Potato virus Y NIa protease activity is not sufficient for elicitation of Ry-mediated disease resistance in potato

Ry confers extreme resistance (ER) to all strains of potato virus Y (PVY). In previous work, we have shown that the protease domain of the nuclear inclusion a protease (NIaPro) from PVY is the elicitor of the Ry-mediated resistance and that integrity of the protease active site is required for the elicitation of the resistance response. Two possibilities arise from these results: first, the structure of the active protease has elicitor activity; second, NIa-mediated proteolysis is required to elicit the resistance response. To resolve these possibilities, the NIaPro from PVY was randomly mutagenised and the clones obtained were screened for elicitation of cell death as an indicator of resistance and proteolytic activity. We did not find any mutants that had retained the ability to elicit cell death but had lost protease activity, as measured by processing of the NIa cleavage site in the viral genome. This was consistent with the idea that protease activity is necessary for elicitor activity. However, protease activity was not sufficient because we found three elicitor-defective mutants in which there was a high level of protease activity in this assay.     

Expression of genes for resistance to potato virus Y in potato plants and protoplasts

Plants of several potato clones with major gene resistance to potato virus Y (PVY) developed necrotic local lesions and systemic necrosis after manual inoculation with common (PVY_o) or veinal necrosis (PVY_N) strains of the virus. The clones reacted similarly, although their resistance genes are thought to be derived from four different wild species of Solarium. Mesophyll protoplasts from each clone became infected when inoculated with RNA of PVY_o by the polyethylene glycol method. The proportion of protoplasts infected, assessed by staining with fluorescent antibody to virus particles, was similar to that of protoplasts of susceptible potato cultivars. In contrast, plants of potato cultivars Corine and Pirola, which possess gene Ry from S. stoloniferum, developed few or no symptoms when manually inoculated or grafted with PVY_o. Moreover, only very few protoplasts of these cultivars produced virus particle antigen after inoculation with PVY_o RNA. The extreme resistance to PVY of cvs Corine and Pirola was therefore expressed by inoculated protoplasts whereas the resistance of the necrotic-reacting potato clones was not.     

PVY-resistant transgenic potato plants expressing an anti-NIa protein scFv antibody

A synthetic gene encoding a single chain Fv fragment of an antibody directed against the nuclear inclusion a (NIa) protein of potato virus Y (PVY) was used to transform two commerical potato cultivars (Claustar and BF15). The NIa protease forms the nuclear inclusion body A and acts as the major protease in the cleavage of the viral polyprotein into functional proteins. Immunoblot analysis showed that most of the resulting transgenic plants accumulate high levels of the transgenic protein. Furthermore, a majority of the selected transgenic lines showed an efficient and complete protection against the challenge virus after mechanical inoculation with PVY^o strain. Two transgenic lines showed an incomplete resistance with delayed appearance of symptoms accompanied by low virus titers, whereas one line developed symptoms during the first days after inoculation but recovered rapidly, leading to a low virus accumulation rate. These results confirm that expression of scFv antibody is able to inhibit a crucial step in the virus multiplication, such as polyprotein cleavage is a powerful strategy for engineered virus resistance. It can lead to a complete resistance that was not obtained previously by expression of scFv directed against the viral coat protein.     

Potato gene Y-1 is an N gene homolog that confers cell death upon infection with potato virus Y

ADG2 is a DNA sequence mapped to a resistance (R) gene-rich region at the distal end of chromosome XI in potato (Solanum tuberosum subsp. andigena). The gene, in which ADG2 represents the predicted nucleotide-binding domain (NBS), was cloned and characterized. The coding region of the gene (designated as Y-1) is 6,187 bp long and structurally similar to gene N that confers hypersensitive resistance to Tobacco mosaic virus in Nicotiana spp. Both belong to the TIR-NBS-LRR class of genes and show 57% identity at the amino acid sequence level. The introns of Y-1 were spliced as predicted from the sequence. Y-1 cosegregated with Ry(adg), a gene for extreme resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) on chromosome XI, as tested in a potato-mapping population and with independent potato cultivars. Leaves of the transgenic potato plants expressing Y-1 under the control of Cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter developed necrotic lesions upon infection with PVY, but no significant resistance was observed, and plants were systemically infected with PVY.     

