Fine specificity and antigen receptor expression among influenza virus-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte clones

Influenza virus stimulates a vigorous cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) response in the mouse that is directed to several virion polypeptides. This report examines the fine specificity of a panel of murine influenza-specific CTL clones restricted by MHC class I products of the H-2d haplotype. Ten of 22 A/JAPAN/305/57-specific CTL clones analyzed were directed to the A/JAPAN/305/57 hemagglutinin protein as detected by using target cells infected with a recombinant vaccinia virus containing hemagglutinin gene. Based on their fine specificity of hemagglutinin recognition, these clones defined four functional epitopes on the hemagglutinin. The remaining 12 cytolytic clones exhibited cross-reactivity for type A influenza viruses of the major human subtypes, and approximately 60% of these clones were directed to the nucleocapsid protein. KJ16-133 monoclonal antibody analysis of the utilization of the T cell receptor V beta 8 gene segment subfamily revealed that members of this V beta gene subfamily are expressed by both hemagglutinin- and nucleocapsid-specific MHC class I-restricted CTL (and by influenza-specific MHC class II-restricted T lymphocytes as well). These results suggest that CTL detect several distinct antigenic sites on the hemagglutinin. In addition, these results reveal no direct correlation between viral antigenic specificity and V beta gene expression by these virus-specific CLT clones.     

Requirements for triggering of lysis by cytolytic T lymphocyte clones

Cloned murine cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) having defined specificity were triggered by the phorbol ester together with a calcium ionophore (either A23187 or Ionomycin) to lyse syngeneic or third party target cells efficiently. Neither phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA) nor calcium ionophore alone induced efficient lysis. The characteristics of the lytic process induced by these signals are similar to those of antigen-specific or lectin-facilitated lysis by CTL. Lysis is calcium and temperature dependent and shows kinetics which are not grossly different from lysis mediated via the antigen receptor. Two helper T lymphocyte clones were not induced to lyse efficiently EL-4 target cells by concanavalin A or PMA + ionophore. Triggering of lysis induced with PMA plus ionophore by the CTL clone L3 differed from antigen-mediated lysis in specificity and in the susceptibility to inhibition by cytochalasin B. Properties of the target cell determine which cell surface associative recognition structures are important in the efficient lysis of these cells. Anti-LFA-1 monoclonal antibodies inhibited efficiently both antigen-mediated and PMA + ionophore-induced lysis of P-815 or EL-4 target cells which are of hematopoietic origin. However, anti-LFA-1 antibodies do not inhibit antigen-mediated, lectin-facilitated, or PMA + Ionomycin-induced CTL cytolysis of target cells derived from the L cell fibroblast line. We conclude that two intracellular signals, which can be provided by the combination of PMA + ionophore, are required for efficient lysis by antigen-specific murine CTL clones. When the T cell receptor for antigen is bypassed using PMA + ionophore to trigger lysis, we show that Lyt-2 and LFA-1 molecules may be required for efficient lysis. These associative recognition structures appear to play an important role in postactivation steps leading to efficient delivery of the lethal hit to the target cell.     

Membranolytic and nucleolytic activities of cytolytic T lymphocyte clones

In an attempt to see if the nucleolytic and membranolytic activities of cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) were totally independent and could be expressed independently, we cloned CTL and determined their membranolytic and nucleolytic activities. If the two lytic mechanisms were completely independent and could be independently expressed by individual CTL, we anticipated that we would find CTL clones exhibiting only one or the other activity. Initial examination of membranolytic and nucleolytic activities in 99 newly established CTL clones revealed a poor correlation (r = 0.4) between the two activities. In addition, some clones expressed membenolytic activity without nucleolytic activity, and others, nucleolytic activity without membenolytic activity. The results suggest that CTL have 2 or more separate and independent mechanisms that lead either to the membranolytic or to the nucleolytic lesions in target cells.     

