A Numerical Investigation of the Electric and Thermal Cell Kill Distributions in Electroporation-Based Therapies in Tissue

Electroporation-based therapies are powerful biotechnological tools for enhancing the delivery of exogeneous agents or killing tissue with pulsed electric fields (PEFs). Electrochemotherapy (ECT) and gene therapy based on gene electrotransfer (EGT) both use reversible electroporation to deliver chemotherapeutics or plasmid DNA into cells, respectively. In both ECT and EGT, the goal is to permeabilize the cell membrane while maintaining high cell viability in order to facilitate drug or gene transport into the cell cytoplasm and induce a therapeutic response. Irreversible electroporation (IRE) results in cell kill due to exposure to PEFs without drugs and is under clinical evaluation for treating otherwise unresectable tumors. These PEF therapies rely mainly on the electric field distributions and do not require changes in tissue temperature for their effectiveness. However, in immediate vicinity of the electrodes the treatment may results in cell kill due to thermal damage because of the inhomogeneous electric field distribution and high current density during the electroporation-based therapies. Therefore, the main objective of this numerical study is to evaluate the influence of pulse number and electrical conductivity in the predicted cell kill zone due to irreversible electroporation and thermal damage. Specifically, we simulated a typical IRE protocol that employs ninety 100-µs PEFs. Our results confirm that it is possible to achieve predominant cell kill due to electroporation if the PEF parameters are chosen carefully. However, if either the pulse number and/or the tissue conductivity are too high, there is also potential to achieve cell kill due to thermal damage in the immediate vicinity of the electrodes. Therefore, it is critical for physicians to be mindful of placement of electrodes with respect to critical tissue structures and treatment parameters in order to maintain the non-thermal benefits of electroporation and prevent unnecessary damage to surrounding healthy tissue, critical vascular structures, and/or adjacent organs.     

Plasma membrane voltage changes during nanosecond pulsed electric field exposure

The change in the membrane potential of Jurkat cells in response to nanosecond pulsed electric fields was studied for pulses with a duration of 60 ns and maximum field strengths of approximately 100 kV/cm (100 V/cell diameter). Membranes of Jurkat cells were stained with a fast voltage-sensitive dye, ANNINE-6, which has a subnanosecond voltage response time. A temporal resolution of 5 ns was achieved by the excitation of this dye with a tunable laser pulse. The laser pulse was synchronized with the applied electric field to record images at times before, during, and after exposure. When exposing the Jurkat cells to a pulse, the voltage across the membrane at the anodic pole of the cell reached values of 1.6 V after 15 ns, almost twice the voltage level generally required for electroporation. Voltages across the membrane on the side facing the cathode reached values of only 0.6 V in the same time period, indicating a strong asymmetry in conduction mechanisms in the membranes of the two opposite cell hemispheres. This small voltage drop of 0.6-1.6 V across the plasma membrane demonstrates that nearly the entire imposed electric field of 10 V/mum penetrates into the interior of the cell and every organelle.     

Electroporation of DC-3F Cells Is a Dual Process

Treatment of biological material by pulsed electric fields is a versatile technique in biotechnology and biomedicine used, for example, in delivering DNA into cells (transfection), ablation of tumors, and food processing. Field exposure is associated with a membrane permeability increase usually ascribed to electroporation, i.e., formation of aqueous membrane pores. Knowledge of the underlying processes at the membrane level is predominantly built on theoretical considerations and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. However, experimental data needed to monitor these processes with sufficient temporal resolution are scarce. The whole-cell patch-clamp technique was employed to investigate the effect of millisecond pulsed electric fields on DC-3F cells. Cellular membrane permeabilization was monitored by a conductance increase. For the first time, to our knowledge, it could be established experimentally that electroporation consists of two clearly separate processes: a rapid membrane poration (transient electroporation) that occurs while the membrane is depolarized or hyperpolarized to voltages beyond so-called threshold potentials (here, +201 mV and −231 mV, respectively) and is reversible within ∼100 ms after the pulse, and a long-term, or persistent, permeabilization covering the whole voltage range. The latter prevailed after the pulse for at least 40 min, the postpulse time span tested experimentally. With mildly depolarizing or hyperpolarizing pulses just above threshold potentials, the two processes could be separated, since persistent (but not transient) permeabilization required repetitive pulse exposure. Conductance increased stepwise and gradually with depolarizing and hyperpolarizing pulses, respectively. Persistent permeabilization could also be elicited by single depolarizing/hyperpolarizing pulses of very high field strength. Experimental measurements of propidium iodide uptake provided evidence of a real membrane phenomenon, rather than a mere patch-clamp artifact. In short, the response of DC-3F cells to strong pulsed electric fields was separated into a transient electroporation and a persistent permeabilization. The latter dominates postpulse membrane properties but to date has not been addressed by electroporation theory or MD simulations.     

