The Nostoc-Gunnera symbiosis: carbon fixation and translocation

The in vitro specific activity of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase (Rubisco; EC 4. 1. 1. 39) and the dark and light in vivo CO₂ fixation activities were determined in the cyanobiont of Gunnera . Compared to the free-living isolate Nostoc PCC 9231, the in vitro Rubisco activity was high, while the in vivo CO₂ fixation was very low. Light did not significantly influence CO₂ fixation if the cyanobiont was left in the sliced Gunnera tissues, while a small light stimulation was found for CO₂ fixation of the freshly-isolated cyanobiont. The adjacent non-infected Gunnera tissue showed a very low CO₂ fixation. A rapid translocation of fixed ¹⁴CO₂ from leaves towards apical parts of the plant was apparent, in particular to the symbiotic tissue. The ¹⁴C label appeared mainly in soluble form in this tissue and was rapidly catabolised as shown by ¹⁴C chase experiments. Also, short-term experiments revealed that maximum ¹⁴C accumulation occurred in the symbiotic tissue showing the highest rates of nitrogen fixation (Söderbäck et al. 1990), about 10–15 mm from the plant apex. The data were taken to indicate that there is a modification in the photosynthetic light reaction of the cyanobiont and that the cyanobiont lives heterotrophically in the dark on photo-synthate rapidly delivered from nearby leaves of the host plant.     

Genetic diversity of Nostoc microsymbionts from Gunnera tinctoria revealed by PCR-STRR fingerprinting

The cyanobacteria belonging to the genus Nostoc fix atmospheric nitrogen, both as free-living organisms and in symbiotic associations with a wide range of hosts, including bryophytes, gymnosperms (cycads), the small water fern Azolla (Pteridophyte), the angiosperm genus Gunnera, and fungi (lichens). The Gunnera–Nostoc symbiosis is the only one that involves a flowering plant. In Chile, 12 species of Gunnera have been described with a broad distribution in the temperate region. We examined the genetic diversity of Nostoc symbionts from three populations of Gunnera tinctoria from Abtao, Chiloé Island, southern Chile, and microsymbionts from other two species of Gunnera from southern Chile, using PCR amplification of STRR (short tandemly repeated repetitive) sequences of the Nostoc infected tissue. To our knowledge, this is the first report of PCR fingerprinting obtained directly from symbiotic tissue of Gunnera. Genetic analyses revealed that Nostoc symbionts exhibit important genetic diversity among host plants, both within and between Gunnera populations. It was also found that only one Nostoc strain, or closely related strains, established symbiosis with an individual plant host.     

Azolla and other plant-cyanobacteria symbioses: Aspects of form and function

Nostoc, a genus of filamentous, heterocystous, cyanobacteria, is widely distributed in the free-living state. It is also the most common phycobiont in N₂-fixing lichens and occurs as the N₂-fixing symbiont in a small and diverse group of green plants. These include several bryophyte genera (e.g. Anthoceros and Blasia), a pteridophyte genus (Azolla; while the symbiont is referred to asAnabaena azollae, it may be aNostoc spp.), a division of gymnosperms (the 10 cycad genera) and one angiosperm genus (Gunnera). In Gunnera the Nostoc apparently penetrates into the cells of the host. In the other associations Nostoc is extracellular but specific morphological modifications and/or structures of the host plant organs create an environment which fosters interaction and metabolite interchange.The individual group of Nostoc-green plant symbioses other than Azolla are summarized in regard to the current understanding of their establishment, perpetuation, and host-symbiont interaction. This includes available information on recognition and specificity, mode(s) of infection if applicable, and a synopsis of morphological modifications of the partners. The symbiosis withAzolla is then addressed separately with a more indepth account of the foregoing areas. In addition, the concept ofAzolla harboring a dominant, obiligately symbiotic Nostoc which has not been cultured as well as minor symbionts capable of free-living growth, the distinction between re-constituting and simply re-establishing the symbiosis, and current approaches to improving the symbiosis and to authenticating the establishment of new associations are considered.     

