Mechanism of action of cysteine proteinases: oxyanion binding site is not essential in the hydrolysis of specific substrates

To study the possible stabilization of the oxyanion of the tetrahedral intermediate formed in the course of the catalyses by cysteine proteinases, papain, chymopapain, papaya peptidase A, and ficin, we synthesized N-(benzyloxycarbonyl)phenylalanylthioglycine O-ethyl ester and compared its hydrolysis with that of the corresponding oxygen ester, a highly specific substrate of the above enzymes. It was found that the substitution of sulfur for the carbonyl oxygen hardly affected the second-order rate constant of acylation and diminished catalytic activity by about 1 order of magnitude in deacylation. These results contrast with those obtained with serine proteinases [Asbóth, B., & Polgár, L. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 117-122], where the hydrolysis of thiono esters could not be detected. From the results the following conclusions can be drawn. Stabilization of the tetrahedral intermediate at an oxyanion binding site is not essential with cysteine proteinases. Therefore, and because of the lack of general base catalysis, cysteine proteinases have a less constrained transition-state structure than serine proteinases.     

Comparison of the kinetics and mechanism of the papain-catalyzed hydrolysis of esters and thiono esters

The kinetic constants for the papain-catalyzed hydrolysis of the methyl thiono esters of N-benzoylglycine and N-(beta-phenylpropionyl)glycine are compared with those for the corresponding methyl ester substrates. The k2/Ks values for the thiono esters are 2-3 times higher than those for the esters, and both show bell-shaped pH dependencies with similar pKa's (approximately 4 and 9). The k3 values for the thiono esters are 30-60 times less than those for the esters and do not exhibit a pH dependency. Solvent deuterium isotope effects on k2/Ks and k3 were measured for the ester and thiono ester substrates of both glycine derivatives. Each thiono ester substrate showed an isotope effect similar to that for the corresponding ester substrate. Moreover, use of the proton inventory technique indicated that, as for esters, one proton is transferred in the transition state for deacylation during reactions involving thiono esters and the degree of heavy atom reorganization in the transition state is very similar in both cases. The k3 values for the hydrolysis of a series of para-substituted N-benzoylglycine esters were found to correlate with the k3 values for the corresponding para-substituted thiono esters [Carey, P. R., Lee, H., Ozaki, Y., & Storer, A. C. (1984) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 106, 8258-8262], showing that the rate-determining step for the deacylation of both thiolacyl and dithioacyl enzymes probably involves the disruption of a contact between the substrate's glycinic nitrogen atom and the sulfur of cysteine-25. It is concluded that the hydrolysis of esters and thiono esters proceeds by essentially the same reaction pathway. Due to an oxygen-sulfur exchange process the product released in the case of the N-(beta-phenylpropionyl)glycine thiono ester substrate is the dioxygen acid; however, for the N-benzoylglycine thiono ester substrate, the thiol acid is the initial product. This thiol acid then acts as a substrate for papain and reacylates the enzyme to eventually give the dioxygen acid product. It is shown that thiol acids are excellent substrates for papain.     

The Oxyanion Hole in Serine beta-Lactamase Catalysis: Interactions of Thiono Substrates with the Active Site

Both functional and structural studies of serine beta-lactamases indicate the existence of an oxyanion hole at the active site with an important role in catalysis. The functional presence of the oxyanion hole is demonstrated by the previous observation that thiono-beta-lactams are very poor substrates of beta-lactamases (B. P. Murphy, and R. F. Pratt, 1988, Biochem. J. 256, 669-672) and in the present paper by the inability of these enzymes to catalyze hydrolysis of a thiono analog of a depsipeptide substrate. This thiono effect was first noted and interpreted in regard to classical serine hydrolases although the chemical basis for it has not been firmly established either in those enzymes or in beta-lactamases. In this paper a computational approach to a further understanding of the effect has been taken. The results for a class C beta-lactamase show that the deacylation tetrahedral intermediate interacted more strongly with the enzyme with an O(-) placed in the oxyanion hole than an S(-). On the other hand, the converse was true for acylation tetrahedral intermediate species, a result distinctly not in accord with experiment. These results indicate that the thiono effect does not arise from unfavorable interactions between enzyme and thiono substrate at the tetrahedral intermediate stage but must be purely kinetic in nature, i.e., arise in a transitional species at an early stage of the acylation reaction. The same conclusion as to the origin of the thiono effect was also indicated by a less extensive series of calculations on a class A beta-lactamase and on chymotrypsin.     

