Hypothermic perfusion preservation: the future of organ preservation revisited?

Hypothermic perfusion preservation (HPP) was an integral step in the development of early clinical transplantation programmes, and considerable progress was made in understanding the basic principles underlying the technique. In subsequent years, the development of better preservation solutions for cold hypoxic storage, along with pragmatic choices made on grounds of costs and logistics, saw a fall in the application of HPP. More recently, the acute shortage of suitable organ donors and the inevitable pressure to use organs from sub-optimal (or expanded criteria) donors, has forced a re-evaluation of HPP, and the development of a new generation of HPP machines and associated perfusion solutions. This review sets out the historical development of HPP across the range of organs in which the method was originally investigated, describes the biological benefits and drawbacks associated with HPP, and sets out the most recent literature on the topic (including comments on the interest in use of higher temperatures in organ perfusion).     

Persufflation (or gaseous oxygen perfusion) as a method of organ preservation

Improved preservation techniques have the potential to improve transplant outcomes by better maintaining donor organ quality and by making more organs available for allotransplantation. Persufflation, (PSF, gaseous oxygen perfusion) is potentially one such technique that has been studied for over a century in a variety of tissues, but has yet to gain wide acceptance for a number of reasons. A principal barrier is the perception that ex vivo PSF will cause in vivo embolization post-transplant. This review summarizes the extensive published work on heart, liver, kidney, small intestine and pancreas PSF, discusses the differences between anterograde and retrograde PSF, and between PSF and other conventional methods of organ preservation (static cold storage, hypothermic machine perfusion). Prospective implications of PSF within the broader field of organ transplantation, and in the specific application with pancreatic islet isolation and transplant are also discussed. Finally, key issues that need to be addressed before PSF becomes a more widely utilized preservation strategy are summarized and discussed.     

Hyperbranched Polyglycerol as a Colloid in Cold Organ Preservation Solutions

Hydroxyethyl starch (HES) is a common colloid in organ preservation solutions, such as in University of Wisconsin (UW) solution, for preventing graft interstitial edema and cell swelling during cold preservation of donor organs. However, HES has undesirable characteristics, such as high viscosity, causing kidney injury and aggregation of erythrocytes. Hyperbranched polyglycerol (HPG) is a branched compact polymer that has low intrinsic viscosity. This study investigated HPG (MW-0.5 to 119 kDa) as a potential alternative to HES for cold organ preservation. HPG was synthesized by ring-opening multibranching polymerization of glycidol. Both rat myocardiocytes and human endothelial cells were used as an in vitro model, and heart transplantation in mice as an in vivo model. Tissue damage or cell death was determined by both biochemical and histological analysis. HPG polymers were more compact with relatively low polydispersity index than HES in UW solution. Cold preservation of mouse hearts ex vivo in HPG solutions reduced organ damage in comparison to those in HES-based UW solution. Both size and concentration of HPGs contributed to the protection of the donor organs; 1 kDa HPG at 3 wt% solution was superior to HES-based UW solution and other HPGs. Heart transplants preserved with HPG solution (1 kDa, 3%) as compared with those with UW solution had a better functional recovery, less tissue injury and neutrophil infiltration in syngeneic recipients, and survived longer in allogeneic recipients. In cultured myocardiocytes or endothelial cells, significantly more cells survived after cold preservation with the HPG solution than those with the UW solution, which was positively correlated with the maintenance of intracellular adenosine triphosphate and cell membrane fluidity. In conclusion, HPG solution significantly enhanced the protection of hearts or cells during cold storage, suggesting that HPG is a promising colloid for the cold storage of donor organs and cells in transplantation.     

Acid-base buffering in organ preservation solutions as a function of temperature: new parameters for comparing buffer capacity and efficiency

Control of acidity and preventing intracellular acidosis are recognized as critical properties of an effective organ preservation solution. Buffer capacity and efficiency are therefore important for comparing the relative merits of preservation fluids for optimum hypothermic storage, but these parameters are not available for the variety of organ preservation solutions of interest in transplantation today. Moreover, buffer capacity is dependent upon both concentration and pH such that buffer capacity is not easily predicted for a complex solution containing multiple buffer species. Using standard electrometric methods to measure acid dissociation constants, this study was undertaken to determine the maximum and relative buffer capacities of a variety of new and commonly used hypothermic preservation solutions as a function of temperature. The reference data provided by these measurements show that comparative buffer capacity and efficiency vary widely between the commonly used solutions. Moreover, the fluids containing zwitterionic sulfonic acid buffers such as Hepes possess superior buffering for alpha-stat pH regulation in the region of physiological importance.     

