Cell lineage analysis in ascidian embryos by intracellular injection of a tracer enzyme. III. Up to the tissue restricted stage

Cell lineages during embryogenesis of the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi were analyzed up until the stage where each blastomere was fated to be only a single tissue type (i.e., the tissue restricted stage) by intracellular injection of horseradish peroxidase using the iontophoretic injection method. Initially, the developmental fates of all blastomeres of the 64-cell stage embryo were examined, and thereafter, only the fates of daughter blastomeres of those blastomeres that were not tissue restricted at the 64-cell stage were traced. The developmental fates of blastomeres were highly invariant except for two candidates for "equivalence groups" (J. Kimble, J. Sulston, and J. White (1979). In "Cell Lineage, Stem Cells and Cell Determination," pp. 59-68. Elsevier, Amsterdam/New York), in which cellular interaction is suggested to be involved in the specification of the fates. The right and left a8.25 cells gave rise to the otolith and ocellus, and the right and left b8.17 cells gave rise to the spinal cord and endodermal strand in a complementary manner. No fixed relationship existed between the position of the blastomere and its derivative. Most restrictions of cell fates occurred early in cleavage. The numbers of blastomeres which generated a single type of tissue were 44 at the 64-cell stage and 94 at the 110-cell stage. Eight pairs of blastomeres had not yet become tissue restricted by the 110-cell stage. Almost complete lineages of epidermis, nervous system, muscle, mesenchyme, notochord, and endodermal tissues were described, and a fate map was constructed for the blastula. For certain tissues, the primordial cells occupied two different regions. Supplementary investigations of the lineage of muscle cells were also performed on embryos of another species, Ciona intestinalis.     

Evolution and development of brain sensory organs in molgulid ascidians

The ascidian tadpole larva has two brain sensory organs containing melanocytes: the otolith, a gravity receptor, and the ocellus, part of a photoreceptor. One or both of these sensory organs are absent in molgulid ascidians. We show here that developmental changes leading to the loss of sensory pigment cells occur by different mechanisms in closely related molgulid species. Sensory pigment cells are formed through a bilateral determination pathway in which two or more precursor cells are specified as an equivalence group on each side of the embryo. The precursor cells subsequently converge at the midline after neurulation and undergo cell interactions that decide the fates of the otolith and ocellus. Molgula occidentalis and M. oculata, which exhibit a tadpole larva with an otolith but lacking an ocellus, have conserved the bilateral pigment cell determination pathway. Programmed cell death (PCD) is superimposed on this pathway late in development to eliminate the ocellus precursor and supernumerary pigment cells, which do not differentiate into either an otolith or ocellus. In contrast to molgulids with tadpole larvae, no pigment cell precursors are specified on either side of the M. occulta embryo, which forms a tailless (anural) larva lacking both sensory organs, suggesting that the bilateral pigment cell determination pathway has been lost. The bilateral pigment cell determination pathway and superimposed PCD can be restored in hybrids obtained by fertilizing M. occulta eggs with M. oculata sperm, indicating control by a zygotic process. We conclude that PCD plays an important role in the evolution and development of brain sensory organs in molgulid ascidians.     

The BMP/CHORDIN antagonism controls sensory pigment cell specification and differentiation in the ascidian embryo

We have investigated the role of the bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) pathway during neural tissue formation in the ascidian embryo. The orthologue of the BMP antagonist, chordin, was isolated from the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi. While both the expression pattern and the phenotype observed by overexpressing chordin or BMPb (the dpp-subclass BMP) do not suggest a role for these factors in neural induction, BMP/CHORDIN antagonism was found to affect neural patterning. Overexpression of BMPb induced ectopic sensory pigment cells in the brain lineages that do not normally form pigment cells and suppressed pressure organ formation within the brain. Reciprocally, overexpressing chordin suppressed pigment cell formation and induced ectopic pressure organ. We show that pigment cell formation occurs in three steps. (1) During cleavage stages ectodermal cells are neuralized by a vegetal signal that can be substituted by bFGF. (2) At the early gastrula stage, BMPb secreted from the lateral nerve cord blastomeres induces those neuralized blastomeres in close proximity to adopt a pigment cell fate. (3) At the tailbud stage, among these pigment cell precursors, BMPb induces the differentiation of specifically the anterior type of pigment cell, the otolith; while posteriorly, CHORDIN suppresses BMP activity and allows ocellus differentiation.     

