Effects of metal ions and catalytic loop sequences on the complex formation of a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate

A deoxyribozyme is a catalytic DNA that catalyzes a site-specific RNA cleavage activity and requires various divalent cations. Earlier we have reported that by downsizing the catalytic loop of a deoxyribozyme from 15-mer to 11-mer it resulted in a short and novel Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme. In this paper, we investigate the complex formation of deoxyribozymes with their RNA substrates by using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) in order to determine quantitatively the effect of Ca2+ or Mg2+ on the recognition step between a deoxyribozyme and its RNA substrate. The results indicate that both the association and dissociation rate constants (k(a) and k(d)) for the deoxyribozyme-RNA complex depends on metal ions as well as the loop size of the deoxyribozyme. Metal ions with high RNA cleavage activity induced an increase in k(a) and a decrease in k(d). On the basis of the results, we propose that Ca2+ ions may play a role in the rearrangement of the 11-mer catalytic loop of the short Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme.     

Development of a short Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme with RNA cleavage activity.

We developed a short Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme with 11 mer catalytic loop domain (dGGCTACAACGA) that catalyzed site-specific RNA cleavage reaction between rA and rU. The second-order rate constant of this short deoxyribozyme is 1.7 x 10(7) M(-1) min(-1) at 37 degrees C, and this value is very similar to that of the deoxyribozyme (dGGCTAGCTACAACGA) in the presence of Ca2+.     

Immobilized small deoxyribozyme to distinguish RNA secondary structures

The RNA folding variation due to one or more mutations leads to different RNA splicing, RNA processing, and translational controls as a result of differences in the primary and higher-ordered structures that interact with other cellular molecules. Thus, distinguishing RNA folding is one of the guides to detect the gene functions related to disease and drug responses. We found, previously, a small Ca(2+)-dependent deoxyribozyme with its site-specific RNA cleavage [Sugimoto, N., Okumoto, Y., and Ohmichi, T. (1999) J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 2, 1382-1388]. In this study, we report the potential of this deoxyribozyme as a useful tool to distinguish RNA foldings. It is found that the immobilized deoxyribozyme using avidin-biotin interaction cleaves the target site within only single-stranded RNAs. The systematic design for the target RNA hairpin loops shows that the immobilized deoxyribozyme is able to cleave them with a > or =17 nucleotide loop size at only one site under single-turnover conditions. Furthermore, an RNA cleavage reaction is detected using the immobilized deoxyribozyme on a surface plasmon resonance (SPR) sensor chip. These results show that the immobilized deoxyribozymes on a column and on an SPR sensor chip become a novel and useful tool to distinguish the RNA foldings.     

Preferential activation of the 8-17 deoxyribozyme by Ca(2+) ions. Evidence for the identity of 8-17 with the catalytic domain of the Mg5 deoxyribozyme

The 8-17 deoxyribozyme is a small RNA-cleaving DNA molecule of potential therapeutic interest. Here, the cleavage rates of 16 variants of the 8-17 deoxyribozyme were measured in the presence of different divalent metal ions. Despite the fact that 8-17 was originally selected in vitro for activity in the presence of Mg(2+) (Santoro, S. W., and Joyce, G. F. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 94, 4262-4266) nearly all the 8-17 variants exhibited substantially higher (up to 20-fold) reaction rates in Ca(2+) as compared with Mg(2+). This preference for calcium ions critically depended on the nucleoside residues at two specific positions of the deoxyribozyme core. The Ca(2+) specificity of 8-17 is strongly reminiscent of the properties of Mg5, an RNA phosphodiester-cleaving deoxyribozyme previously isolated by Faulhammer and Famulok (Faulhammer, D., and Famulok, M. (1996) Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35, 2837-2841). Indeed, analysis of the Mg5 sequence revealed the presence of a complete 8-17 motif, coincident with the conserved region of Mg5. An 8-17 deoxyribozyme modeled after the Mg5 conserved region displayed catalytic features comparable with those reported for the full-length Mg5 deoxyribozyme.     

