Consensus predictions of membrane protein topology

We have explored the possibility that consensus predictions of membrane protein topology might provide a means to estimate the reliability of a predicted topology. Using five current topology prediction methods and a test set of 60 Escherichia coli inner membrane proteins with experimentally determined topologies, we find that prediction performance varies strongly with the number of methods that agree, and that the topology of nearly half of all E. coli inner membrane proteins can be predicted with high reliability (>90% correct predictions) by a simple majority-vote approach.     

Prediction of partial membrane protein topologies using a consensus approach

We have developed a method to reliably identify partial membrane protein topologies using the consensus of five topology prediction methods. When evaluated on a test set of experimentally characterized proteins, we find that approximately 90% of the partial consensus topologies are correctly predicted in membrane proteins from prokaryotic as well as eukaryotic organisms. Whole-genome analysis reveals that a reliable partial consensus topology can be predicted for approximately 70% of all membrane proteins in a typical bacterial genome and for approximately 55% of all membrane proteins in a typical eukaryotic genome. The average fraction of sequence length covered by a partial consensus topology is 44% for the prokaryotic proteins and 17% for the eukaryotic proteins in our test set, and similar numbers are found when the algorithm is applied to whole genomes. Reliably predicted partial topologies may simplify experimental determinations of membrane protein topology.     

Membrane topology of the Bacillus anthracis GerH germinant receptor proteins

Bacillus anthracis spores are the etiologic agent of anthrax. Nutrient germinant receptors (nGRs) packaged within the inner membrane of the spore sense the presence of specific stimuli in the environment and trigger the process of germination, quickly returning the bacterium to the metabolically active, vegetative bacillus. This ability to sense the host environment and initiate germination is a required step in the infectious cycle. The nGRs are comprised of three subunits: the A-, B-, and C-type proteins. To date there are limited structural data for the A- and B-type nGR subunits. Here the transmembrane topologies of the B. anthracis GerH(A), GerH(B), and GerH(C) proteins are presented. C-terminal green fluorescent protein (GFP) fusions to various lengths of the GerH proteins were overexpressed in vegetative bacteria, and the subcellular locations of these GFP fusion sites were analyzed by flow cytometry and protease sensitivity. GFP fusion to full-length GerH(C) confirmed that the C terminus of this protein is extracellular, as predicted. GerH(A) and GerH(B) were both predicted to be integral membrane proteins by topology modeling. Analysis of C-terminal GFP fusions to full-length GerH(B) and nine truncated GerH(B) proteins supports either an 8- or 10-transmembrane-domain topology. For GerH(A), C-terminal GFP fusions to full-length GerH(A) and six truncated GerH(A) proteins were consistent with a four-transmembrane-domain topology. Understanding the membrane topology of these proteins is an important step in determining potential ligand binding and protein-protein interaction domains, as well as providing new information for interpreting previous genetic work.     

膜蛋白的拓扑学

膜蛋白的拓扑学是研究膜蛋白三维结构的出发点．利用融合蛋白和化学修饰等实验技术已确定了很多膜蛋白的拓扑学．对膜蛋白的转运与插膜的研究确定可能存在两类插膜元件．对已知拓扑学的膜蛋白的统计分析以及蛋白质工程的研究表明存在膜蛋白拓扑学的内正规则．目前已形成预测膜蛋白的拓扑学的比较可靠的策略,这在反向生物学上具有重要意义.但要进行三维结构的预测还有许多路要走．     

Prediction by a neural network of outer membrane beta-strand protein topology.

