Novel somatic hybrids (Solanum tuberosum L. + Solanum tarnii) and their fertile BC1 progenies express extreme resistance to potato virus Y and late blight

Solanum tarnii, a wild diploid, tuber-bearing Mexican species belonging to the series Pinnatisecta is highly resistant to Potato virus Y (PVY) and Colorado potato beetle and shows a strong hypersensitive reaction to Phytophthora infestans. Therefore, it could be a potential source of resistance to pathogens for potato breeders. S. tarnii (2n = 2x = 24) is reproductively isolated from tetraploid Solanum tuberosum and hence difficult to include in potato breeding programmes. In this study, interspecific somatic hybrids were produced for the first time by protoplast electrofusion of the cells of potato cv. Delikat (Solanum tuberosum L.) and Solanum tarnii. The hybrid nature of the regenerants was confirmed by simple sequence repeat (SSR) and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers and by morphological analysis and flow cytometry. Selected somatic hybrids were successfully backcrossed with cv. Delikat. Parental lines, primary somatic hybrids and BC₁ progeny were assessed for resistance to PVY by mechanical inoculation, grafting and exposure to viruliferous aphid vectors in the field, and resistance to late blight (P. infestans) by detached leaflet and whole tuber tests. The somatic hybrids showed no symptoms of viral infection and most of them displayed high levels of resistance to foliage blight. The BC₁ progenies were highly resistant to PVY and a few were resistant to foliage blight. Selected hybrids and BC₁ clones were evaluated in the field for tuber quality and tuber yield. Some BC₁ clones produced yields of good quality tubers. The results confirm that both the resistance to PVY and to late blight of S. tarnii is expressed in somatic hybrids, and PVY resistance is transferred to BC₁ progeny, whereas blight resistance is harder to transfer. Somatic hybridization again proved to be a valuable tool for producing pre-breeding material with increased genetic diversity.     

Molecular and morphological characterization of somatic hybrids between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum tuberosum</Emphasis> L. and <Emphasis Type="Italic">S. etuberosum</Emphasis> Lindl.

Interspecific potato somatic hybrids between Solanum tuberosum L. (di)haploid C-13 and 1 endosperm balance number non-tuberous wild species S. etuberosum Lindl. were produced by protoplasts electrofusion. The objective was to transfer virus resistance from this wild species into the cultivated potatoes. Post-fusion products were cultured in VKM medium followed by regeneration of calli in MS₁₃ K medium at 20°C under a 16-h photoperiod, and regenerants were multiplied on MS medium. Twenty-one somatic hybrids were confirmed by RAPD, SSR and cytoplasm (chloroplast/mitochondria) type analysis possessing species-specific diagnostic bands of corresponding parents. Tetraploid nature of these somatic hybrids was determined through flow cytometry analysis. Somatic hybrids showed intermediate phenotypes (plant, leaves and floral morphology) to their parents in glass-house grown plants. All the somatic hybrids were male-fertile. ELISA assay of somatic hybrids after artificial inoculation of Potato virus Y (PVY) infection reveals high PVY resistance.     

Production and characterization of somatic hybrids between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Solanum tuberosum</Emphasis> L. and <Emphasis Type="Italic">S. pinnatisectum</Emphasis> Dun.

Interspecific somatic hybrids between the dihaploid Solanum tuberosum and the wild species S. pinnatisectum Dun. were produced via protoplast fusion. Protoplast isolation, electrofusion, culture of post-fusion products and regeneration of calli/shoots were undertaken following optimized protocols. Regenerants were characterized for hybridity, ploidy and resistance to Phytophthora infestans (Mont.) de Bery, causal fungal pathogen of late blight disease. From a total of 126 regenerated macrocalli, 12 somatic hybrids were confirmed by possessing species-specific diagnostic bands of their corresponding parents as revealed by RAPD, SSRs and cytoplasmic-DNA analyses. Tetraploid status of the 12 hybrids was determined using flow cytometry analysis. Intermediate phenotypes for leaf, flower, and tuber characteristics and high male fertility were observed in field-grown hybrid plants. Hybrids were highly resistant to foliage late blight based on field assessment for two seasons. In contrast, moderate level of resistance to foliage blight was observed in hybrids based on the detached leaf assay under laboratory conditions. Overall, somatic hybrids with moderate levels of resistance to foliage blight were identified, and these will be useful for in situ hybridization in potato breeding efforts.     

