Programs for evaluating and characterising bacterial taxonomic data

Three programs are described for evaluating and characterisingdata collected during numerical taxonomic studies of bacteria.The program VARIANCE compares replicate cultures and evaluatesthe reproducibility of each character. Also it identifies thosecharacters that should be excluded from subsequent taxonomicanalysis because of their poor reproducibility. GPROPS summarisesthe properties of clusters of strains that have been definedfrom a cluster analysis, it can produce a probabilistic identificationmatrix and compares each strain within a cluster with the HypotheticalMean Organism (HMO) of that cluster. OVCLUST is an implementationof the program described by Sneath (1979) which calculates overlapstatistics between major clusters. These programs are designedto complement the CLUSTAN package (Wishart, 1982) which is oftenused for cluster analysis of bacterial taxonomic data. The programswere written in FORTRAN 77 and implemented on an IBM PC usingMS–DOS. Received on November 13, 1986; accepted on January 8, 1987     

A numerical taxonomic study of Leuconostoc oenos strains from wine

Phenotypic data of 108 tests conducted on 70 malolactic bacteria, including 54 presumptive Leuconostoc oenos strains, five presumptive pediococci isolated from wine and 11 reference strains, were analysed by numerical taxonomic techniques. Using the simple matching coefficient, 58 strains were grouped in six clusters at the 87% S level. Cell wall analysis of the interpeptide bridges and morphology was also used to differentiate between the strains. No L. oenos reference strains were found to group in any cluster. The hypothetical median organism (HMO) of cluster A was related at only the 63% S level to the L. oenos type strain and it is proposed that these strains be regarded as 'L. gracile'. The majority of the L. oenos strains (35) grouped together at above the 91% S level in cluster B, with the HMO of this cluster related at the 75% S level to the L. oenos type strain. Results indicate that the majority of L. oenos strains included in this study are closely related, but more research is needed to justify the separation of these strains into more than one species.     

Properties of Bacteria Isolated from Deep-Sea Sediments

Thirty-eight isolates were subjected to taxonomic analysis by computer. Of the 38 isolates, 31 were from sediment samples collected at depths from 9,400 to 10,400 meters in the Philippine and Marianas Trenches of the Pacific Ocean, and 7 cultures were from seawater samples collected at various depths from surface to 4,000 meters and from several locations in the Pacific Ocean. A total of 116 characteristics were determined for each isolate, coded, and transferred to punch cards. Similarity values were obtained by computer analysis, with the use of two recently developed computer programs. Five distinct phenetic clusters were observed from the numerical analyses. Four of the clusters were identified as species of the genus Pseudomonas, and one, as an aerogenic species of Aeromonas. Group IV was identified as pigmented Pseudomonas fluorescens, and the major cluster, consisting of groups I and II, which merged at a species level of similarity, was treated as a new species of Pseudomonas. The 38 strain data were compared with data for 132 marine and nonmarine strains previously subjected to computer taxonomic analysis. The barotolerant deep-sea strains, with the exception of the deep-sea P. fluorescens isolates, clustered separately from all other marine strains.     

THE USE OF PROTEIN-SEROLOGICAL CHARACTERS IN THE SYSTEMATICS OF THE FAMILY OLEACEAE

Serological analyses of soluble seed proteins of 12 representative taxa of the family Oleaceae by the techniques of Ouchterlony, presaturation, and immunoelectrophoresis (IEP) yielded complementary taxonomic information. Ouchterlony reactions differentiated among protein extracts of three species, and the combined serological techniques permitted the detection of protein differences of respective taxa of the two subfamilies Jasminoideae and Oleoideae. IEP enabled the separation of the 12 taxa investigated and the distribution into the two subfamilies, by the differential electrophoretic positions of precipitin arcs, which were consistent with members of each of the two subfamilies. Presaturation data, when analyzed by two cluster analysis computer programs, were taxonomically significant. One program, which calculated amalgamation distances from the presaturation data, clustered the 12 taxa into subgroups which corresponded to tribes, and within two groups, which corresponded to two subfamilies. A monothetic clustering program provided theoretical information on evolution of taxa within the family Oleaceae based on serological correspondences obtained from the presaturation data; the subfamily Jasminoideae was found phylogenetically primitive and the subfamily Oleoideae was advanced. Additionally, IEP data supported those theories suggesting that taxa of the Oleoideae evolved from taxa of the Jasminoideae. The groupings of taxa and different information obtained from the cluster analyses of data and all serological techniques reinforced each other, as well as contemporary taxonomic and phylogenetic treatments of taxa of the family Oleaceae. This research demonstrated the taxonomic value of protein-serological data, particularly as applied to the taxonomy of the Oleaceae.     

