Radiation inactivation analysis of chloroplast CF0-CF1 ATPase

Radiation inactivation technique was employed to measure the functional size of adenosine triphosphatase of spinach chloroplasts. The functional size for acid-base-induced ATP synthesis was 450 +/- 24 kilodaltons; for phenazine methosulfate-mediated ATP synthesis, 613 +/- 33 kilodaltons; and for methanol-activated ATP hydrolysis, 280 +/- 14 kilodaltons. The difference (170 +/- 57 kilodaltons) between 450 +/- 24 and 280 +/- 14 kilodaltons is explained to be the molecular mass of proton channel (coupling factor 0) across the thylakoid membrane. Our data suggest that the stoichiometry of subunits I, II, and III of coupling factor 0 is 1:2:15. Ca2+- and Mg2+-ATPase activated by methanol, heat, and trypsin digestion have a similar functional size. However, anions such as SO3(2-) and CO3(2-) increased the molecular mass for both ATPase's (except trypsin-activated Mg2+-ATPase) by 12-30%. Soluble coupling factor 1 has a larger target size than that of membrane-bound. This is interpreted as the cold effect during irradiation.     

Participation of three distinct active states of chloroplast ATPase complex CF0 X CF1 in the activation by light and dithiothreitol

Chloroplast ATPase complex (CF0 X CF1) in thylakoids is activated by illumination in the presence or absence of dithiothreitol or by incubation with both dithiothreitol and Pi in the post-illumination dark. The activation by dithiothreitol and Pi is inhibited by ADP and decreases with increasing time interval between the end of illumination and the addition of dithiothreitol and Pi. The dithiothreitol/Pi-activated ATP hydrolysis is highly sensitive to pH. The ATP hydrolysis activated by illumination in the presence of dithiothreitol decreases its sensitivity to stimulation by NH4Cl and increases its sensitivity to pH, with increasing time interval between the end of illumination and the addition of ATP. Its pH dependence approaches that of the dithiothreitol/Pi-activated ATP hydrolysis. These results suggest that in the post-illumination dark, the light/dithiothreitol-activated CFo X CF1 converts its state from the one (E2) which is sensitive to an uncoupler and relatively insensitive to pH to the one (E2i) which is insensitive to an uncoupler and highly sensitive to pH. In the post-illumination dark, the presence of both dithiothreitol and Pi brings about the activation of CFo X CF1 to E2i.     

Activation of the CF0-CF1, ATP synthase from spinach chloroplasts by chloroplast lipids

The interactions of CF₀-CF₁ with different lipids were studied by following the stimulation of Mg-ATPase and of P_i-ATP exchange activities of reconstituted CF₀-CF₁ proteoliposomes. The following results were obtained: (1) Both P_i-ATP exchange and Mg-ATPase activities are stimulated by lipids. Furthermore, the inhibition of Mg-ATPase by N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide is dependent on the interactions of CF₀-CF₁ with lipids. (2) A polar lipid extract of thylakoid membranes stimulates Mg-ATPase activity of CF₀-CF₁ more efficiently than phospholipids. The relative effectiveness of Mg-ATPase stimulation is: chloroplast lipids > soybean phospholipids > phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylserine (4: 1) > phosphatidylcholine. The rate of P_i-ATP exchange in chloroplast lipids CF₀-CF₁ proteoliposomes is, however, lower than in soybean lipids CF₀-CF₁ proteoliposomes, due to their higher permeability to protons. Addition of 10% phosphatidylserine to chloroplast lipids reduces their permeability to protons and stimulates P_i-ATP exchange. (3) The kinetic mechanism of ATPase stimulation by chloroplast lipids is by decreasing the K_m (ATP) and by increasing V_max in comparison to soybean lipid proteoliposomes. This may explain the low affinity for ATP and the slow turnover rate of the purified enzyme in artificial lipids in comparison to the native enzyme in chloroplast thylakoids. (4) Chloroplast lipids lacking monogalactosyldiacylglycerols only poorly activate CF₀-CF₁. A large stimulation of P_i-ATP exchange is obtained by a mixture of 60% monogalactosyldiacylglycerol and 40% of the rest of the chloroplast lipids, but not by mixtures of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol with phospholipids. Hydrogenation of the unsaturated fatty acids of monogalactosyldiacylglycerol inhibits the activation of CF₀-CF₁. (5) The results suggest that: (a) interactions of specific chloroplast lipids with CF₀-CF₁ activates the enzyme by increasing its turnover and its affinity for ATP; (b) specific requirements for CF₀-CF₁ activation are the presence of monogalactosyldiacylglycerols together with another chloroplast lipid component and of highly unsaturated fatty acids.     

