Directed Evolution: An Approach to Engineer Enzymes

ABSTRACT

Directed evolution is being used increasingly in industrial and academic laboratories to modify and improve commercially important enzymes. Laboratory evolution is thought to make its biggest contribution in explorations of non-natural functions, by allowing us to distinguish the properties nurtured by evolution. In this review we report the significant advances achieved with respect to the methods of biocatalyst improvement and some critical properties and applications of the modified enzymes. The application of directed evolution has been elaborately demonstrated for protein solubility, stability and catalytic efficiency. Modification of certain enzymes for their application in enantioselective catalysis has also been elucidated. By providing a simple and reliable route to enzyme improvement, directed evolution has emerged as a key technology for enzyme engineering and biocatalysis.     

Strategy and success for the directed evolution of enzymes

Directed evolution is widely used to improve enzymes, particularly for industrial biocatalytic processes. Molecular biology advances present many new strategies for directed evolution. Commonly used techniques have led to many successful examples of enzyme improvement, yet there is still a need to improve both the efficiency and capability of directed evolution. Recent strategies aimed at making directed evolution faster and more efficient take better advantage of available structural and sequence information. The underlying principles that lead to early dead-ends for directed evolution experiments are also discussed along with recent strategies designed to by-pass them. Several emerging methods for creating novel enzymes are also discussed including examples of catalytic activity for which there is no precedent in nature. Finally, the combined use of several strategies is likely to be required in practice to improve multiple target properties of an enzyme, as successfully shown by a recent industrial example.     

Application of a very high-throughput digital imaging screen to evolve the enzyme galactose oxidase

Directed evolution has become an important enabling technology for the development of new enzymes in the chemical and pharmaceutical industries. Some of the most interesting substrates for these enzymes, such as polymers, have poor solubility or form highly viscous solutions and are therefore refractory to traditional high-throughput screens used in directed evolution. We combined digital imaging spectroscopy and a new solid-phase screening method to screen enzyme variants on problematic substrates highly efficiently and show here that the specific activity of the enzyme galactose oxidase can be improved using this technology. One of the variants we isolated, containing the mutation C383S, showed a 16-fold increase in activity, due in part to a 3-fold improvement in K(m). The present methodology should be applicable to the evolution of numerous other enzymes, including polysaccharide-modifying enzymes that could be used for the large-scale synthesis of modified polymers with novel chemical properties.     

Directed evolution and the creation of enantioselective biocatalysts

Directed evolution has emerged as a key technology to generate enzymes with new or improved properties that are of major importance to the biotechnology industry. A directed evolution approach starts with the identification of a target enzyme to be optimized and the cloning of the corresponding gene. An efficient expression system is needed before the target gene is subjected to random mutagenesis and/or in vitro recombination, thereby creating molecular diversity. Subsequently, improved enzyme variants are identified, preferably after being secreted into culture medium, by screening or selection for the desired property. The genes encoding the improved enzymes are then used to parent the next round of directed evolution. Enantioselectivity is a biocatalyst property of major biotechnological importance that is, however, difficult to deal with. We discuss recent examples of creating enantioselective biocatalysts by directed evolution.     

改进酶稳定性的定向进化技术

酶作为一种生物催化剂,以其独特的优良特性,在绿色化学和清洁生产中得到了广泛的应用。随着酶定向进化技术的建立和发展,通过定向进化改进酶稳定性的研究越来越多。详细综述了各种定向进化方法的特点及在提高酶稳定性方面的应用,并从结构和功能的角度进一步解释了相关机理。     

A new intrinsic thermal parameter for enzymes reveals true temperature optima

Two established thermal properties of enzymes are the Arrhenius activation energy and thermal stability. Arising from anomalies found in the variation of enzyme activity with temperature, a comparison has been made of experimental data for the activity and stability properties of five different enzymes with theoretical models. The results provide evidence for a new and fundamental third thermal parameter of enzymes, T(eq), arising from a subsecond timescale-reversible temperature-dependent equilibrium between the active enzyme and an inactive (or less active) form. Thus, at temperatures above its optimum, the decrease in enzyme activity arising from the temperature-dependent shift in this equilibrium is up to two orders of magnitude greater than what occurs through thermal denaturation. This parameter has important implications for our understanding of the connection between catalytic activity and thermostability and of the effect of temperature on enzyme reactions within the cell. Unlike the Arrhenius activation energy, which is unaffected by the source ("evolved") temperature of the enzyme, and enzyme stability, which is not necessarily related to activity, T(eq) is central to the physiological adaptation of an enzyme to its environmental temperature and links the molecular, physiological, and environmental aspects of the adaptation of life to temperature in a way that has not been described previously. We may therefore expect the effect of evolution on T(eq) with respect to enzyme temperature/activity effects to be more important than on thermal stability. T(eq) is also an important parameter to consider when engineering enzymes to modify their thermal properties by both rational design and by directed enzyme evolution.     