Technique of Subnormothermic Ex Vivo Liver Perfusion for the Storage,Assessment, and Repair of Marginal Liver Grafts

The success of liver transplantation has resulted in a dramatic organ shortage. In most transplant regions 20-30% of patients on the waiting list for liver transplantation die without receiving an organ transplant or are delisted for disease progression. One strategy to increase the donor pool is the utilization of marginal grafts, such as fatty livers, grafts from older donors, or donation after cardiac death (DCD). The current preservation technique of cold static storage is only poorly tolerated by marginal livers resulting in significant organ damage. In addition, cold static organ storage does not allow graft assessment or repair prior to transplantation.These shortcomings of cold static preservation have triggered an interest in warm perfused organ preservation to reduce cold ischemic injury, assess liver grafts during preservation, and explore the opportunity to repair marginal livers prior to transplantation. The optimal pressure and flow conditions, perfusion temperature, composition of the perfusion solution and the need for an oxygen carrier has been controversial in the past.In spite of promising results in several animal studies, the complexity and the costs have prevented a broader clinical application so far. Recently, with enhanced technology and a better understanding of liver physiology during ex vivo perfusion the outcome of warm liver perfusion has improved and consistently good results can be achieved.This paper will provide information about liver retrieval, storage techniques, and isolated liver perfusion in pigs. We will illustrate a) the requirements to ensure sufficient oxygen supply to the organ, b) technical considerations about the perfusion machine and the perfusion solution, and c) biochemical aspects of isolated organs.     

Polyethylene glycols interact with membrane glycerophospholipids: is this part of their mechanism for hypothermic graft protection?

Polyethylene glycol (PEG), a high-molecular-weight colloid present in new organ preservation solutions, protects against cold ischemia injuries leading to better graft function of transplanted organs. This protective effect cannot be totally explained by immuno-camouflaging property or signaling-pathway modifications. Therefore, we sought for an alternative mechanism dependent on membrane fluidity. Using the Langmuir–Pockles technique, we show here that PEGs interacted with lipid monolayers of defined composition or constituted by a renal cell lipid extract. High-molecular-weight PEGs stabilized the lipid monolayer at low surface pressure. Paradoxically, at high surface pressure, PEGs destabilized the monolayers. Hypothermia reduced the destabilization of saturated monolayer whereas unsaturated monolayer remained unaffected. Modification of ionic strength and pH induced a stronger stabilizing effect of PEG 35,000 Da which could explain its reported higher effectiveness on cold-induced injuries during organ transplantation. This study sheds a new light on PEG protective effects during organ preservation different from all classical hypotheses.     

Assessment of organ culture for the conservation of human skin allografts

Objective Human skin allografts are used in the treatment of severe burns and their preservation is therefore critical for optimal clinical benefit. Current preservation methods, such as 4°C storage or cryopreservation, cannot prevent the decrease of tissue viability. The aim of this study was to assess viability and function of skin allografts in a new skin organ culture model, allowing conservation parameters as close as possible to physiological conditions: 32°C, air–liquid interface and physiological skin tension. Design Twelve skin samples, harvested from 6 living surgical donors, were conserved 35 days in two conditions: conservation at 4°C and organ culture. Viability and function of skin samples were investigated at Day 0, 7, 14, 21, 28 and 35 using cell culture methods (trypan blue exclusion, Colony Forming Efficiency and Growth Rate), histopathological and histoenzymological studies (Ki67 immunostaining). Results In the two conditions, fibroblast and keratinocyte viability was progressively affected by storage, with a significant decrease observed after 35 days. No statistical difference could be observed between the two conditions. The two methods were also comparable regarding alterations of fibroblast and keratinocyte culture parameters, which were respectively significantly reduced at Day 7 and 21, compared to fresh skin. By contrast, histopathological and histoenzymological studies revealed a better preservation of skin architecture and proliferative potential at 4°C, as compared to organ culture. Conclusion These results indicate that skin organ culture does not provide significant advantages for skin allograft preservation. However, its potential use as an experimental model to study skin physiology and wound healing should be further evaluated.     

