The isolation of apparently homoplastidic mutants induced by a nuclear recessive gene in Arabidopsis thaliana

Summary The nuclear recessive gene, chm1, of Arabidopsis thaliana is a imitator that induces a variety of plastid alterations giving rise to mixed cells and variegated leaves. The variegation is maternally transmitted but chm1 is transmitted in a Mendelian fashion (Rédei 1973; Rédei and Plurad 1973). In order to characterize the different types of plastid alterations induced by chm1, isolating homoplastidic lines, each apparently containing one type of mutant plastid in its cells, was essential since such characterization cannot be carried out on mixed cells. We have used two genetic approaches to isolate several apparently homoplastidic mutant lines by the removal of the mutator from the genetic background, and the maternal transmission of the mutant plastids. The rapidity of obtaining homoplastidic lines in the absence of chm1 indicated a non-stochastic sorting-out of plastids in mixed cells. That each of the chm1-free homoplastidic mutant lines was apparently homoplastidic for one type of mutant plastids was confirmed by electron microscopic observations. Here we report, for the first time, the production of different homoplastidic lines in the absence of the nuclear-mutator gene. Such genetically-stable homogeneous material should be a useful tool for studying the molecular mechanism(s) by which chm1 induces a variety of heritable plastid alterations.     

The role of plastid competition in the control of plastid inheritance in the zonal Pelargonium

The inheritance pattern of mutant white plastids was studied in W × W crosses, in which one mutant was highly stable (W^s) and the other unstable (W^u) owing to the spontaneous restitution (mutation) of white plastids to a new green form. Thirty-six selfs and crosses were made within and between three nuclear type I cultivars, transmitting the unstable plastids, and three nuclear type II cultivars, transmitting the stable plastids. The allelic frequencies of the restituted plastids among the progeny were subjected to an analysis of variance which showed that within each nuclear type the three cultivars were rather similar except for some heterogeneity after W^s × W^u plastid crosses. The relative average transmission of the two mutant plastids in these W × W crosses was estimated and compared with their individual transmission in reciprocal crosses in which one parent contained green plastids. In the latter crosses, the green plastids were superior to the mutant plastids and the unstable plastid mutant was only slightly more successful than the stable mutant. But when the mutant plastids competed against each other, the unstable mutant became greatly superior to the stable mutant and comparable to a green normal plastid. A model to explain these results is discussed.     

INDEPENDENCE OF TISSUES DERIVED FROM APICAL LAYERS IN ONTOGENY OF THE TOBACCO LEAF AND OVARY

Six different homoplastidic periclinal chimeras of tobacco carrying the plastogene DP₁ were selected after somatic segregation in heteroplastidic seedlings. Direct observation of the plane of division in epidermal cells of young leaves, and the number and size of sub-epidermal green spots on leaves with the Green-White-White (G-W-W) pattern of variegation, indicated that the ratio of periclinal to anticlinal divisions in L-I during development of the lamina was 1:3100. The number of green and white seedlings obtained from the different chimeral branches indicated a similar frequency of periclinal divisions in development of the ovary. The arrangement of green and white tissue in mature leaves of the various chimeral types indicated the extent of participation by the three apical layers in the initiation of the buttress, development of the axis, and formation of the lamina. During development of the lamina there must be three independent initial-groups present. L-I and L-II initials remain marginal, but early in the growth of the lamina the leading edge of tissue derived from L-III becomes separated from the submarginal (L-II) initials by the products of frequent periclinal divisions of the L-II initials.     

Nuclear—organelle interactions: the immutans variegation mutant of Arabidopsis is plastid autonomous and impaired in carotenoid biosynthesis

The immutans (im) variegation mutant of Arabidopsis thaliana contains green- and white-sectored leaves due to the action of a nuclear recessive gene. The mutation is somatically unstable, and the degree of sectoring is influenced by light and temperature. Whereas the cells in the green sectors contain normal chloroplasts, the cells in the white sectors are heteroplastidic and contain non-pigmented plastids that lack organized lamellar structures, as well as small pigmented plastids and/or rare normal chloroplasts. This indicates that the plastids in im white cells are not affected equally by the nuclear mutation and that the expression of immutans is ‘plastid autonomous’. In contrast to other variegation mutants with heteroplastidic cells, the defect in im is not maternally inherited. immutans thus represents a novel type of nuclear gene-induced variegation mutant. It has also been found that the white tissues of immutans accumulate phytoene, a non-colored C₄₀ carotenoid intermediate. This suggests that immutans controls, either directly or indirectly, the activity of phytoene desaturase (PDS), the enzyme that converts phytoene to zeta-carotene in higher plants. However, im is not the structural gene for PDS. A secondary effect of carotenoid deficiency, both in immutans and in wild-type plants treated with a herbicide that blocks carotenoid synthesis, is an increase in acid ribonuclease activity in white tissue. It is concluded that the novel variegation generated by the immutans mutation should offer great insight into the complex circuitry that regulates nuclear—organelle interactions.     

