Identifying protein-protein interfacial residues in heterocomplexes using residue conservation scores

Identifying protein–protein interfaces is crucial for structural biology. Because of the constraints in wet experiments, many computational methods have been proposed. Without knowing any information about the partner chains, a new method of predicting protein–protein interaction interface residues purely based on evolutionary information in heterocomplexes is proposed here. Unlike traditional approaches using multiple sequence alignment profiles to represent the conservation level for each residue, we make predictions based on the concept of residue conservation scores so that the dimension of the feature vector for each residue can be drastically reduced, at least 20 times less than conventional methods. Based on the representation approach, a simple linear discriminant function is used to make predictions, so the computational complexity of the whole prediction procedure can also be greatly decreased. By testing our approach on 69 heterocomplex chains, experimental results demonstrate the performance of our approach is indeed superior to current existing methods.     

REVCOM: a robust Bayesian method for evolutionary rate estimation

MOTIVATION: Evolutionary conservation estimated from a multiple sequence alignment is a powerful indicator of the functional significance of a residue and helps to predict active sites, ligand binding sites, and protein interaction interfaces. Many algorithms that calculate conservation work well, provided an accurate and balanced alignment is used. However, such a strong dependence on the alignment makes the results highly variable. We attempted to improve the conservation prediction algorithm by making it more robust and less sensitive to (1) local alignment errors, (2) overrepresentation of sequences in some branches and (3) occasional presence of unrelated sequences. RESULTS: A novel method is presented for robust constrained Bayesian estimation of evolutionary rates that avoids overfitting independent rates and satisfies the above requirements. The method is evaluated and compared with an entropy-based conservation measure on a set of 1494 protein interfaces. We demonstrated that approximately 62% of the analyzed protein interfaces are more conserved than the remaining surface at the 5% significance level. A consistent method to incorporate alignment reliability is proposed and demonstrated to reduce arbitrary variation of calculated rates upon inclusion of distantly related or unrelated sequences into the alignment.     

Entropy calculator: getting the best from your multiple protein alignments

Amino acid sequence alignment is an extremely useful tool in protein family analysis. Most family characteristics, such as the localization of functional residues, structural constraints and evolutionary relationships may be retrieved through the observation of the conservation pattern highlighted by the alignments. A quantitative score for the conservation in the alignment allows different stages of an alignment to be compared and consequently the alignment information to be efficiently exploited. Many scoring methods have been proposed during the last three decades. Claude Shannon's theory of communication (1948) paved the way for a consistent scoring of protein alignments by considering the residue (or symbol) frequency. A number of modifications have been proposed since that time, but the core statistical approach is still considered one of the best. By combining many database managing tools for treatment of protein sequences, a ClustalW software integration, a flexible symbols treatment and gap normalization functions, Entropy Calculator software has been developed. This new tool provides a global and optimal approach to multiple sequence alignment scoring by offering an easy graphic interface and a series of modification options that help in interpreting alignments and allow conservation pattern inferences to be performed.     

A scheme for multiple sequence alignment optimization—an improvement based on family representative mechanics features

As a basic tool of modern biology, sequence alignment can provide us useful information in fold, function, and active site of protein. For many cases, the increased quality of sequence alignment means a better performance. The motivation of present work is to increase ability of the existing scoring scheme/algorithm by considering residue-residue correlations better. Based on a coarse-grained approach, the hydrophobic force between each pair of residues is written out from protein sequence. It results in the construction of an intramolecular hydrophobic force network that describes the whole residue-residue interactions of each protein molecule, and characterizes protein's biological properties in the hydrophobic aspect. A former work has suggested that such network can characterize the top weighted feature regarding hydrophobicity. Moreover, for each homologous protein of a family, the corresponding network shares some common and representative family characters that eventually govern the conservation of biological properties during protein evolution. In present work, we score such family representative characters of a protein by the deviation of its intramolecular hydrophobic force network from that of background. Such score can assist the existing scoring schemes/algorithms, and boost up the ability of multiple sequences alignment, e.g. achieving a prominent increase (∼50%) in searching the structurally alike residue segments at a low identity level. As the theoretical basis is different, the present scheme can assist most existing algorithms, and improve their efficiency remarkably.     

