Ligand-dependent Bohr effect of Chrionomus hemoglobins.

The O2 and CO Bohr effects of monomeric and dimeric hemoglobins of the insect Chironomus thummi thummi were determined as proton releases upon ligation. For the O2 Bohr effect of the monomeric hemoglobin III a maximum value of 0.20 H+/heme was obtained at pH 7.5. Upon ligation with CO, however, only 0.04 H+/heme were released at the same pH. In agreement with this finding isoelectric focusing experiments revealed different isoelectric points for O2-liganded and CO-liganded states of hemoglobin III. Analogous results were obtained in the cases of the monomeric hemoglobin IV and the dimeric hemoglobins of Chironomus thummi thummi; here O2 Bohr effects of 0.43 and 0.86 H+/heme were observed. For the corresponding CO Bohr effects values of 0.08 and 0.31 H+/heme were obtained respectively. On the basis of the available structural data the reduced CO Bohr effect in hemoglobin III is discussed as arising from a steric hindrance of the CO ligand by the side chain of isoleucine-E11, obstructing the movement of the heme-iron upon reaction with carbon monoxide. It should, however, be noted that ligands, according to their different electron donor and acceptor properties, may generally induce different conformational changes and thus different Bohr effects, in those hemoglobins in which distinct tertiary and/or quaternary constraints have not evolved. The general utilization of CO instead of O2 as allosteric effector is ruled out by the results reported here.     

The measurement of the Bohr effect of fish hemoglobins by gel electrofocusing

• 1. Hemolysates from 16 species of Amazon fish and one amphibian were analyzed by gel electrofocusing. The change in isoelectric point upon deoxygenation provided a reliable estimate of the Bohr effect.
• 2. Certain species of fish had single hemoglobin components whose pI increased significantly upon deoxygenation, as in man. Other fish had hemoglobins whose isoelectric points were unaffected by deoxygenation. Six species of fish had at least two hemoglobin components, one of which had a reduced isoelectric point upon deoxygenation indicating a reversed Bohr effect, whereas the other(s) had an increased isoelectric point on deoxygenation, as occurs with the normal alkaline Bohr effect.
• 3. A close correlation was found between the change in isoelectric point with deoxygenation and the Bohr effect determined by oxygen equilibrium measurements.

     

The enhancement of the alkaline Bohr effect of some fish hemoglobins with adenosine triphosphate.

The oxygen equilibria of the hemoglobins of one holostean fish, the spotted gar (Lepisosteus osculatus), and of four teleost fish, the carpsucker (Carpiodes carpio), the small mouth buffalo fish (Ictiobus bubalus), the Rio Grande cichlid (Cichlasoma cyanoguttatum), and the redear sunfish (Lepomis microlophus), have been measured as a function of pH in the presence and absence of ATP. The oxygen equilibria of the teleost hemoglobins in the presence of 200 μm ATP can be superimposed within experimental error upon the data obtained in the absence of ATP by a simple downward shift of the pH scale by 0.5 unit. Thus the effects of proton and ATP binding appear equivalent: Both can be interpreted in terms of a two-state allosteric model in which binding occurs preferentially to the low-affinity T-state. The oxygen affinities of each of the teleost hemoglobins approach asymptotically a maximal value at high pH. Although these high affinities are associated with decreased cooperativity of oxygen binding, as reflected by the Hill coefficient n, the asymptotic value of n never appears lower than 1.2 to 1.4. This indicates that the data cannot be completely described in terms of a single high-affinity R-state in alkaline solution: At least two different conformations are required. The oxygen affinity of the spotted gar hemoglobin, like that of each of the teleost hemoglobins, reaches a maximal value (minimal value of log PO₂ for half-saturation) above pH 8, but unlike teleost hemoglobins, the Hill coefficient reaches maximal values of 2.6 to 2.7 at high pH. The data in the absence of ATP are superimposable on the data in its presence by a downward shift of the pH scale by 0.25 unit. The measurement of the Bohr effect ($\text{Δlog}\text{P}{}_{30}\text{ΔpH}$) in the presence and absence of ATP shows that the Bohr effect in each of the hemoglobins is substantially enhanced by organic phosphates, as it is in mammalian hemoglobins. The extent of the enhancement of the Bohr effect by 200 μm ATP for each of the hemoglobins is approximately the same in the range pH 6.7 to 7.3 (increase in $\text{Δlog}\text{P}{}_{50}\text{ΔpH}\text{~ 0.3}$). This is a direct consequence of the equivalence of the linked-function relationship to the effects of ATP and proton binding on oxygenation.     