The Oxyanion Hole in Serine β-Lactamase Catalysis: Interactions of Thiono Substrates with the Active Site

Both functional and structural studies of serine β-lactamases indicate the existence of an oxyanion hole at the active site with an important role in catalysis. The functional presence of the oxyanion hole is demonstrated by the previous observation that thiono-β-lactams are very poor substrates of β-lactamases (B. P. Murphy, and R. F. Pratt, 1988, Biochem. J.256, 669–672) and in the present paper by the inability of these enzymes to catalyze hydrolysis of a thiono analog of a depsipeptide substrate. This thiono effect was first noted and interpreted in regard to classical serine hydrolases although the chemical basis for it has not been firmly established either in those enzymes or in β-lactamases. In this paper a computational approach to a further understanding of the effect has been taken. The results for a class C β-lactamase show that the deacylation tetrahedral intermediate interacted more strongly with the enzyme with an O⁻ placed in the oxyanion hole than an S⁻. On the other hand, the converse was true for acylation tetrahedral intermediate species, a result distinctly not in accord with experiment. These results indicate that the thiono effect does not arise from unfavorable interactions between enzyme and thiono substrate at the tetrahedral intermediate stage but must be purely kinetic in nature, i.e., arise in a transitional species at an early stage of the acylation reaction. The same conclusion as to the origin of the thiono effect was also indicated by a less extensive series of calculations on a class A β-lactamase and on chymotrypsin.     

Comparison of the kinetics of the papain-catalyzed hydrolysis of glycine- and alanine-based esters and thiono esters

The kinetic constants for the papain-catalyzed hydrolysis of a series of substrates with glycine or alanine in the P1 position are discussed. The substrates have N-benzoyl, N-(p-nitrobenzoyl), N-(beta-phenylpropionyl), or N-(methyloxycarbonyl)phenylalanine attached to the P1 moiety, and kinetic constants are obtained for both esters and thiono esters. The results for the hydrolysis of esters can be readily interpreted in terms of the known specificity of papain. For any glycine ester the change in kcat/Km upon substituting C=S for C=O or upon substituting an alpha-CH3 group is minimal. However, upon making both these substitutions, i.e., going from a glycine ester to an alanine thiono ester substrate, larger changes are seen for this ratio. Data for N-benzoyl- and N-(beta-phenylpropionyl)glycine and -alanine methyl thiono esters show that k2 is the parameter most affected by the double C=S and alpha-CH3 substitution. A further conclusion is that the deacylation rate constants for any pair of glycine and alanine dithioacyl papains are similar; e.g., for the intermediates based on the "good" substrates PheAla and PheGly k3 differs by only 20%. This is a surprising finding in light of the very different conformations and interactions of the bound acyl groups revealed by resonance Raman spectroscopy and raises the possibility that specific stereochemical effects, such as the oxyanion hole and general base catalysis, are not operating in the hydrolysis of dithioacyl papains.     

A theoretical study of the active sites of papain and S195C rat trypsin: implications for the low reactivity of mutant serine proteinases.

The serine and cysteine proteinases represent two important classes of enzymes that use a catalytic triad to hydrolyze peptides and esters. The active site of the serine proteinases consists of three key residues, Asp...His...Ser. The hydroxyl group of serine functions as a nucleophile and the imidazole ring of histidine functions as a general acid/general base during catalysis. Similarly, the active site of the cysteine proteinases also involves three key residues: Asn, His, and Cys. The active site of the cysteine proteinases is generally believed to exist as a zwitterion (Asn...His+...Cys-) with the thiolate anion of the cysteine functioning as a nucleophile during the initial stages of catalysis. Curiously, the mutant serine proteinases, thiol subtilisin and thiol trypsin, which have the hybrid Asp...His...Cys triad, are almost catalytically inert. In this study, ab initio Hartree-Fock calculations have been performed on the active sites of papain and the mutant serine proteinase S195C rat trypsin. These calculations predict that the active site of papain exists predominately as a zwitterion (Cys-...His+...Asn). However, similar calculations on S195C rat trypsin demonstrate that the thiol mutant is unable to form a reactive thiolate anion prior to catalysis. Furthermore, structural comparisons between native papain and S195C rat trypsin have demonstrated that the spatial juxtapositions of the triad residues have been inverted in the serine and cysteine proteinases and, on this basis, I argue that it is impossible to convert a serine proteinase to a cysteine proteinase by site-directed mutagenesis.     