Sub-Cellular Element Analysis of a Cyanobacterium (Nostoc sp.) in Symbiosis with Gunnera manicata by ESI and EELS

Element analysis using electron spectroscopic imaging (ESI) and electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) was performed in a symbiotic Nostoc sp. strain found in the upper stem tissue of Gunnera manicata, and in Nostoc PCC 9229, a free-living heterocyst-forming cyanobacterium able to enter into symbiosis with the angiosperm Gunnera in reconstitution experiments. ESI and EELS unequivocally identified the four elements nitrogen (N), sulphur (S), phosphorus (P) and oxygen (O) in different inclusion bodies of these biological specimens. High amounts of nitrogen were solely detected in huge cyanophycin granules in vegetative cells of the symbiotic Nostoc strain, whereas large polyphosphate bodies, containing high amounts of phosphorus, sulphur and oxygen, could be seen in the free-living Nostoc PCC 9229. The latter were usually not present or, when found, very small in vegetative cells of the cyanobiont.     

Protein expression profiles in an endosymbiotic cyanobacterium revealed by a proteomic approach

Molecular mechanisms behind adaptations in the cyanobacterium (Nostoc sp.) to a life in endosymbiosis with plants are still not clarified, nor are the interactions between the partners. To get further insights, the proteome of a Nostoc strain, freshly isolated from the symbiotic gland tissue of the angiosperm Gunnera manicata Linden, was analyzed and compared with the proteome of the same strain when free-living. Extracted proteins were separated by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and were identified by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry combined with tandem mass spectrometry. Even when the higher percentage of differentiated cells (heterocysts) in symbiosis was compensated for, the majority of the proteins detected in the symbiotic cyanobacteria were present in the free-living counterpart, indicating that most cellular processes were common for both stages. However, differential expression profiling revealed a significant number of proteins to be down-regulated or missing in the symbiotic stage, while others were more abundant or only expressed in symbiosis. The differential protein expression was primarily connected to i) cell envelope-associated processes, including proteins involved in exopolysaccharide synthesis and surface and membrane associated proteins, ii) to changes in growth and metabolic activities (C and N), including upregulation of nitrogenase and proteins involved in the oxidative pentose phosphate pathway and downregulation of Calvin cycle enzymes, and iii) to the dark, microaerobic conditions offered inside the Gunnera gland cells, including changes in relative phycobiliprotein concentrations. This is the first comprehensive analysis of proteins in the symbiotic state.     

Genetic diversity among and within cultured cyanobionts of diverse species of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Azolla</Emphasis>

The cyanobionts isolated from 10 Azolla accessions belonging to 6 species (Azolla mexicana, A. microphylla, A. rubra, A. caroliniana, A. filiculoides, A. pinnata) were cultured under laboratory conditions and analyzed on the basis of whole cell protein profiles and molecular marker dataset generated using repeat sequence primers (STRR(mod) and HipTG). The biochemical and molecular marker profiles of the cyanobionts were compared with those of the free-living cyanobacteria and symbiotic Nostoc strains from Anthoceros sp., Cycas sp. and Gunnera monoika. Cluster analysis revealed the genetic diversity among the selected strains, and identified 3 distinct clusters. Group 1 included cyanobionts from all the 10 accessions of Azolla, group 2 comprised all the symbiotic Nostoc strains, while group 3 included the free-living cyanobacteria belonging to the genera Nostoc and Anabaena. The interrelationships among the Azolla cyanobionts were further revealed by principal component analysis. Cyanobionts from A. caroliniana-A. microphylla grouped together while cyanobionts associated with A. mexicana-A. filiculoides along with A. pinnata formed another group. A. rubra cyanobionts had intermediate relationship with both the subgroups. This is the first study analyzing the diversity existing among the cultured cyanobionts of diverse Azolla species through the use of biochemical and molecular profiles and also the genetic distinctness of these free-living cyanobionts as compared to cyanobacterial strains of the genera Anabaena and Nostoc.     