TNP-specific Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cell clones preferentially respond to TNP-conjugated epidermal cells

A most effective method for the induction of hapten-specific allergic contact sensitivity (CS) is via epicutaneous application of the hapten. Another effective method is by the administration of haptenated epidermal cells (EC) subcutaneously. The latter method induces more intense and longer lasting CS than does the subcutaneous administration of haptenated spleen cells (SC). Thus, there may be something unique about EC which, when haptenated, allows them to generate effector cells more effectively than do SC. We therefore attempted to generate T cell clones that were both hapten- and epidermal-specific. Four days after painting mice with 7% trinitrochlorobenzene, draining lymph node cells were obtained and T cells were purified. These cells were co-cultured with trinitrophenylated (TNP) Langerhans cell-enriched EC. After 4 days, cells were harvested and rested on non-TNP-conjugated EC. The cells were restimulated and rested three times, and were then cloned by limiting dilution with added interleukin 2, which was then continually added. Proliferation of T cells was assessed by [3H]-thymidine incorporation. Cytotoxicity assays utilized TNP-conjugated concanavalin A SC blasts or EC as targets. Clones A-2 and E-4 are Thy-1+, Lyt-2+, and L3T4-, and TNP-specific. In contrast to noncloned TNP-specific T cells, the clones proliferate preferentially in response to TNP-EC rather than TNP-SC. Also in contrast to noncloned T cells, the clones were preferentially cytotoxic for TNP-EC; compared to TNP-SC, there was an eight- to 32-fold increase in killing when TNP-EC were used as targets. Clones A-2 and E-4 therefore exhibit hapten and epidermal specificity. The epidermal-specific epitope that is recognized is unknown, but genetic restriction and antibody inhibition studies indicate that it is co-recognized with H-2K.     

Recognition of influenza-infected cells by cytolytic T lymphocyte clones: determinant selection by class I restriction elements

The fine specificity of virus recognition by influenza A/PR8/34(H1N1)-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones was analyzed with the use of a panel of syngeneic target cells infected with five heterologous influenza A strain viruses. Forty-five H-2 D-end-restricted CTL clones from B10.A(5R) responders (Dd,Ld) demonstrated 14 different patterns of recognition. Many of these clonotypes were able to distinguish between closely related viruses of the same subtype. Such discriminatory capacity, however, was often accompanied by cross-reactivity against a distantly related viral subtype. This supports the contention that virus-specific CTL see different structures than do virus-specific antibodies. A similar analysis of the fine specificity of 60 Db-restricted clones from C57BL/6 responders was performed. The vast majority of this response was composed of clonotypes not observed in the B10.A(5R) response. In addition, the hierarchy of relatedness between the virus strain used for immunization and the various heterologous viruses was different in C57BL/6 and B10.A(5R). In contrast, the D-end-restricted response of Balb/c (Dd,Ld) demonstrated clonotypes similar to those found in B10.A(5R). These data suggest that determinant recognition in an anti-viral CTL response is a function of the H-2 restricting elements, and this is discussed in the context of determinant selection by class I molecules.     

T lymphocyte responses to non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens. I. Role of Ly-1+2+ T cells as cytotoxic effectors and requirement for Ly-1+2+ T cells for optimal generation of cytotoxic effectors

Cytotoxic effector T cells specific for non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens were examined for phenotypic expression of lymphocyte differentiation (Ly) antigens. Virtually all H-Y-specific cytotoxic effectors generated in mixed lymphocyte culture were Ly-1+2+ T cells. H-3-specific effectors comprised both Ly-1+2+ and Ly-1-2+ T cells. However, cytotoxic effectors specific for multiple non-H-2 H antigens were predominantly Ly-1-2+ T cells. The optimal generation of H-Y- and H-3-specific effectors required Ly-1+2+ T cells; optimal generation of multiple non-H-2 H antigen-specific effectors required an interaction between Ly-1+2- and Ly-1-2+ T cells. These observations suggest that the identity of the target H antigen in part determines the Ly type of responsive T cells. Our observations suggest that 2 alternative pathways of T cell response exist for non-H-2 H antigens. The first pathway involves an interaction between Ly-1+2- helper T cells and Ly-1-2+ cytotoxic effector precursors. The 2nd pathway simply involves the response of Ly-1+2+ T cells proliferating and generating H antigen-specific cytotoxic effectors.     

