Ir gene control of immune responses to insulins. II. Phenotypic differences in T cell activity among nonresponder strains of mice

Immune responses by mice to heterologous insulins are controlled by H-2 linked Ir genes. In studies to determine the mechanisms responsible for nonresponsiveness, we found that although pork insulin failed to stimulate antibody or proliferative responses in H-2b mice, it did prime T cells that can express helper activity in adoptive recipient mice. This helper activity was insulin-specific in both elicitation and expression. In studies presented in this paper, we have extended this analysis to the response patterns of helper T cells stimulated by sheep, horse, and rat insulins in mice bearing different H-2 haplotypes. The results demonstrate that nonresponder forms of insulin, including rat insulin, prime T cells in H-2b and H-2d, but not H-2k, mice. These results suggest that regulation of nonresponsiveness to insulin appears to be through different pathways in mice bearing different H-2 haplotypes.     

Genetic control of immune response to sperm whale myoglobin in mice. I. T lymphocyte proliferative response under H-2-linked Ir gene control.

Studies on the genetic control of immune response to sperm whale myoglobin were initiated. As demonstrated in this paper, the T lymphocyte proliferative response to whale myoglobin is under H-2-linked Ir gene control. Mice of H-2d, H-2f, and H-2s haplotypes were high responders to the myoglobin, whereas haplotypes H-2b, H-2k, H-2p, H-2q, and H-2r were low responders. The Ir gene(s) was localized between H-2K and H2D regions, since the recombinant strain A.TL (KsIkSkDd) was a low responder and A.TH (KsIsSsDd) was a high responder. Further studies with recombinant strains revealed that the expression of the high-responder I-Ad or Ias alleles was sufficient to give a good response, since strains D2.GD (d d b b b b b b) and B10.HTT (s s s s k k k d) were high responders. The expression of the I-Cd allele in strains B10.A (k k k k k d d d) and B10.A(5R) (b b b k k d d d) also gave high response, and thus suggested a second Ir gene, derived from the H-2d haplotype. The finding that expression of the I-Cs allele in B10.S(8R) (k k ? ? s s s s) did not result in high response suggests the lack of the second Ir gene in the high-responder H-2s haplotype.     

MHC-linked Ir gene control of T cell responses: GAT-specific proliferating T cells and helper T cells are elicited in nonresponder mice immunized with soluble GAT

The immune response to the synthetic terpolymer GAT is controlled by MHC-linked Ir gene(s). We show in this paper that antigen-presenting cells and T cells from mice belonging to two nonresponder strains (SJL and DBA/1) can present and recognize GAT, respectively. This has been measured with a T cell proliferation assay of GAT-primed lymph node cells. In order to detect T cell proliferation among GAT-primed lymph node cells from DBA/1 mice, it is necessary to treat the cells with monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibodies and complement (C) before the assay. These conclusions were further verified with SJL mice, when a T cell line derived from LN cells was used. We have shown that after immunization with GAT, specific T helper cells can be generated in the lymph nodes of SJL mice but not in the lymph nodes of DBA/1 mice. Furthermore, GAT-specific T helper cells can be detected in the spleen of SJL mice after immunizations with GAT, provided these spleen cells are pretreated with monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibodies + C or mild irradiation. Together, these results support the general idea that nonresponsiveness can be explained by a regulatory imbalance rather than by discrete cellular "defects."     

T cell-independent responses to an Ir gene-controlled antigen. I. Characteristics of the immune response to insulin complexed to Brucella abortus

Immune responses by mice to heterologous insulins are controlled by H-2-linked Ir genes. Antibody responses to insulin are T cell dependent (TD), and nonresponder mice fail to make detectable insulin-specific antibodies. To further analyze the role of T cells in regulation of immune responses to insulin, we have developed a method for induction of insulin-specific B cells in the relative absence of T cells. Insulin has been chemically coupled to the T cell-independent (TI) organism Brucella abortus (insulin-BA). Studies reported here demonstrate that in terms of kinetics of responses, isotype expression, and induction of responses in X-linked immunodeficient mice, insulin-BA behaves as a typical type-1 TI antigen. Despite these characteristic features, T cells appear to augment the response to insulin-BA. More importantly, insulin-BA stimulates IgM and IgG anti-insulin antibodies in all strains tested regardless of whether the mice were responders or nonresponders to the particular insulin tested. Thus insulin-BA should be a useful antigen for dissecting the cell interactions required for development of insulin-specific immunity.     

