Larval feeding experience influences adult predator acceptance of chemically defended prey

Generalist predatory paper wasps, Polistes dominulus, experience plant secondary defensive compounds as developing larvae through their herbivorous lepidopteran caterpillar prey and as adults through attacking caterpillars while foraging. We evaluated the role that larval and early adult experience with unpalatable prey plays in subsequent foraging choices by adult wasps. For periods of two or four weeks, caged wasps were raised exclusively on caterpillars of either unpalatable Buckeye, Junonia coenia, that sequester substantial levels of iridoid glycosides (IG) or on Painted Lady, Vanessa cardui, that contain very low levels of IG. Wasps were then allowed to forage on both caterpillar species simultaneously. Patterns of prey capture differed significantly based on previous prey experience. Regardless of previous feeding experience, adult wasps overwhelmingly preferred to take Vanessa. Yet Junonia-experienced wasps continued to attack and take back to the nest over 50% more Junonia than did Vanessa-experienced wasps. The longer the wasps' larval experience with Junonia, the more likely they were to capture Junonia caterpillars. However, the life stage at which the wasps experienced Junonia was also influential as young adult experience with the unpalatable prey was more of a deterrent than was experience strictly as larvae for Junonia-experienced wasps. The results demonstrate that, in these predators, previous experience with deterrent chemicals during their larval development alters patterns of prey acceptability to the adult insects.     

Prey perception of predation risk: volatile chemical cues mediate non-consumptive effects of a predator on a herbivorous insect

Predators can affect prey in two ways—by reducing their density (consumptive effects) or by changing their behavior, physiology or other phenotypic traits (non-consumptive effects). Understanding the cues and sensory modalities prey use to detect predators is critical for predicting the strength of non-consumptive effects and the outcome of predator–prey encounters. While predator-associated cues have been well studied in aquatic systems, less is known about how terrestrial prey, particularly insect larvae, detect their predators. We evaluated how Colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata, larvae perceive predation risk by isolating cues from its stink bug predator, the spined soldier bug, Podisus maculiventris. When exposed to male “risk” predators that were surgically manipulated so they could hunt but not kill, beetles reduced feeding 29 % compared to controls. Exposure to risk females caused an intermediate response. Beetles ate 24 % less on leaves pre-exposed to predators compared to leaves never exposed to predators, indicating that tactile and visual cues are not required for the prey’s response. Volatile odor cues from predators reduced beetle feeding by 10 % overall, although male predators caused a stronger reduction than females. Finally, visual cues from the predator had a weak effect on beetle feeding. Because multiple cues appear to be involved in prey perception of risk, and because male and female predators have differential effects, beetle larvae likely experience tremendous variation in the information about risk from their local environment.     

Better to be bimodal: the interaction of color and odor on learning and memory

Defended prey frequently advertise to potential predators usingmultimodal warning displays. Signaling through more than onesensory pathway may enhance the rate of avoidance learning andthe memorability of these learned avoidances. If this is so,then mimetic insects would gain more protection from mimickinga multimodal rather than a monomodal model. Day-old domesticchicks (Gallus gallus domesticus) were used to examine whethera common insect warning odor (pyrazine) enhanced learning andmemorability of yellow prey, a common warning color. Pyrazineincreased the rate at which the chicks learned to avoid unpalatableyellow prey, and how well this learned avoidance was rememberedafter a 96-h interval. After 96 h, mimics of the multimodalprey were avoided, whereas mimics of the monomodal prey werenot. In the absence of pyrazine, chicks generalized their learnedavoidance of the unpalatable yellow prey to palatable greenprey; however, the presence of pyrazine reduced this color generalization.These results suggest that much is to be gained from signalingmultimodally, for both models and mimetic prey species. Thepresence of multimodal prey in the habitat may also advantagethe predators as it allows it them to distinguish more easilybetween palatable and unpalatable prey.     

