Conserved folding pathways of alpha-lactalbumin and lysozyme revealed by kinetic CD, fluorescence, NMR, and interrupted refolding experiments

In this report, it is shown by a combination of stopped-flow CD, fluorescence, and time-resolved NMR studies that the Ca^2 +-induced refolding of bovine α-lactalbumin (BLA) at constant denaturant concentration (4 M urea) exhibits triple-exponential kinetics. In order to distinguish between parallel folding pathways and a strictly sequential formation of the native state, interrupted refolding experiments were conducted. We show here that the Ca^2 +-induced refolding of BLA involves parallel pathways and the transient formation of a folding intermediate on the millisecond timescale. Our data furthermore suggest that the two structurally homologous proteins BLA and hen egg white lysozyme share a common folding mechanism. We provide evidence that the guiding role of long-range interactions in the unfolded state of lysozyme in mediating intersubdomain interactions during folding is replaced in the case of BLA by the Ca^2 +-binding site. Time-resolved NMR spectroscopy, in combination with fast ion release from caged compounds, enables the measurement of complex protein folding kinetics at protein concentrations as low as 100 μM and the concomitant detection of conformational transitions with rate constants of up to 8 s^− 1.     

Effects of macromolecular crowding on protein folding and aggregation

We have studied the effects of polysaccharide and protein crowding agents on the refolding of oxidized and reduced hen lysozyme in order to test the prediction that association constants of interacting macromolecules in living cells are greatly increased by macromolecular crowding relative to their values in dilute solutions. We demonstrate that whereas refolding of oxidized lysozyme is hardly affected by crowding, correct refolding of the reduced protein is essentially abolished due to aggregation at high concentrations of crowding agents. The results show that the protein folding catalyst protein disulfide isomerase is particularly effective in preventing lysozyme aggregation under crowded conditions, suggesting that crowding enhances its chaperone activity. Our findings suggest that the effects of macromolecular crowding could have major implications for our understanding of how protein folding occurs inside cells.     

A kinetic study of the competition between renaturation and aggregation during the refolding of denatured-reduced egg white lysozyme

The recovery of proteins following denaturation is optimal at low protein concentrations. The decrease in yield at high concentrations has been explained by the kinetic competition of folding and "wrong aggregation". In the present study, the renaturation-reoxidation of hen and turkey egg white lysozyme was used as a model system to analyze the committed step in aggregate formation. The yield of renatured protein for both enzymes decreased with increasing concentration in the folding process. In addition, the yield decreased with increasing concentrations of the enzyme in the denatured state (i.e., prior to its dilution in the renaturation buffer). The kinetics of renaturation of turkey lysozyme were shown to be very similar to those of hen lysozyme, with a half-time of about 4.5 min at 20 degrees C. The rate of formation of molecular species that lead to formation of aggregates (and therefore fail to renature) was shown to be rapid. Most of the reaction occurred in less than 5 s after the transfer to renaturation buffer, and after 1 min, the reaction was essentially completed. Yet, by observing the effects of the delayed addition of denatured hen lysozyme to refolding turkey lysozyme, it was shown that folding intermediates become resistant to aggregation only much more slowly, with kinetics indistinguishable from those observed for the appearance of native molecules. The interactions leading to the formation of aggregates were nonspecific and do not involve disulfide bonds. These observations are discussed in terms of possible kinetic and structural aspects of the folding pathway.     

Oxidative refolding of lysozyme assisted by DsbA, DsbC and the GroEL apical domain immobilized in cellulose

