The efficacy of Neurospora in detecting agents that cause aneuploidy

A total of 110 agents, 109 chemicals plus gamma-rays, has been tested in a Neurospora pseudowild-type selection system for their ability to induce meiotic aneuploidy. 11 agents were positive, 47 were negative, and 52 were inconclusively tested. The system has a possible role as a short-term test for environmental agents causing human aneuploidy. The advantages of the system are its simplicity and ease of use. Disadvantages are its high variability of aneuploid frequency and an inability to distinguish mechanisms of aneuploidy.     

Lack of correlation between mutagen-induced chromosomal univalency and aneuploidy in mouse spermatocytes

Aneuploidy represents the predominant type of chromosomal abnormality found in human newborns with birth defects. The concern that environmental agents may cause aneuploidy in germ cells has prompted development of assay systems for detection of potentially aneuploidy-producing agents. One of the most frequently used methods involves cytogenetic analysis of murine spermatogenic cells at the stages of meiotic metaphases. However, criteria for aneuploidy induction have not been standardized in this test system. Many investigators consider the ability of an agent to induce univalents an appropriate measure of its potential to induce aneuploidy. In the present study, the relationship between univalency and aneuploidy was examined in mouse spermatocytes after various mutagen treatments. 45 Swiss mice were treated with 4 different agents; viz., adriamycin vinblastine sulfate, cytosine arabinoside, and radiation (cobalt 60) and 10 untreated animals served as controls. From each animal, 50–200 MIs were examined for both sex-chromosomal and autosomal univalency (X-Y U and AU), and equal numbers of MIIs were examined for aneuploidy (hyperhaploidy). No significant correlations between univalency (either X-Y U or AU) and aneuploidy were found in the mutagen-treated mice; nor were they found in the untreated animals. These results indicate that induction of univalents by a mutagen is not necessarily predictive of the aneuploidy-inducing ability of his agent.     

The TX;Y test for the detection of nondisjunction and chromosome breakage in Drosophila melanogaster. II. Results of female exposures

The TX; Y test is a short-term assay for the detection of sex-chromosome nondisjunction and chromosome breakage in Drosophila melanogaster. It has been used in previous work following the exposure of males. In this work, females are exposed. When females are the exposed parent, only chromosome gain can be detected. Positive results for the induction of aneuploidy were obtained following exposures of females to X-rays, 10 degrees C cold shock, and colchicine. No increase in aneuploidy was obtained following exposures of females to DMSO and trifluralin. Comparison with similar work in males reveals no consistent pattern concerning the more appropriate sex to use for aneuploidy testing in Drosophila, as colchicine was found to be positive in females only and DMSO and trifluralin were effective in males only. Further work is necessary to validate the TX; Y test and to understand the relative efficacy of female and male exposures to aneuploidy inducing agents in Drosophila.     

Aprotic polar solvents that affect porcine brain tubulin aggregation in vitro induce aneuploidy in yeast cells growing at low temperatures

Seven aprotic polar solvents which had previously been shown to interfere with the aggregation in vitro of porcine brain tubulin have been examined for their ability to induce mitotic aneuploidy in Saccharomyces cerevisiae in relation to temperature during exposure. Induction of aneuploidy was in general considerably enhanced when incubation at 28 degrees C was interrupted by overnight storage at low temperature (cold shock). The optimum cold-shock temperatures for individual chemicals varied over a range of 0-16 degrees C. While storage at reduced temperature enhanced the effect of treatment at 28 degrees C, it was also shown that continuous incubation at reduced temperature could greatly enhance the induction of aneuploidy. Only 2 chemicals, 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidinone and gamma-valerolactone, required cold shock to yield a positive response. The other chemicals did not require cold shock for enhanced induction. The observation that the agents examined also interfere with in vitro tubulin aggregation suggests that there is a temperature component to the interaction of these agents with tubulin in vivo. This temperature component is unusual in that the most effective temperature range for aneuploidy induction can be well below the optimal growth temperature for the test organism.     