Two distinct mechanisms account for the immune response (Ir) gene control of the T cell response to pigeon cytochrome c

Previous experiments have demonstrated that the immune response of MHC congenic mice to pigeon cytochrome c is under Ir gene control. Expression of I-E-encoded gene products influences both the magnitude and fine specificity of the Th cell response to pigeon cytochrome c and phylogenetic derivatives. Results of those experiments implicate both determinant selection and repertoire selection as mechanisms of Ir gene control in this system. In this report we have compared the TCR expressed in pigeon cytochrome c-reactive Th cells from B10.A(I-Ek), B10.A(5R) (I-Eb), and B10.S(9R) (I-Es) mice. The B10.A(5R) strain is a low responder to pigeon cytochrome c, but in response to moth cytochrome c this strain produces T cells which respond to pigeon or moth cytochrome c on B10.A APC. These cells are phenotypically identical to the predominant clonal phenotype seen in the B10.A response to pigeon cytochrome c. In this report, we show that the B10.A and B10.A(5R) pigeon cytochrome c-reactive T cells express essentially identical T cell receptors. These results, coupled with recent studies reporting a relatively low affinity for I-Eb molecules by pigeon cytochrome c peptides compared with moth cytochrome c peptides, strongly argue that the immune response defect in the B10.A(5R) strain is due to a defect in Ag presentation (determinant selection). In contrast, B10.A and B10.S(9R) strains are high responders to pigeon cytochrome c. Both strains produce T cell clones which are capable of responding to cytochrome c presented by either B10.A or B10.S(9R) APC in vitro. We show that, even in T cells with this MHC restriction degeneracy, the TCR expressed in the two strains are different. Because the APC of both strains can clearly present the cytochrome c Ag, we conclude that the differential expression of the TCR in the responses is due to a T cell repertoire selection difference in the two strains. Thus, for the response to one Ag in three MHC congenic strains, there exists evidence that both determinant selection and repertoire selection can be mechanisms of Ir gene control of an immune response.     

Lack of Ir gene control in the immune response to malaria. I. A thymus-independent antibody response to the repetitive surface protein of sporozoites

The anamnestic antibody response to synthetic peptide antimalarial vaccines is under Ir gene control. It has therefore been inferred that the development of antibody responses to the native repetitive Ag of malaria parasites also requires linkage of T and B cell epitopes, presentation of Ag in the context of MHC class II components, and cognate T cell help for antibody production. In this study, we sought to test this assumption, by utilizing classical protocols to determine whether the antibody response to the repetitive surface Ag of malaria sporozoites, the circumsporozoite (CS) protein, is under Ir gene control. In contrast to vaccine constructs, such as recombinant proteins or synthetic peptides, secondary responses to the repetitive oligomeric domains of the native CS protein of intact malaria sporozoites do not require the presence of Ag-specific Th cells. Conferral of CS-specific Th cells does not appear to influence the magnitude of this thymus-independent response to sporozoites. In further contrast to synthetic CS analogs, exposure to the parasite appears to be associated with low levels of Ag-specific Th cell sensitization. These observations suggest a functional role in immune evasion for the immunodominant repetitive domains found within protein Ag of malaria and other parasites.     

