An Evaluation of the Metachromasy of Anionic Dyes. I. Visual Observations on Tissue Sections

Thirteen dyes of the azo (benzopurpurin, Congo red, trypan blue, chromotrope 2R, orange G), indigoid (indigocarmine), triphenylmethane (acid fuchsin, aniline blue, light green, methyl blue), and xanthene (eosin B, eosin Y, erythrosin B) groups were applied under standard conditions to a variety of human, rabbit, rat, mouse and frog tissues in paraffin sections. Sections were examined for color changes which might indicate metachromatic reactions analogous to the metachromasy of cationic dyes. Disazo and xanthene dyes showed shifts in hue, with some qualification on the shifts of xanthenes. Metachromatic shifts of anionic dyes were generally of low order compared to those of cationic dyes. Nuclei, erythrocytes, inner elastic laminae of arteries, keratinous structures, and certain areas in the ground substance of connective tissue most often elicited metachromasy. It is suggested that basic proteins are responsible for the metachromatic reactions. Equally interesting areas were those staining poorly (cartilage matrix, most types of mucus), since these are sites of highly acidic substances capable of binding proteins.     

An Evaluation of the Metachromasy of Anionic Dyes. II. Visual and Spectral Observations on Solutions

The reactions of 13 anionic dyes in solution with a basic protein (protamine), a cationic detergent, guanidine, histamine, procaine, quinine, and strychnine were examined visually and spectrophotometrically in order to distinguish metachromatic changes of the dyes. Disazo dyes (Congo red, benzopurpurin, but not trypan blue) were metachromatic; indigoid, triphenylmethane and xanthene dyes were not. The magnitude of metachromasy in this series of dyes was not great compared with cationic dyes, the shifts of absorbance maxima being only about 15 mμ against 90 mμ or more for some cationic metachromatic dyes. The most effective chromotropes were protamine and a cationic detergent. Agreement between visual observations on tissue sections, visual observations on solutions, and spectral observations on solutions was generally good.     

Heterogeneity and Metachromasy of Some Commercial Anionic Dyes

The multicomponent character of all commercial anionic dyes tested (monoazo, disazo, indigoid and xanthene) was demonstrated by paper chromatography. On the basis of a reaction on filter paper, certain fractionated components of the dyes: aniline blue WS, benzoazurin, Bordeaux red, Congo red, cotton blue, chromotrope 2R, indigo-carmine, methyl-blau, soluble blue, and wasserblau showed a metachromatic response with the chromotropes, protamine and hexammine cobaltic chloride. The response of these same dye components with the chromotropes neomycin, polymyxin and viomycin was much weaker, and the alkaloids strychnine, codeine and cinchonidine could not elicit any metachromatic response. The hex-amminocobalt complex was the most effective of all the chromotropes studied, including protamine, both on filter paper and in aqueous solutions. Changes in color exhibited by the unchromatographed whole dyes such as alkali blue, alkali blue 6B, azoblau, Congo rubin, Hickson purple, isamine blue, orange G and trypan blue appear to be merely polychromatic effects because comparable changes are not shown by any of their chromatographically resolved components. In a solution system, the blue dyes, benzoazurin, cotton blue, indigo-carmine, methylblau, soluble blue, and wasserblau did not show definite visual changes in hue or in spectral shifts except with the hexamminocobalt complex, which induced a remarkable change in hue of all these dyes to a blue-violet or purple shade. A spectrophotometric study of methylblau has indicated that this change in hue is associated with a 25 mp shift of absorbance maximum to a lower wave length (hypsochromic effect). The filter-paper reaction between a dye component and a chromotrope is quite reliable and convenient for ascertaining a metachromatic response, since, unlike a reaction in solution systems, it is not affected by the unbound components of a reaction mixture. It is usable because water does not play any significant role in the metachromasy of anionic dyes. No correlation has been established between metachromasy and chemical constitution of anionic dyes.     

