Temperature-mediated dynamics of planktonic food chains: the effect of an invertebrate carnivore

1. This study involves an examination of two- and three-trophic-level food chains at two temperatures (18 and 25 °C) in order to determine how the addition of a carnivore to a predator–prey system can alter the dynamics of populations and how this effect may be temperature mediated. The system consisted of phytoplankton, Daphnia pulex and the flatworm Mesostoma ehrenbergii .
2. Although the plant–herbivore system is inherently unstable at 25 °C, the addition of the carnivore led to a further destabilization of the Daphnia –algal dynamics at the higher temperature. No destabilization effect of the carnivore was noted at 18 °C. At the lower temperature, all populations persisted and the carnivore induced changes only in the age structure of the Daphnia populations rather than in overall biomass.
3. The differential effects of the carnivore at two temperatures can be attributed to shifts in the life history, physiological rates and the reproductive strategy employed by Mesostoma .
4. Previous theoretical work has predicted that the addition of a third trophic level to an unstable predator–prey system should stabilize dynamics. Our results indicate that the effect of a carnivore on plant–herbivore dynamics can be significantly affected by ambient temperature.     

Temperature-mediated dynamics of planktonic food chains: the effect of an invertebrate carnivore

1. This study involves an examination of two- and three-trophic-level food chains at two temperatures (18 and 25 °C) in order to determine how the addition of a carnivore to a predator–prey system can alter the dynamics of populations and how this effect may be temperature mediated. The system consisted of phytoplankton, Daphnia pulex and the flatworm Mesostoma ehrenbergii .
2. Although the plant–herbivore system is inherently unstable at 25 °C, the addition of the carnivore led to a further destabilization of the Daphnia –algal dynamics at the higher temperature. No destabilization effect of the carnivore was noted at 18 °C. At the lower temperature, all populations persisted and the carnivore induced changes only in the age structure of the Daphnia populations rather than in overall biomass.
3. The differential effects of the carnivore at two temperatures can be attributed to shifts in the life history, physiological rates and the reproductive strategy employed by Mesostoma .
4. Previous theoretical work has predicted that the addition of a third trophic level to an unstable predator–prey system should stabilize dynamics. Our results indicate that the effect of a carnivore on plant–herbivore dynamics can be significantly affected by ambient temperature.     

Sensitivity of Daphnia to toxic cyanobacteria: effects of genotype and temperature

1. We studied the effects of both acute and chronic exposure of Daphnia pulex to toxic Microcystis aeruginosa . We focused on the effects of Daphnia genotype and temperature (19 and 24 °C).
2. The study revealed variation among ten Daphnia pulex clones in survivorship under acute Microcystis exposure, measured as EC₅₀. An increase in temperature caused a clear decrease in EC₅₀, although the ranking of clones according to sensitivity remained the same at both temperatures.
3. In the chronic exposure of two of the clones, toxic Microcystis reduced survival and reproduction. The two clones differed in their responses, indicating different means of coping with toxic cyanobacteria. Toxic cyanobacteria reduced slightly more at 24 °C than 19 °C.
4. The clonal difference in sensitivity to toxic cyanobacteria at acute exposure was reversed at chronic exposure. This indicates that the results from short-term toxicity cannot be used to predict life history responses under sublethal exposure.     

Sensitivity of Daphnia to toxic cyanobacteria: effects of genotype and temperature

1. We studied the effects of both acute and chronic exposure of Daphnia pulex to toxic Microcystis aeruginosa . We focused on the effects of Daphnia genotype and temperature (19 and 24 °C).
2. The study revealed variation among ten Daphnia pulex clones in survivorship under acute Microcystis exposure, measured as EC₅₀. An increase in temperature caused a clear decrease in EC₅₀, although the ranking of clones according to sensitivity remained the same at both temperatures.
3. In the chronic exposure of two of the clones, toxic Microcystis reduced survival and reproduction. The two clones differed in their responses, indicating different means of coping with toxic cyanobacteria. Toxic cyanobacteria reduced slightly more at 24 °C than 19 °C.
4. The clonal difference in sensitivity to toxic cyanobacteria at acute exposure was reversed at chronic exposure. This indicates that the results from short-term toxicity cannot be used to predict life history responses under sublethal exposure.     

