Kinetic explanations for the sequence biases observed in the nonenzymatic copying of RNA templates

The identification of nonenzymatic pathways for nucleic acid replication is a key challenge in understanding the origin of life. We have previously shown that nonenzymatic RNA primer extension using 2-aminoimidazole (2AI) activated nucleotides occurs primarily through an imidazolium-bridged dinucleotide intermediate. The reactive nature and preorganized structure of the intermediate increase the efficiency of primer extension but remain insufficient to drive extensive copying of RNA templates containing all four canonical nucleotides. To understand the factors that limit RNA copying, we synthesized all ten 2AI-bridged dinucleotide intermediates and measured the kinetics of primer extension in a model system. The affinities of the ten dinucleotides for the primer/template/helper complexes vary by over 7,000-fold, consistent with nearest neighbor energetic predictions. Surprisingly, the reaction rates at saturating intermediate concentrations still vary by over 15-fold, with the most weakly binding dinucleotides exhibiting a lower maximal reaction rate. Certain noncanonical nucleotides can decrease sequence dependent differences in affinity and primer extension rate, while monomers bridged to short oligonucleotides exhibit enhanced binding and reaction rates. We suggest that more uniform binding and reactivity of imidazolium-bridged intermediates may lead to the ability to copy arbitrary template sequences under prebiotically plausible conditions.     

Template-directed primer extension catalyzed by the Tetrahymena ribozyme.

The Tetrahymena ribozyme has been shown to catalyze an RNA polymerase-like reaction in which an RNA primer is extended by the sequential addition of pN nucleotides derived from GpN dinucleotides, where N = A, C, or U. Here, we show that this reaction is influenced by the presence of a template; bases that can form Watson-Crick base pairs with a template add as much as 25-fold more efficiently than mismatched bases. A mutant enzyme with an altered guanosine binding site can catalyze template-directed primer extension with all four bases when supplied with dinucleotides of the form 2-aminopurine-pN.     

The strength of the template effect attracting nucleotides to naked DNA

The transmission of genetic information relies on Watson–Crick base pairing between nucleoside phosphates and template bases in template–primer complexes. Enzyme-free primer extension is the purest form of the transmission process, without any chaperon-like effect of polymerases. This simple form of copying of sequences is intimately linked to the origin of life and provides new opportunities for reading genetic information. Here, we report the dissociation constants for complexes between (deoxy)nucleotides and template–primer complexes, as determined by nuclear magnetic resonance and the inhibitory effect of unactivated nucleotides on enzyme-free primer extension. Depending on the sequence context, K_d′s range from 280 mM for thymidine monophosphate binding to a terminal adenine of a hairpin to 2 mM for a deoxyguanosine monophosphate binding in the interior of a sequence with a neighboring strand. Combined with rate constants for the chemical step of extension and hydrolytic inactivation, our quantitative theory explains why some enzyme-free copying reactions are incomplete while others are not. For example, for GMP binding to ribonucleic acid, inhibition is a significant factor in low-yielding reactions, whereas for amino-terminal DNA hydrolysis of monomers is critical. Our results thus provide a quantitative basis for enzyme-free copying.     

Capped nonviral sequences at the 5' end of the mRNAs of rice hoja blanca virus RNA4.

Subgenomic RNAs of both polarities corresponding to rice hoja blanca virus (RHBV) ambisense RNA4 were detected in RHBV-infected rice tissues. Total RNA extracted from RHBV-infected and noninfected rice tissues and RNA4 purified from RHBV ribonucleoprotein particles were used as templates for primer extension studies. The RNAs extracted from RHBV-infected tissues contain a population of RNA molecules with 10 to 17 nonviral nucleotides at their 5' end. The RNA-cDNA hybrids resulting from primer extension of such RNA molecules were specifically immunoselected with anti-cap antibodies, indicating that the subgenomic RNAs are capped and probably serve as mRNAs and that the additional nucleotides at their 5' end possibly derive from host mRNAs via a cap-snatching mechanism.     

The functional role of a DNA primase in chloroplast DNA replication in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii.

