Lac repressor with the helix-turn-helix motif of lambda cro binds to lac operator.

Lac repressor, lambda cro protein and their operator complexes are structurally, biochemically and genetically well analysed. Both proteins contain a helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif which they use to bind specifically to their operators. The DNA sequences 5'-GTGA-3' and 5'-TCAC-3' recognized in palindromic lac operator are the same as in lambda operator but their order is inverted form head to head to tail to tail. Different modes of aggregation of the monomers of the two proteins determine the different arrangements of the HTH motifs. Here we show that the HTH motif of lambda cro protein can replace the HTH motif of Lac repressor without changing its specificity. Such hybrid Lac repressor is unstable. It binds in vitro more weakly than Lac repressor but with the same specificity to ideal lac operator. It does not bind to consensus lambda operator.     

Lac repressor-operator interaction: DNA length dependence

The interaction of the E. coli lac operon repressor with its operator DNA has been directly examined as a function of the length of operator-containing DNA. The apparent bimolecular association rate constants were calculated as ka = (kd/KD), where the dissociation equilibrium constant, KD and the dissociation rate constant, kd, were measured by nitrocellulose filter adsorption assays. The values obtained for the overall association rate constants are compared with theoretical association rate curves for specific mechanisms. Association of the repressor with short operator containing DNA fragments (less than 70 base pairs) occurs at rates expected of three-dimensional diffusion. Our data also imply that at longer DNA lengths a combination of three-dimensional diffusion with one-dimensional sliding along with hopping and/or intersegment transfer must be involved to facilitate the repressor operator association.     

Binding of polynucleotides to fibroblasts. Effects of complex formation with vinyl analogs of nucleic acids

The nitrocellulose filter assay was used to study the effect of the DNA denaturants glycerol and dimethylsulfoxide (Me2SO) on the lac repressor-operator interaction. Both glycerol and Me2SO decrease the rate of dissociation (kb) of the repressor-operator complex but do not significantly alter the rate of association of repressor and operator. In the presence of 10% Me2SO an almost 10-fold increase of affinity of repressor for operator is observed. A small increase in affinity of repressor for Escherichia coli DNA, chicken blood DNA, and poly(dA-dT) is also found. The results lead to the conclusion that lac repressor when interacting with the operator causes local destabilization of the DNA.     

Synthetic lac operator mediates repression through lac repressor when introduced upstream and downstream from lac promoter.

Plasmids were constructed which carry a synthetic lac operator at various distances from the lac promoter. They were tested in vivo for function in the presence and absence of lac repressor. We found significant repression when the lac operator is situated at the 3' end of the lac I gene or at the 5' end of the lac Z gene. When lac operators are inserted at both sites, we found a greater than 150-fold repression. The complex between lac repressor and DNA carrying these two lac operators is exceedingly stable in vitro suggesting that one tetrameric lac repressor may bind to both lac operators.     

The solution structure of Lac repressor headpiece 62 complexed to a symmetrical lac operator

BACKGROUND: Lactose repressor protein (Lac) controls the expression of the lactose metabolic genes in Escherichia coli by binding to an operator sequence in the promoter of the lac operon. Binding of inducer molecules to the Lac core domain induces changes in tertiary structure that are propagated to the DNA-binding domain through the connecting hinge region, thereby reducing the affinity for the operator. Protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions involving the hinge region play a crucial role in the allosteric changes occurring upon induction, but have not, as yet, been analyzed in atomic detail. RESULTS: We have used nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and restrained molecular dynamics (rMD) to determine the structure of the Lac repressor DNA-binding domain (headpeice 62; HP62) in complex with a symmetrized lac operator. Analysis of the structures reveals specific interactions between Lac repressor and DNA that were not found in previously investigated Lac repressor-DNA complexes. Important differences with the previously reported structures of the HP56-DNA complex were found in the loop following the helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif. The protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions involving the hinge region and the deformations in the DNA structure could be delineated in atomic detail. The structures were also used for comparison with the available crystallographic data on the Lac and Pur repressor-DNA complexes. CONCLUSIONS: The structures of the HP62-DNA complex provide the basis for a better understanding of the specific recognition in the Lac repressor-operator complex. In addition, the structural features of the hinge region provide detailed insight into the protein-protein and protein-DNA interactions responsible for the high affinity of the repressor for operator DNA.     