Effect of cold storage on tissue and cellular glutathione

One of the mechanisms thought to cause injury in preserved organs is the formation of oxygen free radicals. The cell is protected from oxidative stress by many defense mechanisms. A major defense mechanism involves glutathione and glutathione-dependent enzymes. During organ preservation by simple cold storage the loss of glutathione may sensitize the organ to free radical damage after transplantation. In this study we show that glutathione is depleted from the rabbit liver, kidney, and heart cold-stored (5 degrees C) for up to 72 h in the UW solution without glutathione. In the first 24 h kidney glutathione decreased to 84 +/- 3% of control values, liver glutathione decreased to 49 +/- 3% of control values, and heart glutathione decreased to 73 +/- 3% of control values. After 48 h of storage the kidney and liver lost an additional 30 and 20%, respectively, whereas heart glutathione changed very little. By 72 h all three organs had lost more than 50% of the glutathione found in freshly obtained tissue. To determine if glutathione added to the UW solution can effectively prevent this loss of glutathione during preservation, hepatocytes were cold-stored for up to 72 h in a preservation solution with and without glutathione. We found that adding glutathione to the preservation solution slowed the rate of loss of glutathione from the cells. These data suggest that at hypothermia the cell may be permeable to GSH. Methods to suppress the loss of glutathione during preservation of organs may be an important factor in suppressing oxygen free radical injury.     

Current techniques and the future of lung preservation

Although lung transplant remains the only option for patients suffering from end-stage lung failure, donor supply is insufficient to meet demand. Static cold preservation is the most common method to preserve lungs in transport to the recipient; however, this method does not improve lung quality and only allows for 8 h of storage. This results in lungs which become available for donation but cannot be used due to failure to meet physiologic criteria or an inability to store them for a sufficient time to find a suitable recipient. Therefore, lungs lost due to failure to meet physiological or compatibility criteria may be mitigated through preservation methods which improve lung function and storage durations. Ex situ lung perfusion (ESLP) is a recently developed method which allows for longer storage times and has been demonstrated to improve lung function such that rejected lungs can be accepted for donation. Although greater use of ESLP will help to improve donor lung utilization, the ability to cryopreserve lungs would allow for organ banking to better utilize donor lungs. However, lung cryopreservation research remains underrepresented in the literature despite its unique advantages for cryopreservation over other organs. Therefore, this review will discuss the current techniques for lung preservation, static cold preservation and ESLP, and provide a review of the cryopreservation challenges and advantages unique to lungs.     

类器官的应用研究进展

类器官是利用干细胞的自我更新和分化能力,在体外培养形成的一种微小组织器官类似物,在很大程度上具有体内相应器官的功能。迄今为止,在3D培养条件下,已经成功培养出多种类器官如肺、胃、肠、肝和肾等类器官。它们不仅可作为组织器官的替代品用于药物和临床研究,还可用于体内器官移植。本文综述了类器官在药物毒性检测、药效评价和新药筛选中的作用以及利用类器官建立疾病模型、研究组织器官发育和类器官在精准医疗、再生医学中的价值。     

Machine Perfusion versus Cold Storage of Kidneys Derived from Donation after Cardiac Death: A Meta-Analysis

Background

In response to the increased organ shortage, organs derived from donation after cardiac death (DCD) donors are becoming an acceptable option once again for clinical use in transplantation. However, transplant outcomes in cases where DCD organs are used are not as favorable as those from donation after brain death or living donors. Different methods of organ preservation are a key factor that may influence the outcomes of DCD kidney transplantation.

Methods

We compared the transplant outcomes in patients receiving DCD kidneys preserved by machine perfusion (MP) or by static cold storage (CS) preservation by conducting a meta-analysis. The MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane Library databases were searched. All studies reporting outcomes for MP versus CS preserved DCD kidneys were further considered for inclusion in this meta-analysis. Odds ratios and 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated to compare the pooled data between groups that were transplanted with kidneys that were preserved by MP or CS.

Results

Four prospective, randomized, controlled trials, involving 175 MP and 176 CS preserved DCD kidney transplant recipients, were included. MP preserved DCD kidney transplant recipients had a decreased incidence of delayed graft function (DGF) with an odd ration of 0.56 (95% CI = 0.36–0.86, P = 0.008) compared to CS. However, no significant differences were seen between the two technologies in incidence of primary non-function, one year graft survival, or one year patient survival.

Conclusions

MP preservation of DCD kidneys is superior to CS in terms of reducing DGF rate post-transplant. However, primary non-function, one year graft survival, and one year patient survival were not affected by the use of MP or CS for preservation.     

