Unstable proteins: how to subject them to chromatographic separations for purification procedures

The chromatographic separation of an unstable protein is often a challenge to the scientist working in the field of life sciences. Especially for the purification of sensitive enzymes, making use of conventional chromatographic techniques is difficult and frequently results in a complete loss of biological activity of the target protein. This report summarizes some general strategies that may help to keep unstable proteins in their native conformation during the rather harsh conditions of a purification procedure. In this context, a recently developed hollow fiber membrane module, suitable for performing on-line dialysis, is introduced and examples of its application to liquid column chromatography are given. Many innovative separation techniques, characterized by dramatic improvements in both performance and separation time, have recently been developed. Since the chromatographic separation of unstable proteins requires the use of modern state-of-the-art equipment and technology, emphasis is given to newly developed separation techniques such as expanded bed adsorption, perfusion chromatography, protein free flow electrophoresis and the use of tentacle gels. In addition, examples of recently published purifications of unstable proteins are discussed with respect to strategies ensuring the preservation of the native protein structure during chromatographic separation.     

Purification of recombinant human growth hormone from CHO cell culture supernatant by Gradiflow preparative electrophoresis technology

Purification of recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell culture supernatant by Gradiflow large-scale electrophoresis is described. Production of rhGH in CHO cells is an alternative to production in Escherichia coli, with the advantage that rhGH is secreted into protein-free production media, facilitating a more simple purification and avoiding resolubilization of inclusion bodies and protein refolding. As an alternative to conventional chromatography, rhGH was purified in a one-step procedure using Gradiflow technology. Clarified culture supernatant containing rhGH was passed through a Gradiflow BF200 and separations were performed over 60 min using three different buffers of varying pH. Using a 50 mM Tris/Hepes buffer at pH 7.5 together with a 50 kDa separation membrane, rhGH was purified to approximately 98% purity with a yield of 90%. This study demonstrates the ability of Gradiflow preparative electrophoresis technology to purify rhGH from mammalian cell culture supernatant in a one-step process with high purity and yield. As the Gradiflow is directly scalable, this study also illustrates the potential for the inclusion of the Gradiflow into bioprocesses for the production of clinical grade rhGH and other therapeutic proteins.     

High-resolution Native-PAGE for membrane proteins capable of fluorescence detection and hydrodynamic state evaluation

An improved native polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) method capable of evaluating the hydrodynamic states of membrane proteins and allowing in-gel fluorescence detection was established. In this method, bis(alkyl) sulfosuccinate is used to provide negative charges for detergent-solubilized membrane proteins to facilitate proper electrophoretic migration without disturbing their native hydrodynamic states. The method achieved high-resolution electrophoretic separation, in good agreement with the elution profiles obtained by size exclusion chromatography. The applicability of in-gel fluorescence detection for tagged green fluorescent protein (GFP) facilitates the analysis of samples without any purification. This method might serve as a general analytical technique for assessing the folding, oligomerization, and protein complex formation of membrane proteins.     

Native electrophoretic techniques to identify protein–protein interactions

Permanent protein–protein interactions are commonly identified by co‐purification of two or more protein components using techniques like co‐immunoprecipitation, tandem affinity purification and native electrophoresis. Here we focus on blue‐native electrophoresis, clear‐native electrophoresis, high‐resolution clear‐native electrophoresis and associated techniques to identify stable membrane protein complexes and detergent‐labile physiological supercomplexes. Hints for dynamic protein–protein interactions can be obtained using two‐hybrid techniques but not from native electrophoresis and other protein isolation techniques except after covalent cross‐linking of interacting proteins in vivo prior to protein separation.     

Single step recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) purification from milk by peptide affinity chromatography

Recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) is used for the treatment of several pathologies, most of them related to growth. Although different expression systems can be used for its production, the milk from transgenic cows is one of the most interesting due to the high rhGH level achieved (5 g/L). We have designed and synthesized short peptides (9 or 10 amino acid long) using Fmoc chemistry and studied their ability to purify rhGH from milk once immobilized on an agarose support. Using spiked milk with the hormone as a sample, rhGH was purified with 88% yield and 92% purity in a single step with a fold purification of 4.5. © 2018 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 34:999–1005, 2018     

Microencapsulation of human growth hormone within biodegradable polyester microspheres: protein aggregation stability and incomplete release mechanism.

Recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) was encapsulated within poly(D,L-lactic-co-glycolic acid) microspheres by a double emulsion solvent evaporation method. A mixture of methylene chloride and ethyl acetate in varying volume ratios was used for the microsphere preparation. Protein release profiles from three different microsphere formulations demonstrated initial burst effects ranging from 28.2% to 54.7% after a 1-day incubation and exhibited no further significant releases up to 19 days. This was because the encapsulated rhGH with the microspheres was largely aggregated in a noncovalent fashion during the formulation. Nonaggregated water soluble rhGH species within the microspheres are likely to be responsible for the rapid release upon incubation. The initially released rhGH in the incubation medium, however, was composed of mostly monomer species with a small amount of dimer as probed by size-exclusion chromatography. Circular dichroism spectra of the initially released rhGH in the medium revealed that the conformation of the released rhGH was correctly folded relative to that of native rhGH, with little variation in alpha-helix contents depending on the formulations. The "nonrelease" mechanism after the initial burst release was attributed to nonspontaneously dissociable noncovalent protein aggregation and surface adsorption of rhGH present within the microspheres.     

Intermediates in the refolding of reduced ribonuclease A.

The intermediates with one, two, three or four disulphide bonds which accumulate during unfolding of native ribonuclease and refolding of the reduced protein have been trapped by rapid alkylation with iodoacetate and separated by ionexchange chromatography. They have been characterized to varying extents by their enzymic activity, electrophoretic mobility through polyacrylamide gels, disulphide bonds between cysteine residues, the environments of the six tyrosine residues as indicated by ultraviolet absorption and fluorescence spectra, interaction with antibodies directed against either the trapped unfolded reduced protein or the native folded protein, and for the disruption by urea of any stable conformation producing a change in molecular shape.Correctly refolded ribonuclease was indistinguishable from the original native protein, but virtually all the intermediates with up to four disulphide bonds formed directly from the reduced protein were enzymically inactive and unfolded by these criteria. Unfolding of native ribonuclease was an all-or-none transition to the fully reduced protein, with no accumulation of disulphide intermediates. The intermediates in refolding are separated from the fully folded state by the highest energy barrier in the folding transition; they may be considered rapidly interconvertible, relatively unstable microstates of the unfolded protein. The measured elements of the final conformation are not acquired during formation of the first three disulphide bonds, but appear simultaneously with formation of the fourth native disulphide bond.These observations with ribonuclease are qualitatively similar to those made previously in greater detail with pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and suggest a possible general pattern for the kinetic process of protein unfolding and refolding.     

Phi-values for BPTI folding intermediates and implications for transition state analysis

Amino acid replacements were used to probe the roles of 14 sites in two well-characterized intermediates in the folding pathway of bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI). One of these intermediates contains one of the three disulfides found in the native protein (30--51). NMR studies have shown that approximately two-thirds of this polypeptide has a native-like conformation. The other intermediate contains two native disulfides (30--51 and 5--55) and has a fully folded conformation. The phi-values for a majority of residues were <1, indicating that the native protein was significantly more destabilized than either intermediate even when the altered residue was located in a well-ordered region of the intermediate. These observations suggest that folding intermediates and transition states may generally be more structured than indicated by phi-values alone.     

Refolding processes of cytochrome P450cam from ferric and ferrous acid forms to the native conformation. Formations of folding intermediates with non-native heme coordination state

Changes in heme coordination state and protein conformation of cytochrome P450(cam) (P450(cam)), a b-type heme protein, were investigated by employing pH jump experiments coupled with time-resolved optical absorption, fluorescence, circular dichroism, and resonance Raman techniques. We found a partially unfolded form (acid form) of ferric P450(cam) at pH 2.5, in which a Cys(-)-heme coordination bond in the native conformation was ruptured. When the pH was raised to pH 7.5, the acid form refolded to the native conformation through a distinctive intermediate. Formations of similar acid and intermediate forms were also observed for ferrous P450(cam). Both the ferric and ferrous forms of the intermediate were found to have an unidentified axial ligand of the heme at the 6th coordination sphere, which is vacant in the high spin ferric and ferrous forms at the native conformation. For the ferrous form, it was also indicated that the 5th axial ligand is different from the native cysteinate. The folding intermediates identified in this study demonstrate occurrences of non-native coordination state of heme during the refolding processes of the large b-type heme protein, being akin to the well known folding intermediates of cytochromes c, in which c-type heme is covalently attached to a smaller protein.     