Is nitrocellulose filter binding really a universal assay for protein-DNA interactions?

The ability to bind to nitrocellulose is commonly accepted as being a universal property of proteins and has been widely used in many different fields of study. This property was first exploited in the study of DNA-binding proteins 30 years ago, in studies involving DNA binding by the lactose repressor (LacR) of Escherichia coli. Termed the filter-binding assay, it remains the quickest and easiest assay available for the study of protein-DNA interactions. However, the exact mechanism by which proteins bind to nitrocellulose remains uncertain. Given the supposedly universal nature of the interaction, we were surprised to notice that certain LacR variants were completely unable to bind simultaneously to DNA containing a single lac operator and nitrocellulose. Investigation of this loss of binding suggests that LacR requires a protein region that is both hydrophobic in nature and more or less unstructured, in order to bind to both nitrocellulose and DNA. In the case of wild-type, tetrameric LacR, the DNA-recognition domain that is not bound to DNA suffices. Dimeric LacR variants will only bind if they have certain C-terminal extensions. These experiments sound a cautionary note for the use of filter binding as an assay of choice, particularly in applications involving screening for the DNA-binding site of putative DNA-binding proteins.     

Dimerisation mutants of Lac repressor. I. A monomeric mutant, L251A, that binds Lac operator DNA as a dimer.

Dimer formation between monomers of the Escherichia coli Lac repressor is substantially specificed by the interactions between three alpha-helices in each monomer which form a hydrophobic interface. As a first step in analysing the specificity of this interaction, we examined the mutant L251A. LacR bearing this mutation in a background lacking the C-terminal heptad repeats is completely incapable of forming dimers in solution, with a dimer-monomer equilibrium dissociation constant, or Kd, higher than 10(-5)M. This correlates with a 200-fold decrease in its ability to repress the lac operon in vivo compared to dimeric LacR. Surprisingly, the mutant is still capable of forming dimers upon binding to short operator DNA in vitro. Analysis of the kinetic parameters of binding of the mutant to operator DNA reveals a 2000 to 3000-fold increase in the equilibrium dissociation constant (Kd) of the mutant-DNA complex in comparison to dimeric LacR-operator complexes, with the change almost entirely due to a greater than 1000-fold decrease in association rate. The dissociation rate varies only by a factor of about two, in comparison to dimeric LacR. This change reflects a kinetic pathway in which dimer formation, in solution or on DNA, is the rate-limiting step. These findings have implications for the specificity and stability of the protein-protein interface in question.     

Construction, isolation and implications of repressor-galactosidase - beta-galactosidase hybrid molecules.

Escherichia coli heterogenotes, which produce hybrid molecules between the chimaeric protein repressor-galactosidase and the enzyme beta-galactosidase, were constructed. Repressor-galactosidase in which fully active lac repressor is covalently linked to active beta-galactosidase, is an aggregate with a core structure of four beta-galactosidase parts and two peripheral lac repressor dimers. The lac repressor dimers, which are separated by tetrameric beta-galactosidase, retain all the biological activities of tetrameric lac repressor. Substitution of repressor-galactosidase subunits with beta-galactosidase subunits leads to hybrid molecules with y beta-galactosidase subunits aggregated with (4-y) repressor-galactosidase subunits (where y = 1, 2 or 3). A 2:2 hybrid, i.e. a tetrameric beta-galactosidase core with one lac repressor dimer grafted to it, binds at least 100 times less strongly to 32P-labelled lambdaplac DNA than pure lac repressor or repressor-galactosidase. The data suggest a model in which lac repressor binds with two subunits to lac operator and with the other two subunits elsewhere on the DNA, possibly on sequences like the lac operator.     

