Invited Review: Pathogenesis of osteoporosis.

Patients with fragility fractures may have abnormalities in bone structural and material properties such as larger or smaller bone size, fewer and thinner trabeculae, thinned and porous cortices, and tissue mineral content that is either too high or too low. Bone models and remodels throughout life; however, with advancing age, less bone is replaced than was resorbed within each remodeling site. Estrogen deficiency at menopause increases remodeling intensity: a greater proportion of bone is remodeled on its endosteal (inner) surface, and within each of the many sites even more bone is lost as more bone is resorbed while less is replaced, accelerating architectural decay. In men, there is no midlife increase in remodeling. Bone loss within each remodeling site proceeds by reduced bone formation, producing trabecular and cortical thinning. Hypogonadism in 20-30% of elderly men contributes to bone loss. In both sexes, calcium malabsorption and secondary hyperparathyroidism increase remodeling: more bone is removed from an ever-diminishing bone mass. As bone is removed from the endosteal envelope, concurrent bone formation on the periosteal (outer) bone surface during aging partly offsets bone loss and increases bone's cross-sectional area. Periosteal apposition is less in women than in men; therefore, women have more net bone loss because they gain less on the periosteal surface, not because they resorb more on the endosteal surface. More women than men experience fractures because their smaller skeleton incurs greater architectural damage and adapts less by periosteal apposition.     

Computational simulation of spontaneous bone straightening in growing children

Periosteal surface pressures have been shown to inhibit bone formation and induce bone resorption, while tensile strains perpendicular to the periosteal surface have been shown to inhibit bone resorption and induce new bone deposition. A new computational model was developed to incorporate these experimental findings into simulations of spontaneous bone straightening in children with congenital posteromedial bowing of the tibia. Three-dimensional finite element models of the periosteum were used to determine the relationships between the defect angle and the distribution of bone surface pressures and strains due to growth-generated tensile strains in the periosteum. These relationships were incorporated into an iterative simulation to model development of a growing, bowed tibia with an initial defect angle of 27°. When periosteal loads were included in the simulation, the defect angle decreased to 10° after 2 years, and the bone straightened by an age of 25 years. When periosteal loads were not included in the simulation, the defect angle decreased to 23° after 2 years, and a defect angle of 9° remained at an age of 25 years. A “modeling drift” bone apposition/resorption pattern appeared only when periosteal loads were included. The results suggest that periosteal pressures and tensile strains induced by bone bowing can accelerate the process of bone straightening and lead to more complete correction of congenital bowing defects. Including the mechanobiological effects of periosteal surface loads in the simulations produced results similar to those seen clinically, with rapid straightening during the first few years of growth.     

Time course for bone formation with long-term external mechanical loading.

Increased mechanical loading of bone with the rat tibia four-point bending device stimulates bone formation on periosteal and endocortical surfaces. With long-term loading cell activity diminishes, and it has been reported that early gains in bone size may reverse. This study examined the time course for bone cellular and structural response after 6, 12, and 18 wk of loading at 1,200-1, 700 microstrain (muepsilon). Bone formation rates, measured by histomorphometry, were compared within groups, between loaded and contralateral nonloaded tibiae, and between weeks. Formation surface, mineral apposition rate, and bone formation rate on periosteal and endocortical surfaces were elevated after 6 wk of loading. By 12 wk of loading, periosteal and endocortical formation surface and endocortical mineral apposition rates were elevated. By 18 wk of loading, periosteal adaptation appeared complete, whereas endocortical mineral apposition rate remained elevated. No periosteal resorption was observed. Average thickness of new bone formed, from baseline to collection, was greater in loaded than nonloaded tibiae by week 6 and was maintained through week 18. Early increases in bone formation result in periosteal apposition of new bone that persists after formation ceases.     

