomography (CT) or ultrasound (US) guidance. The study correlated the FNA results with biopsy findings and clinical outcome. RESULTS: The initial cytologic diagnoses included 84 (47%) benign, 6 (3%) atypical, 7 (4%) suspicious, 70 (39%) malignant and 13 (7%) inadequate. Six of the 13 cytologically inadequate group, on further investigation, had malignant histology. The benign cytologic categories contained 79 benign conditions and 5 cases with a malignant outcome. The atypical cytologic group contained 5 benign and 1 malignant case. All nine cytologically suspicious cases had malignant histology. The cytologically malignant group contained 62 malignant, 7 benign and 1 patient lost to follow-up. The sensitivity was 92.5%, specificity was 91.9%, positive predictive value was 89.9%, negative predictive value was 94.0%, and efficacy of the test was 92.2%. CONCLUSION: Renal FNA can provide an accurate diagnosis in most instances; however, aspiration cytology of the kidney has limitations and pitfalls. Low grade renal cell carcinoma has to be differentiated from oncocytoma, angiomyolipoma, renal infarct and reactive conditions. Renal FNA has a high negative predictive value, which is useful in reassuring patients with radiologically and cytologically benign lesions. Negative FNA does not exclude malignancy in the presence of a radiologic suspicion.     

Transbronchial needle aspiration in the diagnosis of malignant and benign pulmonary disease

The key diagnoses in respiratory cytology are infections , eg, virus and fungus, and cancer , which in essence is small cell carcinoma vs nonsmall cell carcinoma, or metastases. The basic specimens include exfoliative specimens, including sputum (increasingly uncommon), bronchial cytology (washings, brushings), and bronchoalveolar lavage, and FNA biopsy specimens, including percutaneous, bronchoscopic, and endoscopic ultrasound biopsies. All are cytologically similar. The lecture will review basic respiratory cytology as well as diagnosis and differential diagnosis of reactive and neoplastic pulmonary diseases.     

Endoscopic suction cytology in upper gastrointestinal tract malignancy

In 50 cases of radiographically suspected malignancies of the upper gastrointestinal (GI) tract, the lesions were sampled by suctioning following brushing and forceps biopsy. The cytologic smears prepared from the suctioned material were positive for malignancy in 48 cases (96%), as were the biopsy specimens; the cytologic smears from the brushings were positive in 92% of the cases. All 50 cases were diagnosed as malignant by one or more of the techniques. Suction cytology detected the ulcerated and stenotic growths that biopsy failed to diagnose in two cases. Endoscopic suction cytology, which is a simple and rapid procedure, seems able to assist in diagnosing lesions of the upper GI tract.     

The recognition of Pneumocystis carinii in routine Papanicolaou-stained smears

Using definite criteria it is possible to accurately evaluate routine Papanicolaou-stained cytologic smears for the presence or absence of Pneumocystis carinii. Strict attention must be paid to the cellular environment and the background material intimately associated with the cells. In 133 cytology specimens evaluated from proximal and deep bronchial washings and brushings, 71 were considered positive for P. carinii and 62 were called negative. Ten of the latter were either unsatisfactory or equivocal. The 71 positives correlated in every instance with parallel Grocott methenamine silver-stained transbronchial biopsies or brushings. Fifty-one of the 52 satisfactory cytologic negatives also correlated with the biopsy and brushing findings. There was a single false negative. This high degree of correlation indicates that the Papanicolaou-stained specimen can be a valuable tool in the early diagnosis of pneumocystosis.     

Cytomorphology of the variants of small-cell carcinoma of the lung

Cytologic classification of subtypes of small-cell carcinoma of the lung (SCCL) was retrospectively performed on respiratory material of 90 cases of lung carcinoma cytologically diagnosed as SCCL. Additionally, the cytologic material was reexamined for the presence of variants of SCCL in 68 cases of lung carcinoma whose types had not been conclusively defined by cytology. The type of lung cytology specimens reviewed were sputa, bronchial washings and brushings and fine needle aspirations. The study included review of pretreatment tumor histology, when present, and examination of the ultrastructure of the tumor in selected cases whose type had not been well defined by histology. Subtype recognition depended on the adequacy of the specimens rather than on the type of cytologic material examined. The cytologic subtyping was generally in agreement with the histologic subtyping of the tumor, except for cases in which SCCL was combined with other types of lung carcinoma, where certain discrepancies were noted.     