Expression of recombinant proteins in Escherichia coli often leads to formation of inclusion bodies (IB). If a recombinant protein contains one or more disulfide bonds, protein refolding and thiol oxidation reactions are required to recover its biological activity. Previous studies have demonstrated that molecular chaperones and foldases assist with the in vitro protein refolding. However, their use has been limited by the stoichiometric amount required for the refolding reaction. In search of alternatives to facilitate the use of these folding biocatalysts in this study, DsbA, DsbC, and the apical domain of GroEL (AD) were fused to the carbohydrate-binding module CBD_Cex of Cellulomonas fimi. The recombinant proteins were purified and immobilized in cellulose and used to assist the oxidative refolding of denatured and reduced lysozyme. The assisted refolding yields obtained with immobilized folding biocatalysts were at least twice of those obtained in the spontaneous refolding, suggesting that the AD, DsbA, and DsbC immobilized in cellulose might be useful for the oxidative refolding of recombinant proteins that are expressed as inclusion bodies. In addition, the spontaneous or assisted refolding kinetics data fitted well (r² > 0.9) to a previously reported lysozyme refolding model. The estimated refolding (k _N) and aggregation (k _A) constants were consistent with the hypothesis that foldases assisted the oxidative refolding of lysozyme by decreasing protein aggregation rather than increasing the refolding rate.     

Cooperative folding of the isolated alpha-helical domain of hen egg-white lysozyme.

Proteins in the alpha-lactalbumin and c-type lysozyme family have been studied extensively as model systems in protein folding. Early formation of the alpha-helical domain is observed in both alpha-lactalbumin and c-type lysozyme; however, the details of the kinetic folding pathways are significantly different. The major folding intermediate of hen egg-white lysozyme has a cooperatively formed tertiary structure, whereas the intermediate of alpha-lactalbumin exhibits the characteristics of a molten globule. In this study, we have designed and constructed an isolated alpha-helical domain of hen egg-white lysozyme, called Lyso-alpha, as a model of the lysozyme folding intermediate that is stable at equilibrium. Disulfide-exchange studies show that under native conditions, the cysteine residues in Lyso-alpha prefer to form the same set of disulfide bonds as in the alpha-helical domain of full-length lysozyme. Under denaturing conditions, formation of the nearest-neighbor disulfide bonds is strongly preferred. In contrast to the isolated alpha-helical domain of alpha-lactalbumin, Lyso-alpha with two native disulfide bonds exhibits a well-defined tertiary structure, as indicated by cooperative thermal unfolding and a well-dispersed NMR spectrum. Thus, the determinants for formation of the cooperative side-chain interactions are located mainly in the alpha-helical domain. Our studies suggest that the difference in kinetic folding pathways between alpha-lactalbumin and lysozyme can be explained by the difference in packing density between secondary structural elements and support the hypothesis that the structured regions in a protein folding intermediate may correspond to regions that can fold independently.     

Statistical optimization and multiple objective programming of lysozyme refolding catalyzed by recombinant DsbA in vitro

DsbA (disulfide bond formation protein A) is essential for disulfide bond formation directly affecting the nascent peptides folding to the correct conformation in vivo. In this paper, recombinant DsbA protein was employed to catalyze denatured lysozyme refolding and inhibit the aggregation of folding intermediates in vitro. Statistical methods, i.e., Plackett–Burman design and small central composite design, were adopted to screen out important factors affecting the refolding process and correlating these parameters with the refolding efficiency including both protein recovery and specific activity of refolded lysozyme. Four important parameters: initial lysozyme concentration, urea concentration, KCl concentration and GSSG (glutathione disulfide) concentration were picked out and operating conditions were optimized by introducing the effectiveness coefficient method and transforming the multiple objective programming into an ordinary constrained optimization issue. Finally, 99.7% protein recovery and 25,600 U/mg specific activity of lysozyme were achieved when 281.35 μg/mL denatured lysozyme refolding was catalyzed by an equivalent molar of DsbA at the optimal settings. The results indicated that recombinant DsbA protein could effectively catalyze the oxidized formation and reduced isomerization of intramolecular disulfide bonds in the refolding of lysozyme in vitro.     

The oxidative refolding of hen lysozyme and its catalysis by protein disulfide isomerase.

