Expression of cell surface antigens by suppressor T cell hybridomas. I. Comparison of phenotype and function

The phenotypic expression of cell surface markers by T cell hybridomas that elaborate suppressor factors specific for the polymers L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT) or L-glutamic acid50-L-tyrosine50 (GT) has been analyzed. We found that determinants encoded by the I-J subregion of the H-2 complex were borne on the surface of these hybrid cells and on the factors they secrete, whereas I-J determinants were not expressed by the AKR thymoma fusion parent, BW5147. The level of expression of I-J determinants fluctuated widely depending upon culture conditions, but I-J products and other cell surface markers of normal T cells could be quantitatively increased, or induced to appear, by treatment of the hybridomas with chemical agents, such as dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or phorbol myristate acetate (PMA). In contrast, the surface expression of the viral product gp70 was decreased by the same treatment. Using chemical induction, we typed BW5147, a group of antigen-specific suppressor T cell hybridomas, and two control hybridomas for expression of I-J, Thy-1, Lyt, and H-2K alloantigens. Also, a haplotype-specific hybridoma that produces an antigen-nonspecific factor was analyzed. The results demonstrated that BW5147 failed to express I-J or Lyt alloantigens but expressed Thy-1.1 and H-2Kk gene products. The pattern of expression of these antigens by T cell hybridomas was very complex, but three conclusions could be drawn: 1) Good correlation exists between the expression of certain I-J determinants and the ability of T cell hybridomas to produce suppressor factor. 2) The expression of Thy-1, Lyt, or H-2Kk determinants is variable, and no correlation was found between expression of these antigens and the ability to produce active suppressor factors. 3) I-Jk products contributed by the AKR thymoma fusion partner are expressed by T cell hybridomas.     

Antigen-specific suppressor T cell interactions. I. Induction of an MHC-restricted suppressor factor specific for L-glutamic acid50-L-tyrosine50

The synthetic polymers L-glutamic acid60-L-alanine30-L-tyrosine10 (GAT) and L-glutamic acid50-L-tyrosine50 (GT) stimulate specific suppressor T cells in certain strains of mice. Extracts from these T cells contain factors (TsF) that inhibit GAT- or GT-specific antibody responses by normal spleen cells or proliferative responses by primed T cells. We constructed T cell hybridomas that constitutively produce GAT-TsF or GT-TsF, which functionally and serologically are identical to factors extracted from suppressor T cells. In this report we demonstrate that monoclonal GT-TsF can induce specific unresponsiveness in vivo or in vitro and that this unresponsiveness is due to development of second-order antigen-specific suppressor T cells. T cell hybridomas were constructed by fusion of BW5147 with GT-TsF1 induced second-order suppressor T cells and clones that produced suppressor factor (GT-TsF2) were isolated and characterized. GT-TsF2 differs from the GT-TsF1 used to induce it in that GT-TsF1 acts across allogeneic barriers whereas GT-TsF2 does not. This restriction is controlled by genes in the H-2 gene complex and maps to the I-J subregion. GT-TsF2 is antigen-specific in suppressive activity and also in its antigen-binding site(s). Thus, GT-TsF2 closely resembles the carrier-specific, I-J+, genetically restricted factor described by Tada and his colleagues. Because GT-TsF2 was induced by GT-TsF1, we suggest cells producing GT-TsF1 are an early cell in the pathway of suppression, and that this cell is required for the activation of antigen-specific, MHC-restricted TsF.     

Insulin-specific suppressor T cell factors

Murine antibody responses to heterologous insulins are controlled by MHC-linked immune response genes. Although nonresponder mice fail to make antibody when injected with nonimmunogenic variants of insulin, we have recently shown that nonimmunogenic variants stimulate radioresistant, Lyt- 1+2- helper T cells that support secondary antibody responses. However, the helper activity can not be detected unless dominant, radiosensitive Lyt-1-2+, I-J+ suppressor T cells are removed. In this paper we report that extracts of primed Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells contain insulin-specific suppressor factors (TsF) that are capable of replacing the activity of suppressor T cells in vitro. The activity of these factors is restricted by MHC-linked genes that map to the I-J region, and immunoadsorption studies indicated that they bind antigen and bear I-J-encoded determinants. Insulin-specific TsF consists of at least two chains, one-bearing I-J and the other the antigen-binding site. Furthermore, mixing of isolated chains from different strains of mice indicates that the antigenic specificity is determined by the antigen-binding chain and the MHC restriction by the H-2 haplotype of the source of the non-antigen-binding, I-J+ chain. Moreover, mixtures containing antigen-binding chain from allogeneic cell donors and I-J+ chain from responder cell donors have activity in cultures containing responder lymphocytes. This suggests that preferential activation of suppressor T cells, rather than differential sensitivity to suppression, results in the nonresponder phenotype to insulin.     

