On the requirement of minimum number of four versus eight quanta of light for the evolution of one molecule of oxygen in photosynthesis: A historical note

A bitter controversy had existed as to the minimum number of quanta required for the evolution of one molecule of oxygen in photosynthesis: Otto Warburg had insisted since 1923 that this value was 3–4, whereas Robert Emerson and others continued to obtain a value of 8–12 since the 1940s. It is shown in this letter that the 1931 Nobel-laureate of Physiology & Medicine Otto Warburg published, in his last and final paper, just before his death in 1970, a measured minimum quantum requirement of oxygen evolution of 12 at the lowest intensities of light he used. Although using his theory on photolyte, Warburg calculated a value of 3–4 for the quantum requirement, this is the first confirmation by Warburg of the higher measured quantum requirement. However, it has remained unknown to most investigators. It is expected that this information will be of general interest not only to those interested in the history and research on photosynthesis, but to the entire sci entific community, especially the writers of text books in biology, biochemistry and biophysics.     

Photosynthetic efficiency of Betula pendula acclimated to different quantum flux densities

Abstract. Seedlings of Betula pendula were grown in a controlled environment chamber at quantum flux densities of 50, 250 and 600 μmol m⁻² s⁻¹. The relationship between the flux densities of absorbed CC₂ and quanta was determined for shoots of whole seedlings. Rates of both light-saturated and in situ (measured under the growing conditions) net photosynthesis were determined and the pholosynthetic quantum yields under light-limiting conditions were calculated. Anatomical leaf characteristics, chlorophyll contents and sizes and densities of the photosynthetic units (chlorophyll/P700) were determined. Chloroplasts were isolated and their rates of 2,6-dichlorophenol indophenol photoreduction were measured together with their pool sizes of the electron transport carriers plastoquinone and cylochrome ƒ.
Although acclimated to different quantum flux densities, the three birch populations showed the same quantum yield of net photosynthesis. This was approximately 0.028 in normal air (21.2 kPa oxygen) and about 0.040 when photorespiration was largely inhibited in 2.0 kPa oxygen. In addition, the in situ net photosynthesis rates were limited by the absorbed quantum flux density for low, intermediate and high light grown seedlings. It was concluded that birch acclimated to the three light regimes at different levels of organization (metabolic and anatomical). Thus, the quanta which were absorbed in situ could be transferred into chemical equivalents at an optimal and constant efficiency. The use of different reference bases for expressing rates of net photosynthesis are also discussed.     

Internal conversion in the photosynthetic mechanism of blue-green algae

1. In Chroococcus a quantum of light absorbed by phycocyanin has 90 per cent the chance of doing photosynthesis that a quantum absorbed by chlorophyll has. 2. By a process analogous to internal conversion in radioactivity (but with the linear dimensions and the wave length 10⁴ times larger) there will be transferred from phycocyanin to chlorophyll See PDF for Equation (a number of the order of 100) quanta for every one emitted as fluorescent light by the phycocyanin in the Chroococcus cell. 3. The yield of fluorescent light in Chroococcus is between 1 and 2 per cent. 4. The transfer of energy by internal conversion can account for the photosynthesis by phycocyanin observed by Emerson and Lewis.     

THE PHOTOSYNTHETIC EFFICIENCY OF PHYCOCYANIN IN CHROOCOCCUS,AND THE PROBLEM OF CAROTENOID PARTICIPATION IN PHOTOSYNTHESIS

The absorption spectra of the principal pigment components extracted from Chroococcus cells have been measured, and their sum compared with the absorption of a suspension of living cells. The agreement was sufficiently close so that it was concluded the absorption spectra of the extracted and separated pigment components could be used to obtain estimates of the relative absorption of the various components in the living cells. The quantum yield of Chroococcus photosynthesis was measured at a succession of wave lengths throughout the visible spectrum, and the dependence of yield on wave length was compared with the proportions of light absorbed by the pigment components. This comparison showed beyond reasonable doubt that the light absorbed by phycocyanin is utilized in photosynthesis with an efficiency approximately equal to that of the light absorbed by chlorophyll. The light absorbed by the carotenoid pigments of Chroococcus seems for the most part to be unavailable for photosynthesis. The results leave open the possibility that light absorbed by the carotenoids is active in photosynthesis, but with an efficiency considerably lower than that of chlorophyll and phycocyanin. It is also possible that the light absorbed by one or a few of the several carotenoid components is utilized with a high efficiency, while the light absorbed by most of the components is lost for photosynthesis.     

