Conformational study of calf brain tubulin

The conformation of calf brain tubulin has been monitored by circular dichroism, optical rotatory dispersion, and spectrophotometric titration as a function of pH, temperature, ligand concentrations, and denaturants. At pH 7, calf brain tubulin maintains its structural integrity between 5 and 37 °C as determined by circular dichroism. Furthermore, the presence of MgCl ₂ up to 1.6 × 10^?2m does not induce any observable changes in the circular dichroism spectra, nor does 10^?4m CaCl₂. With increasing pH, the spectral data can best be described as a gradual loosening of the secondary structure between pH 7 and 9. Both spectral and titrimetric data suggest a major unfolding of tubulin between pH 9 and 10. The apparent pK of tyrosine shifts from 10.85 to 9.98 upon transferring from buffer to 6 m guanidine hydrochloride, indicating that at least 14 of the 15 tyrosine groups are not fully accessible to protons in the native protein. The single disulfide bridge in calf brain tubulin helps to maintain a domain which is highly resistant to unfolding by denaturants.     

In vivo incorporation of [14C]tyrosine into the C-terminal position of the α subunit of tubulin

In vitro incorporation of [¹⁴C]tyrosine into the C-terminal position of the α subunit of tubulin was not affected by 4 mm cycloheximide. This inhibitor of protein synthesis was used for in vivo experiments. The in vivo incorporation of [¹⁴C]tyrosine into soluble brain protein of cycloheximide-treated rats was 10% of that of untreated rats. Treatment with vinblastine sulfate of the soluble brain protein showed that the incorporation of [¹⁴C]tyrosine into tubulin was higher in cycloheximide-treated than in untreated rats with respect to the incorporation into the total soluble protein. In the case of cycloheximide-treated rats, about 60% of the radioactivity incorporated into protein was released by the action of carboxypeptidase A, whereas 10% was liberated from the protein of untreated rats. The radioactive compound released by the action of carboxypeptidase A was identified as [¹⁴C]tyrosine. The α and β subunits of tubulin from animals that received [¹⁴C]tyrosine were separated by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The radiosactivity ratio of $\text{α}\text{β}$ subunits of tubulin from cycloheximide-treated rats was threefold higher than that of untreated rats. When a mixture of [¹⁴C]amino acids was injected, the radioactivity ratio of $\text{α}\text{β}$ subunits of tubulin was similar for cycloheximide-treated and untreated rats. The results reported are consistent with the assumption that the α subunit of tubulin can be tyrosinated in vivo.     

Tubulin from cultured tobacco cells: isolation and identification based on similarities to brain tubulin

The microtubule protein, tubulin, was isolated from most other proteins of cell suspension cultures of Nicotiana tabacum L. by its copolymerization with cow-brain tubulin. Cow-brain tubulin was added to the soluble protein fraction of extract from ³⁵S-labeled tobacco cells and subjected to two cycles of temperature-dependent assembly-disassembly (copolymerization). When analyzed by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) about 70% of the radioactivity in the twice copolymerized protein was found in a prominent doublet migrating close to the doublet of brain tubulin. When analyzed by two-dimensional isoelectric-focusing-SDS-PAGE the radioactive doublet behaved like the doublet of brain tubulin. Limited proteolysis of the individual polypeptides of the coublets showed that, while the peptide maps of the leading radioactive band and of the β-subunit of brain tubulin were virtually indistinguishable, the maps of the trailing radioactive band and of the α-subunit of brain tubulin, though similar, were not identical. Most of the copolymerized ³⁵S-labeled protein also behaved like brain tubulin during gel filtration and ion-exchange chromatography. It is concluded that the doublet of radioactive polypeptides isolated by copolymerization with brain tubulin are tobacco tubulin polypeptides that have, in their native as well as denatured forms, properties very similar to, but not identical with, cow brain tubulin. Apparently, tubulin has been highly conserved during evolution.     