Role of cell interactions in ascidian muscle and pigment cell specification

Summary Muscle and brain pigment cell specification was studied by disrupting cell adhesion, cell dissociation, and reaggregation in embryos of the ascidianStyela clava. Treatment of embryos with Ca²⁺-free sea water between the 2-cell and gastrula stages disrupted blastomere adhesion but did not prevent acetylcholinesterase or muscle actin expression in presumptive muscle cells. Similar treatments initiated between the 2- and 32-cell stages caused more ectoderm cells to express tyrosinase and develop pigment granules than expected from the cell lineage. Whereas 2 pigment cells become the otolith and ocellus sensory organs in normal embryos, up to 33 pigment cells could differentiate in embryos after disruption of cell adhesion. Replacement of Ca²⁺-free sea water with normal sea water restored cell adhesion and usually resulted in development of embryos containing the conventional number of pigment cells. Dissociation of embryos into single cells between the 2- and 64-cell stages and culture of these cells beyond the fate restricted stage had no effect on the accumulation of muscle actin mRNA and muscle actin synthesis, but blocked pigment cell differentiation. Reaggregation of the dissociated cells did not enhance the number of cells that developed muscle features, but rescued pigment cell development. The results indicate that ascidian muscle cell specification occurs by an autonomous mechanism, whereas pigment cell specification occurs by a conditional mechanism involving cell interactions. In addition, the results suggest that negative cell interactions may restrict the potential for pigment cell development in the ectoderm of cleaving ascidian embryos.     

Role of cell adhesion in the specification of pigment cell lineage in embryos of the sea urchin, Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus

To clarify the role of cell adhesion in the specification of pigment cell lineage in sea urchin embryos, cell contacts were inhibited by Ca²⁺-free artificial seawater (ASW) treatment, and the number of differentiated pigment cells was examined by the method devised for the present study. Obtained results showed that inhibition of cell contacts during mid-to-late blastula stage greatly affects the number of pigment cells. Treatment with Ca²⁺-free ASW during 7.5–10.5h of development drastically decreased the number of pigment cells, indicating that cell adhesion during this period is indispensable for the specification of pigment cell lineage. On the other hand, the number of pigment cells were increased by the treatment during 9.5–12.5 h of development. It was suggested that this increase was caused by excess divisions of the precursor cells, that is, the division schedule of the precursor cells was altered by inhibition of cell contacts at this period. Interestingly, the number of pigment cells was a multiple of four in a majority of embryos in which pigment cells were drastically decreased in number. These findings suggest that the founder blastomeres of the pigment cell lineage are specified during 7–10 h of development, and that these blastomeres divide twice before they differentiate into pigment cells.     

Development of Pigment Cells in the Brain of Ascidian Tadpole Larvae: Insights into the Origins of Vertebrate Pigment Cells