A Three-Dimensional In?Vitro Tumor Platform for Modeling Therapeutic Irreversible Electroporation

Irreversible electroporation (IRE) is emerging as a powerful tool for tumor ablation that utilizes pulsed electric fields to destabilize the plasma membrane of cancer cells past the point of recovery. The ablated region is dictated primarily by the electric field distribution in the tissue, which forms the basis of current treatment planning algorithms. To generate data for refinement of these algorithms, there is a need to develop a physiologically accurate and reproducible platform on which to study IRE in vitro. Here, IRE was performed on a 3D in vitro tumor model consisting of cancer cells cultured within dense collagen I hydrogels, which have been shown to acquire phenotypes and respond to therapeutic stimuli in a manner analogous to that observed in in vivo pathological systems. Electrical and thermal fluctuations were monitored during treatment, and this information was incorporated into a numerical model for predicting the electric field distribution in the tumors. When correlated with Live/Dead staining of the tumors, an electric field threshold for cell death (500 V/cm) comparable to values reported in vivo was generated. In addition, submillimeter resolution was observed at the boundary between the treated and untreated regions, which is characteristic of in vivo IRE. Overall, these results illustrate the advantages of using 3D cancer cell culture models to improve IRE-treatment planning and facilitate widespread clinical use of the technology.     

Listeria monocytogenes cell wall constituents exert a charge effect on electroporation threshold

Genetically engineered cells with mutations of relevance to electroporation, cell membrane permeabilization by electric pulses, can become a promising new tool for fundamental research on this important biotechnology. Listeria monocytogenes mutants lacking DltA or MprF and assayed for sensitivity to the cathelicidin like anti-microbial cationic peptide (mCRAMP), were developed to study the effect of cell wall charge on electroporation. Working in the irreversible electroporation regime (IRE), we found that application of a sequence of 50 pulses, each 50μs duration, 12.5kV/cm field, delivered at 2Hz led to 2.67±0.29 log reduction in wild-type L. monocytogenes, log 2.60±0.19 in the MprF-minus mutant, and log 1.33±0.13 in the DltA-minus mutant. The experimental observation that the DltA-minus mutant was highly susceptible to cationic mCRAMP and resistant to IRE suggests that the charge on the bacterial cell wall affects electroporation and shows that this approach may be promising for fundamental studies on electroporation.     

A statistical model for multidimensional irreversible electroporation cell death in tissue

Background  

Irreversible electroporation (IRE) is a minimally invasive tissue ablation technique which utilizes electric pulses delivered by electrodes to a targeted area of tissue to produce high amplitude electric fields, thus inducing irreversible damage to the cell membrane lipid bilayer. An important application of this technique is for cancer tissue ablation. Mathematical modelling is considered important in IRE treatment planning. In the past, IRE mathematical modelling used a deterministic single value for the amplitude of the electric field required for causing cell death. However, tissue, particularly cancerous tissue, is comprised of a population of different cells of different sizes and orientations, which in conventional IRE are exposed to complex electric fields; therefore, using a deterministic single value is overly simplistic.     