Subunit interactions within the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0-CF1) as deduced by specific depletion of CF0 polypeptides

The proton-linked ATP synthase (CF1-CF0) of chloroplasts consists of a catalytic component (CF1) and a membrane-embedded part (CF0) that interacts with CF1 and contains a proton channel. The subunits of CF0 which are involved in binding of CF1 were studied by examining the effect of selective depletion of subunits I, II, and IV of CF0 from the chloroplast ATP synthase on the association of the remaining CF0 subunits with CF1. Dissociated CF0 subunits were identified by sucrose density gradient centrifugation. Removal of subunit IV alone from CF0-CF1 did not cause dissociation of the other CF0 subunits from CF1. Upon removal of both subunits I and IV from CF0-CF1, subunit II also dissociated, but subunit III was still bound to CF1. Thus, at least two subunits of CF0, I and III, directly associate with CF1. Subunit II is unlikely to bind CF1 directly and may associate with subunit I. Although depletion of subunit IV does not cause dissociation of CF0 from CF1, its interaction with CF1 subunits is uncertain.     

Chromatographic purification of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0-CF1) and the role of CF0 subunit IV in proton conduction

Chromatographic procedures were developed to purify chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0-CF1) in large amounts and to resolve subunits from this enzyme. The ATP synthase thus obtained has high ATP-Pi exchange and Mg2(+)-ATPase activities upon incorporation into asolectin liposomes. The purity of this preparation was about 95%. By modifications of this chromatographic procedure, we purified subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1, subunit IV-deficient CF0, and subunit IV. Both ATP-Pi exchange and Mg2(+)-ATPase activities were impaired by depletion of subunit IV from CF0-CF1. Partial restoration of these activities was obtained by reconstituting subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1 with subunit IV. The impairment of these activities was likely caused by a loss in proton conductivity of CF0 upon removal of subunit IV. The dicyclohexylcarbodiimide-sensitive Mg2(+)-ATPase of subunit IV-deficient CF0-CF1 was not as sensitive to the depletion of subunit IV as ATP-Pi exchange. Nearly 90% of subunit IV could be removed, but Mg2(+)-ATPase activity was inhibited by only 40-60%. Thus subunit IV of CF0-CF1 may not participate directly in proton transfer but may have a role in organizing and/or stabilizing CF0 structure.     

Inhibition of Thylakoid ATPase by Venturicidin as an Indicator of CF1-CF0 Interaction

