Process and technoeconomics of ethanol production by immobilized cells

Summary A two-stage fermentation process has been developed for continuous ethanol production by immobilized cells of Zymomonas mobilis. About 90–92 kg/m³ ethanol was produced after 4 h of residence time. Entrapped cells of Zymomonas mobilis have a capability to convert glucose to ethanol at 93% of the theoretical yield. The immobilized cell system has functioned for several weeks, and experience indicates that the carrageenan gel apparently facilitates easy diffusion of glucose and ethanol.The simplicity and the high productivity of the plug-flow reactor employing immobilized cells makes it economically attrative. An evaluation of process economics of an immobilized cell system indicates that at least 4 c/l of ethanol can be saved using the immobilized cell system rather than the conventional batch system. The high productivity achieved in the immobilized cell reactor results in the requirement for only small reactor vessels indicating low capital cost. Consequently, by switching from batch to immobilized processing, the fixed capital investment is substantially reduced, thus increasing the profitability of ethanol production by fermentation.     

Flocculating Zymomonas mobilis is a promising host to be engineered for fuel ethanol production from lignocellulosic biomass

Whereas Saccharomyces cerevisiae uses the Embden‐Meyerhof‐Parnas pathway to metabolize glucose, Zymomonas mobilis uses the Entner‐Doudoroff (ED) pathway. Employing the ED pathway, 50% less ATP is produced, which could lead to less biomass being accumulated during fermentation and an improved yield of ethanol. Moreover, Z. mobilis cells, which have a high specific surface area, consume glucose faster than S. cerevisiae, which could improve ethanol productivity. We performed ethanol fermentations using these two species under comparable conditions to validate these speculations. Increases of 3.5 and 3.3% in ethanol yield, and 58.1 and 77.8% in ethanol productivity, were observed in ethanol fermentations using Z. mobilis ZM4 in media containing ～100 and 200 g/L glucose, respectively. Furthermore, ethanol fermentation bythe flocculating Z. mobilis ZM401 was explored. Although no significant difference was observed in ethanol yield and productivity, the flocculation of the bacterial species enabled biomass recovery by cost‐effective sedimentation, instead of centrifugation with intensive capital investment and energy consumption. In addition, tolerance to inhibitory byproducts released during biomass pretreatment, particularly acetic acid and vanillin, was improved. These experimental results indicate that Z. mobilis, particularly its flocculating strain, is superior to S. cerevisiae as a host to be engineered for fuel ethanol production from lignocellulosic biomass.     

Ethanol production by <Emphasis Type="Italic">Zymomonas mobilis</Emphasis> CHZ2501 from industrial starch feedstocks

The optimal conditions of ethanol fermentation process by Zymomonas mobilis CHZ2501 were investigated. Brown rice, naked barley, and cassava were selected as representatives of the starch-based raw material commercially available for ethanol production. Considering enzyme used for saccharification of starch, the ethanol productivity with complex enzyme was higher than glucoamylase. With regards to the conditions of saccharification, the final ethanol productions of simultaneous saccharification and pre-saccharified process for 1 h were not significantly different. The result suggested that it is possible for simultaneous saccharification and fermentation as a cost-effective process for ethanol production by eliminating the separate saccharification. Additionally, the fermentation rate in early fermentation stage was generally increased with increase of inoculum volume. As the result, optimal condition for ethanol production was simultaneous saccharification and fermentation with complex enzyme and 5% inoculation. Under the same condition, the volumetric productivities and ethanol yields were attained to 3.26 g/L·h and 93.5% for brown rice, 2.62 g/L·h and 90.4% for naked barley, and 3.28 g/L·h and 93.7% for cassava, respectively.     

Roles of alcohol dehydrogenases of Zymomonas mobilis (ZADH): characterization of a ZADH-2-negative mutant

Zymomonas mobilis is a potential candidate for fuel ethanol production because of its high ethanol productivity. A key enzyme in ethanol production is alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH). Z. mobilis possesses two isozymes, ZADH-1 and ZADH-2. To clarify their physiological roles, mutants with modified ADH were isolated by selection based on resistance to allyl alcohol. From the physiological characteristics of a ZADH-2-negative mutant, it is suggested that ZADH-1 functions as the major ADH, while ZADH-2 could become functional in the latter stages of fermentation.     