Impaired Chloroplast Biogenesis in Immutans,an Arabidopsis Variegation Mutant,Modifies Developmental Programming,Cell Wall Composition and Resistance to Pseudomonas syringae

The immutans (im) variegation mutation of Arabidopsis has green- and white- sectored leaves due to action of a nuclear recessive gene. IM codes for PTOX, a plastoquinol oxidase in plastid membranes. Previous studies have revealed that the green and white sectors develop into sources (green tissues) and sinks (white tissues) early in leaf development. In this report we focus on white sectors, and show that their transformation into effective sinks involves a sharp reduction in plastid number and size. Despite these reductions, cells in the white sectors have near-normal amounts of plastid RNA and protein, and surprisingly, a marked amplification of chloroplast DNA. The maintenance of protein synthesis capacity in the white sectors might poise plastids for their development into other plastid types. The green and white im sectors have different cell wall compositions: whereas cell walls in the green sectors resemble those in wild type, cell walls in the white sectors have reduced lignin and cellulose microfibrils, as well as alterations in galactomannans and the decoration of xyloglucan. These changes promote susceptibility to the pathogen Pseudomonas syringae. Enhanced susceptibility can also be explained by repressed expression of some, but not all, defense genes. We suggest that differences in morphology, physiology and biochemistry between the green and white sectors is caused by a reprogramming of leaf development that is coordinated, in part, by mechanisms of retrograde (plastid-to-nucleus) signaling, perhaps mediated by ROS. We conclude that variegation mutants offer a novel system to study leaf developmental programming, cell wall metabolism and host-pathogen interactions.     

Aspects of the biochemistry and ultrastructure of a cytoplasmically inherited plastid defect (Dp1) of tobacco

Dpl, a cytoplasmically inherited plastid defect of Nicotiana tabacum L., has been further characterized by pigment and ribulose diphosphate carboxylase (RuDPCase) assays and electron microscopy. RuDPCase activity was reduced in defective plastids to 20–67% of that in normal chloroplasts. The chlorophyll content was reduced to 5% or less of that in normal chloroplasts. Leaf areas with only defective plastids were very light green for several days after the leaf began to expand but eventually turned white. This loss of chlorophyll was correlated with a reduction in internal plastid lamellae, but there was much less reduction in RuDPCase activity. The presence of cells with both mutant and normal plastids indicate that the plastid and not some other cytoplasmic factor was the site of the controlling unit.Scientific Paper No. 3812, College of Agriculture, Washington State University, Pullman, Projects 1916 and 1920. Supported in part by funds provided for medical and biological research by Washington State Initiative Measure 171.     

