Nitric oxide: an effective weapon of the plant or the pathogen?

An explosion of research in plant nitric oxide (NO) biology during the last two decades has revealed that NO is a key signal involved in plant development, abiotic stress responses and plant immunity. During the course of evolutionary changes, microorganisms parasitizing plants have developed highly effective offensive strategies, in which NO also seems to be implicated. NO production has been demonstrated in several plant pathogens, including fungi, but the origin of NO seems to be as puzzling as in plants. So far, published studies have been spread over multiple species of pathogenic microorganisms in various developmental stages; however, the data clearly indicate that pathogen‐derived NO is an important regulatory molecule involved not only in developmental processes, but also in pathogen virulence and its survival in the host. This review also focuses on the search for potential mechanisms by which pathogens convert NO messages into a physiological response or detoxify both endo‐ and exogenous NO. Finally, taking into account the data available from model bacteria and yeast, a basic draft for the mode of NO action in phytopathogenic microorganisms is proposed.     

Response to Dangl: Complex harmonies of the host–pathogen interaction

In the accompanying Research Focus article that summarises our recent research article [1], Jeffery Dangl likens the interplay of the intracellular pathogen Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium with the host resistance protein Nramp1 to the response of a congregation to the teachings of a preacher. In principle, this is a fair interpretation of what we believe to be occurring on the molecular level between host and pathogen within the limited scope of our experiments. However, as with most biological systems, we believe that this analogy might be too simplistic. As Dangl points out, Nramp1 ‘might have a multitude of messages that it sends to different vacuolar inhabitants’. This cannot exclude the fact that the effects of Nramp1 on any single pathogen are pleiotropic and that we focused solely on one aspect of Nramp1 function in our studies, that is, divalent cation limitation. Therefore, we suggest that the interplay between innate host defences and pathogens is far more complex than simple call-and-response. Instead, we propose that it is more like a musical round, where one instrument makes the initial statement of the tune followed by the response of a second instrument, building over successive entrances to a complex orchestral whole. As a case in point, we wish to draw the reader's attention to the complex influences of both Nramp1 and S. enterica Typhimurium on the generation of toxic oxygen and nitrogen intermediates by the host during infection.     

The effects of pathogen challenges on the performance of naïve and immune animals: the problem of prediction

Predictive frameworks for performance under both physical and social stressors are available, but no general framework yet exists for predicting the performance of animals exposed to pathogens. The aim of this paper was to identify the key problems that would need to be solved to achieve this. Challenges of a range of hosts by a range of pathogens were reviewed to consider reductions in growth beyond those associated with reductions in voluntary food intake (VFI). Pair-feeding and marginal response studies identified the extent and mechanisms of how further reductions in growth occur beyond those caused by reduced VFI. Further reductions in growth depended on the pathogen, the host and the dose and were time dependent. In some instances the reduction in VFI fully explained the reduction in growth. Marginal response experiments showed increased maintenance requirements during exposure to pathogens, but these were different for specific amino acids. There were no clear effects on marginal efficiency. Innate immune functions, repair of damaged tissue and expression of acquired immunity caused significant but variable increases in protein (amino acid) requirements. More resistant genotypes had greater requirements for mounting immune responses. The partitioning of protein (amino acids) was found to be different during pathogen challenges. Prediction of the requirements and partitioning of amino acids between growth and immune functions appears to be a crucial problem to solve in order to predict performance during pathogen challenges of different kinds and doses. The problems of accounting for reductions in performance during pathogen challenges that are described here provide a useful starting point for future modelling and experimental solutions.     

Plant–pathogen interactions: will the understanding of common mechanisms lead to the unification of concepts?

Plant-pathogen interactions are still classically described using concepts that make a distinction between qualitative and quantitative aspects linked to these concepts. This article first describes these aspects, using the terminology associated with them. It then presents some recent experimental observations that demonstrate that such concepts share either common or closely related mechanisms at the cellular and molecular levels. The emergence of a more global vision and understanding of the interactions between plants and their parasites is discussed.     

