Alkylsulfonates activate the uncoupling protein UCP1: implications for the transport mechanism

Fatty acids activate the uncoupling protein UCP1 by a still controversial mechanism. Two models have been put forward where the fatty acid operates as either substrate ("fatty acid cycling hypothesis") or prosthetic group ("proton buffering model"). Two sets of experiments that should help to discriminate between the two hypothetical mechanisms are presented. We show that undecanosulfonate activates UCP1 in respiring mitochondria under conditions identical to those required for the activation by fatty acids. Since alkylsulfonates cannot cross the lipid bilayer, these experiments rule out the fatty acid cycling hypothesis as the mechanism of uncoupling. We also demonstrate that without added nucleotides and upon careful removal of endogenous fatty acids, brown adipose tissue (BAT) mitochondria from cold-adapted hamsters respire at the full uncoupled rate. Addition of nucleotides lower the respiratory rate tenfold. The high activity observed in the absence of the two regulatory ligands is an indication that UCP1 displays an intrinsic proton conductance that is fatty acid-independent. We propose that the fatty acid uncoupling mediated by other members of the mitochondrial transporter family probably involves a carrier to pore transition and therefore has little in common with the activation of UCP1.     

Structure-function relationships in UCP1, UCP2 and chimeras: EPR analysis and retinoic acid activation of UCP2.

Uncoupling proteins (UCPs) are composed of three repeated domains of approximately 100 amino acids each. We have used chimeras of UCP1 and UCP2, and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR), to investigate domain specific properties of these UCPs. Questions include: are the effects of nucleotide binding on proton transport solely mediated by amino acids in the third C-terminal domain, and are the amino acids in the first two domains involved in retinoic or fatty acid activation? We first confirmed that our reconstitution system produced UCP1 that exhibited known properties, such as activation by fatty acids and inhibition of proton transport by purine nucleotides. Our results confirm the observations reported for recombinant yeast that retinoic acid, but not fatty acids known to activate UCP1, activates proton transport by UCP2 and that this activation is insensitive to nucleotide inhibition. We constructed chimeras in which the last domains of UCP1 or UCP2 were switched and tested for activation by fatty acids or retinoic acid and inhibition by nucleotides. U1U2 is composed of mUCP1 (amino acids 1-198) and hUCP2 (amino acids 211-309). Fatty acids activated proton transport of U1U2 and GTP mediated inhibition. In the other chimeric construct U2U1, hUCP2 (amino acids 1-210) and mUCP1 (amino acids 199-307), retinoic acid still acted as an activator, but no inhibition was observed with GTP. Using EPR, a method well suited to the analysis of the structure of membrane proteins such as UCPs, we confirmed that UCP2 binds nucleotides. The EPR data show large structural changes in UCP1 and UCP2 on exposure to ATP, implying that a putative nucleotide-binding site is present on UCP2. EPR analysis also demonstrated changes in conformation of UCP1/UCP2 chimeras following exposure to purine nucleotides. These data demonstrate that a nucleotide-binding site is present in the C-terminal domain of UCP2. This domain was able to inhibit proton transport only when fused to the N-terminal part of UCP1 (chimera U1U2). Thus, residues involved in nucleotide inhibition of proton transport are located in the two first carrier motifs of UCP1. While these results are consistent with previously reported effects of the C-terminal domain on nucleotide binding, they also demonstrate that interactions with the N-terminal domains are necessary to inhibit proton transport. Finally, the results suggest that proteins such as UCP2 may transport protons even though they are not responsible for basal or cold-induced thermogenesis.     