The oxidative refolding of hen lysozyme has been studied by a variety of time-resolved biophysical methods in conjunction with analysis of folding intermediates using reverse-phase HPLC. In order to achieve this, refolding conditions were designed to reduce aggregation during the early stages of the folding reaction. A complex ensemble of relatively unstructured intermediates with on average two disulfide bonds is formed rapidly from the fully reduced protein after initiation of folding. Following structural collapse, the majority of molecules slowly form the four-disulfide-containing fully native protein via rearrangement of a highly native-like, kinetically trapped intermediate, des-[76-94], although a significant population (approximately 30%) appears to fold more quickly via other three-disulfide intermediates. The folding catalyst PDI increases dramatically both yields and rates of lysozyme refolding, largely by facilitating the conversion of des-[76-94] to the native state. This suggests that acceleration of the folding rate may be an important factor in avoiding aggregation in the intracellular environment.     

NMR structural study of two-disulfide variant of hen lysozyme: 2SS[6-127, 30-115]--a disulfide intermediate with a partly unfolded structure

The 15N-labeled recombinant hen lysozyme and two species of two-disulfide variants, denoted as 2SS[6-127, 30-115] and 2SS[64-80, 76-94], were studied by means of NMR spectroscopy. The former variant contains two disulfide bridges in the alpha-domain, while the latter has one disulfide bridge in the beta-domain and the other one at the interface between two domains. Resonance assignments were performed using 3D TOCSY-HSQC and NOESY-HSQC spectra. The 15N-1H-HSQC spectrum of 2SS[6-127, 30-115] was similar to that of recombinant lysozyme as a whole, although a number of cross-peaks disappeared. On the other hand, the HSQC spectrum of 2SS[64-80, 76-94] was characteristic of unfolded proteins. The structure of 2SS[6-127, 30-115] was thoroughly examined on the basis of NOE contacts determined by NMR spectroscopy. The structure of the alpha-domain was quite similar to that of authentic lysozyme, while the beta-domain was largely unstructured. However, NMR data clearly demonstrated that some residual structures exist in the beta-domain. The beta1 and beta2 strands were maintained stably as an antiparallel beta-sheet. In addition, the residues 55 and 56 were located in the vicinity of the end of the B-helix. Further, the C-helix was properly set with side-chains of I88, V92, K96, and V99 facing toward the hydrophobic core in the alpha-domain. These residual structures inherent in the amino acid sequence were evaluated concerning the folding process of lysozyme. Our experiments imply that the establishment of the backbone conformation ranging from residues 76-99 plays a key role in attaining the cooperativity between two domains required for the folding transition.     

Comparison of the kinetics of S-S bond, secondary structure, and active site formation during refolding of reduced denatured hen egg white lysozyme

To investigate the role of some tertiary interactions, the disulfide bonds, in the early stages of refolding of hen lysozyme, we report the kinetics of reoxidation of denatured and reduced lysozyme under the same refolding conditions as those previously used to investigate the kinetics of regain of its circular dichroism (CD), fluorescence, and activity. At different stages of the refolding, the oxidation of the protein was blocked by alkylation of the free cysteines with iodoacetamide and the various oxidation states present in the samples were identified by electrospray-mass spectrometry. Thus, it was possible to monitor the appearance and/or disappearance of the species with 0 to 4 disulfide bonds. Using a simulation program, these kinetics were compared with those of regain of far-UV CD, fluorescence, and enzymatic activity and were discussed in terms of a refined model for the refolding of reduced hen egg white lysozyme.     

An NMR and MD study of complexes of bacteriophage lambda lysozyme with tetra- and hexa-N-acetylchitohexaose