Accumulation of potato virus Y is enhanced in Solatium brevidens also infected with tobacco mosaic virus or potato spindle tuber viroid

The accumulation of potato virus Y?(PVY?) and potato leaf roll virus (PLRV) was studied in plants of Solanum brevidens co-infected with each of six viruses or a viroid. Virus could not be detected by ELISA in plants of S. brevidens infected solely with PVY. However, accumulation of PVY was increased c. 1000-fold in plants doubly infected with tobacco mosaic virus or potato spindle tuber viroid (PSTVd). PVY titres in doubly infected plants of S. brevidens were between 1% and 0.1% of those found in the PVY-susceptible interspecific Solanum hybrid DTO-33. Double infections of 5. brevidens by PVY and alfalfa mosaic virus or potato viruses M, S, T or X did not significantly enhance PVY accumulation. Accumulation of PLRV was not enhanced in plants co-infected with any of the six viruses or PSTVd.     

Resistance to potato virus Y and potato virus X in Solanurn brevidens

Although Solanum brevidens could be infected with potato virus X (PVX), potato virus Y⁰ (PVY⁰) and PVY^N, no symptoms of infection were apparent and tests by double antibody sandwich ELISA, electron microscopy and sap transmission to local lesion test plants indicated that the titres of PVX were less than a tenth of those of PVY⁰ and PVY^N were less than a hundredth of those in infected plants of PDH40, a susceptible dihaploid clone of S. tuberosum cv. Pentland Crown. Furthermore, PVY⁰- and PVY^N- infected leaves of S. brevidens were a poor source of inoculum in aphid transmission tests. The possibility of a common mechanism and genetic basis of resistance to PVY, PVX and potato leaf roll virus in S. brevidens is discussed.     

Engineering virus resistance using a modified potato gene

Natural mutations in translation initiation factor eIF4E confer resistance to potyviruses in many plant species. Potato is a staple food crop plagued by several potyviruses, yet to date no known eIF4E-mediated resistance genes have been identified. In this study, we demonstrate that transgenic expression of the pvr1(2) gene from pepper confers resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) in potato. We then use this information to convert the susceptible potato ortholog of this allele into a de novo allele for resistance to PVY using site-directed mutagenesis. Potato plants overexpressing the mutated potato allele are resistant to virus infection. Resistant lines expressed high levels of eIF4E mRNA and protein. The resistant plants showed growth similar to untransformed controls and produced phenotypically similar tubers. This technique disrupts a key step in the viral infection process and may potentially be used to engineer virus resistance in a number of economically important plant-viral pathosystems. Furthermore, the general public may be more amenable to the 'intragenic' nature of this approach because the transferred coding region is modified from a gene in the target crop rather than from a distant species.     

The helper component proteinase cistron of Potato virus Y induces hypersensitivity and resistance in Potato genotypes carrying dominant resistance genes on chromosome IV

The Nc(tbr) and Ny(tbr) genes in Solanum tuberosum determine hypersensitive reactions, characterized by necrotic reactions and restriction of the virus systemic movement, toward isolates belonging to clade C and clade O of Potato virus Y (PVY), respectively. We describe a new resistance from S. sparsipilum which possesses the same phenotype and specificity as Nc(tbr) and is controlled by a dominant gene designated Nc(spl). Nc(spl) maps on potato chromosome IV close or allelic to Ny(tbr). The helper component proteinase (HC-Pro) cistron of PVY was shown to control necrotic reactions and resistance elicitation in plants carrying Nc(spl), Nc(tbr), and Ny(tbr). However, inductions of necrosis and of resistance to the systemic virus movement in plants carrying Nc(spl) reside in different regions of the HC-Pro cistron. Also, genomic determinants outside the HC-Pro cistron are involved in the systemic movement of PVY after induction of necroses on inoculated leaves of plants carrying Ny(tbr). These results suggest that the Ny(tbr) resistance may have been involved in the recent emergence of PVY isolates with a recombination breakpoint near the junction of HC-Pro and P3 cistrons in potato crops. Therefore, this emergence could constitute one of the rare examples of resistance breakdown by a virus which was caused by recombination instead of by successive accumulation of nucleotide substitutions.     

The novel gene Ny-1 on potato chromosome IX confers hypersensitive resistance to Potato virus Y and is an alternative to Ry genes in potato breeding for PVY resistance

Hypersensitive resistance (HR) is an efficient defense strategy in plants that restricts pathogen growth and can be activated during host as well as non-host interactions. HR involves programmed cell death and manifests itself in tissue collapse at the site of pathogen attack. A novel hypersensitivity gene, Ny-1, for resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) was revealed in potato cultivar Rywal. This is the first gene that confers HR in potato plants both to common and necrotic strains of PVY. The locus Ny-1 mapped on the short arm of potato chromosome IX, where various resistance genes are clustered in Solanaceous genomes. Expression of HR was temperature-dependent in cv. Rywal. Strains PVY^O and PVY^N, including subgroups PVY^NW and PVY^NTN, were effectively localized when plants were grown at 20°C. At 28°C, plants were systemically infected but no symptoms were observed. In field trials, PVY was restricted to the inoculated leaves and PVY-free tubers were produced. Therefore, the gene Ny-1 can be useful for potato breeding as an alternative donor of PVY resistance, because it is efficacious in practice-like resistance conferred by Ry genes.     