An approach to the unification of suppressor T cell circuits: a simplified assay for the induction of suppression by T cell-derived, antigen-binding molecules (T-ABM)

A system is presented in which the in vitro response to sheep red blood cells (SRBC) can be regulated using antigenic determinants coupled to SRBC and T cell-derived antigen-binding molecules (T-ABM) directed against the coupled determinants. T suppressor-inducer factors (TsiF's) are composed of two molecules, one of which is a T-ABM and one which bears I-J determinants (I-J+ molecule). Using two purified T-ABM which have not previously been shown to have in vitro activity, we produced antigen-specific TsiF's which were capable of inducing the suppression of the anti-SRBC response. Suppression was found to require both the T-ABM and the I-J+ molecule, SRBC conjugated with the antigen for which the T-ABM was specific, and a population of Ly-2+ T cells in the culture. Two monoclonal TsiF (or TsF1) were demonstrated to induce suppression of the anti-SRBC response in this system, provided the relevant antigen was coupled to the SRBC in culture. The results are discussed in terms of the general functions of T-ABM in the immune system. This model will be useful in direct, experimental comparisons of the function of T-ABM and suppressor T cell factors under study in different systems and laboratories.     

Monoclonal antibodies specific for single chain or two chain GAT-specific suppressor factors: production and analysis of in vitro modulating properties

Fusion of spleen cells from rats hyperimmunized with T cell hybridoma derived GAT-specific TsF1 or TsF2 suppressor T cell factors has resulted in the generation of hybridomas secreting monoclonal antibodies reactive with the appropriate GAT-TsF used for immunization, and in several cases, reactive with other GAT-TsF1 and TsF2. The monoclonal anti-TsF1 antibodies are capable of modulating in vitro GAT-specific PFC response in a GAT-specific manner; some suppress responses to GAT directly, whereas others reverse GAT-TsF1-mediated suppression of responses. The monoclonal anti-TsF2 antibodies all reverse suppression but are reactive with combinatorial determinants, I-J+ chains or antigen-binding chains of the GAT-TsF2. The data are discussed in terms of the nature of the determinants recognized by these antibodies as well as the potential uses of these reagents for studying the suppressor T cell pathway and potential relationships between Ts1, Ts2, and T helper cells.     

Information transfer between T cell subsets is directed by I-J+ antigen nonspecific molecules

T cell antigen-specific suppressor factors (TsF) consist of two distinct polypeptide chains: one that binds antigen (ABM) and one that bears I-J region markers (I-J+ chain). We studied the functional role of these two molecules in delivering the biologic message of suppression to its appropriate target cell. Two different biologically active TsF were used in these studies: TsiF, a T suppressor-inducer factor consisting of an ABM secreted by Ly-1 T cells (Ti-ABM) and an I-J+ subfactor secreted by Ly-1 T cells (I-Ji), which initiates the suppressor circuit by inducing an Ly-1,2 T cell; and TseF, a T suppressor-effector factor consisting of an ABM secreted by Ly-2 T cells (Te-ABM) and an I-J+ subfactor secreted by Ly-1 T cells (I-Je), which delivers the biologic message of suppression to the T helper (TH) cell. In both TsF, the ABM and I-J+ chain are noncovalently associated and can be easily separated. Both molecules must be present, however, for biologic activity of the TsF to be manifest. We studied the role of each chain in delivering these biologically active messages by constructing "hybrid" factors made from mixing the ABM from TsiF with I-J+ chains from either TsiF or TseF and determined which of these chains could reconstitute functional TsiF activity. Likewise, we mixed the AMB from TseF with I-J+ chains of TsiF or TseF to determine which I-J+ chain could reconstitute TseF activity. We found that I-J+ chain from TsiF (I-Ji) can reconstitute ABM from TsiF to form a functional TsiF capable of inducing suppression but cannot reconstitute ABM from TseF to form a functional TsiF capable of suppressing the activity of TH cells. Likewise, the addition of I-J+ chain from TseF to ABM from TseF can reconstitute its ability to suppress TH responses, but I-J+ chain from TsiF plus ABM from TseF has no effect on these TH cell responses. We did find, however, that this hybrid TsF composed of the ABM from TseF and the I-J+ chain from TsiF is capable of suppressing the Ly-1,2 Ttrans cell, the cell normally induced by the ABM + I-J+ suppressor inducer complex from T suppressor-inducer cells (TsiF).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Activation of acceptor-suppressor hybridoma with antigen-specific suppressor T cell factor of two-chain type: requirement of the antigen- and the I-J-restricting specificity