Effect of DNA looping on the induction kinetics of the lac operon

The induction of the lac operon follows cooperative kinetics. The first mechanistic model of these kinetics is the de facto standard in the modeling literature [Yagil, G., Yagil, E., 1971. On the relation between effector concentration and the rate of induced enzyme synthesis. Biophys. J. 11, 11-17]. Yet, subsequent studies have shown that the model is based on incorrect assumptions. Specifically, the repressor is a tetramer with four (not two) inducer-binding sites, and the operon contains two auxiliary operators (in addition to the main operator). Furthermore, these structural features are crucial for the formation of DNA loops, the key determinants of lac repression and induction. Indeed, the repression is determined almost entirely (>95%) by the looped complexes [Oehler, S., Eismann, E.R., Kr?mer, H., Müller-Hill, B., 1990. The three operators of the lac operon cooperate in repression. EMBO J. 9(4), 973-979], and the pronounced cooperativity of the induction curve hinges upon the existence of the looped complexes [Oehler, S., Alberti, S., Müller-Hill, B., 2006. Induction of the lac promoter in the absence of DNA loops and the stoichiometry of induction. Nucleic Acids Res. 34(2), 606-612]. Here, we formulate a model of lac induction taking due account of the tetrameric structure of the repressor and the existence of looped complexes. We show that: (1) The kinetics are significantly more cooperative than those predicted by the Yagil and Yagil model. The cooperativity is higher because the formation of looped complexes is easily abolished by repressor-inducer binding. (2) The model provides good fits to the repression data for cells containing wild-type tetrameric or mutant dimeric repressor, as well as the induction curves for 6 different strains of Escherichia coli. It also implies that the ratios of certain looped and non-looped complexes are independent of inducer and repressor levels, a conclusion that can be rigorously tested by gel electrophoresis. (3) Repressor overexpression dramatically increases the cooperativity of the induction curve. This suggests that repressor overexpression can induce bistability in systems, such as growth of E. coli on lactose, that are otherwise monostable.     

Genetic analysis of the leucine heptad repeats of Lac repressor: evidence for a 4-helical bundle.

Gel-filtration experiments indicate that a peptide (P2) composed of the basic region of GCN4 fused to the leucine heptad repeats of Lac repressor forms tetrameric aggregates. Gel-shift experiments were performed to determine the orientation of the helices in the tetrameric P2 aggregate. Sandwich-complex formation of peptide P2 with two DNA fragments containing two symmetrical CRE binding sites (5'-ATGACGTCAT-3') at a distance of 21 bp suggests antiparallel aggregation of the Lac leucine heptad repeats. Thus, we conclude that the leucine heptad repeats of Lac repressor have the ability to form homomeric 4-helical bundles with an antiparallel arrangement of the helices. This topology enables the two DNA fragments in the sandwich complexes to be held together by two tetramers of peptide P2. Replacement of the uncharged amino acids of the helical g and e positions of peptide P2 by the corresponding charged residues of GCN4 (peptide P4) results in a dimeric and parallel aggregation of the leucine heptad repeats, and consequently abolishes the potential to form sandwich structures. Similarly, a hybrid Lac repressor in which the GCN4 leucine zipper replaces the natural Lac leucine heptad repeats forms dimers only. It regains the ability to form tetramers when the charged amino acids in helical positions g and e are replaced by uncharged alanines.     

In vivo interaction of Escherichia coli lac repressor N-terminal fragments with the lac operator

Escherichia coli lac repressor is a tetrameric protein composed of 360 amino acid subunits. Considerable attention has focused on its N-terminal region which is isolated by cleavage with proteases yielding N-terminal fragments of 51 to 59 amino acid residues. Because these short peptide fragments bind operator DNA, they have been extensively examined in nuclear magnetic resonance structural studies. Longer N-terminal peptide fragments that bind DNA cannot be obtained enzymatically. To extend structural studies and simultaneously verify proper folding in vivo, the DNA sequence encoding longer N-terminal fragments were cloned into a vector system with the coliphage T7 RNA polymerase/promoter. In addition to the wild-type lacI gene sequence, single amino acid substitutions were generated at positions 3 (Pro3----Tyr) and 61 (Ser61----Leu) as well as the double substitution in a 64 amino acid N-terminal fragment. These mutations were chosen because they increase the DNA binding affinity of the intact lac repressor by a factor of 10(2) to 10(4). The expression of these lac repressor fragments in the cell was verified by radioimmunoassays. Both wild-type and mutant lac repressor N termini bound operator DNA as judged by reduced beta-galactosidase synthesis and methylation protection in vivo. These observations also resolve a contradiction in the literature as to the location of the operator-specific, inducer-dependent DNA binding domain.     

