Distribution of lead in human milk fractions

The purpose of this study was to determine the concentration and distribution of lead, calcium, iron, zinc, and copper in major fractions (fat, casein, whey) of mature milk from 38 nursing adult women with low environmental lead exposure. The potential associations between milk lead and maternal blood lead and between milk and blood lead and essential mineral data (nutritional status, dietary intake, and milk concentration) were investigated. Maternal blood lead (geometric mean, 60 μg/L) was negatively associated, although modestly, with dietary calcium intake (r=−0.32, p=0.02). Lead in whole milk (geometric mean, 1.2 μg/L) was positively associated with calcium in whole milk (r=0.56, p=0.005). Distribution of lead in milk fractions was 63%, 28%, and 9%, in whey, fat, and casein, respectively. Milk distribution of essential minerals was 67–76%, 17–18%, and 7–17% in whey, fat, and casein, respectively. Lead in milk whey was positively associated with lead in maternal blood (r=0.49, p=0.02). However, milk lead was not affected by nutritional status, dietary intake, and milk composition of the essential minerals. The high percentage of lead in the milk whey fraction, as seen for the essential minerals, suggests that most lead in human milk is bioavailable to the infant.     

Mycotoxins in South African foods: a case study on aflatoxin M<Subscript>1</Subscript> in milk

The contamination of cow’s milk at the farm level with aflatoxin M₁ was investigated in South Africa. Samples of feeds, forage, maize and milk were taken at nine dairy farms, and at the same time samples of the processed milk (retail milk) were collected from the respective dairies to which the farms delivered their milk. The feeds were analysed for aflatoxin B₁ and the milk samples for aflatoxin M₁ using high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and fluorescence detection. All milk samples from the dairy farms were positive for aflatoxin M₁, ranging from 0.02 μg/l to 1.5 μg/l. Retail milk was also frequently contaminated with AFM₁, at levels of 0.01-3.1 μg/l. High AFB₁ levels in feed materials on the farms supplying the raw milk indicate that various sources account for this contamination frequency in milk.     

Effect of selenium in soluble glass bolus on selenium content of milk and blood of goats

Soluble glass bolus (SGB) with selenium (Se) was administered intraruminally to Se-deficient Philippine does to determine its effect on milk Se and to correlate the Se contents of does' milk and blood of does and kids. Five months after the Se administration, the does in the treated group (n=14) had higher (p<0.01) Se content in their blood (62.2 vs 25.7 μg/L) and milk (5.1 vs 2.5 μg/L) than does in control group (n=13). Consequently, the blood Se of the kids (n=14) from the treated does was higher (p<0.05) than those kids (n=13) in the control group (28.0 vs 5.1 μg/L). Blood and milk Se of does and blood Se of their kids correlated (p<0.01) with each other. The increased Se level of does' milk because of Se supplementation was not regarded as a health hazard to humans.     

Gangliosides in human, cow and goat milk, and their abilities as to neutralization of cholera toxin and botulinum type A neurotoxin

To elucidate the potential of mammalian milk as to protection of infants from infections, we determined the ganglioside compositions of human, cow and goat milk in relation with cholera toxin and botulinum type A neurotoxin-receptors. Gangliosides accounted for 1 to 2 μmol of lipid-bound sialic acid (LSA) in 100 ml of milk, and GD3 comprised about 69% of LSA in all milk samples. Among the milk samples examined, goat milk was found to contain an amount of gangliosides belonging to the b-pathway representing 15.8% of the total LSA. Accordingly, botulinum neurotoxin bound to GT1b and GQ1b in goat milk, but not to any gangliosides in human or cow milk. On the other hand, GM1, the cholera toxin receptor, was found to be present in all milk samples at concentrations of 0.02% to 0.77% of the total LSA and to be maintained at a relatively constant level in human milk during the postpartum period. Gangliosides from 1 ml of pooled human milk exhibited the ability to attenuate the binding of cholera toxin (30 ng) to GM1 by 93%, and those from 500 μl of goat milk completely inhibited the binding of botulinum type A neurotoxin 1.5 μg to GT1b. The glycolipid nomenclature is based on the recommendations of the IUPAC-IUB Commission on Biochemical Nomenclature [1]. The ganglioside nomenclature of Svennerholm is employed throughout [2]. PVP, polyvinylpyrrolidone; LSA, lipid-bound sialic acid.     