Aprotic polar solvents inducing chromosomal malsegregation in yeast interfere with the assembly of porcine brain tubulin in vitro

A number of aprotic solvents which had previously been found to induce mitotic aneuploidy in yeast were tested for their effects on re-assembly of twice recycled tubulin from pig brain. Some of the solvents which were strong aneuploidy-inducing mutagens in yeast slowed down tubulin assembly in vitro at concentrations lower than those required for aneuploidy induction. Ethyl acetate, methyl acetate, diethyl ketone and acetonitrile fell into this category. Other strong aneuploidy-inducing agents like acetone and 2-methoxyethyl acetate accelerated tubulin assembly. Non-genetically active methyl isopropyl ketone and isopropyl acetate both accelerated assembly, whereas methyl n-propyl ketone and n-propyl acetate were weak inducers of aneuploidy and slowed down the rate and extent of assembly. Those chemicals which slowed down the assembly rate also reduced the extent of assembly. Most chemicals which accelerated assembly also led to an increased extent of assembly, with the exception of isopropyl acetate. At the higher concentrations, however, a maximum assembly rate was reached which was followed by a slow decline. Although a perfect correlation between effects on the induction of chromosomal malsegregation and the interference with tubulin assembly in vitro was not seen, the experiments with tubulin were carried out using this class of chemicals because some of them strongly induced mitotic aneuploidy under conditions which suggested tubulin to be the prime target. The lack of a perfect coincidence might be due to species differences between the porcine brain and the yeast spindle tubulin, or the test for aneuploidy induction may have been negative because the concentrations required for an effect on yeast tubulin may be greater than the general lethal toxicity limit. Bearing this reservation in mind, the results suggest that the yeast aneuploidy test has a considerable predictive value for mammalian mutagenicity.     

Aneuploidy in mammalian somatic cells in vivo

Aneuploidy is an important potential source of human disease and of reproductive failure. Nevertheless, the ability of chemical agents to induce aneuploidy has been investigated only sporadically in intact (whole-animal) mammalian systems. A search of the available literature from the EMCT Aneuploidy File (for years 1970-1983) provided 112 papers that dealt with aneuploidy in mammalian somatic cells in vivo. 59 of these papers did not meet minimal criteria for analysis and were rejected from subsequent review. Of the remaining 53 papers that dealt with aneuploidy induction by chemical agents in mammalian somatic cells in vivo, only 3 (6%) contained data that were considered to be supported conclusively by adequate study designs, execution, and reporting. These 3 papers dealt with 2 chemicals, one of which, mercury, was negative for aneuploidy induction in humans, and the other, pyrimethamine, was positive in an experimental rodent study. The majority of papers (94%) were considered inconclusive for a variety of reasons. The most common reasons for calling a study inconclusive were (a) combining data on hyperploidy with those on hypoploidy and/or polyploidy, (b) an inadequate or unspecified number of animals and/or cells per animal scored per treatment group, and (c) poor data presentation such that animal-to-animal variability could not be assessed. Suggestions for protocol development are made, and the future directions of research into aneuploidy induction are discussed.     

A survey of EPA/OPP and open literature on selected pesticide chemicals. III. Mutagenicity and carcinogenicity of benomyl and carbendazim

