Comparative ecophysiology of C3 and C4 plants

Abstract. In this review we relate the physiological significance of C₄ photosynthesis to plant performance in nature. We begin with an examination of the physiological consequences of the C₄ pathway on photosynthesis, then discuss the ecophysiological performance of C₄ plants in contrasting environments. We then compare the performance of C₃ and C₄ plants when they occur together in similar habitats, and finally discuss the distribution of C₄ photosynthesis with respect to the physical environment, phylogeny, and life form.     

C4 photosynthesis in a single C3 cell is theoretically inefficient but may ameliorate internal CO2 diffusion limitations of C3 leaves

Attempts are being made to introduce C₄ photosynthetic characteristics into C₃ crop plants by genetic manipulation. This research has focused on engineering single‐celled C₄‐type CO₂ concentrating mechanisms into C₃ plants such as rice. Herein the pros and cons of such approaches are discussed with a focus on CO₂ diffusion, utilizing a mathematical model of single‐cell C₄ photosynthesis. It is shown that a high bundle sheath resistance to CO₂ diffusion is an essential feature of energy‐efficient C₄ photosynthesis. The large chloroplast surface area appressed to the intercellular airspace in C₃ leaves generates low internal resistance to CO₂ diffusion, thereby limiting the energy efficiency of a single‐cell C₄ concentrating mechanism, which relies on concentrating CO₂ within chloroplasts of C₃ leaves. Nevertheless the model demonstrates that the drop in CO₂ partial pressure, pCO₂, that exists between intercellular airspace and chloroplasts in C₃ leaves at high photosynthetic rates, can be reversed under high irradiance when energy is not limiting. The model shows that this is particularly effective at lower intercellular pCO₂. Such a system may therefore be of benefit in water‐limited conditions when stomata are closed and low intercellular pCO₂ increases photorespiration.     

Extension of a biochemical model for the generalized stoichiometry of electron transport limited C3 photosynthesis

The widely used steady‐state model of Farquhar et al. (Planta 149: 78–90, 1980) for C₃ photosynthesis was developed on the basis of linear whole‐chain (non‐cyclic) electron transport. In this model, calculation of the RuBP‐regeneration limited CO₂‐assimilation rate depends on whether it is insufficient ATP or NADPH that causes electron transport limitation. A new, generalized equation that allows co‐limitation of NADPH and ATP on electron transport is presented herein. The model is based on the assumption that other thylakoid pathways (the Q‐cycle, cyclic photophosphorylation, and pseudocyclic electron transport) interplay with the linear chain to co‐contribute to a balanced production of NADPH and ATP as required by stromal metabolism. The original model assuming linear electron transport limited either by NADPH or by ATP, predicts quantum yields for CO₂ uptake that represent the highest and the lowest values, respectively, of the range given by the new equation. The applicability of the new equation is illustrated for a number of C₃ crop species, by curve fitting to gas exchange data in the literature. In comparison with the original model, the new model enables analysis of photosynthetic regulation via the electron transport pathways in response to environmental stresses.     

The photosynthesis of young Panicum C4 leaves is not C3-like

Evidence is presented contrary to the suggestion that C₄ plants grow larger at elevated CO₂ because the C₄ pathway of young C₄ leaves has C₃-like characteristics, making their photosynthesis O₂ sensitive and responsive to high CO₂. We combined PAM fluorescence with gas exchange measurements to examine the O₂ dependence of photosynthesis in young and mature leaves of Panicum antidotale (C₄, NADP-ME) and P. coloratum (C₄, NAD-ME), at an intercellular CO₂ concentration of 5 Pa. P. laxum (C₃) was used for comparison. The young C₄ leaves had CO₂ and light response curves typical of C₄ photosynthesis. When the O₂ concentration was gradually increased between 2 and 40%, CO₂ assimilation rates (A) of both mature and young C₄ leaves were little affected, while the ratio of the quantum yield of photosystem II to that of CO₂ assimilation (Φ_PSII/Φ_CO2) increased more in young (up to 31%) than mature (up to 10%) C₄ leaves. A of C₃ leaves decreased by 1·3 and Φ_PSII/Φ_CO2 increased by 9-fold, over the same range of O₂ concentrations. Larger increases in electron transport requirements in young, relative to mature, C₄ leaves at low CO₂ are indicative of greater O₂ sensitivity of photorespiration. Photosynthesis modelling showed that young C₄ leaves have lower bundle sheath CO₂ concentration, brought about by higher bundle sheath conductance relative to the activity of the C₄ and C₃ cycles and/or lower ratio of activities of the C₄ to C₃ cycles.     