Taxonomy and Description of Vibrio fluvialis sp. nov. (Synonym Group F Vibrios, Group EF6)

A numerical taxonomic study has been carried out to establish the relationship of group F to other biochemically similar organisms within the family Vibrionaceae. A total of 154 strains were examined including 59 of group F. Out of 114 characters determined for each strain 100 were used to compute average Euclidean distances between strains. Four methods of clustering were used, all of which gave very similar results.
Strains resembling Vibrio anguillarum fell into clusters corresponding to V. anguillarum, Beneckea nereida and a previously unrecognized group, phenon 5. Strains of the Aeromonas hydrophila/punctata group formed a heterogenous phenon within which certain subdivisions, perhaps artificial, could be discerned.
Group F strains all fell in one closely-knit cluster distinct from all the species of Vibrio, Aeromonas, Plesiomonas and Photobacteriwn studied. Group F strains could be divided into two biovars, I and II. Both biovars are present in aquatic, particularly estuarine, environments throughout the world but biovar I strains have also been isolated from humans with diarrhoea. It is concluded that group F is a synonym of group EF6 and that the strains within these groups should be classified in a new species named Vibrio fluvialis. The type strain is NCTC 11327.     

Classification of some lactic acid bacteria from vacuum-packed meats by direct probe mass spectrometry

The technique of direct probe mass spectrometry (DPMS) has been applied to the classification of 40 strains of lactic acid bacteria from refrigerated vacuum-packed beef, pork, lamb and bacon. Relationships between strains were examined by multi-variate statistical techniques using sets of ions selected for reproducibility and sample discrimination. Five groups were distinguished which corresponded closely to those detected in a previous numerical taxonomic study. Two groups contained all 12 representatives of a cluster of unidentifiable non-aciduric streptobacteria whose sub-division is supported by other taxonomic evidence. All twenty-one strains from a cluster of aciduric streptobacteria provisionally identified with Lacto-bacillus sake were contained in two further groups. The sub-division of these acid-uric strains revealed by DPMS has not been verified by other techniques and requires further investigation. The fifth group contained Leuconostoc strains. The study demonstrates the value of DPMS in confirming and clarifying classification schemes obtained by conventional methods.     

Classification of some lactic acid bacteria from vacuum-packed meats by direct probe mass spectrometry

The technique of direct probe mass spectrometry (DPMS) has been applied to the classification of 40 strains of lactic acid bacteria from refrigerated vacuum-packed beef, pork, lamb and bacon. Relationships between strains were examined by multi-variate statistical techniques using sets of ions selected for reproducibility and sample discrimination. Five groups were distinguished which corresponded closely to those detected in a previous numerical taxonomic study. Two groups contained all 12 representatives of a cluster of unidentifiable non-aciduric streptobacteria whose sub-division is supported by other taxonomic evidence. All twenty-one strains from a cluster of aciduric streptobacteria provisionally identified with Lactobacillus sake were contained in two further groups. The sub-division of these aciduric strains revealed by DPMS has not been verified by other techniques and requires further investigation. The fifth group contained Leuconostoc strains. The study demonstrates the value of DPMS in confirming and clarifying classification schemes obtained by conventional methods.     

Presence of a novel 16S-23S rRNA gene intergenic spacer insert in Bradyrhizobium canariense strains

Seven slow-growing bacterial strains isolated from root nodules of yellow serradella (Ornithopus compressus) that originated from Asinara Island on North Western Sardinia in Italy were characterized by partial 16S rRNA gene and intergenic spacer (ITS) sequencing as well as amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) genomic fingerprinting. The results indicated that the O. compressus isolates belong to the Bradyrhizobium canariense species. The analysis of ITS sequences divided the branch of B. canariense strains into two statistically separated groups (ITS clusters I and II). All the strains in ITS cluster I showed the presence of unique oligonucleotide insert TTAGAGACTTAGGTTTCTK. This insert was neither found in other described species of the family Rhizobiaceae nor in any other bacterial families and can be used as a natural and high selective genetic marker for ITS cluster I of B. canariense strains. ITS grouping of O. compressus isolates was supported by the unweighted pair group method with arithmetic averages cluster analysis of their AFLP patterns, suggesting that the strains of ITS cluster II were genetically closer to each other than to isolates from the ITS cluster I. A taxonomic importance is supposed of the revealed 19 bp ITS insert for an intraspecific division within high heterogeneous B. canariense species.     