Two allelic or tightly linked genetic factors at the <Emphasis Type="Italic">PLRV.4</Emphasis> locus on potato chromosome XI control resistance to potato leafroll virus accumulation

A novel locus for potato resistance to potato leafroll virus (PLRV) was characterized by inheritance studies and molecular mapping. The diploid parental clone DW 91-1187 was resistant to PLRV accumulation in both inoculated plants and their tuber progeny. The resistance to PLRV accumulation present in DW 91-1187 was not transmitted to any F₁ offspring when crossed with a PLRV susceptible clone. Instead, one half of the F₁ individuals exhibited undetectable amounts of PLRV as determined by ELISA during the primary infection assay, but accumulated PLRV in their tuber progeny plants. The other half was clearly infected both in the inoculated and tuber-born plants. The inheritance of resistance to PLRV accumulation may be explained by a model of two complementary alleles of a single gene (PLRV.4) or by two complementary genes that are closely linked in repulsion phase. Random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) and inter-simple sequence repeat (ISSR) markers linked to the PLRV.4 locus were selected. The two complementary factors were closely linked in coupling phase to the alternative alleles UBC864₆₀₀ and UBC864₈₀₀ of DNA marker UBC864. These markers may be used for marker-assisted selection of genotypes having both factors for resistance to PLRV accumulation. The PLRV.4 locus was mapped to a central position on linkage group XI of the potato molecular map, where no resistance locus has been mapped previously.     

Molecular marker-assisted introgression of the wild Solanum commersonii genome into the cultivated S. tuberosum gene pool

A breeding scheme involving ploidy and EBN manipulations was set up to overcome the interspecific barriers existing between the cultivated Solanum tuberosum and the wild species S. commersonii. Three backcross generations were obtained that were analyzed by means of molecular markers in order to verify the occurrence of recombination between homeologous chromosomes, the extent of the wild genome carried in each backcross, and the efficiency of introgressing useful genes. Twenty commersonii-specific RFLPs provided evidence for recombination on 5 out of 12 chromoso-mes; for the others no more than 1 commersonii-specific marker was found. Thirty-four commersonii-specific RAPDs and 61 commersonii-specific AFLPs were used to estimate the wild genome content in the BC₁, BC₂, and BC₃ generations. The mean value of commersonii-specific markers was 93% and 91% in the BC₁, 74% and 76% in the BC₂, and 31% and 26% in the BC₃ using RAPDs or AFLPs, respectively. Efficiency of the breeding scheme was evaluated by monitoring across these progenies the introgression of S. commersonii resistance to tuber soft rot caused by Erwinia carotovora. Eleven and five resistant genotypes were found among BC₂ and BC₃ hybrids, respectively. The same progenies were also evaluated for chromosome number and tuber traits. For all analyzed traits except stolon length, all BC₂ and BC₃ hybrids resembled the tuberosum type. In order to choose the best genotypes to obtain the following backcrosses, we performed, in each generation, a negative molecular-assisted selection against the wild genome combined with selection for resistance to Erwinia spp. and other traits. Received: 3 April 2000 / Accepted: 31 August 2000     

Production of interspecific somatic hybrids between tuber mustard (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica</Emphasis><Emphasis Type="Italic">juncea</Emphasis>) and red cabbage (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Brassica oleracea</Emphasis>)

In the present investigation, the interspecific somatic hybridization between tuber mustard and red cabbage was established in order to introduce valuable genes from red cabbage (Brassica oleracea) into Brassica juncea. Prior to fusion treatment, protoplasts of red cabbage were inactivated with 2 mM iodoacetamide to inhibit cell division. Micro-calluses were obtained at a frequency of 10.3% after approximately 5 weeks culture following protoplast fusion. Some of the fusion-derived calluses possessed red pigmented cells after being transferred to proliferation medium, and they were presumably considered to be somatic hybrid cell lines. Plantlets were regenerated from 12 cell lines, of which nine plantlets exhibited characteristics intermediate of both parents in terms of plant morphology. With the exception of common protein bands featured by two parents, there were unique banding patterns produced in the hybrids by using SDS-PAGE analysis. By chromosome countings, it was showed that they ranged approximately from 2n=30 to 42 in chromosome numbers. Their hybridity were further confirmed by RAPD analysis revealing that genes of both parents were partially incorporated into the hybrids. Positively, all these hybrids were capable of seed-setting. The pod-setting was 4.2 in somatic hybrid H₇ when backcrossed with tuber mustard.     