H-2 linked Ir gene control of antibody responses to porcine insulin. I. Development of insulin-specific antibodies in some but not all nonresponder strains injected with proinsulin

Cell-mediated and humoral immune responses to heterologous insulins in mice are controlled by H-2 linked, dominant, immune response (Ir) genes. For example, mice bearing the H-2d haplotype develop T cell proliferative responses and produce antibody after injection with porcine insulin, whereas mice bearing other H-2 haplotypes do not. Data presented in this communication demonstrate that homozygous and heterozygous H-2d mice produce insulin-binding antibodies when immunized with porcine insulin or proinsulin. Some (H-2b,k,s) insulin-nonresponder mice produce insulin-binding antibodies after injection of proinsulin, whereas other insulin-nonresponder strains (H-2q) do not. All strains, except homozygous H-2q mice, produce antibodies specific for proinsulin, suggesting that the response to porcine proinsulin is also controlled by H-2-linked Ir genes. More importantly, F1 hybrids between insulin-nonresponder C57BL/10 (H-2b) and DBA/1 (H-2q) produce no insulin-binding antibodies when injected with proinsulin, despite the fact that proinsulin-binding antibodies are produced by these mice.     

RT1-Linked Ir and Is genes control the immune response to bovine insulin in the rat

The immune response to bovine or pork insulin (BI or PI, respectively) was studied in the rat using the in vitro insulin-induced lymphocyte-proliferation assay. Results indicated that 11 inbred rat strains were divided into categories of high and low responders. Two high responders, SDJ (RT1 ^u) and BN(RT1 ⁿ) inbred rat strains, appeared to recognize different antigenic determinant(s) on the insulin molecule. The results of linkage and segregation analyses in F₁, F₂, backcross, and partially congenic rats showed that the Ir gene (Ir-BI), which encodes the high responsiveness in the SDJ rats, is inherited associated with RT1 ^u, whereas the immune suppression gene (Is-BI), which encodes the low responsiveness in the WKA(_RT1 ^k) rats, is inherited together with RT1 ^k. The Is-BI is the first major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-linked Is gene reported in the rat. The LEJ(RTI-A ^u B ^b) inbred rat strain showed a low response to BI, indicating that Ir-BI is closer to RTI-B/RTI-D region than to RTI-A.Abbreviations used in this paper BI bovine insulin - HEPES N-2-hydroxyethylpiperazine-N-2-ethanesulfonic acid - It immune response - Is immune suppression - MHC major histocompatibility complex - mol. wt. molecular weight - PI pork insulin - sc subcutaneously - SD standard deviation - SI stimulation index     

T cells from nonresponder mice. MHC restricted and unrestricted recognition of insulin

Two types of insulin-reactive T cell hybridomas expressing TCR-alpha beta were derived from nonresponder H-2b mice immunized with pork insulin. One type had characteristics of conventional class II-restricted Th cells. These CD4+ CD8- I-Ab-restricted T cells recognized a self determinant, present within the insulin B-chain. This determinant was distinct from the immunodominant A-chain loop determinant that is recognized by the majority of T cells induced after immunization with normally immunogenic beef insulin. Our results suggest that this determinant is readily generated during immunologic processing of insulins, including nonimmunogenic pork insulin and self insulin. A second type of T cell lacking CD4 and CD8 recognized a distinct B-chain determinant of insulin in a class II-dependent, but MHC unrestricted, fashion. These cells may represent a novel subpopulation which has bypassed conventional selection during development in the thymus.     

Genetic control of experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis in mice. I. Lymphocyte proliferative response to acetylcholine receptors is under H-2-linked Ir gene control.

As a first step in determining the genetic control of experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis in mice, we tested the proliferative responses of lymph node cells to torpedo acetylcholine receptors (TAR). Studies with congenic and recombinant inbred strains of mice revealed that T-cell responses to TAR are controlled by an H-2 linked Ir gene, mapping in the I-A subregion of mouse major histocompatibility complex.     