Production of high ethanol concentrations from glucose using a vertical rotating immobilized cell reactor of the bacterium zymomonas mobilis

Long-term continuous ethanol production of up to 80 g.l¹ with a volumetric ethanol productivity of 63 g. l^?1. h^?1 was maintained for more than 72 days using a Vertical Rotating Immobilized Cell Reactor of the bacterium Z. mobilis. Continuous production of higher ethanol concentration was unsuccessful due to an inhibition of cell growth by long exposure to high ethanol concentrations. However, ethanol concentration as high as 120g. l^?1 and volumetric ethanol productivity of 13g. l^?1. h^?1 were achieved in a repeated-batch fermentation system using the same bioreactor. By a simple washing operation at the end of each run, immobilized biomass could be effectively regenerated and used to carry out more than 10 successive fermentation cycles.     

Conversion of sugar-beet particles to ethanol by the bacteriumZymomonas mobilis in solid-state fermentation

Summary The possibility of usingZymomonas mobilis as the microorganism, in solid-state fermentation of sugar-beet particles was investigated. The major factors affecting the process were investigated and related to ethanol yield and productivity. Ethanol yield of 0.48 g/g sugar, volumetric productivity of 12 g/L h, and final ethanol concentration of 130 g/L show the good performance ofZ.mobilis in a solid-state fermentation.     

The Composition of Jerusalem Artichoke (Helianthus tuberosus L.) Spirits Obtained from Fermentation with Bacteria and Yeasts

The composition of spirits distilled from fermentation of Jerusalem artichoke (Helianthus tuberosus L.) tubers was compared by means of gas chromatography. The microorganisms used in the fermentation processes were the bacterium Zymomonas mobilis, strains 3881 and 3883, the distillery yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, strains Bc16a and D₂ and the Kluyveromyces fragilis yeast with an active inulinase. The fermentation of mashed tubers was conducted using a single culture of the distillery yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and the bacterium Zymomonas mobilis (after acid or enzymatic hydrolysis) as well as Kluyveromyces fragilis (sterilized mashed tubers). The tubers were simultaneously fermented by mixed cultures of the bacterium or the distillery yeast with K. fragilis. The highest ethanol yield was achieved when Z. mobilis 3881 with a yeast demonstrating inulinase activity was applied. The yield reached 94 % of the theoretical value. It was found that the distillates resulting from the fermentation of mixed cultures were characterized by a relatively lower amount of by‐products compared to the distillates resulting from the single species process. Ester production of 0.30–2.93 g/L, responsible for the aromatic quality of the spirits, was noticed when K. fragilis was applied for ethanol fermentation both in a single culture process and also in the mixed fermentation with the bacterium. Yeast applied in this study caused the formation of higher alcohols to concentrations of 7.04 g/L much greater than those obtained with the bacterium. The concentrations of compounds other than ethanol obtained from Jerusalem artichoke mashed tubers, which were fermented by Z. mobilis, were lower than those achieved for yeasts.     

Co-fermentation of a mixture of glucose and xylose to ethanol by Zymomonas mobilis and Pachysolen tannophilus

This research was designed to maximize ethanol production from a glucose-xylose sugar mixture (simulating a sugar cane bagasse hydrolysate) by co-fermentation with Zymomonas mobilis and Pachysolen tannophilus. The volumetric ethanol productivity of Z. mobilis with 50 g glucose/l was 2.87 g/l/h, giving an ethanol yield of 0.50 g/g glucose, which is 98% of the theoretical. P. tannophilus when cultured on 50 g xylose/l gave a volumetric ethanol productivity of 0.10 g/l/h with an ethanol yield of 0.15 g/g xylose, which is 29% of the theoretical. On optimization of the co-fermentation with the sugar mixture (60 g glucose/l and 40 g xylose/l) a total ethanol yield of 0.33 g/g sugar mixture, which is 65% of the theoretical yield, was obtained. The co-fermentation increased the ethanol yield from xylose to 0.17 g/g. Glucose and xylose were completely utilized and no residual sugar was detected in the medium at the end of the fermentation. The pH of the medium was found to be a good indicator of the fermentation status. The optimum conditions were a temperature of 30°C, initial inoculation with Z. mobilis and incubation with no aeration, inactivation of bacterium after the utilization of glucose, followed by inoculation with P. tannophilus and incubation with limited aeration.     

