A novel role for autophagy in T cell education

During T cell development in the thymus, scanning of peptide/major histocompatibility (MHC) molecule complexes on the surface of thymic epithelial cells ensures that only useful (self-MHC restricted) and harmless (self-tolerant) thymocytes survive. In recent years, a number of distinct cell-biological features of thymic epithelial cells have been unraveled that may have evolved to render these cells particularly suited for T cell selection, e.g., cortical epithelial cells use unique proteolytic enzymes for the generation of MHC/peptide complexes, whereas medullary epithelial cells "promiscuously" express otherwise tissue-restricted self-antigens. We recently showed that macroautophagy in thymic epithelial cells contributes to CD4 T cell selection and is essential for the generation of a self-tolerant T cell repertoire. We propose that the unusually high constitutive levels of autophagy in thymic epithelial cells deliver endogenous proteins to MHC class II molecules for both positive and negative selection of developing thymocytes.     

Lymphocyte depletion in thymic nurse cells: a tool to identify in situ lympho-epithelial complexes having thymic nurse cell characteristics

Summary In situ pre-existing complexes of epithelial cells and thymocytes having thymic nurse cell characteristics were visualized in the murine thymus cortex using dexamethasone as a potent killer of cortisone-sensitive thymocytes. The degradation and subsequent depletion of cortisone-sensitive thymocytes enclosed within cortical epithelial cells appeared to be paralleled by thymocyte degradation and depletion in thymic nurse cells isolated from thymic tissue fragments from dexamethasone-treated animals. This suggests that thymic nurse cells are derived from pre-existing sealed complexes of cortical epithelial cells and thymocytes. Not all thymocytes situated within in situ epithelial or thymic nurse cells complexes appear to be cortisone-sensitive: a minority of 1–2 thymocytes per complex survives the dexamethasone-treatment, thus constituting a minor subset of cortical cortisone-resistant thymocytes predominantly localized within cortical epithelial cells in situ and within thymic nurse cells derived from such structures. Cortisone resistance in thymocytes thus seems to be acquired within the cortical epithelial cell microenvironment. Cortisone-resistant thymocytes in thymic nurse cells express the phenotype of mature precursors of the T helper lineage, indicating that the in situ correlates of thymic nurse cells may play an important role in T cell maturation and selection.     

Total lymphoid irradiation leads to transient depletion of the mouse thymic medulla and persistent abnormalities among medullary stromal cells

Mice given multiple doses of sublethal irradiation to both the thymus and the peripheral lymphoid tissues showed major transient, and some persistent disruptions in general thymic architecture and in thymic stromal components. At 2 wk after total lymphoid irradiation (TLI), the thymus lacked identifiable medullary regions by immunohistochemical analyses. Medullary stromal cells expression MHC Ag or a medullary epithelial cell Ag, as well as medullary macrophages, were undetectable. Instead, the processes of cortical epithelial cells were observed throughout the entire thymus. Strikingly, thymocyte subsets with mature phenotypes (CD4+CD8- and CD4-CD8+) were present in the apparent absence of a medulla. This early, gross effect was rapidly reversed such that by 1 to 2 mo after TLI, medullary areas with MHC Ag-positive cells were evident. However, abnormalities in a subset of medullary stromal cells appeared to be more persistent. Medullary epithelial cells, identified by the MD1 mAb, were greatly reduced in number and abnormally organized for at least 4 mo after TLI. In addition, macrophages containing endogenous peroxidase activity, normally abundant in medullary regions, were undetectable at all times examined after TLI. Therefore, this irradiation regimen induced both transient and long term effects in the thymus, primarily in medullary regions. These results suggest that TLI may be used as an experimental tool for studying the impact of selective depletion of medullary stromal cells on the development of specific T cell functions.     

Early events in T lymphocyte genesis in the fetal thymus

There is considerable uncertainty about the nature and level of maturation of the stem cells which colonize the thymus. Arguments are presented here which raise doubts about the claims that these cells have undergone substantial maturation along the T-lineage pathway prior to migration to the thymus. Instead, emphasis is placed on the role of thymic stromal cells in T-lymphocyte maturation. The heterogeneous nature of these cells is well established, but progress is described in analyzing the various cell types and their embryological origins. In particular, the expression of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens on thymic stromal cells might be relevant to the understanding of restriction and tolerance. The early phases of thymus lymphocyte differentiation are described; but no clear account of the generation of T-cell subsets from immature cells can, as yet, be offered.     