Chromosomal location of a gene suppressing powdery mildew resistance genes Pm8 and Pm17 in common wheat (Triticum aestivum L. em. Thell.)

The chromosomal location of a suppressor for the powdery mildew resistance genes Pm8 and Pm17 was determined by a monosomic set of the wheat cultivar Caribo. This cultivar carries a suppressor gene inhibiting the expression of Pm8 in cv Disponent and of Pm17 in line Helami-105. In disease resistance assessments, monosomic F₁ hybrids (2n=41) of Caribo x Disponent and Caribo x Helami-105 lacking chromosome 7D were resistant, whereas monosomic F₁ hybrids involving the other 20 chromosomes, as well as disomic F₁ hybrids (2n=42) of all cross combinations, were susceptible revealing that the suppressor gene for Pm8 and Pm17 is localized on chromosome 7D. It is suggested that genotypes without the suppressor gene be used for the exploitation of genes Pm8 and Pm17 in enhancing powdery mildew resistance in common wheat.     

Characterization of the multiple resistance traits of somatic hybrids between Solanum cardiophyllum Lindl. and two commercial potato cultivars

Interspecific somatic hybrids between commercial cultivars of potato Solanum tuberosum L. Agave and Delikat and the wild diploid species Solanum cardiophyllum Lindl. (cph) were produced by protoplast electrofusion. The hybrid nature of the regenerated plants was confirmed by flow cytometry, simple sequence repeat (SSR), amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP), microsatellite-anchored fragment length polymorphism (MFLP) markers and morphological analysis. Somatic hybrids were assessed for their resistance to Colorado potato beetle (CPB) using a laboratory bioassay, to Potato virus Y (PVY) by mechanical inoculation and field trials, and foliage blight in a greenhouse and by field trials. Twenty-four and 26 somatic hybrids of cph + cv. Agave or cph + cv. Delikat, respectively, showed no symptoms of infection with PVY, of which 3 and 12, respectively, were also resistant to foliage blight. One hybrid of cph + Agave performed best in CPB and PVY resistance tests. Of the somatic hybrids that were evaluated for their morphology and tuber yield in the field for 3 years, four did not differ significantly in tuber yield from the parental and standard cultivars. Progeny of hybrids was obtained by pollinating them with pollen from a cultivar, selfing or cross-pollination. The results confirm that protoplast electrofusion can be used to transfer the CPB, PVY and late blight resistance of cph into somatic hybrids. These resistant somatic hybrids can be used in pre-breeding studies, molecular characterization and for increasing the genetic diversity available for potato breeding by marker-assisted combinatorial introgression into the potato gene pool.     

Analysis of somatic hybrids between two sterile dihaploid Solanum tuberosum L. breeding lines. Restoration of fertility and complementation of G. pallida Pa2 and Pa3 resistance

Fourteen somatic hybrids generated by electrofusion of mesophyll protoplasts from a non-flowering dihaploid S. tuberosum clone, DHAK-11, and a male-sterile dihaploid clone S. tuberosum, DHAK-33, were grown in the greenhouse and subjected to morphological assessments and tests for fertility and resistance to the white potato cyst nematode Globodera pallida pathotypes Pa2 and Pa3. The ploidy level of the hybrids ranged from 38 to 63 chromosomes. All hybrids developed flowers with violet petals except for one, hy-56, that possessed red petals. The colour of the tuber skin was purple in all hybrids except in hy-56 where the tuber skin was red. All of the hybrids were female fertile and generated viable seeds. Near-tetraploid hybrids produced the highest number of seeds per fruit and these seeds had a normal size. Hybrids with 58 or more chromosomes produced smaller seeds and less seeds per fruit. The germination frequency of the seeds was not influenced by the chromosome number of the hybrids. Pollen viability was determined and the male fertility of three hybrids was tested. Pollination with these three hybrids gave rise to fruit development, but only one produced viable seeds. The hybrids were tested for resistance to G. pallida pathotypes Pa2 and Pa3. A high level of resistance to Pa3, inherited from one parental clone, DHAK-11, and a high level of resistance to Pa2, inherited from the other parental clone, DHAK-33, was combined in four hybrids. These results demonstrate, that protoplast fusion is an efficient method for restoring the fertility of somatic hybrids generated from sterile parent clones, and is a powerful procedure for the complementation of multigenetic disease resistance traits in potato breeding lines.     