Ir gene control of the cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to Sendai virus: H-2k mice are low responders to Sendai

H-2k mice generate a secondary in vitro cytotoxic T lymphocyte response to Sendai virus 20- to 100-fold weaker than those of other haplotypes tested (H-2b,d,q,s). This immune response defect maps to both H-2K and H-2D. H-2k x H-2d F1 mice (responder x nonresponder) only lyse targets that have the d allele at H-2K and/or H-2D. H-2k targets are equally lysable with anti-Sendai antibody. Furthermore, H-2k mice demonstrate normal antibody and T cell proliferation responses to Sendai virus. The Ir gene defect therefore appears to be limited to the generation of the cytotoxic T lymphocytes.     

Immune response gene control of determinant selection. II. Genetic control of the murine T lymphocyte proliferative response to insulin.

The genetic control of the murine T cell proliferative response to insulin was examined. It was found for two responder strains of mice that each recognizes a different determinant on the insulin molecule. H-2b mice recognize a determinant in the A chain loop of insulin whereas H-2d mice recognize a determinant that resides in the B chain, possibly in the last eight amino acids. Using H-2 recombinant strains of mice, the location of Ir gene control of the response to both determinants was mapped to the K region and/or I-A subregion of H-2. The possibility of non-MHC regulation of MHC-controlled immune responses is suggested by studies of recombinant inbred strains of mice.     

Variation in T cell responses to ovalbumin in cattle: evidence for Ir gene control

Genetic control of immune responsiveness in cattle was investigated using an antigen-dependent T cell proliferation assay in vitro. Bovine T cell proliferative responses to ovalbumin were dependent upon major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules. Responses of an unrelated panel of animals to a limiting concentration of ovalbumin after a single immunization were compared. Two discrete patterns of response were observed. One group of animals had low or non-responses which were not significantly different from the preimmune levels. Another group of animals showed significant responses. After a second immunization the majority of low responders remained low responders. There was no significant correlation between bovine MHC class I BoLA haplotype and magnitude of response within this group of unrelated animals. However, the magnitude of the T cell responses by two half-sib family groups segregated with BoLA haplotypes inherited from the sire. In contrast no significant correlation with antibody responses in vivo could be demonstrated. We suggest that the observed variation in T cell response is linked to bovine MHC class II immune response (Ir) genes.     

Haplotype-specific suppression of T cell response to lactate dehydrogenase B in (responder x nonresponder)F1 mice

Mouse strains that express the Ek (Ek beta E-1k alpha) molecule are nonresponders (NR) to the enzyme lactate dehydrogenase B (LDHB) in terms of T cell proliferation. Nonresponsiveness is caused by T suppressor (Ts) cells recognizing LDHB in the context of Ek molecules on the antigen-presenting cells. The data presented here demonstrate that the Ek-restricted Ts cells function in (R x NR)F1 mice in a remarkable haplotype-specific fashion: they selectively interfere with the Ak (ANR)-restricted response, and do not affect the response channeled through the A molecules of the responder parent. This haplotype-specificity of suppression provides an explanation of the dominance of responsiveness in (R x NR)F1 mice.     

Ir gene defects may reflect a regulatory imbalance. I. Helper T cell activity revealed in a strain whose lack of response is controlled by suppression.

A singular responsiveness to HEL was revealed in a peripheral lymphoid compartment of the genetically nonresponsive H-2b mouse. Although i.p. injection of HEL induces suppression and a lack of anti-HEL production, following footpad injection there is an early emergence in the popliteal lymph node (P-LN) of HEL-specific helper activity and plaque-forming cells. Furthermore, the early P-LN transiently expresses one of two T cell types needed for initiation of suppression. Delayed recruitment of the second required cell-type permits the induction of efficient suppression. There is only a short period during which there is concurrent representation of the two T cell subpopulations, and by mixing early and late deficient P-LN T cells, suppression could be established. The general implication of these results is that although a vigorous helper cell potential may exist in a strain nonresponsive to a multideterminant antigen, it can be obscured by a regulatory cell imbalance that results in the manifestation of a generalized Ir gene "defect."