Evidence for a thiol ester in duck ovostatin (ovomacroglobulin)

The structure and the mechanism for proteinase inhibition of the egg white protein ovostatin (ovomacroglobulin) are similar to those of plasma alpha 2-macroglobulin, but previous studies have shown that chicken ovostatin lacks a reactive thiol ester (Nagase, H., and Harris, E. D., Jr. (1983) J. Biol. Chem. 258, 7490-7498). Here we show that duck ovostatin has conserved such a thiol ester and is capable of inhibiting both metallo- and serine proteinases stoichiometrically. Evidence for thiol esters was established by the following results with duck ovostatin: 1) autolysis into fragments of Mr = 123,000 and 60,000 occurred by heating in sodium dodecyl sulfate, but was prevented by treatment with CH3NH2; 2) covalent linkages were formed with proteinases on complex formation; 3) reaction with CH3NH2 generated 3.6 SH groups/mol, and 3.9 mol of [14C]CH3NH2 were incorporated per mol of protein; and 4) saturation with a proteinase liberated 3.8 SH groups/mol of the inhibitor. Conformational rearrangement of duck ovostatin upon reacting with CH3NH2 or proteinases was demonstrated by an increased mobility of the protein in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. CH3NH2-treated duck ovostatin was able to bind and inhibit proteinases without forming covalent bonds, but, unlike unmodified ovostatin, its inhibitory activity was destroyed by freezing and thawing. Complexes formed between CH3NH2-treated duck ovostatin and a proteinase were not dissociable except under denaturing conditions. These results and other evidence indicate that covalent bond formation through reaction with a thiol ester is a separate process from the trapping and inhibition of proteinases by this family of proteins.     

The basic difference in catalyses by serine and cysteine proteinases resides in charge stabilization in the transition state

Besides the mechanistic similarities, in particular acylenzyme formation, kinetic investigations and X-ray diffraction studies have revealed some differences between the mechanisms of serine and cysteine proteinases: general base-catalysis in acylation, catalytic contribution by oxyanion binding, and a negatively charged catalytic triad in serine proteinases, but not in cysteine proteinases. In this paper we point out that all these differences are related and connected with the mode of stabilization of the zwitterionic species developing in the transition state of the reactions. In the case of serine proteinases this charge separation requires facilitation by the oxyanion binding and the negative charge of the catalytic triad. On the other hand cysteine proteinases do not require such contributions as they are capable of stabilizing the ion-pair even in the ground state of the reaction. Therefore, cysteine proteinases, in contrast to serine proteinases, may be regarded as "activated" enzymes.     

A serpin-induced extensive proteolytic susceptibility of urokinase-type plasminogen activator implicates distortion of the proteinase substrate-binding pocket and oxyanion hole in the serpin inhibitory mechanism.

The formation of stable complexes between serpins and their target serine proteinases indicates formation of an ester bond between the proteinase active-site serine and the serpin P1 residue [Egelund, R., Rodenburg, K.W., Andreasen, P.A., Rasmussen, M.S., Guldberg, R.E. & Petersen, T.E. (1998) Biochemistry 37, 6375-6379]. An important question concerning serpin inhibition is the contrast between the stability of the ester bond in the complex and the rapid hydrolysis of the acyl-enzyme intermediate in general serine proteinase-catalysed peptide bond hydrolysis. To answer this question, we used limited proteolysis to detect conformational differences between free urokinase-type plasminogen activator (uPA) and uPA in complex with plasminogen activator inhibitor-1 (PAI-1). Whereas the catalytic domain of free uPA, pro-uPA, uPA in complex with non-serpin inhibitors and anhydro-uPA in a non-covalent complex with PAI-1 was resistant to proteolysis, the catalytic domain of PAI-1-complexed uPA was susceptible to proteolysis. The cleavage sites for four different proteinases were localized in specific areas of the C-terminal beta-barrel of the catalytic domain of uPA, providing evidence that the serpin inhibitory mechanism involves a serpin-induced massive rearrangement of the proteinase active site, including the specificity pocket, the oxyanion hole, and main-chain binding area, rendering the proteinase unable to complete the normal hydrolysis of the acyl-enzyme intermediate. The distorted region includes the so-called activation domain, also known to change conformation on zymogen activation.     