Aversive Learning in the Praying Mantis (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Tenodera aridifolia</Emphasis>), a Sit and Wait Predator

Animals learn to associate sensory cues with the palatability of food in order to avoid bitterness in food (a common sign of toxicity). Associations are important for active foraging predators to avoid unpalatable prey and to invest energy in searching for palatable prey only. However, it has been suggested that sit-and-wait predators might rely on the opportunity that palatable prey approach them by chance: the most efficient strategy could be to catch every available prey and then decide whether to ingest them or not. In the present study, we investigated avoidance learning in a sit-and-wait predator, the praying mantis (Tenodera aridifolia). To examine the effects of conspicuousness and novelty of prey on avoidance learning, we used three different prey species: mealworms (novel prey), honeybees (novel prey with conspicuous signals) and crickets (familiar prey). We sequentially presented the prey species in pairs and made one of them artificially bitter. In the absence of bitterness, the mantises consumed bees and crickets more frequently than mealworms. When the prey were made bitter, the mantises still continued to attack bitter crickets as expected. However, they reduced their attacks on bitter mealworms more than on bitter bees. This contrasts with the fact that conspicuous signals (e.g. coloration in bees) facilitate avoidance learning in active foraging predators. Surprisingly, we found that the bitter bees were totally rejected after an attack whereas bitter mealworms were partially eaten (~35%). Our results highlight the fact that the mantises might maintain a selection pressure on bees, and perhaps on aposematic species in general.     

Automimicry destabilizes aposematism: predator sample-and-reject behaviour may provide a solution

Aposematism, the use of conspicuous colours to advertise unpalatability to predators, is perhaps the most studied signalling system in nature. However, its evolutionary stability remains paradoxical. The paradox is illustrated by the problem of automimicry. Automimics are palatable individuals within a population of unpalatable aposematics. Automimics benefit from predators avoiding warning coloration without carrying the models' cost of unpalatability, and should increase in the population, destabilizing the signalling system, unless selected against in some way. Cautious sampling, instead of avoidance, by predators may offer a solution to this problem. Here, we investigate the effect of automimic frequency on predator sampling behaviour, and whether predator sampling behaviour may provide a selection pressure against mimics. Domestic chicks (Gallus gallus domesticus) were subjected to the task of discriminating between green (signalling) and untreated brown chick crumbs. Some of the green crumbs were quinine treated and thus unpalatable. The frequency of palatable signalling prey items varied in four treatments; all unpalatable, low automimic frequency, high automimic frequency and all palatable. The results show that predator sampling behaviour is sensitive to automimic frequency and that predators may discriminate between models and mimics through sampling, and thereby benefit unprofitable prey. The results suggest somewhat surprisingly that aposematic signalling is stable only because of the actions of those predators not actually deterred by warning signals.     

Foraging strategies of caterpillars

Summary An analysis of the foraging behaviors of several species of palatable and unpalatable lepidopterous larvae indicates that palatable caterpillars partition their time between feeding and behaviors that could be related to escape visually oriented predators. Depending on the species, palatable caterpillars do all or several of the following: 1) restrict themselves to the underside of leaves at all times, 2) restrict foraging to night-time, 3) commute to and from their feeding area on leaves, 4) move from the unfinished leaf to a distant leaf after a feeding bout, thus removing themselves from the evidence of their eating, 5) snip off partially-eaten leaves after feeding on them. The less palatable, or unpalatable, caterpillars do not snip off partially-eaten leaves, feed from leaves leaving tattered edges, and are often exposed resting and feeding on the leaf surfaces in direct sunshine. I conclude that some caterpillar foraging behaviors may have evolved under the selective pressure of visually-oriented predators that use leaf-damage as a cue in their searching behavior.     

The effect of invertebrate and vertebrate predators on the foraging movements of Ischnura elegans larvae (Odonata: Zygoptera)

SUMMARY.

