Revisiting the Role of Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator and Counterion Permeability in the pH Regulation of Endocytic Organelles

Organellar acidification by the electrogenic vacuolar proton-ATPase is coupled to anion uptake and cation efflux to preserve electroneutrality. The defective organellar pH regulation, caused by impaired counterion conductance of the mutant cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), remains highly controversial in epithelia and macrophages. Restricting the pH-sensitive probe to CFTR-containing vesicles, the counterion and proton permeability, and the luminal pH of endosomes were measured in various cells, including genetically matched CF and non-CF human respiratory epithelia, as well as cftr^+/+ and cftr^−/− mouse alveolar macrophages. Passive proton and relative counterion permeabilities, determinants of endosomal, lysosomal, and phagosomal pH-regulation, were probed with FITC-conjugated transferrin, dextran, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, respectively. Although CFTR function could be documented in recycling endosomes and immature phagosomes, neither channel activation nor inhibition influenced the pH in any of these organelles. CFTR heterologous overexpression also failed to alter endocytic organellar pH. We propose that the relatively large CFTR-independent counterion and small passive proton permeability ensure efficient shunting of the proton-ATPase–generated membrane potential. These results have implications in the regulation of organelle acidification in general and demonstrate that perturbations of the endolysosomal organelles pH homeostasis cannot be linked to the etiology of the CF lung disease.     

Determinants of the phagosomal pH in macrophages. In situ assessment of vacuolar H(+)-ATPase activity, counterion conductance, and H+ "leak".

We studied the factors that determine the intraphagosomal pH (pHp) in elicited murine peritoneal macrophages. pHp was measured in situ by recording the fluorescence of covalently fluoresceinated Staphylococcus aureus ingested by the macrophages. Following spontaneous acidification of the phagosomes, passive (leak) H+ permeability was determined measuring the rate of change of pHp upon complete inhibition of the H+ pump with bafilomycin A1. A significant, but comparatively low passive H+ permeability was detected. The existence of a passive H+ leak implies that continuous energy expenditure is required for the maintenance of an acidic pHp. In combination with ionophores, bafilomycin was also used to estimate the counterion permeability. The counterion conductance was found to be severalfold higher than the H+ leak. Ion substitution experiments in electropermeabilized cells and the inhibitory effects of quinine and 5-nitro-2-(3-phenylpropylamino)benzoic acid suggest that both monovalent anions and cations permeate the phagosomal membrane. The activity of the H+ pump was measured at various pHp levels. In the steady state, the rate of H+ pumping was considerably lower than counterion permeation. These findings suggest that the phagosomal membrane potential is insignificant. Consistent with this notion, increasing phagosomal conductance with ionophores failed to accelerate the rate of H+ pumping. Thus, the transmembrane delta pH is the predominant component of the proton-motive force across the phagosomal membrane in the steady state. The rate of H+ pumping was found to decrease steeply as the phagosomal lumen became acidified. Therefore, the pH sensitivity of the H+ pump, which possibly reflects a kinetic or allosteric effect, is the primary determinant of pHp.     

Inhibitors of proton pumping: effect on passive proton transport

Reported inhibitors of the Characean plasmalemma proton pump were tested for their ability to inhibit the passive H⁺ conductance which develops in Chara corallina Klein ex Willd. at high pH. Diethylstilbestrol inhibits the proton pump and the passive H⁺ conductance with about the same time course, at concentrations that have no effect on cytoplasmic streaming. N-Ethylmaleimide, a sulfhydryl reagent which is small and relatively nonpolar, also inhibits both pumping and passive conductance of H⁺. However, it also inhibits cytoplasmic streaming with about the same time course, and therefore could not be considered a specific ATPase inhibitor. p-Chloromercuribenzene sulfonate (PCMBS), a sulfhydryl reagent which is large and charged and hence less able to penetrate the membrane, does not inhibit pumping or conductance at low concentration. At high concentration, PCMBS sometimes inhibits pumping without affecting H⁺ conductance, but since streaming is also inhibited, the effect on the pump cannot be said to be specific. 1-Ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide, a water soluble carbodiimide, weakly inhibits both pump and conductance, apparently specifically.     