Resistance to potato leaf roll virus and potato virus Y in somatic hybrids between dihaploid Solanum tuberosum and S. brevidens

Summary Many somatic fusion hybrids have been produced between a dihaploid potato Solanum tuberosum and the sexually-incompatible wild species S. brevidens using both chemical and electrical fusion techniques. S. brevidens was resistant to both potato leaf roll virus (PLRV) and potato virus Y (PVY), the viruses being either at low (PLRV) or undetectable (PVY) concentrations as determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). The S. tuberosum parent was susceptible to both viruses. A wide range of resistance, expressed as a decrease in virus concentration to both viruses was found amongst fusion hybrids, four of which were especially resistant. The practicality of introducing virus resistance from S. brevidens into cultivated potatoes by somatic hybridisation is discussed.     

Potato germ plasm enhancement with disomic tetraploid Solanum acaule. II. Assessment of breeding value of tetraploid F1 hybrids between tetrasomic tetraploid S. tuberosum and S. acaule

The breeding value of tetraploid F₁ hybrids between tetrasomic tetraploid S. tuberosum and the disomic tetraploid wild species S. acaule was examined. The F₁ hybrids showed a tuber yield and appearance comparable to those of their cultivated parent, indicating a potential as acceptable breeding stocks despite the 50% contribution to their pedigree from wild S. acaule. The cytological behavior of the tetraploid F₁ hybrids was examined to determine the probability of recombination for the introgression of S. acaule genes. The majority of the meiotic configurations at metaphase I was bivalents and univalents with mean frequencies of 17.6 and 9.9, respectively. Further, a low frequency of trivalents and quadrivalents was observed. An acceptable low level of meiotic irregularities were observed at the later stages of microsporogenesis, and a reasonable level of pollen stainability was obtained. Therefore, these hybrids could likely be employed for further introgression. From the cytological observations, the following speculations were drawn: (1) some genomic differentiation exists between the S. acaule genomes, (2) at least one of the S. acaule genomes may be homoeologous to the S. tuberosum genomes, (3) intergenomic recombination would likely occur due to the nature of the genomic constitution of the hybrids, and (4) the nature of sesquiploidy of the hybrids may facilitate efficient introgression and establishment of unique aneuploid and euploid recombinant genetic stocks.     

Resistance to Leptosphaeria maculans in Hybrids of Brassica oleracea and Brassica insularis

The inheritance of hypersensitive resistance to Leptosphaeria maculans in a cross between B. oleracea var. alboglabra and B. insularis was studied. Analyses of F₁ and F₂ progeny suggested that resistance is determined by two dominant, independently-segregating genes. F₁ hybrids were semifertile but normal levels of fertility were restored in a proportion of the F₂ progeny.     

Genetic control of the reactions of raspberry to black raspberry necrosis, raspberry leaf mottle and raspberry leaf spot viruses

Black raspberry necrosis virus (BRNV) induces a severe apical necrosis in black raspberry (Rubus occidentalis) but fails to induce diagnostic symptoms in red raspberry. However, BRNV infection of F₁, F₂ and F₃ hybrids from the cross black raspberry × red raspberry induced mosaic symptoms of varying intensity but no typical apical necrosis. In a survey of 28 red raspberry cultivars, a few developed severe angular chlorotic leaf spots when infected with raspberry leaf mottle virus and a few others did so when infected with raspberry leaf spot virus. These reactions were determined by single dominant genes designated Lm and Ls respectively. The value of the different host reactions for controlling the effects and spread of these viruses is discussed.     