The Affinity of DNA-Microtubule Protein Complexes and their Disruption by Tubulin Binding Drugs

Abstract

Using the gel shift assay system, we have measured the apparent affinity constant for the interaction of two different DNAs with MAP proteins found in both total calf brain microtubules and heat stable brain preparations. Both DNAs studied contained centromere/kinetochore sequences- one was enriched in the calf satellite DNA; the other was a large restriction fragment containing the yeast CEN11 DNA sequence. Complexes formed using both DNAs had similar K_app values in the range of 2.1×10⁷ M^?1 to 2.0×10⁸ M^?1. CEN11 DNA-MTP complexes had by far the highest K_app value of 2.0×10⁸ M^?1. The CEN11 DNA sequence is where the yeast kinetochore of chromosome 11 is formed and where the single yeast microtubule is bound in vivo. The CEN11 conserved region II known binding sites -(dA/dT)n runs- for mammalian MAP2 protein, are in good agreement with this higher K_app value. The effects of the classical tubulin binding drugs colchicine, podophyllotoxin and vinblastine on the DNA-MAP protein complex stability were investigated by determining the drug concentrations where the complexes were destabilized. Only the complexes formed from total microtubule protein (tubulin containing) were destabilized over a wide drug concentration range. Heat stable brain protein complexes (no tubulin) were largely unaffected. Furthermore, it took 10–100 fold higher drug concentrations to disrupt the CEN 11 DNA complexes compared to the calf thymus satellite DNA enriched complexes. These data support our previous results suggesting that there is a DNA sequence dependent interaction with MAP proteins that appears to be conserved in evolution (Marx et. al., Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 783, 383–392,1984; Marx and Denial, Molecular Basis of Cancer 172B,65-15 1985). In addition, these results imply that the classical tubulin binding drugs may exert their biological effects in cells at least in part by disrupting DNA-Protein complexes of the type we have studied here.     

Specific affinity labelling of tubulin with bromocolchicine

Bromocolchicine, synthesized by substituting tho N-acetyl moiety of colchicine with a reactive bromoacetyl group, was found to be an affinity label for tubulin. Binding of [³H]colchicine to tubulin was competitively and irreversibly inhibited by bromocolchicine with a K_i value of 2.3 × 10^?5m. The affinity label could not be displaced by precipitating the protein with trichloroacetic acid and is thus covalently bound. Autoradiographs of brain high-speed supernatant proteins after their electrophoretic separation on sodium dodecyl sulphate/polyacrylamide gels showed that [³H]bromocolchicine reacted with four proteins, of which tubulin was one.Labelling of two of these proteins could be prevented by pretreatment of the brain extracts with α-bromoacetic acid, after which 70% of the covalently bound label was specifically located in the tubulin band. Up to 1.6 mol of affinity label could be bound per mol of tubulin, while under our experimental conditions 1 mol of protein bound irreversibly only 0.2 mol of [³H]colchicine. Autoradiography of sodium dodecyl sulphate/urea-polyacrylamide gels, which separate the subunits of tubulin, showed about 30% [³H] bromocolchicine bound to the α-subunit of tubulin and 70% to tho β-subunit.The irreversible binding site of colchicine was localized to the α-subunit, as labelling of only this subunit was inhibited by colchicine at high affinity label concentrations. At lower concentrations, colchicine inhibited the labelling of both subunits.Bromoacetic acid did not inhibit the reaction of the affinity label with the tubulin subunits, but increased the inhibition of [³H]bromocolchicine binding at lower concentrations of the affinity label in brain extracts preincubated with cold colchicine. This is interpreted to show a conformational change which takes place in the two subunits of tubulin upon binding of colchicine and results in the exposure of some of the binding sites of [³H]bromocolchicine to bromoacetic acid.     

Microtubule reassembly in vitro of Strongylocentrotus purpuratus sperm tail outer doublet tubulin