An artificial neural network (NN) was trained to predict the topology of bacterial outer membrane (OM) beta-strand proteins. Specifically, the NN predicts the z-coordinate of Calpha atoms in a coordinate frame with the outer membrane in the xy-plane, such that low z-values indicate periplasmic turns, medium z-values indicate transmembrane beta-strands, and high z-values indicate extracellular loops. To obtain a training set, seven OM proteins (porins) with structures known to high resolution were aligned with their pores along the z-axis. The relationship between Calpha z-values and topology was thereby established. To predict the topology of other OM proteins, all seven porins were used for the training set. Z-values (topologies) were predicted for two porins with hitherto unknown structure and for OM proteins not belonging to the porin family, all with insignificant sequence homology to the training set. The results of topology prediction compare favorably with experimental topology data.     

GO-PROMTO illuminates protein membrane topologies of glycan biosynthetic enzymes in the Golgi apparatus of living tissues

The Golgi apparatus is the main site of glycan biosynthesis in eukaryotes. Better understanding of the membrane topology of the proteins and enzymes involved can impart new mechanistic insights into these processes. Publically available bioinformatic tools provide highly variable predictions of membrane topologies for given proteins. Therefore we devised a non-invasive experimental method by which the membrane topologies of Golgi-resident proteins can be determined in the Golgi apparatus in living tissues. A Golgi marker was used to construct a series of reporters based on the principle of bimolecular fluorescence complementation. The reporters and proteins of interest were recombinantly fused to split halves of yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) and transiently co-expressed with the reporters in the Nicotiana benthamiana leaf tissue. Output signals were binary, showing either the presence or absence of fluorescence with signal morphologies characteristic of the Golgi apparatus and endoplasmic reticulum (ER). The method allows prompt and robust determinations of membrane topologies of Golgi-resident proteins and is termed GO-PROMTO (for GOlgi PROtein Membrane TOpology). We applied GO-PROMTO to examine the topologies of proteins involved in the biosynthesis of plant cell wall polysaccharides including xyloglucan and arabinan. The results suggest the existence of novel biosynthetic mechanisms involving transports of intermediates across Golgi membranes.     

Multiple topogenic sequences determine the transmembrane orientation of the hepatitis B surface antigen.

To investigate the mechanism by which complex membrane proteins achieve their correct transmembrane orientation, we examined in detail the hepatitis B surface antigen for sequences which determine its membrane topology. The results demonstrated the presence of at least two kinds of topogenic elements: an N-terminal uncleaved signal sequence and an internal element containing both signal and stop-transfer function. Fusion of reporter groups to either end of the protein suggested that both termini are translocated across the membrane bilayer. We propose that this topology is generated by the conjoint action of both elements and involves a specifically oriented membrane insertion event mediated by the internal sequence. The functional properties of each element can be instructively compared with those of simpler membrane proteins and may provide insight into the generation of other complex protein topologies.     

Analysis of the role of interfacial tryptophan residues in controlling the topology of membrane proteins

Tryptophans have a high affinity for the membrane-water interface and have been suggested to play a role in determining the topology of membrane proteins. We investigated this potential role experimentally, using mutants of the single-spanning Pf3 coat protein, whose transmembrane topologies are sensitive to small changes in amino acid sequence. Mutants were constructed with varying numbers of tryptophans flanking the transmembrane region and translocation was assessed by an in vitro translation/translocation system. Translocation into Escherichia coli inner membrane vesicles could take place under a variety of experimental conditions, with co- or posttranslational assays and proton motive force-dependent or -independent mutants. It was found that translocation can even occur in pure lipid vesicles, under which conditions the tryptophans must directly interact with the lipids. However, under all these conditions tryptophans neither inhibited nor stimulated translocation, demonstrating that they do not affect topology and suggesting that this may be universal for tryptophans in membrane proteins. In contrast, we could demonstrate that lysines clearly prefer to stay on the cis-side of the membrane, in agreement with the positive-inside rule. A statistical analysis focusing on interfacially localized residues showed that in single-spanning membrane proteins lysines are indeed located on the inside, while tryptophans are preferentially localized at the outer interface. Since our experimental results show that the latter is not due to a topology-determining role, we propose instead that tryptophans fulfill a functional role as interfacially anchoring residues on the trans-side of the membrane.     