Response of wheatgrasses and wheat × wheatgrass hybrids to barley yellow dwarf virus

Summary Resistance to barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV), manifested by low enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) values in plants exposed to viruliferous aphids, was identified in several wheatgrasses (Agropyron spp.). ELISA results were similar for root and leaf extracts of infested plants. No difference in reaction to BYDV was found between plants grown in the field and those in the growth chamber. Interspecific hybrids were generated using pollen from single resistant plants of Agropyron spp. to pollinate soft red winter wheat spikes. Resistance in hybrids appeared to be at the level of virus replication rather than at the level of vector inoculation. The hybrids varied in their reaction to BYDV. Expression of BYDV resistance in hybrids was influenced not only by wheat genotype and Agropyron species but, in some cases, reaction varied even among hybrids between the same wheat genotype and Agropyron plant. Implications of these results are discussed.Contribution from the Purdue Univ. Agric. Exp. Stn., West Lafayette, IN 47907, and USDA-ARS. The research was supported in part by Public Varieties of Indiana. Purdue Univ. Agric. Exp. Stn. Journal No. 11656     

Occurrence of genetic tumours in Triticum interspecies hybrids

Summary F₁ interspecific hybrids involving nine tetraploid Triticum species were studied. Some developed leaf tumours at the seedling stage. Tumorous hybrids were restricted to crosses involving either T. timopheevi or T. araraticum as one parent. The hybrids from the rest of the crosses, including those of T. timopheevi × T. araraticum, were non-tumorous. Genetically divergent and non-integrated parental species appeared to be inducing spontaneous tumour formation in their hybrids.     

Effekt und Risiko des Knöllchentests auf Braunfäuleresistenz bei Kartoffelsämlingen im System der Auslese in der Phytophthora-Resistenzzüchtung

The effects and risks involved with the small tuber assay in plant breeding programmes with potato seedlings for resistance to Phytophthora infestans In an assay which involved 838 potato seedlings, the relative resistance to leaf-Phytophthora (KR_G) was tested at the 4–6 leaf growth stage, and the relative tuber resistance to infection was determined on small pot-grown tubers (B_K) and, in the following 2 years, in slices from field-grown potatoes (B_s). The small tuber assay is described and its value as a measure of disease resistance, compared with the potato slice assay, discussed. Among 357 leaf-Phytophthora susceptible clones (KR_G≤ 5) were 10 clones with a good to very good tuber resistance. 18 of 204 leaf-Phytophthora highly resistant idiotypes were extremely susceptible to tuber rot. After discarding those seedlings which showed KR_G-values ≤ 5 and B_X-values ≤ 5, 208 of the remaining 241 (= 86 %) tuber rot resistance carrying seedlings were selected. 14 % of the clones which showed adequate resistance in the potato slice assay were falsely discarded according to the small tuber assay. 80 clones remained as ballast in the field trials (B_K≤ 5, B_s≤ 6.4), 160 (33 % of the idiotypes tested) had been correctly eliminated. The work-intensive small tuber assay presents a possibility by which breeding material can already be reduced in the seedling stage. In this respect there must be a pronounced genetic differentiation present in the potato population and the selection procedure carried out must not be too harsh.     

Dominant and additive resistance to the root-knot nematodes Meloidogyne chitwoodi and M. fallax in Central American Solanum species

 The inheritance of resistance to Meloidogyne chitwoodi and M. fallax in Solanum fendleri, S. hougasii and S. stoloniferum was studied assuming disomic behaviour of these polyploid Solanum species. Various populations were produced from crosses within the wild Solanum species; resistant×susceptible and reciprocal crosses (F₁), self-pollinations (S₁), testcrosses (TC) and self-pollinations (F₂) of resistant hybrids, if possible. For the test crosses with S. hougasii, susceptible genotypes of S. iopetalum were used. In seedling tests, numbers of egg masses were counted after inoculation with M. chitwoodi or M. fallax. Almost all seedlings of the F₁ and S₁ populations of S. fendleri appeared to be resistant, whereas the TC and F₂ populations of three different resistant hybrid genotypes segregated into resistant (having 1 or no egg mass) and susceptible plants (having more than 1 egg mass) at ratios of 1:1 and 3:1, respectively. The results clearly indicate the action of a single dominantly inherited gene, and the symbol R _Mc2 is proposed for this gene. In the case of S. hougasii, F₁ and S₁ seedlings appeared to be mostly resistant. Difficulties were met in producing TC and F₂ populations, and only four TC populations were obtained, which segregated at a 1:1 ratio. These results also indicate the presence of a simple dominant factor. For both S. fendleri and S. hougasii no differences were observed between M. chitwoodi and M. fallax, indicating that resistance genes are the same for both nematode species. The F₁, S₁ and TC populations of S. stoloniferum segregated for the square root number of egg masses into normal-like distributions, which deviated between the Meloidogyne species used. The patterns indicate the presence of several additive genes and one or more genes effective to M. fallax but not to M. chitwoodi. The relationship of resistance genes present in various Central American Solanum species is discussed. Received: 24 September 1996/Accepted: 8 November 1996     