Uncoupling of the dynamics of host–pathogen interaction uncovers new mechanisms of viral interferon antagonism at the single-cell level

Antiviral defence in mammals is mediated through type-I interferons (IFNs). Viruses antagonise this process through expression of IFN antagonist proteins (IAPs). Understanding and modelling of viral escape mechanisms and the dynamics of IAP action has the potential to facilitate the development of specific and safe drugs. Here, we describe the dynamics of interference by selected viral IAPs, NS1 from Influenza A virus and NS3/4A from Hepatitis C virus. We used Tet-inducible IAP gene expression to uncouple this process from virus-driven dynamics. Stochastic activation of the IFN-β gene required the use of single-cell live imaging to define the efficacy of the inhibitors during the virus-induced signalling processes. We found significant correlation between the onset of IAP expression and halted IFN-β expression in cells where IFN-β induction had already occurred. These data indicate that IAPs not only prevent antiviral signalling prior to IFN-β induction, but can also stop the antiviral response even after it has been activated. We found reduced NF-κB activation to be the underlying mechanism by which activated IFN expression can be blocked. This work demonstrates a new mechanism by which viruses can antagonise the IFN response.     

Transition of secondary to systemic infection of sunflower with Plasmopara halstedii – An underestimated factor in the epidemiology of the pathogen

Plasmopara halstedii, the downy mildew pathogen of sunflower causes significant economic loss world-wide, mostly through soilborne systemic infection of seedlings. Natural infection of sunflower with P. halstedii was monitored in a sunflower field cultivated for ornamental purpose in soil where no sunflower had been grown before. Local and systemic infections were observed in plants of different developmental stages which were sown in five consecutive field plots between Apr. and Jul. The airborne origin of the infection by zoosporangia was concluded from field history, pathogenic symptoms, time course of infection and microscopic investigation of mycelium distribution in stems. A high potential for transition from local to systemic infection was found, at least in ornamental sunflower cultivation under the typical weather conditions in Central Europe. This questions the paradigm that economically and epidemiologically relevant sunflower downy mildew incidences are only derived from subterranean infections. Airborne secondary infections, as they may occur in all developmental stages and on all organs of the host plant, are responsible for late systemic infection and can play a key role in the production of contaminated seeds carrying the pathogen into the next season.     

Ultrastructural characterisation of the host–pathogen interface in white blister-infected Arabidopsis leaves

In this study transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to examine details of the host–pathogen interface in Arabidopsis thaliana cotyledons infected by Albugo candida, causal agent of white blister. After successful entry through stomatal pores, the pathogen developed a substomatal vesicle and subsequently produced intercellular hyphae. TEM observations revealed that coenocytic intercellular hyphae ramified and spread intercellularly throughout the host tissue forming several haustoria in host mesophyll cells. Intracellular haustoria were spherical and 4.5 μm in diameter. Each haustorium was connected to intercellular hyphae by a narrow, slender haustorium neck. The cytoplasm of the haustorium included the organelles characteristic of the pathogen. No obvious response was observed in host cells following formation of haustoria. Most of the mesophyll cells contained normal haustoria and the host cytoplasm displayed a high degree of structural integrity. Absence of host cell wall alteration and cell death in penetrated host cells suggest that the pathogen exerts considerable control over basic cellular processes and in this respect, response to this biotrophic Oomycete differs considerably from responses to other pathogens such as necrotrophs. Modification of the host plasma membrane (PM) along the cell wall and around the haustoria, was detected by applying the periodic acid-chromic acid-phosphotungstic acid (PACP) staining technique. After staining with PACP, the host PM was found to be intensely electron dense where it was adjacent to the host cell wall and the distal region of the haustorial neck. By contrast, the extrahaustorial membrane, where the host PM surrounded the haustorium, was consistently very lightly stained.     