Effect of temperature and long-term operation on passively immobilizedZymomonas mobilis for continuous ethanol production

Summary A fibrous support was used forZ. mobilis immobilization. The system showed a broad optimum temperature range (25–35°C) for highest ethanol productivity, ethanol yield and glucose conversion during continuous fermentation of a 100 g/L glucose medium. Ethanol production and glucose conversion kept steady during two months of continuous operation at D=1h^–1.     

EVALUATION OF BIOETHANOL PRODUCTION FROM CAROB PODS BY Zymomonas mobilis AND Saccharomyces cerevisiae IN SOLID SUBMERGED FERMENTATION

Bioethanol production from carob pods has attracted many researchers due to its high sugar content. Both Zymomonas mobilis and Saccharomyces cerevisiae have been used previously for this purpose in submerged and solid-state fermentation. Since extraction of sugars from the carob pod particles is a costly process, solid-state and solid submerged fermentations, which do not require the sugar extraction step, may be economical processes for bioethanol production. The aim of this study is to evaluate the bioethanol production in solid submerged fermentation from carob pods. The maximum ethanol production of 0.42 g g^?1 initial sugar was obtained for Z. mobilis at 30°C, initial pH 5.3, and inoculum size of 5% v/v, 9 g carob powder per 50 mL of culture media, agitation rate 0 rpm, and fermentation time of 40 hr. The maximum ethanol production for S. cerevisiae was 0.40 g g^?1 initial sugar under the same condition. The results obtained in this research are comparable to those of Z. mobilis and S. cerevisiae performance in other culture mediums from various agricultural sources. Accordingly, solid submerged fermentation has a potential to be an economical process for bioethanol production from carob pods.     

Extractive fermentation by Zymomonas mobilis and the control of oscillatory behavior

Summary Extractive fermentation is shown to greatly improve the performance ofZymomonas mobilis in continuous culture during the conversion of concentrated substrates to ethanol, and it is also used to eliminate the oscillatory behavior often exhibited byZ. mobilis in conventional fermentations. An ethanol productivity of 15.6 g/Lh is achieved with the near-conversion of a 295 g/L glucose feed at a medium dilution rate of 0.11 h^–1 and solvent dilution rate of 1.5 h^–1. This is more than triple the productivity obtained during conventional fermentation of a 135 g/L glucose feed at the same medium dilution rate.     

Continuous ethanol production from sugar beet molasses using an osmotolerant mutant strain of Zymomonas mobilis

A laboratory process was established for ethanol production by fermentation of sugar beet molasses with the bacterium Zymomonas mobilis. Sucrose in the molasses was hydrolyzed enzymatically to prevent levan formation. A continuous system was adopted to reduce sorbitol formation and a two-stage fermentor was used to enhance sugar conversion and the final ethanol concentration. This two-stage fermentor operated stably for as long as 18 d. An ethanol concentration of 59.9 g/l was obtained at 97% sugar conversion and at high ethanol yield (0.48 g/g, 94% of theoretical). The volumetric ethanol productivity (3.0 g/l·h) was superior to that of batch fermentation but inferior to that of a single-stage continuous system with the same medium. However, the thanol concentration was increased to a level acceptable for economical recovery. The process proposed in this paper is the first report of successful fermentation of sugar beet molasses in the continuous mode using the bacterium Z. mobilis.     

Ethanol production by immobilized whole cells ofZymomonas mobilis in a continuous flow expanded bed bioreactor and a continuous flow stirred tank bioreactor

Continuous ethanol fermentation by immobilized whole cells ofZymomonas mobilis was investigated in an expanded bed bioreactor and in a continuous stirred tank reactor at glucose concentrations of 100, 150 and 200 g L^–1. The effect of different dilution rates on ethanol production by immobilized whole cells ofZymomonas mobilis was studied in both reactors. The maximum ethanol productivity attained was 21 g L^–1 h^–1 at a dilution rate of 0.36 h^–1 with 150 g glucose L^–1 in the continuous expanded bed bioreactor. The conversion of glucose to ethanol was independent of the glucose concentration in both reactors.     