Bone growth in length and width: the Yin and Yang of bone stability

Bone growth in length is primarily achieved through the action of chondrocytes in the proliferative and hypertrophic zones of the growth plate. Longitudinal growth is controlled by systemic, local paracrine and local mechanical factors. With regard to the latter, a feedback mechanism must exist which ensures that bone growth proceeds in the direction of the predominant mechanical forces. How this works is unknown at present. Bone growth in length is detrimental to bone stability, but this effect is counteracted by concomitant bone growth in width. This occurs through periosteal apposition, which is the responsibility of periosteal osteoblasts. The action of these cells is mainly controlled by local factors, with modulation by systemic agents. According to the mechanostat theory, periosteal apposition is regulated by mechanical requirements. An alternative model, called sizostat hypothesis, maintains that a master gene or set of genes regulate bone growth in width to reach a pre-programmed size, independent of mechanical requirements. The virtues of these two hypotheses have been the subject of much discussion, but experimental data are scarce. Future research will have to address the question how periosteal bone cells manage to integrate mechanical, hormonal and other input to shape bones that are as strong as they need to be.     

Endoscopic foreheadplasty: a histologic comparison of periosteal refixation after endoscopic versus bicoronal lift

Endoscopic brow lift techniques using temporary fixation rely on rapid readherence of the periosteum to calvarial bone. Little is known about the histologic events that occur during the early postoperative period after these procedures. An animal study was designed to compare and contrast periosteal fixation to bone and unelevated periosteum, with endoscopic and bicoronal brow lift techniques. One method of temporary fixation is the use of absorbable (polylactic/polyglycolic acid copolymer) LactoSorb screws; a histologic analysis of implanted LactoSorb screws was also performed. Sixteen rabbits underwent brow lifts; eight underwent endoscopic brow lift and fixation with LactoSorb screws without skin excision, and another eight underwent traditional bicoronal brow lift with skin excision and closure under tension. Animals were killed 1, 2, 6, and 12 weeks after the procedures were performed to evaluate the interaction of periosteum and bone and the normal, unelevated periosteum/calvarium interface at a site distant from the operative area. Histologic specimens were examined for the degree of apposition of periosteum to bone and for any fibrous or bony reaction at this interface. Histologic analysis showed various degrees of periosteal fibrosis and fixation to calvarial bone. After an initial phase of minimal periosteal adherence and moderate inflammation, the periosteum became progressively more adherent to bone in both groups, with no significant differences between treatment groups in rates of fixation. Fixation required at least 6 weeks. LactoSorb screws were surrounded by an area of mild inflammation and were progressively hydrolyzed and digested. Periosteal fixation increases over time for bicoronal and endoscopic brow lifts with minimal differences between the two techniques. With this animal model, periosteal adherence to calvarium requires at least 6 weeks with complete adherence by 12 weeks. In addition, the use of absorbable fixation screws seems to be both effective and well tolerated. The histologic changes associated with periosteal healing observed in this study suggest that permanent or semipermanent fixation may improve the accuracy and early postoperative maintenance of forehead advancement.     

Changes in femoral morphology during egg-laying in Alligator mississippiensis

Birds and many reptiles are egg-layers. Birds provide calcium for the formation of eggshells by resorbing medullary bone, which is laid down before ovulation. Turtles do not possess this mechanism and resorb structural bone to form eggshells. Femora from three groups of alligators (egg-laying females; quiescent, immature, or barren females; and males) were examined to determine if alligators, which are closely related to birds in evolution, resorb structural bone during the formation of eggshells as do turtles. Microradiographs of cross sections from femoral mid-shafts were analyzed for porosity, and the robusticity index of each femur was determined. Scanning electron micrographs of anorganic endosteal and periosteal femoral surfaces were analyzed to determine numbers of entrances of vascular canals, numbers of lacunae of osteoblasts, and types of femoral surfaces. Femora from egg-laying females were significantly less robust than those of other females or males, and sections of bone from the egg-layers were significantly more porous than those of the other groups. Scanning electron microscopy of anorganic femoral endosteal surfaces from egg-laying females revealed significantly more resorption areas when compared with males or non egg-laying females. Periosteal surfaces from egg-layers had significantly more resting and less bone-forming surface than those from the other groups. Results indicated that apposition of periosteal bone may have been reduced in egg-layers and that egg-laying alligators, like turtles, resorb endosteal structural bone, which may be used as a source of calcium for the formation of eggshells.     