Low-temperature photosynthetic performance of a C4 grass and a co-occurring C3 grass native to high latitudes

The photosynthetic performance of C₄ plants is generally inferior to that of C₃ species at low temperatures, but the reasons for this are unclear. The present study investigated the hypothesis that the capacity of Rubisco, which largely reflects Rubisco content, limits C₄ photosynthesis at suboptimal temperatures. Photosynthetic gas exchange, chlorophyll a fluorescence, and the in vitro activity of Rubisco between 5 and 35 °C were measured to examine the nature of the low‐temperature photosynthetic performance of the co‐occurring high latitude grasses, Muhlenbergia glomerata (C₄) and Calamogrostis canadensis (C₃). Plants were grown under cool (14/10 °C) and warm (26/22 °C) temperature regimes to examine whether acclimation to cool temperature alters patterns of photosynthetic limitation. Low‐temperature acclimation reduced photosynthetic rates in both species. The catalytic site concentration of Rubisco was approximately 5.0 and 20 µmol m^?2 in M. glomerata and C. canadensis, respectively, regardless of growth temperature. In both species, in vivo electron transport rates below the thermal optimum exceeded what was necessary to support photosynthesis. In warm‐grown C. canadensis, the photosynthesis rate below 15 °C was unaffected by a 90% reduction in O₂ content, indicating photosynthetic capacity was limited by the capacity of P_i‐regeneration. By contrast, the rate of photosynthesis in C. canadensis plants grown at the cooler temperatures was stimulated 20–30% by O₂ reduction, indicating the P_i‐regeneration limitation was removed during low‐temperature acclimation. In M. glomerata, in vitro Rubisco activity and gross CO₂ assimilation rate were equivalent below 25 °C, indicating that the capacity of the enzyme is a major rate limiting step during C₄ photosynthesis at cool temperatures.     

Mesophyll cell properties for some C3 and C4 species with high photosynthetic rates

Leaves of twelve C₃ species and six C₄ species were examined to understand better the relationship between mesophyll cell properties and the generally high photosynthetic rates of these plants. The CO₂ diffusion conductance expressed per unit mesophyll cell surface area (g_CO2^cell) cell was determined using measurements of the net rate of CO₂ uptake, water vapor conductance, and the ratio of mesophyll cell surface area to leaf surface area (A^mes/A). A^mes/A averaged 31 for the C₃ species and 16 for the C₄ species. For the C₃ species g_CO2^cell ranged from 0.12 to 0.32 mm s^-1, and for the C₄ species it ranged from 0.55 to 1.5 mm s^-1, exceeding a previously predicted maximum of 0.5 mm s^-1. Although the C₃ species Cammissonia claviformis did not have the highest g_CO2^cell, the combination of the highest A^mes and highest stomatal conductance resulted in this species having the greatest maximum rate of CO₂ uptake in low oxygen, 93 μmol m^-2 s^-1 (147 mg dm^-2 h^-1). The high g_CO2^cell of the C₄ species Amaranthus retroflexus (1.5 mm s^-1) was in part attributable to its thin cell wall (72 nm thick).     

