Copolymerization of tubulin-colchicine complex and unliganded tubulin in a nonmicrotubular polymer

We have shown previously [Saltarelli, D., & Pantaloni, D. (1982) Biochemistry 21, 2996-3006] that the tubulin-colchicine complex is able to polymerize in vitro into peculiar "curly" polymers, under the solution conditions permitting polymerization of unliganded tubulin into microtubules. Here it is further demonstrated that unliganded tubulin can be incorporated into these "curly" polymers. The partial critical concentration of tubulin-colchicine is decreased upon incorporation of unliganded tubulin into the copolymer. GTP hydrolysis occurs on unliganded tubulin upon incorporation in the copolymer. Tubulin-podophyllotoxin does not copolymerize with tubulin-colchicine to form a large polymer but interacts with it, preventing tubulin-colchicine polymerization. The data have been analyzed within a model of random copolymerization of unliganded tubulin and tubulin-colchicine into "curly" polymers. A corollary is that unliganded tubulin is virtually able to self-assemble into curly polymers with a critical concentration 10-fold higher than the critical concentration found for microtubule assembly. Consequently, these peculiar tubulin homopolymers cannot be observed except as transients at high concentrations, or when microtubule assembly is inhibited. Kinetic measurements of the T-TC copolymerization process and associated GTP hydrolysis at different T/TC ratios provide supplementary information about some privileged interactions between tubulin and tubulin-colchicine molecules. A comprehensive phase diagram of the various possible polymers formed in the presence of tubulin and tubulin-colchicine is presented.     

Fluorometric assay of tubulin-colchicine complex.

A fluorometric assay method for the tubulin-colchicine complex has been developed. This assay method is based on the fact that the binding of colchicine to tubulin leads to a 300-fold enhancement of fluorescence intensity of colchicine at 430 nm. Since the excitation wavelength can be set at 350 nm, far from an absorption band of tubulin, the assay does not necessitate the separation of the tubulin-colchicine complex from free colchicine. Fluorescence intensity is linear up to 2 mg/ml of the tubulin-colchicine complex.     

Polymerization of the tubulin-colchicine complex: relation to microtubule assembly

The polymerization of purified tubulin-colchicine complex, which results in polymers different from microtubules under microtubule-promoting conditions, has been characterized. It proceeds as a nucleated condensation polymerization, requires Mg2+, and is inhibited by small concentrations of Ca2+. Polymerization requires GTP binding, but GDP is inhibitory. The GTPase activity proceeds, but it is unlinked to polymerization. The thermodynamic characteristics of the growth reaction, namely, the apparent changes of free energy, enthalpy, entropy, heat capacity, and preferential interaction with H+ and Mg2+, are very similar to those of microtubule assembly. It is proposed that the interactions responsible for the two types of polymerization are very similar and that the molecular mechanism of microtubule inhibition by colchicine may consist in a drug-induced distortion of the normal protomer bonding geometry.     

Polymerization and calcium binding of the tubulin-colchicine complex in the GDP state

The tubulin-colchicine complex instead of tubulin was used in an imidazole buffer throughout experiments. The interaction with calcium was examined, especially in the GDP state. The high affinity sites of calcium took part in the polymerization of the complex in the GTP state, while the low ones participated in the depolymerization. The complex had 2 high affinity sites with the dissociation constant of 11.5 x 10(-6) M, and 16 low affinity sites with the dissociation constant of 2.27 x 10(-4) M in the GTP state. In the case of GDP state, the dissociation constant of the high affinity site was 7.2 x 10(-6) M, and the low affinity site was not observed. The ultracentrifugal experiment indicated a little compact structure in the GTP state compared with the GDP state. This agreed with the results of calcium binding.     

