NATURAL AND ARTIFICIAL HYBRIDS OF HELIANTHUS MAXIMILIANI X H. GROSSESERRATUS

Long , Robert W. (Ohio Wesleyan U., Delaware.) Natural and artificial hybrids of Helianthus Maximiliani × H. grosseserratus. Amer. Jour. Bot. 46(10): 687–692. Illus. 1959.—An investigation of the occurrence of natural hybridization in two perennial sunflowers, Helianthus Maximiliani and H. grosseserratus, was begun in 1950. Subsequently, artificial F₁, F₂, and first and second backcross generations were produced. Fertility and vigor were high in all these plants, but F₁ plants appeared to excel the others in these characteristics. Observations in the experimental garden were supplemented by examination of chromosomes in pollen mother cells, comparisons of herbarium collections, and study of wild populations. Evidence pointed to close genetic relationship of the species and to the occurrence of natural hybridization in areas of distributional overlap. In 1957 and 1958, field work in these areas resulted in the scoring of 18 natural populations, 3 of which consisted of both parental species plus putative F₁ hybrids. Two explanations are offered to account for the seeming absence of introgression. The results support the conclusion that natural hybridization leads to the establishment of F₁ hybrids and that introgression does not occur to any significant extent. Although both species display a high degree of interfertility, they are distinct morphologically. For this reason, it is advisable to maintain them as separate species.     

SYNTHETIC AGROPYRON-ELYMUS HYBRIDS: III. ELYMUS CANADENSIS X AGROPYRON CANINUM,A. TRACHYCAULUM,AND A. STRIATUM

Hybrids were produced with relative ease from controlled crosses of Elymus canadensis L. with European Agropyron caninum (L.) Beauv., North American A. trachycaulum (Link) Malte ex H. F. Lewis, and Asian A. striatum Nees ex Steud. All hybrids appeared to be completely sterile and were, for the most part, morphologically intermediate between their parents. The E. canadensis × A. caninum hybrids were exceptionally vigorous and leafy and may have some potential as forage grasses if fertility can be achieved. All parent plants were tetraploid, 2n = 28, and they behaved cytologically as alloploids. Chromosome pairing in the hybrids indicated that both E. canadensis genomes were closely homologous with those of A. trachycaulum and somewhat less homologous with those of A. caninum. Interchanged and inverted chromosome segments apparently constitute the major differences between E. canadensis, A. trachycaulum, and A. caninum genomes; however, cryptic structural differences must also exist. Partial homologies were detected between one A. striatum and E. canadensis genome, but their other genomes were distinctly different. The genome relations between the parent species were expressed in terms of the following genome formulas: E. canadensis, S₁S₁X₁X₁; A. trachycaulum, S₂S₂X₂X₂; A. caninum, S₃S₃X₃X₃ : and A. striatum S₄S₄YY or X₄X₄YY, where “S” refers to a genome derived from A. spicatum and “X” and “Y” are genomes of unknown origin.     

SYNTHETIC AGROPYRON-ELYMUS HYBRIDS. I. ELYMUS CANADENSIS × AGROPYRON SUBSECUNDUM

Twenty-four seeds were formed in 34 hand-emasculated E. canadensis florets exposed to A. subsecundum pollen. Fifteen of the 24 seeds germinated, and 12 plants were raised to maturity. Each of the 12 plants proved to be a hybrid. The hybrids were morphologically intermediate between the parents, although they favored A. subsecundum in general appearance. The parent plants were meiotically regular and behaved cytologically as strict allotetraploids, 2n = 28. Fourteen bivalents were formed in 12.6% of the hybrid cells interpreted at metaphase I. All other hybrid cells contained various combinations of univalents, bivalents, and multivalents. Mean chromosome associations of 0.22 univalents, 11.70 bivalents, 0.11 trivalente, 0.23 quadrivalents, 0.01 pentavalents, and 0.55 hexavalents were observed in 135 hybrid cells. All hybrid pollen examined was shriveled and non-staining. Five hybrids produced eight seeds, and seven hybrids were completely sterile. The ready cross-compatibility of E. canadensis and A. subsecundum and the relatively good chromosome pairing in their hybrids suggest a much closer relationship between the parent species than is implied by the prevailing taxonomic treatment. Structural rearrangements appear to be responsible for the relatively few differences between E. canadensis and A. subsecundum genomes and for the sterility of the hybrids. Cytological data from this and other investigations indicate a close relationship between many self-fertilizing Agropyron, Elymus, and Sitanion species. It is postulated that this composite of self-fertilizing Agropyron, Elymus, and Sitanion species originated by hybridization between A. spicatum and an unidentified Hordeum species.     