Luminal and cytosolic pH feedback on proton pump activity and ATP affinity of V-type ATPase from Arabidopsis

Proton pumping of the vacuolar-type H(+)-ATPase into the lumen of the central plant organelle generates a proton gradient of often 1-2 pH units or more. Although structural aspects of the V-type ATPase have been studied in great detail, the question of whether and how the proton pump action is controlled by the proton concentration on both sides of the membrane is not understood. Applying the patch clamp technique to isolated vacuoles from Arabidopsis mesophyll cells in the whole-vacuole mode, we studied the response of the V-ATPase to protons, voltage, and ATP. Current-voltage relationships at different luminal pH values indicated decreasing coupling ratios with acidification. A detailed study of ATP-dependent H(+)-pump currents at a variety of different pH conditions showed a complex regulation of V-ATPase activity by both cytosolic and vacuolar pH. At cytosolic pH 7.5, vacuolar pH changes had relative little effects. Yet, at cytosolic pH 5.5, a 100-fold increase in vacuolar proton concentration resulted in a 70-fold increase of the affinity for ATP binding on the cytosolic side. Changes in pH on either side of the membrane seem to be transferred by the V-ATPase to the other side. A mathematical model was developed that indicates a feedback of proton concentration on peak H(+) current amplitude (v(max)) and ATP consumption (K(m)) of the V-ATPase. It proposes that for efficient V-ATPase function dissociation of transported protons from the pump protein might become higher with increasing pH. This feature results in an optimization of H(+) pumping by the V-ATPase according to existing H(+) concentrations.     

GPHR is a novel anion channel critical for acidification and functions of the Golgi apparatus

The organelles within secretory and endocytotic pathways in mammalian cells have acidified lumens, and regulation of their acidic pH is critical for the trafficking, processing and glycosylation of cargo proteins and lipids, as well as the morphological integrity of the organelles. How organelle lumen acidification is regulated, and how luminal pH elevation disturbs these fundamental cellular processes, is largely unknown. Here, we describe a novel molecule involved in Golgi acidification. First, mutant cells defective in Golgi acidification were established that exhibited delayed protein transport, impaired glycosylation and Golgi disorganization. Using expression cloning, a novel Golgi-resident multi-transmembrane protein, named Golgi pH regulator (GPHR), was identified as being responsible for the mutant cells. After reconstitution in planar lipid bilayers, GPHR exhibited a voltage-dependent anion-channel activity that may function in counterion conductance. Thus, GPHR modulates Golgi functions through regulation of acidification.     

V-ATPase engagement in autophagic processes

The proton pumping activity of V-ATPase is responsible for acidification of the lysosome/vacuole. The low lumenal pH of this organelle stimulates the activity of a battery of resident hydrolases responsible for the degradation of various nonselective and selective cargos delivered by autophagic processes. However, the role of V-ATPase in membrane dynamics required for the uptake of autophagic cargo is far from fully understood. Consideration of the available data leads us to speculate that autophagic processes involving direct membrane-to-membrane contacts between the selected cargo and the vacuolar membrane require functional V-ATPase.     

V-ATPase engagement in autophagic processes

The proton pumping activity of V-ATPase is responsible for acidification of the lysosome/vacuole. The low lumenal pH of this organelle stimulates the activity of a battery of resident hydrolases responsible for the degradation of various nonselective and selective cargos delivered by autophagic processes. However, the role of V-ATPase in membrane dynamics required for the uptake of autophagic cargo is far from fully understood. Consideration of the available data leads us to speculate that autophagic processes involving direct membrane-to-membrane contacts between the selected cargo and the vacuolar membrane require functional V-ATPase.     