Factors which affect the abundance of an invasive cladoceran, Daphnia lumholtzi, in U.S. reservoirs

1.  Daphnia lumholtzi is a subtropical, Old World species which is rapidly spreading throughout reservoirs in the southern U.S.A. It was first recorded in Lake Texoma (Oklahoma–Texas) in September 1991.
2. Southern U.S. reservoirs typically have strong spatial and temporal gradients in temperature, conductivity, turbidity and in the distribution of organisms. Therefore, the present experiments examined the reproductive and moulting rates, and survival of D . lumholtzi in relation to extremes of food concentration, temperature, conductivity and turbidity.
3. Increases in temperature (range = 15–29 °C) and decreases in turbidity (range = 0.6–470 NTU) increased reproductive and moulting rates, whereas food concentration only affected the rate of reproduction, while conductivity had no effects. Survival was affected only by temperature.
4.  Daphnia lumholtzi tolerates high temperatures (27–30 °C) at which other cladocerans in Lake Texoma disappear. Therefore, D . lumholtzi may exploit resources in midsummer, when there are few potential competitors.     

Life history consequences for Daphnia pulex feeding on nutrient-limited phytoplankton

1. The growth and feeding of Daphnia pulex De Geer on different algal species was examined. The green algae Chlamydomonas reinhardtii Dangeard and Scenedesmus acutus Meyen, the diatom Synedra tenuissima Kützing, the cryptophyte Cryptomonas pyrenoidifera Geitler and the cyanobacterium Microcystis aeruginosa Kützing were cultured in non-limiting and in N- or P-limiting medium and used as food for D. pulex.
2. Growth limitations were reflected in the elemental and biochemical composition and the morphological characteristics of the algal resources.
3. The clearance rates of D. pulex feeding on nutrient-limited algae were reduced. This was not observed when nutrient-limited mutant Chlamydomonas cells without cell walls were used as food, indicating that the cell wall may play an important part.
4. In comparison with animals grown on nutrient-sufficient cells, nutrient-limited algae resulted in smaller body length, reduced brood sizes, reduced size at maturity, increased age at first reproduction and, consequently, in reduced Daphnia population growth rates.
5. Daphnia population growth rates ( r ) were negatively correlated with the C : P ratio and the carbohydrate content of the food. Moreover, significant correlations between r and clearance rates were found.
6. The observed differences in the grazing and the life history parameters of Daphnia feeding on non-limited and nutrient-limited algae may be the result of both reduced nutritional value and reduced digestibility of nutrient-limited algae.     

The effect of temperature on the response of Daphnia to toxic cyanobacteria

1. In a set of life‐table experiments, cohorts of neonate Daphnia pulex were exposed to a toxic strain of Anabaena affinis and A. flos ‐ aquae , and to a pure cyanobacterial toxin (anatoxin‐a), at 12 or 14, 19, and 25 °C. The fecundity and survival of individual animals were assessed at 1‐, 2‐ or 3‐day intervals, depending on the temperature, through to the fifth brood of the control cohort. The sensitivity of D . pulex to the cyanobacteria and the toxin at each temperature was measured by determining its finite population growth rate (λ) in an experimental treatment as a fraction of that in a control treatment. Tests with three concentrations of cyanobacteria (1.0, 2.5 and 5.0 μg mL^–1) and one concentration of anatoxin‐a (1 μg mL^–1), and with two clones of D. pulex , showed a consistent and statistically significant pattern of increasing sensitivity at higher temperatures.
2. Anabaena affinis affected both survivorship and fecundity, while A. flos ‐ aquae and its toxin, anatoxin‐a, primarily affected fecundity. Presence of cyanobacteria affected brood size, brood number, time to first reproduction and interclutch interval. Temperature affected time to first reproduction and interclutch interval at all concentrations of cyanobacteria. Brood number and brood size were little affected by temperature except at the highest concentrations of cyanobacteria. Increasing the concentration of A. flos ‐ aquae affected demographic parameters, especially at the lower temperatures, while increasing the concentration of A. affinis had less effect.
3. The study suggests that increasing water temperatures in natural systems should exacerbate the inhibitory effect of toxic cyanobacteria on daphniid population growth rates.     

