Isothermal titration calorimetry of RNA

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is a fast and robust method to study the physical basis of molecular interactions. A single well-designed experiment can provide complete thermodynamic characterization of a binding reaction, including K(a), DeltaG, DeltaH, DeltaS and reaction stoichiometry (n). Repeating the experiment at different temperatures allows determination of the heat capacity change (DeltaC(P)) of the interaction. Modern calorimeters are sensitive enough to probe even weak biological interactions making ITC a very popular method among biochemists. Although ITC has been applied to protein studies for many years, it is becoming widely applicable in RNA biochemistry as well, especially in studies which involve RNA folding and RNA interactions with small molecules, proteins and with other RNAs. This review focuses on best practices for planning, designing and executing effective ITC experiments when one or more of the reactants is an RNA.     

Applications of isothermal titration calorimetry in protein science

During the past decade, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) has developed from a specialist method for understanding molecular interactions and other biological processes within cells to a more robust, widely used method. Nowadays, ITC is used to investigate all types of protein interactions, including protein-protein interactions, protein-DNA/RNA interactions, protein-small molecule interactions and enzyme kinetics; it provides a direct route to the complete thermodynamic characterization of protein interactions. This review concentrates on the new applications of ITC in protein folding and misfolding, its traditional application in protein interactions, and an overview of what can be achieved in the field of protein science using this method and what developments are likely to occur in the near future. Also, this review discusses some new developments of ITC method in protein science, such as the reverse titration of ITC and the displacement method of ITC.     

Thermodynamics of coupled folding in the interaction of archaeal RNase P proteins RPP21 and RPP29

We have used isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to identify and describe binding-coupled equilibria in the interaction between two protein subunits of archaeal ribonuclease P (RNase P). In all three domains of life, RNase P is a ribonucleoprotein complex that is primarily responsible for catalyzing the Mg2?-dependent cleavage of the 5' leader sequence of precursor tRNAs during tRNA maturation. In archaea, RNase P has been shown to be composed of one catalytic RNA and up to five proteins, four of which associate in the absence of RNA as two functional heterodimers, POP5-RPP30 and RPP21-RPP29. Nuclear magnetic resonance studies of the Pyrococcus furiosus RPP21 and RPP29 proteins in their free and complexed states provided evidence of significant protein folding upon binding. ITC experiments were performed over a range of temperatures, ionic strengths, and pH values, in buffers with varying ionization potentials, and with a folding-deficient RPP21 point mutant. These experiments revealed a negative heat capacity change (ΔC(p)), nearly twice that predicted from surface accessibility calculations, a strong salt dependence for the interaction, and proton release at neutral pH, but a small net contribution from these to the excess ΔC(p). We considered potential contributions from protein folding and burial of interfacial water molecules based on structural and spectroscopic data. We conclude that binding-coupled protein folding is likely responsible for a significant portion of the excess ΔC(p). These findings provide novel structural and thermodynamic insights into coupled equilibria that allow specificity in macromolecular assemblies.     

Thermodynamics of ion-induced RNA folding in the hammerhead ribozyme: an isothermal titration calorimetric study

The hammerhead ribozyme undergoes a well-defined two-stage conformational folding process, induced by the binding of magnesium ions. In this study, we have used isothermal titration calorimetry to analyze the thermodynamics of magnesium binding and magnesium ion-induced folding of the ribozyme. Binding to the natural sequence ribozyme is strongly exothermic and can be analyzed in terms of sequential interaction at two sites with association constants K(A) = 480 and 2840 M(-1). Sequence variants of the hammerhead RNA give very different isothermal titration curves. An A14G variant that cannot undergo ion-induced folding exhibits endothermic binding. By contrast, a deoxyribose G5 variant that can undergo only the first of the two folding transitions gives a complex titration curve. However, despite these differences the ITC data for all three species can be analyzed in terms of the sequential binding of magnesium ions at two sites. While the binding affinities are all in the region of 10(3) M(-1), corresponding to free energies of Delta G degrees = -3.5 to -4 kcal mol(-1), the enthalpic and entropic contributions show much greater variation. The ITC experiments are in good agreement with earlier conformational studies of the folding of the ion-induced folding of the hammerhead ribozyme.     