Beitr?ge zum Problem der Plastiden-Ab?nderung

Summary The cross experiments on cytoplasmic inheritance in Epilobium reveal the important fact that the cytoplasm of the cells contains numerous constituents (viz. plastied etc.), which can segregate intraindividually. The mutated plastids have to be investigated immediately after the mutation and not after an indefinite time of intraindividual segregation. Unfortunately, the rate of plastid mutation is too low to be observed microscopically. It is known that the rate of plastid mutability can be increased by the influence of certain nuclear genes. Such gene mutations increasing the plastid mutability, also in Epilobium, were looked for in mutation experiments with radioactive isotopes. In the experiments (Table 1) 3 genes inducing plastid mutations more frequently were detected among 849 induced nuclear gene mutations. One of these 3 genes, the mp ₁-gene, is described in this publication.In nearly 100% of the homozygote, recessive (mp ₁ mp ₁) conditions the mp ₁ gene induces numerous various plastome and plasmone mutations. The spectrum of these induced mutations is different from the spectrum of spontaneous mutations (Table 3). It seems possible, that the plastid mutations were indirectly induced by plasmone alterations which are formed presumablely in mp ₁ mp ₁ plants. 1–4% plastid-mutations are induced by the plasmone of the former mp ₁ mp ₁-plants, even after the elimination of the mp ₁ mp ₁-genes. The spontaneous mutation rate is only 0,2%.The induced plastid and plasmone-mutations could be analysed by the backcrossing between mp ₁ mp ₁ xhirsutum Essen Mp ₁ mp ₁ . In this crossing the few mutated constitutents present in the eggcells were transfered by maternal inheritance to the F₁, whereas the effect of the mp ₁-gene was inactivated in the heterozygote condition.The plastid mutations were inherited maternally (Table 7). They are characterized by real mixed cells with two genetically different plastids in young state of cell-differentiation (Table 5) and also by an alternative spotting in specific verschachtelt patterns.The properties of plastids can be changed by mutation variably. The pigment content of the altered tissue can vary from white, cream, yellow over different degrees to green resp. and is determined by a specific alteration or a specific degree of degeneration. The behaviour of the plastids during their distribution at the cell division can vary from a distribution by chance to an onesided distribution. This onesided distribution can be recognized by a onesided situation of the spots and by an acceleration of the outsorting of plastids. The physiological behaviour of the plastids can be altered by the interaction of plastids within the plastome. Mixed cells can disappear in aged cells both the ways mutually influencing the different plastids. Anatomical disturbance within leaf development can arise by alterations of the frequency of cell divisions. Even the greenness of plastids can be increased by environment in certain plastotypes. Numerous backmutations (=restitutions) were induced by the mp ₁-gene in the yellowish cells with colourless plastids at 2 specific plastotypes, and a specific variegation pattern is produced in this way. But in most plasmotypes such an influence of the mp ₁-gene could not be observed. The viability of the white seedlings of the crossings on white branches of the variegated plants can vary. Plastotypes with anatomical disturbances do not produce seeds (Table 6). A plastotype with very small, white spots containing in average 71% green tissue failing to outsort pure white shoots and also of green progenies in spite of the variegated leaves was thought to be a combination with the rhytidiophyllum-plasmotype. The hypothesis is: that the green rhytidiophyllum-seedlings are not viable and that this plasmotype induces plastome-alterations in so late state of development that the cell divisions in the leaves are not sufficient for a complete outsorting in poor white shoots. Some plastotypes were periclinal chimeras with plasmotypes. The progenies of 2 further alterations were uniformly yellow-green. Plasmone alterations can be supposed to be by the failure of variegation.Disturbances of shoot or leaf-development are frequently observed at the plasmone alterations arising in combination with plastid mutations. They are similar but not identical with the plasmone alterations of the Epilobium hirsutum EssenxEpilobium parviflorum Tübingen hybrid. Plasmone alterations are characterized by sudden arising or by quantitative changes of the disturbances and also by the failure of mixed cells with different plastotypes and by gliding alterations of the patterns. Such behaviour can be explained by a flowing or onesided alteration of the ratios between the hereditable units, which occur in the cells in higher numbers. Alterations similar to the alteration stenophyllum (Fig. 13) of the Epilobium hirsutum EssenxEpilobium parviflorum Tübingen do not flower, exceptionally after normalisation of the shoots. Alterations similar to rhytidiophyllum (Fig. 14) show an ill formation of seeds and a quantitative variegation in the formation of their small leaves. Each difference between two single shoots was inherited maternally to the progenies. Alterations similar to irregulare (Fig. 16) show defects in the formation of the plumule of seedlings.All these differences were inherited maternally over at least 3 generations, even of flower-reciprocal crossing of the various alterations with one another (Table 10).     

Hereditary structural alterations of plastids induced by a nuclear mutator gene inArabidopsis

Summary Homozygosity for mutant alleles at thechm locus inArabidopsis induces structural alterations in the plastids. The newly arisen plastid alterations are hereditary, autonomous from the inducer gene, and show maternal transmission only. The mutator action is limited to the plastids but several sites within this organelle become mutable with a very high frequency. The mutations reveal that the plastids have a share in the control of their own structure and function as well as in those of the host cells and organs. The individuality of the plastids was ascertained by genetic and electron microscopic techniques. Within single cells numerous different plastids were revealed. The mutations blocked plastid differentiation at various stages and also produced viable, functional chloroplasts of distinct morphology. Since specific structural alterations can be genetically isolated in homoplastidic forms, one may apply the techniques of the classical cytogenetics to chloroplasts and correlate function with the morphology of this hereditary vehicle in somewhat similar manner as structural alterations of the chromosomes have been correlated with genic expression and pattern of inheritance.Contribution from the Missouri Agricultural Experiment Station. Journal Series Number 6534. Approved by the Director 10/9/72.     