THE F1 HYBRIDS OF SOME SAPOGENIN-BEARING DIOSCOREA SPECIES

Fifteen species of Dioscorea and one of Rajania were cross-pollinated in 60 different combinations. Crosses among New World species were partially successful, whereas crosses between New and Old World or among Old World species usually failed entirely. Viable hybrids were obtained from 13 combinations, including all 12 possible combinations among 4 sapogenin-bearing species. Hybrids were intermediate to their parents with respect to vegetative characteristics, but exhibited wider variation or poor physiological control of critical growth phases, including length of the juvenile phase, dry season dormancy, and season of flowering. The flowers of hybrids were also intermediate to those of parents with no clear expressions of dominance. Chromosomal behavior of hybrids was essentially normal but reduction in fertility was manifested by high percentages of abnormal pollen, low crossability and poor seed germination. The significance of these findings with reference to speciation, reproductive barriers, and improvement by breeding is discussed.     

Tagging QTLs for late blight resistance and plant maturity from diploid wild relatives in a cultivated potato (Solanum tuberosum) background

Phytophthora infestans causes an economically important disease of potato called late blight. The epidemic is controlled chemically but resistant potatoes can become an environment-friendly and financially justified alternative solution. The use of diploid Solanum tuberosum derived from European tetraploid cultivars enabled the introgression of novel genes encoding foliage resistance and tuber resistance from other species into the modern cultivated potato gene pool. This study evaluated the resistance of the obtained hybrids, its quality, expression in leaflets and tubers and its relation to the length of vegetation period. We also identified genetic loci involved in late blight resistance and the length of vegetation period. A family of 156 individuals segregating for resistance to late blight was assessed by three laboratory methods: detached leaflet, tuber slice and whole tuber test, repeatedly over 5 years. Length of vegetation period was estimated by a field test over 2 years. The phenotypic distributions of all traits were close to normal. Using sequence-specific PCR markers of known chromosomal position on the potato genetic map, six quantitative trait loci (QTLs) for resistance and length of vegetation period were identified. The most significant and robust QTL were located on chromosomes III (explaining 17.3% of variance observed in whole tuber tests), IV (15.5% of variance observed in slice tests), X (15.6% of variance observed in leaflet tests) and V (19.9% of variance observed in length of vegetation period). Genetic characterization of these novel resistance sources can be valuable for potato breeders and the knowledge that the most prominent QTLs for resistance and vegetation period length do not overlap in this material is promising with respect to breeding early potatoes resistant to P. infestans. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

HYBRID BREAKDOWN BETWEEN TWO HAPLODIPLOID SPECIES: THE ROLE OF NUCLEAR AND CYTOPLASMIC GENES

A central question in evolutionary biology concerns the population and genetic processes by which new species arise. Here, the genetic basis of hybrid breakdown between two haplodiploid species, Nasonia vitripennis and N. giraulti is investigated. Hybridization between the two species is normally prevented by microorganisms that cause bidirectional incompatibility. However, after elimination of microorganisms, F₁ hybrids females are readily produced (due to haplodiploidy, males develop from unfertilized eggs and are therefore not hybrids). F₁ hybrid females are viable and fecund, but recombinant (haploid) F₂ male offspring suffer from severe hybrid breakdown (larval and pupal mortality). This is typically interpreted as evidence for the existence of different coadapted gene complexes in the two species, which are broken up by recombination. F₂ recombinant eggs were rescued by fertilization with the complete chromosome complement from either species, supporting the view that hybrid lethality genes tend to be recessive. Negative epistatic interactions occur between nuclear genes of the two species, and between cytoplasmically inherited factors (cytoplasmic genes) of giraulti and nuclear genes of vitripennis. Interactions between nuclear genes and cytoplasmic genes are asymmetric. Experiments clearly demonstrate that the latter incompatibility is not due to maternal-effect genes, but to cytoplasmically inherited elements. Nuclear-mitochondrial interactions are possibly involved.