Carotenoid-sensitized photosynthesis: Quantum efficiency,fluorescence and energy transfer

The observation in the early 1940s that the quantum efficiency of photosynthesis in a diatom was almost the same whether incident light was absorbed by chlorophyll a or by fucoxanthol sparked subsequent investigations of the variety of chloroplast pigments and in a diversity of photosynthetic organisms. Subsequent fluorimetric measurements provided the first relevant observation on the existence of excitation energy transfer in photosynthesis. These and some other experiments prior to the classical work of Arnold and Oppenheimer [(1950) J Gen Physiol 33: 423–435] and of Duysens [(1952) Doctoral thesis, State University of Utrecht, the Netherlands] are reviewed here.     

Singlet oxygen production in photosynthesis

A photosynthetic organism is subjected to photo-oxidative stress when more light energy is absorbed than is used in photosynthesis. In the light, highly reactive singlet oxygen can be produced via triplet chlorophyll formation in the reaction centre of photosystem II and in the antenna system. In the antenna, triplet chlorophyll is produced directly by excited singlet chlorophyll, while in the reaction centre it is formed via charge recombination of the light-induced charge pair. Changes of the mid-point potential of the primary quinone acceptor in photosystem II modulate the pathway of charge recombination in photosystem II and influence the yield of singlet oxygen production. Singlet oxygen can be quenched by beta-carotene, alpha-tocopherol or can react with the D1 protein of photosystem II as target. If not completely quenched, it can specifically trigger the up-regulation of the expression of genes which are involved in the molecular defence response of plants against photo-oxidative stress.     

Evidence for Light Wavelength-Specific Photoelectrophysiological Signaling and Memory of Excess Light Episodes in Arabidopsis

Although light is essential for photosynthesis, excess light can damage the photosynthetic apparatus and deregulate other cellular processes. Thus, protective integrated regulatory responses that can dissipate excess of absorbed light energy and simultaneously optimize photosynthesis and other cellular processes under variable light conditions can prove highly adaptive. Here, we show that the local and systemic responses to an excess light episode are associated with photoelectrophysiological signaling (PEPS) as well as with changes in nonphotochemical quenching and reactive oxygen species levels. During an excess light incident, PEPS is induced by quantum redox changes in photosystem II and in its proximity and/or by changes in glutathione metabolism in chloroplasts. PEPS is transduced, at least in part, by bundle sheath cells and is light wavelength specific. PEPS systemic propagation speed and action potential are dependent on ASCORBATE PEROXIDASE2 function. Excess light episodes are physiologically memorized in leaves, and the cellular light memory effect is specific for an excess of blue (450 nm) and red (650 nm) light of similar energy. It is concluded that plants possess a complex and dynamic light training and memory system that involves quantum redox, reactive oxygen species, hormonal, and PEPS signaling and is used to optimize light acclimation and immune defenses.     

The ferredoxin/thioredoxin system: a key element in the regulatory function of light in photosynthesis

In addition to its well-established function in supplying the energy for carbon dioxide assimilation, light plays a regulatory role in photosynthesis. The ferredoxin/thioredoxin system is a major mechanism whereby light functions in this capacity. Here, light absorbed by chlorophyll is converted via ferredoxin into a reductant messenger, reduced thioredoxin, that interacts with key target enzymes, thereby changing their catalytic activities. In this way, the green plant achieves maximum efficiency of its photosynthetic (light) and heterotrophic (dark) capabilities.     