Strongylocentrotus purpuratus outer doublet microtubules were prepared by extraction of sperm tail axonemes with 0.6 m-KCl. Sonication of the outer doublet microtubules in 5 mm-2-(N-morpholino)ethanesulphonic acid, 1 mm-ethyleneglycol-bis-(β-aminoethyl ether) N,N′-tetraacetic acid, 1 inm-MgSO₄ (pH 6.7) solubilized up to 35% of the outer doublet protein, depending on the power input, in a manner which was non-selective for either subfiber. Tubulin comprised 75 to 85% of the total solubilized protein in a 200,000 g supernatant obtained from the sonicated suspension. Colchicine-binding assays demonstrated that the tubulin was largely in a native form (K_A = 10⁶, liters mole^?; 0.74 mole of colchicine bound per mole of tubulin at infinite concentration of colchicine).Microtubule self-assembly from the 200,000 g supernatants in the absence of added seeds or glycerol was quantitated by light-scattering at 350 nm. The critical protein concentration for assembly was 0.55 mg ml^?1 at 37 °C and the reaction occurred optimally in the presence of 2 mm-GTP and 150 mm-KCl. The solubilized outer doublet tubulin formed singlet microtubules upon reassembly under our in vitro conditions. The authenticity of the microtubules was verified by both negative stain and thin-section electron microscopy. Polymerization was prevented by colchicine and podophyllotoxin, and depolymerization occurred rapidly on cooling the microtubules to 0 °C.The susceptibility of the reassembled microtubules to low temperature suggested that they could be “recycled” by the warm assembly-cold disassembly procedure developed for vertebrate brain (Borisy et al., 1974). Twice recycled outer doublet tubulin was devoid of high molecular weight microtubule-associated proteins, as judged by gel electrophoresis in the presence of sodium dodecyl sulfate. However, trace amounts (less than 5%) of intermediate molecular weight material was visible on heavily overloaded gels. The function of this material is uncertain, but it is not chemically equivalent to the tau factor of vertebrate brain (Weingarten et al., 1975), since it cannot be separated from the tubulin by phosphocellulose adsorption. In addition, phosphocellulose-treated tubulin reassembled to the same extent as untreated tubulin, suggesting that the reassembly of outer doublet tubulin does not require the protein equivalents of brain microtubule-associated proteins or tau factor. If accessory proteins are required for the reassembly of outer doublet tubulin, they are not removed by phosphocellulose under the conditions employed, and they must comprise less than 5% of the total protein.     

Polypeptides encoded by the early region of bacteriophage Mu synthesized in minicells of Escherichia coli

The preferential interaction of calf brain tubulin with glycerol in an aqueous buffer (0.01 m-NaP_i, 0.02 m-NaCl, 10^?4m-GTP, pH 7.0) has been investigated by densimetry. The apparent specific volumes of tubulin at constant chemical potential of the diffusible components were determined at 0, 10, 20 and 30% ($\text{v}\text{v}$) glycerol. Application of multicomponent solution thermodynamics shows that tubulin is preferentially hydrated in aqueous glycerol solvent and that such interaction results in thermodynamic destabilization of the system by raising the chemical potentials of both glycerol and tubulin. Interpreted in terms of the Wyman linkage function, the unfavorable free energy change brought about by the preferential protein-glycerol interaction can account for the glycerol enhancement of tubulin self-assembly in vitro into microtubules as well as offer a rationale for glycerol stabilization of the native tubulin conformation.     

Human lymphocyte tubulin: Purification and characterization in normal and leukemic cells

Tubulin has been purified from human blood and tonsil lymphocytes. Using gel filtration, the molecular weight of human lymphocyte tubulin was estimated to be 119 000. The proteins was shown to consist of two subunits, with molecular weights of 61 000 and 58 000 comparable to the α and β polypeptides of human brain tubulin. A partial identity reaction was observed between lymphocyte tubulin and human tubulin when tested by double immunodiffusion against a rabbit anti-human brain tubulin antibody. In the presence of GTP, the purified protein polymerized to form microtubules. Tubulin was localized to the cell's juxtacentriolar region by immunofluorescence and electron microscopy. When assayed by a colchicine-binding assay corrected for time decay, the binding affinity was 1.50 ± 0.86 · 10⁶M^?1 and a level in normal lymphocytes of 1.21 · 10^?2 ± 0.79 g/g of soluble protein was determined. Since chronic lymphocytic leukemia lymphocytes have an anomalous capping behavior as well as an unusual susceptibility to colchicine toxicity, the properties and levels of tubulin were determined in these cells. Similar values were obtained for the level, decay rate, molecular weight, and K_a for colchicine as for normal lymphocytes. Chronic lymphocytic leukemia lymphocyte tubulin polymerized in a normal fashion. It thus appears that a decrease in the quantity or function of tubulin does not account for these anomalies in the chronic lymphocytic leukemia lymphocyte.     

Interaction of anthelmintic benzimidazoles with AscarisSuum embryonic tubulin

The ability of mebendazole and fenbendazole to bind to tubulin in cytosolic fractions from 8-day Ascaris suum embryos was determined by inhibition studies with [³H]colchicine. Colchicine binding in the presence of 1·10^?6 M mebendazole was completely inhibited during a 6 h incubation period at 37°C. Inhibition of colchicine binding to A. suum embryonic tubulin by mebendazole and fenbendazole appeared to be noncompetative. The inhibition constants of mebendazole and fenbendazole for A. suum embryonic tubulin were 1.9·10^?8 M and 6.5·10^?8 M, respectively. Mebendazole and fenbendazole appeared to be competitive inhibitors of colchicine binding to bovine brain tubulin. The inhibition constants of mebendazole and fenbendazole for bovine brain tubulin were 7.3·10^?6 M and 1.7·10^?5 M, respectively. These values are 250–400 times greater than the inhibition constants of fenbendazole and mebendazole for A. suum embryonic tubulin. Differential binding affinities between nematode tubulin and mammalian tubulin for benzimidazoles may explain the selective toxicity. The importance of tubulin as a receptor for anthelmintic benzimidazoles in animal parasitic nematodes is discussed.     