RNA chaperone activity and RNA-binding properties of the E. coli protein StpA

The E. coli protein StpA has RNA annealing and strand displacement activities and it promotes folding of RNAs by loosening their structures. To understand the mode of action of StpA, we analysed the relationship of its RNA chaperone activity to its RNA-binding properties. For acceleration of annealing of two short RNAs, StpA binds both molecules simultaneously, showing that annealing is promoted by crowding. StpA binds weakly to RNA with a preference for unstructured molecules. Binding of StpA to RNA is strongly dependent on the ionic strength, suggesting that the interactions are mainly electrostatic. A mutant variant of the protein, with a glycine to valine change in the nucleic-acid-binding domain, displays weaker RNA binding but higher RNA chaperone activity. This suggests that the RNA chaperone activity of StpA results from weak and transient interactions rather than from tight binding to RNA. We further discuss the role that structural disorder in proteins may play in chaperoning RNA folding, using bioinformatic sequence analysis tools, and provide evidence for the importance of conformational disorder and local structural preformation of chaperone nucleic-acid-binding sites.     

The RNA binding site of bacteriophage MS2 coat protein.

The coat protein of the RNA bacteriophage MS2 binds a specific stem-loop structure in viral RNA to accomplish encapsidation of the genome and translational repression of replicase synthesis. In order to identify the structural components of coat protein required for its RNA binding function, a series of repressor-defective mutants has been isolated. To ensure that the repressor defects were due to substitution of binding site residues, the mutant coat proteins were screened for retention of the ability to form virus-like particles. Since virus assembly presumably requires native structure, this approach eliminated mutants whose repressor defects were secondary consequences of protein folding or stability defects. Each of the variant coat proteins was purified and its ability to bind operator RNA in vitro was measured. DNA sequence analysis identified the nucleotide and amino acid substitutions responsible for reduced RNA binding affinity. Localization of the substituted sites in the three-dimensional structure of coat protein reveals that amino acid residues on three adjacent strands of the coat protein beta-sheet are required for translational repression and RNA binding. The sidechains of the affected residues form a contiguous patch on the interior surface of the viral coat.     

Protein solubility and folding enhancement by interaction with RNA

While basic mechanisms of several major molecular chaperones are well understood, this machinery has been known to be involved in folding of only limited number of proteins inside the cells. Here, we report a chaperone type of protein folding facilitated by interaction with RNA. When an RNA-binding module is placed at the N-terminus of aggregation-prone target proteins, this module, upon binding with RNA, further promotes the solubility of passenger proteins, potentially leading to enhancement of proper protein folding. Studies on in vitro refolding in the presence of RNA, coexpression of RNA molecules in vivo and the mutants with impaired RNA binding ability suggests that RNA can exert chaperoning effect on their bound proteins. The results suggest that RNA binding could affect the overall kinetic network of protein folding pathway in favor of productive folding over off-pathway aggregation. In addition, the RNA binding-mediated solubility enhancement is extremely robust for increasing soluble yield of passenger proteins and could be usefully implemented for high-throughput protein expression for functional and structural genomic research initiatives. The RNA-mediated chaperone type presented here would give new insights into de novo folding in vivo.     