Role of Calcitonin Gene-Related Peptide in Functional Adaptation of the Skeleton

Peptidergic sensory nerve fibers innervating bone and periosteum are rich in calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), an osteoanabolic neurotransmitter. There are two CGRP isoforms, CGRPα and CGRPβ. Sensory fibers are a potential means by which the nervous system may detect and respond to loading events within the skeleton. However, the functional role of the nervous system in the response of bone to mechanical loading is unclear. We used the ulna end-loading model to induce an adaptive modeling response in CGRPα and CGRPβ knockout mouse lines and their respective wildtype controls. For each knockout mouse line, groups of mice were treated with cyclic loading or sham-loading of the right ulna. A third group of mice received brachial plexus anesthesia (BPA) of the loaded limb before mechanical loading. Fluorochrome labels were administered at the time of loading and 7 days later. Ten days after loading, bone responses were quantified morphometrically. We hypothesized that CGRP signaling is required for normal mechanosensing and associated load-induced bone formation. We found that mechanically-induced activation of periosteal mineralizing surface in mice and associated blocking with BPA were eliminated by knockout of CGRPα signaling. This effect was not evident in CGRPβ knockout mice. We also found that mineral apposition responses to mechanical loading and associated BPA blocking were retained with CGRPα deletion. We conclude that activation of periosteal mineralizing surfaces in response to mechanical loading of bone is CGRPα-dependent in vivo. This suggests that release of CGRP from sensory peptidergic fibers in periosteum and bone has a functional role in load-induced bone formation.     

The inhibition of skeletal changes in a rat burn model with a local muscle flap

The effects of early wound closure using a local muscle flap on the development of periosteal new bone formation in a rat burn model were studied. Following a full-thickness burn to one hind limb, periosteal new bone formation along the tibial diaphysis was measured by the use of the fluorochrome agent calcein and an image-analysis system. Prostaglandin E levels, a known inflammatory mediator, from the bone beneath the burn also were measured. Periosteal new bone formation was inhibited by 50 percent in animals that had debridement and wound closure with a gastrocnemius muscle flap and skin graft on postburn day 2 compared to untreated controls or animals closed with skin grafts only. There was a trend toward reduced prostaglandin E measurements from tibial sections in the early closure group compared to untreated controls. This study demonstrates that early wound closure using a local muscle flap inhibits the periosteal new bone formation which is possibly associated with the inflammation in a rat burn model.     

Osteoclast bone resorption is enhanced in the presence of osteoblasts

Bone resorption activity by osteoclasts has been evaluated in a co-culture system in which osteoclasts have been plated in the presence of osteoblasts. The system prevents cell-cell contact but permits diffusion of molecules through the pores of a millipore membrane that separates the two compartments in which the two cell types have been plated. Results demonstrated that osteoblasts exert a stimulatory effect over osteoclast bone resorption due to soluble molecules capable of passing through the membrane pores. The effect is specific since periosteal cells, which do not express osteoblastic characteristics, fail to induce changes in the osteoclast activity. PTH does not affect osteoblast-mediated enhancement of bone resorption, indicating that the stimulatory effect that the hormone exert in vivo occurs via a different cellular system.     

Effects of age and occupation on cortical bone in a group of 18th-19th century British men

The effects of age and occupation on cortical bone in a group of adult males from the 18th-19th century AD skeletal collection from Christ Church Spitalfields, London, were investigated. Cortical bone was monitored using metacarpal radiogrammetry. Individual age at death was known exactly from coffin plates. Occupation for individuals was known from historical sources. Results showed that continued periosteal apposition was evident throughout adult life, but from middle age onwards this was outstripped by about 2:1 by endosteal resorption, so that there was net thinning of cortical bone. The rate of cortical thinning resembled that seen in modern European males. Cross-sectional properties, as measured by second moments of area, bore no relationship to occupation. The results may suggest that, firstly, patterns of loss of cortical bone have remained unchanged in males for at least two centuries in Britain, and secondly, that biomechanical analyses of metacarpal cortical bone may be rather insensitive indicators of intensity of manual activity.     

