Long-term effects of betamethasone on blood pressure and hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenocortical function in spontaneously hypertensive and normotensive rats

An enhanced hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenocortical (HPA) activity has been described during onset of elevated blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR). An instability of the HPA axis could thus contribute to the development of hypertension in these animals. Glucocorticoid effects on blood pressure and HPA function were studied therefore in SHR and normotensive Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) and Wistar rats. Beginning at 4 weeks of age, the rats were treated with 0.1 and 0.5 microgram betamethasone per milliliter drinking water for 7 weeks. SHR and WKY responded with a significant elevation in average blood pressure. In SHR, mean blood pressure rose from 181.4 +/- 3.9 (mean +/- SEM) to 203.1 +/- 2.8 mm Hg in response to the lower dose of betamethasone and to 209.2 +/- 4.0 mm Hg in response to 0.5 microgram betamethasone per milliliter drinking water. In WKY, blood pressure increased from 134.4 +/- 3.3 to 148.2 +/- 3.0 and 157.9 +/- 4.5 mm Hg in response to the lower and higher dose of betamethasone, respectively. No significant effect was seen in Wistar rats, where the mean blood pressure values changed insignificantly from 133.8 +/- 2.1 to 136.3 +/- 3.2 and 135.6 +/- 2.4 mm Hg. Stress-induced secretion of corticosterone was significantly suppressed in a dose-dependent manner in all three strains. Stress-induced secretion of adrenocorticotropin was markedly reduced by 0.5 microgram betamethasone per milliliter in SHR and by both doses in WKY. No significant effect, however, was seen in Wistar rats. A predisposition to the hypertensiogenic actions of glucocorticoids was found therefore in SHR and WKY, but not in Wistar rats.     

正常大鼠植入高血压大鼠肾脏后动脉血压的变化

本实验对12周龄的自发性高血压大鼠(spontaneouslyhypertensiverat,SHR)及其对照组WistarKyoto(WKY)大鼠进行了肾脏移植的研究,并观察受肾移植大鼠动脉血压的变化以及免疫抑制剂对动脉血压的影响。用尾套法对接受同窝另一同胞WKY大鼠肾脏移植且存活5周的6只WKY大鼠(A组)及接受SHR肾脏移植且存活5周的6只WKY大鼠(B组)的尾动脉收缩压进行检测,移植前A、B两组受肾移植大鼠的尾动脉收缩压分别为180±093和183±068kPa,无统计学显著差异(P>005);移植后3、4、5周时,B组大鼠的尾动脉收缩压显著高于A组大鼠,移植后5周时,A,B两组大鼠的收缩压分别为190±071和230±069kPa(P<0001);所用剂量的免疫抑制剂CsA对双侧肾脏完整以及右侧肾脏切除的SHR、WKY大鼠的动脉血压无显著影响。以上结果表明,SHR的肾脏在高血压的形成中可能起重要作用     

正常大鼠植入高血压大鼠肾脏后 动脉血压的变化

本实验对12周龄的自发性高血压大鼠(spontaneously hypertensive rat,SHR)及其对照组Wistar Kyoto (WKY)大鼠进行了肾脏移植的研究, 并观察受肾移植大鼠动脉血压的变化以及免疫抑制剂对动脉血压的影响。 用尾套法对接受同窝另一同胞WKY大鼠肾脏移植且存活5周的6只WKY大鼠(A组)及接受SHR肾脏移植且存活5周的6只WKY大鼠(B组)的尾动脉收缩压进行检测, 移植前A、 B两组受肾移植大鼠的尾动脉收缩压分别为18.0±0.93 和18.3±0.68 kPa,无统计学显著差异(P>0.05); 移植后3、 4、 5周时, B组大鼠的尾动脉收缩压显著高于A组大鼠, 移植后5周时, A, B两组大鼠的收缩压分别为19.0±0.71 和23.0±0.69 kPa (P<0.001); 所用剂量的免疫抑制剂CsA对双侧肾脏完整以及右侧肾脏切除的SHR、 WKY大鼠的动脉血压无显著影响。 以上结果表明, SHR的肾脏在高血压的形成中可能起重要作用。     

A possible explanation of genetic hypertension in the spontaneously hypertensive rat