Fasciclin domain proteins are present in nostoc symbionts of lichens

Differences in the soluble protein fraction between the freshly isolated cyanobiont of lichen Peltigera membranacea, the corresponding free-living strain, and Nostoc punctiforme were analyzed. One protein, which was among the most prominent proteins of the freshly isolated cyanobiont, was expressed at a lower level in the corresponding free-living strain and was not detected at all on the two-dimensional gels of N. punctiforme. This protein was partially sequenced, and the corresponding open reading frame (ORF) in the N. punctiforme genome was identified. This ORF contains a fasciclin domain typical of a class of surface-associated proteins involved in cell adhesion. Similar fasciclin motif-containing genes have previously been shown to be symbiotically induced in other symbiotic systems.     

Arabinogalactan proteins occur in the free-living cyanobacterium genus Nostoc and in plant-Nostoc symbioses

Arabinogalactan proteins (AGP) are a diverse family of proteoglycans associated with the cell surfaces of plants. AGP have been implicated in a wide variety of plant cell processes, including signaling in symbioses. This study investigates the existence of putative AGP in free-living cyanobacterial cultures of the nitrogen-fixing, filamentous cyanobacteria Nostoc punctiforme and Nostoc sp. strain LBG1 and at the symbiotic interface in the symbioses between Nostoc spp. and two host plants, the angiosperm Gunnera manicata (in which the cyanobacterium is intracellular) and the liverwort Blasia pusilla (in which the cyanobacterium is extracellular). Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, immunoblotting, and immunofluorescence analyses demonstrated that three AGP glycan epitopes (recognized by monoclonal antibodies LM14, MAC207, and LM2) are present in free-living Nostoc cyanobacterial species. The same three AGP glycan epitopes are present at the Gunnera-Nostoc symbiotic interface and the LM2 epitope is detected during the establishment of the Blasia-Nostoc symbiosis. Bioinformatic analysis of the N. punctiforme genome identified five putative AGP core proteins that are representative of AGP classes found in plants. These results suggest a possible involvement of AGP in cyanobacterial-plant symbioses and are also suggestive of a cyanobacterial origin of AGP.     

Comparison of photosynthesis and productivity of Gunnera tinctoria Molina (Mirbel) with and without the phycobiont Nostoc punctiforme L.

Abstract. Marked increases in growth and nitrogen content were found with Gunnera tinctoria Molina (Mirbel) plants infected (+ Nostoc ) with the cyanobacterium Nostoc punctiforme L., in comparison to uninfected (— Nostoc ) plants and this was attributed to N₂-fixation by the phycobiont. Whilst host and symbiont can be grown separately, preliminary data indicates that the host plant is reliant on the cyanobacterium to meet its nitrogen requirements because it has little capacity to assimilate nitrate. Although the maximum light-saturated rate of photosynthesis was higher in the + Nostoc plants, there was no reduction in photosynthetic efficiency under lightlimiting conditions, despite marked differences in plant nitrogen status. Differences in photosynthetic rate were implicated as the major reason for the differences in plant productivity. Stomatal conductance was insensitive to changes in plant nitrogen status and did not parallel the variation in photosynthetic rates. The ecological significance of the largely invariant stomatal response and the consequences of differences in water and nitrogen-use efficiencies between + and — Nostoc plants is discussed.     

Evidence for production of the phytohormone indole-3-acetic acid by cyanobacteria

The ability of cyanobacteria to produce the phytohormone indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) was demonstrated. A colorimetric (Salkowski) screening of 34 free-living and symbiotically competent cyanobacteria, that represent all morphotypes from the unicellular to the highly differentiated, showed that auxin-like compounds were released by about 38% of the free-living as compared to 83% of the symbiotic isolates. The endogenous accumulation and release of IAA were confirmed immunologically (ELISA) using an anti-IAA antibody on 10 of the Salkowski-positive strains, and the chemical authenticity of IAA was further verified by chemical characterization using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry in Nostoc PCC 9229 (isolated from the angiosperm Gunnera) and in Nostoc 268 (free-living). Addition of the putative IAA precursor tryptophan enhanced IAA accumulation in cell extracts and supernatants. As the genome of the symbiotically competent Nostoc PCC 73102 contains homologues of key enzymes of the indole-3-pyruvic acid pathway, a transaminase and indolepyruvate decarboxylase (IpdC), the putative ipdC gene from this cyanobacterium was cloned and used in Southern blot analysis. Out of 11 cyanobacterial strains responding positively in the Salkowski/ELISA test, ipdC homologues were found in 4. A constitutive and possibly tryptophan-dependent production of IAA via the indole-3-pyruvic acid pathway is therefore suggested. The possible role of IAA in cyanobacteria in general and in their interactions with plants is discussed.     

