Analysis of high-resolution electron diffraction patterns from purple membrane labelled with heavy-atoms

Progress in the structure determination of bacteriorhodopsin, the protein component of purple membrane from Halobacterium halobium has been limited by the lack of three-dimensional phase information between 6 and 3 A resolution. By analogy with X-ray methods, it is possible that heavy-atom labelling of the membrane crystal may provide heavy-atom derivatives that can be used for phasing by the multiple isomorphous replacement method. This paper describes the screening of heavy-atom compounds as potential derivatives, and the evaluation of the data collected from these heavy-atom-labelled membranes. Improvements in the methods for collecting electron diffraction data and analysing and merging the data are presented. Diffraction patterns of purple membrane samples were taken at -120 degrees C to minimize radiation damage. About 30 heavy-atom compounds were tested for use as potential derivatives. The diffraction patterns from labelled membranes were analysed by examining 6.5 A difference Fourier maps. Two heavy-atom compounds were selected for three-dimensional data collection at 3 A resolution. In addition, a full set of native data at -120 degrees C was collected to 2.7 A resolution. The intensity merging, heavy-atom derivative evaluation, heavy-atom refinement and the calculation of phases are presented. Phases are compared to those determined by electron microscope imaging, and limitations of the method are discussed. It is concluded that, with the present accuracy of data collection and the present magnitude of delta F/F available for the derivatives, the phasing power is too small. The phases that are obtained are not sufficiently accurate to provide a reliably interpretable map. It may be possible, however, to use the heavy-atom derivative data in difference Fourier calculations in which the presence of a peak would confirm the phases calculated from a model or obtained by electron microscope imaging.     

Preparation of heavy-atom derivatives using site-directed mutagenesis. Introduction of cysteine residues into gamma delta resolvase

The ability to determine protein structures by X-ray crystallography is often thwarted by the difficulty of finding isomorphous heavy-atom derivatives. The crystal structure of the site-specific recombinase, resolvase, has been difficult to determine for this reason. We have overcome this problem by introducing 13 single cysteine substitutions into the resolvase catalytic domain using oligonucleotide mutagenesis. The mutant proteins were screened for their ability to crystallize into the orthorhombic form and bind mercury ions isomorphously. Two mutant proteins provided excellent heavy-atom derivatives. This approach should be of general use and particularly helpful in cases where traditional methods have failed to produce a derivative.     

Ca(2+)-binding domain VI of rat calpain is a homodimer in solution: hydrodynamic, crystallization and preliminary X-ray diffraction studies.

The 21-kDa calcium-binding domain (VI) of the small subunit of rat calpain II has been expressed in Escherichia coli, purified, and crystallized. Two orthorhombic crystal forms have been obtained: space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with a = 50.3, b = 56.5, c = 141.3 A; and space group C222(1) with a = 69.4, b = 73.9, c = 157.4 A. Diffraction data have been collected to 2.4 A. Sedimentation equilibrium, dynamic light scattering, and gel-permeation chromatography indicate that domain VI exists as a homodimer in solution. In accordance with the protein's behavior in solution, each crystal form contains two molecules per asymmetric unit. Screening for heavy-atom derivatives is in progress. To decrease the sensitivity to mercurials and to aid in the search for useful derivatives, Cys-to-Ser mutants have been prepared, expressed, and crystallized.     

Advances in direct methods for protein crystallography.

Recent advances in ab initio direct methods have enabled the solution of crystal structures of small proteins from native X-ray data alone, that is, without the use of fragments of known structure or the need to prepare heavy-atom or selenomethionine derivatives, provided that the data are available to atomic resolution. These methods are also proving to be useful for locating the selenium atoms or other anomalous scatterers in the multiple wavelength anomalous diffraction phasing of larger proteins at lower resolution.     