Specific binding of lac repressor to linear versus circular polyoperator molecules

Gel shift assays were used to examine the binding of the lactose (lac) repressor to polyoperator DNA molecules. Specific binding was differentiated from nonspecific DNA association by (i) equilibrating repressor-operator complexes below the nonspecific association constant and (ii) demonstrating the effects of the inducer isopropyl beta-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG) on the formation of repressor-operator complexes. With the linear polyoperator molecules, all eight operator sites could be simultaneously bound by distinct repressors. However, with circular molecules, the eight operator sites were saturable by repressor only in the nicked circular state and not in the covalently closed circular form. Under the experimental conditions used, there was no evidence of bifunctional repressor binding or loop formation. The results suggest that the conformational perturbation of DNA that occurs upon specific repressor binding was retained in topologically closed molecules and could modify other operator sites so as to make them unavailable for specific binding.     

Specificities of three tight-binding Lac repressors.

Tight binding mutants of Lac repressor exhibit complex repression phenomena. In this work, in vivo Lac operator binding of three such mutants of E. coli Lac repressor (X86: ser 61-leu, l12: pro 3-tyr and the double mutant l12X86: pro 3-tyr, ser 61-leu) was analyzed. Repression of beta-galactosidase synthesis controlled by ideal lac operator and its 27 symmetric operator variants containing each possible base-pair at each single half-operator position in the presence of the tight-binding Lac repressor mutants was determined. The average increase of repression with all operator variants was about 3 fold with the X86 mutant. It was about 4 fold with the l12 mutant and about 2 fold with the double mutant l12X86 as compared to wildtype Lac repressor. The X86 mutant showed the same increase of affinity to all operator variants, whereas the l12 and l12X86 mutants exhibited lower repression with some variants than with most others. These results suggest that the X86 mutant has gained no additional specificity. In contrast the l12 mutant and the l12X86 mutant exhibit a relaxed specificity for certain base pairs in positions 1 and 3 of lac operator. This suggests that the extreme N-terminus of Lac repressor may interact with the inner base-pairs in the minor groove.     

The roles of residues 5 and 9 of the recognition helix of Lac repressor in lac operator binding

We constructed expression libraries for Lac repressor mutants with amino acid exchanges in positions 1, 2, 5 and 9 of the recognition helix. We then analysed the interactions of residues 5 and 9 with operator variants bearing single or multiple symmetric base-pair exchanges in positions 3, 4 and 5 of the ideal fully symmetric lac operator. We isolated 37 independent Lac repressor mutants with five different amino acids in position 5 of the recognition helix that exhibit a strong preference for particular residues in position 2 and, to a lesser extent, in position 1 of the recognition helix. Our results suggest that residue 5 of the recognition helix (serine 21) contributes to the specific recognition of base-pair 4 of the lac operator. They further suggest that residue 9 of the recognition helix (asparagine 25) interacts non-specifically with a phosphate of the DNA backbone, possibly between base-pairs 2 and 3.     

Effects of nucleoid proteins on DNA repression loop formation in Escherichia coli

The intrinsic stiffness of DNA limits its ability to be bent and twisted over short lengths, but such deformations are required for gene regulation. One classic paradigm is DNA looping in the regulation of the Escherichia coli lac operon. Lac repressor protein binds simultaneously to two operator sequences flanking the lac promoter. Analysis of the length dependence of looping-dependent repression of the lac operon provides insight into DNA deformation energetics within cells. The apparent flexibility of DNA is greater in vivo than in vitro, possibly because of host proteins that bind DNA and induce sites of flexure. Here we test DNA looping in bacterial strains lacking the nucleoid proteins HU, IHF or H-NS. We confirm that deletion of HU inhibits looping and that quantitative modeling suggests residual looping in the induced operon. Deletion of IHF has little effect. Remarkably, DNA looping is strongly enhanced in the absence of H-NS, and an explanatory model is proposed. Chloroquine titration, psoralen crosslinking and supercoiling-sensitive reporter assays show that the effects of nucleoid proteins on looping are not correlated with their effects on either total or unrestrained supercoiling. These results suggest that host nucleoid proteins can directly facilitate or inhibit DNA looping in bacteria.     