Growth and survival of Daphnia in epilimnetic and metalimnetic water from oligotrophic lakes: the effects of food and temperature

SUMMARY 1. In oligotrophic lakes, phytoplankton and bacteria growing in the deep chlorophyll maximum in the cool metalimnion of lakes often dominate biomass and production, but the importance of this source of food for zooplankton is unknown.
2. During much of the day, Daphnia rosea in two mountain lakes inhabited deep chlorophyll layers where food availability was at least equal to that in the epilimnion.
3. To determine the importance of the two strata (epilimnion and metalimnion) for Daphnia , we used a cross-classified factorial experiment to measure how epilimnetic and metalimnetic food and temperature (10 and 16 °C) influenced survival, growth and reproduction.
4. Daphnia survived and grew better when fed seston from the epilimnion of one lake, although chlorophyll, particulate nitrogen and particulate carbon were 2–2.5 times greater in the metalimnion.
5. Temperature had no significant influence on Daphnia survival or growth. Similar results were obtained with food from the second lake, with Daphnia surviving and reproducing better when provided with epilimnetic, rather than metalimnetic food, although the quantities of chlorophyll and carbon in the two strata were similar.
6. Food quality, rather than quantity or temperature, appeared to be the most important determinant influencing survival, growth and reproduction, and the greater food quantity in the metalimnia was not used effectively by the Daphnia .     

Predation-mediated coexistence of large- and small-bodied Daphnia at different food levels

Using an individual-based age-structured population model (a combination of O'Brien's apparent-prey-size approach, Eggers's reactive-field-volume model, and Holling's disk equation), we could predict that (1) a Daphnia population could be kept at low density by fish predation irrespective of food level, with greater recruitment at higher food being instantly compensated for by raised mortality reflecting increased predation, and (2) Daphnia density levels are species specific and inversely related to both body size at first reproduction and the reaction distance at which a foraging fish sees its Daphnia prey. These two hypotheses were experimentally tested in outdoor mesocosms with two Daphnia species of different body sizes grown in the absence or presence of fish that were allowed to feed for 2-3 h each evening. While each Daphnia quickly reached high density with reproduction halted by food limitation in the absence of fish, the populations stayed at much lower species-specific density levels, similar in low and high food concentrations, in the presence of fish. This suggests that our model offers a reasonable mechanistic explanation for the coexistence of large- and small-bodied zooplankton in proportions reflecting their body sizes throughout habitats comprising a wide productivity spectrum, with each species at a density level at which it becomes included in a predator's diet.     

Experimental testing of dynamic energy budget models

1. Dynamic energy budget (DEB) models describing the allocation of assimilate to the competing processes of growth, reproduction and maintenance in individual organisms have been applied to a variety of species with some success. There are two contrasting model formulations based on dynamic allocation rules that have been widely used (net production and net assimilation formulations). However, the predictions of these two classes of DEB models are not easily distinguished on the basis of simple growth and fecundity data.
2. It is shown that different assumptions incorporated in the rules determining allocation to growth and reproduction in two classes of commonly applied DEB models predict qualitatively distinct patterns for an easily measured variable, cumulative reproduction by the time an individual reaches an arbitrary size.
3. A comparison with experimental data from Daphnia pulex reveals that, in their simplest form, neither model predicts the observed qualitative pattern of reproduction, despite the fact that both formulations capture basic growth features.
4. An examination of more elaborate versions of the two models, in which the allocation rules are modified to account for brief periods of starvation experienced in the laboratory cultures, reveals that a version of the net production model can predict the qualitative pattern seen for cumulative eggs as a function of mass in D. pulex . The analysis leads to new predictions which can be easily tested with further laboratory experiments.     

Vulnerability of cladoceran species to predation by the copepod Mesocyclops leuckarti: laboratory observations on the behavioural interactions between predator and prey

SUMMARY 1. We analysed the vulnerability of a number of cladoceran species ( Bosmina longirostris , B. fatalis , Diaphanosoma brachyurum , Ceriodaphnia reticulata , Daphnia ambigua and D. pulex ) to predation by Mesocyclops leuckarti in the laboratory.
2. The prey species represented a wide range of body size, morphology, and swimming behaviour. To compare vulnerability, we measured the efficiency of capture and ingestion of each prey species by Mesocyclops . We also measured the rate at which prey were damaged in attacks by Mesocyclops .
3. Mesocyclops preyed effectively on Diaphanosoma and small juvenile Ceriodaphnia but not on Bosmina or Daphnia . Observations suggested that various defence mechanisms, including protruding structures and swimming behaviour and speed, are important in determining prey vulnerability.
4. The body size of Daphnia and Ceriodaphnia seems to be important, because larger animals were better able to escape Mesocyclops attacks. Attacks by Mesocyclops often caused fatal damage, however, even to large Daphnia .     

