Homologous recombination in a mammalian plasmid

Summary Bovine papillomavirus (BPV) shuttle vectors replicate as a circular plasmid in mouse cell nuclei without impairing host cell viability. We used these vectors to analyze homologous recombination in mammalian cells. When several BPV-based plasmids carrying direct repeats were introduced into C127 cells, we detected many recombinant plasmid molecules that have lost the sequence between the repeats. Many recombinant type molecules as well as parental type molecules were detected in all the cell clones isolated for analysis. Sequencing after rescue of the plasmid inEscherichia coli showed that most of the recombinants were from accurate homologous recombination. When the repeats on the plasmid were in inverted orientation, no crossing-over type products were detected. We discuss possible mechanisms that explain these features.     

Illegitimate recombination in a bovine papillomavirus shuttle vector: a high level of site specificity.

Recombination in a bovine papillomavirus shuttle vector carrying direct repeats of Moloney murine leukemia virus LTR sequence was examined. Differently from similar vectors carrying direct repeats of SV40 polyA addition signal or neomycin resistance gene, the vector exhibited no homologous recombination between the repeats. Instead, illegitimate recombination took place. There were two major types of recombination products from the restriction cleavage pattern. The plasmids in independent cellular clones belonging to the same recombination type shared the identical crossover point. Thus, in this plasmid, illegitimate recombination occurred at preferential sites involving exactly the same sequences.     

IS-elements and their role in genetic recombination]

The data concerning the biological functions and properties of short specific polynucleotide sequences (so called insertion sequences--IS) are reviewed. IS elements integrated in a genome can lead to strongly polar mutations in Escherichia coli, its bacteriophages and plasmids, while some IS (IS2) being integrated in inverted orientation turn on the gene activity. Several copies of the IS elements are present in the E. coli chromosome. A characteristic feature of IS is their ability to recA-independent migration along the bacterial chromosome. Possible mechanisms of IS integration are discussed. IS elements play the key role in the majority of recA-independent recombinational events: F-prime and partially Hfr-formation, plasmid recombination and dissociation, some cases of deletion formation etc. IS elements participate in recombination in the form of direct or inverted repeats. Direct repeats probably determine the processes of dissociation of the complete multicomponent R-factors and other plasmids. Inverted repeats (some of them are palindromes) are responsible for the migration of several drug-resistance determinants called transposons. Possible mechanisms of IS-dependent and probably IS-controlled recombination are discussed.     

Genomic comparison of archaeal conjugative plasmids from Sulfolobus

All of the known self-transmissable plasmids of the Archaea have been found in the genus Sulfolobus. To gain more insight into archaeal conjugative processes, four newly isolated self-transmissable plasmids, pKEF9, pHVE14, pARN3 and pARN4, were sequenced and subjected to a comparative sequence analysis with two earlier sequenced plasmids, pNOB8 and pING1. The analyses revealed three conserved and functionally distinct sections in the genomes. Section A is considered to encode the main components of the conjugative apparatus, where two genes show low but significant sequence similarity to sections of genes encoding bacterial conjugative proteins. A putative origin of replication is located in section B, which is highly conserved in sequence and contains several perfect and imperfect direct and inverted repeats. Further downstream, in section C, an operon encoding six to nine smaller proteins is implicated in the initiation and regulation of replication. Each plasmid carries an integrase gene of the type that does not partition on integration, and there is strong evidence for their integration into host chromosomes, where they may facilitate intercellular exchange of chromosomal genes. Two plasmids contain hexameric short regularly spaced repeats (SRSR), which have been implicated in plasmid maintenance, and each plasmid carries multiple recombination motifs, concentrated in the variable regions, which likely provide sites for genomic rearrangements.     

Gene conversion associated with site-specific recombination in yeast plasmid pSR1.

A circular DNA plasmid, pSR1, isolated from Zygosaccharomyces rouxii has a pair of inverted repeats consisting of completely homologous 959-base pair (bp) sequences. Intramolecular recombination occurs frequently at the inverted repeats in cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, as well as in Z. rouxii, and is catalyzed by a protein encoded by the R gene of its own genome. The recombination is, however, independent of the RAD52 gene of the host genome. A site for initiation of the intramolecular recombination in the S. cerevisiae host was delimited into, at most, a 58-bp region in the inverted repeats by using mutant plasmids created by linker insertion. The 58-bp region contains a pair with 14-bp dyad symmetry separated by a 3-bp spacer sequence. The recombination initiated at this site was accompanied by a high frequency of gene conversion (3 to 50% of the plasmid clones examined). Heterogeneity created by the linker insertion or by a deletion (at most 153 bp so far tested) at any place on the inverted repeats was converted to a homologous combination by the gene conversion, even in the rad52-1 mutant host. A mechanism implying branch migration coupled with DNA replication is discussed.     