Converting enzyme inhibitors prevent the development of hypertension and normalize arterial blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR), suggesting a critical role for angiotensin II in genetic hypertension. We hypothesized that the SHR is hyperresponsive to the slow-pressor effect of angiotensin II. To test this hypothesis, 14 SHR and 14 normotensive Wistar Kyoto rats (WKY) were treated chronically with captopril (100 mg X kg-1 X day-1 in drinking water) beginning at 5 weeks of age. At 9 weeks of age, either angiotensin II (125 ng/min; 7 SHR and 7 WKY) or vehicle (7 SHR and 7 WKY) was infused for 2 weeks via an osmotic minipump implanted into the peritoneal cavity. Captopril treatment was maintained and systolic blood pressure was monitored 3 times weekly. Although systolic blood pressure was similar in SHR and WKY infused with vehicle (101 +/- 2 versus 103 +/- 5 mmHg, respectively during the second week), systolic blood pressure in SHR treated with angiotensin II was much greater than systolic blood pressure in WKY treated with angiotensin II (193 +/- 9 versus 132 +/- 11 mmHg, respectively during the second week, p less than 0.001). These results indicate that compared to WKY, SHR are remarkably more sensitive to the slow-pressor effect of chronic, low-dose infusions of angiotensin II. Our results support the hypothesis that the critical genetic defect in SHR is a change in the sensitivity to the slow-pressor effect of angiotensin II.     

Increasing oxidative stress with molsidomine increases blood pressure in genetically hypertensive rats but not normotensive controls

Spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) have a higher level of oxidative stress and exhibit a greater depressor response to a superoxide scavenger, tempol, than normotensive Wistar-Kyoto rats (WKY). This study determined whether an increase in oxidative stress with a superoxide/NO donor, molsidomine, would amplify the blood pressure in SHR. Male SHR and WKY were given molsidomine (30 mg.kg(-1).day(-1)) or vehicle (0.01% ethanol) for 1 wk, and blood pressure, renal hemodynamics, nitrate and nitrite excretion (NOx), renal superoxide production, and expression of renal antioxidant enzymes, Mn- and Cu,Zn-SOD, catalase, and glutathione peroxidase (GPx), were measured. Renal superoxide and NOx were higher in control SHR than in WKY. Molsidomine increased superoxide by approximately 35% and NOx by 250% in both SHR and WKY. Mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) was also higher in control SHR than WKY. Molsidomine increased MAP by 14% and caused renal vasoconstriction in SHR but reduced MAP by 16%, with no effect on renal hemodynamics, in WKY. Renal expression of Mn- and Cu,Zn-SOD was not different between SHR and WKY, but expression of catalase and GPx were approximately 30% lower in kidney of SHR than WKY. The levels of Mn- and Cu,Zn-SOD were not increased with molsidomine in either WKY or SHR. Renal catalase and GPx expression was increased by 300-400% with molsidomine in WKY, but there was no effect in SHR. Increasing oxidative stress elevated blood pressure further in SHR but not WKY. WKY are likely protected because of higher bioavailable levels of NO and the ability to upregulate catalase and GPx.     

微小RNA在自发性高血压大鼠主动脉的差异表达

微小RNAs(microRNAs,miRNAs)是一类基因组编码、非蛋白质编码的小RNA,在转录后水平负性调节靶基因表达.本研究探讨miRNAs在自发性高血压大(spontaneously hypertensive rats,SHR)主动脉的表达特征及其与高血压的关系.取4、8、16和24周龄雄性SHR大鼠及同龄正常血压对照(Wistar-Kyoto,WKY)大鼠.MiRanda、TargetScan和PicTar用于候选miRNAs及靶基因预测分析.通过实时定量RT-PCR检测大鼠主动脉miR-1、miR-133a、miR-155及miR-208的表达,并进一步通过实时定量RT-PCR检测呈差异表达的miR-155和miR-208的预测靶基因mRNA表达.结果显示,SHR大鼠主动脉miR-155表达在4、8、24周时与同龄WKY大鼠无显著差异,但在16周时明显低于同龄WKY大鼠(P<0.05),且大鼠主动脉miR-155表达量与血压呈负相关(r=-0.525,P<0.05).MiR-208表达在4周龄时最高,随年龄增长明显下降(P<0.05),其表达水平与血压和年龄呈负相关(r=-0.400,P<0.05;r=-0.684,P<0.0001),但在SHR和WKY大鼠之间无显著差异.miR-1和miR-133a在各年龄组SHR和WKY大鼠间未呈现差异表达.MiR-155和miR-208表达与相应预测靶基因mRNA表达无显著负相关性.以上结果表明,miR-155表达在成年SHR大鼠主动脉明显低于WKY,并与血压呈负相关,提示miR-155可能参与高血压的发生发展,主动脉miR-155表达异常可能是SHR大鼠血压升高的原因之一.大鼠主动脉miR-208表达在幼年时最高,随年龄增长而明显下降,提示其可能与血管发育有关.     