The known aneuploidogens, benomyl and its metabolite, carbendazim (methyl 2-benzimidazole carbamate (MBC)), were selected for the third in a series of ongoing projects with selected pesticides. Mutagenicity and carcinogenicity data submitted to the US Environmental Protection Agency's (US EPA's) Office of Pesticide Programs (OPP) as part of the registration process are examined along with data from the open literature. Mutagenicity and carcinogenicity profiles are developed to provide a complete overview and to determine whether an association can be made between benomyl- and MBC-induced mouse liver tumors and aneuploidy. Since aneuploidogens are considered to indirectly affect DNA, the framework adopted by the Agency for evaluating any mode of action (MOA) for carcinogenesis is applied to the benomyl/MBC data.Both agents displayed consistent, positive results for aneuploidy induction but mostly negative results for gene mutations. Non-linear dose responses were seen both in vitro and in vivo for aneuploidy endpoints. No evidence was found suggesting that an alternative MOA other than aneuploidy may be operative. The data show that by 14 days of benomyl treatment, events associated with liver toxicity appear to set in motion the sequence of actions that leads to neoplasms. Genetic changes (as indicated by spindle impairment leading to missegregation of chromosomes, micronucleus induction and subsequent aneuploidy in bone marrow cells) can commence within 1-24h after dosing, well within the time frame for early key events. Critical steps associated with frank tumor formation in the mouse liver include hepatotoxicity, increased liver weights, cell proliferation, hypertrophy, and other steps involving hepatocellular alteration and eventual progression to neoplasms. The analysis, however, reveals weaknesses in the data base for both agents (i.e. no studies on mouse tubulin binding, no in vivo assays of aneuploidy on the target tissue (liver), and no clear data on cell proliferation relative to dose response and time dependency). The deficiencies in defining the MOA for benomyl/MBC introduce uncertainties into the analysis; consequently, benomyl/MBC induction of aneuploidy cannot be definitively linked to mouse liver carcinogenicity at this time.     

An introduction to a series of U.S. Environmental Protection Agency special committee reports on testing approaches for the detection of chemically induced aneuploidy

A committee of scientists was established by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to appraise the current state of aneuploidy test methodology, to compile and analyze published data on the chemical induction of aneuploidy, and to provide guidance for additional test development and validation. The reports that follow in this special issue of Mutation Research, document the urgent need for test method development and validation in this important area of environmental mutagenesis, and provide directions for further research.     

Characterization of an in vitro micronucleus assay with Syrian hamster embryo fibroblasts

The use of Syrian hamster embryo cells for assessing genotoxicity provides the unique opportunity to determine 5 different end-points (gene mutations, DNA-strand breaks, aneuploidy, DNA repair (unscheduled DNA synthesis, UDS) and neoplastic transformation) in the one cell system. This approach allows direct comparisons of results produced under identical conditions of dose at target, metabolism and bioavailability. We report here on the characterization of an additional end-point in the same cell system: the formation of micronuclei indicating chromosomal changes induced by chemicals. For a preliminary validation of this new test system we have investigated 14 carcinogens and 3 non-carcinogenic structural analogues in order to evaluate the significance of micronucleus induction for carcinogenic properties. All tested carcinogens induced micronuclei in a dose-dependent manner; all non-carcinogens yielded negative results. Correlations between the formation of micronuclei and the Ames test, induction of UDS, cell transformation and the in vivo bone marrow micronucleus test are demonstrated.     

Kinetochore identification in micronuclei in mouse bone-marrow erythrocytes: an assay for the detection of aneuploidy-inducing agents

An in vivo micronucleus assay using mouse bone marrow for identifying the ability of chemicals to induce aneuploidy and/or chromosome breaks is described. Micronucleus formation in bone-marrow erythrocytes of mice is commonly used as an index for evaluating the clastogenicity of environmental agents. However, micronuclei may also originate from intact lagging chromosomes resulting from the effect of aneuploidy-inducing agents. We have used immunofluorescent staining using anti-kinetochore antibodies to classify micronuclei for the presence or absence of kinetochores. Micronuclei positive for kinetochores are assumed to contain intact chromosomes and result from induced aneuploidy; while those negative for kinetochores contain acentric chromosomal fragments and originate from clastogenic events. The assay was evaluated using X-irradiation (a known clastogen) and vincristine sulfate (an aneuploidy-inducing agent). A dose-related response for the induction of micronuclei was observed for both agents. Micronuclei induced by X-irradiation were negative for kinetochores while the majority of the micronuclei resulting from vincristine treatment contained kinetochores. Thus, the micronucleus assay in combination with immunofluorescent staining for kinetochores may provide a useful method to simultaneously assess the ability of chemicals to induce aneuploidy and/or chromosome breaks.     