Expression of the PVYO coat protein (CP) under the control of the PVX CP gene leader sequence: protection under greenhouse and field conditions against PVYO and PVYN infection in three potato cultivars

Coat protein-mediated resistance (CPMR), resistance conferred as a result of the expression of viral coat proteins in transgenic plants, has been illustrated to be an effective way of protecting plants against several plant viruses. Nonetheless, consistent protection has not been achieved for transgenic plants expressing the coat protein of potato virus Y (PVY), the type member of the potyvirus family. In this report, three different potato cultivars were transformed with a chimeric construct consisting of the capsid protein (CP) coding sequences of PVY flanked by the AUG codon and the translational enhancer from the coat protein gene of potato virus X (PVX). These cultivars were shown to express high levels of PVY CP and confer a high degree of protection against PVY^o and PVY^N under both greenhouse and field conditions. In addition, transgenic plants infected with potato virus A (PVA), a related potyvirus, exhibited a delay in virus accumulation, which could be easily overcome with increasing virus concentrations. Received: 26 October 1995 / Accepted: 14 June 1996     

The use of cysteine proteinase inhibitors to engineer resistance against potyviruses in transgenic tobacco plants

As the processing mechanism of all known potyviruses involves the activity of cysteine proteinases, we asked whether constitutive expression of a rice cysteine proteinase inhibitor gene could induce resistance against two important potyviruses, tobacco etch virus (TEV) and potato virus Y (PVY), in transgenic tobacco plants. Tobacco lines expressing the foreign gene at varying levels were examined for resistance against TEV and PVY infection. There was a clear, direct correlation between the level of oryzacystatin message, inhibition of papain (a cysteine proteinase), and resistance to TEV and PVY in all lines tested. The inhibitor was ineffective against tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) infection because processing of this virus does not involve cysteine proteinases. These results show that plant cystatins can be used against different potyviruses and potentially also against other viruses, whose replication involves cysteine proteinase activity.     

Strain group specific and virus specific hypersensitive reactions to infection with potyviruses in potato cultivars

When 12 potato cultivars were inoculated with isolates (one each) of potato virus Y (PVY) ordinary (Y^o), C (Y^c) and tobacco veinal necrosis (Yⁿ) strain groups, potato virus A (PVA) and potato virus V (PVV), none of them responded hypersensitively to Yⁿ. However, with Y^o, Y^c, PVA and PW specific hypersensitive reactions developed depending on isolate-cultivar combination which were all independent of each other. When field isolates of PVY thought to be Y^oor Y^cwere inoculated to the same 12 cultivars, two did not fit into either strain group giving hypersensitive reactions in only two cultivars instead of seven with Y^oor eight with Y^c. These two isolates may represent a previously unreported PVY strain group (Y^z). When Y^owas graft-inoculated to seedlings of the cross Desiree × Maris Piper (hypersensitive × non-hypersensitive for Y^o), the segregation ratio obtained for non-hypersensitive:hypersensitive reactions was close to 1:1 suggesting that a single dominant gene (Ny_tbr) determining Y^ospecific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Desiree (simplex condition). In tests using PVV and Desiree × Maris Piper (non-hypersensitive × hypersensitive for PVV) seedlings, the segregation ratio obtained was close to 1:5 indicating that a single dominant gene (Nv) determining PVV specific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Maris Piper (duplex condition). Cultivars Corine, Pirola and clone G5457(4) which each carry one of the extreme resistance genes (Ry) from Solanum stoloniferum were graft-inoculated with Yⁿ, Y^o, Y^c, PVV and PVA. G5457(4) gave a strong localised hypersensitive reaction in all instances, while cv. Pirola did so with all except PVA to which it was immune. In cv. Corine a severe localised hypersensitive reaction developed with PVA, generalised hypersensitivity with PVV but an immune response with the three PVY strain groups. Large-scale grafting of Yⁿto plants of cvs Corine and Pirola gave no evidence of selection of a strain which overcomes Ry genes.     