The Agrocybe aegerita mitochondrial genome contains two inverted repeats of the nad4 gene arisen by duplication on both sides of a linear plasmid integration site.

The Agrocybe aegerita mitochondrial genome possesses two polB genes with linear plasmid origin. The cloning and sequencing of the regions flanking Aa-polB P1 revealed two large inverted repeats (higher than 2421 nt) separated by a single copy region of 5834 nt. Both repeats contain identical copies of the nad4 gene. The single copy region contains two disrupted genes with plasmid origin Aa-polB P1 and a small ORF homologous to a small gene described in two basidiomycete linear plasmids. The phylogenetic analyses argue in favor of a same plasmid origin for both genes but, surprisingly, these genes were separated by a mitochondrial tRNA-Met. Both strands of the complete region containing the two nad4 inverted copies and the tRNA-Met appear to be transcribed on large polycistronic mRNAs. A model summarizing the events that would have occurred is proposed: (1) capture of the tRNA by the plasmid before its integration in the mtDNA or acquisition of the tRNA gene by recombination after the plasmid integration, (2) integration of the plasmid in the mtDNA, accompanied by a large duplication containing the nad4 gene and (3) erosion of the plasmid sequences by large deletions and mutations.     

The Agrocybe aegerita mitochondrial genome contains two inverted repeats of the nad4 gene arisen by duplication on both sides of a linear plasmid integration site

The Agrocybe aegerita mitochondrial genome possesses two polB genes with linear plasmid origin. The cloning and sequencing of the regions flanking Aa-polB P1 revealed two large inverted repeats (higher than 2421 nt) separated by a single copy region of 5834 nt. Both repeats contain identical copies of the nad4 gene. The single copy region contains two disrupted genes with plasmid origin Aa-polB P1 and a small ORF homologous to a small gene described in two basidiomycete linear plasmids. The phylogenetic analyses argue in favor of a same plasmid origin for both genes but, surprisingly, these genes were separated by a mitochondrial tRNA-Met. Both strands of the complete region containing the two nad4 inverted copies and the tRNA-Met appear to be transcribed on large polycistronic mRNAs. A model summarizing the events that would have occurred is proposed: (1) capture of the tRNA by the plasmid before its integration in the mtDNA or acquisition of the tRNA gene by recombination after the plasmid integration, (2) integration of the plasmid in the mtDNA, accompanied by a large duplication containing the nad4 gene and (3) erosion of the plasmid sequences by large deletions and mutations.     

Towards effective non-viral gene delivery vector

Despite very good safety records, clinical trials using plasmid DNA failed due to low transfection efficiency and brief transgene expression. Although this failure is both due to poor plasmid design and to inefficient delivery methods, here we will focus on the former. The DNA elements like CpG motifs, selection markers, origins of replication, cryptic eukaryotic signals or nuclease-susceptible regions and inverted repeats showed detrimental effects on plasmids’ performance as biopharmaceuticals. On the other hand, careful selection of promoter, polyadenylation signal, codon optimization and/or insertion of introns or nuclear-targeting sequences for therapeutic protein expression can enhance the clinical efficacy. Minimal vectors, which are devoid of the bacterial backbone and consist exclusively of the eukaryotic expression cassette, demonstrate better performance in terms of expression levels, bioavailability, transfection rates and increased therapeutic effects. Although the results are promising, minimal vectors have not taken over the conventional plasmids in clinical trials due to challenging manufacturing issues.     

Characterization of IntA,a Bidirectional Site-Specific Recombinase Required for Conjugative Transfer of the Symbiotic Plasmid of Rhizobium etli CFN42

