The fascinating biology behind phage display: filamentous phage assembly

With the recently awarded Nobel Prize to the inventor of Phage Display, George Smith, the technique has once more gained attention. However, one should not forget about the biology behind the method. Almost always ignored is how the structure of this bacterial virus is assembled. In contrast to lytic phages, filamentous phages are constantly being extruded through the bacterial membranes without lysis. Such filamentous phages are found in all aquatic environments, such as rivers and lakes, in the deep sea, in arctic ice, in hot springs and, associated with their hosts, in plants and animals including humans. While most filamentous phages infect Gram‐negative hosts, inoviruses of Gram‐positive hosts have also been described. Despite being among the minority within the phage family with an estimate of less than 5%, filamentous phages are real parasites as they exist at the expense of the host, but do not kill it. In contrast to lytic bacteriophages, filamentous phages are assembled in the host’s membrane and extruded across the cellular envelope while the bacterium continues to grow. In this review, we focus on this complex and yet poorly understood process of assembly and secretion of filamentous phages.     

Kinetics of filamentous phage assembly

Filamentous phages release their progeny particles by a secretory process without lysing the bacterial cell. By this process about 6 viral particles per min are secreted from each cell. We show here that when the major coat protein (gp8) is provided from a plasmid we observe a phage progeny production rate depending on the induction of gp8 by IPTG. We also show that a transfection of Escherichia coli lacking F-pili is observed using a mutant of M13 that carries an ampicillin resistance gene, and phage particles are secreted in the absence of an F-plasmid. Extruding phage was visualized by atomic force microscopy (AFM) and by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) using gold-labeled antibodies to the major coat protein.     

A theory of the symmetries of filamentous bacteriophages.

A mathematical model is presented which explains the symmetries observed for the protein coats of filamentous bacterial viruses. Three viruses (Ff, IKe, and If1) all have five-start helices with rotation angles of 36 degrees and axial translations of 16 A (Type I symmetry), and three other viruses (Pf1, Xf, and Pf3) all have one-start helices with rotation angles of approximately equal to 67 degrees and translations of approximately 3 A (Type II symmetry). The coat protein subunits in each group diverge from each other in amino acid sequence, and Type II viruses differ dramatically in DNA structure. Regardless of the differences, both Type I and Type II symmetry can be understood as direct, natural consequences of the close-packing of alpha-helical protein subunits. In our treatment, an alpha-helical subunit is modeled as consisting of two interconnected, flexible tubular segments that follow helical paths around the DNA, one in an inner layer and the other in an outer layer. The mathematical model is a set of algebraic equations describing the disposition of the flexible segments. Solutions are described by newly introduced symmetry indices and other parameters. An exhaustive survey over the range of indices has produced a library of all structures that are geometrically feasible within our modeling scheme. Solutions which correspond in their rotation angles to Type I and Type II viruses occur over large ranges of the parameter space. A few solutions with other symmetries are also allowed, and viruses with these symmetries may exist in nature. One solution to the set of equations, obtained without any recourse to the x-ray data, yields a calculated x-ray diffraction pattern for Pf1 which compares reasonably with experimental patterns. The close-packing geometry we have used helps explain the near constant linear mass density of known filamentous phages. Helicoid, rigid cylinder, and maximum entropy structure models proposed by others for Pf1 are reconciled with the flexible tube models and with one another.     

The use of filamentous phage M13 in protein engineering

M13B1 vector based on the filamentous phage M13 has been constructed. M13B1 phage carries the gene of resistance to ampicillin and contains the unique site of recognition for BamHI restriction endonuclease in gene VIII coding for the major coat protein. BamHI restriction site has been inserted into the gene of the major coat protein by means of oligonucleotide directed mutagenesis. The synthetic DNA fragment coding for the model peptides has been inserted through BamHI site into the M13B1 DNA. The possibility of inserting foreign peptides into the N-terminus at maintaining the viability of hybrid phages has been shown. The differences in specificity of the recombinant phage maturation have been determined by analysing the amino acid sequence of B-protein.     