The molecular mechanisms of activation of immunoregulatory T cells were characterized by using two complementary suppressor T cell hybridoma systems: the KLH-specific monoclonal suppressor factor (KLH-TsF), and the inducible acceptor-suppressor hybridoma line with anti-idiotypic receptor for KLH-TsF. It was demonstrated that the identity of the KLH specificity and genetic specificity was required for the TsF-acceptor interaction. These specificities were found to be mediated by the two polypeptide chains of TsF: KLH-binding, Ct-bearing heavy chain and I-J+ light chain. These two chains were essential for stimulation of the acceptor hybridoma. The results were also confirmed by the findings that the mixture of the 11S and 13S mRNA translation products reconstituted the active TsF to stimulate the acceptor hybridoma. Furthermore, the genetic restriction observed was found to be mediated by the I-J+ light chain and to be governed by the gene linked to the H-2 complex but not to the Igh genes. The gene controlling the restriction specificity was strongly suggested to be in the intra-H-2 complex, but not outside of the H-2 complex.     

Nonspecific T suppressor factor (nsTsF) cascade in contact sensitivity: nsTsF-1 causes an Ly-1+2- I-A+ immune T cell to produce a second, genetically restricted, nsTsF-2

We studied the mode of action of the nonspecific T suppressor factor (nsTsF-1) made in the picryl (TNP) system when T acceptor cells armed with antigen-specific TsF are triggered by antigen in the context of I-J. This suppressor factor does not inhibit the passive transfer of contact sensitivity directly, as shown by its failure to inhibit passive transfer by immune cells deprived of I-A+ cells. Its immediate target is an immune, antigen-specific, Ly-1+2-, I-A+ T cell. This cell, which may be regarded as a T suppressor effector cell (Ts-eff-2), produces nsTsF-2 when exposed sequentially to nsTsF-1 and antigen. This nsTsF subsequently inhibits the passive transfer of contact sensitivity. The action of nsTsF-2 is MHC genetically restricted. As the nsTsF-2 bears I-A determinant(s), this raises the possibility that it may act by combining with the recognition site for I-A on the T cell that mediates contact sensitivity.     

Murine interstitial nephritis. V. The auto-induction of antigen-specific Lyt-2+ suppressor T cells diminishes the expression of interstitial nephritis in mice with antitubular basement membrane disease

We observed the emergence of an antigen-specific Lyt-2+ suppressor T cell after the i.v. injection of tubular antigen-derivatized lymphocytes into mice already immunized to produce interstitial nephritis. The auto-induction of these suppressor T cells effectively attenuated both the expression of renal injury and a delayed-type hypersensitivity response to tubular antigen. This suppressive effect was also genetically restricted by gene products in I-J and Igh-1. Although this suppressor system had a marked inhibitory effect on the nephritogenic effector cell repertoire, there was no diminution of titers of antibodies to the tubular basement membrane. Our results demonstrate a protective role for antigen-specific suppressor cells in autoimmune renal injury, and the strategy for their induction may have important therapeutic implications for other immune-mediated disorders.     