Simultaneous analysis of chromosome damage and aneuploidy in cytokinesis-blocked V79 Chinese hamster lung cells using an antikinetochore antibody.

A modified antikinetochore antibody technique was established in the V79 Chinese hamster lung cells to simultaneously analyze chromosome damage and aneuploidy induced by various agents. The method involved sequential treatment of slides with crest serum, fluoresceinated goat-antihuman and swine-antigoat antibodies, and propidium iodide. In this method, cytoplasm (green), nuclei or micronuclei (red), and kinetochores (yellow), are identified using the same filter setting under blue excitation (440-490 nm) with a barrier filter at 520 nm. Using this method, three agents, vinblastine (VB), X-rays, and methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) were tested for micronucleus/aneuploidy induction. An aneugen, VB and a clastogen, X-rays, induced predominantly kinetochore positive (K+) and negative (K-) micronucleated binucleate (MNBN) cells, respectively, in a dose-dependent fashion. An alkylating agent, MMS, produced both K+ and K- MNBN cells. These results are comparable with the results reported in the literature on these compounds using various methods and thus demonstrate the usefulness of this assay in distinguishing clastogenicity from aneugenicity.     

Telomerase abrogates aneuploidy‐induced telomere replication stress,senescence and cell depletion

The causal role of aneuploidy in cancer initiation remains under debate since mutations of euploidy‐controlling genes reduce cell fitness but aneuploidy strongly associates with human cancers. Telomerase activation allows immortal growth by stabilizing telomere length, but its role in aneuploidy survival has not been characterized. Here, we analyze the response of primary human cells and murine hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) to aneuploidy induction and the role of telomeres and the telomerase in this process. The study shows that aneuploidy induces replication stress at telomeres leading to telomeric DNA damage and p53 activation. This results in p53/Rb‐dependent, premature senescence of human fibroblast, and in the depletion of hematopoietic cells in telomerase‐deficient mice. Endogenous telomerase expression in HSCs and enforced expression of telomerase in human fibroblasts are sufficient to abrogate aneuploidy‐induced replication stress at telomeres and the consequent induction of premature senescence and hematopoietic cell depletion. Together, these results identify telomerase as an aneuploidy survival factor in mammalian cells based on its capacity to alleviate telomere replication stress in response to aneuploidy induction.     

The induction of aneuploidy by nitrogen mustard in a human lymphoblastoid cell line

We report that the presence of an extra Y chromosome can be used as a marker for the induction of aneuploidy (mitotic non-disjunction) in a human lymphoblastoid cell line. This endpoint is easily visualized in metaphase chromosome preparations after staining with quinacrine mustard. The induction of cells with two Y chromosomes by nitrogen mustard (NM) was examined. Exposure to 150 ng/ml nitrogen mustard induced a 6-fold increase in aneuploid frequency relative to untreated control levels; maximal induction of aneuploidy was observed 2 days after treatment. Lower concentrations of nitrogen mustard (36 and 75 ng/ml) induced smaller increases in aneuploid frequency, with maximal induction observed 1 day after treatment. This system has the potential to be used as an assay for the induction of aneuploidy in cultured human cells.     

Dimethylsulfoxide induces aneuploidy in a fungal test system

Summary Errors in chromosome segregation leading to numerical anomalies appear to be unusually frequent in Man and consequently a large proportion of conceptions in our species are aneuploid. Concer has been expressed that this frequency may be increased still further following exposure to inducing substances (trisomigens) present in the environment. We have been developing a fungal test system to screen for such trisomigens and in this paper we report its use in detecting induction following exposure to dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO). In our system DMSO induces segregational errors at both the first and second meiotic division. The results also show that increases in aneuploidy are proportional to the underlying spontaneous frequency. If this finding is generally true it will be especially important to avoid exposure to trisomigens as Man might be especially vulnerable to them.     