启动子和细胞全局转录机制的定向进化在微生物代谢工程中的应用

通过随机突变和定向选择而进行的定向进化(又称分子进化或人工进化)在改造酶的催化特性和稳定性、扩展酶的底物范围等方面具有广泛的应用。近年来,定向进化也开始应用在对结构基因的启动子区域和具有调节功能的蛋白如转录因子等进行代谢工程改造,并成功选育了对环境胁迫因素具有较强耐受性,以及发酵效率提高的微生物菌种。以下着重介绍近年来启动子的定向进化,包括启动子的强度和调节功能的分子进化,以及细胞全局转录工程等技术在微生物代谢工程中的应用,这些定向进化技术使人们可以更精细地调节基因表达水平,并可同时改变细胞内多个基因的转录水平,是代谢工程研究新的有力工具。     

Designed evolution of enzymatic properties

By providing a simple and reliable route to enzyme improvement, directed evolution has emerged as a key technology for enzyme engineering and biocatalysis. Recent advances include the evolution of a novel catalytic activity using the alpha/beta barrel scaffold, evolution of a cofactor-free monooxygenase, and the engineering of regulatable enzymes. New screening systems for enantioselectivity and protein solubility, and the continuing stream of new methods for creating enzyme libraries further extend evolution's reach.     

酶祖先序列重建与定向进化

酶祖先序列重建是指通过计算机算法推导来自灭绝生物的祖先酶的氨基酸序列的技术。通常可分为6个步骤,依次为现代酶的核酸/氨基酸序列收集、多序列比对、系统发育树构建、祖先酶序列的计算机推测、基因克隆、酶学性质表征。该方法广泛应用于研究分子在行星时间尺度上对环境条件不断变化的适应性和进化机制。随着酶在生物催化领域中扮演越来越重要的角色,该方法逐渐成为研究酶序列、结构和功能关系的有力手段。同时,祖先酶大多具有温度稳定性、突变稳定性等特性,使其成为进一步定向进化的理想蛋白质支架。文中综述了酶祖先序列重建的计算机算法、应用和常用计算机软件,并结合最新研究进展,展望其在酶定向进化领域中的应用前景。     

Manipulation of enzyme properties by noncanonical amino acid incorporation

Since wild-type enzymes do not always have the properties needed for various applications, enzymes are often engineered to obtain desirable properties through protein engineering techniques. In the past decade, complementary to the widely used rational protein design and directed evolution techniques, noncanonical amino acid incorporation (NCAAI) has become a new and effective protein engineering technique. Recently, NCAAI has been used to improve intrinsic functions of proteins, such as enzymes and fluorescent proteins, beyond the capacities obtained with natural amino acids. Herein, recent progress on improving enzyme properties through NCAAI in vivo is reviewed and the challenges of current approaches and future directions are also discussed. To date, both NCAAI methods-residue- and site-specific incorporation-have been primarily used to improve the catalytic turnover number and substrate binding affinity of enzymes. Numerous strategies used to minimize structural perturbation and stability loss of a target enzyme upon NCAAI are also explored. Considering the generality of NCAAI incorporation, we expect its application could be expanded to improve other enzyme properties, such as substrate specificity and solvent resistance in the near future.     

Enhanced thermostability of a Rhizopus chinensis lipase by in vivo recombination in Pichia pastoris

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Lipase from Rhizopus chinensis is a versatile biocatalyst for various bioconversions and has been expressed at high-level in Pichia pastoris. However, the use of R. chinensis lipase in industrial applications is restricted by its low thermostability. Directed evolution has been proven to be a powerful and efficient protein engineering tool for improvement of biocatalysts. The present work describes improvement of the thermostability of R. chinensis lipase by directed evolution using P. pastoris as the host. RESULTS: An efficient, fast and highly simplified method was developed to create a mutant gene library in P. pastoris based on in vivo recombination, whose recombination efficiency could reach 2.3 x 105 /mug DNA. The thermostability of r27RCL was improved significantly by two rounds of error-prone PCR and two rounds of DNA shuffling in P. pastoris. The S4-3 variant was found to be the most thermostable lipase, under the conditions tested. Compared with the parent, the optimum temperature of S4-3 was two degrees higher, Tm was 22 degrees higher and half-lives at 60degreesC and 65degreesC were 46- and 23- times longer. Moreover, the catalytic efficiency kcat/Km of S4-3 was comparable to the parent. Stabilizing mutations probably increased thermostability by increasing the hydrophilicity and polarity of the protein surface and creating hydrophobic contacts inside the protein. CONCLUSIONS: P. pastoris was shown to be a valuable cell factory to improve thermostability of enzymes by directed evolution and it also could be used for improving other properties of enzymes. In this study, by using P. pastoris as a host to build mutant pool, we succeeded in obtaining a thermostable variant S4-3 without compromising enzyme activity and making it a highly promising candidate for future applications at high temperatures.     