Senescence‐induced loss in photosynthesis enhances cell wall β‐glucosidase activity

A link between senescence‐induced decline in photosynthesis and activity of β‐glucosidase is examined in the leaves of Arabidopsis. The enzyme is purified and characterized. The molecular weight of the enzyme is 58 kDa. It shows maximum activity at pH 5.5 and at temperature of 50°C. Photosynthetic measurements and activity of the enzyme are conducted at different developmental stages including senescence of leaves. Senescence causes a significant loss in total chlorophyll, stomatal conductance, rate of evaporation and in the ability of the leaves for carbon dioxide fixation. The process also brings about a decline in oxygen evolution, quantum yield of photosystem II (PS II) and quantum efficiency of PS II photochemistry of thylakoid membrane. The loss in photosynthesis is accompanied by a significant increase in the activity of the cell wall‐bound β‐glucosidase that breaks down polysaccharides to soluble sugars. The loss in photosynthesis as a signal for the enhancement in the activity of the enzyme is confirmed from the observation that incubation of excised mature leaves in continuous dark or in light with a photosynthesis inhibitor 3‐(3,4‐dichlorophenyl)‐1, 1‐dimethylurea (DCMU) that leads to sugar starvation enhances the activity of the enzyme. The work suggests that in the background of photosynthetic decline, the polysaccharides bound to cell wall that remains intact even during late phase of senescence may be the last target of senescing leaves for a possible source of sugar for remobilization and completion of the energy‐dependent senescence program.     

Expanding the solar spectrum used by photosynthesis

A limiting factor for photosynthetic organisms is their light-harvesting efficiency, that is the efficiency of their conversion of light energy to chemical energy. Small modifications or variations of chlorophylls allow photosynthetic organisms to harvest sunlight at different wavelengths. Oxygenic photosynthetic organisms usually utilize only the visible portion of the solar spectrum. The cyanobacterium Acaryochloris marina carries out oxygenic photosynthesis but contains mostly chlorophyll d and only traces of chlorophyll a. Chlorophyll d provides a potential selective advantage because it enables Acaryochloris to use infrared light (700-750 nm) that is not absorbed by chlorophyll a. Recently, an even more red-shifted chlorophyll termed chlorophyll f has been reported. Here, we discuss using modified chlorophylls to extend the spectral region of light that drives photosynthetic organisms.     

Photoinhibition of chloroplast reactions. I. Kinetics and action spectra

A study was made of photoinhibition of spinach chloroplast reactions. The kinetics and spectral characteristics of the photoinhibition over a range between 230 and 700 mμ have been examined. The decline of activity due to preillumination was independent of wavelength, and dependent upon the number of quanta applied, not upon the rate of application. The effectiveness spectra of photoinhibition indicate that active ultraviolet light is absorbed by a pigment which is not a normal light absorber for photosynthesis and acts with a high quantum efficiency (> 0.1) for photoinhibition.

Active visible light is absorbed by the pigments which sensitize photosynthesis (chlorophyll, carotenoids). A very low quantum efficiency (about 10⁻⁴) was observed for the photoinhibition with visible light.

The action spectrum of the photoinhibition of dye reduction by chloroplasts and lyophylized Anacystis cells indicated that the damage caused by visible light is due to quanta absorbed by photosystem II. However, since system I might not be involved in dye reduction, the spectra may reflect only damage to photosystem II.