Conformation and stability of thiol-modified bovine beta-lactoglobulin

Bovine beta-lactoglobulin A assumes a dimeric native conformation at neutral pH, while the conformation at pH 2 is monomeric but still native. Beta-lactoglobulin A has a free thiol at Cys121, which is buried between the beta-barrel and the C-terminal major alpha-helix. This thiol group was specifically reacted with 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB) in the presence of 1.0 M Gdn-HCI at pH 7.5, producing a modified beta-lactoglobulin (TNB-bIg) containing a mixed disulfide bond with 5-thio-2-nitrobenzoic acid (TNB). The conformation and stability of TNB-bIg were studied by circular dichroism (CD), tryptophan fluorescence, analytical ultracentrifugation, and one-dimensional 1H-NMR. The CD spectra of TNB-bIg indicated disordering of the native secondary structure at pH 7.5, whereas a slight increase in the alpha-helical content was observed at pH 2.0. The tryptophan fluorescence of TNB-bIg was significantly quenched compared with that of the intact protein, probably by the energy transfer to TNB. Sedimentation equilibrium analysis indicated that, at neutral pH, TNB-bIg is monomeric while the intact protein is dimeric. In contrast, at pH 2.0, both the intact beta-lactoglobulin and TNB-bIg were monomeric. The unfolding transition of TNB-bIg induced by Gdn-HCl was cooperative in both pH regions, although the degree of cooperativity was less than that of the intact protein. The 1H-NMR spectrum for TNB-bIg at pH 3.0 was native-like, whereas the spectrum at pH 7.5 was similar to that of the unfolded proteins. These results suggest that modification of the buried thiol group destabilizes the rigid hydrophobic core and the dimer interface, producing a monomeric state that is native-like at pH 2.0 but is molten globule-like at pH 7.5. Upon reducing the mixed disulfide of TNB-bIg with dithiothreitol, the intact beta-lactoglobulin was regenerated. TNB-bIg will become a useful model to analyze the conformation and stability of the intermediate of protein folding.     

Use of ZetaPrep cartridge for the purification of human recombinant interleukin 1 beta

Zetaprep mass ion-exchange media represent a rapid and efficient chromatographic tool in the separation of proteins, in place of the conventional agarose or cellulose-based gels. We adopted this method, combined with classical steps, to purify to homogeneity human recombinant interleukin 1 beta (IL-1 beta) produced from E. coli and from S. cerevisiae. An anion exchanger QAE-ZetaPrep was used to achieve a rapid partial purification of both proteins. The IL-1 beta purification was completed by gel permeation chromatography on Sephadex G-50. When the protein was produced from yeast, an intermediate chromatographic step on a hydroxylapatite column was also necessary. The isolated proteins proved to be homogeneous by electrophoresis and amino acid analysis. The biological activity of IL-1 beta produced by E. coli is comparable to that of the natural protein, while the protein produced by yeast showed very low specific activity.     

A new purification procedure for bovine milk xanthine oxidase: effect of proteolysis on the subunit structure.

A new purification procedure for bovine milk xanthine oxidase is reported. The enzyme so obtained is of the highest purity and shows little evidence of degradation. The enzyme displays a single protein band on either polyacrylamide gels or on sodium dodecyl sulfate-urea polyacrylamide gels. Sedimentation equilibrium studies indicate a native molecular weight of 303,000 and a subunit molecular weight of approximately 150,000. The latter value is in good agreement with the minimum molecular weight of 157,000 calculated from dry weight determination and flavin analysis. In contrast, purification of xanthine oxidase from pancreatin-treated cream yields a protein which displays two subunits corresponding to molecular weights of 92,000 and 39,000 as determined by dodecyl sulfate-urea polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. Pancreatinized enzyme has a greater mobility than unproteolyzed enzyme on polyacrylamide gels. Exposure of milk xanthine oxidase to pancreatin before isolation or after purification yields the same result.     