Binding of fatty acids to the uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue mitochondria

The uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) is a H(+) carrier which plays a key role in heat generation in brown adipose tissue. The H(+) transport activity of UCP1 is activated by long-chain fatty acids and inhibited by purine nucleotides. While nucleotide binding has been well characterized, the interaction of fatty acid with UCP1 remains unknown. Here I demonstrate the binding of fatty acids by competition with a fluorescent nucleotide probe 2(')-O-dansyl guanosine 5(')-triphosphate (GTP), which has been shown previously to bind at the nucleotide binding site in UCP1. Fatty acids but not their esters competitively inhibit the binding of 2(')-O-dansyl GTP to UCP1. The fatty acid effect was enhanced at higher pH, suggesting the binding of fatty acid anion to UCP1. The inhibition constants K(i) were determined by fluorescence titrations for various fatty acids. Short-chain (C<8) fatty acids display no affinity, whereas medium-chain (C10-14) and unsaturated C18 fatty acids exhibit stronger affinity (K(i)=65 microM, for elaidic acid). This specificity profile agrees with previous functional data obtained in both proteoliposomes and mitochondria, suggesting a possible physiological role of this fatty acid binding site.     

Native UCP1 displays simple competitive kinetics between the regulators purine nucleotides and fatty acids

Elucidation of the regulation of uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) activity in its native environment, i.e. the inner membrane of brown-fat mitochondria, has been hampered by the presence of UCP1-independent, quantitatively unresolved effects of investigated regulators on the brown-fat mitochondria themselves. Here we have utilized the availability of UCP1-ablated mice to dissect UCP1-dependent and UCP1-independent effects of regulators. Using a complex-I-linked substrate (pyruvate), we found that UCP1 can mediate a 4-fold increase in thermogenesis when stimulated with the classical positive regulator fatty acids (oleate). After demonstrating that the fatty acids act in their free form, we found that UCP1 increased fatty acid sensitivity approximately 30-fold (as compared with the 1.5-fold increase reported earlier based on nominal fatty acid values). By identifying the UCP1-mediated fraction of the response, we could conclude that the interaction between purine nucleotides (GDP) and fatty acids (oleate) unexpectedly displayed simple competitive kinetics. In GDP-inhibited mitochondria, oleate apparently acted as an activator. However, only a model in which UCP1 is inherently active (i.e."activating" fatty acids cannot be included in the model), where GDP functions as an inhibitor with a K(m) of 0.05 mm, and where oleate functions as a competitive antagonist for the GDP effect (with a K(i) of 5 nm) can fit all of the experimental data. We conclude that, when examined in its native environment, UCP1 functions as a proton (equivalent) carrier in the absence of exogenous or endogenous fatty acids.     

Alkylsulfonates as probes of uncoupling protein transport mechanism. Ion pair transport demonstrates that direct H(+) translocation by UCP1 is not necessary for uncoupling

The mechanism of fatty acid-dependent uncoupling by mitochondrial uncoupling proteins (UCP) is still in debate. We have hypothesized that the anionic fatty acid head group is translocated by UCP, and the proton is transported electroneutrally in the bilayer by flip-flop of the protonated fatty acid. Alkylsulfonates are useful as probes of the UCP transport mechanism. They are analogues of fatty acids, and they are transported by UCP1, UCP2, and UCP3. We show that undecanesulfonate and laurate are mutually competitive inhibitors, supporting the hypothesis that fatty acid anion is transported by UCP1. Alkylsulfonates cannot be protonated because of their low pK(a), consequently, they cannot catalyze electroneutral proton transport in the bilayer and cannot support uncoupling by UCP. We report for the first time that propranolol forms permeant ion pairs with the alkylsulfonates, thereby removing this restriction. Because a proton is transported with the neutral ion pair, the sulfonate is able to deliver protons across the bilayer, behaving as if it were a fatty acid. When ion pair transport is combined with UCP1, we now observe electrophoretic proton transport and uncoupling of brown adipose tissue mitochondria. These experiments confirm that the proton transport of UCP-mediated uncoupling takes place in the lipid bilayer and not via UCP itself. Thus, UCP1, like other members of its gene family, translocates anions and does not translocate protons.     