Unilateral T cell maturation arrest in the thymus of CBA/H mice as a long-term effect after neutron irradiation

Thymuses of CBA/H mice were investigated up to 570 days after whole-body irradiation with 2.5 Gy fast fission neutrons or 6.0 Gy X rays. A number of these thymuses, observed 220-270 days after neutron irradiation, have two equal sized lobes, one of which has an abnormal T cell distribution. The present paper reports on the distribution of lymphoid and stromal cell types in these thymuses. For this purpose, we employed immunohistology using the indirect immunoperoxidase method. We incubated frozen sections of these aberrant thymuses with monoclonal antibodies directed to cell surface differentiation antigens on lymphoid cells, such as Thy-1, T-200, MT-4, Lyt-1, Lyt-2, and MEL-14; monoclonal antibodies directed to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens, such as I-A and H-2K; and monoclonal antibodies directed to determinants in various thymic stromal cell types. The results of this study show a T cell differentiation arrest in only one of the two thymic lobes. T cells in the aberrant lobe express Thy-1, T-200, and MEL-14 antigens but are MT-4- and Lyt-1-. In some lobes, a weak Lyt-2 expression was observed. The observed T cell maturation arrest is mainly restricted to the cortex since in the medulla, in addition to cells with an aberrant cortical phenotype, normal T cell phenotypes are observed. This indicates that cortex and medulla have independent generation kinetics in T cell maturation. The stromal cell composition in these abnormal lobes is not different from that in the normal lobe, but the size of the medulla tends to be smaller. Furthermore, the I-A expression on the cortical epithelial cells does not reveal the characteristic reticular staining pattern that is observed in the normal lobe, since the I-A determinants are not strictly confined to the epithelial cells. In addition, cortical lymphoid and stromal cells in these lobes are slightly H-2K+. These alterations in MHC expression in the cortex are discussed in relation to the observed T cell maturation arrest.     

TSCOT+ thymic epithelial cell-mediated sensitive CD4 tolerance by direct presentation

Although much effort has been directed at dissecting the mechanisms of central tolerance, the role of thymic stromal cells remains elusive. In order to further characterize this event, we developed a mouse model restricting LacZ to thymic stromal cotransporter (TSCOT)-expressing thymic stromal cells (TDLacZ). The thymus of this mouse contains approximately 4,300 TSCOT+ cells, each expressing several thousand molecules of the LacZ antigen. TSCOT+ cells express the cortical marker CDR1, CD40, CD80, CD54, and major histocompatibility complex class II (MHCII). When examining endogenous responses directed against LacZ, we observed significant tolerance. This was evidenced in a diverse T cell repertoire as measured by both a CD4 T cell proliferation assay and an antigen-specific antibody isotype analysis. This tolerance process was at least partially independent of Autoimmune Regulatory Element gene expression. When TDLacZ mice were crossed to a novel CD4 T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic reactive against LacZ (BgII), there was a complete deletion of double-positive thymocytes. Fetal thymic reaggregate culture of CD45- and UEA-depleted thymic stromal cells from TDLacZ and sorted TCR-bearing thymocytes excluded the possibility of cross presentation by thymic dendritic cells and medullary epithelial cells for the deletion. Overall, these results demonstrate that the introduction of a neoantigen into TSCOT-expressing cells can efficiently establish complete tolerance and suggest a possible application for the deletion of antigen-specific T cells by antigen introduction into TSCOT+ cells.     

Establishment of a mouse thymic epithelial cell line, IT-76MHC and a brief review on cultured thymic epithelial cells.

Interactions between thymocytes and thymic stromal cells are essential for thymocyte differentiation, but little evidence has been presented to directly show in vivo functions or interactions of the stromal cells. Among the stromal cells, the thymic epithelial cell has been considered to have profound effect on thymocyte differentiation and maturation. The calcium-depleted medium, originally developed for the culture of mouse epidermal cells, was applied for the culture of the mouse thymic epithelial cells, and successfully, an epithelial cell line, IT-76MHC was obtained from the mouse thymus. IT-76MHC cells were identified as distinct mouse thymic epithelial cells by 1/ mosaic-like arrangement, 2/ presence of well-developed desmosome and 3/ tonofilaments, 4/ positivity for cytokeratin, and 5/ induced expression of MHC class I and II by IFN-gamma treatment. IGF-1, IGF-2, oxytocin and vasopressin were also detected immunohistochemically in IT-76MHC cells. Furthermore, the IT-76MHC thymic epithelial cells, when injected intrathymically in the allogeneic mouse, prolonged the survival of skin graft from the same donor strain that IT-76MHC cells were derived. These results demonstrate that the thymic epithelial cell line IT-76MHC produces modest thymocyte survival factors as well as a growth suppressor, and that IT-76MHC cells have the ability to induce transplantation tolerance probably through their expression of MHC class I and II molecules. Taken altogether, the IT-76MHC thymic epithelial cells have been proved to be useful tools to better understand the in vivo functions of thymic epithelial cells, and to gain a deep insight into their involvement in the critical selection process of thymocytes which still remains obscure. Finally and additionally, literatures so far reported on thymic epithelial cells in culture, especially lines and clones, are reviewed and their identity as well as their functions are discussed.     