Simultaneous evaluation of clastogenicity, aneugenicity and toxicity in the mouse micronucleus assay using immunofluorescence.

An improved antikinetochore antibody technique was established in the mouse micronucleus assay to simultaneously evaluate toxicity, clastogenicity and aneugenicity induced by various test agents. The procedure involved the use of cellulose column fractionated cytospun slides for analysis. The staining method consisted of sequential treatment of slides with crest serum, fluorosceinated goat-antihuman and swine-antigoat antibodies, and propidium iodide. In this method, polychromatic erythrocytes (PCEs, dark red), normochromatic erythrocytes (NCEs, green), chromosome(s)/fragments/micronuclei (orange), and kinetochores (yellow), are identified using the same filter setting under blue excitation (440-490 nm) with a barrier filter at 520 nm. Using this method, three agents, cyclophosphamide, X-rays and vincristine were tested for micronucleus/aneuploidy induction and bone marrow toxicity. The aneugen, vincristine, and clastogens, X-rays and cyclophosphamide, induced predominantly kinetochore positive (K+) and negative (K-) micronucleated PCEs, respectively. At the doses tested, cyclophosphamide caused a slight but statistically significant decrease in PCEs in females, and other agents did not produce any severe bone-marrow toxicity in either male or female mice. These results are comparable with the results reported in the literature on these compounds with various methods and thus demonstrate the usefulness of this assay in distinguishing clastogenicity from aneugenicity and in evaluating toxicity.     

Mouse genetic models for aneuploidy induction in germ cells

Rodents have been successfully used as models to identify risks of chemical exposures or age to aneuploidy induction in germ cells, which may be transmitted to the progeny. For this administration in vivo as well as exposures to in vitro maturing germ cells have been useful. Genetic models involving mice with structural chromosomal rearrangements and transgenic animals have the potential to model conditions predisposing to aneuploidy in one or both sexes, and in this way to identify potential targets for aneugens and gender-effects. The review provides an overview of mouse genetic models for aneuploidy induction in mammalian germ cells and discusses perspectives for combining genetic with experimental approaches in aneuploidy research.     

Acetone, methyl ethyl ketone, ethyl acetate, acetonitrile and other polar aprotic solvents are strong inducers of aneuploidy in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

A diploid yeast strain D61.M was used to study induction of mitotic chromosomal malsegregation, mitotic recombination and point mutation. Several ketones (including acetone and methyl ethyl ketone) and some organic acid esters (including the methyl, ethyl and 2-methoxyethyl esters of acetic acid) and acetonitrile strongly induced aneuploidy but not recombination or point mutation. Only diethyl ketone induced low levels of recombination and point mutation in addition to aneuploidy. Related compounds were weak inducers of aneuploidy: methyl n-propyl ketone, the methyl esters of propionic and butyric acid, acetic acid esters of n- and iso-propanol and ethyl propionate. No mutagenicity was found with n-butyl and isoamyl acetate, ethyl formate, acetyl acetone (2,5-dipentanone) and dioxane. Methyl isopropyl ketone induced only some recombination and point mutation but no aneuploidy. Efficient induction was only observed with a treatment protocol in which growing cells were exposed to the chemicals during a growth period of 4 h at 28 degrees C followed by incubation in ice for more than 90 min, usually overnight for 16-17 h. Aneuploid cells could be detected in such cultures during a subsequent incubation at growth temperature if the chemical was still present. Detailed analysis showed that there was a high incidence of multiple events of chromosomal malsegregation. It is proposed that the mutagenic agents act directly on tubulin during growth so that labile microtubules are formed which dissociate in the cold. When cells are brought back to temperatures above the level critical for reassembly of tubulin and allowed to grow, faulty microtubules are formed.     