Decoy engineering of the receptor-like cytoplasmic kinase StPBS1 to defend against virus infection in potato

Potato virus Y (PVY) is an important pathogen of potato (Solanum tuberosum). Although the PBS1–RPS5 immune system is well documented in Arabidopsis thaliana, it has not been reported in potato. In Arabidopsis, the bacterial effector AvrPphB cleaves AtPBS1 to trigger an immune response. Here, we show that the AvrPphB-triggered immune response is mediated by StPBS1, a close homologue of AtPBS1 in potato. However, downstream signalling of StPBS1 was mediated by unknown resistance (R) proteins other than potato orthologues of AtRPS5 and HvPBR1, which is important for HvPBS1 signalling in barley. Immune signalling of StPBS1 is mediated by the AvrPphB C-terminal cleavage domain and an STKPQ motif, in contrast to AtPBS1-mediated immunity in which both AvrPphB cleavage fragments and an SEMPH motif are essential. The cleavage sequence of AvrPphB in StPBS1 was replaced with that of the PVY NIa-Pro protease to obtain StPBS1^NIa. StPBS1^NIa overexpression potato displayed stronger immunity to PVY infection than did the StPBS1 transgenic lines. StPBS1^NIa was cleaved at the expected target site by NIa-Pro protease from PVY. Thus, we characterized the function of StPBS1 in potato immunity and provide a biotechnology control method for PVY via transformation of decoy-engineered StPBS1^NIa.     

Expression of tobacco class II catalase gene activates the endogenous homologous gene and is associated with disease resistance in transgenic potato plants

We have previously shown that healthy potato plants respond poorly to salicylic acid (SA) for activating disease resistance against the late blight fungal pathogen Phytophthora infestans. However, SA is essential for the establishment of potato systemic acquired resistance (SAR) against P. infestans after treatment with the fungal elicitor arachidonic acid (AA). To understand the molecular mechanisms through which AA induces SA-dependent SAR in potato, we have recently studied the expression of potato class II catalase (Cat2St) in comparison with its tobacco homologue, Cat2Nt, which has previously been shown to bind SA. In the present study, we show that tobacco Cat2Nt is expressed at high levels and accounts for almost half of total SA-binding activity detected in tobacco leaves. In contrast, potato Cat2St is not expressed in healthy leaves, which is associated with the low SA responsiveness of potato plants for activation of disease resistance mechanisms. Upon treatment with AA, expression of potato Cat2St is induced not only in AA-treated leaves, but also in the upper untreated parts of the plants, concomitant with the establishment of SA -dependent SAR to P. infestans. Moreover, expression of the tobacco Cat2Nt gene in transgenic potato plants leads to constitutive expression of the endogenous potato Cat2St gene and is associated with enhanced resistance to P. infestans. These results collectively indicate that plant SA-binding class II catalases may play an important role in the development of disease resistance, possibly by serving as biological targets of SA.     

Strong resistance to potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease in potato induced by transformation with coat protein gene sequences from an NTN isolate of Potato virus Y

The potato cv. Igor is susceptible to infection with Potato virus Y (PVY) and in Slovenia it has been so severely affected with NTN isolates of PVY causing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) that its cultivation has ceased. Plants of cv. Igor were transformed with two transgenes that contained coat protein gene sequence of PVY^NTN. Both transgenes used PVY sequence in a sense (+) orientation, one in native translational context (N‐CP), and one with a frame‐shift mutation (FS‐CP). Although most transgenic lines were susceptible to infection with PVY^NTN and PVY^O, several lines showed resistance that could be classified into two types. Following manual or graft inoculation, plants of partially resistant lines developed some symptoms in foliage and tubers, and virus titre in the foliage, estimated by ELISA, was low or undetectable. In highly resistant (R) lines, symptoms did not develop in foliage and on tubers, and virus could not be detected in foliage by ELISA or infectivity assay. Four lines from 34 tested (two N‐CP and two FS‐CP) were R to PVY^NTN and PVY^O and one additional line was R to PVY^O. When cv. Spey was transformed with the same constructs, they did not confer strong resistance to PVY^O.     