Histological, Chromatographic and Spectrophotometric Studies of Toluidine Blue

Chromatographic analysis of commercial batches of toluidine blue shows these to be dye mixtures. Histologically, some samples were found to be poor metachromatic dyes. These unsatisfactory stains contained blue dyes with little or no metachromatic properties as well as a metachromatic fraction. On the other hand, contaminating dyes in histologically satisfactory samples had poor staining qualities and hence did not interfere with the color produced by the metachromatic fraction.

Chromatographic fractionation of different commercial batches of toluidine blue yielded identical, homogeneous metachromatic dyes. These purified dyes had a peak absorption at 615 mμ in contrast to that of purified azure A whose peak absorption was at 622.5 mμ.     

The cause of the green polarization color of amyloid stained with Congo red

Summary Experiments done with Congo red crystals and with Congo red deposits polished in a single direction by a glass wheel have shown that the appearance of green polarization color primarily depends on near-perfect parallel alignment of the dye particles. The green polarization color was seen only in the deposits which showed a clear transition from red to colorless when examined for dichroism. Another factor was found to be the thickness of the object, as the green polarization color was not present in too thick or too thin sections of amyloid-containing tissues stained with Congo red.The phenomena can be explained by the assumption that the green polarization color is due to interference between the red ray and the red component of the white ray whenever the retardation by the object approximates half the wavelength of red light.The findings indicate that amyloid differs from other materials which are stained by Congo red in that amyloid deposits bind the dye molecules in a more orderly and parallel fashion. It is suggested that minimal amounts of amyloid which are not visible in Congo red stained sections with ordinary light microscopy and which do not give the green polarization color can best be detected by examination for dichroism in ultraviolet light after having been stained with fluorescent dyes.     

Chlorazol Fast Pink B And Trypan Blue Tests for Virus and Other Proteinaceous Inclusions

A 1% solution of chlorazol fast pink B in 0.9% NaCl can be used like trypan blue to detect virus inclusions and proteinaceous entities in peelings from leaves or thin sections taken from living plant tissue. Like trypan blue, a solution of the pink dye causes somatic nuclei to swell and thus facilitates observation of their structure. The two dyes combine into a beautiful differential bicolored stain. Mix 5 ml of 0.5% trypan blue stock solution with 35 ml of 1% chlorazol pink B in 0.9% NaCl. Stain fresh tissue 1-2 minutes. The combination stain is superior to either dye alone for differentiating virus entities.     

Effect of phosphomolybdic acid on the binding of Sudan black B

Paraffin sections of tissues fixed in absolute alcohol or Carnoy's fluid were mordanted in a 1% aqueous solution of phosphomolybdic acid, stained in saturated solutions of Sudan black B, acetylated Sudan black, various solvent and basic dyes in 70% ethyl alcohol for 5 min at room temperature, dehydrated in alcohol and covered in Permount. Sudan black B and other dyes with basic groups stained basement membranes, reticulum and collagen fibers intensely. Acetylated Sudan black, Sudan IV and oil red 0 did not color any tissue structures. Control sections, without pretreatment, did not bind Sudan black B. These findings indicate interaction between basic groups of the dye and free acid groups of phosphomolybdic acid.     

Mutagenicity of selected sulfonated azo dyes in the Salmonella/microsome assay: use of aerobic and anaerobic activation procedures

A selection of 16 sulfonated azo dyes of both the monoazo type and diazo dyes based on benzidine, o-tolidine and o-dianisidine were assayed for mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium strains TA98 and TA100 employing both aerobic and anaerobic preincubation procedures. 3 food dyes, FD & C Red No. 40 and Yellows No. 5 and No. 6 were non-mutagenic in all tests. 5 dyes were mutagenic with aerobic treatment (trypan blue, Pontacyl Sky Blue 4BX, Congo Red, Eriochrome Blue Black B, dimethylaminoazobenzene) and 6 were mutagenic aerobically with riboflavin and cofactors (Deltapurpurin, trypan blue, Pontacyl Sky Blue 4BX, Congo Red, methyl orange, Ponceau 3R). Anaerobic preincubation involving enzymatic reduction of the dyes led to a different pattern of mutagenicity, with trypan blue giving much enhanced mutagenicity; Eriochrome Blue Black B, Pontacyl Sky Blue 4BX, Deltapurpurin and Congo Red exhibiting similar activity to aerobic preincubation; and methyl orange and Ponceau 3R yielding no mutagenicity. The results are interpreted with respect to an hypothesis involving partial reduction of the azo bond under differing degrees of aerobiosis via azo-anion radicals and hydrazo intermediates.     