The conserved regulation of mitochondrial uncoupling proteins: From unicellular eukaryotes to mammals

Uncoupling proteins (UCPs) belong to the mitochondrial anion carrier protein family and mediate regulated proton leak across the inner mitochondrial membrane. Free fatty acids, aldehydes such as hydroxynonenal, and retinoids activate UCPs. However, there are some controversies about the effective action of retinoids and aldehydes alone; thus, only free fatty acids are commonly accepted positive effectors of UCPs. Purine nucleotides such as GTP inhibit UCP-mediated mitochondrial proton leak. In turn, membranous coenzyme Q may play a role as a redox state-dependent metabolic sensor that modulates the complete activation/inhibition of UCPs. Such regulation has been observed for UCPs in microorganisms, plant and animal UCP1 homologues, and UCP1 in mammalian brown adipose tissue. The origin of UCPs is still under debate, but UCP homologues have been identified in all systematic groups of eukaryotes. Despite the differing levels of amino acid/DNA sequence similarities, functional studies in unicellular and multicellular organisms, from amoebae to mammals, suggest that the mechanistic regulation of UCP activity is evolutionarily well conserved. This review focuses on the regulatory feedback loops of UCPs involving free fatty acids, aldehydes, retinoids, purine nucleotides, and coenzyme Q (particularly its reduction level), which may derive from the early stages of evolution as UCP first emerged.     

Activation by retinoids of the uncoupling protein UCP1

The uncoupling protein from brown adipose tissue (UCP1) is a transporter that catalyzes a regulated discharged of the mitochondrial proton gradient. The proton conductance in UCP1 is inhibited by nucleotides and activated by fatty acids. We have recently shown that all-trans-retinoic acid (ATRA) is a high-affinity activator of UCP1. In the present report, we have set to analyze the structural requirements for the ligands that activate UCP1 and particularly the specificity for different retinoids. For this purpose, we have developed a new protocol to determine the activity of UCP1 in respiring yeast mitochondria that can be adapted for high-throughput screenings. Our results evidence differences between the structural requirements for the activation by fatty acids and retinoids. Thus, although all active retinoids must possess a carboxylate, the introduction of additional polar groups renders them inactive. The linear and rigid structure of these molecules suggests the existence of a long hydrophobic binding pocket. We postulate that the access to the retinoid binding site must occur from the lipid bilayer and this could be at the interface between two transmembrane alpha-helices.     

Fatty Acids Change the Conformation of Uncoupling Protein 1 (UCP1)

UCP1 catalyzes proton leak across the mitochondrial inner membrane to disengage substrate oxidation from ATP production. It is well established that UCP1 is activated by fatty acids and inhibited by purine nucleotides, but precisely how this regulation occurs remains unsettled. Although fatty acids can competitively overcome nucleotide inhibition in functional assays, fatty acids have little effect on purine nucleotide binding. Here, we present the first demonstration that fatty acids induce a conformational change in UCP1. Palmitate dramatically changed the binding kinetics of 2′/3′-O-(N-methylanthraniloyl)-GDP, a fluorescently labeled nucleotide analog, for UCP1. Furthermore, palmitate accelerated the rate of enzymatic proteolysis of UCP1. The altered kinetics of both processes indicate that fatty acids change the conformation of UCP1, reconciling the apparent discrepancy between existing functional and ligand binding data. Our results provide a framework for how fatty acids and nucleotides compete to regulate the activity of UCP1.     