Crystallization of yeast iso-2-cytochrome c using a novel hair seeding technique

A hair seeding technique has been developed to obtain diffraction quality crystals of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) iso-2-cytochrome c, a model for studies of protein folding and biological electron transfer reactions. Deep red crystals of this protein were obtained from 88 to 92% saturated solutions of ammonium sulfate containing 20 mg protein/ml, 0.1 M-sodium phoshate, 0.3 M-sodium chloride, 0.04 M-dithiothreitol and adjusted to phosphate, 0.3 M-sodium chloride, 0.04 M-dithiothreitol and adjusted to pH 6.0. Rapid crystal growth was observed, but only along the path of the seeding hair stroke. The space group is P4(3)2(1)2 (or P4(1)2(1)2) with a = b = 36.4 A, c = 137.8 A (1 A = 0.1 nm) and Z = 8. Crystals are stable in the X-ray beam for more than 10 days and diffract to at least 2.5 A resolution. The same hair seeding methodology has proven useful in obtaining crystals of specifically designed mutant iso-2 proteins and in other protein systems where consistent crystal growth had previously proven difficult to attain.     

Crystallographic study of endogenous alpha-amylase inhibitor from wheat

Endogenous alpha-amylase inhibitor from wheat has been crystallized by a microdialysis method. There are two forms of monoclinic crystal in a microdialysis cell with a space group of P2(1). The unit cell dimensions are a = 43.5 A, b = 64.8 A, c = 32.2 A, beta = 113 degrees for the rod-like crystal, and a = 42.5 A, b = 65.2 A, c = 32.2 A, beta = 112 degrees for the plate-like crystal. The former is suitable for structure analysis because it gives the sharp diffraction beyond 2.0 A resolution, and the latter tends to form a twin crystal. A heavy-atom derivative has been successfully prepared with the heavy-atom reagent K2PtCl4, and structure analysis is in progress.     

Crystallization and preliminary crystallographic data on Escherichia coli TEM1 beta-lactamase.

Two crystal forms of Gram- bacteria TEM beta-lactamase have been obtained. The tetragonal form has a very large unit cell and diffracts to 3.0 A resolution. Orthorhombic crystals, grown using ammonium sulfate and a small amount of acetone as precipitating agents, belong to space group P2(1)2(1)2(1) with cell parameters a = 43.1 A, b = 64.4 A, c = 91.2 A and diffract to 1.7 A resolution. A seeding procedure has been designed that ensures reproducibility of the crystal properties. Molecular replacement, using a model reconstructed from the C alpha co-ordinates from Staphylococcus aureus PC1 beta-lactamase, gives a solution that satisfies crystal packing constraints.     

Preliminary crystallographic analysis of the ATP-hydrolysing domain of the Escherichia coli DNA gyrase B protein.

The 43 kDa N-terminal ATPase domain of the Escherichia coli DNA gyrase B protein has been purified from an over-expressing strain. This protein has been crystallized in two crystal forms, both in the presence of the non-hydrolysable ATP analogue 5'-adenylyl-beta,gamma-imidodiphosphate. The first crystal form is monoclinic P2(1), with cell dimensions a = 76 A, b = 88 A, c = 82 A, beta = 105.5 degrees, and diffracts to at least 2.7 A resolution using synchrotron radiation. Crystal density measurements suggest that there are two molecules in the asymmetric unit (Vm = 3.08 A3/Da). The second crystal form is orthorhombic C222(1), with cell dimensions a = 89.2 A, b = 143.1 A and c = 79.8 A. The crystals diffract to beyond 3 A and are stable for at least 100 hours when exposed to X-rays from a rotating anode source. The asymmetric unit of this crystal form appears to contain one molecule (Vm = 2.96 A3/Da). Data have already been collected to 5 A resolution from native crystals of this second form, and to 6 A resolution from three heavy-atom derivatives. Electron density maps calculated using phases obtained from these derivatives show features consistent with secondary structural elements, and have allowed the molecular boundary to be determined. Higher resolution native and derivative data are being collected.     