A negative effect of a pathogen on its vector? A plant pathogen increases the vulnerability of its vector to attack by natural enemies

Plant pathogens that are dependent on arthropod vectors for transmission from host to host may enhance their own success by promoting vector survival and/or performance. The effect of pathogens on vectors may be direct or indirect, with indirect effects mediated by increases in host quality or reductions in the vulnerability of vectors to natural enemies. We investigated whether the bird cherry-oat aphid Rhopalosiphum padi, a vector of cereal yellow dwarf virus (CYDV) in wheat, experiences a reduction in rates of attack by the parasitoid wasp Aphidius colemani when actively harboring the plant pathogen. We manipulated the vector status of aphids (virus carrying or virus free) and evaluated the impact on the rate of attack by wasps. We found that vector status did not influence the survival or fecundity of aphids in the absence of parasitoids. However, virus-carrying aphids experienced higher rates of parasitism and greater overall population suppression by parasitoid wasps than virus-free aphids. Moreover, virus-carrying aphids were accepted as hosts by wasps more often than virus-free aphids, with a greater number of wasps stinging virus-carrying aphids following assessment by antennal palpations than virus-free aphids. Therefore, counter to the prevailing idea that persistent vector-borne pathogens enhance the performance of their vectors, we found that infectious aphids actively carrying a plant pathogen experience greater vulnerability to natural enemies. Our results suggest that parasitoids may contribute to the successful biological control of CYDV by disproportionately impacting virus-carrying vectors, and thus reducing the proportion of vectors in the population that are infectious.     

Physiological characteristics of the trunk sap rot pathogen Fomitiporia sp. on the “Sanbu-sugi” cultivar of Cryptomeria japonica

An unidentified Fomitiporia sp. initially identified as Fomitiporia punctata, causes severe trunk sap rot on Cryptomeria japonica cultivar “Sanbu-sugi”. We investigated the physiological characteristics of the mycelia of the causal fungus (F2, F6, and F43), in comparison with F. punctata (Fp) as a reference, in eight different experiments. The three unidentified isolates showed similar tendencies in change in mycelial growth during incubation, optimal growth temperatures (25 °C), optimal pH range (pH 5–6), glucose to yeast extract ratio (45), utilizable carbon sources (amylose, CM-cellulose, and pectin), utilizable nitrogen sources (yeast extract and polypepton), and water potential (?1.7 Mpa).     

Evolutionary implications of host–pathogen specificity: the fitness consequences of host life history traits

Pathogens and parasites can be strong agents of selection, and often exhibit some degree of genetic specificity for individual host strains. Here we show that this host–pathogen specificity can affect the evolution of host life history traits. All else equal, evolution should select for genes that increase individuals' reproduction rates or lifespans (and thus total reproduction per individual). Using a simple host–pathogen model, we show that when the genetic specificity of pathogen infection is low, host strains with higher reproduction rates or longer lifespans drive slower-reproducing or shorter-lived host strains to extinction, as one would expect. However, when pathogens exhibit specificity for host strains with different life history traits, the evolutionary advantages of these traits can be greatly diminished by pathogen-mediated selection. Given sufficient host–pathogen specificity, pathogen-mediated selection can maintain polymorphism in host traits that are correlated with pathogen resistance traits, despite large intrinsic fitness differences among host strains. These results have two important implications. First, selection on host life history traits will be weaker than expected, whenever host fitness is significantly affected by genotype-specific pathogen attack. Second, where polymorphism in host traits is maintained by pathogen-mediated selection, preserving the genetic diversity of host species may require preserving their pathogens as well. This revised version was published online in November 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

The extended conformation of the 2.9-Å crystal structure of the three-PASTA domain of a Ser/Thr kinase from the human pathogen Staphylococcus aureus

PASTA (penicillin-binding protein and serine/threonine kinase associated) modules are found in penicillin-binding proteins and bacterial serine/threonine kinases mainly from Gram-positive Firmicutes and Actinobacteria. They may act as extracellular sensors by binding peptidoglycan fragments. We report here the first crystal structure of a multiple-PASTA domain from Ser/Thr kinase, that of the protein serine/threonine kinase 1 (Stk1) from the Firmicute Staphylococcus aureus. The extended conformation of the three PASTA subunits differs strongly from the compact conformation observed in the two-PASTA domain of penicillin-binding protein PBP2x, whereas linear conformations were also reported for two-subunit fragments of the four-PASTA domain of the Actinobacteria Mycobacterium tuberculosis studied by liquid NMR. Thus, a stretched organization appears to be the signature of modular PASTA domains in Ser/Thr kinases. Signal transduction to the kinase domain is supposed to occur via dimerization and ligand binding. A conserved X-shaped crystallographic dimer stabilized by intermolecular interactions between the second PASTA subunits of each monomer is observed in the two crystal forms of Stk1 that we managed to crystallize. Extracellular PASTA domains are composed of at least two subunits, and this molecular assembly is a plausible candidate for the biological dimer. We have also performed docking experiments, which predict that the hinge regions of the PASTA domain can accommodate peptidoglycan. Finally, a three-dimensional homology molecular model of full-length Stk1 was generated, suggesting an interaction between the kinase domain and the cytoplasmic face of the plasma membrane via a eukaryotic-like juxtamembrane domain. A comprehensive activation mechanism for bacterial Ser/Thr kinases is proposed with the support of these structural data.     