Benzoylamidoacetonitrile is bound as a thioimidate in the active site of papain

13C NMR spectroscopy has been used to demonstrate that 13CN-labeled benzoylamidoacetonitrile forms a covalent adduct with the thiol group of cysteine 25 in the active site of papain. Spectral comparison with model compounds indicates that the adduct is a thioimidate. On the basis of a proposed mechanism for the formation of the thioimidate, it is concluded that the -CH2C(= NH)S--imino nitrogen does not sit in the active site in the same manner as the thiol ester carbonyl oxygen of the thiol acyl enzyme (or the oxyanion of the tetrahedral intermediate). Thus, in this sense the stabilization of the thioimidate does not reflect a similarity in structure between the bound thioimidate and the transition state.     

Conformational states of N-acylalanine dithio esters: correlation of resonance Raman spectra with structures

The conformational states of N-acylalanine dithio esters, involving rotational isomers about the RC(=O)NH--CH(CH3) and NHCH(CH3)--C(=S) bonds, are defined and compared to those of N-acylglycine dithio esters. The structure of N-(p-nitrobenzoyl)-DL-alanine ethyl dithio ester has been determined by X-ray crystallographic analysis; it is a B-type conformer with the amide N atom cis to the thiol sulfur. Raman and resonance Raman (RR) measurements on this compound and for the B conformers of solid N-benzoyl-DL-alanine ethyl dithio ester and N-(beta-phenylpropionyl)-DL-alanine ethyl dithio ester and its NHCH(CD3)C(=S) and NHCH(CH3)13C(=S) analogues are used to set up a library of RR data for alanine-based dithio esters in a B-conformer state. (Methyloxycarbonyl)-L-phenylalanyl-L-alanine ethyl dithio ester crystallizes in an A-like conformational state wherein the alanine N atom is nearly cis to the thiono S atom (C=S) [Varughese, K.I., Angus, R.H., Carey, P.R., Lee, H., & Storer, A.C. (1986) Can. J. Chem. 64, 1668-1673]. RR data for this solid material in its isotopically unsubstituted and CH(C-D3)C(=S) and CH(CH3)13C(=S) forms provide information on the RR signatures of alanine dithio esters in A-like conformations. RR spectra are compared for the solid compounds, for N-(p-nitrobenzoyl)-DL-alanine, N-(beta-phenylpropionyl)-DL-alanine, and (methyloxycarbonyl)-L-phenylalanyl-DL-alanine ethyl dithio esters, and for several 13C=S- and CD3-substituted analogues in CCl4 or aqueous solutions. The RR data demonstrate that the alanine-based dithio esters take up A, B, and C5 conformations in solution.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Differences in the proteinase inhibition mechanism of human alpha 2-macroglobulin and pregnancy zone protein.

Different conformational states of human alpha 2-macroglobulin (alpha 2M) and pregnancy zone protein (PZP) were investigated following modifications of the functional sites, i.e. the 'bait' regions and the thiol esters, by use of chymotrypsin, methylamine and dinitrophenylthiocyanate. Gel electrophoresis, mAb (7H11D6 and alpha 1:1) and in vivo plasma clearance were used to describe different molecular states in the proteinase inhibitors. In alpha 2M, in which the thiol ester is broken by binding of methylamine and the 'trap' is closed, cyanylation of the liberated thiol group from the thiol ester modulates reopening of the 'trap' and the 'bait' regions become available for cleavage again. The trapping of proteinases in the cyanylated derivative indicates that the trap functions as in native alpha 2M. In contrast, cyanylation has no effect on proteinase-treated alpha 2M. As demonstrated by binding to mAb, the methylamine and dinitrophenylthiocyanate-treated alpha 2M exposes the receptor-recognition site, but the derivative is not cleared from the circulation in mice. The trap is not functional in PZP. In native PZP and PZP treated with methylamine, the conformational states seem similar. The receptor-recognition sites are not exposed and removal from the circulation in vivo is not seen for these as for the PZP-chymotrypsin complex. Tetramers are only formed when proteinases can be covalently bound to the PZP. Conformational changes are not detected in PZP derivatives in which the thiol ester is treated with methylamine and dinitrophenylthiocyanate. The results suggest that the conformational changes in alpha 2M are generated by mechanisms different to these in PZP. The key structure gearing the conformational changes in alpha 2M is the thiol ester, by which the events 'trapping' and exposure of the receptor-recognition site can be separated. In PZP, the crucial step for the conformational changes is the cleavage of the 'bait' region, since cleavage of the thiol ester does not lead to any detectable conformational changes by the methods used.     