Cystamine prevents ischemia-reperfusion injury by inhibiting polyamination of RhoA

Transglutaminase2 (TGase2) activates Rho-associated kinase (ROCK), an important mediator of ischemia-reperfusion (IR) injury, through polyamination of RhoA. Cystamine, an oxidized dimer of cysteamine inhibits the transamidation activity of TGase2. We examined whether addition of cystamine to an organ preservation solution protects rat cardiomyocyte cells (H9C2) from cell death in IR injury. H9C2 cells were stored under hypoxic conditions at 4 °C in laboratory-made preservation solution (SNU) or SNU solution supplemented with cystamine (SNU-C1), and cell preservation in the two solutions was compared by measuring the release of lactate dehydrogenase. The cells were preserved more effectively in SNU-C1 than in SNU solution. Cystamine inhibited the intracellular activity of TGase2 which increased during cold storage or reoxygenation. The inhibition of TGase2 by cystamine reduced the polyamination of RhoA, the interaction between RhoA and ROCK2, and F-actin formation. Cystamine also prevented the activation of caspases during cold storage. These results suggest that addition of cystamine to the organ preservation solution significantly enhances cardiomyocytes preservation apparently by inhibiting TGase2-mediated RhoA-ROCK pathway and that TGase2 may play an important role in IR injury by regulating ROCK.     

Assessment of the cryoprotectant concentration inside a bulky organ for cryopreservation using X-ray computed tomography

Cryoprotection of bulky organs is crucial for their storage and for subsequent transplantation. In this work we demonstrate the capability of the X-ray computed tomography (CT) as a non-invasive method to measure the cryoprotectant (cpa) concentration inside a tissue or an organ, specifically for the case of dymethil sulfoxide (Me₂SO). It is remarkable that the use of Me₂SO has been leader in techniques of cells and tissues cryopreservation. Although CT technologies are mainly based in density differences, and many cpas are alcohols with densities similar to water, the use of very low energies as acceleration voltage (∼70 kV) and the sulfur atom in the molecule of Me₂SO makes possible the visualization of this cpa inside tissues. As result we obtain a CT signal proportional to the Me₂SO concentration with a spatial resolution up to 50 μm in the case of our device.     

From the freezer to the clinic: Antifreeze proteins in the preservation of cells,tissues, and organs

Understanding the mechanisms by which natural anti‐freeze proteins protect cells and tissues from cold could help to improve the availability of donor organs for transplantation.

The first successful organ transplant in humans was performed in 1954 by Joseph Murray, who used a patient’s twin as a kidney donor. Murrays’ breakthrough paved the way for organ transplantation and the number of transplanted organs has grown ever since. For example, in 2017, a total of 139.024 solid organs—mostly kidney, liver, heart, lung, pancreas, and small bowel—were transplanted (Fig 1A). But this number only reflects 10% of the worldwide need; many patients still die of end‐stage organ failure while on a waiting list. The limited number of donor organs contributes only partially to this shortage. Many donor organs are not transplanted eventually owing to inefficient preservation techniques that shorten their extracorporeal lifetime. In fact, the percentage of donor organs that are unused is estimated to range from around 25% for kidneys and livers up to 70–80% for hearts and lungs (Giwa et al, 2017); Fig 1B).Open in a separate windowFigure 1Organ transplantation and preservability statusStatistics show a positive correlation between the duration of ex vivo preservation and the number of organ transplants. Number of solid organs transplanted in 2017 (A). Percentage of organs failed to be transplanted (B). Duration of solid organ ex vivo preservation in static cold storage (C). Sources: Data from the Global Observatory on Donation and Transplantation and (Parsons et al, 2014), (Guibert et al, 2011) and (Editorial: Buying time for transplants (2017))

Many donor organs are not transplanted eventually owing to inefficient preservation techniques that shorten their extracorporeal lifetime.

To address the shortage of donor organs and decrease the number of organs that go to waste, biobanks could efficiently store viable tissues and organs until transplantation. Yet, the current standard for ex vivo preservation of donor organs is static cold storage (4–8°C) which, depending on the organ, ensures viable conservation for only some hours; hearts are typically viable for a maximum of only 4 h (Fig 1C). In addition, this approach leads to hypothermic damage and to ischemia/reperfusion injury.Hence, there is an urgent need for strategies that prolong the viable preservation of donor organs. Two main strategies have emerged for cryopreservation and subzero storage, both of which cool tissues below the freezing point. While subzero storage just below 0°C may suffice for short‐term preservation, cryopreservation at −80°C or even lower temperatures is required for long‐term storage in biobanks. A proof‐of‐principle study already demonstrated that subzero preservation extended the preservation of rat hearts up to 24 h after collection (Amir et al, 2004); cryopreservation of whole hearts is currently not possible. The main reason is that lowering the temperature below the freezing point of water leads to ice formation, which causes cell damage and destroys tissues. One of the main challenges in biomedical research for organ transplantation is therefore finding non‐toxic and biocompatible antifreeze compounds that enable subzero storage and cryopreservation without causing tissue damage. An additional benefit is a larger time window to perform evaluation in terms of organ size and human leukocyte antigens matching and preparing the recipient patient to increase the chance of a successful transplantation.     