A complementation experiment was developed to identify the protein component that is essential for the in vitro replication of a cloned template containing a chloroplast DNA replication origin of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Using this method, we have identified a DNA primase activity that copurified with DNA polymerase from the crude protein mixture. The primase catalyzed the synthesis of short RNA primers on single-stranded DNA templates. Among the synthetic templates, the order of preference was poly(dA), poly(dT), and poly(dC). The primer size range for these templates was 11-18, 5-12, and 3-11 nucleotides, respectively. On a single-stranded template containing the chloroplast DNA replication origin, the primer length range reached 19 to 27 nucleotides, indicating a better processtivity. Several initiation sites were mapped on both strands of the cloned replication origin. Some preferential initiation sites were located on A tracks spaced at one helical turn apart within the bending locus. Primase improved the template specificity of the in vitro DNA replication system and enhanced the incorporation of radioactive dATP into the supercoiled template containing the core sequences of the chloroplast DNA replication origin.     

Mononucleotide and dinucleotide frequencies, and codon usage in poliovirion RNA.

The polio type 1 (Mahoney) RNA sequence (1) has been analyzed in terms of the distribution of its mononucleotides, dinucleotides and trinucleotides (codons). The distribution of adenosine in the sequence is nonuniform, being lower at the 5' end and higher at the 3' end. The dinucleotide CG is relatively rare and the dinucleotides UG and CA are relatively more common than expected. Codon usage is decidedly nonrandom. Codons containing CG are avoided and those ending in adenosine are favored. The asymmetric use of mononucleotides, dinucleotides and codons in polio RNA is unexplained at the present time although the lowered CG frequency may be the result of a DNA origin for polio RNA.     

A new approach to SNP genotyping with fluorescently labeled mononucleotides

Fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) is one of the most powerful and promising tools for single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) genotyping. However, the present methods using FRET require expensive reagents such as fluorescently labeled oligonucleotides. Here, we describe a novel and cost-effective method for SNP genotyping using FRET. The technique is based on allele-specific primer extension using mononucleotides labeled with a green dye and a red dye. When the target DNA contains the sequence complementary to the primer, extension of the primer incorporates the green and red dye-labeled nucleotides into the strand, and red fluorescence is emitted by FRET. In contrast, when the 3′ end nucleotide of the primer is not complementary to the target DNA, there is no extension of the primer, or FRET signal. Therefore, discrimination among genotypes is achieved by measuring the intensity of red fluorescence after the extension reaction. We have validated this method with 11 SNPs, which were successfully determined by end-point measurements of fluorescence intensity. The new strategy is simple and cost-effective, because all steps of the preparation consist of simple additions of solutions and incubation, and the dye-labeled mononucleotides are applicable to all SNP analyses. This method will be suitable for large-scale genotyping.     

Mapping initiation sites for simian virus 40 DNA synthesis events in vitro.

Primer RNA-DNA, a small (approximately 30-nucleotide) RNA-DNA hybrid molecule, was identified in recent studies of simian virus 40 DNA synthesis in vitro. The available evidence indicates that primer RNA-DNA is the product of the polymerase alpha-primase complex. Primer RNA-DNA is formed exclusively on lagging-strand DNA templates; it is synthesized initially in the vicinity of the simian virus 40 origin and at later times at sites progressively distal to the origin. To further characterize initiation events, template sequences encoding the 5' ends of both primer RNA and primer DNA, formed during a 5-s pulse, have been determined. Analyses of these sequences demonstrate the existence of an initiation signal for lagging-strand synthesis. At any given position, the initiation signal is located within those template sequences encoding primer RNA, situated proximal to the nucleotide encoding the 5' end of the RNA primer. In most instances, the sequence 5'-TTN-3' (where N encodes the nucleotide at the 5' end of the primer) is a feature of the initiation signal. Initiation signals are present, on average, once every 19 nucleotides. These results are discussed in terms of the mechanism of Okazaki fragment formation and possible links between prokaryotic and eukaryotic initiation events.     

DNA sequencing by synthesis with degenerate primers

The degenerate primer-based sequencing Was developed by a synthesis method(DP-SBS)for high-throughput DNA sequencing,in which a set of degenerate primers are hybridized on the arrayed DNA templates and extended by DNA polymerase on microarrays.In this method,adifferent set of degenerate primers containing a give nnumber(n)of degenerate nucleotides at the 3'-ends were annealed to the sequenced templates that were immobilized on the solid surface.The nucleotides(n 1)on the template sequences were determined by detecting the incorporation of fluorescent labeled nucleotides.The fluorescent labeled nucleotide was incorporated into the primer in a base-specific manner after the enzymatic primer extension reactions and nine-base length were read out accurately.The main advanmge of the DP-SBS is that the method only uses very conventional biochemical reagents and avoids the complicated special chemical reagents for removing the labeled nucleotides and reactivating the primer for further extension.From the present study,it is found that the DP-SBS method is reliable,simple,and cost-effective for laboratory-sequencing a large amount of short DNA fragments.     