Low electric field parameters required to induce death of cancer cells

Irreversible electroporation (IRE) is a novel technique that deals with killing undesirable cells, mainly cancer cells, directly without using any cytotoxic drugs. Commonly in this technique very high electric field up to 1000?V/cm is used but for very short exposure time (nanoseconds). Low electric fields (LEFs) are used before to internalize molecules and drugs inside the cells (electroendocytosis) but mainly not in killing the cells. The aim of this work is to determine the ability of using LEFs to kill cancer cells (Hela cells). The Physics idea is in making LEFs energy equivalent to IRE energy. Four IRE protocols were selected to represent very high, high, moderate and mild voltages IRE, then we make equivalent energy for each of these protocols using different LEFs’ parameters of different amplitudes (7, 10, 14 and 20?V), different pulse numbers (40, 80, 160 and 320 pulses), different frequencies from 0.5 to 106.86?Hz and different pulse widths from 9.38 to 2000?ms. Each of the calculated LEF equivalent to IRE was applied on Hela cell line. The results show complete destruction of the cancer cells for all the tested exposure protocols. This damage was not due to thermal effect because the measured temperature was not changed before and after the exposure. The possible effect mechanism is discussed. It was concluded that the lethal effect on the cancer cells can be achieved using LEFs if the same energy equivalent to IRE is used. This work will help in using low-risk drug-free techniques in cancer treatment.     

Quantification of electroporative uptake kinetics and electric field heterogeneity effects in cells

We have conducted experiments quantitatively investigating electroporative uptake kinetics of a fluorescent plasma membrane integrity indicator, propidium iodide (PI), in HL60 human leukemia cells resulting from exposure to 40 μs pulsed electric fields (PEFs). These experiments were possible through the use of calibrated, real-time fluorescence microscopy and the development of a microcuvette: a specialized device designed for exposing cell cultures to intense PEFs while carrying out real-time microscopy. A finite-element electrostatic simulation was carried out to assess the degree of electric field heterogeneity between the microcuvette's electrodes allowing us to correlate trends in electroporative response to electric field distribution. Analysis of experimental data identified two distinctive electroporative uptake signatures: one characterized by low-level, decelerating uptake beginning immediately after PEF exposure and the other by high-level, accelerating fluorescence that is manifested sometimes hundreds of seconds after PEF exposure. The qualitative nature of these fluorescence signatures was used to isolate the conditions required to induce exclusively transient electroporation and to discuss electropore stability and persistence. A range of electric field strengths resulting in transient electroporation was identified for HL60s under our experimental conditions existing between 1.6 and 2 kV/cm. Quantitative analysis was used to determine that HL60s experiencing transient electroporation internalized between 50 and 125 million nucleic acid-bound PI molecules per cell. Finally, we show that electric field heterogeneity may be used to elicit asymmetric electroporative PI uptake within cell cultures and within individual cells.     

Optimization of an electroporation protocol using the K562 cell line as a model: role of cell cycle phase and cytoplasmic DNAses

The improvement of gene therapy protocols is intimately related to the establishment of efficient gene transfer methods. Electroporation has been increasingly employed in in vitro and in vivo protocols, and much attention has been given to increasing its transfection potential. The method is based on the application of an electric field of short duration and high voltage to the cells, forming reversible pores through which molecules can enter the cell. In this work, we describe the optimization of a protocol for the electroporation of K562 cells involving the combination of electric field, resistance and capacitance values. Using RPMI 1640 as pulsing buffer and 30 μg of pEGFP-N1 plasmid, 875 V cm⁻¹, 500 μF and infinite resistance, we achieved transfection rates of 82.41 ± 3.03%, with 62.89 ± 2.93% cell viability, values higher than those reported in the literature. Analyzing cell cycle after electroporation, with three different electric field conditions, we observed that in a heterogeneous population of cells, viability of G₁ cells is less affected by electroporation than that of cells in late S and G₂/M phases. We also observed that efficiency of electroporation can be improved using the DNAse inhibitor Zn, immediately after the pulse. These results can represent a significant improvement of current methods of electroporation of animal and plant cells.     