Isotype-like suppression of T cell-mediated immunity in vivo. II. Suppression of the early component of contact sensitivity by a Ly-2+ T cell-derived suppressor factor that binds to contact sensitivity-initiating, antigen-specific, Ly-1+ T cell-derived factors that are of different antigen specificities

Recognition that delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions, such as contact sensitivity (CS) in mice, are initiated by Ly-1+ T cell-derived, antigen-specific factors has led to identification of a new kind of suppressor T cell that regulates this initiation phase of CS. Regulation by these suppressor T cells is T cell isotype-like in that initiation of DTH of various antigenic specificities is suppressed, whereas, Ly-1+ T cells mediating the antigen/major histocompatibility complex-restricted, classic delayed phase of CS responses are not affected, nor are other T cell activities. This study shows that these isotype-specific suppressor T cells probably act by release of soluble, isotype-specific, suppressor factors. These isotype-specific T cell factors bind to and can be eluted from columns linked with antigen-specific Ly-1+ T cell factors that initiate CS, and are of different antigen specificities. These T cell regulating, anti-isotypic suppressor factors are derived from Lyt-2+ I-J- T cells and suppress CS-initiating T cells, but do not affect the delayed-acting T cells of CS. This is in contrast with antigen-specific T cell suppressor factors that affect the late-acting and not the early-acting T cells of CS. It is suggested that the antigen-binding, CS-initiating, T cell factors, and their regulatory, anti-isotypic T cell factors are, respectively, T cell analogues of immunoglobulin(Ig)E antibody, and IgE-binding factors, that regulate IgE antibody production by IgE+ B cells.     

MHC-linked immune response suppression mediated by T cells bearing I-A-encoded determinants

The immune response to chicken egg-white lysozyme (HEL) is actively and specifically regulated by antigen-specific T cell-mediated suppression in mice bearing the H-2b haplotype; the suppression is therefore MHC-linked. In this report, we propose a possible mechanism for MHC-linked suppression of HEL-helper T cells based on expression of I region-encoded cell surface determinants. We determined whether inhibition of anti-HEL antibody responses correlated with expression of serologically detectable I-A-encoded cell surface determinants by antigen-specific helper, suppressor-inducer, or suppressor-effector T cells. It was observed that HEL-suppressor-effector T cells, but not helper or suppressor-inducer T cells, were eliminated after treatment with anti-I-Ab antibody and complement. Furthermore, suppressor-effector T cells co-express Thy-1, Lyt-2, and I-A cell surface antigens. These results raise the possibility that HEL-specific helper T cells become functionally inhibited after recognition of HEL and I-A alloantigen displayed by suppressor-effector T cells. Thus, the interaction between helper and suppressor T cells may be analogous to the mechanism of T cell-B cell interaction.     

Alloreactive cloned T cell lines. VII. Comparison of the kinetics of IL 2 release stimulated by alloantigen or Con A

Injection of poly(Glu50Tyr50)(GT) into B10.BR (H-2k) mice induces GT-specific suppressor T cells and a T cell-derived suppressor factor (TsF1), which in turn induces a second-order suppressor T cell (TS2). In the present study, we show that B10.BR GT-TSF1 is composed of separate I-Jk and idiotype-bearing chains linked by disulfide bond(s). Functional suppressive activity requires both chains to be in association. Neither chain alone can induce TS2, indicating that both chains must be seen in association and suggesting a single cellular target for the two chains. Experiments designed to interchange I-J-bearing chains of GT-TSF1 derived from different H-2 haplotypes indicate that only the homologous I-J and idiotype-bearing chains can reassociate into a suppressive moiety. These experiments may imply heterogeneity of I-J region gene products.     

Functional equivalence of cryptococcal and haptene-specific T suppressor factor (TsF). I. Picryl and oxazolone-specific TsF, which inhibit transfer of contact sensitivity, also inhibit phagocytosis by a subset of macrophages.