The X-ray structure of lysozyme from bacteriophage lambda (λ lysozyme) in complex with the inhibitor hexa-N-acetylchitohexaose (NAG6) (PDB: 3D3D) has been reported previously showing sugar units from two molecules of NAG6 bound in the active site. One NAG6 is bound with four sugar units in the ABCD sites and the other with two sugar units in the E′F′ sites potentially representing the cleavage reaction products; each NAG6 cross links two neighboring λ lysozyme molecules. Here we use NMR and MD simulations to study the interaction of λ lysozyme with the inhibitors NAG4 and NAG6 in solution. This allows us to study the interactions within the complex prior to cleavage of the polysaccharide. ¹H^N and ¹⁵N chemical shifts of λ lysozyme resonances were followed during NAG4/NAG6 titrations. The chemical shift changes were similar in the two titrations, consistent with sugars binding to the cleft between the upper and lower domains; the NMR data show no evidence for simultaneous binding of a NAG6 to two λ lysozyme molecules. Six 150 ns MD simulations of λ lysozyme in complex with NAG4 or NAG6 were performed starting from different conformations. The simulations with both NAG4 and NAG6 show stable binding of sugars across the D/E active site providing low energy models for the enzyme-inhibitor complexes. The MD simulations identify different binding subsites for the 5th and 6th sugars consistent with the NMR data. The structural information gained from the NMR experiments and MD simulations have been used to model the enzyme-peptidoglycan complex.     

1H, 13C, and 15N resonance assignments of the N-terminal domain of human Tubulin Binding Cofactor C

Human Tubulin Binding Cofactor C (hTBCC) is a 346 amino acid protein composed of two domains, which is involved in the folding pathway of newly synthesized α and β-tubulins. The 3D structure of the 111-residue hTBCC N-terminal domain of the protein has not yet been determined. As a previous step to that end, here we report the NMR ¹H, ¹⁵N, and ¹³C chemical shift assignments at pH 6.0 and 25°C, based on a uniformly doubly labelled ¹³C/¹⁵N sample of the domain.     

Heterologous Expression of Hen Egg White Lysozyme and Resonance Assignment of Tryptophan Side Chains in its Non-native States

A new protocol is described for the isotope (¹⁵N and ¹³C,¹⁵N) enrichment of hen egg white lysozyme. Hen egg white lysozyme and an all-Ala-mutant of this protein have been expressed in E. coli. They formed inclusion bodies from which mg quantities of the proteins were purified and prepared for NMR spectroscopic investigations. ¹H,¹³C and ¹⁵N main chain resonances of disulfide reduced and S-methylated lysozyme were assigned and its residual structure in water pH 2 was characterized by chemical shift perturbation analysis. A new NMR experiment has been developed to assign tryptophan side chain indole resonances by correlation of side chain and backbone NH resonances with the C^γ resonances of these residues. Assignment of tryptophan side chains enables further residue specific investigations on structural and dynamical properties, which are of significant interest for the understanding of non-natives states of lysozyme stabilized by hydrophobic interactions between clusters of tryptophan residues.     

Backbone resonance assignments of monomeric SOD1 in dilute and crowded environments

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a fatal neurodegenerative disease that leads to movement disorders. In motor neurons of ALS patients, intracellular aggregates of superoxide dismutase 1 (SOD1) have often been observed. To elucidate the aggregation mechanism, it is important to analyze the folding equilibrium of SOD1 between folded and aggregation-prone unfolded states. However, in most cases, this folding equilibrium has been studied in dilute solution even though the aggregate formation occurs in a highly crowded intracellular environment. Indeed, a recent study reported that the folding stability of SOD1 decreased in an environment containing protein crowder molecules. To understand such a destabilization effect due to protein crowders, it is necessary to obtain more precise structural information on SOD1 in the presence of protein crowders. Here, we report the ¹H, ¹³C, and ¹⁵N backbone resonance assignments of monomeric SOD1 in the absence and presence of the protein crowder lysozyme. The chemical shift differences caused by addition of lysozyme suggest that SOD1 associated with lysozyme via negatively charged surfaces. Based on the assigned chemical shifts, the presence of lysozyme has a limited influence on the secondary structure of SOD1. We anticipate that our assignments will provide an important basis for elucidation of the crowding-induced folding destabilization of SOD1.     