Nucleic acid mutation analysis using catalytic DNA

The sequence specificity of the ‘10–23’ RNA-cleaving DNA enzyme (deoxyribozyme) was utilised to discriminate between subtle differences in nucleic acid sequence in a relatively conserved segment of the L1 gene from a number of different human papilloma virus (HPV) genotypes. DNA enzymes specific for the different HPV types were found to cleave their respective target oligoribonucleotide substrates with high efficiency compared with their unmatched counterparts, which were usually not cleaved or cleaved with very low efficiency. This specificity was achieved despite the existence of only very small differences in the sequence of one binding arm. As an example of how this methodology may be applied to mutation analysis of tissue samples, type-specific deoxyribozyme cleavable substrates were generated by genomic PCR using a chimeric primer containing three bases of RNA. The RNA component enabled each amplicon to be cleavable in the presence of its matching deoxyribozyme. In this format, the specificity of deoxyribozyme cleavage is defined by Watson–Crick interactions between one substrate-binding domain (arm I) and the polymorphic sequence which is amplified during PCR. Deoxyribozyme-mediated cleavage of amplicons generated by this method was used to examine the HPV status of genomic DNA derived from Caski cells, which are known to be positive for HPV16. This method is applicable to many types of nucleic acid sequence variation, including single nucleotide polymorphisms.     

Development of a novel functional biosensor with a short Ca(2+)-dependent deoxyribozyme.

We develop a novel functional biosensor on a deoxyribozyme. A 5'-end-immobilized short Ca(2+)-dependent deoxyribozyme (dCGCTGGCAGGCTACAACGAGTCTTC) binds to a target RNA substrate (rGAAGACA decrease UGCCAGCG; decrease denotes an RNA cleavage site), and acts as an enzyme in the presence of Ca2+. It cleaves the target RNA substrate at one site of rAp decrease U in the asymmetric internal loop.     

Characterization of a catalytically efficient acidic RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme

We previously demonstrated—through the isolation of RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes by in vitro selection that are catalytically active in highly acidic solutions—that DNA, despite its chemical simplicity, could perform catalysis under challenging chemical conditions [Liu,Z., Mei,S.H., Brennan,J.D. and Li,Y. (2003) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125, 7539–7545]. One remarkable DNA molecule therefrom is pH4DZ1, a self-cleaving deoxyribozyme that exhibits a k_obs of ~1 min⁻¹ at pH 3.8. In this study, we carried out a series of experiments to examine the sequence and catalytic properties of this acidic deoxyribozyme. Extensive nucleotide truncation experiments indicated that pH4DZ1 was a considerably large deoxyribozyme, requiring ~80 out of the original 123 nt for the optimal catalytic activity. A reselection experiment identified ten absolutely conserved nucleotides that are distributed in three catalytically crucial sequence elements. In addition, a trans deoxyribozyme was successfully designed. Comparison of the observed rate constant of pH4DZ1 with experimentally determined rate constant for the uncatalyzed reaction revealed that pH4DZ1 achieved a rate enhancement of ~10⁶-fold. This study provides valuable information about this low-pH-functional deoxyribozyme and paves way for further structural and mechanistic characterization of this unique catalytic DNA.     

Multiple occurrences of an efficient self-phosphorylating deoxyribozyme motif

The catalytic and structural characteristics of two new self-phosphorylating deoxyribozymes (referred to as deoxyribozyme kinases), denoted "Dk3" and "Dk4", are compared to those of Dk2, a previously reported deoxyribozyme kinase. All three deoxyribozymes not only utilize GTP as the source of activated phosphate and Mn(II) as the divalent metal cofactor but also share a common secondary structure with significant sequence variations. Multiple Watson-Crick helices are identified within the secondary structure, and these helical interactions confine three extremely conserved sequence elements of 8, 5, and 14 nucleotides in length, presumably for the formation of the catalytic core for GTP binding and the self-phosphorylating reaction. The locations of the conserved regions suggest that these three deoxyribozymes arose independently from in vitro selection. The existence of three sequence variants of the same deoxyribozyme from the same in vitro selection experiment implies that these catalytic DNAs may represent the simplest structural solution for the DNA self-phosphorylation reaction when GTP is used as the substrate.     

Light-activated deoxyguanosine: photochemical regulation of peroxidase activity

Photochemical activation of a deoxyribozyme with peroxidase activity was achieved by the synthesis and incorporation of a caged deoxyguanosine.     