Directed evolution of enzyme stability

Modern enzyme development relies to an increasing extent on strategies based on diversity generation followed by screening for variants with optimised properties. In principle, these directed evolution strategies might be used for optimising any enzyme property, which can be screened for in an economically feasible way, even if the molecular basis of that property is not known. Stability is an interesting property of enzymes because (1) it is of great industrial importance, (2) it is relatively easy to screen for, and (3) the molecular basis of stability relates closely to contemporary issues in protein science such as the protein folding problem and protein folding diseases. Thus, engineering enzyme stability is of both commercial and scientific interest. Here, we review how directed evolution has contributed to the development of stable enzymes and to new insight into the principles of protein stability. Several recent examples are described. These examples show that directed evolution is an effective strategy to obtain stable enzymes, especially when used in combination with rational or semi-rational engineering strategies. With respect to the principles of protein stability, some important lessons to learn from recent efforts in directed evolution are (1) that there are many structural ways to stabilize a protein, which are not always easy to rationalize, (2) that proteins may very well be stabilized by optimizing their surfaces, and (3) that high thermal stability may be obtained without forfeiture of catalytic performance at low temperatures.     

Chemical modification of enzymes for enhanced functionality.

The explosion in commercial and synthetic applications of enzymes has stimulated much of the interest in enhancing enzyme functionality and stability. Covalent chemical modification, the original method available for altering protein properties, has now re-emerged as a powerful complementary approach to site-directed mutagenesis and directed evolution for tailoring proteins and enzymes. Glutaraldehyde crosslinking of enzyme crystals and polyethylene glycol (PEG) modification of enzyme surface amino groups are practical methods to enhance biocatalyst stability. Whereas crosslinking of enzyme crystals generates easily recoverable insoluble biocatalysts, PEGylation increases solubility in organic solvents. Chemical modification has been exploited for the incorporation of cofactors onto protein templates and for atom replacement in order to generate new functionality, such as the conversion of a hydrolase into a peroxidase. Despite the breadth of applicability of chemically modified enzymes, a difficulty that has previously impeded their implementation is the lack of chemo- or regio-specificity of chemical modifications, which can yield heterogeneous and irreproducible product mixtures. This challenge has recently been addressed by the introduction of a unique position for modification by a site-directed mutation that can subsequently be chemically modified to introduce an unnatural amino acid sidechain in a highly chemo- and regio-specific manner.     

Directed evolution of aldolases for exploitation in synthetic organic chemistry

This review focuses on the directed evolution of aldolases with synthetically useful properties. Directed evolution has been used to address a number of limitations associated with the use of wild-type aldolases as catalysts in synthetic organic chemistry. The generation of aldolase enzymes with a modified or expanded substrate repertoire is described. Particular emphasis is placed on the directed evolution of aldolases with modified stereochemical properties: such enzymes can be useful catalysts in the stereoselective synthesis of biologically active small molecules. The review also describes some of the fundamental insights into mechanistic enzymology that directed evolution can provide.     

Directed evolution strategies for improved enzymatic performance

The engineering of enzymes with altered activity, specificity and stability, using directed evolution techniques that mimic evolution on a laboratory timescale, is now well established. However, the general acceptance of these methods as a route to new biocatalysts for organic synthesis requires further improvement of the methods for both ease-of-use and also for obtaining more significant changes in enzyme properties than is currently possible. Recent advances in library design, and methods of random mutagenesis, combined with new screening and selection tools, continue to push forward the potential of directed evolution. For example, protein engineers are now beginning to apply the vast body of knowledge and understanding of protein structure and function, to the design of focussed directed evolution libraries, with striking results compared to the previously favoured random mutagenesis and recombination of entire genes. Significant progress in computational design techniques which mimic the experimental process of library screening is also now enabling searches of much greater regions of sequence-space for those catalytic reactions that are broadly understood and, therefore, possible to model.     