The detection of mitotic and meiotic chromosome gain in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae: effects of methyl benzimidazol-2-yl carbamate, methyl methanesulfonate, ethyl methanesulfonate, dimethyl sulfoxide, propionitrile and cyclophosphamide monohydrate

The diploid yeast strain BR1669 was used to study induction of mitotic and meiotic chromosome gain by selected chemical agents. The test relies on a gene dosage selection system in which hyperploidy is detected by the simultaneous increase in copy number of two alleles residing on the right arm of chromosome VIII: arg4-8 and cup1S (Rockmill and Fogel. 1988; Whittaker et al., 1988). Methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) induced mitotic, but not meiotic, chromosome gain. Methyl benzimidazol-2-yl carbamate (MBC) and ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) induced both mitotic and meiotic chromosome gain. Propionitrile, a polar aprotic solvent, induced only mitotic chromosome gain; a reliable response was only achieved by overnight incubation of treated cultures at 0 degrees C. MBC is postulated to act by binding directly to tubulin. The requirement for low-temperature incubation suggests that propionitrile also induces aneuploidy by perturbation of microtubular dynamics. The alkylating agents MMS and EMS probably induce recombination which might in turn perturb chromosome segregation. Cyclophosphamide monohydrate and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) failed to induce mitotic or meiotic chromosome gain.     

The genetic toxicology of putative nongenotoxic carcinogens

This report examines a group of putative nongenotoxic carcinogens that have been cited in the published literature. Using short-term test data from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency/International Agency for Research on Cancer genetic activity profile (EPA/IARC GAP) database we have classified these agents on the basis of their mutagenicity emphasizing three genetic endpoints: gene mutation, chromosomal aberration and aneuploidy. On the basis of results of short-term tests for these effects, we have defined criteria for evidence of mutagenicity (and nonmutagenicity) and have applied these criteria in classifying the group of putative nongenotoxic carcinogens. The results from this evaluation based on the EPA/IARC GAP database are presented along with a summary of the short-term test data for each chemical and the relevant carcinogenicity results from the NTP, Gene-Tox and IARC databases. The data clearly demonstrate that many of the putative nongenotoxic carcinogens that have been adequately tested in short-term bioassays induce gene or chromosomal mutations or aneuploidy.     

A genetic assay for the detection of aneuploidy in the germ-line cells of Drosophila melanogaster

A 2-generation assay is described for the detection of aneuploidy in the germ-line cells of Drosophila melanogaster. Larvae and adult females that carry marker mutations are exposed to test compounds, and the F2 generation is scored for exceptional phenotypes. As a consequence of nondisjunction and/or loss of the sex chromosomes, 5 exceptional phenotypes appear. These phenotypes are often indicative of specific types of nondisjunction. Based on the time course and the pattern of exception production of the treated parents, aneuploidy due to meiotic and mitotic defects can be separated. The genetic analysis of the exceptions reveals whether nondisjunction has occurred due to failure of the spindle fibres to disjoin chromosomes or attachment of the chromosomes. The described assay is an extension of the so-called Somatic Mutation and Recombination Test (SMART) and allows screening for different genetic endpoints: aneuploidy, recombinogenic and mutagenic activities in the same treatment. The effects of colchicine and EMS are described with respect to the induction of aneuploidy in the germ line and somatic mutation and recombination in the eyes, wings and female germ-line cells. Colchicine induces aneuploidy in the germ-line cells while the frequency of mosaic spots does not increase after colchicine treatment. This result suggests that aneuploidy plays little (if any) role in the formation of mosaic spots. Colchicine induces nondisjunction in the mitotically rather than in the meiotically dividing germ-line cells. EMS, as expected, induces high frequency of somatic mutation and recombination but not aneuploidy in the female germ line.