Ribosome-DnaK interactions in relation to protein folding

Bacterial ribosomes or their 50S subunit can refold many unfolded proteins. The folding activity resides in domain V of 23S RNA of the 50S subunit. Here we show that ribosomes can also refold a denatured chaperone, DnaK, in vitro, and the activity may apply in the folding of nascent DnaK polypeptides in vivo. The chaperone was unusual as the native protein associated with the 50S subunit stably with a 1:1 stoichiometry in vitro. The binding site of the native protein appears to be different from the domain V of 23S RNA, the region with which denatured proteins interact. The DnaK binding influenced the protein folding activity of domain V modestly. Conversely, denatured protein binding to domain V led to dissociation of the native chaperone from the 50S subunit. DnaK thus appears to depend on ribosomes for its own folding, and upon folding, can rebind to ribosome to modulate its general protein folding activity.     

Molecular recognition via coupled folding and binding in a TPR domain

The majority of known tetratricopeptide repeat (TPR) domains consist of three copies of the helix-turn-helix TPR motif, together with a seventh C-terminal helix. TPR domains function as protein-protein recognition modules in intracellular signalling. This function is exemplified by the TPR domain of protein phosphatase 5 (PP5), which binds to the C terminus of the chaperone protein Hsp90. Here, we report NMR and CD spectroscopic studies that reveal that this domain is largely unfolded at physiological temperatures, and that interaction with an MEEVD pentapeptide derived from Hsp90 stabilises a folded structure. This complex, coupled folding-binding mechanism is characterised further by its observed enthalpy change on binding (determined by isothermal titration calorimetry), which displays a markedly non-linear relationship with temperature. A nested Gibbs-Helmholtz model is used in a novel combined analysis of the CD and ITC data to determine separately the thermodynamic contributions of the intrinsic folding and binding events to the overall coupled process. The analysis shows that, despite the expected large entropic opposition to the folding process, a nearly equal favourable folding enthalpy means the net effect of coupled folding on the observed affinity is small across a broad range of temperature. We hypothesise that a coupled folding-binding mechanism is common in this class of domains.     

Physical nature of signal peptide binding to DmsD

Here we describe the biophysical characterization of the interaction of the redox enzyme maturation protein DmsD with the signal peptide of its target protein, DmsA. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), size exclusion chromatography (SEC), and an in vitro Far-Western assay is used to show that DmsD binds the twin-arginine signal peptide from DmsA in the micromolar range and in a 1:1 molar ratio. The SEC also shows that there is no oligomerization upon binding. Urea and guanidium hydrochloride denaturation profiles demonstrate the stability of DmsD and give insights on how electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions are important within this binding process. Furthermore, by use of N- and C-terminal fusions of DmsA signal peptide to GST, we observe that N-terminal display of the peptide is important for binding DmsD. In addition, all the folding forms of DmsD were found to bind the DmsA signal peptide as observed with the Far-Western assay.     

Making cool drugs hot: isothermal titration calorimetry as a tool to study binding energetics

Characterization of the thermodynamics of binding interactions is important in improving our understanding of bimolecular recognition and forms an essential part of the rational drug design process. Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) is rapidly becoming established as the method of choice for undertaking such studies. The power of ITC lies in its unique ability to measure binding reactions by the detection of the heat change during the binding interaction. Since heat changes occur during many physicochemical processes, ITC has a broad application, ranging from chemical and biochemical binding studies to more complex processes involving enthalpy changes, such as enzyme kinetics. Several features of ITC have facilitated its preferential use compared to other techniques that estimate affinity. It is a sensitive, rapid, and direct method with no requirement for chemical modification or immobilization. It is the only technique that directly measures enthalpy of binding and so eliminates the need for van't Hoff analysis, which can be time consuming and prone to uncertainty in parameter values. Although ITC has facilitated the measurement of the thermodynamics governing binding reactions, interpretation of these parameters in structural terms is still a major challenge.     