Ultrasound-guided fine needle aspiration cytology of impalpable breast lesions in a rural setting. Comparison of cytology with imaging and final outcome

OBJECTIVE: To analyze the effectiveness of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in a multidisciplinary setting in rural Australia and to compare the imaging (mammographic and ultrasound) appearances and cytomorphologic findings with the final outcome. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective analysis of ultrasound-guided FNA cytology results from 426 women, aged 40-86 years, with screening-detected mammographic abnormalities. Cases of microcalcification, assessed mainly by stereotactatic core biopsy, were not included in the study. The FNAs were performed at a rural breast screening and assessment program in New South Wales, Australia, over a three-year period between May 1993 and May 1996. RESULTS: Imaging, FNA and combined imaging and FNA results from 426 women were as follows. The imaging diagnoses included 176 (41%) benign, 34 (8%) probably benign, 17 (4%) equivocal, 104 (24%) suspicious and 95 (23%) malignant cases. The FNA findings showed 59 (14%) no epithelial cells seen (nondiagnostic), 175 (41%) benign, 36 (8%) atypical, 41 (10%) suspicious and 115 (27%) malignant. Combined imaging and cytologic results comprised 224 (52.6%) benign, 10 (2.3%) atypical/equivocal, 59 (13.9%) suspicious and 133 (31.2%) malignant cases. All the malignant cases, by combined assessment, had malignant histology, and all the benign cases behaved in a benign fashion. In 80% of the suspicious lesions, the histologic diagnosis was malignant, but only 10% of the atypical/equivocal lesions had malignant histology. The positive predictive value of diagnosis of malignancy by combined imaging and FNA was 100%, and the false negative rate was 0%. CONCLUSION: Despite the recent surge in the popularity of core biopsy, FNA cytology of impalpable, mammographically detected lesions, when practiced in a multidisciplinary setting, is an extremely accurate test with high sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and efficacy. FNA cytology of the breast is a well-tolerated, relatively noninvasive test with a very low risk of complications. The sensitivity and positive predictive values for malignant and suspicious mammographic categories are also very high.     

Diagnostic use of mean nuclear area and nuclear DNA content in preoperative breast cancer cytology

OBJECTIVE: Fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of breast lumps is a routine procedure, and the diagnostic accuracy can be 95%. Occasional discrepancies arise, and it would be valuable to have additional parameters for accurate diagnosis. We evaluated nuclear DNA content and mean nuclear area (MNA) using image cytometry in the diagnosis of preoperative breast cancers by FNA in those with a discrepancy between clinical, radiologic and cytologic diagnoses. STUDY DESIGN: One hundred eighteen consecutive preoperative FNA samples were evaluated for nuclear DNA and MNA and were compared to cytologic and postoperative histologic diagnoses. RESULTS: Sensitivity, accuracy and positive predictive value of routine cytology were 95%, 90%, 95% as compared to nuclear DNA (66%, 66%, 96%) and MNA (61%, 61%, 97%). Combining these 3 parameters gave a sensitivity of 97%, accuracy of 94% and positive predictive value of 99%. CONCLUSION: These results demonstrate that nuclear DNA and MNA combined with routine cytology may be useful adjuncts in preoperative breast cancer cytologic diagnosis when discrepancies arise. This may lead to better and more accurate planning of treatment regimens in preoperative breast cancer patients.     

Diagnostic significance of "severe dysplasia" in sputum cytology

The diagnostic significance of a cytologic diagnosis of "severe dysplasia" on sputum samples was assessed. In a group of 46 patients with diagnoses of severe dysplasia, follow-up showed no malignancy of the lung in 25 patients (54%) and a malignant process in 21 patients (46%). These groups were compared to 52 patients with correct negative and 202 patients with correct positive sputum diagnoses. Of the patient characteristics investigated, age, previous sputum production, vital capacity and low forced expiratory volume were not significantly related to a sputum cytodiagnosis of severe dysplasia. In contrast, severe dyspnea showed a significantly higher frequency in patients with a sputum cytodiagnosis of severe dysplasia, but without an underlying malignant lung process. Follow-up disclosed a malignant tumor in 10 of 13 patients with disease; the presence of severely dysplastic cells in sputum specimens from such patients should be considered a warning signal for an underlying malignant lung process. Since severe dysplasia should be considered a premalignant epithelial lesion, patients with sputum cytodiagnoses of severe dysplasia should undergo bronchoscopy, with multiple bronchial brushings of all areas showing suspicious mucosal changes, together with segmental bronchial washings. In case a malignant process cannot be located, sputum examinations should be repeated at three-month intervals.     

Value of fine needle aspiration cytology in the initial diagnosis of Hodgkin's disease. Analysis of 188 cases with an emphasis on diagnostic pitfalls

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy and pitfalls of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in the initial evaluation of Hodgkin's disease (HD) and to assess the influence of the pathologist's experience by comparing the results during two periods. STUDY DESIGN: A total of 170 cytodiagnoses of HD were reviewed and compared with those on the final histopathologic report. Thirty-three cases of HD with a previous, different cytologic diagnosis were also selected. In all the cases under study, FNA was performed as part of the initial diagnostic approach. From a practical perspective, diagnostic errors were divided into major or minor according to the consequences on patient management. RESULTS: Fifteen cytologic diagnoses of HD were followed by a different histologic diagnosis after lymph node biopsy. In 33 cases of HD an erroneous cytologic diagnosis was given prior to biopsy. The sensitivity of the series was 82.4% (86.1% excluding nonrepresentative cases). The positive predictive value reached 91.2%. Sensitivity varied from 79.3% in the first period (1982-1990) to 84.9% in the second (1991-1999) (83.3% and 88.2%, respectively, excluding nonrepresentative cases). Similarly, the positive predictive value increased from 89% to 92.8%. Diagnostic errors with important consequences for patient management diminished from 14 in the first period to 5 in the second. CONCLUSION: Cytology offers a rapid and accurate approach not only for the diagnosis of recurrent HD but also for its initial recognition. These results increase the capacity of FNA as a first-level diagnostic technique in the screening of lymphadenopathies.     