Individual filamentous phage imaged by electron holography

An in-line electron hologram of an individual f1.K phage was recorded with a purpose-built low energy electron point source (LEEPS) microscope. Cryo-microscopic methods were employed to prepare the specimen so that a single phage could be presented to the coherent low energy electrons: An aqueous phage suspension was applied to a thin carbon membrane with micro-machined slits. The membrane was rapidly cooled to freeze the remaining water as an amorphous ice sheet, which was then sublimated at low temperatures and pressures to leave individual free-standing phages suspended across slits. An image of a phage particle, depicted as the amplitude of the object wave, was reconstructed numerically from a digitized record of the hologram, obtained using 88 eV coherent electrons. The reconstructed image shows a single phage suspended across a slit in a supporting carbon membrane, magnified by a factor of 100,000. The width and shape in the reconstructed image compared well with a TEM image of the same filament. It is thus possible to record and reconstruct electron holograms of an individual phage. The challenge now is to improve the resolution of reconstructed images obtained by this method and to extend these structural studies to other biological molecules.     

Maximizing filamentous phage yield during computer-controlled fermentation

Filamentous phage such as M13 and fd consist of a circular, single-stranded DNA molecule surrounded by several different coat proteins. These phages have been used extensively as vectors in phage display where one of the phage coat proteins is genetically engineered to contain a unique peptide surface loop. Through these peptide sequences, a phage collection can be screened for individual phage that binds to different macromolecules or small organic and inorganic molecules. Here, we use computer-controlled bioreactors to produce large quantities of filamentous phage in the bacterial host Escherichia coli. By measuring phage yield and bacterial growth while changing the growth medium, pH and dissolved oxygen concentration, we found that the optimal conditions for phage yield were NZY medium with pH maintained at 7.4, the dO₂ held at 100% and agitation at 800 rpm. These computer-controlled fermentations result in a minimum of a tenfold higher filamentous phage production compared to standard shake flask conditions.     

Biodistribution of filamentous phage peptide libraries in mice

In vivo phage display is a new approach to acquire peptide molecules that bind stably to a given target. Phage peptide display libraries have been selected in mice and humans and numerous vasculature-targeting peptides have been reported. However, in vivo phage display has not typically produced molecules that extravasate to target specific organ or tumor antigens. Phage selections in animals have been performed for very short times without optimization for biodistribution or clearance rates to a particular organ. It is hypothesized that peptides that home to a desired antigen/organ can be obtained from in vivo phage experiments by optimization of incubation times, phage extraction and propagation procedures. To accomplish this goal, one must first gain a better understanding of the in vivo biodistribution and rate of clearance of engineered phage peptide display libraries. While the fate of wild type phage in rodents has been reported, the in vivo biodistribution of the commonly used engineered fd-tet M13 phage peptide display libraries (such as in the fUSE5 vector system) have not been well established. Here we report the biodistribution and clearance properties of fd-tet fifteen amino acid random peptide display libraries in fUSE5 phage in three common mouse models employed for drug discovery - CF-1, nude, and SCID mice.     

Reprogramming the infection mechanism of a filamentous phage

When they infect Escherichia coli cells, the filamentous phages IF1 and fd first interact with a pilus and then target TolA as their common receptor. They use the domains N2 and N1 of their gene-3-proteins (G3P) for these interactions but differ in the mechanism of infection. In G3P of phage IF1, N1 and N2 are independent modules that are permanently binding-active. G3P of phage fd is usually in a closed state in which N1 and N2 are tightly associated. The TolA binding site is thus inaccessible and the phage incompetent for infection. Partial unfolding and prolyl isomerization must occur to abolish the domain interactions and expose the TolA binding site. This complex mechanism of phage fd could be changed to the simple infection mechanism of phage IF1 by reprogramming its G3P following physicochemical rules of protein stability. The redesigned phage fd was robust and as infectious as wild-type phage fd.     