1H, 13C, 15N backbone and side chain NMR resonance assignments of the N-terminal NEAr iron transporter domain 1 (NEAT 1) of the hemoglobin receptor IsdB of Staphylococcus aureus

Staphylococcus aureus is an opportunistic pathogen that causes skin and severe infections in mammals. Critical to S. aureus growth is its ability to scavenge iron from host cells. To this effect, S. aureus has evolved a sophisticated pathway to acquire heme from hemoglobin (Hb) as a preferred iron source. The pathway is comprised of nine iron-regulated surface determinant (Isd) proteins involved in heme capture, transport, and degradation. A key protein of the heme acquisition pathway is the surface-anchored hemoglobin receptor protein IsdB, which is comprised of two NEAr transporter (NEAT) domains that act in concert to bind Hb and extract heme for subsequent transfer to downstream acquisition pathway proteins. Despite significant advances in the structural knowledge of other Isd proteins, the structural mechanisms and molecular basis of the IsdB-mediated heme acquisition process are not well understood. In order to provide more insights into the mode of function of IsdB, we have initiated NMR structural studies of the first NEAT domain of IsdB (IsdB^N1). Herein, we report the near complete ¹H, ¹³C and ¹⁵N resonance assignments of backbone and side chain atoms, and the secondary structural topology of the 148-residue IsdB NEAT 1 domain. The NMR results are consistent with the presence of eight β-strands and one α-helix characteristic of an immunoglobulin-like fold observed in other NEAT domain family proteins. This work provides a solid framework to obtain atomic-level insights toward understanding how IsdB mediates IsdB-Hb protein–protein interactions critical for heme capture and transfer.     

Disulfide content of reduced hen egg white and human milk lysozymes during the folding process

In order to obtain a better understanding of the possible influence of the primary sequence of a protein on its folding pathway, renaturation of reduced human milk lysozyme was compared to that of reduced hen egg white lysozyme. Following disulfide bond formation, under identical conditions, similar products were found during the folding of both lysozymes, but the kinetics of appearance and disappearance of these intermediates as well as the appearance of the native conformation were different.     

Mechanism of Gemini Disulfide Detergent Mediated Oxidative Refolding of Lysozyme in a New Artificial Chaperone System

Gemini surfactants are a new class of surfactants that consist of two hydrophilic head groups and two hydrophobic tails separated by a spacer group. As the properties of geminis are different to their monomeric counterparts, a large number of applications have been investigated. Here we report on the use of a new class of gemini detergents containing a disulfide bond in the spacer (Det-SS-Det) for protein refolding. Using lysozyme as a model protein we could demonstrate that the disulfide gemini detergents allow oxidative refolding of the protein in the absence of any external redox system in an “artificial chaperone system”. Refolding kinetics using gemini disulfide detergents differing in their hydrophobicity were analysed to determine the folding and aggregation rate constants. The results point to an important role of the transiently formed mixed disulfides between the protein and the detergent (Prot-SS-Det) in the oxidative refolding process of lysozyme.     

Two-State Folding of Lysozyme Versus Multiple-State Folding of α-Lactalbumin Illustrated by the Technique of Disulfide Scrambling

The folding of lysozyme and of alpha-lactalbumin exhibits vastly different kinetics and pathways. Existing evidence indicates that folding intermediates of alphaLA form a well-populated equilibrium molten globule state that is absent in the case of hen lysozyme. We demonstrate here such divergent folding mechanisms of lysozyme and alphaLA using the technique of disulfide scrambling. Two extensively unfolded homologous isomers (beads-form) of lysozyme (Cys6-Cys30, Cys64-Cys76, Cys80-Cys94, Cys115-Cys127) and alphaLA (Cys6-Cys28, Cys61-Cys73, Cys77-Cys91, Cys111-Cys120) were allowed to refold in parallel to form the native protein. Folding kinetics was measured by the recovery of the native structure. Folding intermediates, which illustrate the folding pathway, were trapped by quenching disulfide shuffling and were analyzed by reversed-phase high-pressure liquid chromatography. The results revealed that under identical folding conditions, the folding rate of lysozyme is about 30-fold faster than that of alphaLA. Folding intermediates of lysozyme are far less heterogeneous and sparsely populated than those of alphaLA. Numerous predominant on-pathway and off-pathway intermediates observed along the folding pathway of alphaLA are conspicuously absent in the case of lysozyme. The difference is most striking under fast folding conditions performed in the presence of protein disulfide isomerase. Under these conditions, folding of lysozyme undergoes a near two-state mechanism without accumulation of stable folding intermediates.     