In vitro recombination and terminal elongation of RNA by Q beta replicase.

SV-11 is a short-chain [115 nucleotides (nt)] RNA species that is replicated by Q beta replicase. It is reproducibly selected when MNV-11, another 87 nt RNA species, is extensively amplified by Q beta replicase at high ionic strength and long incubation times. Comparing the sequences of the two species reveals that SV-11 contains an inverse duplication of the high-melting domain of MNV-11. SV-11 is thus a recombinant between the plus and minus strands of MNV-11 resulting in a nearly palindromic sequence. During chain elongation in replication, the chain folds consecutively to a metastable secondary structure of the RNA, which can rearrange spontaneously to a more stable hairpin-form RNA. While the metastable form is an excellent template for Q beta replicase, the stable RNA is unable to serve as template. When initiation of a new chain is suppressed by replacing GTP in the replication mixture by ITP, Q beta replicase adds nucleotides to the 3' terminus of RNA. The replicase uses parts of the RNA sequence, preferentially the 3' terminal part for copying, thereby creating an interior duplication. This reaction is about five orders of magnitude slower than normal template-instructed synthesis. The reaction also adds nucleotides to the 3' terminus of some RNA molecules that are unable to serve as templates for Q beta replicase.     

SNP typing by apyrase-mediated allele-specific primer extension on DNA microarrays

This study reports the development of a microarray-based allele-specific extension method for typing of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The use of allele-specific primers has been employed previously to identify single base variations but it is acknowledged that certain mismatches are not refractory to extension. Here we have overcome this limitation by introducing apyrase, a nucleotide-degrading enzyme, to the extension reaction. We have shown previously that DNA polymerases exhibit slower reaction kinetics when extending a mismatched primer compared with a matched primer. This kinetic difference is exploited in the apyrase-mediated allele-specific extension (AMASE) assay, allowing incorporation of nucleotides when the reaction kinetics are fast but degrading the nucleotides before extension when the reaction kinetics are slow. Here we show that five homozygous variants (14% of the total number of variants) that were incorrectly scored in the absence of apyrase were correctly typed when apyrase was included in the extension reaction. AMASE was performed in situ on the oligonucleotide microarrays using fluorescent nucleotides to type 10 SNPs and two indels in 17 individuals generating approximately 200 genotypes. Cluster analysis of these data shows three distinct clusters with clear-cut boundaries. We conclude that SNP typing on oligonucleotide microarrays by AMASE is an efficient, rapid and accurate technique for large-scale genotyping.     

The Paradox of Dual Roles in the RNA World: Resolving the Conflict Between Stable Folding and Templating Ability

The hypothesized dual roles of RNA as both information carrier and biocatalyst during the earliest stages of life require a combination of features: good templating ability (for replication) and stable folding (for ribozymes). However, this poses the following paradox: well-folded sequences are poor templates for copying, but poorly folded sequences are unlikely to be good ribozymes. Here, we describe a strategy to overcome this dilemma through G:U wobble pairing in RNA. Unlike Watson–Crick base pairs, wobble pairs contribute highly to the energetic stability of the folded structure of their sequence, but only slightly, if at all, to the stability of the folded reverse complement. Sequences in the RNA World might thereby combine stable folding of the ribozyme with an unstructured, reverse-complementary genome, resulting in a “division of labor” between the strands. We demonstrate this strategy using computational simulations of RNA folding and an experimental model of early replication, nonenzymatic template-directed RNA primer extension. Additional study is needed to solve other problems associated with a complete replication cycle, including separation of strands after copying. Interestingly, viroid RNA sequences, which have been suggested to be relics of an RNA World (Diener, Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86:9370–9374, 1989), also show significant asymmetry in folding energy between the infectious (+) and template (?) strands due to G:U pairing, suggesting that this strategy may even be used by replicators in the present day.     