A filamentous phage display system for N-linked glycoproteins

We have developed a filamentous phage display system for the detection of asparagine-linked glycoproteins in Escherichia coli that carry a plasmid encoding the protein glycosylation locus (pgl) from Campylobacter jejuni. In our assay, fusion of target glycoproteins to the minor phage coat protein g3p results in the display of glycans on phage. The glyco-epitope displayed on phage is the product of biosynthetic enzymes encoded by the C. jejuni pgl pathway and minimally requires three essential factors: a pathway for oligosaccharide biosynthesis, a functional oligosaccharyltransferase, and an acceptor protein with a D/E-X₁-N-X₂-S/T motif. Glycosylated phages could be recovered by lectin chromatography with enrichment factors as high as 2 × 10⁵ per round of panning and these enriched phages retained their infectivity after panning. Using this assay, we show that desired glyco-phenotypes can be reliably selected by panning phage-displayed glycoprotein libraries on lectins that are specific for the glycan. For instance, we used our phage selection to identify permissible residues in the −2 position of the bacterial consensus acceptor site sequence. Taken together, our results demonstrate that a genotype–phenotype link can be established between the phage-associated glyco-epitope and the phagemid-encoded genes for any of the three essential components of the glycosylation process. Thus, we anticipate that our phage display system can be used to isolate interesting variants in any step of the glycosylation process, thereby making it an invaluable tool for genetic analysis of protein glycosylation and for glycoengineering in E. coli cells.     

A new filamentous phage cloning vector: fd-tet

We have constructed a hybrid chromosome composed of the genome of wild-type fd (a filamentous, male-specific bacteriophage) and a segment of transposon Tn10 coding for tetracycline resistance but not including the Tn10 insertion sequences. The hybrid phage infects male E. coli, thereby transducing the infected cells to tetracycline resistance. The phage DNA can also be propagated in F- cells after transfection. This new phage, fd-tet, may be used as a cloning vector to produce large quantities of cloned DNA in single-stranded form. Its usefulness has been demonstrated by cloning of a fragment from bacteriophage lambda. Some unexpected sequence alterations have been identified in lambda cloning experiments.     

Isolation of chloroform-resistant mutants of filamentous phage: localization in models of phage structure

Interaction of fd or M13 filamentous phage with a chloroform/water interface induces morphological change, contracting the filaments sequentially into shortened rods (I-forms), and then into spheroidal particles (S-forms). To further investigate this phage contraction, 34 and 26 chloroform-resistant isolates of fd and M13, respectively, were selected after chloroform treatment of wild-type phages at pH 8. 2 and 4 degrees C. DNA sequencing of gene VIII of the 34 fd isolates revealed five different mutants: these were D5H, M28L, V31L, I37T, and S50T. All 26 M13 isolates were I37T. These mutants exhibited variable sensitivity to chloroform, but all contracted much more slowly than wild-type phage during treatment at 4 degrees C. They all contracted like wild-type phage at 37 degrees C. Site-directed mutagenesis showed that the indicated single mutations carried the chloroform resistance. In structural models of the phage, the D5H locus is on the outside and the S50T locus is on the inside. The M28L and I37T loci are buried in a mostly hydrophobic region in the middle. Although these four mutants are spread out radially, they are localized in the axial direction into a thin disk in the model. The last mutant locus, V31L, is out of this disk, but this locus is proximal to the M28L and I37T loci and also in contact with the surface via a deep hydrophobic hole or depression. These five mutants, their locations, and their variable affects on contraction suggest that chloroform-induced contraction involves a specific mechanism rather than a generalized solvent-induced denaturation and that the critical structural changes occur in a localized level in the phage. These results add weight to suggestions that the sequential contraction of filaments-->I-forms-->S-forms mimic corresponding steps in phage penetration, and, in the reverse order, for phage assembly.     