Microtubule assembly in developing mammalian brain.

Microtubule protein was measured in mouse brain homogenates by quantitative colchicine binding. Neonatal animals contained more than twice the amount of brain tubulin as adult mice. The percentage of colchicine-binding protein which was polymerized was determined by extracting brain at room temperature into a medium designed to stabilize intact microtubules. Under identical conditions and tubulin concentrations, neonatal brain tubulin (colchicine-binding activity) had a greater proportion of the total extracted in an apparently polymerized state (pelletable by centrifugation) than did adult brain. A slight variation in the ratio of assembled to unassembled tubulin was observed with varying protein concentration (volume of extract), indicating that the values obtained may not reflect exactly the in vivo situation, because a rapid equilibration takes place upon homogenization. At all protein concentrations, the neonatal brain extracts contained a significantly greater proportion of assembled tubulin than did adult brain. This proportion began to fall at 5 days postnatal and reached the adult level at 30 days. The tubulin assembled/not assembled ratios were not altered by addition of nucleoside triphosphates, additional EGTA, or sulfhydryl protecting agents, and did not vary with preparation times of 30–90 min. The colchicine-binding reaction and decay of colchicine-binding activity with time were similar in extracts of different aged mouse brains, with neonatal slightly more stable than adult. Pools of tubulin from any age which were soluble at room temperature (unpolymerized) could not repolymerize well in vitro when incubated with GTP at 37 °C, whereas pools of tubulin which were sedimentable at room temperature (polymerized) could be redissolved at 0 °C and readily reassembled at 37 °C. The neonatal extract tubulin was thus more polymerization competent than the adult extracts; this correlates with a greater proportion of assembled tubulin in extracts at room temperature and possibly in vivo.     

Purification of microtubule protein from beef brain and comparison of the assembly requirements for neuronal microtubules isolated from beef and hog.

The polymerization of microtubule protein from beef brain is inefficient under the same conditions which are optimal for the assembly of microtubules isolated from hog brain (0.1 m piperazine-N,N′-bis(2-ethanesulfonic acid) buffer at pH 6.94). In examining the conditions required for microtubule polymerization in both beef brain extract and purified microtuble protein, it was determined that the pH optimum was pH 6.62 or 0.3 pH unit lower than the reported optimum for hog. Other assembly requirements (ionic strength, Mg²⁺ and nucleotide concentration, temperature) remained essentially the same as for hog. By separating and recombining fractions of tubulin and nontubulin components prepared from beef and hog microtubule protein, the requirement for the reduction in pH was found to be due to the tubulin and not to the microtubule-associated proteins. It was also determined that the efficiency of beef tubulin assembly, as measured by the yield of microtubule polymer, decreased rapidly after slaughter with a half-time of 19 min. Furthermore, when the overall efficiency of polymerization was reduced, the extent of assembly at each cycle of purification by disassembly and assembly was also observed to be depressed. The variations in the requirements for neuronal tubulin assembly in two closely related mammals suggest that the conditions required for assembly of microtubule protein in other tissues and cell types may also be different.     

The structure and amount of tubulin in cells and tissues.

The NH2-terminals and amino acid compositions of three carboxymethylcysteine-containing peptides produced from carboxymethylated calf brain tubulin by digestion with elastase have been determined. The 3H/14C ratio obtained when these peptides were generated from mixtures of [14C]carboxymethylated calf brain tubulin and the [3H]carboxymethylated proteins of mouse brain or 3T3 cells and subsequently purified indicated that both mouse brain and 3T3 cells contained protein giving rise to peptides homologous to these peptides. This indicates that the tubulins of calf brain, mouse brain, and 3T3 cells are homologous in the regions of amino acid sequence accounting for the peptides examined. From the 3H/14C ratio of the isolated peptides, 13.5% of the protein of mouse brain and 3.5% of the protein of 3T3 cells were estimated to be tubulin.     