Monoclonal and conventional cryptococcal-specific T suppressor factors (TsF) (also called TsFmp) depress phagocytosis by a subset of macrophages, while picryl- and oxazolone-specific TsF depress the passive transfer of contact sensitivity. This paper shows that these haptene-specific TsF also inhibit phagocytosis by a subset of macrophages and, using this assay, that the anti-haptene TsF resemble the anti-cryptococcal TsF in five respects: (i) the need for reexposure to specific antigen to trigger the release of TsF; (ii) genetic restriction in action; (iii) possession of an antigen-binding site; (iv) expression of I-J determinants; and (v) inactivation by reduction and alkylation. Purification of the anti-picryl TsF by sequential affinity chromatography indicates that the inhibition of phagocytosis is due to the TsF itself and not to a TsF-antigen complex. The TsF inhibits phagocytosis by a direct action as macrophages treated with TsF and exposed to antigen do not release a second factor which inhibits phagocytosis. These results and those of the accompanying paper indicate that the anti-cryptococcal and anti-haptene TsF are functionally equivalent, antigen-specific suppressor factors.     

A primary in vitro antibody assay for antigen-specific T-suppressor factor: cross-suppression of TNP-specific antibody responses by TMA-specific TsF1

We have previously shown that phenyltrimethylammonium (TMA)-specific, first-order suppressor T cells (Ts1) and soluble factors extracted from these cells (TsF1) can suppress delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses. The TsF1, as monitored in the DTH system, was characterized and found to be a single-chain, antigen-binding, I-J+, and Id+ molecule. To monitor TsF1 in an efficient manner, an in vitro antibody system was developed. The studies show that in vitro stimulation of naive A/J spleen cells with the thymic-independent antigen, Brucella abortus, to which TMA and trinitrophenol (TNP) or fluorescein (FL) are coupled (TMA-BA-TNP or TMA-BA-FL), induces significant numbers of anti-TNP or anti-FL plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses. The addition of TMA-specific TsF1 results in the cross-suppression of 30-50% of the total anti-TNP and FL PFC responses. This activity is antigen (TMA) dependent since suppression occurs only when the TMA ligand is present in the culture media. Analysis of the TNP-specific PFC responses in nonsuppressed cultures revealed that 20-35% of the PFC bear the cross-reactive idiotype(s) (CRI) normally associated with anti-TMA antibodies. In cultures containing TMA-TsF1, CRI+PFC are suppressed by 90-100% while the CRI-PFC are suppressed only by 10-30%. Our studies further show that an induction-phase, antigen-binding, CRI+, and I-J+ single-chain factor is responsible for the observed in vitro suppression. The possibility of utilizing this assay to monitor a variety of antigen-specific suppressor factors is discussed.     

Involvement of antigen and I-J determinants in the induction of effector T suppressor cells by immune B cells

Immune B cells induce effector T suppressor cells in vitro. The B cells act as antigen-presenting cells, and express both I-A and I-J determinants. Antigen and I-J determinants are required for the induction of suppressor T cells by immune B cells, but I-A determinants are not. These findings indicate that precursors of suppressor T cells appear to recognize antigen in the context of I-J determinants on the surface of immune B cells.     

Characterization and activity of contrasuppressor T cells induced by type III pneumococcal polysaccharide

Optimally immunogenic amounts of type III pneumococcal polysaccharide (S3) activate a population of contrasuppressor T cells (Tcs), which have been shown to play an important role in the induction of anti-S3 antibody responses. These Tcs belong to a unique T cell subset that has the surface phenotype Lyt 1+2- L3T4- I-J+ I-A+. These Tcs are also cyclophosphamide (Cy)-sensitive and sensitive to antilymphocyte serum (ALS) and mitomycin C. Tcs have antigen-binding receptors, indicating that any interactions of Tcs with B cells or T suppressor cells (Ts) (both of which also have antigen-binding receptors) must be via an antigen bridge rather than an idiotype-anti-idiotype interaction. Tcs are also Igh restricted in their action. Contrasuppression is manifest only when the Tcs are Igh compatible with both the Ts and the responding B cells. Tcs apparently mediate their effects by releasing a soluble factor, since a soluble factor extracted from Tcs is able to abrogate the effects of S3-specific Ts.     