Thermodynamic stability of carbonic anhydrase: measurements of binding affinity and stoichiometry using ThermoFluor

ThermoFluor (a miniaturized high-throughput protein stability assay) was used to analyze the linkage between protein thermal stability and ligand binding. Equilibrium binding ligands increase protein thermal stability by an amount proportional to the concentration and affinity of the ligand. Binding constants (K(b)) were measured by examining the systematic effect of ligand concentration on protein stability. The precise ligand effects depend on the thermodynamics of protein stability: in particular, the unfolding enthalpy. An extension of current theoretical treatments was developed for tight binding inhibitors, where ligand effect on T(m) can also reveal binding stoichiometry. A thermodynamic analysis of carbonic anhydrase by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) enabled a dissection of the Gibbs free energy of stability into enthalpic and entropic components. Under certain conditions, thermal stability increased by over 30 degrees C; the heat capacity of protein unfolding was estimated from the dependence of calorimetric enthalpy on T(m). The binding affinity of six sulfonamide inhibitors to two isozymes (human type 1 and bovine type 2) was analyzed by both ThermoFluor and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), resulting in a good correlation in the rank ordering of ligand affinity. This combined investigation by ThermoFluor, ITC, and DSC provides a detailed picture of the linkage between ligand binding and protein stability. The systematic effect of ligands on stability is shown to be a general tool to measure affinity.     

Heat capacity changes associated with DNA duplex formation: salt- and sequence-dependent effects

Duplexes are the most fundamental elements of nucleic acid folding. Although it has become increasingly clear that duplex formation can be associated with a significant change in heat capacity (deltaC(p)), this parameter is typically overlooked in thermodynamic studies of nucleic acid folding. Analogy to protein folding suggests that base stacking events coupled to duplex formation should give rise to a deltaC(p) due to the release of waters solvating aromatic surfaces of nucleotide bases. In previous work, we showed that the deltaC(p) observed by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) for RNA duplex formation depended on salt and sequence [Takach, J. C., Mikulecky, P. J., and Feig, A. L. (2004) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 6530-6531]. In the present work, we apply calorimetric and spectroscopic techniques to a series of designed DNA duplexes to demonstrate that both the salt dependence and sequence dependence of deltaC(p)s observed by ITC reflect perturbations to the same fundamental phenomenon: stacking in the single-stranded state. By measuring the thermodynamics of single strand melting, one can accurately predict the deltaC(p)s observed for duplex formation by ITC at high and low ionic strength. We discuss our results in light of the larger issue of contributions to deltaC(p) from coupled equilibria and conclude that observed deltaC(p)s can be useful indicators of intermediate states in nucleic acid folding phenomena.     

Thermodynamics and folding pathway of tetraloop receptor-mediated RNA helical packing

Little is known about the thermodynamic forces that drive the folding pathways of higher-order RNA structure. In this study, we employ calorimetric [isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)] and spectroscopic (NMR and UV) methods to characterize the thermodynamics of the GAAA tetraloop-receptor interaction, utilizing a previously described bivalent construct. ITC studies indicate that the bivalent interaction is enthalpy driven and highly stable, with a binding constant (K(obs)) of 5.5x10(6) M(-1) and enthalpy (DeltaH(obs)(o)) of -33.8 kcal/mol at 45 degrees C in 20 mM KCl and 2 mM MgCl(2). Thus, we derive the DeltaH(obs)(o) for a single tetraloop-receptor interaction to be -16.9 kcal/mol at these conditions. UV absorbance data indicate that an increase in base stacking quality contributes to the enthalpy of complex formation. These highly favorable thermodynamics are consistent with the known critical role for the tetraloop-receptor motif in the folding of large RNAs. Additionally, a significant heat capacity change (DeltaC(p,obs)(o)) of -0.24 kcal mol(-1) K(-1) was determined by ITC. DSC and UV-monitored thermal denaturation experiments indicate that the bivalent tetraloop-receptor construct follows a minimally five-state unfolding pathway and suggest the observed DeltaC(p,obs)(o) for the interaction results from a temperature-dependent unbound receptor RNA structure.     