Improved sensitivity of profile searches through the use of sequence weights and gap excision

Position-specific substitution matrices, known as profiles,derived from multiple sequence alignments are currently usedto search sequence databases for distantly related members ofprotein families. The performance of the database searches isenhanced by using (i) a sequence weighting scheme which assignshigher weights to more distantly related sequences based onbranch lengths derived from phylogenetic trees, (ii) exclusionof positions with mainly padding characters at sites of insertionsor deletions and (iii) the BLOSUM62 residue comparison matrix.A natural consequence of these modifications is an improvementin the alignment of new sequences to the profiles. However,the accuracy of the alignments can be further increased by employinga similarity residue comparison matrix. These developments areimplemented in a program called PROFILEWEIGHT which runs onUnix and Vax computers. The only input required by the programis the multiple sequence alignment. The output from PROFILEWEIGHTis a profile designed to be used by existing searching and alignmentprograms. Test results from database searches with four differentfamilies of proteins show the improved sensitivity of the weightedprofiles.     

Structural-based analysis of dihydrofolate reductase evolution

The evolution of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) was studied through a comprehensive structural-based analysis. An amino acid sequence alignment was generated from a superposition of experimentally determined X-ray crystal structures of wild-type (wt) DHFR from the Protein Data Bank (PDB). Using this structure-based alignment of DHFR, a metric was generated for the degree of conservation at each alignment site - not only in terms of amino acid residue, but also secondary structure, and residue class. A phylogenetic tree was generated using the alignment that compared favorably with the canonical phylogeny. This structure-based alignment was used to confirm that the degree of conservation of active-site residues in terms of both sequence as well as structure was significantly greater than non-active site residues. These results can be used in helping to understand the likely future evolution of DHFR in response to novel therapies.     

Are protein–protein interfaces more conserved in sequence than the rest of the protein surface?

Protein interfaces are thought to be distinguishable from the rest of the protein surface by their greater degree of residue conservation. We test the validity of this approach on an expanded set of 64 protein-protein interfaces using conservation scores derived from two multiple sequence alignment types, one of close homologs/orthologs and one of diverse homologs/paralogs. Overall, we find that the interface is slightly more conserved than the rest of the protein surface when using either alignment type, with alignments of diverse homologs showing marginally better discrimination. However, using a novel surface-patch definition, we find that the interface is rarely significantly more conserved than other surface patches when using either alignment type. When an interface is among the most conserved surface patches, it tends to be part of an enzyme active site. The most conserved surface patch overlaps with 39% (+/- 28%) and 36% (+/- 28%) of the actual interface for diverse and close homologs, respectively. Contrary to results obtained from smaller data sets, this work indicates that residue conservation is rarely sufficient for complete and accurate prediction of protein interfaces. Finally, we find that obligate interfaces differ from transient interfaces in that the former have significantly fewer alignment gaps at the interface than the rest of the protein surface, as well as having buried interface residues that are more conserved than partially buried interface residues.     

Grouping of amino acid types and extraction of amino acid properties from multiple sequence alignments using variance maximization

Understanding of amino acid type co-occurrence in trusted multiple sequence alignments is a prerequisite for improved sequence alignment and remote homology detection algorithms. Two objective approaches were used to investigate co-occurrence, both based on variance maximization of the weighted residue frequencies in columns taken from a large alignment database. The first approach discretely grouped amino acid types, and the second approach extracted orthogonal properties of amino acids using principal components analysis. The grouping results corresponded to amino acid physical properties such as side chain hydrophobicity, size, or backbone flexibility, and an optimal arrangement of approximately eight groups was observed. However, interpretation of the orthogonal properties was more complex. Although the principal components accounting for the largest variances exhibited modest correlations with hydrophobicity and conservation of glycine, in general principal components did not correspond to physical properties of amino acids. Although not intuitive, these amino acid mathematical properties were demonstrated to be robust and to improve local pairwise alignment accuracy, relative to 20 amino acid frequencies alone, for a simple test case.     