On the significance of C3—C4 intermediate photosynthesis to the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Abstract Evidence is drawn from previous studies to argue that C₃—C₄ intermediate plants are evolutionary intermediates, evolving from fully-expressed C₃ plants towards fully-expressed C₄ plants. On the basis of this conclusion, C₃—C₄ intermediates are examined to elucidate possible patterns that have been followed during the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. An hypothesis is proposed that the initial step in C₄-evolution was the development of bundle-sheath metabolism that reduced apparent photorespiration by an efficient recycling of CO₂ using RuBP carboxylase. The CO₂-recycling mechanism appears to involve the differential compartmentation of glycine decarboxylase between mesophyll and bundle-sheath cells, such that most of the activity is in the bundlesheath cells. Subsequently, elevated phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) carboxylase activities are proposed to have evolved as a means of enhancing the recycling of photorespired CO₂. As the activity of PEP carboxylase increased to higher values, other enzymes in the C₄-pathway are proposed to have increased in activity to facilitate the processing of the products of C₄-assimilation and provide PEP substrate to PEP carboxylase with greater efficiency. Initially, such a ‘C₄-cycle’ would not have been differentially compartmentalized between mesophyll and bundlesheath cells as is typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Such metabolism would have limited benefit in terms of concentrating CO₂ at RuBP carboxylase and, therefore, also be of little benefit for improving water- and nitrogen-use efficiencies. However, the development of such a limited C₄-cycle would have represented a preadaptation capable of evolving into the leaf biochemistry typical of fully-expressed C₄ plants. Thus, during the initial stages of C₄-evolution it is proposed that improvements in photorespiratory CO₂-loss and their influence on increasing the rate of net CO₂ assimilation per unit leaf area represented the evolutionary ‘driving-force’. Improved resourceuse efficiency resulting from an efficient CO₂-concentrating mechanism is proposed as the driving force during the later stages.     

Models of carbon metabolism in C3-C4 intermediate plants as applied to the evolution of C4 photosynthesis

Abstract Models developed to explain the biphasic response of CO₂ compensation concentration to O₂ concentration and the C₃-like carbon isotope discrimination in C₃-C₄ intermediate species are used to characterize quantitatively the steps necessary in the evolution of C₄ photosynthesis. The evolutionary stages are indicated by model outputs, CO₂ compensation concentration and δ₁₃C value. The transition from intermediate plants to C₄ plants requires the complete formation of C₄ cycle capacity, expressed by the models as transition from C₄ cycle limitation by phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) regeneration rate to limitation by PEP carboxylase activity. Other steps refer to CO₂ leakage from bundle sheath cells, to further augmentations of C₄ cycle components, to the repression of ribulose-1,5-bisphos-phate carboxylase in the mesophyll cells, and to a decrease in the CO₂ affinity of the enzyme. Possibilities of extending the suggested approach to other physiological characteristics, and the adaptive significance of the steps envisaged, are discussed.     

Stomatal acclimation over a subambient to elevated CO2 gradient in a C3/C4 grassland

An investigation to determine whether stomatal acclimation to [CO₂] occurred in C₃/C₄ grassland plants grown across a range of [CO₂] (200–550 µmol mol^?1) in the field was carried out. Acclimation was assessed by measuring the response of stomatal conductance (g_s) to a range of intercellular CO₂ (a g_s–C_i curve) at each growth [CO₂] in the third and fourth growing seasons of the treatment. The g_s–C_i response curves for Solanum dimidiatum (C₃ perennial forb) differed significantly across [CO₂] treatments, suggesting that stomatal acclimation had occurred. Evidence of non–linear stomatal acclimation to [CO₂] in this species was also found as maximum g_s (g_smax; g_s measured at the lowest C_i) increased with decreasing growth [CO₂] only below 400 µmol mol^?1. The substantial increase in g_s at subambient [CO₂] for S. dimidiatum was weakly correlated with the maximum velocity of carboxylation (V_cmax; r² = 0·27) and was not associated with CO₂ saturated photosynthesis (A_max). The response of g_s to C_i did not vary with growth [CO₂] in Bromus japonicus (C₃ annual grass) or Bothriochloa ischaemum (C₄ perennial grass), suggesting that stomatal acclimation had not occurred in these species. Stomatal density, which increased with rising [CO₂] in both C₃ species, was not correlated with g_s. Larger stomatal size at subambient [CO₂], however, may be associated with stomatal acclimation in S. dimidiatum. Incorporating stomatal acclimation into modelling studies could improve the ability to predict changes in ecosystem water fluxes and water availability with rising CO₂ and to understand their magnitudes relative to the past.     