Detection of hybridization between two loach species (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Paramisgurnus dabryanus</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Misgurnus anguillicaudatus</Emphasis>) in wild populations

Artificial interspecific hybrids between large scale loach P. dabryanus and tetraploid pond loach M. anguillicaudatus (Cobitidae, Cypriniformes) are viable. To detect the occurrence of possible natural hybridization, genetic analyses by using microsatellite markers were performed for natural populations of large scale loach and pond loach, the reciprocal laboratory hybrids, and “supposed hybrids” with ambiguous morphology. The fertility of the artificial hybrids was also tested. At one diagnostic microsatellite (Mac50), one out of 20 “supposed hybrids” was identified to be F₁ hybrid between the two loach species because it had the same genotype as that of the laboratory hybrids. The triploid hybrids between the two species were confirmed to be female-sterile. The results show that rare hybridization has occurred between diploid large scale loach and tetraploid pond loach in nature although it may have little effect in genetic introgression. This study is helpful for fish conservation and encourages further investigation on natural hybridization and introgression of loaches.     

Hybridization and asymmetric introgression between Cypripedium tibeticum and C. yunnanense in Shangrila County,Yunnan Province,China

Hybridization and introgression are thought to be important for speciation and adaptation in many plants. However, little is known about the hybridization and introgression among Cypripedium species. To investigate the evidence for hybridization and the pattern of introgression between Cypripedium yunnanense and C. tibeticum in Shangrila County, Yunnan Province, China, morphological characters and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) data for both the species and their putative hybrids were studied. Hand pollination was also performed to verify the crossability of the putative parents. Principal coordinate analysis based on morphological characters and the AFLP data suggested that the putative hybrids were true hybrids of these two Cypripedium species. Analysis with the NewHybrids software indicated that the putative hybrids were F1 generation individuals and backcrosses to C. yunnanese, but no F2 generation was found. Analysis with the Structure software demonstrated asymmetric introgression from C. tibeticum to C. yunnanense. We conclude that natural hybridization and introgression can occur between these two species and that in situ conservation of the parental species is required before fully assessing the evolutionary potential of hybrids.     

A large scale survey of Populus nigra presence and genetic introgression from non-native poplars in Switzerland based on molecular identification

Populus nigra is considered a rare and threatened tree species in Switzerland because of dramatic habitat loss owing to river regulations during the last two centuries and because of potential gene introgression from non-indigenous P. deltoides through planted P. x canadensis hybrids. The significance of introgression as an endangerment to P. nigra, however, is controversial. The aims of the present study were (1) to assess how abundant P. nigra trees are in Switzerland and (2) to assess potential gene introgression. We present data from a molecular survey of 1372 putative P. nigra trees from Switzerland, using both chloroplast DNA and nuclear DNA markers. The results show that P. nigra is more abundant in Switzerland than hitherto thought. Furthermore, we detected a low frequency of gene introgression.     

Potato germ plasm enhancement with disomic tetraploid Solanum acaule. II. Assessment of breeding value of tetraploid F1 hybrids between tetrasomic tetraploid S. tuberosum and S. acaule

The breeding value of tetraploid F₁ hybrids between tetrasomic tetraploid S. tuberosum and the disomic tetraploid wild species S. acaule was examined. The F₁ hybrids showed a tuber yield and appearance comparable to those of their cultivated parent, indicating a potential as acceptable breeding stocks despite the 50% contribution to their pedigree from wild S. acaule. The cytological behavior of the tetraploid F₁ hybrids was examined to determine the probability of recombination for the introgression of S. acaule genes. The majority of the meiotic configurations at metaphase I was bivalents and univalents with mean frequencies of 17.6 and 9.9, respectively. Further, a low frequency of trivalents and quadrivalents was observed. An acceptable low level of meiotic irregularities were observed at the later stages of microsporogenesis, and a reasonable level of pollen stainability was obtained. Therefore, these hybrids could likely be employed for further introgression. From the cytological observations, the following speculations were drawn: (1) some genomic differentiation exists between the S. acaule genomes, (2) at least one of the S. acaule genomes may be homoeologous to the S. tuberosum genomes, (3) intergenomic recombination would likely occur due to the nature of the genomic constitution of the hybrids, and (4) the nature of sesquiploidy of the hybrids may facilitate efficient introgression and establishment of unique aneuploid and euploid recombinant genetic stocks.     