SEGA: semiglobal graph alignment for structure-based protein comparison

Comparative analysis is a topic of utmost importance in structural bioinformatics. Recently, a structural counterpart to sequence alignment, called multiple graph alignment, was introduced as a tool for the comparison of protein structures in general and protein binding sites in particular. Using approximate graph matching techniques, this method enables the identification of approximately conserved patterns in functionally related structures. In this paper, we introduce a new method for computing graph alignments motivated by two problems of the original approach, a conceptual and a computational one. First, the existing approach is of limited usefulness for structures that only share common substructures. Second, the goal to find a globally optimal alignment leads to an optimization problem that is computationally intractable. To overcome these disadvantages, we propose a semiglobal approach to graph alignment in analogy to semiglobal sequence alignment that combines the advantages of local and global graph matching.     

A new method for quantifying residue conservation and its applications to the protein folding nucleus

The conservation of residues in columns of a multiple sequence alignment (MSA) reflects the importance of these residues for maintaining the structure and function of a protein. To date, many scores have been suggested for quantifying residue conservation, but none has achieved the full rigor both in biology and statistics. In this paper, we present a new approach for measuring the evolutionary conservation at aligned positions. Our conservation measure is related to the logarithmic probabilities for aligned positions, and combines the physicochemical properties and the frequencies of amino acids. Such a measure is both biologically and statistically meaningful. For testing the relationship between an amino acid's evolutionary conservation and its role in the Phi-value defined protein folding kinetics, our results indicate that the folding nucleus residues may not be significantly more conserved than other residues by using the biological-relevance weighted statistical scoring method suggested in this paper as an alternative to entropy-based procedures.     

PSAR: measuring multiple sequence alignment reliability by probabilistic sampling

Multiple sequence alignment, which is of fundamental importance for comparative genomics, is a difficult problem and error-prone. Therefore, it is essential to measure the reliability of the alignments and incorporate it into downstream analyses. We propose a new probabilistic sampling-based alignment reliability (PSAR) score. Instead of relying on heuristic assumptions, such as the correlation between alignment quality and guide tree uncertainty in progressive alignment methods, we directly generate suboptimal alignments from an input multiple sequence alignment by a probabilistic sampling method, and compute the agreement of the input alignment with the suboptimal alignments as the alignment reliability score. We construct the suboptimal alignments by an approximate method that is based on pairwise comparisons between each single sequence and the sub-alignment of the input alignment where the chosen sequence is left out. By using simulation-based benchmarks, we find that our approach is superior to existing ones, supporting that the suboptimal alignments are highly informative source for assessing alignment reliability. We apply the PSAR method to the alignments in the UCSC Genome Browser to measure the reliability of alignments in different types of regions, such as coding exons and conserved non-coding regions, and use it to guide cross-species conservation study.     

Multiple protein sequence alignment from tertiary structure comparison: assignment of global and residue confidence levels.

An algorithm is presented for the accurate and rapid generation of multiple protein sequence alignments from tertiary structure comparisons. A preliminary multiple sequence alignment is performed using sequence information, which then determines an initial superposition of the structures. A structure comparison algorithm is applied to all pairs of proteins in the superimposed set and a similarity tree calculated. Multiple sequence alignments are then generated by following the tree from the branches to the root. At each branchpoint of the tree, a structure-based sequence alignment and coordinate transformations are output, with the multiple alignment of all structures output at the root. The algorithm encoded in STAMP (STructural Alignment of Multiple Proteins) is shown to give alignments in good agreement with published structural accounts within the dehydrogenase fold domains, globins, and serine proteinases. In order to reduce the need for visual verification, two similarity indices are introduced to determine the quality of each generated structural alignment. Sc quantifies the global structural similarity between pairs or groups of proteins, whereas Pij' provides a normalized measure of the confidence in the alignment of each residue. STAMP alignments have the quality of each alignment characterized by Sc and Pij' values and thus provide a reproducible resource for studies of residue conservation within structural motifs.     

Are residues in a protein folding nucleus evolutionarily conserved?