Human exposure to metals through the diet in Tarragona, Spain

The concentrations of arsenic (As), beryllium (Be), cadmium (cd), chromium (Cr), mercury (Hg), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb), tin (Sn), thallium (Tl), and vanadium (V) were determined in a number of food items purchased in zones of Tarragona, County (Catalonia, Spain) near a hazardous waste incinerator (HWI), which has been operating since 1999. Food samples corresponded to the following groups: meat, fish and seafood, pulses, cereals, vegetables, fruits, tubers, whole milk, yogurt, eggs, and sugar. Be and Tl were under their respective limits of detection in all samples. For the analyzed trace elements, the dietary intake by the general population of Tarragona was 458.5 μg/d for As, 14.3 μg/d for Cd, 88.3 μg/d for Cr, 5.3 μg/d for Hg, 2421.4 μg/d for Mn, 138.3 μg/d for Ni, 44.8 μg/d for Pb, 34.6 μg/d for Sn, and 28.9 μg/d for V. Results were compared with those found in a baseline survey carried out in the same area during the construction of the HWI (1996–1998). In general terms, the dietary intake of metals in 2003 was comparatively similar to those found in the baseline survey. For the most toxic elements (As, Cd, Hg, and Pb), it was under their respective Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI) estabished by the FAO/WHO.     

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay of chlorampenicol in foodstuff

A test-system based on enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the quantitative detection of chloramphenicol (CAP) in foodstuff has been developed. The detection limit of the method was 0.05 μg/l. The procedures for milk samples preparation of various fat content and chicken muscles were optimized. Before the analysis milk was diluted 5-fold with a buffer. The detection limit for milk was 0.3 μg/l; recoveries varied from 74 to 118%. Two protocols for chicken muscles preparation were elaborated; extraction with buffer (the express method) and extraction with acetonitrile. The detection limits of CAP in chicken muscles were 0.5 and 0.3 μg/kg, respectively; recovery values were 71–107% and 95–115%, respectively. The results of residual amounts of CAP detection in foodstuff by ELISA and HPLC-MS were in good correlation.     

Mammary Specific Transgenic Over-expression of Insulin-like Growth Factor-I (IGF-I) Increases Pig Milk IGF-I and IGF Binding Proteins,with no Effect on Milk Composition or Yield

IGF-I regulates lactation by stimulating mammary mitogenesis, inhibiting apoptosis, and partially mediating the effects of growth hormone on lactogenesis. Herein, lactation performance during first and second parity was assessed in transgenic swine (TG) that over-expressed human IGF-I in milk under the control of the bovine α-lactalbumin promoter, regulatory regions and signal peptide coding sequence. Milk samples were collected throughout lactation (farrowing to d24) from TG sows and non-transgenic littermates (CON) and IGF-I, IGF-II, and IGFBP determined. Colostral (<24 h postpartum) IGF-I content was 26-fold greater (p < 0.001) in TG sows (949 ± 107 μg/L; range 228–1600 μg/L) than CON (36 ± 17.8 μg/L) and was 50- to 90-fold greater (p < 0.001) in mature milk (d2-24 postpartum). There was no effect of parity on milk IGF-I content. Milk IGF-II concentration was unaffected by IGF-I over-expression. Low molecular weight IGFBP (IGFBP-2 and -5) in the milk of TG sows were higher (p = 0.02) than CON in the early postpartum period, but did not differ in mature milk. Milk yield, determined by weigh-suckle-weigh, was similar in TG and CON as was litter weight gain. Milk nutrient composition was not significantly affected by IGF over-expression. Thus, mammary specific transgenic over-expression of IGF-I significantly increased milk IGF-I and IGFBP content, but did not impact lactation performance in swine.     