Venturicidin inhibits the F0 portion of membrane-located, H+-pumping ATPases. We find it meets the criteria for an energy transfer inhibitor for spinach (Spinacia oleracea) thylakoids: complete inhibition of photophosphorylation and of photophosphorylation-stimulated and basal electron flow rates, but not of electron flow under uncoupled conditions. The extent of H+ uptake in the light is stimulated by venturicidin (vtcd), as expected for a compound blocking H+ efflux through CF0. Vtcd had no effect on the nonproton pumping, methanol-stimulated ATPase of thylakoids or on soluble CF1 ATPase. Under totally uncoupled conditions (saturating NH4Cl + gramicidin), vtcd can still inhibit sulfite-stimulated thylakoid ATPase completely. The concentration of vtcd needed for inhibition of ATPase was proportional to the concentration of thylakoids present in the assay, with an apparent stoichiometry of about 10 vtcd molecules per CF1/CF0 for 50% inhibition. Vtcd raised the Km for ATP somewhat, but had a stronger effect on the Vmax with respect to ATP. Inhibition by saturating vtcd ranged from 50 to 100%, depending on the condition of the thylakoids. Grinding leaves in buffer containing 0.2 M choline chloride (known to provide superior photophosphorylation rates) helped bring on maximum vtcd inhibition; trypsin treatment or aging of thylakoids brought on vtcd-resistant ATPase. We conclude that the extent of inhibition by vtcd can be used as an indicator of the tightness of coupling between CF1 and CF0.     

Enzymes of plastid ribosome-deficient mutants chloroplast ATPase (CF1)

Summary The mutant line albostrians ofHordeum vulgare L. was investigated by a variety of methods to detect the presence of the chloroplast coupling factor of photophosphorylation (CF₁). The plastids in white leaves of the line albostrians lack ribosomes and are therefore not able to synthesize proteins.Plastid membranes were isolated from light-grown and dark-grown leaves of the wild-type and of the plastid ribosome-deficient mutant. CF₁ could be removed from chloroplast membranes of the wild-type by treatment with EDTA. However, no ATPase activity was found in EDTA extracts of the mutant, and no trace of CF₁ could be detected in this extract by reaction with antiserum against CF₁ in two-dimensional immunoelectrophoresis. Eight isoenzymes of ATPase were found in the fraction of soluble proteins of green wild-type leaves. No CF₁ is detected in this fraction isolated from mutant leaves, but four of the ATPases (not identical with CF₁) are reduced in activity or lacking. Visualization of CF₁ upon internal membranes of etioplasts of the wild-type was made possible by a special electron microscope procedure. CF₁ particles were found in large numbers attached to the pro-thylakoid membranes. CF₁ particles could not be observed upon the membranes from plastids prepared from the mutant.Since no trace of CF₁ could be detected in the plastids of the mutant by various methods, it is concluded that the absence of CF₁ in this mutant is a direct effect of the deficiency in the capacity of the plastid to synthesize proteins.This is part XVII of a series on: Structure and function of the genetic information in plastids.     

Single channel H+ currents through reconstituted chloroplast ATP synthase CF0-CF1.

The purified chloroplast ATP synthase (CF(0)-CF(1)) was reconstituted into azolectin liposomes from which bilayer membranes on the tip of a glass pipette ('dip stick technique')and planar bilayer membranes were form ed. The CF(0)-CF(1) facilitated ion conductance through the bilayer membranes. Our results clearly indicated that the observed single channel currents were carried by H+ through the isolated and reconstituted chloroplast ATPase. We demonstrated that in proteoliposomes it is the whole enzyme complex CF(0)-CF(1) and not the membrane sector CF(0) alone that constitutes a voltagegated, proton-selective channel with a high conductance of 1-5 pS at pH 5.5-8.0. After removal of CF(1) from the liposomes by NaBr treatment the membrane sector CF(0) displayed various kinds of channels also permeable to monovalent cations. The open probability P(0) of the CF(0)-CF(1) channel increased considerable with increasing membrane voltage [from P(0) less than or equal to 1% (V(m) less than or equal to 120 mV) to P(0) less than or equal to 30% (120 mV less than or equal to Vm 200 mV)]. In the presence of ADP (3 microM) and P(i) (5 microM), which specifically bind to CF(1), the open probability decreased and venturicidin (1 microM), a specific inhibitor of H+ flow through CF(0) in thylakoid membranes, blocked the channel almost completely. Our results, which reveal a high channel unit conductance, and at membrane voltages less than 100 mV low open probability with concomitant mean open times in the micros timescale (less than 100 micros) for the energy coupling in the enzyme complex. At physiological membrane voltages for photophosphorylation (about 30 mV) the enzyme complex would then display a time-averaged conductance of about 1 fS.     