Mechanism of induced folding: Both folding before binding and binding before folding can be realized in staphylococcal nuclease mutants

A considerable number of functional proteins are unstructured under physiological condition. These "intrinsically disordered" proteins exhibit induced folding when they bind their targets. The induced folding comprises two elementary processes: folding and binding. Two mechanisms are possible for the induced folding: either folding before binding or binding before folding. We found that these two mechanisms can be distinguished by the target-concentration dependence of folding kinetics. We also created two types of mutants of staphylococcal nuclease showing the different inhibitor-concentration dependence of induced folding kinetics. One mutant obeys the scheme of binding before folding, while the other the folding before binding. This is the first experimental evidence demonstrating that both mechanisms are realized for a single protein. Binding before folding is possible, when the protein lacks essential nonlocal interaction to stabilize the native conformation. The results cast light on the protein folding mechanism involved in the intrinsically disordered proteins.     

Characterisation of size variants of type I DNA topoisomerase isolated from calf thymus

Calf thymus DNA topoisomerase I, which belongs to the eukaryotic type I topoisomerases, is in a typical preparation purified as a set of five major polypeptides with Mr between 70000 and 100000. At least four of these proteins have binding affinity for DNA as was shown by incubating them with radioactive single-stranded DNA after separation in dodecylsulfate polyacrylamide gels and blotting onto nitrocellulose filters. That these polypeptides have DNA relaxing activity was directly demonstrated with protein extracted from single bands of dodecylsulfate/polyacrylamide gels. We consider the 100000-Mr protein to be the native enzyme. The smaller components are catalytically active fragments of the native topoisomerase most probably arising from limited proteolysis either within the nucleus or during the purification of the enzyme. In two-dimensional non-equilibrium pH-gradient electrophoresis gels the topoisomerase size variants exhibit apparent pI values between 8.1 and 8.3, with small but distinct differences between the components. The calf thymus topoisomerase I, upon binding to phage fd-DNA, protects a stretch of 15-25 nucleotides against digestion with DNase I.     

Optimization of the cell wall microenvironment allows increased production of recombinant Bacillus anthracis protective antigen from B. subtilis.

The stability of heterologous proteins secreted by gram-positive bacteria is greatly influenced by the microenvironment on the trans side of the cytoplasmic membrane, and secreted heterologous proteins are susceptible to rapid degradation by host cell proteases. In Bacillus subtilis, degradation occurs either as the proteins emerge from the presecretory translocase and prior to folding into their native conformation or after the native conformation has been reached. The former process generally involves membrane- and/or cell wall-bound proteases, while the latter involves proteases that are released into the culture medium. The identification and manipulation of factors that influence the folding of heterologous proteins has the potential to improve the yield of secreted heterologous proteins. Recombinant anthrax protective antigen (rPA) has been used as a model secreted heterologous protein because it is sensitive to proteolytic degradation both before and after folding into its native conformation. This paper describes the influence of the microenvironment on the trans side of the cytoplasmic membrane on the stability of rPA. Specifically, we have determined the influence of net cell wall charge and its modulation by the extent to which the anionic polymer teichoic acid is D-alanylated on the secretion and stability of rPA. The potential role of the dlt operon, responsible for D-alanylation, was investigated using a Bacillus subtilis strain encoding an inducible dlt operon. We show that, in the absence of D-alanylation, the yield of secreted rPA is increased 2.5-fold. The function of D-alanylation and the use of rPA as a model protein are evaluated with respect to the optimization of B. subtilis for the secretion of heterologous proteins.     

Analysis of recombinant human growth hormone by capillary electrophoresis with bilayer-coated capillaries using UV and MS detection