Rapid changes in specificity within single clones of cytolytic effector cells

We find rapid changes in the specificity of the cytolytic effector cells in a mixed lymphocyte culture. The lysis patterns produced by cytolytic effector cells generated near limiting dilution in murine mixed lymphocyte reactions of three types, F₁ anti-parent (F₁(A × B) anti-A), allogeneic (C anti-F₁(A × B)), and F₁ anti-modified parent (F₁(A × B) anti-A-TNP), were investigated. Cultures were characterized by their ability or inability to lyse a panel of target cells (e.g., A, B, F₁). When individual cultures were tested at two different times, changes in lytic pattern were routinely seen, with some patterns reproducibly increasing in frequency and others reproducibly decreasing (e.g., patterns involving lysis of F₁ decreased in an F₁ anti-A response but increased in a C anti-F₁ response). X-linked isoenzyme analysis showed that changes can occur within a single clone of effector cells. These results imply that the T cell specificity repertoire continues to evolve during an ongoing immune response, a conclusion incompatible with clonal selection theory.     

Avidity dictates the lytic capacity of human cytolytic T lymphocyte clones with similar fine specificity against murine cells expressing HLA-B27 antigen

The role of the avidity of human CTL in the recognition and lysis of murine P815 cells expressing HLA-B27.1 Ag has been examined. Seven B27-specific alloreactive CTL clones were tested for their ability to lyse a B27.1+-P815 transfectant clone 1-7E, obtained after cotransfection of P815-HTR cells with HLA-B27.1 and human beta 2-microglobulin genes. The expression level of HLA-B27.1 on 1-7E cells was comparable to that on a human lymphoblastoid cell line, as determined by flow cytometry. Of the seven CTL clones used, CTL 1, 26, and 29 displayed the same fine specificity as established with a panel of target cells expressing six structurally different HLA-B27 variants. However, CTL 1 and 29 were of higher avidity than CTL 26, in that the lysis of human target cells by only this latter clone was inhibited by an anti-CD8 mAb. Based on the same criteria, CTL 2, 15, and 48 possessed the same or very similar fine specificity, but CTL 48 was of higher avidity than CTL 2 or 15. The seventh clone, CTL 40, was of a different fine specificity and its lysis of human target cells was also inhibited by the same anti-CD8 mAb. Only those clones whose lysis of human targets could not be inhibited by anti-CD8 antibody were able to lyse the 1-7E murine transfectants. These results indicate that, for human CTL clones with identical or very similar fine specificity, only those of higher avidity are able to lyse P815 murine cells expressing the HLA-B27 antigen. The lysis of HLA-B27.1+-murine transfectants by relevant clones was inhibited by anti-CD8 antibody. This result strongly suggests that the relative contribution of CD8 in stabilizing the interaction between human CTL and HLA-B27+-murine target cells is more significant than with human target cells.     

Antigen-specific human T lymphocyte clones: viral antigen specificity of influenza virus-immune clones

Human T lymphocyte clones (TLC) specific for type A (A/Texas/1/77) influenza virus and maintained in continuous culture with T cell growth factor, were analyzed to define the cellular specificity pattern of virus recognition. A panel of TLC were stimulated with strains of serologically characterized type A influenza subtypes. Five TLC recognized all the viral subtypes; the remaining clones recognized only subtypes that shared serologically defined determinants with the immunizing subtype. In addition, the 11 TLC were analyzed for their fine antigenic specificity by using the purified viral components hemagglutinin (HA), neuraminidase (NA), matrix protein (MP), and nucleoprotein (NP). Five TLC proliferated in response to NA, four to MP, one to HA, and one to NP. None of the clones responded to the unrelated B strain influenza virus, B/Singapore. Furthermore, the fine specificity of an MP-reactive TLC was confirmed by subcloning.     

CD4 is involved in a post-binding event in the cytolytic reaction mediated by human CD4+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones

CTL lyse their target cells in discrete phases. First, the CTL bind to the target cell in a Mg2+-dependent manner followed by a Ca2+-dependent cytolytic phase. In the present study, we investigated the role of CD4 in the different phases of the cytolytic reaction mediated by human CD4+ class II MHC-specific CTL clones by using a single cell assay. It was found that the anti-CD4+ mAb OKT4A, which blocks cytotoxic reactions by CD4+ CTL clones as measured with a 51Cr release assay, only marginally affects the formation of conjugates. It appeared that OKT4A more strongly blocked the post-binding phase of the cytolytic reaction. In contrast, anti-leukocyte function-associated mAb strongly blocked the formation of conjugates but not the subsequent lytic phase. As was found previously with CD8+ CTL clones, anti-TCR mAb generally did not affect the formation of conjugates. One exception was noted. The activity of a CD4+ CTL clone, HY-640, could not be blocked by OKT4A, but was affected by an anti-TCR mAb. This anti-TCR mAb could partly reduce the formation of conjugates between HY-640 cells and their specific target cells. These results suggest that this clone has a high affinity TCR, which can contribute to the formation of conjugates. Although preincubation of the CTL clones with OKT4A only marginally affects the number of conjugates upon subsequent mixture with target cells, it was observed that incubation at 37 degrees C of preformed conjugates with OKT4A markedly reduced the number of conjugates. This dissociation of preformed conjugates was optimal only after 2 h of incubation. In contrast, an anti-leukocyte function-associated mAb induced a much more rapid dissociation of preformed conjugates.     

Expression of H-2I region-restricted cytolytic activity by an Lyt-2+ influenza virus-specific T lymphocyte clone

The expression of Lyt-2 on T lymphocytes has been postulated to correlate closely with restriction by, or alloreactivity to, class I MHC gene products, whereas I region-restricted or alloreactive populations appear to be associated with Lyt-1 and L3T4 expression. However, exceptions to this axiom among alloreactive T cells have been shown to exist. In this report we describe a clonal population of influenza virus-specific T lymphocytes that bears the Lyt-2+, L3T4- phenotype. Notably, this clone is restricted in influenza virus recognition by class II MHC molecules and is cytolytic for virus-infected target cells expressing the appropriate class II molecules. Antibody directed to the Lyt-2 molecule does not inhibit cytolysis.     

Target specificity and cell surface structures involved in the human cytolytic T lymphocyte response to endothelial cells

Two long-term cytolytic T lymphocyte (CTL) lines derived from the peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of a single donor were analyzed for target specificity and involvement of cell surface molecules in CTL-target interactions. One line, AH2, was generated after stimulation with B lymphoblastoid cells. Cytolysis by these cells was restricted to targets expressing the appropriate HLA-A2 specificity and was blocked by mAb recognizing CD2, CD3, CD8, LFA-1, and LFA-3. The second line, AE1, was generated after stimulation with cultured endothelial cells derived from human newborn preputial microvessels. These CTL lysed all human target cells tested, except autologous cells and the Class I negative cell line Daudi. In addition, mAb specific for CD2, CD3, and CD8 did not affect cytolysis. Anti-LFA-1 and -LFA-3 mAb blocked cytolysis of B lymphoblastoid targets but not endothelial targets. These results indicate that some CTL utilize as yet uncharacterized cell surface structures for CTL-target interactions.     

Limiting dilution analysis of alloantigen-reactive T lymphocytes. IV. High frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells in MLC blasts separated by velocity sedimentation

A sensitive limiting dilution microculture system was used to obtain minimal estimates of the frequency of cytolytic T lymphocyte precursor cells (CTL-P) directed against DBA/2 alloantigens, after priming of spleen cells in unidirectional mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC, C57BL/6 anti-DBA/2). The mean CTL-P frequency in day 4 to 5 MLC populations was found to be approximately 50- to 100-fold greater than the frequency in normal spleen, and up to 25% of the cells present in such MLC could be identified operationally as CTL-P. Even higher frequencies (up to 50%) of CTL-P were obtained in a population of large-sized cells separated from day 4 MLC by velocity sedimentation. Furthermore, since a strikingly quantitative correlation was observed between CTL activity and CTL-P frequency in such separated MLC populations, it is likely that mature CTL in MLC are not end cells, but can further proliferate and thus behave operationally as CTL-P.     

Human myelin basic protein-specific cytolytic T lymphocyte clones are functionally restricted by HLA class II gene products

Cellular immune reactions against the autoantigen myelin basic protein (MBP) are strongly implicated in the occurrence of postinfectious and postvaccination encephalomyelitis. Clinical autoimmune encephalomyelitis in experimental animals can be transferred with cloned MBP-specific cytolytic major histocompatibility complex Class II-restricted T lymphocytes. The HLA restriction pattern of specific proliferative and cytolytic functions of two human MBP-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte clones, derived from two different multiple sclerosis patients, was analyzed in detail. Using monoclonal antibodies against various HLA gene products and allogeneic Epstein-Barr virus-transformed B cells as antigen-presenting cells and as targets for cytolysis, it was found that MBP-specific functions of the T cell clones was restricted by HLA class II antigens, and, more specifically, by molecules encoded for by DR locus genes.     