Sulfonamide inhibition studies of two β-carbonic anhydrases from the bacterial pathogen Legionella pneumophila

Two β-carbonic anhydrases (CAs, EC 4.2.1.1) were identified, cloned and purified in the pathogenic bacterium Legionella pneumophila, denominated LpCA1 and LpCA2. They efficiently catalyze CO₂ hydration to bicarbonate and protons, with k_cat in the range of (3.4–8.3) × 10⁵ s⁻¹ and k_cat/K_m of (4.7–8.5) × 10⁷ M⁻¹ s⁻¹, and are inhibited by sulfonamides and sulfamates. The best LpCA1 inhibitors were aminobenzolamide and structurally similar sulfonylated aromatic sulfonamides, as well as acetazolamide and ethoxzolamide(K_Is in the range of 40.3–90.5 nM). The best LpCA2 inhibitors belonged to the same class of sulfonylated sulfonamides, together with acetazolamide, methazolamide and dichlorophenamide (K_Is in the range of 25.2–88.5 nM). As these enzymes may be involved in pH regulation in the phagosome during Legionella infection, their inhibition may lead to antibacterials with a novel mechanism of action.     

When does pathogen evolution maximize the basic reproductive number in well-mixed host–pathogen systems?

Pathogen evolution towards the largest basic reproductive number, $\mathcal R _0$ , has been observed in many theoretical models, but this conclusion does not hold universally. Previous studies of host–pathogen systems have defined general conditions under which $\mathcal R _0$ maximization occurs in terms of $\mathcal R _0$ itself. However, it is unclear what constraints these conditions impose on the functional forms of pathogen related processes (e.g. transmission, recover, or mortality) and how those constraints relate to the characteristics of natural systems. Here we focus on well-mixed SIR-type host–pathogen systems and, via a synthesis of results from the literature, we present a set of sufficient mathematical conditions under which evolution maximizes $\mathcal R _0$ . Our conditions are in terms of the functional responses of the system and yield three general biological constraints on when $\mathcal R _0$ maximization will occur. First, there are no genotype-by-environment interactions. Second, the pathogen utilizes a single transmission pathway (i.e. either horizontal, vertical, or vector transmission). Third, when mortality is density dependent: (i) there is a single infectious class that individuals cannot recover from, (ii) mortality in the infectious class is entirely density dependent, and (iii) the rates of recovery, infection progression, and mortality in the exposed classes are independent of the pathogen trait. We discuss how this approach identifies the biological mechanisms that increase the dimension of the environmental feedback and prevent $\mathcal R _0$ maximization.     

Effects of temperature on the host–pathogen interaction in Ascochyta blight (Ascochyta lentis) of lentil

The effects of temperature regimes on the radial growth rate of different isolates of Ascochyta lentis and pathogen virulence and host susceptibility were studied in the laboratory and growth chamber using different pathogen isolates, and lentil genotypes with varying levels of resistance to Ascochyta blight. The growth rate of most isolates increased as temperature increased up to 20°C and declined thereafter. In experiment 1, the highest disease severities were observed on cvs. Laird and Eston and the lowest on ILL5588. Mean disease severities were similar from 10 to 20°C but substantially lower at 25°C for all genotypes except ILL5588. In experiment 2, no significant differences were observed between the two mating types, or in their interactions with genotypes and temperatures. The interactions of genotypes with temperature and with isolates indicated that the relative susceptibility of lentil genotypes depended on temperature and on the isolates of A. lentis. These findings indicated that when temperature changes during epidemic development in the field, different isolates could predominate in the pathogen population at different times.     