In vitro assembly of microtubule proteins from myxamoebae of Physarum polycephalum

Microtubule protein of >95% purity has been isolated by self-assembly from concentrated cell extracts of myxamoebae of Physarum polycephalum. Ninety-eight percent of the amoebal microtubule protein was tubulin. Both a and β subunits of amoebal tubulin were different from neurotubulin α and β subunits, but very similar to those of Tetrahymena ciliary tubulin. The non-tubulin components, which co-purified with tubulin through three assembly cycles, were essential to microtubule formation and contained several polypeptides including some of apparent molecular weights 49000, 57000 and 59000. Purified amoebal microtubule protein formed microtubules on warming in the absence of glycerol which were cold- and Ca²⁺-labile. In vitro, microtubule assembly was inhibited by vinblastine, benzimidazole derivatives and griseofulvin, but not by 10^?4 M colchicine. Amoebal tubulin had a much lower affinity than neurotubulin for colchicine.     

Isolation of brain Ca2+-calmodulin tubulin kinase containing calmodulin binding proteins

Ca²⁺-calmodulin tubulin kinase activity was isolated from brain cytosol and separated from its substrate protein, tubulin, and Ca²⁺ regulatory protein, calmodulin. Characterization of the Ca²⁺-tubulin kinase system revealed a Km of 4 μM, 0.5 μM, 60 μM for Ca²⁺, calmodulin and ATP, respectively. The tubulin kinase system bound to a calmodulin affinity column in the presence of Ca²⁺ and was released from the column by chelation with EGTA. A major 55,000 and a minor 65,000 dalton peptide were identified as the only calmodulin binding proteins in the enzyme fraction, indicating that one or both of these peptides represent the calmodulin binding subunit of the Ca²⁺-calmodulin tubulin kinase system.     

Polymerization of tubulin in the presence of colchicine or podophyllotoxin. Formation of a ribbon structure induced by guanylyl-5'-methylene diphosphonate

GTP-dependent in vitro polymerization of rat brain microtubular protein is inhibited to 50% by substoichiometric concentrations of the antimitotic drugs colchicine (0.12 mol/mol of tubulin) and podophyllotoxin (0.14 mol/mol of tubulin). Substitution of pp(CH₂)pG² for GTP, however, results in an extensive microtubular protein polymerization at such concentrations. In the presence of pp(CH₂)pG, suprastoichiometric concentrations of podophyllotoxin (19 mol/mol of tubulin) are required to inhibit the polymerization process by 50%. Colchicine is very ineffective since 3 × 10⁵ moles/mole of tubulin are required to give a 50% inhibition. Electron microscopical analysis shows that the polymers formed by microtubular protein in the presence of suprastoichiometric concentrations of drugs are not the normal short microtubules typical of pp(CH₂)pG-driven polymerization, but are ribbons with three or four protofilaments. The colchicine content of the harvested ribbons has been measured directly and found to be approximately 0.8 moles colchicine/mole of tubulin. Treatment of microtubular protein with substoichiometric concentrations of drugs results in an increase in the number of protofilaments forming the ribbons. Many of the ribbons can close into morphologically normal microtubules when microtubular protein is treated with only 0.05 moles of either colchicine or podophyllotoxin per mole of tubulin.     

Isolation and characterization of a unique 15 kilodalton trypanosome subpellicular microtubule-associated protein.

A protein of 15 kDa (p15) was isolated from Trypanosoma brucei subpellicular microtubules by tubulin affinity chromatography. The protein bound tubulin specifically both in its native form and after SDS-PAGE in tubulin overlay experiments. p15 promoted both the in vitro polymerization of purified calf brain tubulin and the bundling of preformed mammalian microtubules. Immunolabeling identified p15 at multiple sites along microtubule polymers comprising calf brain tubulin and p15 as well as on the subpellicular microtubules of cryosectioned trypanosomes. Antibodies directed against p15 did not cross react with mammalian microtubules. It is suggested that p15 is a trypanosome-specific microtubule-associated protein (MAP) that contributes to the unique organization of the subpellicular microtubules.     