Binding rates, O--S substitution effects, and the pH dependence of chymotrypsin reactions.

The pH dependence for acylation of alpha-chymotrypsin by N-acetyltryptophan p-nitrophenyl-, p-nitrothiophenyl-, ethyl-, and thiolethyl esters has been studied by the stopped-flow technique. Values for the acylation rate constant, k2, and the binding constant, KS, were obtained by using measurements of phenolate release, for the p-nitrophenyl esters, and proflavin displacement, for the ethyl esters. The oxygen esters tested have slightly higher k2 values, and substantially higher KS values relative to the analogous thiol esters. Whereas k2/KS for the thiolethyl ester is higher than that for the analogous oxygen ester, the k2/KS values for oxy- and thio-p-nitrophenyl esters are nearly identical. These data are interpreted to indicate rate-determining formation of a tetrahedral intermediate in acylation of alpha-chymotrypsin by p-nitrophenyl esters, and rate-determining breakdown of such an intermediate in the case of the ethyl esters. It is also concluded that the oxygen to sulfur substitution causes a substantial increase in the proportion of nonproductive binding in these substrates. pH dependent k2 and KS values were used to calculate values for k1 and k-1, the binding and debinding rate constants for the two p-nitrophenyl compounds. This is the first such calculation based on experimentally determined acylation rate constants.     

Hydrolysis of oxo- and thio-esters by human butyrylcholinesterase

Catalytic parameters of human butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) for hydrolysis of homologous pairs of oxo-esters and thio-esters were compared. Substrates were positively charged (benzoylcholine versus benzoylthiocholine) and neutral (phenylacetate versus phenylthioacetate). In addition to wild-type BuChE, enzymes containing mutations were used. Single mutants at positions: G117, a key residue in the oxyanion hole, and D70, the main component of the peripheral anionic site were tested. Double mutants containing G117H and mutations on residues of the oxyanion hole (G115, A199), or the pi-cation binding site (W82), or residue E197 that is involved in stabilization of tetrahedral intermediates were also studied. A mathematical analysis was used to compare data for BuChE-catalyzed hydrolysis of various pairs of oxo-esters and thio-esters and to determine the rate-limiting step of catalysis for each substrate. The interest and limitation of this method is discussed. Molecular docking was used to analyze how the mutations could have altered the binding of the oxo-ester or the thio-ester. Results indicate that substitution of the ethereal oxygen for sulfur in substrates may alter the adjustment of substrate in the active site and stabilization of the transition-state for acylation. This affects the k2/k3 ratio and, in turn, controls the rate-limiting step of the hydrolytic reaction. Stabilization of the transition state is modulated both by the alcohol and acyl moieties of substrate. Interaction of these groups with the ethereal hetero-atom can have a neutral, an additive or an antagonistic effect on transition state stabilization, depending on their molecular structure, size and enantiomeric configuration.     

The importance of a distal hydrogen bonding group in stabilizing the transition state in subtilisin BPN'