Myocardial hypertrophy of normotensive Wistar-Kyoto rats

In our studies with spontaneously hypertensive (SHR), Wistar-Kyoto (WKY), and Wistar rats, we observed normotensive WKY rats with cardiac hypertrophy determined by a greater left ventricular (LV) mass (LVM)-to-body weight (BW) ratio (LVM/BW) than that of normotensive Wistar rats. Thus we compared the following parameters in SHR, WKY, and Wistar rats: LVM/BW, cell capacitance as index of total surface area of the myocytes, length, width, and cross-sectional area of cardiac myocytes, LV collagen volume fraction, and myocardial stiffness. The LVM/BW of WKY (2.41 +/- 0.03 mg/g, n = 41) was intermediate between SHR (2.82 +/- 0.04 mg/g, n = 47) and Wistar rats (1.98 +/- 0.04 mg/g, n = 28). A positive correlation between blood pressure and LVM was found in SHR, whereas no such relationship was observed in WKY or Wistar rats. Cell capacitance and cross-sectional area were not significantly different in SHR and WKY rats; these values were significantly higher than those of Wistar rats. The cell length was smaller but the width was similar in WKY compared with SHR. Papillary muscles isolated from the LV of WKY and SHR were stiffer than those from Wistar rats. Consistently, a greater level of myocardial fibrosis was detected in WKY and SHR compared with Wistar rats. These findings demonstrate blood pressure-independent cardiac hypertrophy in normotensive WKY rats.     

Opposite effect of methionine-supplemented diet, a model of hyperhomocysteinemia, on plasma and liver antioxidant status in normotensive and spontaneously hypertensive rats

Hyperhomocysteinemia is often associated with an increase in blood pressure. However our previous study has shown that methionine supplementation induced an increase in blood pressure in Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) rats and a decrease in blood pressure in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) with significant differences in plasma homocysteine (Hcy) metabolites levels. Previously liver antioxidant status has been shown to be decreased in SHR compared to WKY rats. It has been suggested that oxidative stress may predispose to a decrease in NO bioavailability and induce the flux of Hcy through the liver transsulfuration pathway. Thus the aim of this study was 1) to investigate the effect of methionine supplementation on NO-derived metabolites in plasma and urine 2) to investigate whether abnormalities in Hcy metabolism may be responsible for the discrepancies observed between WKY rats and SHR concerning blood pressure and 3) to investigate whether a methionine-enriched diet, differently modified plasma and liver antioxidant status in WKY rats an SHR. We conclude that the increase in blood pressure in WKY rats is related to high plasma cysteine levels and is not due to a decrease in NO bioavailability and that the decrease in blood pressure in SHR is associated with high plasma GSH levels after methionine supplementation. So GSH synthesis appears to be stimulated by liver oxidative stress and GSH is redistributed into blood in SHR. So the great GSH synthesis can be rationalized as an autocorrective response that leads to a decreased blood pressure in SHR.     