Reasons why dynamic compression plates are inferior to locking plates in osteoporotic bone: a finite element explanation

While locking plate fixation is becoming increasingly popular for complex and osteoporotic fractures, for many indications compression plating remains the standard choice. This study compares the mechanical behaviour of the more recent locking compression plate (LCP) device, with the traditional dynamic compression plates (DCPs) in bone of varying quality using finite element modelling. The bone properties considered include orthotropy, inhomogeneity, cortical thinning and periosteal apposition associated with osteoporosis. The effect of preloads induced by compression plating was included in the models. Two different fracture scenarios were modelled: one with complete reduction and one with a fracture gap. The results show that the preload arising in DCPs results in large principal strains in the bone all around the perimeter of the screw hole, whereas for LCPs large principal strains occur primarily on the side of the screw proximal to the load. The strains within the bone produced by the two screw types are similar in healthy bone with a reduced fracture gap; however, the DCP produces much larger strains in osteoporotic bone. In the presence of a fracture gap, the DCP results in a considerably larger region with high tensile strains and a slightly smaller region with high compressive strains. These findings provide a biomechanical basis for the reported improved performance of locking plates in poorer bone quality.     

Continuing periosteal apposition. II: The significance of peak bone mass, strain equilibrium, and age-related activity differentials for mechanical compensation in human tubular bones

It is generally presumed that compensation for the reduction of bone strength by progressive endosteal bone loss in adults is provided by continuing periosteal apposition (CPA) of new lamellar bone. However, the appropriate magnitude of compensatory bone growth, and the parameters that operate to determine that magnitude, are unknown. This paper examines the mechanical compensation hypothesis in a series of right-circular tubular bone analogues. Under this hypothesis, the stated objective of CPA is maintenance of the cross-sectional geometric properties of the element. These include the second and polar moments of area, as well as the cortical area of the section (I, J, and CA, respectively). This study assumes that, as resorption and apposition proceed, geometric change is isometric (shape preserving). The analysis suggests that for a given rate of endosteal bone loss (the stimulus), the magnitude of periosteal growth (the response) required to maintain geometric strength is determined by the maximum ratio (CT0) of the radial distances from the section centroid to the endosteal and periosteal surfaces (i.e., cortical thickness prior to the onset of progressive endosteal bone loss, or peak bone mass). The analysis also indicates that, for any given individual, the amount of compensatory periosteal gain required may be very small. This is particularly true for individuals having a large CT0 and for whom the magnitude of dynamic loading imparted to the skeleton declines with advancing age. This finding is illustrated in a model that relates concepts of bone surface remodeling equilibria and age-related activity differentials.     

Anisotropic mechanical properties of ovine femoral periosteum and the effects of cryopreservation

The mechanical properties of periosteum are not well characterized. An understanding of these properties is critical to predict the environment of pluripotent and osteochondroprogenitor cells that reside within the periosteum and that have been shown recently to exhibit a remarkably rapid capacity to generate bone de novo. Furthermore, the effects of cryopreservation on periosteal mechanical properties are currently unknown. We hypothesized that the periosteum is pre-stressed in situ and that the periosteum exhibits anisotropic material properties, e.g. the elastic modulus of the periosteum depends significantly on the direction of loading. We measured the change in area, axial length, and circumferential length of anterior, posterior, medial, and lateral fresh periosteal samples removed from underlying bone (t=0-16 h) as well as the average strain in axially and circumferentially oriented anterior periosteal samples subjected to tensile strain (0.004 mm/s) until failure. The elastic modulus was calculated from the resulting stress-strain curves. Tensile testing was repeated with axially aligned samples that had been slowly cryopreserved for comparison to fresh samples. Periosteal samples from all aspects shrank 44-54%, 33-47%, and 9-19% in area, axial length, and circumferential length, respectively. At any given time, the periosteum shrank significantly more in the axial direction than the circumferential direction. Tensile testing showed that the periosteum is highly anisotropic. When loaded axially, a compliant toe region of the stress-strain curve (1.93±0.14 MPa) is followed by a stiffer region until failure (25.67±6.87 MPa). When loaded circumferentially, no toe region is observable and the periosteum remained compliant until failure (4.41±1.21 MPa). Cryopreservation had no significant effect on the elastic modulus of the periosteum. As the periosteum serves as the bounding envelope of the femur, anisotropy in periosteal properties may play a key role in modulating bone growth, healing and adaptation, in health, disease, and trauma.     