Conformational features of reduced and disulfide intact forms of hen egg white lysozyme in aqueous solution in presence of 3-chloro-1, 2-propanediol and dioxane: implications for protein folding intermediates

Conformational features of reduced and disulfide intact hen egg white lysozyme in aqueous 1,4-dioxane and 3-chloro-1, 2-propanediol solutions have been examined using circular dichroism and fluorescence spectroscopy. We find that in presence of 1, 4-dioxane, reduced lysozyme assumes a relatively compact conformational form with secondary structure closer to native state and no tertiary structure as judged by peptide and aromatic CD spectra and ANS binding studies monitored by fluorescence. Further, in presence of 40% (v/v) 3-chloro-1, 2-propanediol, disulfide intact lysozyme (DI-lysozyme) assumes a conformational form with native like secondary structure and no tertiary structure akin to a molten globule state. We correlate our results to kinetic hydrogen- deuterium exchange NMR results of the refolding of lysozyme available in literature and suggest that the conformational forms observed in our study could be models for kinetic intermediates in the refolding of lysozyme.     

Spectroscopic, immunochemical, and thermodynamic properties of carboxymethyl(Cys6, Cys127)-hen egg white lysozyme

A three-disulfide form of hen egg white lysozyme with Cys⁶ and Cys¹²⁷ blocked by carboxymethyl groups was prepared, purified, and characterized for eventual use in protein folding experiments. Trypsin digestion followed by proline-specific endopeptidase digestion facilitated the unambiguous assignment of the disulfide bond pairings and the modified residues in this derivative. 3SS-lysozyme demonstrated nearly full enzymatic activity at itspH optimum,pH 5.5. The 3SS-lysozyme derivative and unmodified lysozyme were shown to be identical by CD spectroscopy atpH 3.6. Immunochemical binding assays demonstrated that the conformation of lysozyme was perturbed predominantly only locally by breaking and blocking the disulfide bond between Cys⁶ and Cys¹²⁷. Both 3SS-lysozyme and unmodified lysozyme exhibited reversible thermally induced transitions atpH 2.0 but theT _m of 3SS-lysozyme, 18.9°C, was found to be 34° lower than that of native lysozyme under the same conditions. The conformational chemical potential of the denatured form of unmodified lysozyme was determined from the transition curves to be approximately 6.7 kcal/mol higher than that of the denatured form of 3SS-lysozyme, atpH 2.0 and 35°C, if the conformational chemical potential for the folded forms ofboth 3SS-lysozyme and unmodified lysozyme is arbitrarily assumed to be 0.0 kcal/mol. A calculation of the increase in the theoretical loop entropy of denatured 3SS-lysozyme resulting from the cleavage of the Cys⁶-Cys¹²⁷ disulfide bond, however, yielded a value of only 5.4 kcal/mol for the difference in conformational chemical potential. This suggests that, in addition to the entropic component, there is also an enthalpic contribution to the difference in the conformational chemical potential corresponding to approximately 1.3 kcal/mol. Thus, it is concluded that the reduction and blocking of the disulfide bond between Cys⁶ and Cys¹²⁷ destabilizes 3SS-lysozyme relative to unmodified lysozyme predominantly by stabilizing the denatured conformation by increasing its chain entropy.Cornell Biotechnology Army Research Office Predoctoral Fellow, 1986–1989.     

1H, 13C and 15N resonance assignments of the bb′ domains of human protein disulfide isomerase

Protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) participates in protein folding and catalyses formation of disulfide bonds. The b′ domain of human PDI contributes to binding unfolded proteins; its structure is stabilized by the b domain. Here, we report NMR chemical shift assignments for the bb′ fragment.