Antihypertensive effect of low ethanol intake in spontaneously hypertensive rats

Light to moderate drinking in humans lowers the risk of coronary heart disease and may lower blood pressure. We examined the effect of chronic low daily alcohol consumption on blood pressure, platelet cytosolic free calcium [Ca²⁺]_i, tissue aldehyde conjugates and renal vascular changes in normotensive Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) and spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR). We also examined the effects of the same weekly amount of alcohol consumption over a one day period each week simulating weekend drinking in humans. Animals, age 7 weeks, were divided into six groups of six animals each and were treated as follows: WKY and SHR control, normal drinking water; WKY and SHR, 0.5% ethanol in drinking water; WKY and SHR, 3.5% ethanol in drinking water one day/week. After 14 weeks systolic blood pressure, platelet [Ca²⁺]_i, liver, kidney and aortic aldehyde conjugates were significantly higher (p < 0.05) in untreated SHRs as compared to untreated WKYs. Daily 0.5% ethanol consumption in SHRs significantly (p < 0.05) attenuated these changes and also attenuated smooth muscle cell hyperplasia and narrowing of the lumen in small arteries and arterioles of the kidney. WKY rats treated with 0.5% ethanol had lower aldehyde conjugates without any significant effect on blood pressure and platelet [Ca²⁺]_i as compared to WKY controls. Consumption of 3.5% ethanol one day/week did not affect blood pressure and associated changes in normotensive WKY rats or hypertensive SHRs as compared to their respective controls. These results suggest that chronic daily low ethanol intake lowers blood pressure in SHRs by lowering tissue aldehyde conjugates and cytosolic free calcium.     

Indapamide-induced prevention of myocardial fibrosis in spontaneous hypertension rats is not nitric oxide-related

We studied the effect of thiazide-like diuretic--indapamide on fibrosis development in the left ventricle of young spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) and assessed the involvement of nitric oxide in this process. Six-week-old male SHR were treated with indapamide (1 mg/kg/day) for six weeks. Age-matched SHR were used as hypertensive and Wistar-Kyoto rats (WKY) as normotensive control. Systolic blood pressure was measured by tail-cuff plethysmography. Nitric oxide synthase (NOS) activity, protein expressions of endothelial (eNOS) and inducible NOS (iNOS), myocardial fibrosis and collagen type I and III were determined in the left ventricle. Indapamide treatment partially prevented SBP increase in SHR (SHR+Indapamide: 157+/-4, SHR: 171+/-3, WKY: 119+/-3 mmHg). Indapamide prevented myocardial fibrosis development in SHR, but without affecting collagen type I to type III ratio. Indapamide did not affect NOS activity as well as eNOS and iNOS protein expressions in the left ventricles evaluated by both Western blot and immunohistochemically. In conclusion, our results indicate that indapamide-induced prevention of myocardial fibrosis is not mediated by nitric oxide-related mechanism.     

The effect of prolonged infusion and withdrawal of angiotensin II in the spontaneously hypertensive rat

In spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) and their normotensive Wistar-Kyoto controls (WKY), prolonged intravenous administration of angiotensin II (AII, 0.2 microgram X kg-1 X min-1 for 3h) resulted in similar increases in arterial blood pressure. Heart rate decreased in WKY and increased in SHR. At the end of the infusion, blood pressure dropped substantially in SHR, but not in WKY: at 5 h after AII withdrawal, blood pressure in SHR had fallen from a control value of 172 +/- 3.3 to 146 +/- 3.9 mmHg (p less than 0.01), whereas pressure in WKY had fallen from 116 +/- 3.0 to 107 +/- 4.2 mmHg (statistically non significant). Thus, pressure at 5 h after AII withdrawal was still substantially higher (p less than 0.01) in the SHR than in the WKY. The results demonstrate that the fall in blood pressure following withdrawal of a prolonged infusion of AII in SHR is much less than that reported to occur following withdrawal of a prolonged infusion of vasopressin (AVP) in SHR.     

Chronic infusion of low doses of atrial natriuretic factor (ANF Arg 101-Tyr 126) reduces blood pressure in conscious SHR without apparent changes in sodium excretion

Conscious SHR and WKY rats were infused during 7 days with synthetic ANF (Arg 101-Tyr 126), 100 ng/hr/rat (35 pmol/hr/rat) by means of miniosmotic pumps. The SHR initial blood pressure of 177 +/- 5 mmHg gradually dropped to 133 +/- 3 and 142 +/- 4 mmHg the last two days of infusion. No significant change in blood pressure was observed in the ANF-infused WKY group. No apparent difference in natriuresis or diuresis was observed in ANF-infused SHR and WKY when compared with non-infused control groups. A slight but significant lower immunoreactive ANF concentration was found in the atria of SHR than in their normotensive controls. No difference in cardiac weight was found between infused and non-infused rats. It is suggested that the hypotensive response observed in SHR and not in WKY is due to a decrease in vascular peripheral resistance. Whether ANF is involved in the development and maintenance of high blood pressure in SHR remains to be elucidated.     