Mechanism of cytotoxicity of methylmercury

Mechanism of methylmercury cytotoxicity was investigated with special reference to its preferential action on microtubules and protein biosynthesis in cultured cells. The tubulin synthesis analyzed by autoradiography of two-dimensional electropherogram using³⁵S-methionine was inhibited by 50–70% in mouse glioma cells exposed to 5×10^?6 M methylmercury for 3 h, which almost completely depolymerized microtubules. Total protein synthesis monitored by incorporation of labeled methionine into acid insoluble fraction was decreased slightly but significantly and the protein bands other than tubulin on gradient urea-PAGE gel appeared to remain unchanged under the experimental condition used. These results suggest that the inhibition of protein synthesis observed on exposure to methylmercury can be ascribed, at least partly, to a possible autoregulatory depression in tubulin synthesis owing to the increase in the pool of tubulin subunits resulted from microtubule depolymerization by methylmercury.     

Tubulin synthesis during ciliogenesis in the mouse oviduct.

We reported earlier that tubulin levels increase in the developing mouse oviduct during that period after birth when ciliogenesis is at a maximum (Staprans, I., and Dirksen, E. R. (1974) J. Cell Biol., 62, 164). To determine the degree to which de novo synthesis and tubulin pools contribute to this increase, [³H]leucine-incorporation experiments were performed in vivo and in culture. Soluble, particulate and axonemal fractions, obtained from homogenized oviducts of 3-, 5-, 8- and 12-day-old suckling mice, were electrophoresed on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels and the specific activity of the tubulin band determined. The present work shows that more than 90% of the tubulin in 3-day-old and 75% in 5-day-old mouse oviducts is synthesized de novo. From both the in vivo and in culture experiments we conclude that although tubulin pools are present in mouse oviduct, they are continuously being replenished by newly synthesized protein as there is a rapid outflow from the soluble and particulate to the axonemal fraction into structures such as basal bodies and cilia. This burst of de novo tubulin synthesis corresponds to evidence from electron microscopic autoradiography, where label is present to a greater extent over centriole precursors and basal bodies than over other cell organelles. [³H]leucine incorporation into tubulin was inhibited by cycloheximide, demonstrating that we are dealing with synthesis, while colchicine below 10^?3, M concentration had no effect on tubulin assembly into axonemes.     

Calmodulin-dependent protein kinase (kinase II) which is involved in the activation of tryptophan 5-monooxygenase catalyzes phosphorylation of tubulin

Tubulin was shown to be an endogenous substrate of the calmodulin-dependent protein kinase (kinase II), which is involved in the activation of tryptophan 5-monooxygenase [T. Yamauchi and H. Fujisawa (1983) Eur. J. Biochem.132, 15–21]. Serine and threonine were identified as the phosphate acceptor amino acids of tubulin. The V_max of the phosphorylation of tubulin and the apparent K_m value for tubulin of calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II were 89 nmol phosphate transferred min^?1 mg kinase II^?1 and 1.7 μm, respectively. The maximum ³²P incorporation into tubulin was 0.18 mol P_i/mol α-tubulin and 0.13 mol P_i/mol β-tubulin. The phosphorylation of tubulin was decreased by the denaturation of tubulin. The phosphorylation of tubulin by kinase II did not affect the assembly of microtubules.     

An Apparent Paradox in the Occurrence, and the In Vivo Turnover, of C-Terminal Tyrosine in Membrane-Bound Tubulin of Brain

: Tubulin tyrosine ligase catalyzes the reversible addition of tyrosine to the C-terminus of tubulin α chains. By using ligase and carboxypeptidase A in conjunction, we have previously shown that brain cytoplasmic tubulin exists in three forms: 15–40% already has C-terminal tyrosine, another 10-30% can accept additional tyrosine, and about one-half is an uncharacterized species which is not a ligase substrate. A membrane-bound fraction of brain tubulin, purified by vinblastine precipitation from a detergent extract, has been found to differ by the complete absence of preexisting tyrosine. The membrane fraction from which tubulin was extracted also contained masked forms of both ligase and a distinct detyrosylating enzyme, which can be released by detergent extraction. The turnover of α-chain C-terminal tyrosine in vivo was studied by incubating brain mince with labeled tyrosine, or injecting it intracerebrally, under conditions where protein synthesis was inhibited. Tyrosine appeared to turn over to about the same extent in membrane-bound, as in soluble, tubulin. This apparently paradoxical result was not due to ATPase in the membrane fraction, which might have allowed ligase-catalyzed exchange between free and fixed tyrosine. Authentic [¹⁴C]tyrosylated tubulin added to the brain membrane fraction was not detyrosylated or subject to endoprotease digestion during subsequent procedures to isolate tubulin. The unexpected finding that tubulin tyrosylated at the C-terminal in vivo appears to be in the “non-substrate” fraction points toward a possible resolution of the paradox.