Evaluation of plastic composite-supports for enhanced ethanol production in biofilm reactors

Biofilms are a natural form of cell immobilization that result from microbial attachment to solid supports. Biofilm reactors with polypropylene composite-supports containing up to 25% (w/w) of various agricultural materials (corn hulls, cellulose, oat hulls, soybean hulls or starch) and nutrients (soybean flour or zein) were used for ethanol production. Pure cultures ofZymomonas mobilis, ATCC 31821 orSaccharomyces cerevisiae ATCC 24859 and mixed cultures with either of these ethanol-producing microorganisms and the biofilm-formingStreptomyces viridosporus T7A ATCC 39115 were evaluated. An ethanol productivity of 374g L^–1 h^–1 (44% yield) was obtained on polypropylene composite-supports of soybean hull-zein-polypropylene by usingZ. mobilis, whereas mixed-culture fermentations withS. viridosporus resulted in ethanol productivity of 147.5 g L^–1 h^–1 when polypropylene composite-supports of corn starch-soybean flour were used. WithS. cerevisiae, maximum productivity of 40 g L^–1 h^–1 (47% yield) was obtained on polypropylene composite-supports of soybean hull-soybean flour, whereas mixed-culture fermentation withS. viridosporus resulted in ethanol productivity of 190g L^–1 h^–1 (35% yield) when polypropylene composite-supports of oat hull-polypropylene were used. The maximum productivities obtained without supports (suspension culture) were 124 g L^–1 h^–1 and 5 g L^–1 h^–1 withZ. mobilis andS. cerevisiae, respectively. Therefore, forZ. mobilis andS. cerevisiae, ethanol productivities in biofilm fermentations were three- and eight-fold higher than suspension culture fermentations, respectively. Biofilm formation on the chips was detected by weight change and Gram staining of the support material at the end of the fermentation. The ethanol production rate and concentrations were consistently greater in biofilm reactors than in suspension cultures.This is Journal Paper No. J-16356 of the Iowa Agriculture and Home Economics Experiment Station, Ames, Iowa. Project No. 3253     

Continuous ethanol production from sago starch using immobilized amyloglucosidase and Zymomonas mobilis

To produce ethanol more economically than in a conventional process, it is necessary to attain high productivity and low production cost. To this end, a continuous ethanol production from sago starch using immobilized amylogucosidase (AMG) and Zymomonas mobilis cells was studied. Chitin was used for immobilization of AMG and Z. mobilis cells were immobilized in the form of sodium alginate beads. Ethanol was produced continuously in an simultaneous saccharification and ethanol fermentation (SSF) mode in a pacekd bed reactor. The maximum ethanol productivity based on the void volume, V_v, was 37 g/l/h with ethanol yield, Y_p/s, 0.43 g/g (84% of the theoretical ethanol yield) in this system. The steady-state concentration of ethanol (46 g/l could be maintained in a stable manner over two weeks at the dilution rate of 0.46 h⁻.     

Ethanol production by Zymomonas mobilis entrapped in alumina pellets

Summary Zymomonas mobilis cells were immobilized on pellets of alumina (Al₂O₃) by entrapment based on electrostatic forces. Entrapped cells produced 52 g/l^-1 ethanol every 24 h for many successive fermentation batches, when inoculated in batch synthetic media containing 12% glucose. It was shown that the rate of growth, ethanol production and glucose utilization increased when Al₂O₃ was added in the growth medium. This increase was dependent upon the concentration of Al₂O₃. The optimum conditions for immobilization of Z. mobilis on Al₂O₃ were established. Reduction in productivity and yield was not observed for up to 15 successive fermentation batches using the same entrapped cells.     

Sugar Beet Juice Fermentation by Zymomonas mobilis Attached to Stainless Steel Wire Spheres

The fermentation of sugar beet juice as well as juice syrup medium by Zymomonas mobilis inoculum attached to stainless steel wire spheres was investigated. A semi‐synthetic sucrose medium enriched with mineral salts and yeast extract was used as the control. It was established that raw sugar beet juice ensured good Zymomonas mobilis culture growth and slightly decreased ethanol synthesis applying both flame‐burned and TiCl₄‐treated wire spheres as carriers (Q_x = 0.05—0.06 g/l × h; Q_eth = 1.02—1.22 g/l × h). High ethanol yield was also observed in juice medium (Y = 0.45‐0.46 g/g), however, levan synthesis with this medium decreased. The application of juice syrup brought about less growth effect and ethanol synthesis as compared to juice medium. The use of semi‐synthetic sucrose medium resulted in high levan production (Q_lev = 0.6—0.7 g/l × h), however, reduced ethanol production by 40%. In conclusion, sugar beet juice or syrup is recommendable for the preparation of Zymomonas mobilis inoculum. The levan production stage has to be realized using an optimized semi‐synthetic sucrose medium. The installed wire spheres filled with inocula provided the possibility for a repeated batch fermentation process, which could be recommended for both juice and semi‐synthetic sucrose medium fermentation.     