Decolourization of recalcitrant dyes with a laccase from Streptomyces coelicolor under alkaline conditions

Colored wastewater from textile industries is a consequence of dye manufacturing processes. Two percent of dyes that are produced are discharged directly in aqueous effluent and more than 10% are subsequently lost during the textile coloration process. It is not surprising that these compounds have become a major environmental concern. In that context, we have evaluated the potential use of Streptomyces coelicolor laccase for decolourization of various dyes with and without a mediator. Results showed that in all cases the combination of laccase and the mediator acetosyringone was able to rapidly decolourize, to various degrees, all the dyes tested. In 10 min, decolourization was achieved at 94% for acid blue 74, 91% for direct sky blue 6b and 65% for reactive black 5. Furthermore, decolourization was achieved at 21% for reactive blue 19 and at 39% for the direct dye Congo red in 60 min. These results demonstrate the potential use of this laccase in combination with acetosyringone, a natural mediator, for dye decolourization.     

Metachromasy: an experimental and theoretical reevaluation

Non-chromotropic substances such as fibrin and gelatin and most tissue and cellular structures stain orthochromatically with internal dye concentrations of such metachromatic dyes as methylene blue and toluidine blue which, if in solution, would be metachromatic. Therefore, at ordinary levels of staining these substances depress the natural tendency of these dyes to change color. However, at elevated levels of dye-binding metachromasy eventually occurs. This phenomenon is explained on the basis of the distribution of dye-binding sites. In these substrates, by contrast with chromotropic substances, many binding sites are too far removed for dye interaction, consequently the interaction frequency can become high enough to produce a color change only as saturation of the available sites is approached. It is also shown that the destruction of color is a characteristic of metachromasy and that water molecules intercalated between approximated dye ions are responsible for the loss and change of color. A concept of metachromasy is proposed in which the interaction between water molecules and suitably approximated dye ions plays an essential role. The experimental studies are described against a background of the history and evolution of ideas on metachromasy. The literature is reviewed and reassessed particularly from the physicochemical viewpoint.     

Metachromasy: An Experimental and Theoretical Reevaluation

Non-chromotropic substances such as fibrin and gelatin and most tissue and cellular structures stain orthochromatically with internal dye concentrations of such metachromatic dyes as methylene blue and toluidine blue which, if in solution, would be metachromatic. Therefore, at ordinary levels of staining these substances depress the natural tendency of these dyes to change color. However, at elevated levels of dye-binding metachromasy eventually occurs. This phenomenon is explained on the basis of the distribution of dye-binding sites. In these substrates, by contrast with chromotropic substances, many binding sites are too far removed for dye interaction, consequently the interaction frequency can become high enough to produce a color change only as saturation of the available sites is approached. It is also shown that the destruction of color is a characteristic of metachromasy and that water molecules intercalated between approximated dye ions are responsible for the loss and change of color. A concept of metachromasy is proposed in which the interaction between water molecules and suitably approximated dye ions plays an essential role. The experimental studies are described against a background of the history and evolution of ideas on metachromasy. The literature is reviewed and reassessed particularly from the physicochemical viewpoint.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Investigation of Thiazin Dyes as Biological Stains I. The Staining Properties of Thionin and its Derivatives as Compared with Their Chemical Formulae

An investigation has been made of the staining properties of eight dyes of the thionin group. The dyes studied are as follows: tetra-ethyl thionin, asymmetrical di-ethyl thionin, tetra-methyl thionin (methylene blue), tri-methyl thionin (azure B), asymmetrical di-methyl thionin (azure A), symmetrical di-methyl thionin, mono-methyl thionin (azure C), and unsubstituted thionin. The staining properties were tested on sections of paraffin embedded material following five different methods of fixation. No counterstain was employed. It was shown that there was a general correlation between the extent of ethylation or methylation of the dyes and their staining properties. As one passes from tetra-ethyl thionin down the series to thionin itself, there is a progressive decrease in the amount of green showing in the preparations, and an increase in the amount of red present, also an increase in the metachromatic effects, and in the intensity of nuclear staining. There seems, also, to be a similar relation between staining qualities on the one hand and the color and solubility of the dye base on the other.     