• 1 The foraging movements of late instar Ischnura elegans larvae were monitored in laboratory experiments to study the effects of predators on larval feeding behaviour.
• 2 Ischnura larvae are sit-atid-wait, or ambush, foragers, moving occasionally between perches in search of profitable feeding sites. Larval foraging movements, monitored at different densities of Daphnia prey, increased significantly when prey were absent.
• 3 In experiments without prey, larval movement was inhibited by the presence of fish predators, as well as by invertebrate predators (Notonecta glauca), but not by closely related, non-predatory invertebrates (Corixa punctata) or physical disturbance of the water (intermittent air bubbles).
• 4 Further experiments varied Ischnura hunger levels (0–8 days without food) and illumination (light or dark) with and without notonectid predators. Hunger had no consistent effect on penultimate instar behaviour but final instar foraging activity was significantly modified: movements increased after 4 days starvation and decreased again after 8 days. This response was suppressed by the presence of predators. Both larval instars moved significantly less often in the light, even when predators were absent.
• 5 These phenotypically flexible predator-avoidance responses are likely to decrease the risk of predation by both visual and tactile predators. However, predators clearly have an important influence on the feeding niche of Ischnura larvae, and may decrease the overall feeding efficiency, growth rate, and survival of larvae by constraining their movement in search of profitable feeding sites.

     

The importance of pattern similarity between Müllerian mimics in predator avoidance learning

Müllerian mimicry, where unpalatable prey share common warning patterns, has long fascinated evolutionary biologists. It is commonly assumed that Müllerian mimics benefit by sharing the costs of predator education, thus reducing per capita mortality, although there has been no direct test of this assumption. Here, we specifically measure the selection pressure exerted by avian predators on unpalatable prey with different degrees of visual similarity in their warning patterns. Using wild-caught birds foraging on novel patterned prey in the laboratory, we unexpectedly found that pattern similarity did not increase the speed of avoidance learning, and even dissimilar mimics shared the education of naive predators. This was a consistent finding across two different densities of unpalatable prey, although mortalities were lower at the higher density as expected. Interestingly, the mortalities of Müllerian mimics were affected by pattern similarity in the predicted way by the end of our experiment, although the result was not quite significant. This suggests that the benefits to Müllerian mimics may emerge only later in the learning process, and that predator experience of the patterns may affect the degree to which pattern similarity is important. This highlights the need to measure the behaviour of real predators if we are to understand fully the evolution of mimicry systems.     

Facilitated predation through interaction between life stages in the stinkbug predatorperillus bioculatus (Hemiptera: Pentatomidae)

Competitive interactions in arthropod predators are well-known, but positive interactions have received less attention. The two-spotted stinkbugPerillus bioculatus often feeds gregariously on leaf beetle larvae and caterpillar prey. Consequences of prey sharing amongP. bioculatus conspecifics of dissimilar size (instar) was studied using Colorado potato beetle (CPB) prey. Rearing second-instar (N2) nymphs ofP. bioculatus with an N5 conspecific facilitated early feeding on L4 CPB larvae (a difficult prey to handle by N2 nymphs but not by N5’s), thus increasing survival and accelerating development. One in every 20 cases ofP. bioculatus foraging in the field was accounted for by pairs or small groups of mostly feeding individuals. CPB egg masses and L4’s represented a disproportionate number of cases of aggregated feeding byP. bioculatus, compared to feeding singly. Small CPB larvae decreased in the diet of aggregated stinkbugs compared to L4 larvae and egg masses, suggesting that sharing these prey may be favorable or unavoidable. In a field test measuring residence/survival of N2’s limited to L4 prey, the N2’s rate of residence/survival increased significantly when large nymphs acting as food providers were also present. The function of communal feeding inP. bioculatus is discussed, as well as the potential for greater impact on prey density that may be expected from tolerance to opportunistic feeding by conspecifics in slightly gregarious predators.     