Semi-rational approaches to engineering enzyme activity: combining the benefits of directed evolution and rational design

Many research groups successfully rely on whole-gene random mutagenesis and recombination approaches for the directed evolution of enzymes. Recent advances in enzyme engineering have used a combination of these random methods of directed evolution with elements of rational enzyme modification to successfully by-pass certain limitations of both directed evolution and rational design. Semi-rational approaches that target multiple, specific residues to mutate on the basis of prior structural or functional knowledge create 'smart' libraries that are more likely to yield positive results. Efficient sampling of mutations likely to affect enzyme function has been conducted both experimentally and, on a much greater scale, computationally, with remarkable improvements in substrate selectivity and specificity and in the de novo design of enzyme activities within scaffolds of known structure.     

Directing the evolution of Rubisco and Rubisco activase: first impressions of a new tool for photosynthesis research

During the last decade the practice of laboratory-directed protein evolution has become firmly established as a versatile tool in biochemical research by enabling molecular evolution toward desirable phenotypes or detection of novel structure-function interactions. Applications of this technique in the field of photosynthesis research are still in their infancy, but recently first steps have been reported in the directed evolution of the CO(2)-fixing enzyme Rubisco and its helper protein Rubisco activase. Here we summarize directed protein evolution strategies and review the progressive advances that have been made to develop and apply suitable selection systems for screening mutant forms of these enzymes that improve the fitness of the host organism. The goal of increasing photosynthetic efficiency of plants by improving the kinetics of Rubisco has been a long-term goal scoring modest successes. We discuss how directed evolution methodologies may one day be able to circumvent the problems encountered during this venture.     

Extending the capabilities of nature's most versatile catalysts: directed evolution of mammalian xenobiotic-metabolizing P450s

Cytochrome P450 enzymes are amongst the most versatile enzymatic catalysts known. The ability to introduce a single atom of oxygen into an organic substrate has led to the diversification and exploitation of these enzymes throughout nature. Nowhere is this versatility more apparent than in the mammalian liver, where P450 monooxygenases catalyze the metabolic clearance of innumerate drugs and other environmental chemicals. In addition to the aromatic and aliphatic hydroxylations, N- and O-dealkylations, and heteroatom oxidations that are common in drug metabolism, many more unusual reactions catalyzed by P450s have been discovered, including reductions, group transfers and other biotransformations not typically associated with monooxygenases. A research area that shows great potential for development over the next few decades is the directed evolution of P450s as biocatalysts. Mammalian xenobiotic-metabolizing P450s are especially well suited to such protein engineering due to their ability to interact with relatively wide ranges of substrates with marked differences in structure and physicochemical properties. Typical characteristics, such as the low turnover rates and poor coupling seen during the metabolism of xenobiotics, as well as the enzyme specificity towards particular substrates and reactions, can be improved by directed evolution. This mini-review will cover the fundamental enabling technologies required to successfully engineer P450s, examine the work done to date on the directed evolution of mammalian forms, and provide a perspective on what will be required for the successful implementation of engineered enzymes.     

Directed evolution of enzymes and biosynthetic pathways

Directed evolution is an important tool for overcoming the limitations of natural enzymes as biocatalysts. Recent advances have focused on applying directed evolution to a variety of enzymes, such as epoxide hydrolase, glyphosate N-acetyltransferase, xylanase and phosphotriesterase, in order to improve their activity, selectivity, stability and solubility. The focus has also shifted to manipulating biosynthetic pathways for the production of many naturally synthesized compounds, as well as the production of novel 'unnatural' compounds. A combined directed evolution and computational design approach is becoming increasingly important in exploring enzyme sequence-space and creating improved or novel enzymes. Fueled by recent breakthroughs in genomics and metagenomics, these developments should help expand the use of biocatalysts in industry.     

Metabolic engineering and directed evolution for the production of pharmaceuticals

The tools of metabolic and enzyme engineering have been well developed in academic laboratories and are now being applied for the optimization of biocatalysts used in the production of a wide range of pharmaceutically important molecules. Engineered microorganisms with a diverse set of modified or non-native enzyme activities are being used both to generate novel products and to provide improved processes for the manufacture of established products, such as in the production of precursors, intermediates, and complete compounds of importance to the pharmaceutical industry, including polyketides, nonribosomal peptides, steroids, vitamins, and unnatural amino acids. The use of directed evolution has rapidly emerged to be the method of choice for the development and selection of mutated enzymes with improved properties. A variety of such methods have been used to alter the activity, stability and availability of an array of enzymes. The industrial practice of these technologies at large scale is, however, in its infancy and stands as an exciting challenge for process scientists today.