Stabilization of an oxyanion transition state is important to catalysis of peptide bond hydrolysis in all proteases. For subtilisin BPN', a bacterial serine protease, structural data suggest that two hydrogen bonds stabilize the tetrahedral-like oxyanion intermediate: one from the main chain NH of Ser221 and another from the side chain NH2 of Asn155. Molecular dynamic studies (Rao, S., N., Singh, U., C. Bush, P. A., and Kollman, P. A. (1987) Nature 328, 551-554) have indicated the gamma-hydroxyl of Thr220 may be a third hydrogen bond donor even though it is 4A away in the static x-ray structure. We have probed the role of Thr220 by replacing it with serine, cysteine, valine, or alanine by site-directed mutagenesis. These substitutions were intended to alter the size and hydrogen bonding ability of residue 220. Removal of the gamma-hydroxyl group reduced the transition state stabilization energy (delta delta GT) by 1.8-2.1 kcal/mol depending upon the substitution. By comparison, removal of the gamma-methyl group in the Thr220 to serine mutation only decreased delta GT by 0.5 kcal/mol. The gamma-hydroxyl of Thr220 is most important for catalysis, not substrate binding, because virtually all of the effects were on kcat and not KM. The role of the Thr220 hydroxyl is functionally independent from the amide NH2 of Asn155 because the free energy effects of double alanine mutants at these two positions are additive. These data indicate that a distal hydrogen bond donor, namely the hydroxyl of Thr220, plays a functionally important role in stabilizing the oxyanion transition state in subtilisin which is independent of Asn155.     

Thionesters as a probe for electrophilic catalysis in the serine protease mechanism

Specific and nonspecific thionester substrates for alpha-chymotrypsin and subtilisin Carlsberg have been synthesized and the kinetic parameters for their enzyme-catalyzed hydrolyses measured. Despite equal nonenzymic reactivities of ester-thionester pairs, each thionester is considerably less reactive toward enzymic hydrolysis, the difference being greatest for the specific substrates. The data support the operation of electrophilic catalysis by a hydrogen bond network at the carbonyl oxygen adjacent to the scissile bond of the substrate. The free energy of stabilization is 19 kJ mol-1 for a specific thionester substrate and will be higher for oxygen esters and amides. Chymotrypsin binds esters and thionesters about equally well, whereas subtilisin binds thionesters more tightly. This is consistent with continuous hydrogen bonding in the chymotrypsin mechanism and with a differential hydrogen bonding mechanism for subtilisin. A comparison of the relative rates of enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of ester and thionester substrates with their relative reactivities toward amines does not support an acyl histidine intermediate in the serine protease mechanism.     

Electrostatic effects and binding determinants in the catalysis of prolyl oligopeptidase. Site specific mutagenesis at the oxyanion binding site

Prolyl oligopeptidase, a member of a new family of serine peptidases, plays an important role in memory disorders. Earlier x-ray crystallographic investigations indicated that stabilization of the tetrahedral transition state of the reaction involved hydrogen bond formation between the oxyanion of the tetrahedral intermediate and the OH group of Tyr(473). The contribution of the OH group was tested with the Y473F variant using various substrates. The charged succinyl-Gly-Pro-4-nitroanilide was hydrolyzed with a much lower k(cat)/K(m) compared with the neutral benzyloxycarbonyl-G1y-Pro-2-naphthylamide, although the binding modes of the two substrates were similar, as shown by x-ray crystallography. This suggested that electrostatic interactions between Arg(643) and the succinyl group competed with the productive binding mechanism. Unlike most enzyme reactions, catalysis by the wild-type enzyme exhibited positive activation entropy. In contrast, the activation entropy for the Y473F variant was negative, suggesting that the tyrosine OH group is involved in stabilizing both the transition state and the water shell at the active site. Importantly, Tyr(473) is also implicated in the formation of the enzyme-substrate complex. The nonlinear Arrhenius plot suggested a greater significance of the oxyanion binding site at physiological temperature. The results indicated that Tyr(473) was more needed at high pH, at high temperature, and with charged substrates exhibiting "internally competitive inhibition."     

Direct crystallographic observation of an acyl-enzyme intermediate in the elastase-catalyzed hydrolysis of a peptidyl ester substrate: Exploiting the "glass transition" in protein dynamics