Inhibition of mitochondrial UCP1 and UCP3 by purine nucleotides and phosphate

Mitochondrial membrane uncoupling protein 3 (UCP3) is not only expressed in skeletal muscle and heart, but also in brown adipose tissue (BAT) alongside UCP1, which facilitates a proton leak to support non-shivering thermogenesis. In contrast to UCP1, the transport function and molecular mechanism of UCP3 regulation are poorly investigated, although it is generally agreed upon that UCP3, analogous to UCP1, transports protons, is activated by free fatty acids (FFAs) and is inhibited by purine nucleotides (PNs). Because the presence of two similar uncoupling proteins in BAT is surprising, we hypothesized that UCP1 and UCP3 are differently regulated, which may lead to differences in their functions. By combining atomic force microscopy and electrophysiological measurements of recombinant proteins reconstituted in planar bilayer membranes, we compared the level of protein activity with the bond lifetimes between UCPs and PNs. Our data revealed that, in contrast to UCP1, UCP3 can be fully inhibited by all PNs and IC50 increases with a decrease in PN-phosphorylation. Experiments with mutant proteins demonstrated that the conserved arginines in the PN-binding pocket are involved in the inhibition of UCP1 and UCP3 to different extents. Fatty acids compete with all PNs bound to UCP1, but only with ATP bound to UCP3. We identified phosphate as a novel inhibitor of UCP3 and UCP1, which acts independently of PNs. The differences in molecular mechanisms of the inhibition between the highly homologous transporters UCP1 and UCP3 indicate that UCP3 has adapted to fulfill a different role and possibly another transport function in BAT.     

A sequence related to a DNA recognition element is essential for the inhibition by nucleotides of proton transport through the mitochondrial uncoupling protein.

The uncoupling protein (UCP) is uniquely expressed in brown adipose tissue, which is a thermogenic organ of mammals. The UCP uncouples mitochondrial respiration from ATP production by introducing a proton conducting pathway through the mitochondrial inner membrane. The activity of the UCP is regulated: nucleotide binding to the UCP inhibits proton conductance whereas free fatty acids increase it. The similarities between the UCP, the ADP/ATP carrier and the DNA recognition element found in the DNA binding domain of the estrogen receptor suggested that these proteins could share common features in their respective interactions with free nucleotides or DNA, and thus defined a putative 'nucleotide recognition element' in the UCP. This article provides demonstration of the validity of this hypothesis. The putative nucleotide recognition element corresponding to the amino acids 261-269 of the UCP was gradually destroyed, and these mutant proteins were expressed in yeast. Flow cytometry, measuring the mitochondrial membrane potential in vivo, showed increased uncoupling activities of these mutant proteins, and was corroborated with studies with isolated mitochondria. The deletion of the three amino acids Phe267, Lys268 and Gly269, resulted in a mutant where proton leak could be activated by fatty acids but not inhibited by nucleotides.     

Synergy of fatty acid and reactive alkenal activation of proton conductance through uncoupling protein 1 in mitochondria

The kinetics of proton transport through mammalian UCP1 (uncoupling protein 1) expressed in yeast mitochondria were measured. There was little or no UCP1 activity in the absence of added palmitate, but significant activity in its presence. The activator 4-HNE (4-hydroxy-2-nonenal) had little effect when added alone, but significantly enhanced proton conductance in the presence of added palmitate. Activation of the proton conductance of UCP1 was synergistic: proton conductance in the presence of both palmitate and 4-HNE was significantly greater than the sum of the individual effects. Mitochondria from control yeast transformed with empty vector showed no such synergy, showing that synergy is a property of UCP1. Activation by the 4-HNE analogue trans-cinnamate showed essentially the same characteristics as activation by 4-HNE. Mitochondria from brown adipose tissue also showed synergistic activation of GDP-sensitive proton conductance by palmitate and 4-HNE. These results show that reactive alkenals activate the proton conductance of UCP1 more strongly when fatty acids are also added, with implications for both mechanistic and physiological models of UCP1 activation.     