MCS/SEL/BAS program--an overlapping clustering method with examples from mating type interactions of ciliated protozoa

The MCS/SEL/BAS program provides a method for group recognition,based on a criterion of homegeneity within the groups. The basicaim of this clustering method is not to ‘force’data into a number of separate groups, as it allows the possibilitythat a given element in the data set can be assigned to morethan one group. Moreover, a parsimonious path through the groupsis sought by selecting groups on the basis of two suitably chosen,peak-ordered criteria. This selection continues until a coveringof the data set is obtained (i. e., until each element in thedata set is assigned to at least one group). Then relationshipsoccurring among the set of selected groups are investigatedby means of two coefficients, called overlapping and cohesioncoefficient, respectively. The utility of this program has beendemonstrated here in elaborating large sets of data derivedfrom mating type interactions of ciliates, but it can be usedalso for analyzing data derived from a wide spectrum of compatibilityphenomena exhibited by other living organisms. Algorithms ofthis program are written in BASIC and formulated in a conversationalmode for processing on a Macintosh. A computer program (MCS/SEL/BAS)is available from G.Mancini upon request. Received on September 18, 1990; accepted on January 21, 1991     

Characterization of oxytetracycline-resistant heterotrophic bacteria originating from hospital and freshwater fishfarm environments in England and Ireland

This ecotaxonomic study compared the antibiotic tolerance among culturable oxytetracyline-resistant (Ot(r)) heterotrophic strains isolated from two aquatic environments representing human activities in health care and aquaculture, namely hospital effluents and freshwater fishfarms. Using a standardized methodology, samples taken in England and Ireland were analyzed to determine the antibiotic tolerance profiles of two groups of culturable Ot(r) bacterial isolates at the intergeneric and intrageneric level comprising heterotrophs (189 strains) and mesophilic Aeromonas spp. (153 strains), respectively. Antibiogram data of heterotrophic isolates revealed that Irish hospital strains comprised higher frequencies of multi-tolerance than those originating from fishfarm environments whereas a reverse correlation was found among the English heterotrophs. Polyphasic identification of the isolates using fatty acid analysis and API 20E profiling showed that this difference arose from the unique taxonomic diversity within each heterotrophic strain set. Acinetobacter (27%) and Brevundimonas (22%) were predominant among the Irish Ot(r) fishfarm isolates, whereas isolates originating from the English aquaculture site almost entirely consisted of Stenotrophomonas maltophilia (86%) exhibiting high frequencies of tolerance to ampicillin and streptomycin. Within both the English and the Irish Ot(r) Aeromonas strain sets, on the other hand, the hospital strain sets displayed higher numbers of multi-tolerant isolates than to fishfarm isolates although country-specific differences were observed for individual antimicrobial agents. The typical occurrence of kanamycin-tolerant aeromonads in the Irish hospital site could to some extent be linked to the typical presence of A. hydrophila DNA hybridization group (HG) 3 strains as determined by fatty acid analysis and fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism (FAFLP) fingerprinting. Essentially, these data indicate that tolerance profiles in a specific environment of one country do not necessarily reflect the corresponding tolerance profiles of the same type of environment in another country, and this mainly as a result of the unique taxonomic composition of each site. Ot(r) representatives of Acinetobacter, S. maltophilia, and A. veronii biovar sobria HG8 were common to most if not all of the four sites under study, indicating that these three taxa may serve as potential indicator organisms for monitoring antibiotic tolerance among indigenous bacterial populations in various aquatic environments.     

Identification of psychrotrophic pseudomonads from goats' milk by computer-assisted analysis of carbon source assimilation data

The results of carbon source assimilation tests on a group of psychrotrophic pseudomonas were compared with published data for established Pseudomonas taxa, using computer-assisted numerical taxonomic analysis and a modified diagnostic computer program. Several phenons were not grouped at the biovar level by numerical taxonomic analysis. Identification of strains by the diagnostic program revealed heterogeneity among those in the unassigned phenons, and supported a continuum concept among the fluorescent pseudomonads.     