A Technique for High-Throughput Protein Crystallization in Ionically Cross-Linked Polysaccharide Gel Beads for X-Ray Diffraction Experiments

A simple technique for high-throughput protein crystallization in ionically cross-linked polysaccharide gel beads has been developed for contactless handling of crystals in X-ray crystallography. The method is designed to reduce mechanical damage to crystals caused by physical contact between crystal and mount tool and by osmotic shock during various manipulations including cryoprotection, heavy-atom derivatization, ligand soaking, and diffraction experiments. For this study, protein crystallization in alginate and κ-carrageenan gel beads was performed using six test proteins, demonstrating that proteins could be successfully crystallized in gel beads. Two complete diffraction data sets from lysozyme and ID70067 protein crystals in gel beads were collected at 100 K without removing the crystals; the results showed that the crystals had low mosaicities. In addition, crystallization of glucose isomerase was carried out in alginate gel beads in the presence of synthetic zeolite molecular sieves (MS), a hetero-epitaxic nucleant; the results demonstrated that MS can reduce excess nucleation of this protein in beads. To demonstrate heavy-atom derivatization, lysozyme crystals were successfully derivatized with K₂PtBr₆ within alginate gel beads. These results suggest that gel beads prevent serious damage to protein crystals during such experiments.     

Membrane Protein Structural Validation by Oriented Sample Solid-State NMR: Diacylglycerol Kinase

The validation of protein structures through functional assays has been the norm for many years. Functional assays perform this validation for water-soluble proteins very well, but they need to be performed in the same environment as that used for the structural analysis. This is difficult for membrane proteins that are often structurally characterized in detergent environments, although functional assays for these proteins are most frequently performed in lipid bilayers. Because the structure of membrane proteins is known to be sensitive to the membrane mimetic environment, such functional assays are appropriate for validating the protein construct, but not the membrane protein structure. Here, we compare oriented sample solid-state NMR spectral data of diacylglycerol kinase previously published with predictions of such data from recent structures of this protein. A solution NMR structure of diacylglycerol kinase has been obtained in detergent micelles and three crystal structures have been obtained in a monoolein cubic phase. All of the structures are trimeric with each monomer having three transmembrane and one amphipathic helices. However, the solution NMR structure shows typical perturbations induced by a micelle environment that is reflected in the predicted solid-state NMR resonances from the structural coordinates. The crystal structures show few such perturbations, especially for the wild-type structure and especially for the monomers that do not have significant crystal contacts. For these monomers the predicted and observed data are nearly identical. The thermostabilized constructs do show more perturbations, especially the A41C mutation that introduces a hydrophilic residue into what would be the middle of the lipid bilayer inducing additional hydrogen bonding between trimers. These results demonstrate a general technique for validating membrane protein structures with minimal data obtained from membrane proteins in liquid crystalline lipid bilayers by oriented sample solid-state NMR.     

A method for the preparation of heavy-atom derivatives of yeast cytochrome c peroxidase.

This Letter describes a strategy for preparation of heavy-atom derivatives which has succeeded with yeast cytochrome c peroxidase and which may be useful for other crystalline proteins. Transfer of the crystals from methylpentanediol solutions, in which they were grown, to solutions of polyethylene glycol (M_r 6000) maintains the crystal structure so that crystals tolerate heavy-atom concentrations at least ten times larger than could be attained in methylpentanediol mother liquors.     

Porous silicon: an effective nucleation-inducing material for protein crystallization

Protein crystals play a pivotal part in structural genomics, hence there is an urgent requirement for new and improved methodology to aid crystal growth. Considerable effort has been invested in the search of substances (nucleants) that will induce efficient nucleation of protein crystals in a controlled manner. To date, nucleation has been facilitated mainly by seeding, epitaxy, charged surfaces or mechanical means. A different approach is introduced here, involving the use of a mesoporous material that is likely to constrain protein molecules and thereby encourage them to aggregate in crystalline order. Large single crystals were obtained using porous silicon at conditions that are not sufficient for spontaneous nucleation, for five out of six proteins that were investigated. We propose that this success is due to the size distribution of pores in the specially designed porous silicon.     