Photosynthesis, immediate export and carbon partitioning in source leaves of C3, C3-C4 intermediate, and C4Panicum and Flaveria species at ambient and elevated CO2 levels

Immediate export in leaves of C₃‐C₄ intermediates were compared with their C₃ and C₄ relatives within the Panicum and Flaveria genera. At 35 Pa CO₂, photosynthesis and export were highest in C₄ species in each genera. Within the Panicum, photosynthesis and export in ‘type I’ C₃‐C₄ intermediates were greater than those in C₃ species. However, ‘type I’ C₃‐C₄ intermediates exported a similar proportion of newly fixed ¹⁴C as did C₄ species. Within the Flaveria, ‘type II’ C₃‐C₄ intermediate species had the lowest export rather than the C₃ species. At ambient CO₂, immediate export was strongly correlated with photosynthesis. However, at 90 Pa CO₂, when photosynthesis and immediate export increased in all C₃ and C₃‐C₄ intermediate species, proportionally less C was exported in all photosynthetic types than that at ambient CO₂. All species accumulated starch and sugars at both CO₂ levels. There was no correlation between immediate export and the pattern of ¹⁴C‐labelling into sugars and starch among the photosynthetic types within each genus. However, during CO₂ enrichment, C₄Panicum species accumulated sugars above the level of sugars and starch normally made at ambient CO₂, whereas the C₄Flaveria species accumulated only additional starch.     

Carbon: terrestrial C4 plants

The carbon isotope composition of terrestrial C₄ plants depends on the primary carboxylation of phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) and on the diffusion of CO₂ to the carboxylation sites, but is also influenced by the final carboxylation of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP). Several models have been used for reproducing this complex situation. In the present review, a particular model is applied as a means to interpret the effects of environmental and genetically determined factors on carbon isotope discrimination during C₄ photosynthesis. As a new feature, the model considers four types of limitation of the overall CO₂ assimilation rate. Both carboxylation reactions are assumed to be limited by either maximum enzyme activity or maximum substrate regeneration rate. The model is applied to experimental data on the effects of CO₂, irradiance and water stress on short-term discrimination by leaves of several C₄ species measured simultaneously with CO₂ gas exchange characteristics. In particular, different patterns of the influence of low irradiances on carbon isotope discrimination are interpreted as due to variations in that irradiance at which a transition from limitation by PEP regeneration rate and RuBP carboxylase activity to limitation by the regeneration rates of both substrates occurs. After discussing literature data on the effects of environmental conditions on carbon isotope discrimination by C₄ plants seasonal and developmental changes in carbon isotope composition, studies on the systematic and geographic distribution of C₄ plants, evolutionary and genetical aspects, and some ecological implications are reviewed.     

Carbonic anhydrase in the plasma membranes from leaves of C3 and C4 plants

Plasma membranes were isolated from green leaves of maize ( Zea mays ), spinach ( Spinacia oleracea ), Setaria viridis and wheat ( Triticum aestivum cv. Omase) by aqueous two-phase partitioning. Carbonic anhydrase activity was detected in these membranes. The activity was inhibited by specific inhibitors for carbonic anhydrase, acetazolamide and ethoxyzolamide. The carbonic anhydrase activity was markedly enhanced by the addition of Triton X-100 to the plasma membranes. The highest activity was obtained in the presence of 0.015% detergent. The activity was scarcely affected when the plasma membrane vesicles were treated with proteinase K, but largely inactivated by the protease after treating the membranes with Triton X-100. These results indicate that carbonic anhydrase faces the cytoplasmic side of the membrane since plasma membranes purified by aqueous two-phase partitioning are tightly sealed vesicles of right side-out orientation (apoplastic side-out). With leaves of C₄ plants, 20 to 60% of the total carbonic anhydrase activity was found in the microsomal fraction. By contrast, only 1 to 3% of the activity was found in the microsomal fraction from leaves of C₃ plants. Western blot analysis showed that a polypeptide in the spinach plasma membrane cross-reacted with an antiserum raised against spinach chloroplast carbonic anhydrase, and that the molecular mass of the plasma membrane enzyme was higher than that of the chloroplast carbonic anhydrase (28 and 26 kDa, respectively). This indicates the presence of different molecular species of carbonic anhydrase in the chloroplast and the plasma membrane.     