Enhanced ganglionic responses to substance P in spontaneously hypertensive rats

Intravenous injection of substance P (SP) increases blood pressure in normotensive rats by stimulating sympathetic ganglia. This study compared the effects of SP to increase renal nerve firing and blood pressure in normotensive and hypertensive rats treated with chlorisondamine. The increase in renal nerve firing was greatest in spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR), intermediate in Wistar rats, and least in Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) rats. Blood pressure was increased more in SHR than in Wistar rats. Blood pressure was not increased in WKY rats. Responses to the ganglionic stimulant 1,1-dimethyl-4-phenylpiperazinium were the same in the three strains. These results suggest that there is a selective increase in the action of SP on sympathetic ganglia of SHR and that ganglion responsiveness to SP is correlated with its effect on blood pressure.     

Effect of hypertension on the angiotensin II fibres arriving at the posterior lobe of the hypophysis of the rat. An immunohistochemical study

We studied immunohistochemically the posterior lobe of the hypophysis (PL) of 15-week-old spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) and of matched normotensive Wistar Kyoto rats (WKY), by using our own polyclonal antibody raised in mice against Angiotensin II (mouse-antiangiotensin II, MAAII). The blood pressure, water intake and volume of the PL were also recorded. The SHR rats were hypertensive, drank more water and showed a clear hypertrophy of their hypophysial PL. Also the PL of the SHR animals showed an increase in the immunoreactivity to the anti-angiotensin II antibody in the fibres arriving at the PL, with respect to the PL of WKY rats. This increase is compatible with the hyperactivity of the brain RAS, depletion of vasopressin content in the PL and increase in plasmatic levels of vasopressin described in SHR rats with respect to normotensive animals, as angiotensin II could locally stimulate vasopressin release to plasma from the neurohypophysis.     

Defective nitric oxide production impairs angiotensin II-induced Na-K-ATPase regulation in spontaneously hypertensive rats

Angiotensin (ANG) II via ANG II type 1 receptors (AT1R) activates renal sodium transporters including Na-K-ATPase and regulates sodium homeostasis and blood pressure. It is reported that at a high concentration, ANG II either inhibits or fails to stimulate Na-K-ATPase. However, the mechanisms for these phenomena are not clear. Here, we identified the signaling molecules involved in regulation of renal proximal tubular Na-K-ATPase at high ANG II concentrations. Proximal tubules from spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR) and Wistar-Kyoto (WKY) rats were incubated with low concentrations of ANG II (pM), which activated Na-K-ATPase in both the groups; however, the stimulation was more robust in SHR. A high concentration of ANG II (μM) failed to stimulate Na-K-ATPase in WKY rats. However, in SHR ANG II (μM) continued to stimulate Na-K-ATPase, which was sensitive to the AT1R antagonist candesartan. In the presence of N(G)-nitro-l-arginine methyl ester (l-NAME), a nitric oxide (NO) synthase (NOS) inhibitor, ANG II (μM) caused stimulation of Na-K-ATPase in proximal tubules of WKY rats while having no further stimulatory effect in SHR. ANG II (μM), via AT1R, increased proximal tubular NO levels in WKY rats but not in SHR. In SHR, NOS was uncoupled as incubation of proximal tubules with ANG II and l-arginine, a NOS substrate, caused superoxide generation only in SHR and not in WKY rats. The superoxide production in SHR was sensitive to l-NAME. There was exaggerated proximal tubular AT1R-G protein coupling and NAD(P)H oxidase activation in response to ANG II (μM) in proximal tubules of SHR compared with WKY rats. In SHR, inhibition of NADPH oxidase restored NOS coupling and ANG II-induced NO accumulation. In conclusion, at a high concentration ANG II (μM) activates renal NO signaling, which prevents stimulation of Na-K-ATPase in WKY rats. However, in SHR ANG II (μM) overstimulates NADPH oxidase, which impairs the NO system and leads to continued Na-K-ATPase activation.     