Protein is the working molecule of the cell, and evolution is the hallmark of life. It is important to understand how protein folding and evolution influence each other. Several studies correlating experimental measurement of residue participation in folding nucleus and sequence conservation have reached different conclusions. These studies are based on assessment of sequence conservation at folding nucleus sites using entropy or relative entropy measurement derived from multiple sequence alignment. Here we report analysis of conservation of folding nucleus using an evolutionary model alternative to entropy-based approaches. We employ a continuous time Markov model of codon substitution to distinguish mutation fixed by evolution and mutation fixed by chance. This model takes into account bias in codon frequency, bias-favoring transition over transversion, as well as explicit phylogenetic information. We measure selection pressure using the ratio omega of synonymous versus non-synonymous substitution at individual residue site. The omega-values are estimated using the PAML method, a maximum-likelihood estimator. Our results show that there is little correlation between the extent of kinetic participation in protein folding nucleus as measured by experimental phi-value and selection pressure as measured by omega-value. In addition, two randomization tests failed to show that folding nucleus residues are significantly more conserved than the whole protein, or the median omega value of all residues in the protein. These results suggest that at the level of codon substitution, there is no indication that folding nucleus residues are significantly more conserved than other residues. We further reconstruct candidate ancestral residues of the folding nucleus and suggest possible test tube mutation studies for testing folding behavior of ancient folding nucleus.     

SQUARE--determining reliable regions in sequence alignments

The Server for Quick Alignment Reliability Evaluation (SQUARE) is a Web-based version of the method we developed to predict regions of reliably aligned residues in sequence alignments. Given an alignment between a query sequence and a sequence of known structure, SQUARE is able to predict which residues are reliably aligned. The server accesses a database of profiles of sequences of known three-dimensional structures in order to calculate the scores for each residue in the alignment. SQUARE produces a graphical output of the residue profile-derived alignment scores along with an indication of the reliability of the alignment. In addition, the scores can be compared against template secondary structure, conserved residues and important sites.     

Predicting protein interaction sites from residue spatial sequence profile and evolution rate

This paper proposes a novel method that can predict protein interaction sites in heterocomplexes using residue spatial sequence profile and evolution rate approaches. The former represents the information of multiple sequence alignments while the latter corresponds to a residue's evolutionary conservation score based on a phylogenetic tree. Three predictors using a support vector machines algorithm are constructed to predict whether a surface residue is a part of a protein-protein interface. The efficiency and the effectiveness of our proposed approach is verified by its better prediction performance compared with other models. The study is based on a non-redundant data set of heterodimers consisting of 69 protein chains.     

Automated detection of remote homology

The classification of a newly identified protein as a member of a superfamily is important for focusing experiments on its most likely functions. Such classification, often performed by hand, has now been fully automated. This sophisticated new approach takes into account not only alignment scores but also a number of other computable attributes, such as functional sites deduced from sequence conservation patterns.     

Accurate Prediction of Protein Catalytic Residues by Side Chain Orientation and Residue Contact Density

Prediction of protein catalytic residues provides useful information for the studies of protein functions. Most of the existing methods combine both structure and sequence information but heavily rely on sequence conservation from multiple sequence alignments. The contribution of structure information is usually less than that of sequence conservation in existing methods. We found a novel structure feature, residue side chain orientation, which is the first structure-based feature that achieves prediction results comparable to that of evolutionary sequence conservation. We developed a structure-based method, Enzyme Catalytic residue SIde-chain Arrangement (EXIA), which is based on residue side chain orientations and backbone flexibility of protein structure. The prediction that uses EXIA outperforms existing structure-based features. The prediction quality of combing EXIA and sequence conservation exceeds that of the state-of-the-art prediction methods. EXIA is designed to predict catalytic residues from single protein structure without needing sequence or structure alignments. It provides invaluable information when there is no sufficient or reliable homology information for target protein. We found that catalytic residues have very special side chain orientation and designed the EXIA method based on the newly discovered feature. It was also found that EXIA performs well for a dataset of enzymes without any bounded ligand in their crystallographic structures.     

细胞色素P450超家族蛋白质基于结构知识的序列联配

应用计算机程序对细胞色素Ｐ４５０蛋白２０个家族的代表序列进行初步多序列联配后,利用结构知识对匹配结果加以调整,调整的依据是Ｐ４５０蛋白二级结构特征和某些超二级结构特征的保守性,三维结构空间配置的保守性,在结构与功能重要残基的保守性,亲水和疏水片段的保守性。大量定点突变实验、选择性化学修饰实验、抗多肽抗体结合实验等能很好地确证该联配结果的正确性。联配结果对真核Ｐ４５０蛋白膜结合方式、活性位点残基分布、与氧化还原偶联蛋白有相互作用的残基的分布等作出了合理的推断。细胞色素Ｐ４５０超家族蛋白基于结构知识的序列联配的尝试对Ｐ４５０蛋白结构与功能关系研究提供了参考