Correlation between the ATP synthetic active state and the ATP hydrolytic active state in chloroplast ATP synthase-ATPase complex CF0 . CF1

Illumination of chloroplast thylakoids activates ATP synthase-ATPase complex CF0 . CF1. The time course of ATP synthesis is linear if ADP and Pi are added before or simultaneously with illumination. ATP synthesis initiated by adding the substrates in the light exhibits a curvilinear time course with a low initial rate (Vi). Vi, but not the rate at a steady state, decreases with increasing preillumination time with a half-time of 2 s. Coincident with this decrease in Vi, activation of ATP hydrolysis takes place. In the postillumination dark, restoration of Vi is observed: Vi increases with increasing time intervals between the end of illumination and the addition of the substrates with simultaneous reillumination (half-time of 3 s). Coincident with this restoration of Vi, inactivation of ATP hydrolysis takes place. Such an increase in Vi in the postillumination dark is not observed in thylakoids pretreated with N-ethylmaleimide. These results suggest the following: in the light, the ATP synthetically active, but ATP hydrolytically inactive state (Es) converts to the ATP hydrolytically active, but ATP synthetically inactive (or less active) state (Eh) in the absence of ADP and Pi. The N-ethylmaleimide pretreatment inhibits this process. In the postillumination dark, the reverse conversion takes place.     

Purification and Characterization of a Glycerol-Resistant CF(0)-CF(1) and CF(1)-ATPase from the Halotolerant Alga Dunaliella bardawil

The isolation of the chloroplast ATP synthase complex (CF₀-CF₁) and of CF₁ from Dunaliella bardawil is described. The subunit structure of the D. bardawil ATPase differs from that of the spinach in that the D. bardawil α subunit migrates ahead of the β subunit and ε-migrates ahead of subunit II of CF₀ when separated by sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The CF₁ isolated from D. bardawil resembles the CF₁ isolated from Chladmydomonas reinhardi in that a reversible, Mg²⁺-dependent ATPase is induced by selected organic solvents. Glycerol stimulates cyclic photophosphorylation catalyzed by D. bardawil thylakoid membranes but inhibits photophosphorylation catalyzed by spinach thylakoid membranes. Glycerol (20%) also stimulates the rate of ATP-P_i exchange catalyzed by D. bardawil CF₀-CF₁ proteoliposomes but inhibits the activity with the spinach enzyme. The ethanol-activated, Mg²⁺-ATPase of the D. bardawil CF₁ is more resistant to glycerol inhibition than the octylglucoside-activated, Mg²⁺-ATPase of spinach CF₁ or the ethanol-activated, Mg²⁺-dependent ATPase of the C. reinhardi CF₁. Both cyclic photophosphorylation and ATP-P_i exchange catalyzed by D. bardawil CF₀-CF₁ are more sensitive to high concentrations of NaCl than is the spinach complex.     

Stimulation mechanism of soluble ATPase from chloroplasts (CF1)]

Effects of various compounds on Mg-dependent ATPase activity of chloroplast coupling factor--CF1--were studied. It was shown that the stimulating effect of compounds is increased with the increase in their hydrophobicity. Under given experimental conditions all compounds under study readily accept and donate protons. The maximal efficiency is reached when pH of the medium is close to the pK value of conjugated acid. It is assumed that the stimulating effects of compounds on Mg-dependent chloroplast ATPase consist in the increase of the rate of the limiting step of enzyme induced proton translocation coupled to the catalytic step of ATP hydrolysis.     