Proton permeation of lipid bilayers

Proton permeation of the lipid bilayer barrier has two unique features. First, permeability coefficients measured at neutral pH ranges are six to seven orders of magnitude greater than expected from knowledge of other monovalent cations. Second, proton conductance across planar lipid bilayers varies at most by a factor of 10 when pH is varied from near 1 to near 11. Two mechanisms have been proposed to account for this anomalous behavior: proton conductance related to contaminants of lipid bilayers, and proton translocation along transient hydrogen-bonded chains (tHBC) of associated water molecules in the membrane. The weight of evidence suggests that trace contaminants may contribute to proton conductance across planar lipid membranes at certain pH ranges, but cannot account for the anomalous proton flux in liposome systems.Two new results will be reported here which were designed to test the tHBC model. These include measurements of relative proton/potassium permeability in the gramicidin channel, and plots of proton flux against the magnitude of pH gradients. (1) The relative permeabilities of protons and potassium through the gramicidin channel, which contains a single strand of hydrogenbonded water molecules, were found to differ by at least four orders of magnitude when measured at neutral pH ranges. This result demonstrates that a hydrogen-bonded chain of water molecules can provide substantial discrimination between protons and other cations. It was also possible to calculate that if approximately 7% of bilayer water was present in a transient configuration similar to that of the gramicidin channel, it could account for the measured proton flux. (2) The plot of proton conductance against pH gradient across liposome membranes was superlinear, a result that is consistent with one of three alternative tHBC models for proton conductance described by Nagle elsewhere in this volume.     

Gloeobacter Rhodopsin,Limitation of Proton Pumping at High Electrochemical Load

We studied the photocurrents of a cyanobacterial rhodopsin Gloeobacter violaceus (GR) in Xenopus laevis oocytes and HEK-293 cells. This protein is a light-driven proton pump with striking similarities to marine proteorhodopsins, including the D121-H87 cluster of the retinal Schiff base counterion and a glutamate at position 132 that acts as a proton donor for chromophore reprotonation during the photocycle. Interestingly, at low extracellular pH_o and negative voltage, the proton flux inverted and directed inward. Using electrophysiological measurements of wild-type and mutant GR, we demonstrate that the electrochemical gradient limits outward-directed proton pumping and converts it into a purely passive proton influx. This conclusion contradicts the contemporary paradigm that at low pH, proteorhodopsins actively transport H⁺ into cells. We identified E132 and S77 as key residues that allow inward directed diffusion. Substitution of E132 with aspartate or S77 with either alanine or cysteine abolished the inward-directed current almost completely. The proton influx is likely caused by the pK_a of E132 in GR, which is lower than that of other microbial ion pumping rhodopsins. The advantage of such a low pK_a is an acceleration of the photocycle and high pump turnover at high light intensities.     

Gloeobacter Rhodopsin,Limitation of Proton Pumping at High Electrochemical Load

We studied the photocurrents of a cyanobacterial rhodopsin Gloeobacter violaceus (GR) in Xenopus laevis oocytes and HEK-293 cells. This protein is a light-driven proton pump with striking similarities to marine proteorhodopsins, including the D121-H87 cluster of the retinal Schiff base counterion and a glutamate at position 132 that acts as a proton donor for chromophore reprotonation during the photocycle. Interestingly, at low extracellular pH_o and negative voltage, the proton flux inverted and directed inward. Using electrophysiological measurements of wild-type and mutant GR, we demonstrate that the electrochemical gradient limits outward-directed proton pumping and converts it into a purely passive proton influx. This conclusion contradicts the contemporary paradigm that at low pH, proteorhodopsins actively transport H⁺ into cells. We identified E132 and S77 as key residues that allow inward directed diffusion. Substitution of E132 with aspartate or S77 with either alanine or cysteine abolished the inward-directed current almost completely. The proton influx is likely caused by the pK_a of E132 in GR, which is lower than that of other microbial ion pumping rhodopsins. The advantage of such a low pK_a is an acceleration of the photocycle and high pump turnover at high light intensities.     