DNA supercoiling promotes formation of a bent repression loop in lac DNA

Titration experiments on supercoiled lac DNA show that one repressor tetramer can bind simultaneously to the primary lac operator and to the very weak lac pseudo-operator, located 93 base-pairs apart. The formation of this complex is accompanied by the appearance of an extreme hypersensitive site in a five base-pair sequence located approximately midway between the operators. This remote sequence is hypersensitive to attack by two different chemical probes, dimethyl sulfate and potassium permanganate, the latter of which is a new probe for distorted DNA. We interpret these results in terms of a complex in which lac repressor holds two remote operators together in a DNA loop. The formation of this bent DNA loop requires negative DNA supercoiling. In vivo, both lac operators bind repressor even though the presence of multiple operator copies has forced the two operators to compete for a limited amount of repressor. This suggests that the operator and pseudo-operator have similar affinities for repressor in vivo. Such similar affinities were observed in vitro only when DNA supercoiling forced formation of a repression loop.     

Degradation of the DNA-binding domain of wild-type and i-d lac repressors in Escherichia coli.

It has been shown that 28 transdominant mutant lac repressors which have lost operator DNA-binding ability in vivo and in vitro, but still bind inducer and are able to form tetramers (i-d repressors), could be divided into two groups by their capacity or incapacity to bind non-specifically to the phosphate groups of the DNA backbone. All but one of 15 analysed i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the C-terminal of residue 52 showed uneffected non-specific DNA binding. All 13 tested i-d repressors with amino acid substitutions to the N-terminal of residue 53 did not bind to double-stranded DNA, and 11 of these repressors derived from missense mutations in the lacI gene were endogenously degraded. The degradation in vivo only affects the amino-terminal 50-60 residues producing a mutant-specific pattern of stable repressor fragments. These fragments are tetrameric and capable of binding inducer in vivo and in vitro. The proteolytic attack presumably takes place during synthesis of the i-d repressors, since the resulting fragments are stable, both in vivo (as shown by a pulse-chase experiment) and in vitro. The proteolysis in vivo depends on the growth conditions of the bacteria and is higher in cells grown in minimal media than in rich media. Wild-type repressor is only susceptible to limited proteolysis in cells grown in minimal media but not in cells grown in rich media. The results suggest that the majority of the sequence alterations before residue 53 in missense mutant i-d lac repressor proteins affect the three-dimensional structure of the amino-terminal DNA-binding domain of the repressor protein, making it susceptible to proteolytic attack by one or several intracellular proteases.     

Crystallographic analysis of Lac repressor bound to natural operator O1

Previous structures of Lac repressor bound to DNA used a fully symmetric "ideal" operator sequence that is missing the central G-C base-pair present in the three natural operator sequences. Here we have determined the X-ray crystal structure of a dimeric Lac repressor bound to a 22 base-pair DNA with the natural operator O1 sequence and the anti-inducer ONPF, at 4.0 A resolution. The natural operator is bent in the same way as the symmetric sequence, due to the binding of the hinge helices of the repressor to the minor groove at the central GCGG sequence of O1. Comparison of the structures of the repressor bound to the natural and symmetric operators shows very similar overall structures, with only slight rearrangements of the headpiece domains of the repressor. Analysis of crystals with iodinated DNA shows that the operator is uniquely positioned and allows for the sequence registration of the DNA relative to the repressor to be determined. The kink in the operator is centered between the left half-site and the central G-C base-pair of O1. Our results are most consistent with a previously proposed model in which, relative to the complex with the symmetric operator, the repressor accommodates binding to the natural operator sequence by shifting the position of the right headpiece by one base-pair step towards the center of O1.