Energy-dependent conformational changes in the epsilon subunit of the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0CF1)

Incubation of spinach chloroplast thylakoids with pyridoxal 5'-phosphate modified the epsilon subunit of ATP synthase (CF0CF1). Illumination of thylakoids stimulated the modification of one specific amino acid residue of the epsilon subunit by a factor of 3. Endoproteinase Glu-C treatment of the isolated epsilon subunit and fractionation of the peptides by high performance liquid chromatography revealed a major fluorescent peptide with the sequence GKRQKIE. Further treatment of this peptide with endoproteinase Arg-C gave a strongly fluorescent tripeptide (GXR). From the primary structure of the epsilon subunit, the specifically modified residue was deduced to be Lys-109. This suggests the energy-dependent conformational changes in the epsilon subunit which change the surroundings of Lys-109 and alter the reactivity of this residue.     

Proton efflux through the chloroplast ATP synthase (CF0 . CF1) in the presence of sulfhydryl-modifying agents

The rate of photosynthetic electron transport measured in the absence of ADP and Pi is stimulated by low levels of Hg2+ or Ag+ (50% stimulation approximately or equal to 3 Hg2+ or 6 Ag+/100 chlorophyll) to a plateau equal to the transport rate under normal phosphorylating conditions (i.e. +ADP, +Pi). Chloroplasts pretreated in the light under energizing conditions with N-ethylmaleimide show a similar stimulation of non-phosphorylating electron transport. The stimulations of non-phosphorylating electron transport by Hg2+, Ag+ and N-ethylmaleimide are reversed by the CF1 inhibitor phlorizin, the CF0 inhibitor triphenyltin chloride, and can be further stimulated by uncouplers such as methylamine. The Hg2+ and N-ethylmalemide stimulations, but not the Ag+ stimulation, are completely reversed by low levels of ADP (2 microM), ATP (2 microM), AND Pi (400 microM). Ag+, which is a potent inhibitor of ATP synthesis, has little or no effect upon phosphorylating electron transport (+ADP, +Pi). Concomitant with the stimulations of non-phosphorylating electron transport by Hg2+, Ag+ and ADP + Pi, there is a decrease in the level of membrane energization (as measured by atebrin fluorescence quenching) which is reversed when the CF0 channel is blocked by triphenyltin. These results suggest that modification of critical CF1 sulfhydryl residues by Hg2+, Ag+ or N-ethylmalemide leads to the loss of intra-enzyme coupling between the transmembrane proton-transferring and the ATP synthesis activities of the CF0-CF1 ATP synthase complex.     

Photolabelling with 8-azido-adenine nucleotides of adenine nucleotide-binding sites in isolated spinach chloroplast ATPase (CF1)

1. Photolabelling of chloroplast ATPase (CF1) with either 8-azido-ATP or 8-azido-ADP leads to inactivation of the ATPase activity. ATP and ADP protect against the inactivation, whereas AMP dose not. 2. Ca2+ has little if any effect on the degree of inactivation by photolabelling with 8-azido-ADP, but, at the same degree of inactivation, twice as much label is bound in the presence of Ca2+ as in its absence. 3. The degree of inactivation of ATPase and the amount of bound photolabel are independent of the extent of pre-activation of the CF1. 4. Upon extrapolation to complete inactivation, 2 mol label, either 8-azido-ATP or 8-azido-ADP can be bound. 5. In all cases the label is bound specifically to the alpha and beta subunits in almost equal amounts. The location of the bound label is not affected by addition of Ca2+, ATP or ADP.     

ATP hydrolysis catalyzed by a beta subunit preparation purified from the chloroplast energy transducing complex CF1.CF0

Washing thylakoid membranes with 1 M LiCl causes the release of the beta subunit from the chloroplast energy transducing complex (CF1.CF0) in spinach chloroplasts. This protein purifies by size exclusion chromatography as a 180-kDa aggregate and, thus, is probably composed of a trimer of beta polypeptides. The purified aggregate binds ADP to a high and a low affinity site with dissociation constants of 15 and 202 microM, respectively. Mg2+ is required for ADP to bind to both sites. Manganese binds to the protein in a cooperative manner to at least two sites with high affinity. The beta subunit preparation catalyzes Mg2+-dependent ATP hydrolysis at rates which are comparable to other subunit-deficient CF1 preparations and is increased by treatments known to activate the Mg2+-ATPase activity of CF1. However, Ca2+ is not an effective cofactor for this reaction and treatments which activate the Ca2+-ATPase of CF1 are either ineffective or inhibitory.     