Molecular and morphological evidence of natural interspecific hybridization between the uncommon Eucalyptus aggregata and the widespread E. rubida and E. viminalis

Human activities can promote increased hybridization in the genus Eucalyptus with potentially detrimental consequences for the persistence of rare species. However, many hybrid combinations have not been investigated with combined use of genetic markers and morphology. We assessed the efficiency of the STRUCTURE program and morphological intermediacy for identifying hybrids between the uncommon tree, Eucalyptus aggregata, which putatively hybridizes with the common congeners, E. rubida and E. viminalis in south-eastern Australia. We sampled 1,005 seedlings across 27 populations, all seedlings were genotyped at 6 allozyme loci and scored for 22 stem and leaf characters. Both marker sets confirmed that E. aggregata is hybridizing with both E. rubida and E. viminalis. Allozymes revealed hybrids from E. aggregata trees in 88% of populations and hybrids comprised 7.3% of all seedlings. Both genetics and morphology indicated that ~50% were likely to be F₁ hybrids, and both simulations and morphological characteristics indicated that the remainder were mostly backcrosses. Morphological analysis correctly distinguished 71% of F₁ hybrids from parentals and was least accurate when dealing with potential backcrosses (50% success). Hence, techniques using genetic data (no prior information) and the assessment of appropriate admixture thresholds through simulations provided the most accurate estimates of hybrid frequency. In this study, potential introgression and the high frequency of hybrids in small populations (~30%), suggests that hybridization should be considered in the management and conservation of E. aggregata.     

GENOME RELATIONS AMONG ELYMUS CANADENSIS,ELYMUS TRITICOIDES,ELYMUS DASYSTACHYS,AND AGROPYRON SMITHII

Hand-emasculated Elymus canadensis pollinated by E. triticoides, E. dasystachys, and Agropyron smithii yielded 15, 21, and 1 viable hybrid seeds from 56, 52, and 52 florets, respectively. The 28-chromosome species—E. canadensis, E. triticoides, and E. dasystachys—behaved meiotically as allotetraploids and consistently formed 14 bivalents at metaphase I. Octoploid A. smithii, 2n = 56, averaged 0.41^I, 27.72^II, and 0.03^IV in 87 metaphase-I cells. Agropyron smithii is apparently an allooctoploid or a segmental autoallooctoploid. Meiosis was similar in the E. canadensis X E. triticoides and E. dasystachys hybrids. Chromosome pairing was very low in both hybrids, about two loosely connected open-ended bivalents per cell, and may not represent genuine homologies. The genomes of E. canadensis are distinctly different from those of E. triticoides and E. dasystachys. The E. canadensis X A. smithii hybrid averaged 13.37^I and 14.31^II in 76 metaphase-I cells. More than half of the bivalents were closed at both ends. Inability to distinguish between auto- and allosyndesis resulted in two interpretations of genome relations. Either A. smithii is an alloploid with two of its four genomes similar to those of E. canadensis, or it is a segmental autoalloploid genomically unrelated to E. canadensis. The first interpretation is favored. Agropyron dasystachyum, or one of its close relatives, and E. triticoides are suggested as possible parents of A. smithii.     

Does host outcrossing disrupt compatibility with heritable symbionts?