Effects of prey quantity and quality on predatory wasps

1. The simultaneous effects of prey quantity and prey quality on fitness correlates of the predatory wasp Polistes fuscatus were examined in a glasshouse study. Prey quantity was manipulated by providing prey in excess (high quantity) or one‐third of that (low quantity). Prey quality was manipulated by providing either palatable (Manduca sexta) caterpillars or unpalatable (Junonia coenia) caterpillars. 2. The effect of prey quality on wasp production depended on prey quantity. Nests given unpalatable prey produced few wasps whereas nests given palatable prey increased wasp production with increased prey. 3. The low production of nests given unpalatable prey reflected the low acceptability of those prey. The wasps preferred the palatable prey and learned to reject the unpalatable prey. With no choice of prey, they took only enough unpalatable prey to develop a small nest or colony. 4. A diet of unpalatable prey also resulted in smaller wasps and reduced the proportion of males produced, from about 40% to just 8–14%, depending on the year.     

The costs of reduced feeding due to predator avoidance: potential effects on growth and fitness in Ischnura elegans larvae (Odonata: Zygoptera)

ABSTRACT.

• 1 This paper investigates the behaviour, in the laboratory, of a forager simultaneously confronted with the conflicting needs to feed and to avoid predators. The foragers were larvae of the damselfly Ischnura elegans Van der Linden, feeding on Daphnia magna Strauss. The predators were adult females of Notonecta glauca L.
• 2 Patch choice by Ischnura larvae was significantly modified by the presence of predators. Larvae moved to feed in patches of high prey density when predators were absent but preferred dense cover, even though virtually no prey were available, when predators were present. This behaviour was not altered by hunger, up to 12 days without food. In other words, Ischnura larvae were risk averse in their foraging behaviour.
• 3 In experiments with abundant prey available, the feeding rates of Ischnura larvae confined to a single patch were also significantly reduced by the presence of hydrodynamically and chemically detectable predators. Predators detectable only by vision had little effect.
• 4 Calculations made from published data show that reduced larval feeding rates can lead to slower growth and development and prolonged instar durations in Ischnura elegans larvae. This may have important consequences for larval survival and adult reproductive fitness.

     

Effects of non-lethal attacks by three phytoseiid species on subsequent development,fecundity and mortality of the two-spotted spider mite

The effects of attack by the three predaceous mite speciesPhytoseiulus persimilis Athias-Henriot,Phytoseius finitimus Ribaga andAmblyseius gossipi Elbadry on the development, reproduction and mortality of the two-spotted spider miteTetranyschus urticae Koch were evaluated after the prey larvae being exposed to attack by these predators for limited periods. Development of the surviving prey immatures was significantly prolonged; this influence was more distinctive when prey larvae were exposed to the predators for a longer period. The number of prey adults which died early was positively correlated with the length of the feeding period allowed to the predators. A substantial reduction in the number of eggs deposited by the prey females was noted, although the oviposition by the prey females was noted, although the oviposition period and adult longivity were not significantly affected.     

Brittle-star bioluminescence functions as an aposematic signal to deter crustacean predators

The behaviour of three species of nocturnally active, visually orienting crabs (Portunus sebae, P. spinnimanus and P. ordwayi) was observed to determine whether the luminescent signals produced by Ophiopsila riisei (Echinodermata: Ophiuroidea) function as an aposematic deterrent against crustacean predators. In repeated experimental trials, crabs showed more rapid rejection of luminescent unpalatable ophiuroids than of non-luminescent controls. After five trials, unpalatable luminescent prey were rejected three times as quickly as either unpalatable or palatable non-luminescent controls. Over the course of the trials, crabs damaged fewer luminescent ophiuroids than non-luminescent controls. Furthermore, blind crabs (that could not perceive the luminescent flashes) caused significantly more damage to luminescent brittle-stars than did crabs with intact eyes (that could see the light signals). All three species of crab ophiuroids versus non-luminescent controls. Ophiopsila riisei survived the majority of crab attacks, and crabs can therefore learn to reject unpalatable luminescent prey without killing them. This suggests that individual selection may be an important mechanism for the evolution of aposematic luminescent signals in this, and probably other, luminescent species.     