In vertebrates, melanins produced in specialized pigment cells are required for visual acuity, camouflage, sexual display and protection from ultra violet (UV) radiation. There are three pigment cell types that are classified based on their distinct embryonic origins. Retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) cells originate from the outer layer of the optic cup. Pigment cells of the pineal organ are formed from the developing diencephalon. Melanocytes are derived from the neural crest unique to vertebrate embryos. Some of these pigment cells also play roles that are independent of the activity of tyrosinase, the key melanogenesis enzyme, or melanin: production of substrate(s) for catecholamine synthesis, maintenance of endolymph composition in the cochlea, maintenance of photoreceptor cells in the retina and retinoid metabolism essential for the visual cycle. To deduce the evolutionary origins of vertebrate pigment cells and a possible archetypal genetic circuitry, which may have been modified and utilized to generate multiple pigment cell types, comparison of developmental mechanisms of pigment cells between vertebrates and closely related invertebrate ascidians are proposed to provide useful information. The tadpole‐type larva of ascidians possesses two melanin‐containing pigment cells, termed the otolith and ocellus pigment cells, in the brain that are believed to be required for photo‐ and geotactic responses during swimming. In this review, current knowledge on the development of the two ascidian pigment cells is summarized, i.e. complete cell lineage, structure and expression of genes encoding two melanogenesis enzymes, and molecular developmental mechanisms involving BMP‐CHORDIN antagonism, and possible evolutionary relationships between ascidian and vertebrate pigment cells are discussed.     

Autonomy of acetylcholinesterase differentiation in muscle lineage cells of ascidian embryos

The two muscle lineage blastomeres were removed surgically from Ciona intestinalis embryos at the eight-cell stage and allowed to develop in isolation. Acetylcholinesterase, an enzyme that occurs only in muscle cells of the developing larva, was detected histochemically in progeny cells of these isolated blastomers. Acetylcholinesterase differentiation in muscle lineage cells is not, therefore, dependent on inductive interactions with embryonic tissues derived from other eight-cell stage blastomeres.     

Development of pigment cells in the brain of ascidian tadpole larvae: insights into the origins of vertebrate pigment cells.

In vertebrates, melanins produced in specialized pigment cells are required for visual acuity, camouflage, sexual display and protection from ultra violet (UV) radiation. There are three pigment cell types that are classified based on their distinct embryonic origins. Retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) cells originate from the outer layer of the optic cup. Pigment cells of the pineal organ are formed from the developing diencephalon. Melanocytes are derived from the neural crest unique to vertebrate embryos. Some of these pigment cells also play roles that are independent of the activity of tyrosinase, the key melanogenesis enzyme, or melanin: production of substrate(s) for catecholamine synthesis, maintenance of endolymph composition in the cochlea, maintenance of photoreceptor cells in the retina and retinoid metabolism essential for the visual cycle. To deduce the evolutionary origins of vertebrate pigment cells and a possible archetypal genetic circuitry, which may have been modified and utilized to generate multiple pigment cell types, comparison of developmental mechanisms of pigment cells between vertebrates and closely related invertebrate ascidians are proposed to provide useful information. The tadpole-type larva of ascidians possesses two melanin-containing pigment cells, termed the otolith and ocellus pigment cells, in the brain that are believed to be required for photo- and geotactic responses during swimming. In this review, current knowledge on the development of the two ascidian pigment cells is summarized, i.e. complete cell lineage, structure and expression of genes encoding two melanogenesis enzymes, and molecular developmental mechanisms involving BMP-CHORDIN antagonism, and possible evolutionary relationships between ascidian and vertebrate pigment cells are discussed.     

Cell lineage and determination of cell fate in ascidian embryos

A detailed cell lineage of ascidian embryos has been available since the turn of the century. This cell lineage was deduced from the segregation of pigmented egg cytoplasmic regions into particular blastomeres during embryogenesis. The invariant nature of the cell lineage, the segregation of specific egg cytoplasmic regions into particular blastomeres, and the autonomous development of most embryonic cells suggests that cell fate is determined primarily by cytoplasmic determinants. Modern studies have provided strong evidence for the existence of cytoplasmic determinants, especially in the primary muscle cells, yet the molecular identity, localization, and mode of action of these factors are still a mystery. Recent revisions of the classic cell lineage and demonstrations of the lack of developmental autonomy in certain embryonic cells suggest that induction may also be an important mechanism for the determination of cell fate in ascidians. There is strong evidence for the induction of neural tissue and indirect evidence for inductive interactions in the development of the secondary muscle cells. In contrast to the long-accepted dogma, specification of cell fate in ascidians appears to be established by a combination of cytoplasmic determinants and inductive cell interactions.     