Maintenance of milk protein gene expression in a subpopulation of 7,12-dimethylbenz (a) anthracene-induced rat mammary carcinoma cells grown on attached collagen gels

Summary Milk protein gene expression was studied in cell subpopulations of 7,12-dimethylbenz(a)anthracene-induced rat mammary carcinoma cells enriched or depleted for casein production grown on attached collagen gels. Culture of these cells in the presence of 10% fetal bovine serum, insulin (5 μg/ml), hydrocortisone (10 μg/ml), and prolactin (5 μg/ml) maintained α-, β-, and γ-casein and whey acidic protein mRNAs at levels identical to cells isolated from perphenazine-treated rats. Whey acidic protein mRNA levels in the tumor cells relative to the 14-d lactating gland were greater than those of the casein mRNAs. Withdrawal of prolactin from the casein-producing cells resulted in the loss of all four milk protein mRNAs. Subsequent addition of prolactin to the withdrawn cells caused a rapid accumulation of these mRNAs to prewithdrawal levels. Milk protein gene expression in this tumor cell subpopulation is modulated by prolactin (in the presence of insulin and hydrocortisone) in a similar manner to that observed in the normal mammary gland when these tumor cells are cultured on attached collagen gels. This work was supported by National Institutes of Health grant CA 16303. M. L. Johnson was the recipient of NIH Fellowship, HD 06157.     

Maternal and neonatal scalp hair concentrations of zinc, copper, cadmium, and lead

Postpartum scalp hair samples from 82 term-pregnancy mother/neonate pairs were analyzed for their concentration of zinc (Zn), copper (Cu), cadmium (Cd), and lead (Pb), using inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry. Maternal and neonatal Zn concentrations had geometric means (and 99% confidence intervals) of 122.5 μg/g (117.9–131.5 μg/g) and 146.9 μg (141.5–156.7 μg/g) respectively. Corresponding Cu values were 18.4 μg/g (17.6–23.8 μg/g) and 6.7 μg/g (6.3–7.6 μg/g). Those of Cd were 0.49 μg/g (0.47–0.69 μg/g) in the mothers and 0.57 μg/g (0.55–0.86 μg/g) in the neonates. For Pb, they were 7.95 μg/g (7.60–9.32 μg/g) and 4.56 μg/g (4.39–5.56 μg/g). Cigaret smoking, despite its relatively low prevalence (19.5%), was associated with lower Zn and higher Cd and Pb concentrations and in lower Zn/Cd and Zn/Pb molar concentration ratios. Smoking also altered interelemental relationships, particularly those of Zn with Cd and Pb and those between Cd and Pb. Smoking frequency appeared to show negative dose-response effects on maternal and neonatal Zn concentrations, Zn/Pb molar concentration ratios, and birth weight. Mothers with a history of oral contraceptive (OC) usage had significantly higher Cu concentrations and lower Zn/Cu molar concentration ratios than nonusers, with the highest Cu concentrations and lowest Zn/Cu values being associated with third-generation OCs. No similar effects were elicited in the respective neonatal Cu concentrations. Neither alcohol consumption nor prenatal supplementation with iron and/or folic acid had discernible effects on the maternal or neonatal elemental concentrations. The data from this study suggest that in a given population of term-pregnancy mothers and neonates, significant interindividual variations in hair trace element concentrations can occur, irrespective of commonality of general environment, and that lifestyle factors, including cigaret smoking and OC usage history, can be significant contributory factors to such variations. The data are discussed in relation to the effects of smoking-associated exposure to Cd and Pb exposure on Zn availability for placental transfer, as well as on the quantitative maternal Zn supply levels to the fetus resulting from the known tendency of smokers to have lower dietary intakes of Zn. The higher Cu concentrations in OC users are discussed in relation to altered Cu metabolism, characterized by increased synthesis of the Cu-binding protein, ceruloplasmin, as an acute-phase antioxidant response to altered lipid profile and increased lipid oxidation.     