Carbon isotope discrimination in C3-C4 intermediates

Carbon isotope discrimination in C₃–C₄ intermediates is determined by fractionations during diffusion and the biochemical fractionations occurring during CO₂ fixation. These biochemical fractionations in turn depend on the fractionation by Rubisco in the mesophyll, the amount of CO₂ fixation. These biochemical fractionations in turn depend on the fractionation by Rubisco in the mesophyll, the amount of CO₂ fixation occurring in the bundle sheath, the extent of bundle-sheath leakiness and the contribution which C₄-cycle activity makes to the CO₂ pool there. In most instances, carbon isotope discrimination in C₃–C₄ intermediates is C₃-like because only a small fraction of the total carbon fixed is fixed in the bundle sheath. In particular, this must be the case for Flaveria intermediates which initially fix substantial amounts of CO₂ into C₄-acids. In C₃–C₄ intermediates that refix photorespiratory CO₂ alone, it is possible for carbon isotope discrimination to be greater than in C₃-species, particularly at low CO₂ pressures or at high leaf temperatures. Short-term measurements of carbon isotope discrimination and gas exchange of leaves can be used to study the photosynthetic pathways of C₃-C₄ intermediates and their hybrids as has recently been done for C₃ and C₄ species.     

Comparison of the specific activity of ribulose-1,5-bis-phosphate carboxylase-oxygenase from some C3 and C4 plants

The specific activity of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase (Rubisco, EC 4.1.1.39) was measured from the crude extracts of five C₃ plants consisting of wheat ( Triticum aestivum L. cv. Maris Mink), spinach ( Spinacia oleracea L.), pea ( Pisum sativum L. cv. Greenfeast), pumpkin ( Cucurbita pepo L. cv. Jättiläismeloni) and Ceratodon purpureus (Hedw.) Brid., and two C₄ plants, maize ( Zea mays L. ETA F₁) and sugar sorghum [ Sorghum saccharatum (L. emend, L.) Moench]. The amount of Rubisco in the crude extracts was estimated by polyacrylamide gel electro-phoresis with the Coomassie Brilliant Blue staining procedure. The amounts of the dye bound to the purified Rubisco of different higher plants were similar. The method gave a linear response for both purified enzyme and crude extracts, and the results agreed with those observed by immunochemical methods. The addition of positive effectors such as inorganic phosphate was necessary to obtain maximal activity in the crude extracts of all the studied plants except in that of maize. No significant differences in the specific carboxylase activity at 25°C were found between the C₃ and C₄ plants.     

Re-evaluation of proposed C4 photosynthetic characteristics in the genus Larix

It has been suggested previously that Japanese larch ( Larix kaempferi ) exhibits characteristics of C₄ photosynthesis. To further evaluate this suggestion, stable carbon isotope ratios were determined for leaf and bark tissue of Larix gmelini, L. kaempferi, L. laricina, L. Iyallii, L. occidentalis , and L. sibirica. All δ¹³C values were more negative than –22‰. Short-term labeling with ¹⁴CO₂ showed that phosphoglyceric acid and other phosphorylated compounds were the first products of photosynthesis in L. sibirica. Both of these results strongly suggest that the initial fixation of atmospheric CO₂ in these six Larix species is accomplished solely via the C₃ photosynthetic pathway.     

Dynamic photo-inhibition and carbon gain in a C4 and a C3 grass native to high latitudes

C₄ plants are rare in the cool climates characteristic of high latitudes and altitudes, perhaps because of an enhanced susceptibility to photo‐inhibition at low temperatures relative to C₃ species. In the present study we tested the hypothesis that low‐temperature photo‐inhibition is more detrimental to carbon gain in the C₄ grass Muhlenbergia glomerata than the C₃ species Calamogrostis Canadensis. These grasses occur together in boreal fens in northern Canada. Plants were grown under cool (14/10 °C day/night) and warm (26/22 °C) temperatures before measurement of the light responses of photosynthesis and chlorophyll fluorescence at different temperatures. Cool growth temperatures led to reduced rates of photosynthesis in M. glomerata at all measurement temperatures, but had a smaller effect on the C₃ species. In both species the amount of xanthophyll cycle pigments increased when plants were grown at 14/10 °C, and in M. glomerata the xanthophyll epoxidation state was greatly reduced. The detrimental effect of low growth temperature on photosynthesis in M. glomerata was almost completely reversed by a 24‐h exposure to the warm‐temperature regime. These data indicate that reversible dynamic photo‐inhibition is a strategy by which C₄ species may tolerate cool climates and overcome the Rubisco limitation that is prevalent at low temperatures in C₄ plants.