Membrane protein topology: effects of delta mu H+ on the translocation of charged residues explain the ''positive inside'' rule.

The membrane electrochemical potential is critical for the export of most periplasmic proteins in Escherichia coli. Its exact role during insertion of integral inner membrane proteins, however, remains obscure. Using derivatives of the inner membrane protein leader peptidase (Lep), we now show that the membrane potential appears to stimulate the membrane translocation of chain segments containing negatively charged residues, that positively charged regions appear to be more easily translocated in the absence of a potential, and that certain Lep constructs insert with different topologies in the presence and absence of a membrane potential, suggesting that the electrochemical potential introduces an asymmetry between the topological effects of positively and negatively charged amino acids during the process of membrane protein insertion in E. coli.     

The distribution of charged amino acids in mitochondrial inner-membrane proteins suggests different modes of membrane integration for nuclearly and mitochondrially encoded proteins.

We have analyzed the amino acid distribution in seven nuclearly encoded and five mitochondrially encoded inner membrane proteins with experimentally well characterized topologies. The mitochondrially encoded proteins conform to the 'positive inside' rule, i.e. they have many more positively charged residues in their non-translocated as compared to translocated domains. However, most of the nuclearly encoded proteins do not show such a bias but instead have a surprisingly skewed distribution of Glu residues with an almost ten times higher frequency in the intermembrane space than in the matrix domains. These findings suggest that some, but possibly not all, nuclearly encoded inner membrane proteins may insert into the membrane by a mechanism that does not depend on the distribution of positively charged amino acids.     

Outer membrane lipoprotein biogenesis: Lol is not the end

Bacterial lipoproteins are lipid-anchored proteins that contain acyl groups covalently attached to the N-terminal cysteine residue of the mature protein. Lipoproteins are synthesized in precursor form with an N-terminal signal sequence (SS) that targets translocation across the cytoplasmic or inner membrane (IM). Lipid modification and SS processing take place at the periplasmic face of the IM. Outer membrane (OM) lipoproteins take the localization of lipoproteins (Lol) export pathway, which ends with the insertion of the N-terminal lipid moiety into the inner leaflet of the OM. For many lipoproteins, the biogenesis pathway ends here. We provide examples of lipoproteins that adopt complex topologies in the OM that include transmembrane and surface-exposed domains. Biogenesis of such lipoproteins requires additional steps beyond the Lol pathway. In at least one case, lipoprotein sequences reach the cell surface by being threaded through the lumen of a beta-barrel protein in an assembly reaction that requires the heteropentomeric Bam complex. The inability to predict surface exposure reinforces the importance of experimental verification of lipoprotein topology and we will discuss some of the methods used to study OM protein topology.     

Anomalous Diffusion Induced by Cristae Geometry in the Inner Mitochondrial Membrane

Diffusion of inner membrane proteins is a prerequisite for correct functionality of mitochondria. The complicated structure of tubular, vesicular or flat cristae and their small connections to the inner boundary membrane impose constraints on the mobility of proteins making their diffusion a very complicated process. Therefore we investigate the molecular transport along the main mitochondrial axis using highly accurate computational methods. Diffusion is modeled on a curvilinear surface reproducing the shape of mitochondrial inner membrane (IM). Monte Carlo simulations are carried out for topologies resembling both tubular and lamellar cristae, for a range of physiologically viable crista sizes and densities. Geometrical confinement induces up to several-fold reduction in apparent mobility. IM surface curvature per se generates transient anomalous diffusion (TAD), while finite and stable values of projected diffusion coefficients are recovered in a quasi-normal regime for short- and long-time limits. In both these cases, a simple area-scaling law is found sufficient to explain limiting diffusion coefficients for permeable cristae junctions, while asymmetric reduction of the junction permeability leads to strong but predictable variations in molecular motion rate. A geometry-based model is given as an illustration for the time-dependence of diffusivity when IM has tubular topology. Implications for experimental observations of diffusion along mitochondria using methods of optical microscopy are drawn out: a non-homogenous power law is proposed as a suitable approach to TAD. The data demonstrate that if not taken into account appropriately, geometrical effects lead to significant misinterpretation of molecular mobility measurements in cellular curvilinear membranes.     