Preservation methods for kidney and liver

With the successful testing of the immunosuppressive effects of cyclosporine in transplant patients in 1978, the field of organ transplants began an exponential growth. With that, the field of organ preservation became increasingly important as the need to increase preservation time and improve graft function became paramount. However, for every patient that receives a transplanted organ, there are 4 more on the waiting list. In addition, a patient dies from the lack of a transplant almost every 1½ hour. To alleviate this donor crisis, there is a need to expand the donor pool to marginal donor organs. The main reason these organs are underutilized is because the current method of static preservation, simple cold storage, is ineffective. This article will provide a general review of the methods of preservation including simple cold storage, hypothermic machine perfusion, normothermic machine perfusion, and oxygen persufflation. In addition, the article will provide a review of how these dynamic preservation methods have improved the recovery and preservation of marginal donor organs including donation after cardiac death and fatty livers.     

A metabolic index of ischemic injury for perfusion-recovery of cadaveric rat livers

With over 110,000 patients waiting for organ transplantation, the current crisis in organ transplantation is based on a lack of donors after brain-death (DBD). A very large alternative pool of donor organs that remain untapped are the donors after cardiac death (DCD), recovered after cardiac activity has ceased and therefore sustained some ischemic injury. Machine perfusion has been proposed as a novel modality of organ preservation and treatment to render such cadaveric organs, and in particular livers, transplantable. Two key issues that remain unaddressed are how to assess whether a DCD liver is damaged beyond repair, and whether machine perfusion has rendered an injured organ sufficiently viable for transplantation. In this work, we present a metabolic analysis of the transient responses of cadaveric rat livers during normothermic machine perfusion (NMP), and develop an index of ischemia that enables evaluation of the organ ischemic injury level. Further, we perform a discriminant analysis to construct a classification algorithm with >0.98 specificity to identify whether a given perfused liver is ischemic or fresh, in effect a precursor for an index of transplantability and a basis for the use of statistical process control measures for automated feedback control of treatment of ischemic injury in DCD livers. The analyses yield an index based on squared prediction error (SPE) as log(SPE) >1.35 indicating ischemia. The differences between metabolic functions of fresh and ischemic livers during perfusion are outlined and the metabolites that varied significantly for ischemic livers are identified as ornithine, arginine, albumin and tyrosine.     

Preservation methods for kidney and liver

With the successful testing of the immunosuppressive effects of cyclosporine in transplant patients in 1978, the field of organ transplants began an exponential growth. With that, the field of organ preservation became increasingly important as the need to increase preservation time and improve graft function became paramount. However, for every patient that receives a transplanted organ, there are four more on the waiting list. In addition, a patient dies from the lack of a transplant almost every 1½ hour. To alleviate this donor crisis, there is a need to expand the donor pool to marginal donor organs. The main reason these organs are underutilized is because the current method of static preservation, simple cold storage, is ineffective. This article will provide a general review of the methods of preservation including simple cold storage, hypothermic machine perfusion, normothermic machine perfusion, and oxygen persufflation. In addition, the article will provide a review of how these dynamic preservation methods have improved the recovery and preservation of marginal donor organs including Donation after Cardiac Death and Fatty livers.     

Characteristics of protein-carbohydrate interactions as a basis for developing novel carbohydrate-based antirejection therapies

The relative shortage of human organs for transplantation is today the major barrier to a broader use of transplantation as a means of treating patients with end-stage organ failure. This barrier could be partly overcome by an increased use of blood group ABO-incompatible live donors, and such trials are currently underway at several transplant centres. If xenotransplantation can be used clinically in the future, the human organ shortage will, in principle, be eradicated. In both these cases, carbohydrate antigens and the corresponding anti-carbohydrate antibodies are the major primary immunological barriers to overcome. Refined carbohydrate-based therapeutics may permit an increased number of ABO-incompatible transplantations to be carried out, and may remove the initial barriers to clinical xenotransplantation. Here, we will discuss the chemical characteristics of protein-carbohydrate interactions and outline carbohydrate-based antirejection therapies as used today in experimental as well as in clinical settings. Novel mucin-based adsorbers of natural anti-carbohydrate antibodies will also be described.