Anion inhibition studies of two new β-carbonic anhydrases from the bacterial pathogen Legionella pneumophila

We investigated the cloning, catalytic activity and anion inhibition of the β-class carbonic anhydrases (CAs, EC 4.2.1.1) from the bacterial pathogen Legionella pneumophila. Two such enzymes, lpCA1 and lpCA2, were found in the genome of this pathogen. These enzymes were determined to be efficient catalysts for CO₂ hydration, with k_cat values in the range of (3.4–8.3) × 10⁵ s⁻¹ and k_cat/K_M values of (4.7–8.5) × 10⁷ M⁻¹ s⁻¹. A set of inorganic anions and small molecules was investigated to identify inhibitors of these enzymes. Perchlorate and tetrafluoroborate were not acting as inhibitors (K_I >200 mM), whereas sulfate was a very weak inhibitor for both lpCA1 and lpCA2 (K_I values of 77.9–96.5 mM). The most potent lpCA1 inhibitors were cyanide, azide, hydrogen sulfide, diethyldithiocarbamate, sulfamate, sulfamide, phenylboronic acid and phenylarsonic acid, with K_I values ranging from 6 to 94 μM. The most potent lpCA2 inhibitors were diethyldithiocarbamate, sulfamide, sulfamate, phenylboronic acid and phenylarsonic acid, with K_I values ranging from 2 to 13 μM. As these enzymes seem to be involved in regulation of phagosome pH during Legionella infection, inhibition of these targets may lead to antibacterial agents with a novel mechanism of action.     

Comparative proteome profiling of host–pathogen interactions: insights into the adaptation mechanisms of Francisella tularensis in the host cell environment

The intracellular pathogens have the unique capacity to sense the host cell environment and to respond to it by alteration in gene expression and protein synthesis. Proteomic analysis of bacteria exposed directly to the host cell milieu might thus greatly contribute to the elucidation of processes leading to bacterial adaptation and proliferation inside the host cell. Here we have performed a global proteome analysis of a virulent Francisella tularensis subsp. holarctica strain during its intracellular cycle within the macrophage-like murine cell line J774.2 using the metabolic pulse-labeling of bacterial proteins with ³⁵S-methionine and ³⁵S-cysteine in various periods of infection. The two-dimensional gel analysis revealed macrophage-induced bacterial proteome changes in which 64 identified proteins were differentially expressed in comparison to controls grown in tissue culture medium. Nevertheless, activation of macrophages with interferon gamma before in vitro infection decreased the number of detected alterations in protein levels. Thus, these proteomic data indicate the F. tularensis ability to adapt to the intracellular hostile environment that is, however, diminished by prior interferon gamma treatment of host cells.     

For the insect pathogen Photorhabdus luminescens,which end of a nematode is out?

The nematode Heterorhabditis bacteriophora is the vector for transmitting the entomopathogenic bacterium Photorhabdus luminescens between insect larvae. The dauer juvenile (DJ) stage nematode selectively retains P. luminescens in its intestine until it releases the bacteria into the hemocoel of an insect host. We report the results of studying the transmission of the bacteria by its nematode vector. Cells of P. luminescens labeled with green fluorescent protein preferentially colonized a region of the DJ intestine immediately behind the basal bulb, extending for various distances toward the anus. Incubation of DJ nematodes in vitro in insect hemolymph induced regurgitation of the bacteria. Following a 30-min lag, the bacteria migrated in a gradual and staggered movement toward and ultimately exited the mouth. This regurgitation reaction was induced by a low-molecular-weight, heat- and protease-stable, anionic component present in arthropod hemolymph and in supernatants from insect cell cultures. Nematodes anesthetized with levamisole or treated with the antihelmenthic agent ivermectin did not release their bacteria into hemolymph. The ability to visualize P. luminescens in the DJ nematode intestine provides the first clues to the mechanism of release of the bacteria during infection of insect larvae. This and the partial characterization of a component of hemolymph triggering release of the bacteria render this fascinating example of both a mutualistic symbiosis and disease transmission amenable to future genetic and molecular study.