Predicting transmembrane protein topology with a hidden Markov model: application to complete genomes

We describe and validate a new membrane protein topology prediction method, TMHMM, based on a hidden Markov model. We present a detailed analysis of TMHMM's performance, and show that it correctly predicts 97-98 % of the transmembrane helices. Additionally, TMHMM can discriminate between soluble and membrane proteins with both specificity and sensitivity better than 99 %, although the accuracy drops when signal peptides are present. This high degree of accuracy allowed us to predict reliably integral membrane proteins in a large collection of genomes. Based on these predictions, we estimate that 20-30 % of all genes in most genomes encode membrane proteins, which is in agreement with previous estimates. We further discovered that proteins with N(in)-C(in) topologies are strongly preferred in all examined organisms, except Caenorhabditis elegans, where the large number of 7TM receptors increases the counts for N(out)-C(in) topologies. We discuss the possible relevance of this finding for our understanding of membrane protein assembly mechanisms. A TMHMM prediction service is available at http://www.cbs.dtu.dk/services/TMHMM/.     

Insertion of bitopic membrane proteins into the inner membrane of mitochondria involves an export step from the matrix

The mitochondrial inner membrane contains a large number of polytopic proteins that are derived from prokaryotic ancestors of mitochondria. Little is known about the intramitochondrial sorting of these proteins. We chose two proteins of known topology as examples to study the pathway of insertion into the inner membrane; Mrs2 and Yta10 are bitopic proteins that expose negatively charged loops of different complexity into the intermembrane space. Here we show that both Mrs2 and Yta10 transiently accumulate as sorting intermediates in the matrix before they integrate into the inner membrane. The sorting pathway of both proteins can be separated into two sequential reactions: (i) import into the matrix and (ii) insertion from the matrix into the inner membrane. The latter process was found to depend on the membrane potential and, in this respect, is similar to the insertion of membrane proteins in bacteria. A comparison of the charge distribution of intermembrane space loops in a variety of mitochondrial inner membrane proteins suggests that this mode of "conservative sorting" might be the typical insertion route for polytopic inner membrane proteins that originated from bacterial ancestors.     

Topology of IEP110, a component of the chloroplastic protein import machinery present in the inner envelope membrane.

Proteins from both the inner and outer envelope membranes are engaged in the recognition and translocation of precursor proteins into chloroplasts. A 110 kDa protein of the chloroplastic inner envelope membrane was identified as a component of the protein import apparatus by two methods. First, this protein was part of a 600 kDa complex generated by cross-linking of precursors trapped in the translocation process. Second, solubilization with detergents of chloroplasts containing trapped precursors resulted in the identification of a complex containing both radiolabeled precursor and IEP110. Trypsin treatment of intact purified chloroplasts was used to study the topology of IEP110. The protease treatment left the inner membrane intact while simultaneously degrading domains of inner envelope proteins exposed to the intermembrane space. About 90 kDa of IEP110 was proteolitically removed, indicating that large portions protrude into the intermembrane space. Hydropathy analysis of the protein sequence deduced from the isolated cDNA clone in addition to Western blot analysis using an antiserum of IEP110 specific to the N-terminal 20 kDa, suggests that the N-terminus serves to anchor the protein in the membrane. We speculate that IEP110 could be involved in the formation of translocation contact sites due to its specific topology.     