A novel co-culture process with Zymomonas mobilis and Pichia stipitis for efficient ethanol production on glucose/xylose mixtures

An efficient conversion of glucose and xylose is a requisite for a profitable process of bioethanol production from lignocellulose. Considering the approaches available for this conversion, co-culture is a simple process, employing two different organisms for the fermentation of the two sugars. An innovative fermentation scheme was designed, co-culturing immobilized Zymomonas mobilis and free cells of Pichia stipitis in a modified fermentor for the glucose and xylose fermentation, respectively. A sugar mixture of 30 g/l glucose and 20 g/l of xylose was completely converted to ethanol within 19 h. This gave a volumetric ethanol productivity of 1.277 g/l/h and an ethanol yield of 0.49–0.50 g/g, which is more than 96% of the theoretical value. Extension of this fermentation scheme to sugarcane bagasse hydrolysate resulted in a complete sugar utilisation within 26 h; ethanol production peaked at 40 h with a yield of 0.49 g/g. These values are comparable to the best results reported. Cell interaction was observed between Z. mobilis and P. stipitis. Viable cells of Z. mobilis inhibited the cell activity of P. stipitis and the xylose fermentation. Z. mobilis showed evidence of utilising a source other than glucose for growth when co-cultured with P. stipitis.     

Production of Ethanol from Maltose by Zymobacter palmae Fermentation

The production of ethanol from maltose by Zymobacter palmae T109 in monoculture fermentations, and in co-culture fermentations together with Zymomonas mobilis B69 was studies. Zymobacter palmae T109, produced 5.5% (w/v) of ethanol when co-cultured with Zymomonas mobilis B69, but Zymobacter palmae T109 produced only 4.9% (w/v) ethanol from 15% (w/v) maltose medium in monoculture fermentation.     

The effect of chemical treatment of stainless steel wire surfaces on Zymomonas mobilis cell attachment and product synthesis

The attachment, growth and product synthesis of non-flocculating Zymomonas mobilis cell, fixed in stainless steel wire spheres (WS), were investigated. The carrier surface was activated by treatment with titanium (IV) chloride (TiCl₄) and γ-aminopropyltriethoxysilane (AS) in an attempt to raise the efficiency in the immobilization of the cells. System productivity for ethanol and levan production, using cells immobilized on a modified stainless steel in the batch fermentation of a sucrose medium, rose as a result of increased biomass compared to the productivity of cells fixed on untreated (control) metal surfaces. Stabilized ethanol synthesis was demonstrated in the course of four cycles (each cycle 48 h) of repeated fermentations with a stainless steel carrier treated with AS, and three cycles when TiCl₄ was used. Levan synthesis decreased after three cycles with cells immobilized on a silanized surface. System productivity for ethanol and levan production after the fourth cycle in experiments with TiCl₄-activated, silanized and unmodified carriers were Q_eth = 1.01, 1.06 and 0.27 g/l × h; Q_lev = 0.32, 0.29 and 0.12 g/l × h, respectively. However, the specific productivity of biomass for product synthesis was higher in fermentation systems with untreated stainless steel surfaces, probably due to some loss of physiological activity of cells attached to a modified carrier. Investigations of throughly washed activated stainless steel wire surfaces, by scanning electron microscopy after immobilization, showed significant attachment of cells to the carriers. A polymer layer covered the wire surface treated with TiCl₄ after fermentations. This may be explained as the binding of extracellular polysaccharide, such as the fructose-polymer levan and yeast extract components, to the modified support via chelation. After four fermentations, craters and holes in the polymer layer were evident, probably as a result of CO₂ formation. A small number of cells appeared on this layer. In view of the good ethanol formation during all fermentation cycles, it is probably that active Z. mobilis cells remained under the polymer layer. Wire treatment with AS resulted in the formation of long filamentous cells during fermentation and some disturbance of cellular fission. This may be partly explained by strong electrostatic interactions between the positively charged carrier surface and the predominately negatively charged surface of Z mobilis cells. However, this did not significantly affect other cellular functions. The surface of the wire treated with AG was practically without a polymer layer.