Positive selection of the T cell repertoire: where and when does it occur?

The T cell repertoire is shaped by both positive and negative influences. T lymphocytes that express the V beta 6 variable region are positively selected in the thymus by cells expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II E molecules. To identify these cells, we have quantitated V beta 6+ T lymphocytes in a set of transgenic mice showing variant patterns of E expression in the thymus. We demonstrate that class II molecules must be expressed on epithelial cells of the cortex for positive selection to occur. Using a direct assay of unmanipulated thymocytes, we show that positive selection is manifest only as a rather late event in thymocyte differentiation, after the maturation of cortical double-positives into single-positives.     

Differentiation of an immature T cell line: a model of thymic positive selection.

Thymocyte differentiation is dependent upon recognition of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules on thymic stroma, a process called positive selection. Here we describe an immature CD4+8+ T cell line derived from a TCR transgenic mouse that differentiates into CD4+8- cells in response to antigen and nonthymic antigen-presenting cells. When injected intrathymically, these cells differentiate in the absence of antigen. The ability of immature T cells to recognize MHC molecules in the absence of foreign antigen in the thymus can thus be attributed to a unique property of thymic antigen-presenting cells. These studies also demonstrate the phenotypic and functional changes associated with TCR-mediated T cell maturation and establish an in vitro model system of positive selection.     

Phenotypic and functional characterization of human thymic stromal cell lines.

To establish new tools for studying human thymic stromal cells, we transfected adherent cells from a human postnatal thymus using a plasmid encoding SV40 large T antigen. Among the cell lines obtained, we characterized four epithelial cell lines (LT-TEC1 to LT-TEC4) and one thymic myoid cell line (MITC). Several morphological, functional and phenotypic differences were observed between these 2 cell types. Epithelial cells were heterogeneous and larger than myoid cells. Untreated LT-TEC lines expressed MHC class I, ICAM-1 and LFA-3 antigens and not MHC class II antigens, similarly to primary thymic epithelial cells (PTEC), while MITC line expressed only class I and LFA-3 antigens. After IFN-gamma treatment, MHC class II and ICAM-1 antigens were markedly upregulated in LT-TEC lines but not in MITC, indicating the absence or a dysfunction of regulatory factors in MITC line. Myoid cells expressed mRNA for all the subunits of the acetylcholine receptor (AChR) while epithelial cells expressed only the alpha, beta and epsilon subunits. Strikingly, LT-TEC produced much more C-C chemokines and IL-6 than MITC cells, while these latter produced higher levels of IL-8 and TNF-alpha. Altogether, these results reveal phenotypic and functional differences between these two stromal cell types, suggesting a potential involvement of myoid cells in the thymic function.     