Inhibition of tubulin self-assembly and tubulin-colchicine GTPase activity by guanosine 5'-(gamma-fluorotriphosphate)

The inhibitory effects of guanosine 5'-(gamma-fluorotriphosphate) [GTP(gamma F)] on both the polymerization and the colchicine-dependent GTPase activity of calf brain tubulin have been studied. The results demonstrate that this analogue of GTP, with a fluorine atom on the gamma-phosphate, is a reversible competitive dead-end inhibitor of the colchicine-induced GTPase activity with a K1 value of (1.8 +/- 0.6) X 10(-4) M. GTP(gamma F) did not promote assembly of tubulin from which the E-site guanine nucleotide had been removed. It binds to the exchangeable nucleotide site competitively with respect to GTP, diminishing both the rate and extent of tubulin polymerization. Treatment in terms of the Oosawa-Kasai model of the inhibitory effect of GTP(gamma F) on the assembly led to a value of Kdis = 1.1 X 10(-6) M for the complex GTP(gamma F)-tubulin. This analogue does not bind to the postulated third site. The growing of tubulin polymers at 37 degrees C was arrested by GTP(gamma F), and only limited depolymerization was induced by the addition of this analogue after assembly in the presence of GTP. This result confirms that the E-site is blocked in the polymer and that this analogue can bind only to the ends of the polymers. Sedimentation velocity and circular dichroism studies showed that the conformation of the tubulin-GTP(gamma F) complex is not identical with that of tubulin-GTP. This is caused by the replacement of the hydroxyl group in the gamma-phosphate by the fluorine group, which have 2.20- and 1.35-A van der Waals radii, respectively.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The stabilization of microtubules in isolated spindles by tubulin-colchicine complex

We have analyzed the effect of colchicine and tubulin dimer-colchicine complex (T-C) on microtubule assembly in mitotic spindles. Cold- and calcium-labile mitotic spindles were isolated from embryos of the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus employing EGTA/glycerol stabilization buffers. Polarization microscopy and measurements of spindle birefringent retardation (BR) were used to record the kinetics of microtubule assembly-disassembly in single spindles. When isolated spindles were perfused out of glycerol stabilizing buffer into a standard in vitro microtubule reassembly buffer (0.1 M Pipes, pH 6.8, 1 mM EGTA, 0.5 mM MgCl2, and 0.5 mM GTP) lacking glycerol, spindle BR decreased with a half-time of 120 s. Colchicine at 1 mM in this buffer had no effect on the rate of spindle microtubule disassembly. Inclusion of 20 microM tubulin or microtubule protein, purified from porcine brain, in this buffer resulted in an augmentation of spindle BR. Interestingly, in the presence of 20 microM T-C, spindle BR did not increase, but was reversibly stabilized; subsequent perfusion with reassembly buffer without T-C resulted in depolymerization. This behavior is striking in contrast to the rapid depolymerization of spindle microtubules induced by colchicine and T-C in vivo. These results support the current view that colchicine does not directly promote microtubule depolymerization. Rather, it is T-C complex that alters microtubule assembly, by reversibly binding to microtubules and inhibiting elongation. In vivo, colchicine can induce depolymerization of nonkinetochore spindle microtubules within 20 s. In vitro, colchicine blocks further microtubule assembly, but does not induce rapid disassembly.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Tubulin and tubulin-colchicine complex bind to brain microsomal membrane in vitro

Brain tubulin was labeled in vitro by post-translational incorporation of [14C]-tyrosine or in vivo by intra-cranial injection of [3H]-leucine. The labeled protein was purified by ion-exchange chromatography. After incubating at 37 degrees C with a microsomal membrane preparation from rat brain, part of the labeled soluble tubulin became sedimentable at high-speed centrifugation. This was independent of the native configuration of tubulin, the state of tyrosination of the COOH-terminus, or the presence of 100 microM colchicine in the mixture. In addition, the double-labeled tubulin-colchicine complex obtained from the binding of [3H]-colchicine to [14C]-tyrosinated tubulin, bound to the membrane preparation to the same extent as [14C]-tyrosinated tubulin. The data show that either tubulin or the complex resulting from its binding to colchicine distributed between the soluble and the membrane fractions when mixed at 37 degrees C with a microsome preparation. Seemingly, the site for colchicine binding to tubulin needs not to be free for the protein-membrane association.     