Fitness and sexual response to population density in Daphnia pulex

1. The switch between asexual and sexual reproduction is an important fitness component in cyclically parthenogenetic populations as it is the key to persistence in unstable habitats and because it influences population genetic characteristics such as linkage disequilibrium and population genetic structure.
2. Genetic variation for sexual and asexual reproductive rate ( R _C) was examined, under varying population density, in Daphnia pulex sampled from a rockpool system and two other distinct European localities.
3. Density affected the switch to sexual behaviour, as found in other studies and reduced R _c. Production of males was not correlated with sexual reproduction, promoting outcrossing.
4. Genetic variation was found for the response to density, both within and between populations. There was substantial variation within the rockpools despite their demographic instability, indicating rapid recovery of life-history variation or maintenance during bottlenecks.     

The effects of temperature and photoperiod on life history parameters of Daphnia magna (Crustacea: Cladocera)

SUMMARY. 1. The life history responses of two common and three rare Daphnia magna clones to constant conditions of temperature and photoperiod were investigated, and intraspecific variation in the genes controlling growth, survivorship and reproduction was observed.
2. Rearing temperature had a significant effect on growth, survivorship and on all reproductive parameters measured (generation time, intrinsic rate of increase and male production), while photoperiod influenced significantly only survivorship and male production.
3. The maximum proportion of male offspring was produced at a low temperature (14°C) and at a mid-range photoperiod (L:D16:8).
4. The likely mechanism whereby clones with different life histories are maintained in the population is discussed.     

Phenotypic plasticity of Daphnia life history traits: the roles of predation, food level and toxic cyanobacteria

1. We studied the life history responses of Daphnia pulex under different biotic conditions. In a factorially designed experiment, we tested the impacts of water conditioned by the invertebrate predator Chaoborus, low and high food level (10 000 and 100 000 Scenedesmus cells ml^–1), and exposure to toxic Microcystis (5000 cells ml^–1) on twelve D. pulex clones originating from different habitats. Our aim was to compare the phenotypic plasticity of different clones, and to study the interactions among biotic factors.
2. Individuals cultured in Chaoborus -conditioned water started to reproduce at a larger size than individuals cultured in water not conditioned by the predators. We found interactions between food level and Chaoborus -conditioned water on age at first reproduction and total offspring number. In addition, the impact of the Chaoborus treatment on the size at first reproduction was reduced by Microcystis exposure.
3. Clonal differences were found in the degree of phenotypic plasticity of different life history traits. However, there was no obvious connection between the original habitat of the clone and the degree of plasticity.     

Influence of food quality on growth and reproduction in Daphnia

SUMMARY. 1. Growth and reproduction were measured for Daphnia pulex (Leydig) fed Scenedesmus obliquus (Turp.) Kutz. grown with nitrogen-sufficient and nitrogen-deficient media. The incorporation of carbon into the body of D. pulex was traced using ¹⁴C-labelled algae and biochemical fractionation.
2. Scenedesmus cultured on N-defkient media allocated more carbon to lipid and less to protein than when cultured on N-sufficient media.
3. In a short-term feeding experiment, Daphnia accumulated more lipid when fed N-deficient algal cells high in lipid content than when fed algae grown on N-sufficient media that were lower in lipid.
4. Animals grew faster and produced larger broods when fed algae grown on an N-sufficient medium over an 8-day period. Daphnids fed N-deficient algae had higher quantities of body lipid, suggesting it was not a lack of energy which limited their growth and reproduction.
5. Daphnia fed algae grown on N-deficient media allocated more lipid to eggs, and their offspring lived longer under starvation conditions.     

Diet restriction and life history trade-offs in short- and long-lived species of Daphnia

The life-extending effects of diet restriction are well documented. One evolutionary model that accounts for this widespread conservation is the resource allocation model, where the selected individuals are those that can delay reproduction during periods of resource limitation. In this study, we use closely related species of a model organism, Daphnia, with widely divergent lifespans to address the relationship between diet restriction and longevity and assess whether the relationships are owing to trade-offs between reproductive and somatic investment. Specifically, we conducted a common garden experiment and constructed reaction norms for lifespan, fecundity, and body size as a function of food concentration. Our study provides evidence that the short-lived species in our study, D. pulex, shows the classically observed relationship of enhanced lifespan in response to reduced diet intake, but does not divert resources to somatic maintenance at the expense of reproduction during chronic diet restriction. In contrast, we find no evidence that the long-lived species in our study, D. pulicaria, gains any life-extending effects through diet restriction. Combined, our results provide evidence that the resource allocation model is not sufficient to explain the evolution of diet-mediated lifespan plasticity.     