Induced fit of RNA on binding the L7Ae protein to the kink-turn motif

The kink-turn is a widespread motif in RNA consisting of a three-nucleotide bulge flanked on one side by consecutive A3G mismatches. Important examples are found in the ribosome, U4 RNA, and in snoRNAs involved in RNA modification. The motif is a common protein binding site, and the RNA has been found to adopt a tightly kinked conformation in crystal structures. However, in free solution there is a dynamic exchange between kinked and extended conformations, with the equilibrium driven toward the kinked form by the addition of metal ions. Here we used fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to show that the L7Ae protein of Archaeoglobus fulgidus binds to RNA containing a kink-turn with nanomolar affinity, and induces folding into the tightly kinked conformation even in the absence of metal ions. Thus this RNA may act as a relatively flexible hinge during RNA folding, until fixed into its ultimate kinked structure by the binding of L7 or related protein.     

Influence of correct secondary and tertiary RNA folding on the binding of cellular factors to the HCV IRES

Structural integrity of the hepatitus C virus (HCV) 5′ UTR region that includes the internal ribosome entry site (IRES) element is known to be essential for efficient protein synthesis. The functional explanation for this observation has been provided by the recent evidence that binding of several cellular factors to the HCV IRES is dependent on the conservation of its secondary structure. In order to better define the relationship between IRES activity, protein binding and RNA folding of the HCV IRES, we have focused our attention on its major stem–loop region (domain III) and the binding of several cellular factors: two subunits of eukaryotic initiation factor eIF3 and ribosomal protein S9. Our results show that binding of eIF3 p170 and p116/p110 subunits is dependent on the ability of the domain III apical stem–loop region to fold in the correct secondary structure whilst secondary structure of hairpin IIId is important for the binding of S9 ribosomal protein. In addition, we show that binding of S9 ribosomal protein also depends on the disposition of domain III on the HCV 5′ UTR, indicating the presence of necessary interdomain interactions required for the binding of this protein (thus providing the first direct evidence that tertiary folding of the HCV RNA does affect protein binding).     

How RNA folds.

We describe the RNA folding problem and contrast it with the much more difficult protein folding problem. RNA has four similar monomer units, whereas proteins have 20 very different residues. The folding of RNA is hierarchical in that secondary structure is much more stable than tertiary folding. In RNA the two levels of folding (secondary and tertiary) can be experimentally separated by the presence or absence of Mg2+. Secondary structure can be predicted successfully from experimental thermodynamic data on secondary structure elements: helices, loops, and bulges. Tertiary interactions can then be added without much distortion of the secondary structure. These observations suggest a folding algorithm to predict the structure of an RNA from its sequence. However, to solve the RNA folding problem one needs thermodynamic data on tertiary structure interactions, and identification and characterization of metal-ion binding sites. These data, together with force versus extension measurements on single RNA molecules, should provide the information necessary to test and refine the proposed algorithm.     

Structural basis for the self-chaperoning function of an RNA collapsed state

Prior to folding to a native functional structure, many large RNAs form conformationally collapsed states. Formation of the near-native collapsed state for the bI5 group I intron RNA plays an obligatory role in self-chaperoning assembly with its CBP2 protein cofactor by preventing formation of stable, misassembled complexes. We show that the collapsed state is essential because CBP2 assembles indiscriminately with the bI5 RNA in any folding state to form long-lived complexes. The most stable protein interaction site in the expanded state-CBP2 complex overlaps, but is not identical to, the native site. Folding to the collapsed state circumvents two distinct misassembly events: inhibitory binding by multiple equivalents of CBP2 and formation of bridged complexes in which CBP2 straddles cognate and noncognate RNAs. Strikingly, protein-bound sites in the expanded state RNA complex are almost the inverse of native RNA-RNA and RNA-protein interactions, indicating that folding to the collapsed state significantly reduces the fraction of RNA surfaces accessible for misassembly. The self-chaperoning function for the bI5 collapsed state is likely to be conserved in other ribonucleoproteins where a protein cofactor binds tightly at a simple RNA substructure or has an RNA binding surface composed of multiple functional sites.