Identification of psychrotrophic pseudomonads from goats'milk by computer-assisted analysis of carbon source assimilation data

The results of carbon source assimilation tests on a group of psychrotrophic pseudomonas were compared with published data for established Pseudomonas taxa, using computer-assisted numerical taxonomic analysis and a modified diagnostic computer program. Several phenons were not grouped at the biovar level by numerical taxonomic analysis. Identification of strains by the diagnostic program revealed heterogeneity among those in the unassigned phenons, and supported a continuum concept among the fluorescent pseudomonads.     

Restriction endonuclease analysis of mitochondrial DNA as an aid in the taxonomy of Naegleria and Vahlkampfia

Using restriction enzyme analysis, mitochondrial DNA fragment patterns from seven strains of pathogenic and nonpathogenic Naegleria and one strain of Vahlkampfia were compared to estimate nucleotide sequence divergence. Significantly high levels of estimated genetic variation between strains of N. gruberi, N. fowleri, and N. jadini support the current taxonomic level of the individual Naegleria species and suggest a distinct phylogeny for each group. Naegleria lovaniensis, strain TS, was shown to have significant nucleotide sequence homology with N. gruberi, strain EGs, suggesting that the two groups share a close taxonomic relationship. The pathogenic strain MB-41 of N. fowleri exhibited distinct genetic divergence from the highly homologous, pathogenic strain Nf66 and the drug-cured strain 6088. Morphologically distinct strains EGs and 1518/la of N. gruberi exhibited significantly large sequence divergence consistent with a more distant taxonomic relationship. Amoebae from the genus Vahlkampfia expressed genetic similarity with strains of N. gruberi.     

Phylogenetic analysis of aerobic methylotrophic bacteria, using dichloromethane

The phylogenetic relationships of 12 aerobic dichloromethane-degrading bacteria that implement different C1-assimilation pathways was determined based on 16S ribosomal RNA sequences and DNA-DNA hybridization data. The restricted facultative methylotroph "Methylophilus leisingerii" DM11 with the ribulose monophosphate pathway was found to belong to the genus Methylophilus cluster of the beta subdivision of the phylogenetic kingdom Proteobacteria. The facultative methylotroph Methylorhabdus multivorans DM13 was assigned to a separate branch of the alpha-2 group of Proteobacteria. Paracoccus methylutens DM12, which utilizes C1-compounds via the Calvin cycle was found to belong to the alpha-3 group of the Proteobacteria (more precisely, to the genus Paracoccus cluster). Thus, phylogenetic analysis confirmed the taxonomic status of these recently characterized bacteria. According to the degree of DNA homology, several novel strains of methylotrophic bacteria were divided into three genotypic groups within the alpha-2 group of the Proteobacteria. Genotypic group 1, comprising strains DM1, DM3, and DM5 through DM9, and genotypic group 3, comprising strain DM10, were phylogenetically close to the methylotrophic bacteria of the genus Methylopila, whereas genotypic group 2 (strain DM4) was close to bacteria of the genus Methylobacterium. The genotypic groups obviously represent distinct taxa of methylotrophic bacteria, whose status should be confirmed by phenotypic analysis.     

Electrophoretic patterns of cell wall protein as a criterion for the identification and classification of Corynebacteria

Electrophoretic patterns of cell wall protein of three industrial strains, that were used for production of lysin, and eight collection strains from the genus Corynevacterium were studied to analyze their similarity as well as to estimate an opportunity of using this parameter as an additional criterion for identification and classification of corynebacteria. Similarity coefficient of cell wall overall and main protein electrophoretic patterns were determined by a specially created computer program. Electrophoretic analysis showed that every specie had an individual protein profile. There were determined biopolymers common for the specie, genus and individual among the overall majors and minors. The obtained results showed, that the patterns of main proteins were more conservative and informative in comparison with those ones of overall proteins. The definition of similarity coefficient by the main protein patterns has correlated with the protein profile characteristics of every analyzed strain, and it managed to distribute them into the separate groups. The similarity coefficient of preparations by the main protein patterns allows to separate one specie or a strain from another, and that gives us a chance to claim that this parameter could be used as an additional criterion for differentiation and referring the corynebacteria to a certain taxonomic group.     