H-2K-restricted granuloma formation by Ly-2+ T cells in antibacterial protection to facultative intracellular bacteria

Cellular, genetic, and antigenic requirements for granuloma formation in murine listeriosis were determined by using adoptive transfer of granuloma formation. Granuloma formation was restricted by a class I MHC antigen (H-2K) and critically depended on a Ly-2+ (Ly-1+2+) T cell. Expression of granuloma formation required living bacteria; heat-killed bacteria was not sufficient. H-2K-restricted transfer of granuloma formation was associated with a high degree of protection. Markedly less protection, presumably due to macrophage activation by T cells, was found under conditions of H-2 I-A homology. It is concluded that two T cell populations are involved in protection against L. monocytogenes: protection associated with granuloma formation depends on Ly-2+ (Ly-1+2+) T cells, is restricted by H-2K, and requires products of living bacteria to be expressed, whereas protection based on macrophage activation depends on H-2 I-A-restricted T helper cells.     

NK cells suppress the generation of Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cells by suppressing or eliminating dendritic cells

Cells highly enriched for natural killer activity suppress the generation of Lyt-2+ cytolytic T cells in one-way mixed lymphocyte cultures. Suppression occurs because natural killer cells suppress or eliminate dendritic cells, which are required for proliferation of both Ly-1+ and Lyt-2+ lymphocytes.     

Limiting dilution analysis of the specificity of influenza-immune cytotoxic T cells

The frequency of memory T cells in the spleens of mice primed with the A/Puerto Rico/8/34/1 (H1N1) (PR8) influenza A virus was determined using limiting dilution protocols. The mean frequency of memory cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) in spleen populations from mice primed with PR8 and restimulated in vitro with the same virus ranged, in six experiments, from 1 in 1600 to 1 in 4800. In the same experiments, the frequencies of CTL capable of lysing targets infected with the heterologous A/Hong Kong/×31/68 (H3N2) (HK) virus ranged from 1 in 1700 to 1 in 4700 nucleated spleen cells. Thus, at least 80% of PR8 (H1N1) influenza-specific cytotoxic T cells are lytic for both HK (H3N2)- and PR8-infected target cells. Further analysis of the specificity of a series of monoclonal influenza-specific CTL was achieved by expanding limit dilution cultures and then testing lytic capacity for targets infected with a range of influenza A viruses. This approach confirmed that the great majority of PR8-primed influenza-specific CTL are cross-reactive for a variety of influenza A subtypes. These experiments demonstrate the feasibility of quantitating different influenza-immune CTL specificities at a stage very close to removal of cells from the animal.     

Antigen-specific human T lymphocyte clones: induction, antigen specificity, and MHC restriction of influenza virus-immune clones

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes from an HLA-Dw1,3 individual were primed in vitro with influenza A virus (A/Texas/1-77/x-49) and subsequently cloned by limiting dilution in TCGF. Of the 96 TLCs originally obtained, nine were characterized in detail. TLCs were antigen specific, responding to influenza A virus, not to influenza B, TGAL, GAT, tetanus toxoid, or KLH, and only when antigen was presented by cells unable to form rosettes with AET-treated SRBC. Presentation of antigen by unseparated PBL often resulted in significant "back stimulation," probably via production of growth factors. The MHC requirements for the induction of TLC proliferation were analyzed. Of four representative clones analyzed, three required Dw1;DR1 compatibility for successful presentation of viral antigens by a panel of antigen-presenting cells. In contrast, one TLC showed an unusual pattern of response that could not be correlated to a particular HLA haplotype. Monoclonal anti-T cell antibody analysis of the surface phenotype of two TLCs maintained in continuous culture for 5 mo indicated that they were OKT3+, 4+, and 8-, consistent with an inducer/helper phenotype. To confirm the clonal nature of TLCs, data on the functional properties of TLC subclones are also presented.