Vertically transmitted microbes are common in macro‐organisms and can enhance host defense against environmental stress. Because vertical transmission couples host and symbiont lineages, symbionts may become specialized to host species or genotypes. Specialization and contrasting reproductive modes of symbiotic partners could create incompatibilities between inherited symbionts and novel host genotypes when hosts outcross or hybridize. Such incompatibilities could manifest as failed colonization or poor symbiont growth in host offspring that are genetically dissimilar from their maternal host. Moreover, outcrossing between host species could influence both host and symbiont reproductive performance. We tested these hypotheses by manipulating outcrossing between populations and species of two grasses, Elymus virginicus and E. canadensis, that host vertically transmitted fungal endophytes (genus Epichloё). In both greenhouse and field settings, we found that host–symbiont compatibility was robust to variation in host genetic background, spanning within‐population, between‐population and between‐species crosses. Symbiont transmission into the F₁ generation was generally high and weakly affected by host outcrossing. Furthermore, endophytes grew equally well in planta regardless of host genetic background and transmitted at high frequencies into the F₂ generation. However, outcrossing, especially inter‐specific hybridization, reduced reproductive fitness of the host, and thereby the symbiont. Our results challenge the hypothesis that host genetic recombination, which typically exceeds that of symbionts, is a disruptive force in heritable symbioses. Instead, symbionts may be sufficiently generalized to tolerate ecologically realistic variation in host outcrossing.     

SIGNIFICANT ROLE FOR HISTORICAL EFFECTS IN THE EVOLUTION OF REPRODUCTIVE ISOLATION: EVIDENCE FROM PATTERNS OF INTROGRESSION BETWEEN THE CYPRINID FISHES,LUXILUS CORNUTUS AND LUXILUS CHRYSOCEPHALUS

Samples of Luxilus cornutus, Luxilus chrysocephalus, and their hybrids were collected along hypothesized routes of dispersal from Pleistocene refugia to examine the significance of geographic variation in patterns of introgression between these species. Patterns of allozyme and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) variation were generally consistent with those from previous studies. Tests of Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium revealed significant deficiencies of heterozygotes in all samples, indicating some form of reproductive isolation. Mitochondrial DNAs of each species were not equally represented in F₁ hybrids; however, this bias was eliminated when the two largest samples were excluded from the analysis. Backcross hybrids exhibited biased mtDNA introgression, as samples from Lake Erie (eastern) and Lake Michigan (western) drainages showed significant excesses of mtDNAs from L. chrysocephalus and L. cornutus, respectively, relative to frequencies of diagnostic allozyme markers. The extent and direction of allozyme and mtDNA introgression was quantified by calculating isolation index values from morphologically “pure” individuals of each species from each locality. Analysis of variance of these measures identified limited introgression of allozyme variants with no geographic pattern, but significant differences in direction of mtDNA introgression between drainages (i.e., postglacial dispersal route). Association between patterns of mtDNA introgression and dispersal route across the latitudinal width of the contact zone is best explained by genetic divergence during past isolation of ancestral populations from these drainages. These results identify a significant role for historical effects in the evolution of reproductive isolation and the process of speciation.     

Hybridization and introgression in a mixed population of the intertidal seaweeds Fucus evanescens and F. serratus

The introduced Fucus evanescens (hermaphroditic) and the native F. serratus (dioecious) have been in secondary contact along the Danish coast of the Kattegat Sea for 60–100 years and dioecious hybrids have been observed at Blushøj for several years. Hybridization in Fucus is unusual because it appears to always involve a hermaphroditic and a dioecious parental pair. We determined the degree and spatial patterns of introgression for 286 individuals using 10 microsatellite loci and cpDNA. Hybrids accounted for nearly 13% of the population, yet parental species were well differentiated (F_ST = 0.633). The presence of F. evanescens chloroplasts in 100% of F₁ hybrids revealed asymmetrical hybridization. Fucus evanescens cpDNA was observed in 50% of introgressed and 5.4% of pure F. serratus, but no F. serratus cpDNA was found in F. evanescens. In contrast, nuclear DNA introgression was symmetrical with an equal amount (≈1.5%) of genes introgressed into each parental species. Survivorship and viability data suggest selection against hybrids in the hybrid zone.     