Analysis of fine needle aspiration cytology of the breast: a review of 1,297 cases and correlation with histologic diagnoses

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology of the breast and to ascertain its usefulness. STUDY DESIGN: The authors reviewed 1,297 cases of FNA cytology of the breast which were performed at Chonnam National University Hospital from 1999 to 2002. Cytologic diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses in 457 cases that underwent both cytologic and histologic examination. RESULTS: Of 1,297 cases, 1,201 (92.6%) were satisfactory and 96 (7.4%) unsatisfactory. Subsequent histologic examination was performed on 291 cases (29.7%) out of 981 "benign" lesions, 28 (73.7%) of 38 "suspicious," 124 (68.1%) of 182 "malignant" and 14 (14.6%) of 96 "unsatisfactory." FNA cytology revealed 77.7% sensitivity, 99.2% specificity, 98.4% positive predictive value and 88.0% negative predictive value. Diagnostic accuracy was 91.1%. Of the 291 benign cases on cytology, 35 cases were malignancy on histology. Of the 124 cases reported as malignant, 2 were benign. Interpretive error was the leading cause of false positive diagnoses. CONCLUSION: Although FNA cytology is a useful diagnostic procedure for the evaluation of breast lesions, it should be combined with other diagnostic modalities, such as physical examination, ultrasonography and mammography.     

Evaluation of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules

FNA cytology of 112 patients with thyroid nodules seen in a 5-year period in a general hospital setting, and the histology obtained from the 53 operated patients, were retrospectively analysed. the inadequacy rate of FNA cytology was 11%, sensitivity was 84% (16/19), specificity was 52% (15/29), positive predictive value was 53% (16/30) and negative predictive value was 83% (15/18). Extrapolating these figures to the whole study group a negative predictive value of 95% is put forward as a more realistic figure. the results and the clinical pitfalls of the use of FNA cytology in diagnosing thyroid nodules are discussed. the authors conclude that FNA cytology is a reliable first diagnostic step in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules, even in a general hospital setting.     

Cytomorphology of granular-cell tumor of the bronchus. A case report

The cytologic features of a bronchial granular-cell tumor clinically mimicking a bronchogenic carcinoma are presented. Distinctive granular cells similar to the main cellular components of the surgical specimen were found in abundance in bronchial brushings and washings obtained during bronchoscopy. Our findings and conclusions confirm previously published studies. Granular-cell tumors of the bronchus can easily be diagnosed on cytologic examination if the entity is considered in the differential diagnosis of clinically suspected lung tumors.     

Clinicopathologic analysis of fine needle aspiration cytology of the thyroid. A review of 1,613 cases and correlation with histopathologic diagnoses

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of fine needle aspiration (FNA) of thyroid lesions at our institution and to ascertain its usefulness in determining the therapeutic approach. STUDY DESIGN: The authors reviewed the results of 1,613 cases of FNA cytology of thyroid nodules performed from 1999 to 2001 at the Department of Pathology, Chonnam National University Hospital. Cytologic diagnoses were compared with histologic diagnoses in 207 cases that included both FNA and thyroid surgery. RESULTS: The sensitivity for the detection of neoplasms (carcinoma and follicular adenoma) was 78.4% and the specificity 98.2%. A false positive diagnosis was made in 1 case (1.8%) and false negative ones in 28 cases (21.5%). The diagnostic accuracy was 84.4%, with a positive predictive value of 99.0% and negative predictive value of 66.3%. The predictive value of a cytologic diagnosis was 100% in papillary carcinoma. CONCLUSION: FNA is a useful test in determining the therapeutic approach of thyroid lesions.     

Fine needle aspiration cytology of pulmonary carcinoid tumors

Twenty-four cases coded as pulmonary carcinoid tumors initially sampled by fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy were reviewed in order to determine the cytologic features most useful in making the FNA diagnosis. The diagnosis of carcinoid tumor had been confirmed in 23 cases; the remaining case, though closely resembling a carcinoid tumor on the FNA specimen, proved to be a sclerosing hemangioma of the lung. Comparison of the original and review interpretations of the FNA specimens revealed that all typical spindle cell carcinoids and all atypical carcinoids were correctly diagnosed and classified. Of the 15 typical round cell carcinoids, the original cytologic diagnosis was lymphoma in 2 cases and benign bronchial lining cells in 2 cases. Thus, it appears that diagnostic errors are most likely in "typical" carcinoids. Review of the FNA findings suggests that the frequently stripped cytoplasm (with resulting non-cohesive bare nuclei), coupled with the almost universal plexiform vascularity (seen in 21 of 23 cases), should allow an accurate cytologic diagnosis in virtually all cases.