Voltage- and pH-Dependent Changes in Vectoriality of Photocurrents Mediated by Wild-type and Mutant Proteorhodopsins upon Expression in Xenopus Oocytes

Proteorhodopsin (PR), a light-driven proton pump from marine proteobacteria, exhibits photocycle characteristics similar to bacteriorhodopsin (BR) at neutral pH, including an M-like photointermediate. However, at acidic pH, spectroscopic evidence for an M-like species was absent, and the vectoriality of proton pumping was inverted. To gain further insight into this unusual property, we examined the voltage dependence of stationary and laser flash-induced photocurrents of PR under different pH conditions upon expression in Xenopus oocytes. The current-voltage curves were linear under all conditions tested, and photocurrent reversal potentials distinctly depended on the pH gradient. PR mutants D97N and D97T exhibited transient and stationary inward currents already at neutral pH, showing that neutralization of the proton acceptor abolishes forward pumping and permits only inward proton transport. Mutation E108G, which disrupts the donor site for Schiff base (SB) reprotonation, resulted in largely reduced photocurrents, which could be strongly stimulated by azide, similar to previous observations on BR mutant D96G. When PR and BR photocurrents in response to blue or green laser flashes during or after continuous illumination were compared, direct electrical evidence for the occurrence of an M-like intermediate at neutral pH could only be obtained when reprotonation of the SB was slowed down by PR mutation E108G. For PR at acidic pH, laser flashes only produced inwardly directed photocurrents, independent from background illumination, thus precluding electrical identification of an M-like species. However, when visible absorption spectroscopy was carried out at low temperatures, occurrence of an M-like species was robustly observed at low pH. This indicates that SB deprotonation and reprotonation occur during the PR photocycle also at low pH. Our results corroborate the conclusion that in PR, the direction of proton pumping can be switched by changes in pH and membrane potential, with the protonation state of Asp-97 being the key determinant for selecting between transport modes.     

Aspartate-histidine interaction in the retinal schiff base counterion of the light-driven proton pump of Exiguobacterium sibiricum

One of the distinctive features of eubacterial retinal-based proton pumps, proteorhodopsins, xanthorhodopsin, and others, is hydrogen bonding of the key aspartate residue, the counterion to the retinal Schiff base, to a histidine. We describe properties of the recently found eubacterium proton pump from Exiguobacterium sibiricum (named ESR) expressed in Escherichia coli, especially features that depend on Asp-His interaction, the protonation state of the key aspartate, Asp85, and its ability to accept a proton from the Schiff base during the photocycle. Proton pumping by liposomes and E. coli cells containing ESR occurs in a broad pH range above pH 4.5. Large light-induced pH changes indicate that ESR is a potent proton pump. Replacement of His57 with methionine or asparagine strongly affects the pH-dependent properties of ESR. In the H57M mutant, a dramatic decrease in the quantum yield of chromophore fluorescence emission and a 45 nm blue shift of the absorption maximum with an increase in the pH from 5 to 8 indicate deprotonation of the counterion with a pK(a) of 6.3, which is also the pK(a) at which the M intermediate is observed in the photocycle of the protein solubilized in detergent [dodecyl maltoside (DDM)]. This is in contrast with the case for the wild-type protein, for which the same experiments show that the major fraction of Asp85 is deprotonated at pH >3 and that it protonates only at low pH, with a pK(a) of 2.3. The M intermediate in the wild-type photocycle accumulates only at high pH, with an apparent pK(a) of 9, via deprotonation of a residue interacting with Asp85, presumably His57. In liposomes reconstituted with ESR, the pK(a) values for M formation and spectral shifts are 2-3 pH units lower than in DDM. The distinctively different pH dependencies of the protonation of Asp85 and the accumulation of the M intermediate in the wild-type protein versus the H57M mutant indicate that there is strong Asp-His interaction, which substantially lowers the pK(a) of Asp85 by stabilizing its deprotonated state.     

The sodium proton exchanger NHE9 regulates phagosome maturation and bactericidal activity in macrophages