Nonspecific inhibitor of contact sensitivity made by T-acceptor cells: triggering of T cells armed with antigen-specific T-suppressor factor (TsF) requires both occupancy of the major histocompatibility complex recognition site by soluble I-J product and cross-linking of the antigen recognition sites of the TsF

The phenomenon of associative recognition, i.e., the recognition of antigen together with major histocompatibility complex products (MHC) was studied in a model system. T-acceptor cells armed with antigen-specific T-suppressor factor (TsF) released a nonspecific inhibitor of the transfer of contact sensitivity when exposed to antigen together with MHC. The MHC product occurred in a KCl extract of cells and behaved genetically and serologically as I-J. Cells armed with anti-picryl or anti-"oxazolone" TsF could be triggered by the corresponding "bis-picryl-L-lysine" and "bis-oxazolone-L-lysine" together with MHC. This suggested that cross-linking of antigen recognition sites on separate molecules of TsF might be required. To investigate this possibility the bifunctional "mixed" hapten "N alpha-picryl-N epsilon-oxazolone-L-lysine," which is univalent with respect to the picryl and oxazolone haptenic groups, was synthesized. This triggered cells armed with a mixture of anti-picryl and anti-oxazolone TsF but not cells armed with either TsF alone. It was concluded that both occupancy of the I-J recognition site and the cross-linking of separate molecules of TsF was required for triggering. Moreover the hapten and the KCl extract could be given sequentially and in either order. This finding suggested that the triggering of the release of nonspecific inhibitor was due to the separate recognition of I-J and antigen and not to new antigenic determinants produced by their interaction.     

Functional analysis of cloned macrophage hybridomas. V. Induction of suppressor T cell responses

It has been suggested that macrophage-like accessory cells are involved in suppressor T cell (Ts) induction. To further analyze this issue, we obtained several cloned macrophage hybridoma cell lines by somatic cell fusion of the macrophage tumor P388D1 of DBA/2 (H-2d) origin with splenic adherent cells of CKB mice (H-2k). Several cloned lines displayed the serological and functional characteristics of macrophages. We evaluated the ability of these hybridomas to induce third order or effector Ts (Ts3) to suppress the contact sensitivity response against the hapten 4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl acetyl (NP). In contrast to the parental P388D1 and two other macrophage hybridomas, one macrophage hybridoma clone, termed 63, when conjugated with NP, induced Ts3, which suppressed contact sensitivity responses against NP but not DNFB, showing that the Ts3 were antigen specific. Macrophage hybridoma 63 could specifically induce Ts3 activity in either H-2k, H-2d, or H-2k/H-2d heterozygous hosts. Thus, macrophage hybridoma 63 functionally expressed major histocompatibility complex-related restricting determinants, and the fusion with cells from a H-2k macrophage donor caused a functional complementation of H-2d-related, Ts-inducing elements. The genetic restriction governing induction of Ts3 was controlled by genes that mapped to I-J region. Furthermore, NP-conjugated macrophage hybridoma 63 could serve as a target for elicitation of suppressor responses after administration of I-Jk, but not I-Jb, restricted suppressor factor. The data suggest that macrophage hybridomas represent a means to dissect heterogeneity within the macrophage population. The data also imply that the I-J determinants expressed on macrophages represent a ligand for the antigen receptor of Ts.     

Regulation of the immune response to tumor antigen. IV. Tumor antigen-specific suppressor factor(s) bear I-J determinants and induce suppressor T cells in vivo.

The nature and function of suppressor factor(s) elaborated by suppressor T cells in response to certain chemically induced tumors have been further defined. Thus, suppressor factor(s) specific for the S1509a methylchol-anthrene-induced fibrosarcoma have been shown to bear determinants encoded by the I-J subregion of the murine MHC since suppressive activity is removed by passage of the factor through an immunoadsorbent composed of anti-I-Jk coupled to Sepharose. No loss of activity was observed after passage of factor through control columns composed of normal mouse globulin. Furthermore, activity could be recovered from the relevant immunoadsorbent by elution with high salt. The administration of crude suppressor factor(s) to normal animals for 4 days resulted in the development of a population of suppressor cells that act in a manner analogous to the suppressor cell population used for production of factor. These factor-induced suppressor cells are T cells and exhibit an antigen specificity similar to that displayed by the tumor-induced suppressor cells. Thus, tumor-specific suppressor factor(s) bear I-J determinants and are capable of inducing the appearance of suppressor T cells in the nontumor-bearing host, which may then act in a specific manner to limit host responsiveness to tumor antigen.