Bone morphometrics and tetracycline marking patterns in young growing American alligators (Alligator mississippiensis)

Nine young American alligators (Alligator mississippiensis) were injected at monthly intervals with tetracycline to determine the bone apposition rate and the resorption patterns over a 3-mo period. The periosteal apposition rate increased progressively over the 3-mo period from 2.99 microns/day to 5.94 microns/day. Endosteal apposition rate was much slower with incomplete tetracycline lines being observed on the endosteum. This suggests that most modeling-resorptive activities occur on the endosteal envelope.     

Application of autologous periosteal cells for the regeneration of class III furcation defects in Beagle dogs

The aim of this study was to evaluate the healing of class III furcation defects following transplantation of autogenous periosteal cells combined with β-tricalcium phosphate (β-TCP). Periosteal cells obtained from Beagle dogs’ periosteum explant cultures, were inoculated onto the surface of β-TCP. Class III furcation defects were created in the mandibular premolars. Three experimental groups were used to test the defects’ healing: group A, β-TCP seeded with periosteal cells were transplanted into the defects; group B, β-TCP alone was used for defect filling; and group C, the defect was without filling materials. Twelve weeks post surgery, the tissue samples were collected for histology, immunohistology and X-ray examination. It was found that both the length of newly formed periodontal ligament and the area of newly formed alveolar bone in group A, were significantly increased compared with both group B and C. Furthermore, both the proportion of newly formed periodontal ligament and newly formed alveolar bone in group A were much higher than those of group B and C. The quantity of cementum and its percentage in the defects (group A) were also significantly higher than those of group C. These results indicate that autogenous periosteal cells combined with β-TCP application can improve periodontal tissue regeneration in class III furcation defects.     

An expanded overview of postmenopausal osteoporosis

Why is the incidence of osteoporotic fracture so much higher in women than in men? The dominant medical view holds that the exaggerated skeletal fragility and fracture risk of postmenopausal women solely reflects the loss of bone following withdrawal of endogenous estrogen. Indeed, an enormous amount of research in this area has attempted to understand the rise in fractures after menopause in terms of the impact of estrogen lack on bone remodeling. Recent insights suggest that this simple view does not offer an adequate explanation for the greater susceptibility of older women to fracture compared to that of men. It seems more reasonable to view bone health as a lifelong process, reflecting the contributions and influences of myriad events occurring throughout life to skeletal acquisition and maintenance. Only recently has the medical community recognized that the amount of bone present at skeletal maturity makes a powerful contribution to lifelong skeletal status. A second area that must be incorporated into discussions of this topic relates to bone size and geometry. Women's bones are inherently smaller than those of men. A bone's strength is determined by its size as well as by its material properties. In boys, pubertal increases in the cortical thickness of long bones are achieved by (testosterone-dependent) periosteal apposition. By contrast, increased cortical thickness in girls reflects bone expansion into the medullary space, with little or no periosteal apposition, suggesting an inhibitory effect of estrogen on the latter process. Consequently, at skeletal maturity, men have wider bones of greater mechanical competence. Although estrogen is generally held to be skeletally protective, this aspect of its actions may actually render women more susceptible to some fractures. In later life, men may lose even more bone from appendicular sites than do women, but men show much greater concomitant increases in periosteal apposition than women, permitting them to maintain a relatively favorable mechanical profile. These several findings are based on cross-sectional observations of relatively few individuals and therefore require confirmation in prospective longitudinal studies. The degree to which gender-related differences in later life skeletal adaptation reflects a bone's mechanical or metabolic environment has been frequently discussed but still awaits experimental confirmation.     