Acidification of phagosomes is essential for the bactericidal activity of macrophages. Targeting machinery that regulates pH within the phagosomes is a prominent strategy employed by various pathogens that have emerged as major threats to public health. Nascent phagosomes acquire the machinery for pH regulation through a graded maturation process involving fusion with endolysosomes. Meticulous coordination between proton pumping and leakage mechanisms is crucial for maintaining optimal pH within the phagosome. However, relative to mechanisms involved in acidifying the phagosome lumen, little is known about proton leakage pathways in this organelle. Sodium proton transporter NHE9 is a known proton leakage pathway located on the endosomes. As phagosomes acquire proteins through fusions with endosomes during maturation, NHE9 seemed a promising candidate for regulating proton fluxes on the phagosome. Here, using genetic and biophysical approaches, we show NHE9 is an important proton leakage pathway associated with the maturing phagosome. NHE9 is highly expressed in immune cells, specifically macrophages; however, NHE9 expression is strongly downregulated upon bacterial infection. We show that compensatory ectopic NHE9 expression hinders the directed motion of phagosomes along microtubules and promotes early detachment from the microtubule tracks. As a result, these phagosomes have shorter run lengths and are not successful in reaching the lysosome. In accordance with this observation, we demonstrate that NHE9 expression levels negatively correlate with bacterial survival. Together, our findings show that NHE9 regulates lumenal pH to affect phagosome maturation, and consequently, microbicidal activity in macrophages.     

Nitrate-Sensitive ATPase Activity and Proton Pumping in Guard Cell Protoplasts of Commelina

ATPase activity was measured in crude homogenates of guard cellprotoplasts of Commelina communis L. using a linked enzyme assay.A low level of azide-sensitive ATPase activity was detectedwith a pH optimum of 6.8. This activity was stimulated by 0.01%(v/v) Triton X-100, and the pH optimum shifted to pH 7.4. Nitrate-sensitiveATPase activity was measured in the presence of azide and showeda pH optimum around pH 8.0. Proton pumping activity in a mixedpopulation of vesicles from GCP was monitored using fluorescencequenching of quinacrine. Mg-ATP dependent proton pumping wasobserved at pH 8.0, but not at pH 6.6. The activity at pH 8.0was inhibited by nitrate and DCCD but not vanadate. These dataindicate that activity of the tonoplast proton pump was beingmeasured. There was, however, no evidence for a tonoplast cation(K⁺)/proton antiporter under these assay conditions as potassiumdid not reduce the initial rate of pH gradient formation orincrease the rate of collapse of a pre-formed gradient afterinhibition of the pump. Key words: Tonoplast ATPase, proton pump, guard cell protoplasts, Commelina     

Chloride ion binding to bacteriorhodopsin at low pH: an infrared spectroscopic study

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and halorhodopsin (hR) are light-induced ion pumps in the cell membrane of Halobacterium salinarium. Under normal conditions bR is an outward proton transporter, whereas hR is an inward Cl- transporter. There is strong evidence that at very low pH and in the presence of Cl-, bR transports Cl- ions into the cell, similarly to hR. The chloride pumping activity of bR is connected to the so-called acid purple state. To account for the observed effects in bR a tentative complex counterion was suggested for the protonated Schiff base of the retinal chromophore. It would consist of three charged residues: Asp-85, Asp-212, and Arg-82. This quadruplet (including the Schiff base) would also serve as a Cl- binding site at low pH. We used Fourier transform infrared difference spectroscopy to study the structural changes during the transitions between the normal, acid blue, and acid purple states. Asp-85 and Asp-212 were shown to participate in the transitions. During the normal-to-acid blue transition, Asp-85 protonates. When the pH is further lowered in the presence of Cl-, Cl- binds and Asp-212 also protonates. The binding of Cl- and the protonation of Asp-212 occur simultaneously, but take place only when Asp-85 is already protonated. It is suggested that HCl is taken up in undissociated form in exchange for a neutral water molecule.     

Aspartic acid 85 in bacteriorhodopsin functions both as proton acceptor and negative counterion to the Schiff base.