     

The PsbU subunit of photosystem II stabilizes energy transfer and primary photochemistry in the phycobilisome-photosystem II assembly of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

The PsbU subunit of photosystem II (PSII) is one of three extrinsic polypeptides associated with stabilizing the oxygen evolving machinery of photosynthesis in cyanobacteria. We investigated the influence of PsbU on excitation energy transfer and primary photochemistry by spectroscopic analysis of a PsbU-less (or deltaPsbU) mutant. The absence of PsbU was found to have multiple effects on the excited state dynamics of the phycobilisome and PSII. DeltaPsbU cells exhibited decreased variable fluorescence when excited with light absorbed primarily by allophycocyanin but not when excited with light absorbed primarily by chlorophyll a. Fluorescence emission spectra at 77 K showed evidence for impaired energy transfer from the allophycocyanin terminal phycobilisome emitters to PSII. Picosecond fluorescence decay kinetics revealed changes in both allophycocyanin and PSII associated decay components. These changes were consistent with a decrease in the coupling of phycobilisomes to PSII and an increase in the number of closed PSII reaction centers in the dark-adapted deltaPsbU mutant. Our results are consistent with the assumption that PsbU stabilizes both energy transfer and electron transport in the PBS/PSII assembly.     

Greening of intermittent-light-grown bean plants in continuous light: thylakoid components in relation to photosynthetic performance and capacity for photoprotection

Phaseolus vulgaris (cvv. Windsor longpod and snap bean) plants, etiolated during germination, were exposed to intermittent light (2 min light every 2 hr) for up to 68 hr and then transferred to continuous white light. On transfer of the plants to continuous light (100 photons mumol m-2 s-1, 24 degrees C), the quantum yield of oxygen evolution increased two-fold in about 30 hr. The chlorophyll content per unit leaf area or unit fresh weight increased dramatically, but the fresh weight per unit leaf area was relatively constant. The changes were expressed on the basis of fresh weight or leaf area. On this basis, the contents of photosystem (PS) I and II increased in continuous light, by a factor of 3 and 8, respectively. While the chlorophyll b content and the contents of apoproteins of light-harvesting chlorophyll-protein complexes (LHCIIb, CP29, CP26 and CP24) increased markedly, neither the total carotenoid content nor the de-epoxidation state of the xanthophylls [ratio of zeaxanthin(Z) + antheraxanthin(A) to (Z + A + violaxanthin) was about 0.4)] responded significantly on transfer to continuous light. The fast rise of the flash-induced electrochromic signal (delta A518) was well correlated with the increases in PS I and PS II reaction centres, and with chlorophyll b and total carotenoid contents. The increase in the quantum yield of oxygen evolution during greening in continuous light is attributed to a more balanced distribution of excitation energy between the two photosystems, facilitated by the increased number of PS II units, the increased antenna size of each unit and the enhancement of grana formation. The chloroplast in intermittent light was found to contain abundant xanthophyll cycle pigments and the psbS gene product, presumably adequate for photoprotection in continuous light as soon as chlorophyll a/b- protein complexes are synthesized. The results suggest that greening in continuous light is accompanied by adjustments that include enhanced quantum efficiency of photosynthesis and development of a capacity for harmless dissipation of excess excitation energy.     

Photosynthesis and photoinhibition in leaves of chlorophyll b-less barley in relation to absorbed light

The response of photosynthesis to absorbed light by intact leaves of wild-type ( Hordeum vulgare L. cv. Gunilla) and chlorophyll b -less barley ( H. vulgare L. cv. Dornaria, chlorina-f2²⁸⁰⁰) was measured in a light integrating sphere. Up to the section where the light response curve bends most sharply the responses of the b -less and wild-type barley were similar but not identical. Average quantum yield and convexity for the mutant light response curves were 0.89 and 0.90, respectively, times those of the wild-type barley. The maximum quantum yield for PSII photochemistry was also 10% lower as indicated by fluorescence induction kinetics (F_v/F_m). Just above the region where the light curve bends most sharply, photosynthesis decreased with time in the mutant but not in the wild-type barley. This decrease was associated with a decrease in F_v/F_m indicating photoinhibition of PSII. This photoinhibition occurred in the same region of the light response curve where zeaxanthin formation occurs. Zeaxanthin formation occurred in both the chlorophyll b -less and wild-type leaves. However, the epoxidation state was lower in the mutant than in the wild-type barley. The results indicate that chlorophyll b -less mutants will have reduced photosynthetic production as a result of an increased sensitivity to photoinhibition and possibly a lowered quantum yield and convexity in the absence of photoinhibition.     