Blood Selenium Associated with Health and Fertility in Norwegian Dairy Herds

A survey of blood selenium (Se) concentrations in Norwegian Red heifers and dry period cows was conducted to reveal possible association to management, feeding, health and fertility. Selenium contents were determined in 254 herd blood samples consisting of pooled samples from individual non-lactating animals from herds in 5 counties. The Se concentrations showed a normal distribution with mean 0.09 μg Se/g blood, with a standard deviation (SD) of 0.05, and ranged from 0.02 to 0.23 μg/g, with 50 % of the samples being between 0.06 and 0.11 μg/g. The herds with Se concentrations below 0.06 μg/g were smaller (21.4 ± 8.7 cow-years) than those with Se levels above 0.11 μg/g (27.5 ± 14.1 cow-years) (P < 0.01), but there were no differences in milk yield, incidence of replacement, proportion of animal culling, amount of concentrate or grass silage as percentage of energy consumption between the groups. Treatment registration records showed a tendency that more animals in the low Se herds were treated for all the diseases included in this investigation (64.8 animals per 100 cow-years) than those in the high Se herds (57.5 per 100 cow-years), while no such differences were revealed for individual disorders. There was, however, a significant difference in bulk milk somatic cell counts (BMSCC) between low and high Se herds, their values being 137 000 and 155 000 cells/ml, respectively. This difference was significantly influenced by herd size. Furthermore, a total of 4 916 lactations were analyzed from individual health and fertility recordings, including 2 934 first lactations and 1 982 later lactations. The present study revealed a reduced incidence of disease treatment with increased Se concentrations from 0.02 to 0.23 μg Se/g blood. In this regard, there seemed to be an optimum of 0.10 to 0.15 μg Se/g for all types of mastitis treatments summarized, and for treatment of retained placenta. Thus, herd Se concentrations below and above these values was connected with increased probability for sum mastitis and retained placenta, reflecting the effect of the quadratic term of Se. The cow (composite) milk somatic cell count (SCC) was lower in lactations from low Se herds than in high Se herds with a marked SCC increase in the Se concentration interval from 0.11–0.13 μg/g blood. In conclusion, heifers and dry period cows in Norway are low in blood Se content and there seems to be a positive association between increased blood Se concentration pre partum and decreased incidence of mastitis, ovarian cysts and anoestrus/silent oestrus post partum.     

Contribution of milk to iodine intake in France

A survey based on 838, samples of milk obtained from 537 dairies covering 70 of 95 districts in France was organized to assess iodine content of milk and its contribution to total intake. Iodine levels were significantly higher in winter than in summer. Very low iodine contents (<25 μg I/kg) were found in the eastern part of the country (the Vosges, Jura, and the Alpes) and the Massif Central. During milk processing, much of the iodine is lost in the whey. The other significant sources of dietary iodine are fish and eggs. Iodized salt is sold only to households and not to industry. Even if about 20% of the iodine is lost over the first 3 mo, salt remains the main source for this trace element. It is concluded that, if iodized salt is not provided systematically for both domestic and agro-industrial use, then milk may be the most important source of iodine. This key role may explain seasonal and geographical variations in the frequencies of goiter in France.     

Yersinia intermedia: A new species of enterobacteriaceae composed of rhamnose-positive,melibiose-positive,raffinose-positive strains (formerly calledYersinia enterocolitica orYersinia enterocolitica-like)

The drugs griseofulvin (10 μg/ml), nalidixic acid (0.05 μg/ml), quinine dihydrochloride (50 μg/ml), quinine ethylcarbonate (50 μg/ml), quinine urea hydrochloride (50 μg/ml), quinine lactate (50 μg/ml), and pamaquine (50 μg/ml) were chosen for laboratory studies. The minimal inhibitory concentration of the drug was used for determining the range of drug concentration needed to produce “mutational synergism” with ultraviolet radiation. Forward mutation from streptomycin sensitivity to resistance was used as a marker for mutagenicity. No stimulatory or inhibitory effects were noted on viable counts and mutation frequency, when the drugs were added (20–60 μg/ml) to the growth medium of unirradiatedEscherichia coli HCR⁺, HCR⁻, and irradiated HCR⁻ strains. These drugs increased mutation frequency and lethality of irradiated HCR⁺ bacteria. Incorporation of adenine (6 μm) into the minimal expression medium reverses the mutagenic effect of chloroquine. Chloroquine (50 μg/ml) did not interfere with the photoactivation of irradiated HCR⁺ cells. Our findings suggest that these chemicals selectively interfere with excision-repair.     