In bacteriorhodopsin Asp85 has been proposed to function both as a negative counterion to the Schiff base and as proton acceptor in the early stages of the photocycle. To test this proposal further, we have replaced Asp85 by His. The rationale for this replacement is that although His can function as a proton acceptor, it cannot provide a negative charge at residue 85 to serve as a counterion to the protonated Schiff base. We show here that the absorption spectrum of the D85H mutant is highly sensitive to the pH of the external medium. From spectroscopic titrations, we have determined the apparent pK for deprotonation of the Schiff base to be 8.8 +/- 0.1 and the apparent pK for protonation of the His85 side chain to be approximately 3.5. Between pH 3.5 and 8.8, where the Schiff base is protonated, and the His side chain is deprotonated, the D85H mutant is completely inactive in proton transport. Time-resolved studies show that there is no detectable formation of an M-like intermediate in the photocycle of the D85H mutant. These experiments show that the presence of a neutral proton-accepting moiety at residue 85 is not sufficient for carrying out light-driven proton transport. The requirements at residue 85 are therefore for a group that serves both as a negatively charged counterion and as a proton acceptor.     

A cation counterflux supports lysosomal acidification

The profound luminal acidification essential for the degradative function of lysosomes requires a counter-ion flux to dissipate an opposing voltage that would prohibit proton accumulation. It has generally been assumed that a parallel anion influx is the main or only counter-ion transport that enables acidification. Indeed, defective anion conductance has been suggested as the mechanism underlying attenuated lysosome acidification in cells deficient in CFTR or ClC-7. To assess the individual contribution of counter-ions to acidification, we devised means of reversibly and separately permeabilizing the plasma and lysosomal membranes to dialyze the cytosol and lysosome lumen in intact cells, while ratiometrically monitoring lysosomal pH. Replacement of cytosolic Cl⁻ with impermeant anions did not significantly alter proton pumping, while the presence of permeant cations in the lysosomal lumen supported acidification. Accordingly, the lysosomes were found to acidify to the same pH in both CFTR- and ClC-7–deficient cells. We conclude that cations, in addition to chloride, can support lysosomal acidification and defects in lysosomal anion conductance cannot explain the impaired microbicidal capacity of CF phagocytes.     

Counterion collapse and the effect of diamines on bacteriorhodopsin

A recent report of electrical measurements on oriented bacteriorhodopsin in gels [(1986) FEBS Lett. 195, 164 168] concluded that low concentrations of diamines reversed the direction of the proton pump. Calculations are presented which show that in low diamine concentrations, charge displacements of the counterion atmosphere in the direction opposite to proton pumping are expected following H+ ejection. It is also shown that the effect will be sharply reduced by raising the diamine concentration or by adding excess salt, as was observed. Hence it is not necessary to conclude that diamines reverse the direction of the proton pump itself.     

Specificity of the proton adenosinetriphosphatase of Escherichia coli for adenine, guanine, and inosine nucleotides in catalysis and binding

Specificity of the Escherichia coli proton ATPase for adenine, guanine, and inosine nucleotides in catalysis and binding was studied. MgADP, CaADP, MgGDP, and MgIDP were each good substrates for oxidative phosphorylation. The corresponding triphosphates were each substrates for hydrolysis and proton pumping. At 1 mM concentration, MgATP, MgGTP, and MgITP drove proton pumping with equal efficiency. At 0.1 mM concentration, MgATP was 4-fold more efficient than MgITP or MgGTP. Nucleotide-depleted soluble F1 could rebind to F1-depleted membranes and block proton conductivity through F0; rebound nucleotide-depleted F1 catalyzed pH gradient formation with MgATP, MgGTP, or MgITP. This showed that the nonexchangeable nucleotide sites on F1 need not be occupied by adenine nucleotide for proton pumping to occur. It was further shown that no nucleotide was tightly bound in the nonexchangeable sites of F1 during proton pumping driven by MgGTP in these reconstituted membranes, whereas adenine nucleotide was tightly bound when MgATP was the substrate. Nucleotide-depleted soluble F1 bound maximally 5.9 ATP, 3.2 GTP, and 3.6 ITP of which half the ATP and almost all of the GTP and ITP exchanged over a period of 30-240 min with medium ADP or ATP. Also, half of the bound ATP exchanged with medium GTP or ITP. These data showed that inosine and guanine nucleotides do not bind to soluble F1 in nonexchangeable fashion, in contrast to adenine nucleotides. Purified alpha-subunit from F1 bound ATP at a single site but showed no binding of GTP nor ITP, supporting previous suggestions that the non-exchangeable sites in intact F1 are on alpha-subunits.