Nitrogen deprivation stimulates symbiotic gland development in Gunnera manicata

Gunnera is the only genus of angiosperms known to host cyanobacteria and the only group of land plants that hosts cyanobacteria intracellularly. Motile filaments of cyanobacteria, known as hormogonia, colonize Gunnera plants through cells in the plant's specialized stem glands. It is commonly held that Gunnera plants always possess functional glands for symbiosis. We found, however, that stem gland development did not occur when Gunnera manicata plants were grown on nitrogen (N)-replete medium but, rather, was initiated at predetermined positions when plants were deprived of combined N. While N status was the main determinant for gland development, an exogenous carbon source (sucrose) accelerated the process. Furthermore, a high level of sucrose stimulated the formation of callus-like tissue in place of the gland under N-replete conditions. Treatment of plants with the auxin transport inhibitor 1-naphthylphthalamic acid prevented gland development on N-limited medium, most likely by preventing resource reallocation from leaves to the stem. Optimized conditions were found for in vitro establishment of the Nostoc-Gunnera symbiosis by inoculating mature glands with hormogonia from Nostoc punctiforme, a cyanobacterium strain for which the full genome sequence is available. In contrast to uninoculated plants, G. manicata plants colonized by N. punctiforme were able to continue their growth on N-limited medium. Understanding the nature of the Gunnera plant's unusual adaptation to an N-limited environment may shed light on the evolution of plant-cyanobacterium symbioses and may suggest a route to establish productive associations between N-fixing cyanobacteria and crop plants.     

Phenotypic and Genotypic Comparison of Symbiotic and Free-Living Cyanobacteria from a Single Field Site

PCR amplification techniques were used to compare cyanobacterial symbionts from a cyanobacterium-bryophyte symbiosis and free-living cyanobacteria from the same field site. Thirty-one symbiotic cyanobacteria were isolated from the hornwort Phaeoceros sp. at several closely spaced locations, and 40 free-living cyanobacteria were isolated from the immediate vicinity of the same plants. One of the symbiotic isolates was a species of Calothrix, a genus not previously known to form bryophyte symbioses, and the remainder were Nostoc spp. Of the free-living strains, two were Calothrix spp., three were Chlorogloeopsis spp. and the rest were Nostoc spp. All of the symbiotic and all but one of the free-living strains were able to reconstitute the symbiosis with axenic cultures of both Phaeoceros and the liverwort Blasia sp. Axenic cyanobacterial strains were compared by DNA amplification using PCR with either short arbitrary primers or primers specific for the regions flanking the 16S-23S rRNA internal transcribed spacer. With one exception, the two techniques produced complementary results and confirmed for the first time that a diversity of symbiotic cyanobacteria infect Phaeoceros in the field. Symbionts from adjacent colonies were different as often as they were the same, showing that the same thallus could be infected with many different cyanobacterial strains. Strains found to be identical by the techniques employed here were often found as symbionts in different thalli at the same locale but were never found free-living. Only one of the free-living strains, and none of the symbiotic strains, was found at more than one sample site, implying a highly localized distribution of strains.     