Testing chemical defence based on pyrrolizidine alkaloids

Pyrrolizidine alkaloids are considered the primary defence mechanism in aposematic ithomiine butterflies and arctiid moths. Despite evidence that pyrrolizidine alkaloids are effective against some invertebrate predators, proof for a protective function of pyrrolizidine alkaloids against vertebrate predators is fragmented. The present work shows that the pyrrolizidine alkaloid monocrot-aline is unpalatable to the pileated finch,Coryphospingus pileatusand that the unpalatability is learned through association with a specific colour pattern (blue stripes). In a series of trials, using mealworms as model prey, birds rejected those to which pyrrolizidine alkaloid solution had been applied topically but accepted prey devoid of the alkaloid. Subsequent offerings of prey with pyrrolizidine alkaloid and a painted blue-striped pattern led to consistent rejections by the experimental birds. Birds were then offered blue-striped painted larvae without pyrrolizidine alkaloids (‘mimics’), which were rejected at levels similar to the previous trial. The predators learned to recognize the prey as unpalatable items based on their experience in the previous encounters. These results provide evidence for the protective capacity of the pyrrolizidine alkaloid against a vertebrate predator and supports the role of these chemicals in aposematism in the Lepidoptera.     

Disturbance to a stream food web by a bacterial larvicide specific to black flies: feeding responses of predatory macroinvertebrates

1. A field study was conducted to: (i) assess feeding habit changes of two predatory stoneflies following the loss of larval black fly (Diptera: Simuliidae) prey from two streams; and (ii) determine the relative importance of black fly larvae as prey for these and other selected predatory benthic macroinvertebrates. 2. Acroneuria lycorias and Paragnetina media (Plecoptera: Perlidae) diets were monitored in response to local reductions in larval black fly populations caused by Bacillus thuringiensis var. israelensis (B.t.i.) in two Michigan streams. These predators were collected from B.t.i.-treated and control sections of the streams, and their foreguts inspected for prey. 3. Black flies were the major dietary component of both predators collected from the control sections, but the number of black flies ingested was significantly less for predators collected from B.t.i.-treated habitats. Total number of prey ingested significantly decreased for A. lycorias, but not for P. media, and non-black fly prey consumption significantly increased for P. media, but not for A, lycorias, following B.t.i. applications. 4. In prey choice trials conducted in experimental channels, A. lycorias and P. media showed no preference between prey types (black flies and mayflies). Body mass gain of individual A. lycorias nymphs was measured, and was similar for nymphs in black fly-rich and black fly-poor environments. Conversely, Isoperla signata and I. dicala (Plecoptera: Perlodidae) ingested significantly more Simulium vittatum (Diptera: Simuliidae) than Baetis flavistriga (Ephemeroptera: Baetidae) or Epeorus vitrea (Heptageniidae) prey. Boyeria vinosa (Odonata: Aeshnidae) ingested significantly more B. flavistriga than S. vittatum prey. 5. Reducing black fly densities in these streams, using B.t.i., indirectly and differentially affected predators. In black fly-poor environments, feeding habits of specialist predators were most affected, and generalist predators least affected because the latter consumed alternative prey. Predator—predator and predator-prey interactions, and prey community structure may be affected indirectly by disturbances such as B.t.i. applications by reducing food resources and forcing predation onto less preferred prey.     

Aversive reactions of two invertebrate predators to European red–black insects

Prey species gain protection by imitating signals of unpalatable models in defensive mimicry. Mimics have been traditionally classified as Batesian (palatable mimic resembling an unpalatable model) or Müllerian (unpalatable mimic resembling a similarly unpalatable model). However, recent studies suggest that rather than discrete categories, the phenomenon of mimicry can be better understood as a continuum. The level of unpalatability of defended prey is a key factor in determining the type of mimetic relationship. Herein, we used insects (ladybugs and true bugs) from a putative European “red–black” mimetic complex as experimental models of defended species and crickets as a control prey. We offered the prey to two species of sympatric invertebrate predators (praying mantis and spider) and video recorded the interactions. We tested three alternative hypotheses, namely (i) the three red–black species tested are similarly defended against both predators; (ii) some red–black species are better defended than others against both predator species, and (iii) the effectiveness of the red–black species defenses is predator dependent. Both predators attacked all prey types with a similar frequency. But while all three red–black species similarly elicited aversive behaviors in spiders, the mantises' aversive reactions varied depending on the prey species. Our results provide support to the third hypothesis, suggesting that the same prey species can fall into different parts of the spectrum of palatability–unpalatability depending on the type of predator.     