Contribution of cooperativity and the Bohr effect to efficient oxygen transport by hemoglobins from five mammalian species

By using published experimental values of the standard oxygen (O2) equilibrium curve and the in vivo arterial and venous O2 pressure (PO2) of fetal and maternal blood in five mammalian species (human, cow, pig, sheep, and horse), we investigated the relationship between the efficiency of O2 delivery and the effectiveness of the Bohr shift, and discussed the significance of cooperativity for mammalian Hb. The O2 delivery of fetal blood was more efficient than that of maternal blood, and the effectiveness of the Bohr shift at both O2 loading and release sites of fetal blood was high. A linear relationship was observed between the efficiency of O2 delivery and the effectiveness of the Bohr shift at O2 loading sites of the five mammalian species. In both fetal and maternal blood, the theoretically obtained optimal P50 value for O2 delivery (optP50(OD)) was nearly equal to the optimal P50 value for the effectiveness of the Bohr shift at the O2 loading site (optP50(BS)(loading)). This phenomenon was favorable for fetal blood to uptake O2 from maternal blood with the aid of the Bohr shift and to deliver a large amount of O2 to the tissues. The optP50s for the effectiveness of the Bohr shift at given arterial PO2 (PaO2) and venous PO2 (PvO2) were derived as follows: optP50(BS)(loading) = PaO2((n+1)/(n-1))(1/n), and optP50(BS)(release) = PvO2((n+1)/(n-1))(1/n). The relationship between in vivo PO2s and n, PaO2/PvO2 = ((n+1)/(n-1))(2/n), was derived by letting optP50 for the efficiency of O2 delivery be equal to that for the effectiveness of the Bohr shift.     

Haemoglobin Hiroshima and the Mechanism of the Alkaline Bohr Effect

HAEMOGLOBIN Hiroshima is a variant with interesting physiological properties^1,2 discovered in a Japanese family. Its Bohr effect is halved, its oxygen affinity at physiological pH increased about three-fold and haem-haem interaction is somewhat reduced compared with normal haemoglobin. In 0.1 M NaCl solutions initially stripped of phosphate, 2,3-diphospho-glycerate (2,3-DPG) diminishes the oxygen affinity as in haemoglobin A (H. F. Bunn, unpublished results). The amino-acid substitution originally deduced for this abnormal haemoglobin was histidine 143 (H21)β ? aspartic acid¹. It was possible to conceive of a mechanism which accounted for its diminished Bohr effect³, but the normal response of its oxygen affinity to 2,3-DPG was inconsistent with the proposed role of histidine 143 in 2,3-DPG binding by haemoglobin A^4,5. An X-ray crystallographic study of deoxyhaemoglobin Hiroshima has now revealed that the replacement occurs not in position 143 but 146β. This was confirmed by chemical methods and the physiological properties of this haemoglobin are now satisfactorily accounted for. The results support the role of histidine 146β in the alkaline Bohr effect⁶.     

The cooperativity of human fetal and adult hemoglobins is optimized: a consideration based on the effectiveness of the Bohr shift

The physiological significance of the cooperativity of human hemoglobin (Hb) is considered from the viewpoint of the effectiveness of the Bohr shift at the sites of O(2) release and uptake across the placental membrane. The effects of the Bohr shift was examined by changing the O(2) saturation of Hb (S(pO2)) per unit change in P(50), -dS(PO2)/d P(50), where P(50) is partial pressure of O(2) at half saturation. The Bohr shift at the sites of O(2) uptake and release was found to be highly effective in both fetal and maternal bloods at physiological degree of cooperativity (Hill's coefficient, n=2.65). From the results obtained in this paper, it is concluded that the positions of OECs of fetal and maternal Hbs are regulated to receive a maximal benefit from the Bohr shift, and that a relatively low n value of human tetrameric Hb is adequate for the O(2) and CO(2) exchange across the placental membrane.     