Target site selection for an RNA-cleaving catalytic DNA.

A small catalytic DNA, known as the 10-23 DNA enzyme or deoxyribozyme, has been shown to efficiently hydrolyze RNA at purine-pyrimidine (R-Y) junctions in vitro. Although these potentially cleavable junctions are ubiquitous, they are often protected from deoxyribozyme activity by RNA secondary structure. We have developed a multiplex cleavage assay for screening the entire length of a target RNA molecule for deoxyribozyme cleavage sites that are efficient, both in terms of kinetics and accessibility. This strategy allowed us to simultaneously compare the RNA cleaving activity of 80 deoxyribozymes for a model target gene (HPV16 E6), and an additional 60 deoxyribozymes against the rat c-myc target. The human papilloma virus (HPV) target was used primarily to characterize the multiplex system and determine its validity. The c-myc target, coupled with a smooth muscle cell proliferation assay, allowed us to assess the relationship between in vitro cleavage efficiency and c-myc gene suppression in cell culture. The multiplex reaction approach streamlines the process of revealing effective deoxyribozymes in a functional assay and provides accessibility data that may also be applicable to site selection for other hybridization-based agents.     

In Vitro Selection of a Deoxyribozyme That Can Utilize Multiple Substrates

Deoxyribozymes that could catalyze the formation of an internucleotide phosphorothioester linkage were selected from a random sequence pool. During the course of the selection, the pool was successively challenged with five oligonucleotide substrates, each of which terminated in the same hexanucleotide sequence. Selected deoxyribozyme ligases could use all five substrates, albeit to different degrees, and appeared to form secondary structures that allow differential pairing between the deoxyribozyme and each substrate. These results suggest that early replicases may have been able to bind a variety of oligonucleotide substrates while catalyzing ligation via a common junction. Received: 12 December 2000 / Accepted: 28 June 2001     

Characterization of a DNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme

A copper-dependent self-cleaving DNA that was isolated by in vitro selection has been minimized to its smallest active domain using both in vitro selection and rational design methods. The minimized 46-nucleotide deoxyribozyme forms duplex and triplex substructures that flank a highly conserved catalytic core. This self-cleaving construct can be converted into a bimolecular complex that comprises separate substrate and enzyme domains. Substrate cleavage is directed at one of two adjacent nucleotides and proceeds via an oxidative cleavage mechanism that is unique to the position cleaved. The structural, kinetic and mechanistic characteristics of this DNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme are reported.     

Kinetic and thermodynamic characterization of the RNA-cleaving 8-17 deoxyribozyme

The 8-17 deoxyribozyme is a small DNA catalyst of significant applicative interest. We have analyzed the kinetic features of a well behaved 8-17 construct and determined the influence of several reaction conditions on such features, providing a basis for further exploration of the deoxyribozyme mechanism. The 8-17 bound its substrate with a rate constant ~10-fold lower than those typical for the annealing of short complementary oligonucleotides. The observed free energy of substrate binding indicates that an energetic penalty near to +7 kcal/mol is attributable to the deoxyribozyme core. Substrate cleavage required divalent metal ion cofactors, and the dependence of activity on the concentration of Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺ or Mn²⁺ suggests the occurrence of a single, low-specificity binding site for activating ions. The efficiency of activation correlated with the Lewis acidity of the ion cofactor, compatible with a metal-assisted deprotonation of the reactive 2′-hydroxyl group. However, alternative roles of the metal ions cannot be excluded, because those ions that are stronger Lewis acids are also capable of forming stronger interactions with ligands such as the phosphate oxygens. The apparent enthalpy of activation for the 8-17 reaction was close to the values observed for hydroxide-catalyzed and hammerhead ribozyme-catalyzed RNA cleavage.     