The characterization of recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH; somatropin) by capillary electrophoresis (CE) with UV-absorbance and mass spectrometric (MS) detection using capillaries noncovalently coated with polybrene (PB) and poly(vinyl sulfonic acid) (PVS) is demonstrated. Compared with bare fused-silica capillaries, PB-PVS coated capillaries yielded more favorable migration-time reproducibilities and higher separation efficiencies. Optimal separation conditions for the bilayer-coated capillaries comprised a background electrolyte (BGE) of 400 mM Tris phosphate (pH 8.5) yielding migration-time R.S.D.s of less than 1.0% and plate numbers above 300,000 for intact rhGH. The protein was also analyzed using the CE method described in the European Pharmacopoeia (Ph. Eur.) monograph. The pharmacopoeial method gave much longer analysis times (22 min versus 8 min), lower resolution and plate numbers, and consecutive shifts in migration time for rhGH, indicating possible interactions between the protein and the inner capillary wall. Due to stable migration times obtained with the coated capillaries, reliable profiling and quantification of rhGH and its byproducts in time was possible. Analysis of thermally degraded rhGH revealed the formation of two main degradation products. CE-mass spectrometry (MS) of this sample, using a PB-PVS coated capillary and a BGE of 75 mM ammonium formate (pH 8.5), suggests that these products are desamido forms of rhGH. Analyses of expired rhGH preparations with CE-UV and CE-MS indicated the presence of both deamidation and oxidation products.     

Biochemical characterization of substances with myometrium contraction inhibitory action, originated from ovaries of pregnant sows

In order to understand life itself, we need biotechnology to purify biologically active substances as well. One of these processes results peptides with myometrium contraction inhibitory effect, originated from the ovaries of pregnant sows, but different from relaxin. After collection and acidic-acetone extraction of the ovaries (product generation, primary purification) the substance with myometrium contraction inhibitory effect was further purified on Sephadex G-25 (fine), CM-52 and again Sephadex G-25 (fine) gels (secondary purification) without loosing the bioactivity of the substance (quality control). Product analysis by analytical high performance liquid chromatography and capillary isotachophoresis were performed at this stage of the experiments. The analysis mentioned above resulted in 2-15 different subfractions in the studied extract. This shows that the biologically active ovarian extract needs further purification before the planned final amino-acid analysis is performed.     

alpha-L-arabinofuranosidase from Ruminococcus albus 8: purification and possible role in hydrolysis of alfalfa cell wall.

An alpha-L- arabinofuranosidase has been purified from the extracellular broth of cultures of Ruminococcus albus 8. The purification procedure utilized gel filtration, (NH4)2SO4 precipitation, and isoelectric focusing. The purified enzyme appeared to be homogeneous when chromatographed on disc and analytical isoelectric focusing gels. The estimated molecular weight of the native protein was 305,000 to 310,000. Sodium dodecyl sulfate-gel electrophoresis analysis suggested that the native protein is a tetramer composed of 75,000-molecular-weight subunits. The enzyme appeared to have no metal cofactor requirement but was sensitive to several sulfhydryl reagents. The pH optimum with p-nitrophenyl-alpha-L-arabinofuranoside as the substrate was 6.9 and the Km was 1.3 mM. Several lines of evidence indicated that the enzyme is a glycoprotein. When assayed against alfalfa cell wall material, the enzyme hydrolyzed only small amounts of arabinose from the substrate. When assayed together with hemicellulolytic or pectinolytic enzymes against the same substrate, the arabinosidase significantly enhanced the hydrolytic action of the glycanases .     

The native metastability and misfolding of serine protease inhibitors

The native metastability of serine protease inhibitors (serpins) is believed to facilitate the conformational change required for biological function. However, energetically unfavorable structural features that contribute to metastability of the native serpin conformation, such as buried polar groups, cavities, and over-packing of side-chains, also appear to hinder proper folding. Hence, folding of serpin polypeptides appears prone to error; in particular, the folding polypeptides are readily diverted toward a non-productive folding pathway culminating in a more stable but inactive conformation. In a survey of deficient serpin mutants, various folding defects, such as retarded protein folding, destabilized native conformation, and spontaneous conversion into more stable, inactive conformations such as the latent form and loop-sheet polymers, have been discovered.     

In vitro protein folding by E. coli ribosome: unfolded protein splitting 70S to interact with 50S subunit

Folding of unfolded protein on Escherichia coli 70S ribosome is accompanied by rapid dissociation of the ribosome into 50S and 30S subunits. The dissociation rate of 70S ribosome with unfolded protein is much faster than that caused by combined effect of translation and polypeptide release factors known to be involved in the dissociation of ribosome into subunits. The protein then reaches a “folding competent” state on 50S and is released to take up native conformation by itself. Release before attaining the folding competent state or prevention of release by cross-linking it with ribosome, would not allow the protein to get back to its native conformation.