Genetically engineered resistance to potato virus X in four commercial potato cultivars

The genes for the capsid protein (CP) and the 8K movement protein of PVX were introduced into potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) and expressed under the control of CaMV 35S promoter using a binary vector andAgrobacterium tumefaciens. Four commercial potato cultivars (Russet Burbank, Shepody, Desirée and Bintje) have been efficiently transformed. Eleven independent transgenic clones, with CP expression levels higher than 0.05% of the soluble leaf proteins, were analyzed for resistance to inoculation with PVX (5 and 50µg/ml). The resistance of the transgenic plants to PVX was observed with the lower titer of virus inoculation (5 µg/ml) but not with higher titer (50 µg/ml). A significant reduction in the accumulation of virus in the inoculated transgenic potato plants has been observed under greenhouse and field conditions. Furthermore, the CP gene is very stable and is transferred to new plants originated from stem cuttings or from tubers. The transgenic plants appeared to be phenotypically identical to the nontransformed controls.Abbreviations BAP benzyl-aminopurine - BCIP 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolylphosphate p-Toluidine salt - CaMV cauliflower mosaic virus - CP capsid protein - GA₃ gibberellic acid - Kbp kilobase pair - NAA naphthalene acetic acid - NBT nitroblue tetrazolium chloride - NOS nopaline synthase - NPT II neomycin phosphotransferase II - PMSF phenyl methyl sulfonyl fluoride - PVX potato virus X - PVY potato virus Y     

Colorado potato beetle larvae on potato plants expressing a locust proteinase inhibitor

The natural defence system of plants often involves inhibitors of digestive enzymes of their pests. Modem and environmental-friendly methods try to increase this plant resistance by expressing heterologous protease inhibitors in crops. Here we report the effects of expressing a gene from desert locust (Schistocerca gregaria) encoding two serine protease inhibitors in potato on Colorado potato beetle (Leptinotarsa decemlineata) larvae. The gene encoding both peptides on a single chain was used for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of potato plants. The presence of the active inhibitor protein in the leaves was verified. The feeding bioassays in the laboratory showed that despite the low level of the peptide in leaves, CPB larvae on transgenic plants have grown slightly but significantly more slowly than those on control potato plants. The results support the notion that expression of multifunctional proteinase inhibitors of insect origin in plants might be a good strategy to improve insect resistance.     

Expression of a luteoviral movement protein in transgenic plants leads to carbohydrate accumulation and reduced photosynthetic capacity in source leaves

Elucidating the role of viral genes in transgenic plants revealed that the movement protein (MP) from tobacco mosaic virus is responsible for altered carbohydrate allocation in tobacco and potato plants. To study whether this is a general feature of viral MPs, the movement protein MP17 of potato leafroll virus (PLRV), a phloem-restricted luteovirus, was constitutively expressed in tobacco plants. Transgenic lines were strongly reduced in height and developed bleached and sometimes even necrotic areas on their source leaves. Levels of soluble sugars and starch were significantly increased in source leaves. Yet, in leaf laminae the hexose—phosphate content was unaltered and ATP reduced to only a small extent, indicating that these leaves were able to maintain homeostatic conditions by compartmentalization of soluble sugars, probably in the vacuole. On the contrary, midribs contained lower levels of soluble sugars, ATP, hexose—phosphates and UDP-glucose supporting the concept of limited uptake and catabolism of sucrose in the phloem. The accumulation of carbohydrates led to a decreased photosynthetic capacity and carboxylation efficiency of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (rubisco) probably owing to decreased expression of photosynthetic proteins. In parallel, levels of pathogenesis-related proteins were elevated which may be the reason for the obtained limited resistance against the unrelated potato virus Y (PVY)^N in the transgenic tobacco plants. Ultrathin sections of affected leaves harvested from 2-week-old plants revealed plasmodesmal alterations in the phloem tissue while plasmodesmata between mesophyll cells were indistinguishable from wild-type. These data favour the phloem tissue to be the primary site of PLRV MP17 action in altering carbohydrate metabolism.     

Overexpression of the wild potato eIF4E-1 variant Eva1 elicits Potato virus Y resistance in plants silenced for native eIF4E-1

Potato virus Y (PVY) is the most important viral pathogen of cultivated potato (Solanum tuberosum) from a commercial perspective, causing severe losses in both tuber quality and yield worldwide. Specific accessions of wild potato species exhibit resistance against PVY but efforts to transfer the trait to cultivated material have not yielded widely adopted varieties. Because amino acid substitutions at specific domains of host factor eIF4E-1 often confer resistance to various crops, we sequenced the associated genes expressed in wild potato plants. A novel eIF4E-1 variant, designated here as Eva1, was identified in S. chacoense, S. demissum, and S. etuberosum. The protein contains amino acid substitutions at ten different positions when compared to its cultivated potato (S. tuberosum) homolog. In the yeast two-hybrid system, Eva1 failed to bind VPg, a viral protein required for infectivity. Overexpression of the associated cDNA conferred PVY resistance to transgenic potato plants silenced for the native eIF4E-1 gene. Because the gene sources of Eva1 are sexually compatible with potato, the molecular strategies described can be employed to develop 'intragenic' potato cultivars.