Morphological and molecular evidence of natural hybridization in Shorea (Dipterocarpaceae)

Shorea (Dipterocarpaceae) is a large genus in which many closely related species often grow together in Southeast Asian lowland tropical rain forests. Many Shorea species share common pollinators, and earlier studies suggested occurrence of interspecific hybridization and introgression. Here, we show morphological and molecular evidence of hybridization between Shorea species. In the census of all the trees of Shorea curtisii, Shorea leprosula, and Shorea parvifolia (>30 cm dbh) within the 164-ha area of Bukit Timah Nature Reserve in Singapore, we found 21 morphologically recognizable hybrid individuals. All of the putative hybrids could be distinguished obviously from the parental species on the basis of vegetative characters. Population genetic analysis of DNA sequences of two nuclear (GapC and PgiC) and chloroplast (trnL-trnF) regions demonstrated that each of the three species had several species-specific mutations. The nuclear sequences of the putative hybrids were heterozygote at all the species-specific sites between two parental species. Hybrid between S. curtisii and S. leprosula was found most, while S. curtisii × S. parvifolia and S. leprosula × S. parvifolia hybrids were also found. Almost no shared polymorphism between populations of the parental species suggests rarity of introgression. The study indicated that natural hybridization between sympatric Shorea species should not be uncommon, but all of the hybrid individuals were F₁, and the post-F₁ hybrids were considerably rare.     

Preferences of juveniles and adults of the invasive Ponto-Caspian amphipod <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pontogammarus robustoides</Emphasis> for various species of macrophytes and artificial substrata

We studied preferences of invasive Ponto-Caspian amphipod P. robustoides for various macrophyte species (Myriophyllum spicatum, Ceratophyllum demersum, Potamogeton perfoliatus, Elodea canadensis) and artificial plant-like objects (artificial Christmas tree branches) in laboratory pairwise-choice tests. Juvenile (<7 mm) and adult gammarids exhibited different habitat preferences. Adults did not discriminate between artificial and natural substrata, or among most of the tested species of plants. In contrast, juveniles clearly preferred all tested macrophytes over artificial substrata. Moreover, they particularly preferred plants with the finest leaf elements: M. spicatum and C. demersum over the others and E. canadensis over P. perfoliatus. We found no influence of chironomid larvae, a potential food source for adult gammarids, on their distribution, nor any effect of adults on the habitat choice by juveniles. The habitat partitioning between juvenile and adult P. robustoides may help them survive in a new environment and increase their invasive potential by reducing the intraspecific competition and cannibalism.     

Molecular genetic data reveal hybridization between Typha angustifolia and Typha latifolia across a broad spatial scale in eastern North America

A recent increase in the abundance of cattails (Typha spp.) in North American wetlands has been anecdotally linked with hybridization between Typha latifolia and Typha angustifolia. In this study, we used molecular genetic markers (microsatellites) to investigate whether the hybrid lineage (Typha × glauca) is restricted to The Great Lakes region, or exists across a much broader spatial scale. We also investigated the possibility of backcrossing and genetic introgression in natural populations. Parental species could be distinguished from one another based on the distribution of alleles at six microsatellite loci. Species identification based on genetic data corresponded well with species identifications based on leaf width, a key morphological trait that can distinguish the two parental species. We found that hybrids occur in Ontario, Quebec, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia, but we did not detect hybrids in Maine. F₁s are more abundant than backcrossed or intercrossed hybrids, although we also found evidence of backcrossing, particularly in Ontario. This indicates that hybrids are fertile, and are therefore potential conduits of gene flow between the parental species. Further work is needed to determine whether T. × glauca is particularly successful in the Great Lakes region relative to other areas in which the two parental species co-exist, and to assess whether introgression may lead to increased invasiveness in the species complex.     

Do they really hybridize? A field study in artificially established mixed populations of Euphrasia minima and E. salisburgensis (Orobanchaceae) in the Swiss Alps

Hybridization and introgression in the European species of Euphrasia depend on the relationships between the species, on flower size and habitat. Hybridization between Euphrasia minima and Euphrasia salisburgensis was investigated in their natural habitat using artificial sympatric populations of both species in the Swiss Alps. The insect behavior in the populations suggests, that cross-pollination is likely to occur. A number of putative hybrids were detected by morphological characteristics, and their hybrid origin was verified using RAPD analysis. The predominance of RAPD bands in one of the species and the occurrence of these bands in some plants of the second species point to earlier introgression events. The number of hybrids found in the artificial populations together with results of earlier studies indicate that insect visits and cross-pollination in small-flowered Euphrasia species in lower alpine regions may be more common than has been suggested in the past.     