The ascidian homolog of the vertebrate homeobox gene Rx is essential for ocellus development and function

The tadpole larvae prosencephalon of the ascidian Ciona intestinalis contains a single large ventricle, along the inner walls of which lie two sensory organs: the otolith (a gravity-sensing organ) and the ocellus (a photo-sensing organ composed of a single cup-shaped pigment cell, about 20 photoreceptor cells, and three lens cells). Comparison has been drawn between the morphology and physiology of photoreceptor cells in the ascidian ocellus and the vertebrate eye. The development of vertebrate and invertebrate eyes requires the activity of several conserved genes and it is regulated by precise expression patterns and cell fate decisions common to several species. We have isolated a Ciona homeobox gene (Ci-Rx) that belongs to the paired-like class of homeobox genes. Rx genes have been identified from a variety of organisms and have been demonstrated to have a role in vertebrate eye formation. Ci-Rx is expressed in the anterior neural plate in the middle tailbud stage and subsequently in the larval stage in the sensory vesicle around the ocellus. Loss of Ci-Rx function leads to an ocellus-less phenotype that shows a loss of photosensitive swimming behavior, suggesting the important role played by Ci-Rx in basal chordate photoreceptor cell differentiation and ocellus formation. Furthermore, studies on Ci-Rx regulatory elements electroporated into Ciona embryos using LacZ or GFP as reporter genes indicate the presence of Ci-Rx in pigment cells, photoreceptors, and neurons surrounding the sensory vesicle. In Ci-Rx knocked-down larvae, neither basal swimming activity nor shadow responses develop. Thus, Rx has a role not only in pigment cells and photoreceptor formation but also in the correct development of the neuronal circuit that controls larval photosensitivity and swimming behavior. The results suggest that a Ci-Rx "retinal" territory exists, which consists of pigment cells, photoreceptors, and neurons involved in transducing the photoreceptor signals.     

Specific cellular localization of tyrosinase mRNA during Ciona intestinalis larval development

A Ciona intestinalis cDNA clone that encodes a protein highly homologous to other tyrosinases was isolated. Northern blot analysis showed that expression of Ciona tyrosinase starts at the early neurula stage and continues throughout the tail-bud and tadpole larval stages. The earliest tyrosinase expression was detected, by in situ hybridization, at the neural plate stage, in pigment precursor cells located along the two neural folds, in the animal region of the embryo. In the course of embryonic development the strong hybridization signal was always localized, within the rostral part of the developing brain, in the pigment precursor cells and was later detected in the otolith and ocellus. These results are discussed in relation to tyrosinase as an early marker of neural induction.     

Role of cell contact in the specification process of pigment founder cells in the sea urchin embryo

Effects of LiCl on the specification process of pigment founder cells were examined in the sea urchin Hemicentrotus pulcherrimus. If embryos were treated with 30 mM LiCl during 4-7 or 7-10 hours postfertilization, pigment cells increased significantly. Aphidicolin treatment indicated that this increase was due to the increase in the pigment founder cells. Interestingly, if the embryos were treated sequentially with LiCl and Ca2+-free seawater during 4-7 and 7-10 hr, respectively, they differentiated only about the same number of pigment cells as control embryos. Further, the increase was scarcely discerned when the embryos were treated with LiCl in the absence of Ca2+ during 7-10 hr. These results suggested that effect of LiCl would be ascribed to the increase in cell adhesiveness. In fact, LiCl-treated embryos were more difficult to be dissociated into single cells. Cell electrophoresis showed that the amount of the negative cell surface charges decreased considerably in LiCl-treated embryos. It was also found that the number of pigment cells seldom exceeded 100, even if embryos were exposed to a higher concentration of LiCl. This suggested that only a subpopulation of the descendants of veg2 blastomeres received the inductive signal emanated from the micromere progeny.     