Molecular modeling of the axial and circumferential elastic moduli of tubulin

Microtubules play a number of important mechanical roles in almost all cell types in nearly all major phylogenetic trees. We have used a molecular mechanics approach to perform tensile tests on individual tubulin monomers and determined values for the axial and circumferential moduli for all currently known complete sequences. The axial elastic moduli, in vacuo, were found to be 1.25 GPa and 1.34 GPa for α- and β-bovine tubulin monomers. In the circumferential direction, these moduli were 378 MPa for α- and 460 MPa for β-structures. Using bovine tubulin as a template, 269 homologous tubulin structures were also subjected to simulated tensile loads yielding an average axial elastic modulus of 1.10 ± 0.14 GPa for α-tubulin structures and 1.39 ± 0.68 GPa for β-tubulin. Circumferentially the α- and β-moduli were 936 ± 216 MPa and 658 ± 134 MPa, respectively. Our primary finding is that that the axial elastic modulus of tubulin diminishes as the length of the monomer increases. However, in the circumferential direction, no correlation exists. These predicted anisotropies and scale dependencies may assist in interpreting the macroscale behavior of microtubules during mitosis or cell growth. Additionally, an intergenomic approach to investigating the mechanical properties of proteins may provide a way to elucidate the evolutionary mechanical constraints imposed by nature upon individual subcellular components.     

Molecular dynamics modeling of tubulin C-terminal tail interactions with the microtubule surface

Tubulin, an α/β heterodimer, has had most of its 3D structure analyzed; however, the carboxy (C)-termini remain elusive. Importantly, the C-termini play critical roles in regulating microtubule structure and function. They are sites of most of the post-translational modifications of tubulin and interaction sites with molecular motors and microtubule-associated proteins. Simulated annealing was used in our molecular dynamics modeling to predict the interactions of the C-terminal tails with the tubulin dimer. We examined differences in their flexibility, interactions with the body of tubulin, and the existence of structural motifs. We found that the α-tubulin tail interacts with the H11 helix of β-tubulin, and the β-tubulin tail interacts with the H11 helix of α-tubulin. Tail domains and H10/B9 loops interact with each other and compete for interactions with positively-charged residues of the H11 helix on the neighboring monomer. In a simulation in which α-tubulin's H10/B9 loop switches on sub-nanosecond intervals between interactions with the C-terminal tail of α-tubulin and the H11 helix of β-tubulin, the intermediate domain of α-tubulin showed more fluctuations compared to those in the other simulations, indicating that tail domains may cause shifts in the position of this domain. This suggests that C-termini may affect the conformation of the tubulin dimer which may explain their essential function in microtubule formation and effects on ligand binding to microtubules. Our modeling also provides evidence for a disordered-helical/helical double-state system of the T3/H3 region of the microtubule, which could be linked to depolymerization following GTP hydrolysis.     

Divalent cation-nucleotide complex at the exchangeable nucleotide binding site of tubulin

Tubulin was first treated with alkaline phosphatase-agarose to vacate the exchangeable nucleotide binding site and then tested for manganese binding sites by Mn(II) EPR. Buttlaire et al. ((1980) J. Biol. Chem. 255, 2164-2168) have shown that high affinity manganese binding occurs at a single site normally occupied by magnesium. We report that the number of high affinity manganese binding sites per mol of tubulin depends on the number of occupied exchangeable nucleotide binding sites. Thus, removal of nucleotides results in a loss of high affinity manganese binding sites. The EPR spectra of manganese bound to tubulin and to GTP are found to be qualitatively similar. These data indicate that high affinity manganese binding is the result of the formation of a metal-nucleotide complex at the exchangeable nucleotide binding site. In addition it was found that zinc, cobalt, and magnesium bind with approximately equal affinity to this site whereas calcium binds only weakly.     