Energy upconversion theory of the primary photochemical reaction in plant photosynthesis

In this paper we suggest a basic mechanism for the utilization of light quanta in photosynthesis. Through interactions between the lowest lying triplet state of the reaction-center chlorophylls and the first excited singlet state of the antenna chlorophylls, absorbed light quanta are upconverted to a higher-lying charge transfer state of the reaction-center Chl molecules. It is shown that the efficiency of the upconversion process is maximized by the parallel configuration of the two Chl porphyrin rings in the reaction-center water adduct proposed by the writer. Steady-state solutions are obtained, and the theoretical results are shown to account for a variety of crucial experimental observations including (1) the doubling (in whole cells) of in vivo fluorescence quantum yield of system II in strong light, (2) the observation by Dutton et al. of the light-induced triplet-state reaction-center bacteriochlorophyll when the primary electron acceptor is reduced and (3) despite the apparent involvement of two excitations in the energy upconversion process, only one quantum is needed for the transfer of one electron in the primary photo-chemical reaction, satisfying the eight-quanta requirement for the evolution of one O₂ molecule in photosynthesis.     

The development of structure and function in chloroplasts of greening mutants of Scenedesmus II. Development of the photosynthetic apparatus

Mutant C-2A' of Scenedesmus obliquus formed only traces of chlorophylland showed no detectable photosynthesis when grown heterotrophically.When transferred to light this mutant developed chlorophylland its photosynthetic capacity was established. Following ashort initial lag phase, both photosynthetic capacity and totallight absorption of the cells reached saturation more rapidlythan did the rate of chlorophyll synthesis. Consequently, thequantum requirement of photosynthesis showed a rapid declineduring the initial 6 hr of greening, to a best value of 8. Subsequently,a slow increase occurred as additional chlorophyll was synthesized.Behavior parallel to that of the quantum requirement was alsonoted for the relative fluorescence yield and for the onsetof the 520 nm light-induced absorbance change. Of the two photosystems,PS-I seemed to develop more rapidly than did PS-II. The appearanceof PS-II activity appeared to accompany linkage of the two photosystems,as revealed by analysis of the variable-yield fluorescence andthe kinetics of the 520 nm light-induced absorbance change.During the phase of greening at which photosynthetic capacitydeveloped its maximum quantum efficiency, no significant changesin type or content of the various chloroplast cytochromes weredetected. Analysis of the ratio of chlorophyll/plastoquinone,however, showed that changes in this value followed more closelythe observed increase in the quantum efficiency of photosynthesisand the other parameters of photosynthesis examined. (Received May 19, 1972; )     

The fluorescence spectra of red algae and the transfer of energy from phycoerythrin to phycocyanin and chlorophyll

1. The fluorescence spectra of the alga Porphyridium have been recorded as energy distribution curves for eleven different incident wave lengths of monochromatic incident light between wave lengths 405 and 546 mµ. 2. In these spectra chlorophyll fluorescence predominates when the incident light is in the blue part of the spectrum which is strongly absorbed by chlorophyll. 3. For blue-green and green light the spectrum excited in Porphyridium contains in addition to chlorophyll fluorescence, the fluorescence bands characteristic of phycoerythrin and of phycocyanin. 4. From these spectra the approximate curves for the fluorescence of the individual pigments phycoerythrin, phycocyanin, and chlorophyll in the living material have been derived and the relative intensity of each of them has been obtained for each of the eleven incident wave lengths. 5. The effectiveness spectrum for the excitation of the fluorescence of these three pigments in vivo has been plotted. 6. From comparisons of the effectiveness spectrum for the excitation of each of these pigments it appears that both phycocyanin and chlorophyll receive energy from light which is absorbed by phycoerythrin. 7. It is suggested that phycocyanin may be an intermediate in the resonance transfer of energy from phycoerythrin to chlorophyll. 8. Since phycoerythrin and phycocyanin transfer energy to chlorophyll, it appears probable that chlorophyll plays a specific chemical role in photosynthesis in addition to acting as a light absorber.     