Display of Ras on filamentous phage through cysteine replacement

Phage display technology has been used in a variety of contexts to understand and manipulate biomolecular interactions between proteins and other biomolecules. In this paper we describe the establishment of a phage display system for elucidation of the interactions between the GTPase Ras and its panel of effectors. It is shown how technical problems associated with phage display of a protein with unpaired cysteines, likely to be caused by the oxidizing environment of the bacterial periplasm into which the protein is directed, can be overcome by cysteine replacement based on functional and structural studies. First, the catalytic domain (residues 1-166) of mammalian H-Ras (Ras) was observed to be displayed on phage in an incorrect conformation not detectable by antibodies recognizing conformational epitopes on Ras. Although truncation of the phage coat protein used as fusion partner (g3p) resulted in minor improvements in the display, Ras was tailored for phage display by cysteine replacement. By replacing the three cysteines at positions 51, 80 and 118 of Ras with the corresponding residues in Saccharomyces cerevisiae RAS1, the resulting fusion-phage is recognized by the conformation-dependent anti-Ras antibodies. Furthermore, display of cysteine-free Ras is demonstrated by GTP-analogue dependent binding to the Ras-binding domain of the Ras-effector Raf1. These data pave the way for analysis of Ras-effector interactions using phage display technology yet demonstrate that phage display of proteins with normally reduced cysteines should be approached with caution.     

The inhibitory effect of dithiothreitol on the assembly of the filamentous phage fd

Assembly of the filamentous phage fd is preceded by the formation of a complex between the viral single-stranded (ss) DNA and the virally coded gene 5 protein (gene 5 protein-ssDNA complex). The presence of 5 mM dithiothreitol in the growth medium prevents phage production; however, phage infection, phage DNA replication and phage genome expression are still observed. In contrast, the gene 5 protein-ssDNA complex is not formed in the presence of dithiothreitol in vivo, although the complex is not affected by the disulfide reducing agent in vitro. Furthermore, host lipid composition is altered by growth in the presence of dithiothreitol. The zwitterionic lipid, phosphatidylethanolamine, increases while the cationic phospholipid content, cardiolipin and phosphatidylglycerol, decreases. This suggests a role for lipids or membranous structures in the process of gene 5 protein-ssDNA complex formation.     

Pore-forming properties of the adsorption protein of filamentous phage fd

The gene 3-encoded adsorption protein (g3p) of filamentous phage fd has been purified to homogeneity by using high-performance liquid chromatography. Removal of SDS from the SDS-solubilized g3p results in spontaneous oligomerization of the g3p. Reconstitution into artificial lipid bilayer membranes shows that the oligomer forms large aqueous pores that remain open for seconds and are insensitive to changes in membrane potential. The estimated diameter of the pores suggest that they are large enough to allow passage of phage single-stranded DNA. The implications of these findings for phage infection are discussed.     

Interdomain interactions within the gene 3 protein of filamentous phage

A number of disorders related to cystic fibrosis have been described since the cloning of the cystic fibrosis gene, including infertility due to the congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens. We have identified, in several patients, complex cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator genotypes like double-mutant alleles. We have now analyzed the structure-function relationships of one of these mutants, R74W-D1270N cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, expressed in HeLa cells, to evaluate the contribution of each mutation in the phenotype. We found that R74W cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator appears to be a polymorphism, while D1270N cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator could be responsible for the congenital bilateral absence of the vas deferens phenotype. The combination of the two produced a more severe effect on the chloride conductance pathway as well as on the phenotype.     

Raman spectroscopy and deuterium exchange of the filamentous phage fd

The filamentous phage fd has been investigated using the techniques of Raman spectroscopy and deuterium exchange. Despite the rather uniform secondary structure of the fd phage coat protein, which is predominantly alpha-helix, the deuterium exchange is complex. A substantial fraction of the helical peptides exchange deuterium by 8 h at room temperature, yet another substantial fraction does not exchange following an additional 5 months at 4 degrees C. Heating the phage to 70 degrees C for several hours leads to additional deuterium exchange compared to samples soaked for 5 months in heavy water. We suggest that the wide variation in peptide exchange rates may be related to the phage protein quaternary structure, which has been shown to be a double layer of tightly packed helices. The accomplishment of enhanced exchange by reaction at high temperature combined with digital difference spectroscopic methods has enabled us to define the structure of the amide III and III' bands. The complexity of these bands is unexpected for a simple helical protein, but we suggest that the complexity arises at least in part from end-effects that become important in short alpha-helices.     