The Role of Ph Fronts in Tissue Electroporation Based Treatments

Treatments based on electroporation (EP) induce the formation of pores in cell membranes due to the application of pulsed electric fields. We present experimental evidence of the existence of pH fronts emerging from both electrodes during treatments based on tissue EP, for conditions found in many studies, and that these fronts are immediate and substantial. pH fronts are indirectly measured through the evanescence time (ET), defined as the time required for the tissue buffer to neutralize them. The ET was measured through a pH indicator imaged at a series of time intervals using a four-cluster hard fuzzy-c-means algorithm to segment pixels corresponding to the pH indicator at every frame. The ET was calculated as the time during which the number of pixels was 10% of those in the initial frame. While in EP-based treatments such as reversible (ECT) and irreversible electroporation (IRE) the ET is very short (though enough to cause minor injuries) due to electric pulse characteristics and biological buffers present in the tissue, in gene electrotransfer (GET), ET is much longer, enough to denaturate plasmids and produce cell damage. When any of the electric pulse parameters is doubled or tripled the ET grows and, remarkably, when any of the pulse parameters in GET is halved, the ET drops significantly. Reducing pH fronts has relevant implications for GET treatment efficiency, due to a substantial reduction of plasmid damage and cell loss.     

Nanosecond pulsed electric fields have differential effects on cells in the S-phase

Nanosecond pulsed electric fields (nsPEFs) are a type of nonthermal, nonionizing radiation that exhibit intense electric fields with high power, but low energy. NsPEFs extend conventional electroporation (EP) to affect intracellular structures and functions and depending on the intensity, can induce lethal and nonlethal cell signaling. In this study, HCT116 human colon carcinoma cells were synchronized to the S-phase or remained unsynchronized, exposed to electric fields of 60 kV/cm with either 60-ns or 300-ns durations, and analyzed for apoptosis and proliferative markers. Several nsPEF structural and functional targets were identified. Unlike unsynchronized cells, S-phase cells under limiting conditions exhibited greater membrane integrity and caspase activation and maintained cytoskeletal structure. Regardless of synchronization, cells exposed to nsPEFs under these conditions primarily survived, but exhibited some turnover and delayed proliferation in cell populations, as well as reversible increases in phosphatidylserine externalization, membrane integrity, and nuclei size. These results show that nsPEFs can act as a nonligand agonist to modulate plasma membrane (PM) and intracellular structures and functions, as well as differentially affect cells in the S-phase, but without effect on cell survival. Furthermore, nsPEF effects on the nucleus and cytoskeleton may provide synergistic therapeutic actions with other agents, such as ionizing radiation or chemotherapeutics that affect these same structures.     

Decreasing the thresholds for electroporation by sensitizing cells with local cationic anesthetics and substances that decrease the surface negative electric charge

The recently described method of cell electroporation by flow of cell suspension through localized direct current electric fields (dcEFs) was applied to identify non-toxic substances that could sensitize cells to external electric fields. We found that local cationic anesthetics such as procaine, lidocaine and tetracaine greatly facilitated the electroporation of AT2 rat prostate carcinoma cells and human skin fibroblasts (HSF). This manifested as a 50% reduction in the strength of the electric field required to induce cell death by irreversible electroporation or to introduce fluorescent dyes such as calcein, carboxyfluorescein or Lucifer yellow into the cells. A similar decrease in the electric field thresholds for irreversible and reversible cell electroporation was observed when the cells were exposed to the electric field in the presence of the non-toxic cationic dyes 9-aminoacridine (9-AAA) or toluidine blue. Identifying non-toxic, reversibly acting cell sensitizers may facilitate cancer tissue ablation and help introduce therapeutic or diagnostic substances into the cells and tissues.     

高压电场对A549细胞中ABCG2和V-ATPase的表达及其耐药性的影响

目的:探讨高压电场对A549细胞中ABCG2和V-ATPase表达量的影响;探讨高压电场对A549细胞耐药性的影响。方法:MTT法测细胞生长曲线,明确能导致细胞可逆性电穿孔的最高电场强度。慢病毒构建ABCG2和V-ATPase低表达的A549细胞系,并用电场处理,用q-RT-PCR和Western-blot法检测处理前后ABCG2和V-ATPase的m RNA和蛋白表达量的变化。最适强度的高压电场处理各组细胞,在处理前后的细胞中分别加入阿霉素,用高效液相色谱法检测各组细胞中阿霉素浓度。结果:当电场强度为1500 V/cm时,肿瘤细胞增殖最慢;电场强度为1500 V/cm时,肿瘤细胞中ABCG2和V-ATPase的m RNA和蛋白的表达量分别降至对照组的58%和61%,具有统计学差异;1500 V/cm强度的电场可以提高肿瘤细胞内阿霉素的浓度3-4倍。结论:高压电场可以显著降低肿瘤细胞中V-ATPase和ABCG2的m RNA和蛋白的表达量并降低肿瘤细胞的耐药性。     