Site-specific recombination occurs at short specific sequences, mediated by the cognate recombinases. IntA is a recombinase from Rhizobium etli CFN42 and belongs to the tyrosine recombinase family. It allows cointegration of plasmid p42a and the symbiotic plasmid via site-specific recombination between attachment regions (attA and attD) located in each replicon. Cointegration is needed for conjugative transfer of the symbiotic plasmid. To characterize this system, two plasmids harboring the corresponding attachment sites and intA were constructed. Introduction of these plasmids into R. etli revealed IntA-dependent recombination events occurring at high frequency. Interestingly, IntA promotes not only integration, but also excision events, albeit at a lower frequency. Thus, R. etli IntA appears to be a bidirectional recombinase. IntA was purified and used to set up electrophoretic mobility shift assays with linear fragments containing attA and attD. IntA-dependent retarded complexes were observed only with fragments containing either attA or attD. Specific retarded complexes, as well as normal in vivo recombination abilities, were seen even in derivatives harboring only a minimal attachment region (comprising the 5-bp central region flanked by 9- to 11-bp inverted repeats). DNase I-footprinting assays with IntA revealed specific protection of these zones. Mutations that disrupt the integrity of the 9- to 11-bp inverted repeats abolish both specific binding and recombination ability, while mutations in the 5-bp central region severely reduce both binding and recombination. These results show that IntA is a bidirectional recombinase that binds to att regions without requiring neighboring sequences as enhancers of recombination.     

Molecular organization of plasmid R906 (Inc P-1)

Genetic and restriction (for enzymes EcoRI, BamHI and HindIII) maps of the relatively broad host range plasmid R906 are constructed. There are two non-essential regions on the R906 DNA which can be deleted and cloned. Non-essential regions confer a resistance to different agents and restriction sites are clustered in these regions. Essential and conjugativity genes are located in two other DNA regions approximately at 0-23 and 29-44 kb of the R906 map. These large regions share a high level of homology with Inc-1 group plasmids R751 and RP4 according to Southern-blot hybridization and heteroduplex analyses. A transposon-like structure is found on the R751 DNA among R751/R906 heteroduplex molecules. This transposon of total length 5.1 kb has 1.4 kb inverted repeats at the ends. Bla genes of R906 and RP4 plasmids do not have homologous sequences. Data evidence that IncP-1 group plasmids irrespective to their original bacterial source and range of coded antibiotic resistance have very similar molecular organization. The role of possible factors which are responsible for the broad host range property of the IncP-1 group plasmids is discussed.     

The RecE recombination pathway mediates recombination between partially homologous DNA sequences: structural analysis of recombination products

Escherichia coli generalized recombination, utilizing the RecA RecB recombination pathway, requires large stretches (70-200 bp) of complete DNA sequence homology. In contrast, we have found that the RecE pathway can promote recombination between DNA with only short stretches of homology. A plasmid containing 10 partially homologous direct repeats was linearized by digestion with specific restriction enzymes. After transformation, a RecE+ (sbcA) host was able to circularize the plasmid by recombination between partially homologous direct repeat sequences. Recombination occurred in regions of as little as 6 bp of perfect homology. Recombination was enhanced in the regions adjacent to restriction sites used to linearize the plasmid, consistent with a role of double-strand breaks in promoting recombination. A mechanism is proposed in which the 5' exonuclease, ExoVIII, produces 3' single-stranded ends from the linearized plasmid. These pair with other sequences of partial homology. Partial homologies in the sequences flanking the actual join serve to stabilize this recombination intermediate. Recombination is completed by a process of "copy and join." This recombination mechanism requires less homology to stabilize intermediates than the degree of homology needed for mechanisms involving strand invasion. Its role in nature may be to increase genomic diversity, for example, by enhancing recombination between bacteriophages and regions of the bacterial chromosome.     

Automatic elimination of unnecessary bacterial sequences from yeast vectors.

Most vectors for Saccharomyces cerevisiae are shuttle vectors which can be both propagated and selected in Escherichia coli. The DNA segments, however, which are required for propagation in E. coli are unnecessary and moreover toxic in S. cerevisiae. To delete these harmful DNA fragments from the vector after it is introduced into S. cerevisiae cells, we propose a specific gene conversion mechanism of a yeast plasmid, pSR1. Plasmid pSR1 has a pair of inverted repeats (IRs) that divides the plasmid molecule into two unique regions. Intramolecular recombination frequently occurs at a pair of specific recombination sites in IRs catalyzed by recombinase R, encoded by a pSR1 plasmid gene. This R-mediated recombination is often accompanied by gene conversion in IRs. Thus, a 2.1-kb pBR322 sequence for the E. coli host ligated into one of the IRs of a composite plasmid was automatically and effectively eliminated when the plasmid was introduced into S. cerevisiae cells.     

Breakage--reunion and copy choice mechanisms of recombination between short homologous sequences.