Immunohistochemical characterization of the thymic microenvironment

Summary The epithelial framework of the human thymus has been studied in parallel by immunohistochemical methods at the light- and electron-microscopic levels. Different monoclonal antibodies were used, reacting with components of the major histocompatibility complex, keratins, thymic hormones and other as yet antigenically undefined substances, which show specific immunoreactivities with human thymus epithelial cells.The electron-microscopic immunocytochemical observations clearly confirm microtopographical differences of epithelial cells not only between the thymic cortex and medulla, but also within the cortex itself. At least four subtypes of epithelial cells could be distinguished: 1) the cortical surface epithelium; 2) the main cortical epithelial cells and thymic nurse cells; 3) the medullary epithelial cells; and 4) the epithelial cells of Hassall's corpuscles.The various epithelial cell types of the thymus display several common features like tonofilaments, desmosomes and some surface antigens as demonstrated by anti-KiM3. In other respects, however, they differ from each other. The cortical subtype of thymic epithelial cells including the thymic nurse cells shows a distinct pattern of surface antigens reacting positively with antibodies against HLA-DR (anti-HLA-DR) and anti-21A62E. Electron-microscopic immunocytochemistry with these antibodies clearly reveals a surface labeling and a narrow contact to cortical thymocytes particularly in the peripheral cortical regions. An alternative staining pattern is realized by antibodies to some antigens associated with other subtypes of thymic epithelial cells. Medullary epithelial cells as well as the cortical surface epithelium react likewise positively with antibodies to special surface antigens (anti-Ep-1), to special epitopes of cytokeratin (anti-IV/82), and to thymic hormones (anti-FTS). The functional significance of distinct microenvironments within the thymus provided by different epithelial cells is discussed in view of the maturation of T-precursor cells.Glossary of Abbreviations Anti-X anti-X antibody - APUD-cells amine precursor uptake and decarboxylation (gastro-intestinal endocrine cells) - DAB diamino-benzidine - DMSO dimethyl sulfoxide - FTS facteur thymique sérique - HLA-A, B, C human leucocyte antigen, A, B, C-region related - HLA-DR human leucocyte antigen, D-region related - IDC interdigitating cell - MHC major histocompatibility gene complex - PBS phosphate-buffered saline - TNC thymic nurse cell This investigation was supported by grants from the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, and its Sonderforschungsbereich 111Fellow of the Alexander von Humbold-Stiftung, Institute of Pathology, University of Würzburg, Federal Republic of GermanyThe authors appreciate the contribution of human thymus tissue from Professor Alexander Bernhard, Abteilung kardiovasculäre Chirurgie der Universität Kiel; the gift of monoclonal antibodies from Dr. M.J.D. Anderson, Dr. M. Dardenne and Dr. H.J. Radzun; and the excellent technical assistence of Mrs. O.M. Bracker, Mrs. H. Hansen, Mrs. R. Köpke, Mrs. M. v. Kolszynski, Mrs. J. Quitzau, Mrs. H. Siebke, and Mrs. H. Waluk     

A putative 12 transmembrane domain cotransporter expressed in thymic cortical epithelial cells

We have isolated a full-length cDNA clone (thymic stromal origin (TSO)-1C12) from a SCID thymus library using a probe from a PCR-based subtractive library enriched for sequences from fetal thymic stromal cells. TSO-1C12 mRNA is expressed mainly in the thymic cortex and is highly enriched in SCID thymus. Expression per cell is highest during fetal thymus development and decreases after day 16. Antipeptide Abs immunoprecipitated a hydrophobic, plasma membrane glycoprotein (thymic stromal cotransporter, TSCOT) whose translated sequence has weak homology to bacterial antiporters and mammalian cation cotransporters with 12 transmembrane domains. TSCOT represents a new member of this superfamily that is highly expressed in thymic cortical epithelial cells.     

Repopulation of the mouse thymus after sublethal fission neutron irradiation. II. Sequential changes in the thymic microenvironment

The stromal cells of the thymus of sham-irradiated and sublethal fission neutron-irradiated CBA/H mice were analyzed with immunohistology, using monoclonal antibodies directed to I-A and H-2K antigens as well as specific determinants for cortical and medullary stromal elements. In the control thymuses, I-A expression in the thymus shows a reticular staining pattern in the cortex and a confluent staining pattern in the medulla. In contrast, H-2K expression is mainly confluently located in the medulla. Whole body irradiation with 2.5 Gy fission neutrons reduces within 24 hr the cortex to a rim of vacuolized "nurse cell-like" epithelial cells, largely depleted of lymphoid cells. The localization of I-A antigens changes in the cortex and I-A determinants are no longer associated with or localized on epithelial reticular cells. Medullary stromal cells, however, are more or less unaffected. A high rate of phagocytosis is observed during the first 3 days after irradiation. About 5 days after irradiation, the thymus becomes highly vascularized and lymphoid cells repopulate the cortex. The repopulation of the thymic cortex coincides with the appearance of a bright H-2K expression in the cortex which is associated with both stromal cells as well as lymphoid blasts. During the regeneration of the thymus, the thymic stromal architecture is restored before the expression of cell surface-associated reticular MHC staining patterns. The observed sequential changes in the thymic microenvironment are related to the lymphoid repopulation of the thymus.     