Physiological regulation of the transport activity in the uncoupling proteins UCP1 and UCP2

Brown fat is a thermogenic organ that allows newborns and small mammals to maintain a stable body temperature when exposed to cold. The heat generation capacity is based on the uncoupling of respiration from ATP synthesis mediated by the uncoupling protein UCP1. The first studies on the properties of these mitochondria revealed that fatty acid removal was an absolute prerequisite for respiratory control. Thus fatty acids, that are substrate for oxidation, were proposed as regulators of respiration. However, their ability to uncouple all types of mitochondria and the demonstration that several mitochondrial carriers catalyze the translocation of the fatty acid anion have made them unlikely candidates for a specific role in brown fat. Nevertheless, data strongly argue for a physiological function. First, fatty acids mimic the noradrenaline effects on adipocytes. Second, there exists a precise correlation between fatty acid sensitivity and the levels of UCP1. Finally, fatty acids increase the conductance by facilitating proton translocation, a mechanism that is distinct from the fatty acid uncoupling mediated by other mitochondrial carriers. The regulation of UCP1 and UCP2 by retinoids and the lack of effects of fatty acids on UCP2 or UCP3 are starting to set differences among the new uncoupling proteins.     

Fatty acid activation of the uncoupling proteins requires the presence of the central matrix loop from UCP1

Noradrenaline signals the initiation of brown fat thermogenesis and the fatty acids liberated by the hormone-stimulated lipolysis act as second messengers to activate the uncoupling protein UCP1. UCP1 is a mitochondrial transporter that catalyses the re-entry of protons to the mitochondrial matrix thus allowing a regulated discharge of the proton gradient. The high affinity of UCP1 for fatty acids is a distinct feature of this uncoupling protein. The uncoupling proteins belong to a protein superfamily formed by the mitochondrial metabolite carriers. Members of this family present a tripartite structure where a domain containing two transmembrane helices, linked by a long hydrophilic loop, is repeated three times. Using protein chimeras, where the repeats had been swapped between UCP1 and UCP3, it has been shown that the central third of UCP1 is necessary and sufficient for the response of the protein to fatty acids. We have extended those studies and in the present report we have generated protein chimeras where different regions of the second repeat of UCP1 have been sequentially replaced with their UCP2 counterparts. The resulting chimeras present a progressive degradation of the characteristic bioenergetic properties of UCP1. We demonstrate that the presence of the second matrix loop is necessary for the high affinity activation of UCP1 by fatty acids.     

Regulation of UCP1 and UCP3 in arctic ground squirrels and relation with mitochondrial proton leak.

Uncoupling protein (UCP) 1 (UCP1) catalyzes a proton leak in brown adipose tissue (BAT) mitochondria that results in nonshivering thermogenesis (NST), but the extent to which UCP homologs mediate NST in other tissues is controversial. To clarify the role of UCP3 in mediating NST in a hibernating species, we measured Ucp3 expression in skeletal muscle of arctic ground squirrels in one of three activity states (not hibernating, not hibernating and fasted for 48 h, or hibernating) and housed at 5 degrees C or -10 degrees C. We then compared Ucp3 mRNA levels in skeletal muscle with Ucp1 mRNA and UCP1 protein levels in BAT in the same animals. Ucp1 mRNA and UCP1 protein levels were increased on cold exposure and decreased with fasting, with the highest UCP1 levels in thermogenic hibernators. In contrast, Ucp3 mRNA levels were not affected by temperature but were increased 10-fold during fasting and >3-fold during hibernation. UCP3 protein levels were increased nearly fivefold in skeletal muscle mitochondria isolated from fasted squirrels compared with nonhibernators, but proton leak kinetics in the presence of BSA were unchanged. Proton leak in BAT mitochondria also did not differ between fed and fasted animals but did show classical inhibition by the purine nucleotide GDP. Levels of nonesterified fatty acids were highest during hibernation, and tissue temperatures during hibernation were related to Ucp1, but not Ucp3, expression. Taken together, these results do not support a role for UCP3 as a physiologically relevant mediator of NST in muscle.     