To study recombination between short homologous sequences in Escherichia coli we constructed plasmids composed of the pBR322 replicon, M13 replication origin and a recombination unit inserted within and inactivating a gene encoding chloramphenicol resistance. The unit was composed of short direct repeats (9, 18 or 27 bp) which flanked inverted repeats (0, 8 or 308 bp) and a gene encoding kanamycin resistance. Recombination between direct repeats restored a functional chloramphenicol resistance gene, and could be detected by a simple phenotype test. The plasmids replicated in a double-stranded form, using the pBR322 replicon, and generated single-stranded DNA when the M13 replication origin was activated. The frequency of chloramphenicol-resistant cells was low (10(-8)-10(-4] when no single-stranded DNA was synthesized but increased greatly (to 100%) after induction of single-stranded DNA synthesis. Recombination between 9 bp direct repeats entailed no transfer of DNA from parental to recombinant plasmids, whereas recombination between 18 or 27 bp repeats entailed massive transfer. The presence or length of inverted repeats did not alter the pattern of DNA transfer. From these results we propose that direct repeats of 9 bp recombine by a copy choice process, while those greater than or equal to 18 bp can recombine by a breakage-reunion process. Genome rearrangements detected in many organisms often occur by recombination between sequences less than 18 bp, which suggests that they may result from copy choice recombination.     

Homologous Recombination as the Main Mechanism for DNA Integration and Cause of Rearrangements in the Filamentous Ascomycete Ashbya Gossypii

A slow and a fast growth phenotype were observed after transformation of the phytopathogenic fungus Ashbya gossypii using a plasmid carrying homologous DNA and as selectable marker the Tn903 aminoglycoside resistance gene expressed from a strong A. gossypii promoter. Transformations with circular plasmids yielded slowly and irregularly growing geneticin-resistant mycelia in which 1% of nuclei contained plasmid sequences. Occasionally, fast growing sectors appeared which were shown to be initiated by homologous integration of the transforming DNA. Transformants obtained with plasmids linearized within the homology region immediately exhibited fast radial growth. In all 28 transformants analyzed plasmid DNA was integrated homologously. Such apparent lack of nonhomologous recombination has so far not been observed in filamentous ascomycetes. In 14 transformants two to four tandemly integrated plasmid copies were found. They underwent several types of genetic changes, mainly in the older mycelium: excision of whole plasmid copies and rearrangements within the integrated DNA (inversions and deletions). These internal rearrangements involved 360-bp inverted repeats, remnants of IS-elements flanking the resistance gene, and 156-bp direct repeats, originating from the strong A. gossypii promoter. Improved vectors lacking sequence repetitions were constructed and used for stable one-step gene replacement in A. gossypii.     

Double or triple sets of replication functions as inverted and direct repeats on in vitro reconstructed streptococcal MLS resistance plasmids

In vitro rearrangement of plasmid pDB102 together with comparative studies of other streptococcal plasmids allowed the localization of replication and copy control functions on sequences which were present on pDB102 and its naturally occurring ancestor pSM19035 as duplicates in inverted orientation. Evidence is presented that neither the presence of duplicate replication regions nor their arrangement in inverted orientation was essential for plasmid survival. Among the in vitro reconstructed plasmids were several that stably carried two or three sets of replication and copy control functions either as inverted or direct repeats or both. A copy control mutation is described which led to a tenfold increase of copy number over that of the naturally occurring plasmid pSM19035.     

Recombination within the yeast plasmid 2mu circle is site-specific

The multicopy yeast plasmid, 2mu circle, encodes a specialized recombination system. It contains two regions, each 599 bp in length, that are precise inverted repeats of each other and between which recombination occurs readily. In addition, this recombination requires the product of a 2mu circle gene, designated FLP. By examining the products of FLP-mediated recombination of plasmids containing single insertions within one of the repeated regions, we show that this recombination occurs only at a specific site within the repeat. This result was confirmed from analysis of the ability of plasmids containing various deletions within one of the repeated regions to serve as substrates for FLP-mediated recombination. These experiments limit the recombination site to a sequence of less than 65 bp. In addition, by mutational analysis of the recombination potential of a hybrid plasmid containing the entire 2mu circle genome, we have shown that FLP is only the 2mu circle gene necessary for this site-specific recombination. Finally, we describe a sensitive assay for recombination between the repeated sequences of 2mu circle; using it, we demonstrate that even in the absence of FLP gene product, recombination between the repeats occurs at a low but detectable level during meiosis.     