Proteolysis of tubulin and the substructure of the tubulin dimer

The alpha and beta subunits of tubulin each have a single highly reactive site for a variety of proteases that divides each subunit into two unequal regions. The position of cleavage is not the same for alpha and beta, since alpha is consistently cleaved into about 38- and 14-kDa pieces, while beta is cleaved into about 34- and 21-kDa pieces. The larger fragment is amino-terminal in both subunits as shown: by size reduction of the smaller fragment by subtilisin (which cleaves at the extreme carboxyl-terminal end), but no change in size of the larger fragment; by the charge/mass ratios of the proteolytic fragments; and by sequence analysis which locates trypsin cleavage after residue 339 (alpha) and chymotrypsin cleavage after residue 281 (beta). Since this cleavage pattern of the alpha and beta subunits is found for very different proteases, we suggest that it is determined by structural features of the tubulin molecule. The two pieces of each subunit remain associated following cleavage. While both cleavage sites are exposed in the free dimer, assembly of dimers into microtubules or sheets protects the internal site against cleavage. By contrast, the carboxyl-terminal subtilisin-sensitive sites remain exposed. Based on these results we propose a model for the substructure of the tubulin dimer that accommodates internal cleavage in the dimer but not the polymer, access to the COOH termini in both forms, and the orientation of the dimer in the polymer.     

The mammalian exocyst, a complex required for exocytosis, inhibits tubulin polymerization

The exocyst is a 734-kDa complex essential for development. Perturbation of its function results in early embryonic lethality. Extensive investigation has revealed that this complex participates in multiple biological processes, including protein synthesis and vesicle/protein targeting to the plasma membrane. In this article we report that the exocyst may also play a role in modulating microtubule dynamics. Using monoclonal antibodies, we observed that endogenous exocyst subunits co-localized with microtubules and mitotic spindles in normal rat kidney cells. To test for a functional relationship between the exocyst complex and microtubules, we established an in vitro exocyst reconstitution assay and studied exocyst effect on microtubule dynamics. We found that the exocyst complex reconstituted from eight recombinant exocyst subunits inhibited tubulin polymerization in vitro. Deletion of exocyst subunit sec5, sec6, sec15, or exo70 diminished its tubulin polymerization inhibition activity. Surprisingly, exocyst subunit exo70 itself was also capable of inhibiting tubulin polymerization, although exocyst complex with exo70 deletion did not lose its activity completely. Overexpression of exo70 in NRK cells resulted in microtubule network disruption and the formation of filopodia-like plasma membrane protrusions. The formation of these membrane protrusions was greatly hampered by stabilizing microtubules with taxol. Overexpression of exo84, an exocyst subunit that did not show tubulin polymerization inhibition activity, did not cause this phenotype. Results shown in this article, along with a previous report that localized microtubule instability induces plasma membrane addition, implicates a novel role for the exocyst in modulating microtubule dynamics underlying exocytosis.     

Domain analysis of the tubulin cofactor system: a model for tubulin folding and dimerization

Background  

The correct folding and dimerization of tubulins, before their addition to the microtubular structure, needs a group of conserved proteins called cofactors A to E. The biochemical analysis of cofactors gave an insight to their general functions, however not much is known about the domain structure and detailed, molecular function of these proteins.     