Inductive interactions and embryonic equivalence groups in a basal metazoan, the ctenophore Mnemiopsis leidyi

Ctenophores undergo locomotion via the metachronal beating of eight longitudinally arrayed rows of comb plate cilia. These cilia are normally derived from two embryonic lineages, which include both daughters of the four e1 micromeres (e11 and e12) and a single daughter of the four m1 micromeres (the m12 micromeres). Although the e1 lineage is established autonomously, the m1 lineage requires an inductive interaction from the e1 lineage to contribute to comb plate formation. Successive removal of the e1 progeny at later stages of development indicates that this interaction takes place after the 32-cell stage and likely proceeds over a prolonged period of development. Normally, the e1, cell lies in closest proximity to the m12 cell that generates comb plate cilia; however, either of the e1 daughters (e11 or e12) is capable of emitting the signal required for m1 descendants to form comb plates. Previous cell lineage analyses indicate that the two e1 daughters generate the same suite of cell fates. On the other hand, the m1 daughters (m11 and m12) normally give rise to different cell fates. Reciprocal m1 daughter deletions show that in the absence of one daughter, the other cell can generate all the cell types normally formed by the missing cell. Together, these findings demonstrate that the two m1 daughters (m11 and m12) represent an embryonic equivalence group or field and that differences in the fates of the two m1 daughters are normally controlled by cell-cell interactions. These combined properties of ctenophore development, including the utilization of deterministic cleavage divisions, inductive interactions, and the establishment of embryonic fields or equivalence groups, are remarkably similar to those present in the development of various bilaterian metazoans.     

Binary specification of nerve cord and notochord cell fates in ascidian embryos

In the ascidian embryo, the nerve cord and notochord of the tail of tadpole larvae originate from the precursor blastomeres for both tissues in the 32-cell-stage embryo. Each fate is separated into two daughter blastomeres at the next cleavage. We have examined mechanisms that are responsible for nerve cord and notochord specification through experiments involving blastomere isolation, cell dissociation, and treatment with basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) and inhibitors for the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) cascade. It has been shown that inductive cell interaction at the 32-cell stage is required for notochord formation. Our results show that the nerve cord fate is determined autonomously without any cell interaction. Presumptive notochord blastomeres also assume a nerve cord fate when they are isolated before induction is completed. By contrast, not only presumptive notochord blastomeres but also presumptive nerve cord blastomeres forsake their default nerve cord fate and choose the notochord fate when they are treated with bFGF. When the FGF-Ras-MAPK signaling cascade is inhibited, both blastomeres choose the default nerve cord pathway, supporting the results of blastomere isolation. Thus, binary choice of alternative fates and asymmetric division are involved in this nerve cord/notochord fate determination system, mediated by FGF signaling.     

Quantitative control of end products in the melanocyte lineage of the ascidian embryo.

Terminal amounts of tyrosinase (EC 1.10.3.1) activity and melanin pigment in the giant melanocytes of cleavage-arrestedCiona intestinalis (L.) embryos are regulated independently of cell size and number of nuclei in the cells. Embryos were cleavage-arrested in cytochalasin B at a time before the last two divisions of the melanocyte lineage took place. The resulting two giant melanocytes, one from each of the two bilateral melanocyte lineages, developed tyrosinase and melanin. The cells were about three times larger in volume than the normal larval melanocytes and each contained four nuclei instead of just one. Quantitative measurements of melanin synthesized and tyrosinase activity in embryos with the giant melanocytes revealed amounts identical to those found in normal embryos. This specification of exact quantities differs markedly from the situation in mammalian melanocytes where cell volume and gene dosage influence the extent of melanotic differentiation. Quantitative control of differentiation in ascidian melanocytes appears to be mediated by a cytoplasmic determinant segregated through the melanocyte lineage and inherited by one daughter at each division of the lineages.