REPRODUCTIVE ISOLATION AND INTROGRESSION BETWEEN NOTROPIS CORNUTUS AND NOTROPIS CHRYSOCEPHALUS (FAMILY CYPRINIDAE): COMPARISON OF MORPHOLOGY,ALLOZYMES, AND MITOCHONDRIAL DNA

Hybrid zones in fluvial fishes may be heterogeneous from drainage to drainage. The comparison of data from morphology, allozymes, and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) indicates variability in the causes and degree of restriction of gene flow between Notropis cornutus and Notropis chrysocephalus. Allozyme marker loci show frequency-dependent introgression; i.e., the rarer species, whichever it is at a particular locality, tends to exhibit a higher proportion of introgressed alleles. Unlike allozymes, introgression of mtDNA haplotypes varies geographically. In westward-flowing Michigan drainages, N. cornutus mtDNA haplotypes are more common in F₁ hybrids and backcrosses, independent of parental frequencies. In eastward-flowing Michigan drainages, N. chrysocephalus mtDNA is more common in F₁ hybrids and backcrosses; this pattern may be due to local ecological effects or frequency-dependent introgression. Morphological data alone are not sufficient to distinguish all classes of hybrids. The lack of concordance of morphological, allozymic, and mtDNA introgression patterns implies operation of one or two factors: 1) geographically variable patterns of selection against different hybrid and backcross combinations or 2) genetic differences between Michigan populations inhabiting eastward- and westward-flowing drainage systems accumulated during historical isolation.     

Evolutionary patterns in the antR-Cor gene in the dwarf dogwood complex (Cornus, Cornaceae)

The evolutionary pattern of the myc-like anthocyanin regulatory gene antR-Cor was examined in the dwarf dogwood species complex (Cornus Subgenus Arctocrania) that contains two diploid species (C. canadensis and C. suecica), their putative hybrids with intermediate phenotypes, and a tetraploid derivative (C. unalaschkensis). Full-length sequences of this gene (∼4 kb) were sequenced and characterized for 47 dwarf dogwood samples representing all taxa categories from 43 sites in the Pacific Northwest. Analysis of nucleotide diversity indicated departures from neutral evolution, due most likely to local population structure. Neighbor-joining and haplotype network analyses show that sequences from the tetraploid and diploid intermediates are much more strongly diverged from C. suecica than from C. canadensis, and that the intermediate phenotypes may represent an ancestral group to C. canadensis rather than interspecific hybrids. Seven amino acid mutations that are potentially linked to myc-like anthocyanin regulatory gene function correlate with petal colors differences that characterize the divergence between two diploid species and the tetraploid species in this complex. The evidence provides a working hypothesis for testing the role of the gene in speciation and its link to the petal coloration. Sequencing and analysis of additional nuclear genes will be necessary to resolve questions about the evolution of the dwarf dogwood complex.     

SYNTHETIC HYBRIDS OF HORDEUM BOGDANII WITH ELYMUS CANADENSIS AND SITANION HYSTRIX

Seven viable hybrid seeds were obtained from 48 hand-emasculated Elymus canadensis L., 2n = 28, florets pollinated by Hordeum bogdanii Wilensky, 2n = 14. The hybrids were large, vigorous, and completely sterile plants that bore a closer morphological resemblance to E. canadensis than to H. bogdanii. Chromosome associations in the 21-chromosome hybrids averaged 9.98^I, 5.40^II, and 0.08^III in 264 metaphase-I cells. Chromosome pairing was attributed to allosyndetic pairing between E. canadensis and H. bogdanii chromosomes. The H. bogdanii genome appears to be partially homologous with one of the two E. canadensis genomes. One Sitanion hystrix (Nutt.) J. G. Smith X H. bogdanii hybrid was obtained from a cross involving 37 emasculated S. hystrix florets. This triploid, 2n = 21, hybrid was morphologically intermediate between the parents and totally sterile. Averages of 9.09^I, 5.72^II, and 0.16^III were observed in 106 cells at metaphase I. A modified form of the H. bogdanii genome appears to occur in S. hystrix as well as in E. canadensis. Many allotetraploid Agropyron, Elymus, and Sitanion species apparently contain a genome derived from Hordeum.