Vital Staining with Two Dis-Azo Textile Dyes

Subcutaneous injections of 0.25% saline solutions of two dis-azo textile dyes, calcodur pink 2BL, C. I. 353, also known as benzo fast pink 2BL and amidine fast rose 2BL, and a blue dye, dianil blue G, C. I. 508, were made on alternate days on albino rats for one week. The blue dye is closely similar to Niagara blue 4B, C. I. 520, and dianil blue R, C. I. 465. Staining reactions were much like those of other vital blue disazo dyes. Although the pink dye exhibited a similar staining pattern, there were notable differences. The tissues of most glands were stained pink or red. Nuclei of the tubular epithelial cells of the kidney contained red granules as did the cytoplasm of the Kupfer cells. Most unusual was the bright red staining of the elastica interna of medium and large sized arteries.     

Differential Congo Red staining: The effects of pH, non-aqueous solvents and the substrate

Summary Congo Red is an acid-base indicator dye. In free solution the colour and absorption characteristics of Congo Red depend not only on the pH but are also governed by the nature of the solvent environment. In tissue sections stained by Congo Red, alteration of the pH and the use of non-aqueous solvents can effect differential colouring of the tissue components. Stained sections of unmodified and chemically substituted celluloses show that differential red or blue coloration reflects the acidic or basic character of the substrate. In stained tissue sections, secondary protein structure and porosity of the substrate may also influence their colour. The effect of non-aqueous solvents is probably to modify the ionization state of the dye- substrate complex, thus altering the colour of the Congo Red. Such solvents may also change the aggregation or solvation states of the dye, with consequent modification in the colour of tissue components.     

Demonstration of amyloid with Mesitol WLS-Congo Red: Application of a textile auxiliary to histochemistry

Summary Previous histochemical investigations demonstrated similarities in the binding of Congo Red and other direct cotton dyes by amyloid and cellulose. It seemed threfore of interest to determine whether or not the cellulose-like reactivity of amyloid extends also to dye solutions containing an anionic reserving agent. These reagents are used in the dyeing of wool-cellulose (Halbwolle) fabrics to prevent binding of direct cotton dyes by proteins. Mesitol WLS-Congo Red solutions stained amyloid selectively; other tissue structures, except some hyaline deposits in arterioles, remained unstained. The cause of this non-specific reaction could not be determined with certainty. Therefore, the alkaline Congo Red method is recommended for histochemical identification of amyloid. However, the Mesitol WLS-Congo Red technic was very useful for demonstration of amyloid after prolonged storage of tissues in formalin; amyloid in such material showed little or no reactivity with the alkaline Congo Red or the Sirius dye methods. This pilot study indicates that anionic reserving agents can be effectively employed under conditions of histochemical technics.     

Staining of macromolecules: possible mechanisms and examples

This review is based on a presentation given at the Biological Stain Commission meeting in June 2008. I discuss staining as an interaction between dye, solvent, and biological macromolecules. Most staining takes place in water, where the physico-chemical properties of the macromolecules are particularly important. Staining from aqueous solution is summarized. The first step is diffusion–ion exchange, which builds up the dye ion concentration close to the appropriately charged tissue constituents. While charge interactions are important for selectivity and build-up of dye ions around specific tissue and cell constituents, they have in most cases little to do with actual dye binding. The next step, actual binding, is predominantly between aromatic and other non-polar parts of the dye and corresponding groups in the tissue constituent. This results in a reduction of the total hydrophobic area exposed to water, hence the term hydrophobic interaction. Because dye binding is predominantly by dispersive forces, the larger the aromatic dye system and the fewer the number of charges on the dye, the greater the substantivity or affinity. Some relatively straightforward anionic or cationic one-step staining systems are discussed also. These include amyloid staining with Congo red, elastin staining with orceins, collagen staining with picrofuchsin, DNA–RNA staining with methyl green-pyronin Y, acid heteroglycan staining with Alcian blue, and metachromatic staining.     