Anion Bohr effect of human hemoglobin

The pH dependence of oxygen affinity of hemoglobin (Bohr effect) is due to ligand-linked pK shifts of ionizable groups. Attempt to identify these groups has produced controversial data and interpretations. In a further attempt to clarify the situation, we noticed that hemoglobin alkylated in its liganded form lost the Bohr effect while hemoglobin alkylated in its unliganded form showed the presence of a practically unmodified Bohr effect. In spite of this difference, analyses of the extent of alkylation of the two compounds failed to identify the presence of specific preferential alkylations. In particular, the alpha 1 valines and beta 146 histidines appeared to be alkylated to the same extent in the two proteins. Focusing our attention on the effect of the anions on the functional properties of hemoglobin, we measured the Bohr effect of untreated hemoglobin in buffers made with HEPES [N-(2-hydroxyethyl)piperazine-N'-2-ethanesulfonic acid], MES [2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulfonic acid], and MOPS [3-(N-morpholino)propanesulfonic acid], which being zwitterions do not need addition of chlorides or other anions for reaching the desired pH. The shape acquired by the Bohr effect curves, either as pH dependence of oxygen affinity or as pH dependence of protons exchanged with the solution, was irreconcilable with that of the Bohr effect curves in usual buffers. This indicated the relevance of solvent components in determining the functional properties of hemoglobin. A new thermodynamic model is proposed for the Bohr effect that includes the interaction of hemoglobin with solvent components. The classic proton Bohr effect is a special case of the new theory.     

Iron-histidine stretching vibration in the deoxy state of insect hemoglobins with different O2 affinities and Bohr effects

Resonance Raman spectroscopy has been employed to detect the iron-proximal histidine stretching mode in deoxyhemoglobins from insect larvae of Chironomus thummi thummi (CTT). With the excitation of 413.1 nm, we observe a sharp and intense line in the 220-224 cm-1 region. The assignment of this line to the Fe-N epsilon (His) stretching mode was made on the basis of a 3-cm-1 shift upon 57Fe/54Fe isotope substitution. The Fe-N epsilon (His) vibration is used to monitor the possible changes in the Fe-N epsilon (His) bond strength (hence bone length) in the deoxy state of the monomeric (CTT I, III, and IV) and dimeric (CTT II) insect hemoglobins. As these hemoglobins differ in O2 affinity, off-rate and on-rate constants, and in the Bohr effect, they are excellent model systems for investigating the mechanism of protein control of the heme reactivity. Some of these hemoglobins (CTT III, IV, and II) are allosteric, exhibiting two interconvertible conformational states with high and low O2 affinity at high and low pH, respectively. The Fe-N epsilon (His) stretching frequency does not correlate with the O2 affinity, the on-rate and the off-rate constants for different hemoglobins, for different conformational states, and for modified hemoglobins with different heme peripheral groups. This vibrational mode is insensitive to deuteration of the heme vinyl groups. It is important to note that the Fe-N epsilon (His) bonds in the high pH (high-affinity) and the low pH (low-affinity) states are identical. This implies that the O2 molecule, prior to binding, "sees" identical binding sites. Thus, the difference in free energy changes upon O2 binding is manifested only in the oxy form.     