Characterization of non-8-17 sequences uncovers structurally diverse RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes

RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes (DNAzymes) can be isolated from random-sequence DNA pools via the process of in vitro selection. However, small and simple catalytic motifs, such as the 8-17 DNAzyme, are commonly observed in sequence space, presenting a challenge in discovering large and complex DNAzymes. In an effort to investigate underrepresented molecular species derived from in vitro selection, in this study we sought to characterize non-8-17 sequences obtained from a previous in vitro selection experiment wherein the 8-17 deoxyribozyme was the dominant motif. We examined 9 sequence families from 21 motifs by characterizing their structural and functional features. We discovered 9 novel deoxyribozyme classes with large catalytic domains (>40 nucleotides) utilizing three-way or four-way junction structural frameworks. Kinetic studies revealed that these deoxyribozymes exhibit moderate to excellent catalytic rates (k(obs) from 0.003 to 1 min(-1)), compared to other known RNA-cleaving DNAzymes. Although chemical probing experiments, site-directed mutational analyses, and metal cofactor dependency tests suggest unique catalytic cores for each deoxyribozyme, common dinucleotide junction selectivity was observed between DNAzymes with similar secondary structural features. Together, our findings indicate that larger, structurally more complex, and diverse catalytic motifs are able to survive the process of in vitro selection despite a sequence space dominated by smaller and structurally simpler catalysts.     

Factors that contribute to efficient catalytic activity of a small Ca2+-dependent deoxyribozyme in relation to its RNA cleavage function

Recently, we found a small Ca(2+)-dependent deoxyribozyme (unmodified), d(GCCTGGCAG(1)G(2)C(3)T(4)A(5)C(6)A(7)A(8)C(9)G(10)A(11)GTCCCT), with cleavage activity for its RNA substrate, r(AGGGACA downward arrow UGCCAGGC) ( downward arrow denotes the RNA cleavage site), in the presence of Ca(2+) and developed a functional SPR sensor chip with this deoxyribozyme [Okumoto, Y., Ohmichi, T., and Sugimoto, N. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 2769-2773]. In the study presented here, to clarify the factors contributing to the efficient catalytic activity of the unmodified deoxyribozyme, RNA cleavage reactions were carried out using 24 mutant deoxyribozymes containing one unnatural DNA nucleotide, such as dI (2'-deoxyinosine), 7-deaza-dG, 2-aminopurine, 7-deaza-dA, 2-amino-dA, dm(5)C (5-methyl-2'-deoxycytosine), or d(P)C (5-propynyl-2'-deoxycytosine). The K(m) values (Michaelis constants) with the mutants that lacked N7 and O6 of G(1) and O6 of G(2) were 4.5 and 6.6 times that of the unmodified one, respectively. The k(cat) value (cleavage rate constant) with the mutants that lacked O6 of G(10) was 0.025 times that of the unmodified one. The results of UV melting curves, SPR kinetics, and CD spectra supported the quantitative idea that the catalytic activity of the unmodified form was achieved using Ca(2+). On the basis of these results, a preliminary model for two G(1) x A(8) and G(2) x A(7) mismatched base pairs such as G(anti) x A(anti) formed in the catalytic loop is proposed. The factor of 10 increase in the k(cat)/K(m) value of the mutant deoxyribozyme, which has C(9) substituted with d(P)C, suggests that the base stacking interaction between the substituted propynyl group in dC and the nearest-neighbor base grew stronger. Thus, substituting d(P)C for dC in the catalytic loop would be one of the best ways to increase the catalytic activity of the deoxyribozyme.     

Toward automated nucleic acid enzyme selection.

Methods for automation of nucleic acid selections are being developed. The selection of aptamers has been successfully automated using a Biomek 2000 workstation. Several binding species with nanomolar affinities were isolated from diverse populations. Automation of a deoxyribozyme ligase selection is in progress. The process requires eleven times more robotic manipulations than an aptamer selection. The random sequence pool contained a 5' iodine residue and the ligation substrate contained a 3' phosphorothioate. Initially, a manual deoxyribozyme ligase selection was performed. Thirteen rounds of selection yielded ligators with a 400-fold increase in activity over the initial pool. Several difficulties were encountered during the automation of DNA catalyst selection, including effectively washing bead-bound DNA, pipetting 50% glycerol solutions, purifying single strand DNA, and monitoring the progress of the selection as it is performed. Nonetheless, automated selection experiments for deoxyribozyme ligases were carried out starting from either a naive pool or round eight of the manually selected pool. In both instances, the first round of selection revealed an increase in ligase activity. However, this activity was lost in subsequent rounds. A possible cause could be mispriming during the unmonitored PCR reactions. Potential solutions include pool redesign, fewer PCR cycles, and integration of a fluorescence microtiter plate reader to allow robotic 'observation' of the selections as they progress.     