Microsecond and nanosecond electric pulses in cancer treatments

New local treatments based on electromagnetic fields have been developed as non‐surgical and minimally invasive treatments of tumors. In particular, short electric pulses can induce important non‐thermal changes in cell physiology, especially the permeabilization of the cell membrane. The aim of this review is to summarize the present data on the electroporation‐based techniques: electrochemotherapy (ECT), nanosecond pulsed electric fields (nsPEFs), and irreversible electroporation (IRE). ECT is a safe, easy, and efficient technique for the treatment of solid tumors that uses cell‐permeabilizing electrical pulses to enhance the activity of a non‐permeant (bleomycin) or low permeant (cisplatin) anticancer drug with a very high intrinsic cytotoxicity. The most interesting feature of ECT is its unique ability to selectively kill tumor cells without harming normal surrounding tissue. ECT is already used widely in the clinics in Europe. nsPEFs could represent a drug free, purely electrical cancer therapy. They allow the inhibition of tumor growth, and interestingly, nsPEF can target intracellular organelles. However, many questions remain on the mechanism of action of these pulses. Finally, IRE is a new ablation procedure using pulses that provoke the permanent permeabilization of the cells resulting in their death. This technique does not result in any thermal effect, which is its main advantage in current physical ablation technologies. For both the nsPEF and the IRE, the preservation of the normal tissue, which is characteristic of ECT, has not yet been shown and their safety and efficacy still have to be investigated thoroughly in vivo and in the clinics. Bioelectromagnetics 33:106–123, 2012. © 2011 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

On the molecular mechanisms implicated in the bipolar cancellation of membrane electroporation

Bipolar cancellation is the phenomenon in which the permeability of cell membranes subjected to high intensity short pulsed electric field (ns-μs range) is reduced or eliminated when the system is subjected to bipolar instead of monopolar pulses. Although several studies have tried to explain bipolar cancellation, the underlying mechanisms remain unclear. Very few articles study bipolar cancellation by means of molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. In this paper, we investigated the molecular mechanisms underlying the difference in electroporation induced by bipolar and monopolar picosecond electric pulses (EPs) using MD simulation. The electric field gradients and electric forces on water molecules of the two pulses were analyzed in detail for the first time. For a certain pulse width, when the field intensity is relatively small, the direction of bipolar electric force on the interfacial water molecule reverses as the bipolar EPs reverse, while the electric force on interfacial water molecules of the cathode side remains in the same direction as that of applied monopolar EPs. The bipolar electric force reversal delays the water protrusion and increases the pore formation time. Therefore, this phenomenon could correspond to bipolar cancellation. When the field intensity is relatively large, although the bipolar electric force direction still reverses, half of the total time of the monopolar EPs has no electric fields. The electric forces of monopolar no-field half-cycles are much smaller than those of the bipolar EPs. Therefore, the pore formation time of bipolar EPs reduces, and this phenomenon is called bipolar enhancement. The occurrence of bipolar cancellation or bipolar enhancement depends on conditions such as the width and intensity of the pulse.     

Metabolomic evaluation of pulsed electric field-induced stress on potato tissue

Metabolite profiling was used to characterize stress responses of potato tissue subjected to reversible electroporation, providing insights on how potato tissue responds to a physical stimulus such as pulsed electric fields (PEF), which is an artificial stress. Wounded potato tissue was subjected to field strengths ranging from 200 to 400 V/cm, with a single rectangular pulse of 1 ms. Electroporation was demonstrated by propidium iodide staining of the cell nucleae. Metabolic profiling of data obtained through GC/TOF-MS and UPLC/TOF-MS complemented with orthogonal projections to latent structures clustering analysis showed that 24 h after the application of PEF, potato metabolism shows PEF-specific responses characterized by the changes in the hexose pool that may involve starch and ascorbic acid degradation.     