Predator Presence Moves <Emphasis Type="Italic">Helicoverpa armigera</Emphasis> Larvae to Distraction

Displacement of herbivorous insects by the presence of predators on whole plants has rarely been studied. By semi-continuous observations of an externally feeding insect herbivore and a predator, we show how the mere presence of the predator, Geocoris lubra Kirkaldy (Hemiptera: Geocoridae), on a plant can have a strong influence on the movement and behaviors of Helicoverpa armigera (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) larvae. The presence of predators, as opposed to mortality by predators, influenced the proportion of larvae feeding, resting and implementing avoidance activities. In addition, the proportion of time individual larvae allocated to feeding, resting and dropping off plants was affected when predators were present with and without contact between the two. Predators do more than just reduce numbers of herbivores; they influence feeding, displacement and subsequently the distribution of plant damage.     

Determinants of predation on phytophagous insects: the importance of diet breadth

To evaluate the role of predation in the evolution of diet specialization and to determine the effectiveness of various larval defenses, we offered lepidopteran larvae to colonies of the tropical ant Paraponera clavata. We recorded behavioral and physical characteristics of prey items and used log-linear models to analyze their importance as deterrents to predation by P. clavata. The most important determinant of probability of prey rejection by P. clavata was a prey's diet breadth; specialists were rejected by the ants significantly more than generalists. Other less important, but significant, predictors of prey rejection included ontogeny, morphology and chemistry. Late instar caterpillars were rejected more frequently than early instars, hairy caterpillars were rejected more frequently than caterpillars with other morphologies, and one caterpillar species with an unpalatable extract was rejected more frequently than two species with palatable extracts.     

Influence of the forest caterpillar hunter Calosoma sycophanta on the transmission of microsporidia in larvae of the gypsy moth Lymantria dispar

• 1 The behaviour of predators can be an important factor in the transmission success of an insect pathogen. We studied how Calosoma sycophanta influences the interaction between its prey [Lymantria dispar (L.) (Lepidoptera, Lymantriidae)] and two microsporidian pathogens [Nosema lymantriae (Microsporidia, Nosematidae) and Vairimorpha disparis (Microsporidia, Burellenidae)] infecting the prey.
• 2 Using laboratory experiments, C. sycophanta was allowed to forage on infected and uninfected L. dispar larvae and to disseminate microsporidian spores when preying or afterwards with faeces.
• 3 The beetle disseminated spores of N. lymantriae and V. disparis when preying upon infected larvae, as well as after feeding on such prey. Between 45% and 69% of test larvae became infected when C. sycophanta was allowed to disseminate spores of either microsporidium.
• 4 Laboratory choice experiments showed that C. sycophanta did not discriminate between Nosema‐infected and uninfected gypsy moth larvae. Calosoma sycophanta preferred Vairimorpha‐infected over uninfected gypsy moth larvae and significantly influenced transmission.
• 5 When C. sycophanta was allowed to forage during the latent period on infected and uninfected larvae reared together on caged, potted oak saplings, the percentage of V. disparis infection among test larvae increased by more than 70%. The transmission of N. lymantriae was not affected significantly in these experiments.
• 6 Beetles never became infected with either microsporidian species after feeding on infected prey.
• 7 We conclude that the transmission of N. lymantriae is not affected. Because no V. disparis spores are released from living larvae, feeding on infected larvae might enhance transmission by reducing the time to death and therefore the latent period.