A deoxyribozyme with a novel guanine quartet-helix pseudoknot structure

Here we report a deoxyribozyme with a unique structure that contains a two-tiered guanine quadruplex interlinked to a Watson-Crick duplex. Through in vitro selection, sequence mutation, and methylation interference, we show the presence of both the two-tiered guanine-quadruplex and two helical regions contained in the active structure of this self-phosphorylating deoxyribozyme. Interestingly, one GG element of the quadruplex is part of a hairpin loop within one of the identified helical regions. Circular dichroism analysis showed that antiparallel quadruplex formation was dependent on this helix. To our knowledge, this is the first report of a pseudoknot nucleic acid structure that involves a guanine quadruplex. Our findings indicate that guanine quadruplexes can be part of complex structural arrangements, increasing the likelihood of finding more complex guanine quadruplex arrangements in biological systems.     

Towards elucidation of the mechanism of UV1C, a deoxyribozyme with photolyase activity

Among the unexpected chemistries that can be catalyzed by nucleic acid enzymes is photochemistry. We have reported the in vitro selection of a small, cofactor-independent deoxyribozyme, UV1C, capable of repairing thymine dimers in a DNA substrate, most optimally with light at a wavelength of >300 nm. We hypothesized that a guanine quadruplex functioned both as a light antenna and an electron source for the repair of the substrate within the enzyme-substrate complex. Here, we report structural and mechanistic investigations of that hypothesis. Contact-crosslinking and guanosine to inosine mutational studies reveal that the thymine dimer and the guanine quadruplex are positioned close to each other in the deoxyribozyme-substrate complex, and permit us to refine the structure and topology of the folded deoxyribozyme. In exploring the substrate utilization capabilities of UV1C, we find it to be able to repair uracil dimers as well as thymine dimers, as long as they are present in an overall deoxyribonucleotide milieu. Some surprising similarities with bacterial CPD photolyase enzymes are noted.     

A continuous kinetic assay for RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes,exploiting ethidium bromide as an extrinsic fluorescent probe

We describe a rapid and inexpensive method to monitor the kinetics of small RNA-cleaving deoxyribozymes, based on the exogenous fluorophore ethidium bromide. Ethidium binds preferentially to double-stranded nucleic acids, and its fluorescence emission increases dramatically upon intercalation. Thus, ethidium can be used in single-turnover experiments to measure both annealing of the deoxyribozyme to its substrate and release of the products. Under conditions in which dissociation of the product is fast compared with cleavage, the apparent rate of product release reflects the cleavage step. The method was developed for characterizing the so-called 8-17 catalytic DNA, but its general applicability in the deoxyribozyme field was verified using the 10-23 RNA-cleaving construct. Catalysis by both deoxyribozymes was not inhibited in the presence of substoichiometric amounts of ethidium, and the rates obtained through the ethidium assay were virtually identical to the rates determined using radiolabeled substrates. In contrast, the assay cannot be applied to the large, structured ribozymes, and its use to study the kinetics of the small hammerhead ribozyme was hampered by the presence on the catalyst of at least one high-affinity ethidium binding site.     

Deoxyribozymes that recode sequence information

Allosteric nucleic acid ligases have been used previously to transform analyte-binding into the formation of oligonucleotide templates that can be amplified and detected. We have engineered binary deoxyribozyme ligases whose two components are brought together by bridging oligonucleotide effectors. The engineered ligases can ‘read’ one sequence and then ‘write’ (by ligation) a separate, distinct sequence, which can in turn be uniquely amplified. The binary deoxyribozymes show great specificity, can discriminate against a small number of mutations in the effector, and can read and recode DNA information with high fidelity even in the presence of excess obscuring genomic DNA. In addition, the binary deoxyribozymes can read non-natural nucleotides and write natural sequence information. The binary deoxyribozyme ligases could potentially be used in a variety of applications, including the detection of single nucleotide polymorphisms in genomic DNA or the identification of short nucleic acids such as microRNAs.