TAXONOMIC STUDY OF MARINE OSCILLATORIACEAN STRAINS (CYANOBACTERIA) WITH NARROW TRICHOMES. II. NUCLEOTIDE SEQUENCE ANALYSIS OF THE 16S RIBOSOMAL RNA1

Partial 16S ribosomal RNA sequences from five marine oscillatoriacean strains with narrow trichomes were determined by a dideoxynucleotide-termination method. A phenogram was constructed by a distance matrix method including a bootstrap analysis. In addition, a consensus tree was built using cladistic analysis. The results were largely congruent and indicate that the five strains belong to two different lineages. The first lineage groups four phycoerythrin-producing strains with the strain PCC7375 (“Phormidium ectocarpi Gomont”). The second cluster groups strain PCC7105 (“Oscillatoria williamsii Drouet”) with the previously studied strain Microcoleus 10mfx. Comparisons to morphological data are made and the taxonomic level of the separations is estimated.     

Characterization of the genus Bifidobacterium by automated ribotyping and 16S rRNA gene sequences

In order to characterize the genus Bifidobacterium, ribopatterns and approximately 500 bp (Escherichia coli positions 27 to 520) of 16S rRNA gene sequences of 28 type strains and 64 reference strains of the genus Bifidobacterium were determined. Ribopatterns obtained from Bifidobacterium strains were divided into nine clusters (clusters I-IX) with a similarity of 60%. Cluster V, containing 17 species, was further subdivided into 22 subclusters with a similarity of 90%. In the genus Bifidobacterium, four groups were shown according to Miyake et al.: (i) the Bifidobacterium longum infantis-longum-suis type group, (ii) the B. catenulatum-pseudocatenulatum group, (iii) the B. gallinarum-saeculare-pullorum group, and (iv) the B. coryneforme-indicum group, which showed higher than 97% similarity of the 16S rRNA gene sequences in each group. Using ribotyping analysis, unique ribopatterns were obtained from these species, and they could be separated by cluster analysis. Ribopatterns of six B. adolescentis strains were separated into different clusters, and also showed diversity in 16S rRNA gene sequences. B. adolescentis consisted of heterogeneous strains. The nine strains of B. pseudolongum subsp. pseudolongum were divided into five subclusters. Each type strain of B. pseudolongum subsp. pseudolongum and B. pseudolongum subsp. globosum and two intermediate groups, which were suggested by Yaeshima et al., consisted of individual clusters. B. animalis subsp. animalis and B. animalis subsp. lactis could not be separated by ribotyping using Eco RI. We conclude that ribotyping is able to provide another characteristic of Bifidobacterium strains in addition to 16S rRNA gene sequence phylogenetic analysis, and this information suggests that ribotyping analysis is a useful tool for the characterization of Bifidobacterium species in combination with other techniques for taxonomic characterization.     

Pseudomonas fluorescens biovar V: its resolution into distinct component groups and the relationship of these groups to other P. fluorescens biovars, to P. putida, and to psychrotrophic pseudomonads associated with food spoilage

A numerical taxonomic analysis was performed to evaluate the appropriateness of a single biovar designation (biovar V) for all Pseudomonas fluorescens isolates negative for denitrification, levan production and phenazine pigmentation and to determine the relationship of biovar V strains to other taxa within the same Pseudomonas RNA homology group. Seventy-two strains assigned to P. fluorescens biovar V and four strains of P. fragi were characterized and the data subjected to a numerical taxonomic analysis along with comparable data for 17 previously characterized strains of this biovar and 89 P. putida strains. Seven distinct biovar V clusters containing three or more strains were revealed, and the carbon sources useful for their differentiation were identified. Cluster 1 (38 strains) closely resembled two atypical P. fluorescens I strains. It was also related to P. fluorescens biovar IV and to P. fragi. Cluster 2 (5 strains) was related to cluster 1. Cluster 3 (7 strains) was identical to a major group of meat spoilage psychrotrophic pseudomonads (P. lundensis). Cluster 4 (3 strains) was not related to any other group examined. Cluster 5 consisted of six isolates initially designated P. putida A along with four P. fluorescens biovar V strains all of which resembled P. putida more than they resembled the other P. fluorescens groups. Cluster 6 (16 strains) was distinct from the other biovar V clusters, but was closely related to P. fluorescens biovars I and II. Cluster 7 (3 strains) shared many characteristics with cluster 5. Separate P. fluorescens biovar designations are proposed for cluster 6 and for the combined clusters 1 and 2. A new P. putida biovar is proposed for the combined clusters 5 and 7.