Isolation and properties of CF1 ATPase chloroplasts with changed submolecular structure]

An isolation procedure is worked out and properties are studied of CF1 ATPase from chloroplasts with changed submolecular structure. The enzyme, isolated by chlorophorm treatment, produced Ca-dependent ATPase activity in water solution. As compared with the enzyme isolated by well known Lien and Racker method, the enzyme preparation obtained is slightly activated by heating, is not activated by trypsin and has a lesser ability to recover ATP synthesis in EDTA-treated chloroplasts. Purification on DEAE-Sephadex produced the enzyme preparation free of delta-subunit. Chlorophorm treatment is suggested to change submolecular protein structure, in particular, loosening of the link of delta-subunit with other enzyme subunits. The data obtained suggest that delta-subunit participates in the binding of CF1 ATPase with chloroplast membrane.     

Reconstitution of CF1-depleted thylakoid membranes with complete and fragmented chloroplast ATPase. The role of the delta subunit for proton conduction through CF0

Chloroplast ATPase (CF1) was isolated from spinach, pea and maize thylakoids by EDTA extraction followed by anion-exchange chromatography. CF1 was purified and resolved by HPLC into integral CF1, and CF1 lacking the delta & epsilon subunits: CF1(-delta) and CF1(-epsilon). Washing Mono-Q-bound CF1 with alcohol-containing buffers followed by elution without alcohol produced the beta subunit and in separate peaks CF1(-delta) and CF1(-epsilon). Elution from Mono Q in the presence of tenside yielded a beta delta fragment, CF1(-delta) and CF1(-delta epsilon). Chloroplasts were CF1-depleted by EDTA extraction. Reconstitution of photophosphorylation in these 'EDTA vesicles' was obtained by addition of CF1 and its fragments. CF1, CF1(-delta) and CF1(-delta epsilon) were active with cross-reactivity between spinach, pea and maize. delta-containing CF1 always reconstituted higher activities than delta-deficient CF1. The beta delta fragment and dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD)-inhibited CF1 also were reconstitutively active while beta and DCCD-inhibited CF1(-delta) were not. These results support the notion that subunit delta can function as a stopcock to the CF0 proton channel as proposed by Junge, W., Hong, Y. Q., Qian, L. P. and Viale, A. [(1984) Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 81, 3078-3082].     

Characterization of nucleotide binding sites of the isolated H(+)-ATPase from spinach chloroplasts, CF(0)F(1)

Soluble purified CF(0)F(1) from chloroplasts was either oxidized or reduced and then incubated with [alpha-(32)P]ATP in the presence or in the absence of Mg(2+). Depending on the conditions of incubation, the enzyme showed different tight-nucleotide binding sites. In the presence of EDTA, two sites bind [alpha-(32)P]ATP from the reaction medium at different rates. Both sites promote ATP hydrolysis, since equimolar amounts of [alpha-(32)P]ATP and [alpha-(32)P]ADP are bound to the enzyme. In the presence of Mg(2+), only one site appears during the first hour of incubation, with characteristics similar to those described in the absence of Mg(2+). However, after this time a third site appears also permitting binding of ATP from the reaction medium, but in this case the bound ATP is not hydrolyzed. Covalent derivatization by 2-azido-[alpha-(32)P]ATP was used to distinguish between catalytic and noncatalytic sites. In the presence of Mg(2+), there are at least three distinct nucleotide binding sites that bind nucleotide tightly from the reaction medium: two of them are catalytic and one is noncatalytic.