Pigment distribution and nitrogen fixation inAnabaena azollae

Summary The symbiotic heterocystous cyanobacteriumAnabaena azollae present in the leaf cavities of the water fernAzolla spp. was studied. The cyanobacteria extracted from the leaf cavities showed differences in pigment composition in three species ofAzolla, i.e A.pinnata var.pinnata, A.caroliniana and A.filiculoides, as observed by pigment absorption and epifluorescence tests. These differences suggest that of these species the cyanobiont ofA. pinnata is the most actively nitrogenfixing form. This has been confirmed by nitrogen fixation (acetylene reduction) tests. Heterocysts of the symbiont ofA. pinnata were characterized by high chlorophylla and low phycocyanin content, a low fluorescence yield of chlorophyll in the heterocysts compared to vegetative cells and a gradient of phycocyanin concentration in the vegetative cells adjacent to heterocysts. This indicates that only photosystem I is present in the heterocyst. In the two otherAzolla species quantitative shifts in the pigment composition occurred suggesting a lower nitrogen fixation activity.In the cyanobiontAnabaena azollae the heterocyst frequency could reach a value of 44–45%. It is argued that there are two generations of heterocysts in a matureAzolla plant, which are concomitant with two peaks of nitrogen fixation activity correlated with leaf age,i.e. leaf number along the main axis of the plant. At both peaks of maximal N₂-ase activity, only 20–25% of the heterocysts present are metabolically active as demonstrated by the reduction of Neotetrazolium chloride (NTC) in the heterocysts and darkening of nuclear emulsions by silver salt reduction. Vegetative cells of the cyanobiont reduce Neotetrazolium chloride (NTC) to formazan more rapidly than has been observed in the free-living heterocystous cyanobacteriumAnabaena cylindrica tested in parallel experiments. This feature may be due to a more permeable cell wall of the vegetative cells of the cyanobiont compared to the free-living form, since the vegetative cells of the symbiont play a role in cross-feeding of the host (Azolla).Evidence is obtained that only the heterocysts of the cyanobiont ofAzolla are involved in the nitrogen fixation process as in free-living heterocystous cyanobacterium species. This situation is different from other cyanobacterial symbioses such as inGunnera, Blasia andAnthoceros, where physiological modifications are reported in the symbiosis with another photosynthetic partner such as the absence of O₂ evolution and the absence of photo-fixation of CO₂ in the cyanobionts.Pigment composition and N₂-ase activity in the symbiotic cyanobacteria of three Azolla species have indicated the superiority of theA. pinnata symbiont.A. pinnata var.pinnata is a semidomesticated form used in S.E. Asia for agricultural purposes (irrigated rice culture) to increase soil fertility.It is suggested that by selection (domestication) more efficient strains (clones) can be obtained, and further that with more advanced techniques such as gene mutation and genetic manipulation even more efficient and for agriculture more beneficial clones can be obtained.     

Regulation of expression of glutamine synthetase in a symbiotic Nostoc strain associated with Anthoceros punctatus.

A characteristic of N2-fixing cyanobacteria in symbiotic associations appears to be release of N2-derived NH4+. The specific activity of the primary ammonium-assimilating enzyme, glutamine synthetase (GS), was found to be three- to fourfold lower in Nostoc sp. strain 7801 grown in symbiotic association with the bryophyte Anthoceros punctatus than in free-living Nostoc sp. strain 7801. Quantitative immunological assays with antisera against GS purified from Nostoc sp. strain 7801 and from Escherichia coli indicated that similar amounts of the GS protein were present in symbiotic (50 micrograms mg-1) and free-living (68 micrograms mg-1) cultures. The conclusion from these experiments is that GS is regulated by a posttranslational mechanism in Anthoceros-associated Nostoc sp. strain 7801. However, the results of comparative catalytic and immunological experiments between N2- and NH4+-grown free-living Nostoc sp. strain 7801 implied control of GS synthesis. A correlation was not observed between the level of GS expression and the extent of symbiotic heterocyst differentiation in Nostoc sp. strain 7801 associated with A. punctatus.     

结合态氮对满江红内生细菌群落组成和结构的影响

研究从超微结构和分子水平上探讨结合态氮对满江红(Azolla)叶腔中以共生藻占优势的微生物群落的影响。为排除外源污染并保留其内生菌的多样性, 采用茎尖组织培养并添加结合态氮等方法, 取得了表面无菌的含藻满江红(AmA)和无藻满江红(AmB)。电镜观察揭示, AmB较AmA的萍体表型有某种程度的修饰。AmA的微生物群落结构以共生藻、内生菌和宿主腺毛及其分泌物组成的生物被膜和藻囊为主要特征, 而AmB的叶腔几乎中空。基于16S rRNA基因和nifH基因的高通量测序结果显示, 生长于无氮培养液的AmA样品的微生物群落有相当高的多样性, 共有17个可操作分类单元(OTU), 分属4个细菌门, 并有一个以Nostoc azollae为优势的固氮微生物亚群包括草螺菌、根瘤菌和Niveispirillum等。而生长于富含结合态氮培养液的AmB样品的群落多样性明显降低, 仅有8个OTU, 且以Nostoc azollae为优势的上述固氮微生物亚群全部消失。研究结果表明, 通过调整氮素营养, 可改变宿主植物的微生物群落组成与结构, 进而改良植物的生长发育。     