Uncoupling protein 1 affects the yeast mitoproteome and oxygen free radical production

Uncoupling protein 1 (UCP1) is a mitochondrial inner membrane protein that dissipates the proton electrochemical gradient built up by the respiratory chain. Its activity is stimulated by free fatty acids and inhibited by purine nucleotides. Here we investigated how active and regulated recombinant UCP1 expressed in yeast at approximately 1 and approximately 10 microg/mg of total mitochondrial proteins induced changes in the mitochondrial proteome and in oxygen free radical production. Using two-dimensional differential in-gel electrophoresis (2D-DIGE), we found that most of the proteins involved in the response to ectopically expressed UCP1 are related to energy metabolism. We also quantified the cellular H(2)O(2) release in the absence or in the presence of UCP1. Our results suggest that UCP1 has a dual influence on free radical generation. On one side, FFA-activated UCP1 was able to decrease the superoxide anion production, demonstrating that a decrease in the generation of reactive oxygen species is an obligatory outcome of UCP1 activity even in a heterologous context. On the other side, an increase in UCP1 content was concomitant with an increase in the basal release of superoxide anion by mitochondria as a side consequence of the overall increase in oxidative metabolism.     

Role of intrahelical arginine residues in functional properties of uncoupling protein (UCP1)

The functional role of the four intrahelical arginines in uncoupling protein (UCP1) from brown adipose tissue were studied in mutants where they were replaced by noncharged residues. Wild-type and mutant UCP1 were expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. As measured in isolated UCP1, nucleotide binding was largely lost in mutants of R83, R182, and R276 occurring in three repeated domains and common to mitochondrial carrier family, whereas mutation of the UCP typical R91 shows normal binding capacity but > 20-fold lower binding affinity and a near loss of pH dependency of binding. In reconstituted UCP1, fatty acid dependent H(+) transport is retained in all four mutants, but inhibition by nucleotide changes according to the binding ability of UCP1. Cl(-) transport is inhibited only by mutations of arginines in the first domain (R83 and R91). Also in isolated mitochondria H(+) transport and respiration with all four mutants is similar to wt, and inhibition by GDP is found only in R91T. The three "regular" arginines are suggested to influence the nucleotide binding site indirectly via a charge network and the "extra" R91 directly via an ion bond with the previously characterised pH sensor E190. The mutants were also used to assess intrahelical control of UCP1. In the yeast cells expressing UCP1, the aerobic growth could be reduced by fatty acid addition only with the nucleotide insensitive mutants. This demonstrates an intracellular control of UCP1 by nucleotides and fatty acids.     

Dimorphic expression of uncoupling protein-3 in golden hamster harderian gland: effects of castration and testosterone administration

Hamster (Mesocricetus auratus) harderian gland (HG) is a dimorphic orbital gland producing a copious lipid secretion. Two cell-types are present in hamster HG, type I in both sexes, type II only in males. In hamster HGs, we found a marked sexual dichotomy in the expression of uncoupling protein-3 (UCP3), a mitochondrial protein carrier, that probably exports fatty acid anions and fatty acid peroxides from the mitochondrial matrix. Following castration and/or testosterone treatment: (1) UCP3 levels correlated with the type II-cell percentage, not with testosterone levels, (2) in male HGs, UCP3 was comparable to female levels at 30 days post-castration (when the type II-cell percentage had fallen from 50 to 5%), although testosterone was already near zero at 15 days (when neither the type II-cell percentage nor the UCP3 level had fallen), and testosterone-replacement therapy prevented these changes. Testosterone-treated females possessed type II cells and a UCP3 level about twofold higher than in control females. Males displayed more intense UCP3 immunohistochemical positivity in type I HG cells than females. Hence, testosterone may indirectly control UCP3 expression by regulating the gland's morphological and lipid dimorphism. Straight-chain fatty acids [found in alkyl diacylglycerols (ADGs) in males] are oxidized predominantly in mitochondria, branched-chain fatty acids (abundant in ADGs in females) predominantly in peroxisomes, so we speculate that the higher UCP3 expression in males reflects greater fatty acid flux in HG mitochondria. This is supported by our finding that in female (not male) HGs, the peroxisome-rich fraction contained alpha-methylacyl-CoA racemase (AMACR), an enzyme important in the beta-oxidation of branched-chain fatty acids.