Molybdenum Content of Canadian and US Infant Formulas

Molybdenum is an essential trace nutrient in the human diet. Our purpose was to provide a comprehensive analysis of Mo content of various types of powdered infant formulas across Canada and the USA. All infant formulas, available on the day of sampling, were purchased from random supermarkets in Grand Forks, ND, USA; San Diego, CA, USA; Washington, DC, USA; and Winnipeg, MB, Canada. Reference powdered milk, human milk (HM), and formula samples were weighed and acid-digested prior to analysis by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectroscopy. Mo content in all formulas ranged from 15.4 to 80.3 μg/L (mean ± SE, 37.7 ± 1.7 μg/L). HM Mo concentration ranged from 1.5 to 9.5 μg/L (5.09 ± 0.81 μg/L). Formulas intended for full-term or for premature infants feeding contained, on average, more Mo than HM. Formulas intended for infants with special needs contained similar mean Mo levels to HM. No significant differences were detected between mean Mo values of formulas of a same type purchased from different brands and/or at different locations. High Mo intake may pose health risks, despite lower bioavailability of Mo from formula compared with HM.     

Production of recombinant human lysozyme in the milk of transgenic pigs

In the swine industry pathogenic infections have a significant negative impact on neonatal survival. Piglets fed with human lysozyme, a natural antibiotic, might be more resistant to gastrointestinal infections. Here we describe the generation of transgenic swine expressing recombinant human lysozyme by somatic cell nuclear transfer. Three cloned female pigs were born, one of which expressed rhLZ at 0.32 ± 0.01 μg/ml in milk, 50-fold higher than that of the pig native lysozyme. Both the transgenic gilts and their progeny appear healthy. Introducing human lysozyme into pigs’ milk has a potential to benefit the piglets by enhancing immune function and defending against pathogenic bacteria, thereby increasing the new born survival rate. This advance could be of great value to commercial swine producers.     

Selenium levels in infant milk formula

Twenty-four brands of commercial infant milk formula were collected and analysed for selenium by inductively coupled plasma spectrometry with the hydride t-system after an acid digestion procedure. The mean selenium concentration was 49.0 ± 11.55 g l, with a range from 26-68 g l, resulting in an adequate daily selenium intake for infants aged from zero to six months consuming 0.75 l milk daily as set by the US National Research Council in 1989.     

Zearalenone, deoxynivalenol and fumonisins in mixed-feed for laying hens

Fusarium toxins are secondary metabolites produced byfungi of these genera in many commodities under certain conditions. A study was carried out to investigate the co-occurrence of zearalenone (ZEN), deoxynivalenol (DON) and fumonisins (FB₁ and FB₂) in 52 samples of mixed-feed for poultry contaminated withFusarium verticillioides. The zearalenone and deoxynivalenol were checked using immunoaffinity column and the extraction of fumonisin was performed by strong anion exchange (SAX) solid phase column. Detection and quantification were determined by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The limit of detection was 5 μg/kg for ZEN, 100 μg/kg for DON and 50 and 100 μg/kg for FB₁ and FB₂ respectively.Fusarium toxins were detected in 20 samples. Sixteen samples were positive for ZEN (30.7%) presenting levels that ranged from 7.4 μg/kg to 61.4 μg/kg (mean=27.0 μg/kg). 13.5% of the samples presented contaminations of DON, with levels ranging from 100.0 μg/kg to 253 μg/kg (mean=l18.07 μg/kg). FB₁ was detected in 19.2% of samples, with levels ranging from 50.0 μg/kg to 110.0 μg/kg (mean=73.6 μg/kg). FB2 was not detected in any sample. In positive samples simultaneously contamination with two or three mycotoxins were detected in 9 of them (17.3%).     

Cadmium,cobalt, chromium,and experimental myocardial infarction

In the case of experimental heart muscle infarction, the infarcted tissue of 18 pigs had a cadmium content of 0.38 μg/g dry weight and a cobalt content of 0.45 μg/g dry weight. In 25 non-infarcted pig hearts, the cadmium concentration amounted to 0.27 μg/g dry weight and the cobalt concentration to 0.37 μg/g dry weight. Thus, as far as the infarcted heart muscle tissue is concerned, there is a highly significant increase in the cadmium content (p<0.01) and a significant increase in cobalt content (p<0.05) compared to a non-infarcted heart. No differences were established with regard to chromium concentrations.     