Beiträge zum Problem der Plastidenabänderungen

Summary Seeds ofEpilobium hirsutum were treated with 0.5 mC³⁵S isotope. One treated plant gave rise to variegated plants when selfed. Crosses revealed that this was caused by a recessive gene mp₂ which induces plastid mutations.That the observed variegation was due to mutations of the plastids could be derived from the evidence of the characteristic patterns of the leaves and from the occurrence of actual mixed cells. Maternal inheritance of the mutated plastids could not be demonstrated as the mp₂ gene induces most of the plastid mutations too late in the development of the leaves to exert an effect on the shoots and cell lines giving rise to egg cells.     

Induction,ultrastructure, isolation,and tissue culture of chlorophyll mutants in carrot

Summary Seeds ofDaucus carota “Danvers” were treated with ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) for 6-hr periods at concentrations of 0.01, 0.03, 0.1, 0.3, 1.0, and 3.0% to induce plastid mutants. In these treatments, there was a gradual decrease in percent germination from control up to 1.0% EMS and no germinations at 3.0%. The number of chlorophyll mutants increased with dose of mutagen. One mutant plant was isolated from the 0.1% treatment and it had leaf sections of green, white layered on green and pure white; and white and green striped petioles. Histogenic analysis of this mutant showed it to be a GGW chimera, the “all-white” sectors being GWW, arising from displacement of L-II by L-III. Electron micrographs of the white sections showed plastids that had dilated thylakoids typical of PS-I mutants. So called “mixed cells” of normal and mutant plastids were found, suggesting a plastome mutation. Leaf and petiole sections have been successfully cultured through the development of callus, and both green and white plants have been regenerated. Regenerated white plantlets were insensitive to 10 mM methyl viologen (paraquat), whereas green tissues were killed by the herbicide. Support for some of this work was provided by the Miami University Faculty Research Committee and the Comprehensive Employment and Training Act (CETA). This paper will be included as part of the dissertation work of P. D. Miller.     

Somatic instability of carotenoid biosynthesis in the tomato ghost mutant and its effect on plastid development

The tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum (L.) Mill.) ghost plant is a mutant of the San Marzano cultivar affected in carotenoid biosynthesis. ghost plants exhibit a variable pattern of pigment biosynthesis during development. Cotyledons are green but true leaves are white. Green sectors, which appear to be clonal in origin, are frequently observed in the white tissue. Because of the lack of photosynthesis ghost plants have a very low viability in soil. We have developed a strategy for propagating ghost plants that employs organ culture to generate variegated green-white plants which, supported by the photosynthetic green areas, develop in soil to almost wild-type size. These plants were used to analyze the pigment content of the different tissues observed during development and plastid ultrastructure. Cotyledons and green leaves contain both colored carotenoids and chlorophyll but only the colorless carotenoid phytoene accumulates in white leaves. the plastids in the white tissue of ghost leaves lack internal membrane structures but normal chloroplasts can be observed in the green areas. The chromoplasts of white fruits are also impaired in their ability to form thylakoid membranes.     

Development of Photosystem I and Photosystem II Activities in Leaves of Light-grown Maize (Zea mays)

To compare chloroplast development in a normally grown plant with etiochloroplast development, green maize plants (Zea mays), grown under a diurnal light regime (16-hour day) were harvested 7 days after sowing and chloroplast biogenesis within the leaf tissue was examined. Determination of total chlorophyll content, ratio of chlorophyll a to chlorophyll b, and O₂-evolving capacity were made for intact leaf tissue. Plastids at different stages of development were isolated and the electron-transporting capacities of photosystem I and photosystem II measured. Light saturation curves were produced for O₂-evolving capacity of intact leaf tissue and for photosystem I and photosystem II activities of isolated plastids. Structural studies were also made on the developing plastids. The results indicate that the light-harvesting apparatus becomes increasingly efficient during plastid development due to an increase in the photosynthetic unit size. Photosystem I development is completed before that of photosystem II. Increases in O₂-evolving capacity during plastid development can be correlated with increased thylakoid fusion. The pattern of photosynthetic membrane development in the light-grown maize plastids is similar to that found in greening etiochloroplasts.     

Impact of the stringency of cell selection on plastid segregation in protoplast fusion-derived Nicotiana regenerates

Summary Vegetative segregation of a mixed plastid population in protoplast fusion-derived cell lines can be directed by a selection favouring the multiplication of one of the parental plastid types. This report defines some of the critical conditions leading to a homogeneous plastid population in cybrid plants generated by protoplast fusion between Nicotiana plumbaginifolia and an albino and streptomycin-resistant N. tabacum plastid mutant. Light (1,500 lx) conferred a strong selective advantage to chloroplasts versus albino plastids, while the lack of this effect in dim light (300 lx) indicated that a sufficient light intensity is essential to the phenomenon. Selection on streptomycin-containing medium in the dark, however, led to the preferential multiplication of resistant plastids. Streptomycin selection of resistant chloroplasts in the light, consequently, results in a plastid selection of doubled stringency. In another experiment a definite, but leaky, selection for chloroplast recombination (selection for greening on streptomycin-containing medium in dim light) was used to reveal various recombination products. Protoplast fusion in fact resulted in cybrid plants showing only simple chimeric segregation of unchanged parental plastids. These results demonstrate the essential requirement for stringent plastid selection, as defined by cell culture conditions, to precede the formation of shoots expected to possess the desired plastid genetic composition.     