Immunohistology of thymic nurse cells

The demonstration of thymic nurse cells (TNC), complexes between stromal cells and thymocytes, in cell suspensions of murine thymuses, prompted us to investigate (1) the relationship of TNC to other thymic stromal cell types defined in situ, and (2) the maturation stage of the enclosed thymocytes. To this purpose we incubated frozen sections of TNC suspensions with various monoclonal antisera directed to T cells and stromal cell types, using immunohistology. This approach enabled us to study antigen expression on the "nursing" cell itself and to analyze the phenotype of the enclosed lymphocytes in cross sections of TNC. The results show that lymphocytes enveloped by TNC express high levels of Thy-1, moderate levels of T200, and variable amounts of Lyt-1. Due to enzymatic degradation Lyt-2 expression could not be studied. The enveloped cells also bear PNA receptors, but no detectable I-A/E antigens. Expression of H-2K antigens on enclosed thymocytes varied from weak to absent. The "nursing" cells react with ER-TR4, a monoclonal antibody which detects cortical epithelial-reticular cells. In addition TNC express I-A/E and H-2K antigens. In contrast, TNC do not react with ER-TR 5 and 7, monoclonal antibodies, which detect medullary epithelial cells and reticular fibroblasts, respectively. TNC do not express the macrophage antigens Mac-1 and Mac-2. We conclude that TNC in vitro represent the in vivo association of epithelial-reticular cells with cortical thymocytes. However, the enclosed thymocytes do not constitute a phenotypically distinct subset of subcapsular or outer cortical cells.     

Antigen presenting ability of thymic macrophages and epithelial cells: evidence for defects in the antigen processing function of thymic epithelial cells

We compared the antigen presenting ability of cloned thymic macrophage and epithelial cell lines using T cell hybridomas with well-characterized activation requirements. A cloned thymic epithelial cell line (3D.1), preinduced with interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) activated the T cell hybridoma 3DO-18.3 but not the T cell hybridoma DO-11.10. Analyses using preprocessed antigen suggest that the failure of 3D.1 to activate DO-11.10 is due to its inability to process chicken ovalbumin to produce a peptide recognized by the Ag:MHC T cell receptor of DO-11.10. The epithelial cell line 3D.1 was able to activate DO-11.10 if the superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B was used for activation instead of ovalbumin. These observations indicate that IFN-gamma-induced 3D.1 expresses sufficient I-Ad molecules to activate DO-11.10 but is unable to produce the peptide of ovalbumin recognized by DO-11.10. Furthermore, 3D.1 appears to be representative of nonmacrophage thymic stromal cells cultured in vitro, since heterogeneous cultures containing epithelial cells exhibited the same selective T cell activation characteristics. In contrast, thymic macrophage cell lines activated all T cells studied. These results suggest that there is a functional difference between the capacity of thymic epithelial cells and macrophages to process and present antigen to T cells.     

Reaggregate Thymus Cultures

In the thymus, immature CD4+8+ thymocytes expressing randomly rearranged T-cell receptor α- and b-chain genes undergo positive and negative selection events based on their ability to recognize self-peptide/major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules expressed by thymic stromal cells. In vivo analysis of the role of thymic stromal cells during intrathymic selection is made difficult by the cellular complexity of the thymic microenvironment in the steady-state adult thymus, and by the lack of appropriate targeting strategies to manipulate gene expression in particular thymic stromal compartments. We have shown that the thymic microenvironment can be readily manipulated in vitro through the use of reaggregate thymus organ cultures, which allow the preparation of three-dimensional thymus lobes from defined stromal and lymphoid cells. Although other in vitro systems support some aspects of T-cell development, reaggregate thymus organ culture remains the only in vitro system able to support efficient MHC class I and II-mediated thymocyte selection events, and so can be used as an effective tool to study the cellular and molecular regulation of positive and negative selection in the thymus.Download video file.^{(67M, mp4)}     

Preparation of 2-dGuo-Treated Thymus Organ Cultures

In the thymus, immature CD4+8+ thymocytes expressing randomly rearranged T-cell receptor α- and b-chain genes undergo positive and negative selection events based on their ability to recognize self-peptide/major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules expressed by thymic stromal cells. In vivo analysis of the role of thymic stromal cells during intrathymic selection is made difficult by the cellular complexity of the thymic microenvironment in the steady-state adult thymus, and by the lack of appropriate targeting strategies to manipulate gene expression in particular thymic stromal compartments. We have shown that the thymic microenvironment can be readily manipulated in vitro through the use of reaggregate thymus organ cultures, which allow the preparation of three-dimensional thymus lobes from defined stromal and lymphoid cells. Although other in vitro systems support some aspects of T-cell development, reaggregate thymus organ culture remains the only in vitro system able to support efficient MHC class I and II-mediated thymocyte selection events, and so can be used as an effective tool to study the cellular and molecular regulation of positive and negative selection in the thymus.Download video file.^{(93M, mp4)}