Diverse roles of the GlcP glucose permease in free-living and symbiotic cyanobacteria

Certain cyanobacteria can form symbiotic associations with plants, where the symbiont supplies the plant partner with nitrogen and in return obtains sugars. We recently showed that in the symbiotic cyanobacterium Nostoc punctiforme, a glucose specific permease, GlcP, is necessary for the symbiosis to be formed. Results presented here from growth yield measurements of mutant strains with inactivated or overexpressing sugar transporters suggest that GlcP could be induced by a symbiosis specific substance. We also discuss that the transporter may have a role other than nutritional once the symbiosis is established, i.e., during infection, and more specifically in the chemotaxis of the symbiont. Phylogenetic analysis shows that the distribution of GlcP among cyanobacteria is likely influenced by horizontal gene transfer, but also that it is not correlated with symbiotic competence. Instead, regulatory patterns of the transporter in Nostoc punctiforme likely constitute symbiosis specific adaptations.     

Genetic diversity of symbiotic cyanobacteria in Cycas revoluta (Cycadaceae)

The diversity of cyanobacterial species within the coralloid roots of an individual and populations of Cycas revoluta was investigated based on 16S rRNA gene sequences. Sixty-six coralloid roots were collected from nine natural populations of cycads on Kyushu and the Ryukyu Islands, covering the entire distribution range of the species. Approximately 400?bp of the 5'-end of 16S rRNA genes was amplified, and each was identified by denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis. Most coralloid roots harbored only one cyanobiont, Nostoc, whereas some contained two or three, representing cyanobiont diversity within a single coralloid root isolated from a natural habitat. Genotypes of Nostoc within a natural population were occasionally highly diverged and lacked DNA sequence similarity, implying genetic divergence of Nostoc. On the other hand, Nostoc genotypes showed no phylogeographic structure across the distribution range, while host cycads exhibited distinct north-south differentiation. Cycads may exist in symbiosis with either single or multiple Nostoc strains in natural soil habitats.     

Sarcosine: a possible regulatory compound in the Peltigera praetextata-Nostoc symbiosis

Abstract In analyses of free amino acids in the lichen Peltigera praetextata high levels of sarcosine ( N -methylglycine) were found.
Sarcosine was found to stimulate nitrogenase activity of the cyanobiont Nostoc , isolated from Peltigera canina . This stimulation was optimal at 1 mM sarcosine, a concentration which is close to that calculated as being present in a water-saturated lichen thallus. Sarcosine also was found to inhibit the activity of glutamine synthetase in Nostoc . This inhibitory effect may account for the stimulation of nitrogenase activity and may be important in the symbiotic regulation of cyanophilic lichens.     

High cyanobiont selectivity of epiphytic lichens in old growth boreal forest of Finland

Here, cyanobiont selectivity of epiphytic lichen species was examined in an old growth forest area in Finland. Samples of the eight lichen species were collected from the same aspen (Populus tremula) and adjacent aspens in the same stand. The cyanobionts of these samples were compared with free and symbiotic Nostoc obtained from other habitats and geographic regions. Our results, based on the phylogenetic analysis of a partial small subunit of the ribosomal DNA (16S rDNA) and the rbcLX gene complex did not show any correlation with the geographic origin of the samples at any spatial scale. Instead, there was a correlation between the cyanobionts and the alleged taxonomy of their mycobionts. The results indicate that the lichen species examined are highly selective towards their cyanobiont partners. Only Lobaria pulmonaria proved to be more flexible, being able to associate with a wide range of Nostoc. A same Nostoc strain was found to form associations with taxonomically unrelated lichens indicating that the cyanobiont-mycobiont associations as a whole were not highly specific in the examined species.