Increased sympathetic innervation in the cerebral and mesenteric arteries of hypertensive rats

The density of catecholamine-containing nerve fibers was studied in the cerebral and mesenteric arteries from normotensive Wistar-Kyoto rats (WKY), spontaneously hypertensive rats (SHR), and stroke-prone SHR (SHRSP) in the growing (SHR, WKY) and adult (SHR, SHRSP, WKY) animals. Cerebral arteries from SHR showed an increased adrenergic innervation from day 1. The nerve plexuses reached an adult pattern earlier in SHR than in WKY. The arteries from adult SHR and SHRSP (22 weeks old) showed a markedly higher nerve density than WKY. There was a positive linear correlation between blood pressure and nerve density for four cerebral arteries. The mesenteric arteries were not innervated at birth. However, hyperinnervation of these arteries in the SHR was already present at 10 days of age as compared with WKY. Sympathectomy with anti-nerve growth factor and guanethidine caused a complete disappearance of fluorescent fibers in the mesenteric arteries from SHR and WKY, and in the cerebral arteries of WKY. The same procedure caused only partial denervation of the cerebral arteries from hypertensive animals. We postulate that the increase in nerve density in the cerebral arteries from the hypertensive rats may contribute to the development of arterial hypertrophy in chronic hypertension through the trophic effect of the sympathetic innervation on vascular structure.     

Effects of a fructose-enriched diet on plasma insulin and triglyceride concentration in SHR and WKY rats

Significant increases (P less than 0.001) in plasma insulin and triglyceride concentrations and in blood pressure were seen when SHR and WKY rats ate a fructose-enriched diet for 14 days. However, all of the changes were significantly accentuated (P less than 0.02-0.001) in SHR rats. Specifically the increment in plasma insulin concentration following the fructose-enriched diet was 42 +/- 4 microU/ml in SHR as compared to 25 +/- 4 microU/ml in WKY rats (P less than 0.001). Plasma triglyceride concentrations also increased to a greater degree in response to fructose in SHR rats (260 +/- 24 vs. 136 +/- 20 mg/dl, P less than 0.001). Finally, the fructose-induced increase in blood pressure of 29 +/- 4 mm of Hg in SHR rats was greater (P less than 0.02) than that seen in WKY rats (19 +/- 2 mm of Hg). There was no change in plasma glucose concentration in response to the fructose diet. WKY rats gained more weight than did the SHR rats. Thus, although plasma triglyceride and insulin concentration and blood pressure increased when either WKY or SHR rats consumed a fructose enriched diet, the magnitude of these changes was greater in SHR rats.     

Vitamin E, membrane fluidity, and blood pressure in hypertensive and normotensive rats

Vitamin E treatment was found to lower blood pressure, and increase membrane fluidity in rats. The objectives of this study were to investigate the effects of the antioxidant, vitamin E, on the blood pressure and erythrocyte membrane fluidity in spontaneously hypertensive (SHR) and normotensive (WKY) rats. Membrane fluidity was assessed using spin labeling technique and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy. Two different spin labels were used in this study, 5-doxylstrearic acid (5-SASL) and 16-doxylstearic acid (16-SASL). The rats were given vitamin E, 3 days/week for 3 weeks and blood pressure was measured once weekly, using the tail-cuff method. Subsequently, blood was taken via heart puncture and erythrocytes were prepared for spin labeling. The fluidity of the membrane in the nonpolar region of erythrocytes from hypertensive rats was found quite different from that of normal rats as judged by the spectra of 16-SASL. The values of maximum splitting parameter of the EPR spectra of the spin label 5-SASL incorporated in erythrocyte membrane from both SHR and WKY rats, and the effects of vitamin E on membrane fluidity were compared. The maximum splitting parameter calculated from EPR spectra was larger for SHR than WKY rats. Additionally, the maximum splitting parameter calculated for vitamin E treated SHR and WKY rats were lower than those of their respective controls. As expected, the blood pressure of the SHR rats was found to be higher than that of the WKY rats. Vitamin E treated SHR and WKY rats showed significantly lower blood pressure than their controls.