5 Efficient and high-fidelity copying of an RNA-like model prebiotic system

Nonenzymatic RNA replication would provide an important bridge to the RNA world. However, the demonstration of efficient and high-fidelity copying chemistry remains a great experimental challenge. It requires an efficient mechanism that can lead to both a high rate of polymerization and a high degree of fidelity in the copying chemistry. Previous experiments concerning nonenzymatic template-directed synthesis of RNA with activated monomers have led to the copying of short RNA templates, but these reactions are generally slow (taking days to weeks) and highly error-prone. Therefore, the ability to efficiently and accurately copy arbitrary template sequences remains frustratingly out of reach. N3′-P5′-linked phosphoramidate DNA is a highly reactive model for self-replicating genetic materials and has been used for studies of nonenzymatic RNA self-replication. It is also an excellent RNA mimic, due to its similar overall duplex structure, rigidity, and level of hydration (Tereshko, Gryaznov, & Egli, 1998). Our experiments show that the high reactivity imparted by the presence of an amino nucleophile allows rapid and efficient copying of all four nucleobases on both homopolymeric and mixed templates. On the other hand, G:T wobble pairing leads to a high error rate. We have, therefore, investigated the use of the modified nucleobase, 2-thio T (Ts) (Sintim & Kool, 2006), to suppress formation of the G:T wobble base-pair. Our results illustrate that the 2-thio modification can both increase polymerization rate and enhance fidelity in this self-replicating N3′-P5′-DNA system. These results suggest that this simple nucleobase modification may have played a role in primordial RNA (or proto-RNA) replication. In addition to suppressing the G:T mismatch, an additional benefit gained from its stronger base-pairing with A is that it also reduces A:C mismatch formation. Thus, simple modifications of nucleobases might provide a means of suppressing mismatches to yield better fidelity. Taken together, our results show that a high rate of polymerization and a high degree of fidelity are not mutually exclusive, but can be achieved simultaneously in nonenzymatic copying of N3′-P5′-linked phosphoramidate DNA. The structural similarity of NP-DNA to RNA suggests that these results could be translated to an RNA-only system.     

Primer-dependent synthesis of covalently linked dimeric RNA molecules by poliovirus replicase.

Poliovirus-specific RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (replicase, 3Dpol) was purified from HeLa cells infected with poliovirus. The purified enzyme preparation contained two proteins of apparent molecular weights 63,000 and 35,000. The 63,000-Mr polypeptide was virus-specific RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, and the 35,000-Mr polypeptide was of host origin. Both polypeptides copurified through five column chromatographic steps. The purified enzyme preparation catalyzed synthesis of covalently linked dimeric RNA products from a poliovirion RNA template. This reaction was absolutely dependent on added oligo(U) primer, and the dimeric product appeared to be made of both plus- and minus-strand RNA molecules. Experiments with 5' [32P]oligo(U) primer and all four unlabeled nucleotides suggest that the viral replicase elongates the primer, copying the poliovirion RNA template (plus strand), and the newly synthesized minus strand snaps back on itself to generate a template-primer structure which is elongated by the replicase to form covalently linked dimeric RNA molecules. Kinetic studies showed that a partially purified preparation of poliovirus replicase contains a nuclease which can cleave the covalently linked dimeric RNA molecules, generating template-length RNA products.     

Deconstructing the Polymerase Chain Reaction: Understanding and Correcting Bias Associated with Primer Degeneracies and Primer-Template Mismatches

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is sensitive to mismatches between primer and template, and mismatches can lead to inefficient amplification of targeted regions of DNA template. In PCRs in which a degenerate primer pool is employed, each primer can behave differently. Therefore, inefficiencies due to different primer melting temperatures within a degenerate primer pool, in addition to mismatches between primer binding sites and primers, can lead to a distortion of the true relative abundance of targets in the original DNA pool. A theoretical analysis indicated that a combination of primer-template and primer-amplicon interactions during PCR cycles 3–12 is potentially responsible for this distortion. To test this hypothesis, we developed a novel amplification strategy, entitled “Polymerase-exonuclease (PEX) PCR”, in which primer-template interactions and primer-amplicon interactions are separated. The PEX PCR method substantially and significantly improved the evenness of recovery of sequences from a mock community of known composition, and allowed for amplification of templates with introduced mismatches near the 3’ end of the primer annealing sites. When the PEX PCR method was applied to genomic DNA extracted from complex environmental samples, a significant shift in the observed microbial community was detected. Furthermore, the PEX PCR method provides a mechanism to identify which primers in a primer pool are annealing to target gDNA. Primer utilization patterns revealed that at high annealing temperatures in the PEX PCR method, perfect match annealing predominates, while at lower annealing temperatures, primers with up to four mismatches with templates can contribute substantially to amplification. The PEX PCR method is simple to perform, is limited to PCR mixes and a single exonuclease step which can be performed without reaction cleanup, and is recommended for reactions in which degenerate primer pools are used or when mismatches between primers and template are possible.