Methods for staining amyloid in tissues: a review

The traditional way of identifying amyloid in tissue sections has been staining with Congo red and demonstration of green birefringence under crossed polarizers. The original method of Congo red staining, described by Bennhold in 1922, has undergone several modifications to improve its sensitivity, specificity, and reliability. The most common modification is the alkaline Congo red method described by Puchtler and co-workers in 1962. Specificity is improved by using freshly prepared stain and a staining solution fully saturated with sodium chloride. Amyloid proteins can be further distinguished by autoclaving or by treating the tissue with potassium permanganate or alkaline guanidine. Autoclaving the tissues at 120 C for 30 min causes protein AA to lose its affinity for Congo red. Prolongation of autoclaving to 120 min abolishes the Congophilia of protein AL, but prealbumin-related amyloid shows little or no change. Treatment of the tissue with potassium permanganate causes protein AA and B2-microglobulin amyloid to lose their affinity to Congo red. Protein AA fails to stain with Congo red after treatment with alkaline guanidine for 1 min and protein AL and systemic senile amyloid protein (SSA) after 2 hr. Familial amyloid protein (FAP), prealbumin type, can stand 2 hr of alkaline guanidine treatment without losing its ability to stain with Congo red. Other methods of detection of amyloid include fluorescent stains, e.g., thioflavin T or S, and metachromatic stains such as crystal violet. Immunofluorescence and immunoperoxidase methods are used to identify and classify amyloid proteins in tissues. Antibodies against the P component, proteins AA and AL and FAP have been used with great precision. Due to cross-reactivity, these methods do not differentiate between some types of familial and senile systemic amyloidosis.     

An Evaluation of the Metachromasia of Bromophenol Blue

The heterogeneity of bromophenol blue from different commercial sources was revealed by paper chromatography. Isopropanol:ammonia:water (20:1:2) as the solvent system gave the best separation. A variety of impurities: violet, pink, light blue and yellow coloured ones were observed. Two of the yellow fractions showed a spectral shift to red in the presence of ammonia vapour. The respone of the main dye component with the anionic chromotropes such as heparin and hyaluronate was found to be metachromatic similar to that exhibited by the dye solution and not due to a polychromatic effect. The metachromatic effect was blocked by FeCl₃ as in the case of cationic dye metachromasy. The observed metachromatic colour is not one of the colours which characterize those resulting from changes caused by pH.     

How Romanowsky stains work and why they remain valuable — including a proposed universal Romanowsky staining mechanism and a rational troubleshooting scheme

Abstract

An introduction to the nomenclature and concept of “Romanowsky stains” is followed by a brief account of the dyes involved and especially the crucial role of azure B and of the impurity of most commercial dye lots. Technical features of standardized and traditional Romanowsky stains are outlined, e.g., number and ratio of the acidic and basic dyes used, solvent effects, staining times, and fixation effects. The peculiar advantages of Romanowsky staining are noted, namely, the polychromasia achieved in a technically simple manner with the potential for stain intensification of “the color purple.” Accounts are provided of a variety of physicochemically relevant topics, namely, acidic and basic dyeing, peculiarities of acidic and basic dye mixtures, consequences of differential staining rates of different cell and tissue components and of different dyes, the chemical significance of “the color purple,” the substrate selectivity for purple color formation and its intensification in situ due to a template effect, effects of resin embedding and prior fixation. Based on these physicochemical phenomena, mechanisms for the various Romanowsky staining applications are outlined including for blood, marrow and cytological smears; G-bands of chromosomes; microorganisms and other single-cell entities; and paraffin and resin tissue sections. The common factors involved in these specific mechanisms are pulled together to generate a “universal” generic mechanism for these stains. Certain generic problems of Romanowsky stains are discussed including the instability of solutions of acidic dye–basic dye mixtures, the inherent heterogeneity of polychrome methylene blue, and the resulting problems of standardization. Finally, a rational trouble-shooting scheme is appended.