Effect of the fluctuations in electron density within a globular protein on the excess small-angle X-ray scattering

Excess small angle X-ray scattering in solvents of differing electron density has been calculated from the crystal structures obtained for rubredoxin, trypsin inhibitor, myogen, ferricytochrome c₂, ribonuclease S, lysozyme, nuclease, myoglobin, α-chymotrypsin, elastase, subtilisin, carboxypeptidase A, thermolysin, methemoglobin, deoxyhemoglobin, and a single polypeptide chain of M₄ lactate dehydrogenase. The scattering curves for each protein can be reproduced by the sum of three curves, with the weighting of the three curves depending on the electron density of the solvent. The radius of gyration obtained from the small angle X-ray scattering by globular proteins in aqueous solution will usually exceed the values defined by the shape of the macromolecule. Deviations for certain of the proteins cited are calculated to be as large as 6%. These deviations arise from the tendency for the amino acid residues with low electron density to be situated closer to the center of the protein than the amino acid residues of high electron density. An upper limit of 19% is obtained for the discrepancy between the radius of gyration defined by the shape of a spherical globular protein of typical amino acid composition and the apparent radius of gyration measured for that protein in water by small angle X-ray scattering.     

What is the average conformation of bacteriophage T4 lysozyme in solution? A domain orientation study using dipolar couplings measured by solution NMR

Lysozyme from T4 bacteriophage is comprised of two domains that are both involved in binding substrate. Although wild-type lysozyme has been exclusively crystallized in a closed form that is similar to the peptidoglycan-bound conformation, a more open structure is thought to be required for ligand binding. To determine the relative arrangement of domains within T4 lysozyme in the solution state, dipolar couplings were measured in several different dilute liquid crystalline media by solution NMR methods. The dipolar coupling data were analyzed with a domain orientation procedure described previously that utilizes high- resolution X-ray structures. The cleft between the domains is significantly larger in the average solution structure than what is observed in the X-ray structure of the ligand-free form of the protein (approximately 17 degrees closure from solution to X-ray structures). A comparison of the solution domain orientation with X-ray-derived structures in the protein data base shows that the solution structure resembles a crystal structure obtained for the M6I mutant. Dipolar couplings were also measured on the lysozyme mutant T21C/T142C, which was oxidized to form an inter-domain disulfide bond (T4SS). In this case, the inter-domain solution structure was found to be more closed than was observed in the crystal (approximately 11 degrees). Direct refinement of lysozyme crystal structures with the measured dipolar couplings using the program CNS, establishes that this degree of closure can be accommodated whilst maintaining the inter-domain cystine bond. The differences between the average solution conformations obtained using dipolar couplings and the crystal conformations for both forms of lysozyme investigated in this study illustrate the impact that crystal packing interactions can have on the arrangement of domains within proteins and the importance of alternative methods to X-ray crystallography for evaluating inter-domain structure.     

Assembly of a polytopic membrane protein structure from the solution structures of overlapping peptide fragments of bacteriorhodopsin.

Three-dimensional structures of only a handful of membrane proteins have been solved, in contrast to the thousands of structures of water-soluble proteins. Difficulties in crystallization have inhibited the determination of the three-dimensional structure of membrane proteins by x-ray crystallography and have spotlighted the critical need for alternative approaches to membrane protein structure. A new approach to the three-dimensional structure of membrane proteins has been developed and tested on the integral membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin, the crystal structure of which had previously been determined. An overlapping series of 13 peptides, spanning the entire sequence of bacteriorhodopsin, was synthesized, and the structures of these peptides were determined by NMR in dimethylsulfoxide solution. These structures were assembled into a three-dimensional construct by superimposing the overlapping sequences at the ends of each peptide. Onto this construct were written all the distance and angle constraints obtained from the individual solution structures along with a limited number of experimental inter-helical distance constraints, and the construct was subjected to simulated annealing. A three-dimensional structure, determined exclusively by the experimental constraints, emerged that was similar to the crystal structure of this protein. This result suggests an alternative approach to the acquisition of structural information for membrane proteins consisting of helical bundles.     