Structure of the filamentous phage pIV multimer by cryo-electron microscopy

The homo-multimeric pIV protein constitutes a channel required for the assembly and export of filamentous phage across the outer membrane of Escherichia coli. We present a 22 A-resolution three-dimensional reconstruction of detergent-solubilized pIV by cryo-electron microscopy associated with image analysis. The structure reveals a barrel-like complex, 13.5 nm in diameter and 24 nm in length, with D14 point-group symmetry, consisting of a dimer of unit multimers. Side views of each unit multimer exhibit three cylindrical domains named the N-ring, the M-ring and the C-ring. Gold labeling of pIV engineered to contain a single cysteine residue near the N or C terminus unambiguously identified the N-terminal region as the N-ring, and the C-terminal region was inferred to make up the C-ring. A large pore, ranging in inner diameter from 6.0 nm to 8.8 nm, runs through the middle of the multimer, but a central domain, the pore gate, blocks it. Moreover, the pore diameter at the N-ring is smaller than the phage particle. We therefore propose that the pIV multimer undergoes a large conformational change during phage transport, with reorganization of the central domain to open the pore, and widening at the N-ring in order to accommodate the 6.5 nm diameter phage particle.     

An improved filamentous helper phage for generating single-stranded plasmid DNA

Gene cloning in plasmid vectors that contain a filamentous phage intergenic region presents several advantages. However, technical difficulties have been a problem, primarily low yields of packaged single stranded (ss) plasmid DNA from the rapid, small scale procedures usually employed, and ambiguities in sequencing reactions attributed to the contamination by helper phage ss DNA. We report here the construction and some properties of a new f1 helper phage. Using this phage, R408, plasmid ss DNA is packaged and exported preferentially over phage ss DNA, and the absolute yield of plasmid ss DNA is usually increased.     

Homodimeric peptides displayed by the major coat protein of filamentous phage

Peptide libraries displayed by filamentous bacteriophage have proven a powerful tool for the discovery of novel peptide agonists, antagonists and epitope mimics. Most phage-displayed peptides are fused to the N terminus of either the minor coat protein, pIII, or the major coat protein, pVIII. We report here that peptides containing cysteine residues, displayed as N-terminal fusions to pVIII, can form disulfide-bridged homodimers on the phage coat. Phage clones were randomly selected from libraries containing one or two fixed Cys residues, and surveyed for the presence of peptide-pVIII homodimers by SDS-PAGE analysis that involved pretreatment of the phage with reducing or thiol-modifying agents. For all phage whose recombinant peptide contained a single Cys residue, a significant fraction of the peptide-pVIII molecules were displayed as dimers on the phage coat. The dimeric form was in greater abundance than the monomer in almost all cases in which both forms could be reliably observed. Occasionally, peptides containing two Cys residues also formed dimers. These results indicate that, for a given pVIII-displayed peptide bearing a single Cys residue, a significant fraction of the peptide (>40 %) will dimerize regardless of its sequence; however, sequence constraints probably determine whether all of the peptide will dimerize. Similarly, only occasionally do peptides bearing two Cys residues form intermolecular disulfide bridges instead of intramolecular ones; this indicates that sequence constraints may also determine dimerization versus cyclization. Sucrose-gradient analysis of membranes from cells expressing pVIII fused to a peptide containing a single Cys residue showed that dimeric pVIII is present in the cell prior to its assembly onto phage. A model of the peptide-pVIII homodimer is discussed in light of existing models of the structure and assembly of the phage coat. The unique secondary structures created by the covalent association of peptides on the phage surface suggest a role for homo- and heterodimeric peptide libraries as novel sources of bioactive peptides.