Aflatoxin B<Subscript>1</Subscript> in chilies from the Punjab region,Pakistan

The occurrence of aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) in chilies from Pakistan was determined by using HPLC in work undertaken in Pakistan. Whole (n = 22) and powdered (n = 22) chilies were analyzed. Sixteen (73.0%) and 19 (86.4%) samples of whole and ground chilies, respectively, were contaminated. The mean concentration in powdered chilies (32.20 μg/kg) was higher statistically than in whole chilies (24.69 μg/kg). Concentrations ranged from 0.00 to 89.56 μg/kg for powdered chilies, compared with 0.00–96.3 μg/kg for whole chilies. The limits of detection and quantification were 0.05 μg/kg and 0.53 μg/kg, respectively. The concentrations were high in general and greater than the statutory limit set by the European Union. There is considerable scope for improvements in chili production in Pakistan.     

Production, purification and characterization of a 50-kDa extracellular metalloprotease from Serratia marcescens

The extracellular metalloprotease (SMP 6.1) produced by a soil isolate of Serratia marcescens NRRL B-23112 was purified and characterized. SMP 6.1 was purified from the culture supernatant by ammonium sulfate precipitation, acetone fractional precipitation, and preparative isoelectric focusing. SMP 6.1 has a molecular mass of approximately 50 900 Da by sodium dodecyl sulfate/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE). The following substrates were hydrolyzed: casein, bovine serum albumin, and hide powder. SMP 6.1 has the characteristics of a metalloprotease, a pH optimum of 10.0, and a temperature optimum of 42° C. The isoelectric point of the protease is 6.1. Restoration of proteolytic activity by in-gel renaturation after SDS-PAGE indicates a single polypeptide chain. SMP 6.1 is inhibited by EDTA (9 μg/ml) and not inhibited by antipain dihydrochloride (120 μg/ml), aprotinin (4 μg/ml), bestatin (80 μg/ml), chymostatin (50 μg/ml), E-64 (20 μg/ml), leupeptin (4 μg/ml), Pefabloc SC (2000 μg/ml), pepstatin (4 μg/ml), phosphoramidon (660 μg/ml), or phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (400 μg/ml). SMP 6.1 retains full activity in the presence of SDS (1% w/v), Tween-20 (1% w/v), Triton X-100 (1% w/v), ethanol (5% v/v), and 2-mercaptoethanol (0.5% v/v). The extracellular metalloprotease SMP 6.1 differs from the serratiopeptidase (Sigma) produced by S. marcescens ATCC 27117 in the following characteristics: isoelectric point, peptide mapping and nematolytic properties. Received: 22 November 1996 / Received revision: 27 February 1997 / Accepted: 7 March 1997     

Expression of human serum albumin in the milk of transgenic mice

We have tested the feasibility of producing large quantities of human serum albumin (HSA) in the milk of transgenic livestock by generating transgenic mice as a model system. The sheep β-lactoglobulin (BLG) 5′-regulatory promoter sequences were used to support expression of BLG or HSA in transgenic mice. Transgenic animals generated from the entire BLG gene including 3, 5.5 or 10.8 kb of 5′-sequences demonstrated that 3 kb of 5′-sequences were sufficient to support high levels of expression of BLG, and that the longer 5′-sequences did not improve upon the levels of expression. As such, the 3 kb 5′-sequences were used to drive expression of HSA in BLG-HSA constructs. HSA was not detectably expressed in eight transgenic lines generated from a BLG-HSA construct containing the HSA cDNA. Two transgenic lines of 26 generated, using five different constructs, with an HSA minigene possessing the first intron expressed HSA in their milk. One of these expressed HSA at high levels (2.5 mg ml⁻¹) and has stably transmitted this ability to its progeny. A high percentage of transgenic mouse lines (four of six) generated from a vector containing an HSA minigene possessing introns 1 and 2 expressed HSA in their milk at levels which ranged from 1 to 35 μg ml⁻¹. In a similar trend, levels of expression of HSA by transfected tissue culture cells from BLG-HSA vectors containing an introduced SV40 enhancer were low with the HSA cDNA, increased with the HSA minigene with intron 1 and increased further with the minigene containing introns 1 and 2. This study demonstrates that high levels of HSA can be expressed in the milk of transgenic animals, that introns of the HSA gene play a role in its expression and that transfected cell lines may be used to quickly evaluate the relative expression efficiencies of various vector constructs intended for future transgenic evaluation.