Aspects on human amyloid forms and their fibril polypeptides

Amyloid is an in vivo fibrillar substance containing a fibril protein and several additional molecules. Presently, 25 proteins have been reported as main fibril components. Why just a few proteins form amyloid in vivo is still insufficiently understood. Many fibril proteins appear as fragments of larger precursors and for some types it is not clear whether fragmentation comes before or after fibrillation. The self-assembly by amyloid proteins can be speeded up by seeding with preformed fibrils. In mice, systemic amyloidoses are transmissible by a seeding mechanism. Whether this prion-like mechanism occurs in humans is not known, but can definitely not be ruled out.     

Crystallization and crystal data on tyrosine phenol-lyase

Crystals of the apoenzyme of tyrosine phenol-lyase (EC 4.1.99.2), a pyridoxal 5'-phosphate-dependent enzyme from Citrobacter intermedius, have been grown by vapor diffusion of an ammonium sulfate solution to a protein solution. The crystals belong to space group P2(1)2(1)2, with dimensions of a = 75.5 A, b = 138.4 A and c = 94.1 A and diffract up to 2.7 A resolution. The asymmetric unit contains one half of the enzyme tetrameric molecule. Two heavy-atom derivatives of the crystals have been obtained.     

The crystal structure of the olfactory marker protein at 2.3 A resolution

Olfactory marker protein (OMP) is a highly expressed and phylogenetically conserved cytoplasmic protein of unknown function found almost exclusively in mature olfactory sensory neurons. Electrophysiological studies of olfactory epithelia in OMP knock-out mice show strongly retarded recovery following odorant stimulation leading to an impaired response to pulsed odor stimulation. Although these studies show that OMP is a modulator of the olfactory signal-transduction cascade, its biochemical role is not established. In order to facilitate further studies on the molecular function of OMP, its crystal structure has been determined at 2.3 A resolution using multiwavelength anomalous diffraction experiments on selenium-labeled protein. OMP is observed to form a modified beta-clamshell structure with eight antiparallel beta-strands. While OMP has no significant sequence homology to proteins of known structure, it has a similar fold to a domain found in a variety of existing structures, including in a large family of viral capsid proteins. The surface of OMP is mostly convex and lacking obvious small molecule binding sites, suggesting that it is more likely to be involved in modulating protein-protein interaction than in interacting with small molecule ligands. Three highly conserved regions have been identified as leading candidates for protein-protein interaction sites in OMP. One of these sites represents a loop known to mediate ligand interactions in the structurally homologous EphB2 receptor ligand-binding domain. This site is partially buried in the crystal structure but fully exposed in the NMR solution structure of OMP due to a change in the orientation of an alpha-helix that projects outward from the structurally invariant beta-clamshell core. Gating of this conformational change by molecular interactions in the signal-transduction cascade could be used to control access to OMP's equivalent of the EphB2 ligand-interaction loop, thereby allowing OMP to function as a molecular switch.     

Structural analysis of T4 DNA helix destabilizing protein (gp32 I) crystal by electron microscopy

Low dose electron diffraction and imaging techniques have been applied to the study of the crystalline structure of gp32*I, a DNA helix destabilizing protein derived from bacteriophage T4 gene 32 protein. A quantitative analysis of intensities from electron diffraction patterns from tilted, multilayered gp32*I crystal has provided the unit cell thickness of the crystal. The three-dimensional phases indicate that the space group P2(1)2(1)2. By taking into account the unit cell volume and the solvent content in the crystal, it was deduced that there is one gp32*I molecule in each asymmetric unit. A projected density map of unstained, glucose-embedded gp32*I crystal was synthesized with amplitudes from electron diffraction intensities and phases from electron images with reflections out to 7.6 A. Because of the similarity in the scattering density between glucose and protein, this projected map cannot be interpreted with certainty. A low resolution three-dimensional reconstruction shows that the protein molecule is about 90 A long and about 20 A in diameter. Because the dimer is formed around a dyad axis, the protein molecules comprising it must be arranged head-to-head. This dimeric arrangement of the proteins in the unit cell may be implicated as one of the conformational states of this protein in solution.