The crystal structure of the acyl complex of porcine pancreatic elastase with its peptidyl ester substrate N-acetyl-ala-ala-ala-methyl ester (Ac(Ala)3OMe) has been determined at 2.5 A resolution. The complex was stabilized by exploiting the "glass transition" in protein dynamics that occurs at around -53 degrees C (220 K). Substrate was flowed into the crystal in a cryoprotective solvent above this temperature, and then the crystal was rapidly cooled to a temperature below the transition to trap the species that formed. The use of a flow cell makes the experiment a kinetic one and means that the species prior to the rate determining transition state has a chance to accumulate. The resulting crystal structure shows an acyl-enzyme intermediate in which the leaving group is absent and the carbonyl carbon of the C-terminal alanine residue is covalently bound to the gamma oxygen of the active site serine. The ester carbonyl shows no significant distortion from planarity, with the carbonyl oxygen forming one hydrogen bond with the oxyanion hole. The tripeptide is bound in an extended antiparallel beta-sheet with main chain residues of the enzyme. The geometry and interactions of this acyl-enzyme suggest that it represents a productive intermediate. To test this hypothesis, the same crystal was then warmed above the glass transition temperature and a second data set was collected. The resulting electron density map shows no sign of the substrate, indicating hydrolysis of the intermediate followed by product release. This experiment provides direct evidence for the importance of dynamic properties in catalysis and also provides a blueprint for the stabilization of other short-lived species for direct crystallographic observation.     

Probing the mechanism and improving the rate of substrate-assisted catalysis in subtilisin BPN'

A mutant of the serine protease, subtilisin BPN', in which the catalytic His64 is replaced by Ala (H64A), is very specific for substrates containing a histidine, presumably by the substrate-bound histidine assisting in catalysis [Carter, P., & Wells, J.A. (1987) Science (Washington, D.C.) 237, 394-399]. Here we probe the catalytic mechanism of H64A subtilisin for cleaving His and non-His substrates. We show that the ratio of aminolysis to hydrolysis is the same for ester and amide substrates as catalyzed by the H64A subtilisin. This is consistent with formation of a common acyl-enzyme intermediate for H64A subtilisin, analogous to the mechanism of the wild-type enzyme. However, the catalytic efficiencies (kcat/KM) for amidase and esterase activities with His-containing substrates are reduced by 5000-fold and 14-fold, respectively, relative to wild-type subtilisin BPN, suggesting that acylation is more compromised than deacylation in the H64A mutant. High concentrations of imidazole are much less effective than His substrates in promoting hydrolysis by the H64A variant, suggesting that the His residue on the bound (not free) substrate is involved in catalysis. The reduction in catalytic efficiency kcat/KM for hydrolysis of the amide substrate upon replacement of the oxyanion stabilizing asparagine (N155G) is only 7-fold greater for wild-type than H64A subtilisin. In contrast, the reductions in kcat/KM upon replacement of the catalytic serine (S221A) or aspartate (D32A) are about 3000-fold greater for wild-type than H64A subtilisin, suggesting that the functional interactions between the Asp32 and Ser221 with the substrate histidine are more compromised in substrate-assisted catalysis.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Esterolytic antibodies as mechanistic and structural models of hydrolases-a quantitative analysis

Understanding enzymes quantitatively and mimicking their remarkable catalytic efficiency is a paramount challenge. Here, we applied esterolytic antibodies (the D-Abs) to dissect and quantify individual elements of enzymatic catalysis such as transition state (TS) stabilization, nucleophilic reactivity and conformational changes. Kinetic and mutagenic analysis of the D-Abs were combined with existing structural evidence to show that catalysis by the D-Abs is driven primarily by stabilization of the tetrahedral oxyanionic intermediate of ester hydrolysis formed by the nucleophilic attack of an exogenous (solution) hydroxide anion. The side-chain of TyrH100d is shown to be the main H-bond donor of the D-Abs oxyanion hole. The pH-rate and pH-binding profiles indicate that the strength of this H-bond increases dramatically as the neutral substrate develops into the oxyanionic TS, resulting in TS stabilization of 5-7 kcal/mol, which is comparable to oxyanionic TS stabilization in serine hydrolases. We show that the rate of the exogenous (intermolecular) nucleophilic attack can be enhanced by 2000-fold by replacing the hydroxide nucleophile with peroxide, an alpha-nucleophile that is much more reactive than hydroxide. In the presence of peroxide, the rate saturates (k(cat)(max)) at 6 s(-1). This rate-ceiling appears to be dictated by the rate of the induced-fit conformational rearrangement leading to the active antibody-TS complex. The selective usage of negatively charged exogenous nucleophiles by the D-Abs led to the identification of a positively charged channel. Imprinted by the negatively-charged TS-analogue against which these antibodies were elicited, this channel presumably directs the nucleophile to the antibody-bound substrate. Our findings are discussed in comparison with serine esterases and, in particular, with cocaine esterase (cocE), which possesses a tyrosine based oxyanion hole.