The mechanism of the mixed inheritance of chloroplast genes in Pelargonium

Summary The distributions are given of gene frequencies among embryos after G X W and W X G plastid crosses within and between eight Pelargonium cultivars and some of their inbred or hybrid derivatives.Two distinct segregation patterns are recognized. Homozygous type I female parents (Pr₁Pr₁) have a high frequency of progeny with only maternal alleles, are intermediate for biparental and low for paternal offspring. Heterozygous type II female plants (Pr₁Pr₂) have an equally high frequency of maternal and paternal offspring and a generally low biparental frequency. These correspond to L-shaped and U-shaped gene frequency distributions respectively in which the only modes are at 0 per cent (maternal embryos) and 100 per cent (paternal embryos), with no mode corresponding to the population mean and no sign of a Gaussian distribution.The extremely variable plastid gene frequencies are strongly influenced by the maternal nuclear genotype and by the plastid genotype in which the wild-type allele is always more successful than the mutant in strict comparisons.The relative frequencies of maternal and paternal zygotes, and the mean gene frequency among all the zygotes in a cross, are explicable in terms of the input frequencies of genes from the two parents, their degree of mixing, and by some form of selective replication of plastids. This selection is controlled by nuclear and plastid genotypes which may act in the same direction, to increase the frequency of either the maternal or the paternal alleles, or in opposition. But selection alone is inadequate to explain the shapes of the gene frequency distributions. Instead, a model is proposed in which the segregation or replication of plastids appears to have a strong random element, which results in random drift of gene frequencies within a heteroplasmic zygote or embryo.     

Alterations in photosynthesis in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis> lacking IMMUTANS,a chloroplast terminal oxidase

Green and white variegation in the Arabidopsis immutans (im) mutant is caused by a nuclear recessive gene. The green sectors contain cells with normal-appearing chloroplasts, while cells in the white sectors have photooxidized plastids lacking organized lamellae. In the present experiments, we found that the green im sectors have enhanced rates of carbon assimilation (monitored by ¹⁴CO₂ uptake) and that there are corresponding increases in the activities of Rubisco and SPS, elevated starch and sucrose pool sizes, and an altered pattern of carbohydrate partitioning that favors sucrose over starch. We hypothesize that these increases are due, at least in part, to interactions with white sectors, perhaps to compensate for reductions in total source tissue. Consistent with this idea, the im white sectors accumulate low levels of sucrose and acid invertase activities are markedly increased in the white versus green cells. This suggests that there is a sucrose gradient between the green and white sectors, and that sucrose is transported from the green to white cells in response to sink demand. The expression of photosynthetic genes is not appreciably altered in the green im sectors versus wild type, but rather there is an up-regulation of genes involved in defense against oxidative stress and down-regulation of genes involved in cell wall biosynthesis. We postulate that changes in photosynthesis in the im green cells are driven by a need for photoprotection (especially early in chloroplast biogenesis) and due to source-sink interactions. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Plastid Ontogeny during Petal Development in Arabidopsis

Imaging of chlorophyll autofluorescence by confocal microscopy in intact whole petals of Arabidopsis thaliana has been used to analyze chloroplast development and redifferentiation during petal development. Young petals dissected from unopened buds contained green chloroplasts throughout their structure, but as the upper part of the petal lamina developed and expanded, plastids lost their chlorophyll and redifferentiated into leukoplasts, resulting in a white petal blade. Normal green chloroplasts remained in the stalk of the mature petal. In epidermal cells the chloroplasts were normal and green, in stark contrast with leaf epidermal cell plastids. In addition, the majority of these chloroplasts had dumbbell shapes, typical of dividing chloroplasts, and we suggest that the rapid expansion of petal epidermal cells may be a trigger for the initiation of chloroplast division. In petals of the Arabidopsis plastid division mutant arc6, the conversion of chloroplasts into leukoplasts was unaffected in spite of the greatly enlarged size and reduced number of arc6 chloroplasts in cells in the petal base, resulting in few enlarged leukoplasts in cells from the white lamina of arc6 petals.