Photoprotective energy dissipation involves the reorganization of photosystem II light-harvesting complexes in the grana membranes of spinach chloroplasts

Plants must regulate their use of absorbed light energy on a minute-by-minute basis to maximize the efficiency of photosynthesis and to protect photosystem II (PSII) reaction centers from photooxidative damage. The regulation of light harvesting involves the photoprotective dissipation of excess absorbed light energy in the light-harvesting antenna complexes (LHCs) as heat. Here, we report an investigation into the structural basis of light-harvesting regulation in intact spinach (Spinacia oleracea) chloroplasts using freeze-fracture electron microscopy, combined with laser confocal microscopy employing the fluorescence recovery after photobleaching technique. The results demonstrate that formation of the photoprotective state requires a structural reorganization of the photosynthetic membrane involving dissociation of LHCII from PSII and its aggregation. The structural changes are manifested by a reduced mobility of LHC antenna chlorophyll proteins. It is demonstrated that these changes occur rapidly and reversibly within 5 min of illumination and dark relaxation, are dependent on ΔpH, and are enhanced by the deepoxidation of violaxanthin to zeaxanthin.     

Fluorescence lifetime,yield, energy transfer and spectrum in photosynthesis, 1950–1960*

The fluorescence lifetime of chlorophyll agives information about the primary photo-physical events in photosynthesis. Most of the light energy absorbed by chlorophylls is utilized for photochemistry. There are two main additional pathways competing for the absorbed light energy: fluorescence and radiationless internal conversion (heat). Only a few percent of the absorbed energy proceeds along these two pathways. This historical minireview focuses on the first direct measurements of the lifetime of chlorophyll fluorescence, the time it takes to transfer energy from phycoerythrin to chlorophyll a, and the discovery of the fluorescence band at 720 nm (F720; then attributed to a dimer of chlorophyll). These works were carried out during the the late 1950s to the early 1960s in the laboratory of Professor Eugene Rabinowitch at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign [Brody (1995) Photosynth Res 43: 67–74]. This Minireview is dedicated to Professor Eugene Rabinowitch (1901–1973), mentor of the author (Steve Brody) as well as of the editor, and authors classmate (Govindjee). The career and contributions of Eugene Rabinowitch are available in a dedication by Bannister (1972). This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Enhanced Employment of the Xanthophyll Cycle and Thermal Energy Dissipation in Spinach Exposed to High Light and N Stress

The involvement of the xanthophyll cycle in photoprotection of N-deficient spinach (Spinacia oleracea L. cv Nobel) was investigated. Spinach plants were fertilized with 14 mM nitrate (control, high N) versus 0.5 mM (low N) fertilizer, and grown under both high- and low-light conditions. Plants were characterized from measurements of photosynthetic oxygen exchange and chlorophyll fluorescence, as well as carotenoid and cholorophyll analysis. Compared with the high-N plants, the low-N plants showed a lower capacity for photosynthesis and a lower chlorophyll content, as well as a lower rate of photosystem II photosynthetic electron transport and a corresponding increase in thermal energy dissipation activity measured as nonphotochemical fluorescence quenching. The low-N plants displayed a greater fraction of the total xanthophyll cycle pool as zeaxanthin and antheraxanthin at midday, and an increase in the ratio of xanthophyll cycle pigments to total chlorophyll. These results indicate that under N limitation both the light-collecting system and the photosynthetic rate decrease. However, the increased dissipation of excess energy shows that there is excess light absorbed at midday. We conclude that spinach responds to N limitation by a combination of decreased light collection and increased thermal dissipation involving the xanthophyll cycle.