Molecular modeling study of the norfloxacin-DNA complex

Molecular modeling and molecular dynamics were performed to investigate the interaction of norfloxacin with the DNA oligonucleotide 5'-d(ATACGTAT)(2). Eight quinolone-DNA binding structures were built by molecular modeling on the basis of experimental results. A 100ps molecular dynamics calculation was carried out on two groove binding models and six partially intercalating models. The resulting average structures were compared with each other and to free DNA structure as a reference. The favorable binding mode of norfloxacin to a DNA substrate was pursued by structural assess including steric hindrance, presence of hydrogen-bonding, non-bonding energies of the complex and presence of abnormal structural distortion. Although two of the intercalative models showed the highest binding energy and the lowest non-bonding interaction energy, they presented structural features which contrast with experimental results. On the other hand, one groove binding model demonstrated the most acceptable structure when the experimental observation was accounted. In this model, hydrogen bonding of the carbonyl and carboxyl group of the norfloxacin rings with the DNA bases was present, and norfloxacin binds to the amine group of the guanine base which protrudes toward the minor groove of B-DNA.     

Structural model of a complex between the heterotrimeric G protein, Gsalpha, and tubulin

A number of studies have demonstrated interplay between the cytoskeleton and G protein signaling. Many of these studies have determined a specific interaction between tubulin, the building block of microtubules, and G proteins. The alpha subunits of some heterotrimeric G proteins, including Gsalpha, have been shown to interact strongly with tubulin. Binding of Galpha to tubulin results in increased dynamicity of microtubules due to activation of GTPase of tubulin. Tubulin also activates Gsalpha via a direct transfer of GTP between these molecules. Structural insight into the interaction between tubulin and Gsalpha was required, and was determined, in this report, through biochemical and molecular docking techniques. Solid phase peptide arrays suggested that a portion of the amino terminus, alpha2-beta4 (the region between switch II and switch III) and alpha3-beta5 (just distal to the switch III region) domains of Gsalpha are important for interaction with tubulin. Molecular docking studies revealed the best-fit models based on the biochemical data, showing an interface between the two molecules that includes the adenylyl cyclase/Gbetagamma interaction regions of Gsalpha and the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of tubulin. These structural models explain the ability of tubulin to facilitate GTP exchange on Galpha and the ability of Galpha to activate tubulin GTPase.     

The integrity of tubulin molecule is not required for the activity of tubulin carboxypeptidase

Tubulin dimer, alpha-tubulin subunit, and C-terminal peptides obtained from the alpha-tubulin subunit were compared in their capabilities to act as substrates of tubulin carboxypeptidase. The results obtained indicate that the enzyme does not require the beta-tubulin subunit to release tyrosine from alpha-tubulin. The 17-Kd C-terminal peptide of the alpha-tubulin subunit was obtained and it was detyrosinated at the same rate as tubulin dimer. A smaller C-terminal peptide of 2.8-3.7 Kd showed a lower capability to act as substrate. Similar results were obtained with pancreatic carboxypeptidase A. From the analysis of the results we consider that an optimal activity of the tubulin carboxypeptidase depends mainly on the accessibility of the C-terminal end of alpha-tubulin.     

Using simultaneous equation modeling for defining complex phenotypes

Background

Interactions between multiple biological phenotypes are difficult to model. Simultaneous equation modelling (SEM), as used in econometric modelling, may prove an effective tool for this problem. Generalized linear models were used to derive the structural equations defining the interactions between cholesterol, glucose, triglycerides and high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL-C). These structural equations were then applied, using SEM, to Cohort 2 data (replicates 1–100) to estimate the phenotypic structure underlying the simulation. The goal was to determine if this empiric method of deriving structural equations for use in SEM was able to recover the simulation model better than generalized linear models.

Results

First, the underlying structural equations were estimated using generalized linear model techniques, which found strong a relationship between glucose, triglycerides and HDL-C. Using these structural equations, I used SEM to evaluate these relationships jointly. I found that a combination of the empiric structural equations and the SEM method was better at recovering the underlying simulated relationship between biologic measures than generalized linear modelling.

Conclusion

The empiric SEM procedure presented here estimated different relationships between dependent variables than generalized linear modelling. The SEM procedure using empirically developed structural equations was able to recover the underlying simulation relationship partially and thus holds promise as a technique for complex phenotype analysis. Robust methods for determining the structural equations must be developed for application of SEM to population data.