Permeabilization of tumor cells induced by pulsed electric fields in vitro

The permeabilization of tumor cells in vitro under the action of pulsed electric fields with a duration of 6 mks in the range of amplitudes 1-7 kV/cm was studied. In the mode of excitation in the ambience of localized plasma discharge in a chamber of special design, an enhanced damage to cells in suspension was observed. It is assumed that the enhancement is due to the synchronous action of the electric field and acoustic shock wave pulses. In the mode without the plasma breakdown of ambience, when the pulse duration of electric field of intensity of 1-2 kV/cm was increased to 60 mks, the efficiency of permeabilization increases nearly by one order. The experimental results are compared with the known theoretical models of cell membrane electroporation.     

Comparison of membrane electroporation and protein denature in response to pulsed electric field with different durations

In this paper, we compared the minimum potential differences in the electroporation of membrane lipid bilayers and the denaturation of membrane proteins in response to an intensive pulsed electric field with various pulse durations. Single skeletal muscle fibers were exposed to a pulsed external electric field. The field‐induced changes in the membrane integrity (leakage current) and the Na channel currents were monitored to identify the minimum electric field needed to damage the membrane lipid bilayer and the membrane proteins, respectively. We found that in response to a relatively long pulsed electric shock (longer than the membrane intrinsic time constant), a lower membrane potential was needed to electroporate the cell membrane than for denaturing the membrane proteins, while for a short pulse a higher membrane potential was needed. In other words, phospholipid bilayers are more sensitive to the electric field than the membrane proteins for a long pulsed shock, while for a short pulse the proteins become more vulnerable. We can predict that for a short or ultrashort pulsed electric shock, the minimum membrane potential required to start to denature the protein functions in the cell plasma membrane is lower than that which starts to reduce the membrane integrity. Bioelectromagnetics 34:253–263, 2013. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

High-efficiency gene transfection by in situ electroporation of cultured cells

It is demonstrated in this study that high-efficiency gene transfection can be obtained by directly electroporating cultured mammalian cells in their attached state using a pulsed radio-frequency (RF) electric field. A plasmid DNA containing the reporter gene beta-gal was introduced into COS-M6 cells and CV-1 cells using this in situ electroporation method. At the optimal electric field strength (1.2 kV/cm), we found that over 80% of the M6 cells took up and expressed the beta-gal gene with a cell survival rate of about 50%. In contrast, the transfection efficiency was less than 20% when the M6 cells were electroporated in suspension. It was shown that CV-1 cells could also be electroporated highly efficiently using the in situ method. Furthermore, we have measured the time required to express the beta-gal gene after the plasmid DNA was introduced. We found that the percentage of cells expressing beta-gal reached a peak value about 10 h after electroporation. This time-course was the same for both attached and suspended cells, suggesting that the observed difference in transfection efficiency was mainly the result of effects of the detachment treatment on the electroporation process rather than on the gene expression.     

脉冲电场在医学中的基础研究及电穿孔的临床应用

脉冲电场利用方波直流脉冲发生器改变细胞膜的通透性,并在细胞膜上形成纳米级细孔,其被称为电穿孔是一种新型微创技术,分为可逆电穿孔(reversible electroporation)及不可逆电穿孔(irreversible electroporation)。在过去的四十年,电穿孔大量的实验研究及其自身的优点及先进性,使电穿孔相关的技术已被允许应用与临床。目前临床和实验中应用电穿孔的化疗药物已有十余种,通过电穿孔进行基因转染及DNA疫苗的研发已取得巨大成功。尤其近几年发展的非热能的不可逆电穿孔对实体肿瘤的消融作用,为肿瘤治疗提供新的思路,因其比其他局部治疗方法:具有治疗时间短,减少间接热损伤,对毗邻主要血管的肿瘤组织有消融能力等优点引起了对不可逆电穿孔巨大的临床研究兴趣。本文就电穿孔的基本理论,电化学治疗,基因电转染及不可逆电穿孔的临床应用进行探讨。