Identification and evolution of dual-topology membrane proteins

Integral membrane proteins are generally believed to have unique membrane topologies. However, it has been suggested that dual-topology proteins that adopt a mixture of two opposite orientations in the membrane may exist. Here we show that the membrane orientations of five dual-topology candidates identified in Escherichia coli are highly sensitive to changes in the distribution of positively charged residues, that genes in families containing dual-topology candidates occur in genomes either as pairs or as singletons and that gene pairs encode two oppositely oriented proteins whereas singletons encode dual-topology candidates. Our results provide strong support for the existence of dual-topology proteins and shed new light on the evolution of membrane-protein topology and structure.     

Examining protein translocation in cell-free systems and microinjected Xenopus oocytes

A variety of assays have been developed which permit rapid and unambiguous determination of the membrane topology adopted by newly synthesized proteins. Cell-free systems and microinjected Xenopus oocytes are two of the most attractive approaches for characterizing the elements in both the nascent polypeptide and the membrane which together determine the final orientation of the protein in the membrane. Careful analysis of the mechanism of protein translocation using these methods has revealed a number of unusual topologies. The applications of a number of different assays for endoplasmic reticulum membrane translocation are described for the most commonly used cell-free systems (wheat germ and reticulocyte lysate), as well as for microinjected Xenopus oocytes.     

Rapid exploration of the folding topology of helical membrane proteins using paramagnetic perturbation

An understanding of the folding states of α-helical membrane proteins in detergent systems is important for functional and structural studies of these proteins. Here, we present a rapid and simple method for identification of the folding topology and assembly of transmembrane helices using paramagnetic perturbation in nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. By monitoring the perturbation of signals from glycine residues located at specific sites, the folding topology and the assembly of transmembrane helices of membrane proteins were easily identified without time-consuming backbone assignment. This method is validated with Mistic (membrane-integrating sequence for translation of integral membrane protein constructs) of known structure as a reference protein. The folding topologies of two bacterial histidine kinase membrane proteins (SCO3062 and YbdK) were investigated by this method in dodecyl phosphocholine (DPC) micelles. Combing with analytical ultracentrifugation, we identified that the transmembrane domain of YbdK is present as a parallel dimer in DPC micelle. In contrast, the interaction of transmembrane domain of SCO3062 is not maintained in DPC micelle due to disruption of native structure of the periplasmic domain by DPC micelle.     

A redox-sensitive luciferase assay for determining the localization and topology of endoplasmic reticulum proteins

Correct localization and transmembrane topology are crucial for the proteins residing and functioning in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). We have developed a rapid and convenient assay, based on the redox-sensitive luciferase from Gaussia princeps (Gluc) and green fluorescence protein (GFP), to determine the localization or topology of ER proteins. Using the tandem Gluc-GFP reporter fused to different positions of a target protein, we successfully characterized the topologies of two ER transmembrane proteins Herp and HRD1 that are involved in the ER quality control system. This assay method may also be applicable to the proteins in secretory pathway, plasma membrane, and other compartments of cells.     

Influence of network topology on the elasticity of the red blood cell membrane skeleton.

A finite-element network model is used to investigate the influence of the topology of the red blood cell membrane skeleton on its macroscopic mechanical properties. Network topology is characterized by the number of spectrin oligomers per actin junction (phi a) and the number of spectrin dimers per self-association junction (phi s). If it is assumed that all associated spectrin is in tetrameric form, with six tetramers per actin junction (i.e., phi a = 6.0 and phi s = 2.0), then the topology of the skeleton may be modeled by a random Delaunay triangular network. Recent images of the RBC membrane skeleton suggest that the values for these topological parameters are in the range of 4.2 < phi a < 5.5 and 2.1 < phi s < 2.3. Model networks that simulate these realistic topologies exhibit values of the shear modulus that vary by more than an order of magnitude relative to triangular networks. This indicates that networks with relatively sparse nontriangular topologies may be needed to model the RBC membrane skeleton accurately. The model is also used to simulate skeletal alterations associated with hereditary spherocytosis and Southeast Asian ovalocytosis.