Size, structure and gender: lessons about fracture risk

The differences in age-related fracture risks among men and women must reflect gender differences in the relevant variables. We are concerned here with gender differences in structural variables that relate to the size and shape of bones. As children grow, their bones grow in diameter through periosteal modeling. Studies show that radial growth is driven by mechanical forces and is not just "genetically programmed". Moving bone mass farther from the center of the diaphysis makes it more effective in resisting bending and twisting forces, and disproportionately so in comparison to changes in bone mass. Gender differences in long bone structure appear to arise because the bone cells of males and females function in different hormonal environments which affect their responses to mechanical loading. In girls, bone formation on the metacarpal periosteal surface essentially stops at puberty, and is replaced by formation on the endosteal surface, reducing endosteal diameter until about age 20. Bone strength is 60% greater in male metacarpals than in those of females because bone is added periosteally in boys and endosteally in girls. At menopause endosteal resorption resumes, accompanied by slow periosteal apposition, weakening cortical structure. Similar phenomena occur in such critical regions as the femoral neck. Another fundamental gender difference in skeletal development is that whole body bone mineral content increases in linear proportion to lean body mass throughout skeletal maturation in boys, but in girls there is a distinct increase in the slope of this relationship at puberty, when estrogen rises. Frost's hypothesis is that this reflects an effect of estrogen on bone's mechanostat set point, and this is increasingly supported by data showing that estrogen and mechanical strain act through a common pathway in osteoblast-like cells. If Frost's hypothesis is correct, the mechanostat is set for maximal effect of mechanical loading on bone gain during the 2-3 years preceding menarche. During the childbearing years, the set point is at an intermediate level, and at menopause, it shifts again to place the skeleton into the metabolic equivalent of a disuse state. The most direct approach to resolving this problem would be to simulate the putative effect of estrogen on the set point itself.     

Periosteal biaxial residual strains correlate with bone specific growth rates in chick embryos

It has been proposed that periosteal residual tensile strains influence periosteal bone apposition and endochondral ossification. The role of bone growth rates on the development of residual strains is not well known. This study examined the relationships between specific growth rate and residual strains in chick tibiotarsi. We measured length and circumference during embryonic days 11-20 using microCT. Bones grew faster in length, with longitudinal and circumferential specific growth rates decreasing from 17 to 9% and 14 to 8% per day, respectively. To calculate residual strains, opening dimensions of incisions through the periosteum were analysed using finite element techniques. Results indicate that Poisson's ratio for an isotropic material model is between 0 and 0.04. For the model with Poisson's ratio 0.03, longitudinal and circumferential residual strains decreased from 46.2 to 29.3% and 10.6 to 3.9%, respectively, during embryonic days 14-20. Specific growth rates and residual strains were positively correlated (p<0.05).     

Ossification of the antler in the Lapland reindeer (Rangifer tarandus tarandus)

A histological and histochemical study of biopsy specimens from the Lapland reindeer antler indicated that the intercellular matrix of the cartilage that forms the partitions of longitudinal channels becomes calcified at virtually the initial stage of formation. The lacunae at the peripheries of the cartilaginous partitions are invaded by osteoblasts in a process comparable to endochondral ossification. The very centres of the partitions evidently become directly converted into bone without the presence of e.g. osteoclasts. The osseous partitions are remodelled by osteoclasts. The antler increases in diameter by periosteal apposition.     

The osteochondral ligament: a fibrous attachment between bone and articular cartilage in Rana catesbeiana

The anuran epiphyseal cartilage shows a lateral expansion that covers the external surface of the bone, besides other features that distinguish it from the corresponding avian and mammalian structures. The fibrous structure that attaches the lateral cartilage to the bone was characterized in this work. It was designated osteochondral ligament (OCL) and presented two main areas. There was an inner area that was closer to the periosteal bone and contained a layer of osteoblasts and elongated cells aligned to and interspersed with thin collagen fibers. The thin processes of the cells in this area showed strong alkaline phosphatase activity. The outer area, which was closer to the cartilage, was rich in blood vessels and contained a few cells amongst thick collagen fibers. TRITC-phaloidin staining showed the cells of the inner area to be rich in F-actin, and were observed to form a net around the cell nucleus and to fill the cell processes which extended between the collagen fibers. Cells of the outer area were poor in actin cytoskeleton, while those associated with the blood vessels showed intense staining. Tubulin-staining was weak, regardless of the OCL region. The main fibers of the extracellular matrix in the OCL extended obliquely upwards from the cartilage to the bone. The collagen fibers inserted into the bone matrix as Sharpey's fibers and became progressively thicker as they made their way through the outer area to the cartilage. Immunocytochemistry showed the presence of type I and type III collagen. Microfibrils were found around the cells and amongst the collagen fibrils. These microfibrils were composed of either type VI collagen or fibrilin, as shown by immunocytochemistry. The results presented in this paper show that the osteochondral ligament of Rana catesbeiana is a complex and specialized fibrous attachment which guarantees a strong and flexible anchorage of the lateral articular cartilage to the periosteal bone shaft, besides playing a role in bone growth.