Genetic analysis of the mechanism of the Salmonella phase variation site specific recombination system

Summary Phase variation, the alternation of expression of flagellar antigens H1 and H2, in Salmonella typhimurium is mediated by site specific inversion of a 995 bp DNA segment of the chromosome. Hin, a protein encoded within the 995 bp segment, is thought to catalyze the recombination reaction between 14 bp inverted repeats flanking the 995 bp segment. By comparison of the relative rates of inversion of two different plasmids containing the H2 inversion segment flanked by different sequences, we conclude that the sequences adjacent to the inversion segment affect the rate of inversion. Homologous pairing of the repeats is important in H2 inversion since the orientation of the repeats on the host molecule(s) determines the result of the recombination reaction. The presence of the hin gene mediates the fusion of two plasmids when each contains one of the 14 bp repeat sequences. When the 14 bp sequences are direct repeats on a single molecule the sequence between them is deleted. These results support the hypothesis that the H2 inversion system functions by homologous, conservative, site specific recombination which is similar to the systems found associated with TnA transposons and temperate bacteriophage.     

High frequency excision of Ty elements during transformation of yeast.

Yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) transposons (Ty elements) are excised from up to 20% of supercoiled plasmids during transformation of yeast cells. The excision occurs by homologous recombination across the direct terminal repeats (deltas) of the Ty element, leaving behind a single delta in the transforming plasmid. Only the initial transforming plasmid is susceptible to excision, and no high frequency excision is observed in plasmids that have become established in transformed cells or in plasmids that are resident in cells undergoing transformation. High frequency excision from plasmids during yeast transformation is not specific for Ty elements and can be observed with other segments of plasmid DNA bounded by direct repeats. The frequency of Ty excision from supercoiled plasmids is greatly reduced when the host yeast cells contain the rad52 mutation, a defect in double-strand DNA repair. When linear or ligated-linear plasmid DNAs containing a Ty element are used for transformation, few or no excision plasmids are found among the transformant colonies. These results suggest that when a yeast cell is transformed with a supercoiled plasmid, the plasmid DNA is highly susceptible to homologous recombination for a short period of time.     

Molecular characterization of the replicon of the Pediococcus pentosaceus 43200 pediocin A plasmid pMD136

The pediocin A-encoding plasmid of Pediococcus pentosaceus 43200, pMD136, was characterized by restriction enzyme analysis. Analysis of its replicon was facilitated by the construction of a probe vector consisting of the Escherichia coli plasmid pSP72 and the cat gene from Staphylococcus aureus plasmid pC194. The replication region of pMD136 was localized on a 1.6-kb EcoRI/BglII fragment. Sequencing analysis revealed a non-coding region, repA, spanning the first 440 bp, followed by an open reading frame, repB, encoding a putative protein of 390 amino acids. The non-coding region contained two sets of 6-bp and two sets of 22-bp direct repeats and two sets of inverted repeats upstream of the open reading frame. Strong homology of the isolated replicon was found to theta-type replicons of Lactococcus lactis plasmids. Segregational stability assay suggested at least two regions as potentially involved in the stabilization of pMD136. The plasmid's strong homology to other theta-type replicons and its relatively high stability suggest that pMD136 belongs to the widespread family of theta-replication plasmids.     

Associations between inverted repeats and the structural evolution of bacterial genomes

The stability of the structure of bacterial genomes is challenged by recombination events. Since major rearrangements (i.e., inversions) are thought to frequently operate by homologous recombination between inverted repeats, we analyzed the presence and distribution of such repeats in bacterial genomes and their relation to the conservation of chromosomal structure. First, we show that there is a strong under-representation of inverted repeats, relative to direct repeats, in most chromosomes, especially among the ones regarded as most stable. Second, we show that the avoidance of repeats is frequently associated with the stability of the genomes. Closely related genomes reported to differ in terms of stability are also found to differ in the number of inverted repeats. Third, when using replication strand bias as a proxy for genome stability, we find a significant negative correlation between this strand bias and the abundance of inverted repeats. Fourth, when measuring the recombining potential of inverted repeats and their eventual impact on different features of the chromosomal structure, we observe a tendency of repeats to be located in the chromosome in such a way that rearrangements produce a smaller strand switch and smaller asymmetries than expected by chance. Finally, we discuss the limitations of our analysis and the influence of factors such as the nature of repeats, e.g., transposases, or the differences in the recombination machinery among bacteria. These results shed light on the challenges imposed on the genome structure by the presence of inverted repeats.