Molecular basis of the Bohr effect in arthropod hemocyanin

Flash photolysis and K-edge x-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) were used to investigate the functional and structural effects of pH on the oxygen affinity of three homologous arthropod hemocyanins (Hcs). Flash photolysis measurements showed that the well-characterized pH dependence of oxygen affinity (Bohr effect) is attributable to changes in the oxygen binding rate constant, k(on), rather than changes in k(off). In parallel, coordination geometry of copper in Hc was evaluated as a function of pH by XAS. It was found that the geometry of copper in the oxygenated protein is unchanged at all pH values investigated, while significant changes were observed for the deoxygenated protein as a function of pH. The interpretation of these changes was based on previously described correlations between spectral lineshape and coordination geometry obtained for model compounds of known structure (Blackburn, N. J., Strange, R. W., Reedijk, J., Volbeda, A., Farooq, A., Karlin, K. D., and Zubieta, J. (1989) Inorg. Chem., 28, 1349-1357). A pH-dependent change in the geometry of cuprous copper in the active site of deoxyHc, from pseudotetrahedral toward trigonal was assigned from the observed intensity dependence of the 1s --> 4p(z) transition in x-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) spectra. The structural alteration correlated well with increase in oxygen affinity at alkaline pH determined in flash photolysis experiments. These results suggest that the oxygen binding rate in deoxyHc depends on the coordination geometry of Cu(I) and suggest a structural origin for the Bohr effect in arthropod Hcs.     

Tetramer-dimer dissociation in homoglobin and the Bohr effect.

The pH dependence of the apparent tetramer to dimer dissociation constant has been determined at 20 degrees for both oxy- and deoxyhemoglobins A and Kansas. These measurements were made by three different procedures: gel chromatography, sedimentation velocity, and kinetic methods in either of three buffer systems: 0.05 M cacodylate, Tris, or glycine with 1 mM EDTA and 0.1 M NaCl between pH 6.5 and 11. The tetramer-dimer dissociation constant of human oxyhemoglobin A decreases from about 3.2 X 10(-6) M at pH 6.0 to about 3.2 X 10(-8) M at pH 8.5. The slope of this line indicates that the dissociation of tetramer to dimer is accompanied by the uptake of about 0.6 protons per mol of tetramer in this region. The corresponding dissociation constant for deoxyhemoglobin in the same pH region increases apparently almost linearly from 1.0 x 10(-12) M at pH 6.5 to about 1.0 x 10(-5) M at pH 11. To dimer is associated with the release of about 1.6 protons per mol of tetramer. Comparison of these data with the known proton release accompanying the oxygenation of tetramers confirms that the pH dependence of oxygen binding by dimers must be very small. The present data predict that the overall proton release or uptake per oxygen bound by dimer should be less than 0.1. The tetramer-dimer dissociation equilibria of oxy- and deoxyhemoglobins above pH 8.5 have identical pH dependences. In this range the dissociation constant of deoxy-Hb is about one-tenth that of oxyhemoglobin. Human oxyhemoglobin Kansas is known to have an enhanced tetramer-dimer dissociation compared with that of hemoglobin A. Below pH 8.5 the tetramer-dimer dissociation constant of Hb Kansas is about 400 times greater than that of HbA in the absence of phosphate buffers. In contrast, the tetramer-dimer dissociation constants of deoxyhemoglobins A and Kansas appear to be identical. These findings are consistent with previous structural observations on these hemoglobins. The data on the tetramer-dimer dissociation of human hemoglobin were used to calculate the total free energy of binding of oxygen to the tetramer and the median oxygen pressure on the basis of fundamental linkage relations and a pH-independent estimate of the total free energy of binding oxygen to dimer. Simulated oxygen binding curves were generated with the equations of Ackers and Halvorson (Ackers, G. K., and Halvorson, H. (1974) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 71, 4312-4316) by making two assumptions: (a) that the dimers are noncooperative and pH-independent in O2 binding and (b) that the distribution of cooperative energy in the oxygenation of tetramers is independent of pH. We have compared these simulations with experimental data obtained at low protein concentrations (30 to 124 muM heme) to show that the variation in oxygen affinity with pH can be described in terms of the subunit equilibria. We conclude that an accurate analysis of the contributions of individual oxygen binding steps to the Bohr effect cannot be made without considering the contributions of the dimers to oxygen binding...