Temperature effects on chemical signalling in a predator–prey system

SUMMARY 1. We investigated the effect of temperature on chemical signalling in a predator–prey model system (planktivorous fish and Daphnia galeata ). Life-history changes in Daphnia in response to chemical cues (kairomones) derived from fish have become a paradigm for chemically induced anti-predator defences.
2. As temperature can affect both predator and prey, we carried out two experiments to disentangle these effects. In order to test for temperature effects on the predator, we kept prey at a single temperature and exposed them to kairomones from fish exposed to two different temperatures. Daphnia exhibited a higher intrinsic rate of population increase ( r ) when exposed to fish kairomones produced at high rather than low temperature. Assuming a positive correlation between r (because of an earlier maturation and/or increased clutch sizes) and kairomone concentration, our results suggest that kairomone production increases with rising temperature.
3. In the second experiment, to study the influence of temperature on the prey, Daphnia were kept at two different temperatures and exposed to fish kairomones produced at one constant temperature. We found no interaction between the effects of fish kairomone and temperature on Daphnia life history, suggesting that temperature does not directly alter life-history responses to fish kairomones.
4. Our results suggest that temperature influences Daphnia life history through its effects on fish kairomone concentration, but that temperature does not affect the strength of the response of Daphnia to the presence of fish.     

Clonal variation in the survival and reproduction of Daphniapulicaria under low-food stress

1. Survivorship and reproductive parameters of eight Daphnia pulicaria clones were evaluated in a life-table experiment under four dietary regimes ranging from food limitation to complete food deprivation.
2. D . pulicaria exhibited both diet-independent interclonal differences and genotype–environment interactions in life-span.
3. Reproduction ceased entirely or nearly so under the three treatments with lowest food availability. Under life-long food limitation, differences between clones were evident in clutch sizes and age at first reproduction. Some clones produced ephippia at a markedly higher frequency than others under food-limiting conditions.
4. For most of the life-history traits evaluated, within-lake variation among clones exceeded differences between the two lake populations they represented.
5. Intraspecific variations in response to periods of food deprivation and to extended quantitative or qualitative food-limitation could affect the clonal composition of Daphnia populations. They are therefore of potential importance in determining the effect of altered phytoplankton assemblages on zooplankton communities.     

Salamander predation and vertical distributions of zooplankton

SUMMARY. 1. The impact of different predation regimes of zooplanktivorous larval tiger salamanders, Ambystoma tigrinum nebulosum , on the vertical temporal distributions of Daphnia pulex, Diaptomus nudus and larval Chaoborus flavicans was studied in limnetic enclosures in a pond in east-central Arizona. Zooplankton densities were monitored 1-2 h before sunset, at sunset, and 1-2 h after sunset at three depths (0-0.4, 1.0 and 2.0 m) in four salamander treatments (0, 20, 40 salamanders per enclosure, and unenclosed limnetic areas).
2. Densities and body size of Daphnia pulex were consistently greater in salamander-free enclosures than in other treatments. More Daphnia were generally nearer the surface (0-1.0 m) than along the bottom before and at sunset than after sunset in enclosures without salamanders. After sunset, Daphnia was by far most dense along the bottom. Densities were uniform among depths and sample times in treatments with salamanders. Salamanders moved throughout the water column. Frequencies of D. pulex spined morphs (with prominent dorsal crest) did not differ among salamander treatments.
3. Chaoborus densities were positively correlated with D. pulex distributions among depths and sample times in treatments. Spatio-temporal distributions of Chaoborus were influenced more by their daphnid prey than by risk of predation from larval salamanders.
4. Densities of Diaptomus nudus were highest in open water controls and lowest in enclosures without salamanders. Diaptomus was generally more dense between 0 and 1 m than at 2.0 m depths in all treatments, and vertical distributions were not dependent on salamander density.     

Clonal variation in the survival and reproduction of Daphniapulicaria under low-food stress

1. Survivorship and reproductive parameters of eight Daphnia pulicaria clones were evaluated in a life-table experiment under four dietary regimes ranging from food limitation to complete food deprivation.
2. D . pulicaria exhibited both diet-independent interclonal differences and genotype–environment interactions in life-span.
3. Reproduction ceased entirely or nearly so under the three treatments with lowest food availability. Under life-long food limitation, differences between clones were evident in clutch sizes and age at first reproduction. Some clones produced ephippia at a markedly higher frequency than others under food-limiting conditions.
4. For most of the life-history traits evaluated, within-lake variation among clones exceeded differences between the two lake populations they represented.
5. Intraspecific variations in response to periods of food deprivation and to extended quantitative or qualitative food-limitation could affect the clonal composition of Daphnia populations. They are therefore of potential importance in determining the effect of altered phytoplankton assemblages on zooplankton communities.