Studies of the species barrier between Drosophila subobscura and D. madeirensis IV. A genetic dissection of the X chromosome for speciation genes

The genetics of four traits contributing to the isolation mechanism between the two closely related species of Drosophila belonging to the obscura group, D. subobscura and D. madeirensis, have been investigated, especially regarding the influence exerted by the X chromosome. This chromosome has been roughly dissected genetically by the use of four markers. It was found that factors affecting viability of backcross males are spread from the centromeric end of the chromosome up the region marked by Bx. Three sections were responsible for male sterility/fertility. The abnormal head shape of the backcross males was affected by factor(s) on the madeirensis and the subobscura sex chromosome located at the region of MAD1 inversion. Finally, an abnormal trait in these males (presence of extra sex combs) was found to be controlled by four sections, two on the madeirensis X chromosome and two on the subobscura one.     

Multilocus analysis of nucleotide variation in Drosophila madeirensis, an endemic species of the Laurisilva forest in Madeira

Drosophila madeirensis is an endemic species of Madeira that inhabits the island Laurisilva forest. Nucleotide variation in D. madeirensis is analysed in six genomic regions and compared to that previously reported for the same regions in Drosophila subobscura, an abundant species in the Palearctic region that is closely related to D. madeirensis. The gene regions analysed are distributed along the O₃ inversion. The O₃ arrangement is monomorphic in D. madeirensis, and it was present in ancestral populations of D. subobscura but went extinct in this species after the origin of the derived O_ST and O₃₊₄ arrangements. Levels of nucleotide polymorphism in D. madeirensis are similar to those present in the O_ST and O₃₊₄ arrangements of D. subobscura, and the frequency spectrum is skewed towards rare variants. Purifying selection against deleterious nonsynonymous mutations is less effective in D. madeirensis. Although D. madeirensis and D. subobscura coexist at present in Madeira, no clear evidence of introgression was detected in the studied regions.     

DNA variation at the rp49 gene region in Drosophila madeirensis and D. subobscura from Madeira: inferences about the origin of an insular endemic species

An ~1.6 ‐ kb fragment spanning the rp49 gene was sequenced in 16 lines of Drosophila subobscura from Madeira and in 22 lines of the endemic species D. madeirensis. Nucleotide diversity in D. subobscura from Madeira (π=0.0081) was similar to that in lines from Spain carrying the O₃₊₄ chromosomal arrangement (π=0.0080). No significant genetic differentiation was detected between insular and continental O₃₊₄ lines of D. subobscura. These results are compatible both with a rather recent and massive colonization, and with multiple colonization events from the continent. Nucleotide diversity in D. madeirensis (π=0.0076) was similar to that in D. subobscura, which deviates from the expectation, under strict neutrality, of a lower level of variation in an insular species with a small population size. The observed numbers of shared polymorphisms and of fixed differences between D. madeirensis and D. subobscura are compatible with the isolation model of speciation, where shared polymorphisms are due to common ancestry.     

The Adh in Drosophila: Chromosomal location and restriction analysis in species with different phylogenetic relationships

Restriction analysis of the genomic region containing the Adh gene and in situ hybridization assays were performed in six Drosophila species belonging to three different subgenera: D. ambigua, D. subobscura, D. madeirensis and D. guanche (sg. Sophophora); D. immigrans (sg. Drosophila); and D. lebanonensis (sg. Pholadoris). In agreement with previous observations, comparison of restriction maps of the Adh region shows that D. subobscura and D. madeirensis are very closely related. Partial homology is also observed with the rest of the obscura group species. Nevertheless, no resemblance at the restriction map level is detected when more distantly related species are compared. In D. ambigua, D. immigrans and D. lebanonensis in situ hybridization assays reveal a single chromosomal location for Adh, which in D. lebanonensis appears to be sex linked. In contrast, in D. subobscura, D. madeirensis and D. guanche multiple sites of hybridization with homologous and heterologous probes are observed. For example, in D. subobscura and D. madeirensis the functional Adh gene is located on the U chromosome and additional homologous retrosequences are found on the E chromosome.by H. Jäckle     

Sex‐ratio in natural and experimental populations of Drosophila subobscura from North America

The sex‐ratio (SR), defined as the proportion of males, has been studied in three North American colonizing populations of Drosophila subobscura (Eureka, Davis and Gilroy). The proportion of sexes under laboratory conditions was studied using the one‐generation serial transfer technique in one‐ and two‐species populations, to infer whether biased SR affects the outcome when competing with Drosophila pseudoobscura, another member of the same group now in sympatry with D. subobscura in North America. The wild samples of D. subobscura yielded a significantly higher number of males than females during those months where the species is more abundant. However, there was no significant deviation in the 1 : 1 proportion of sexes in the descendants of D. subobscura at any of the experimental conditions. On the contrary, D. pseudoobscura produced a higher proportion of females which could be responsible for the exclusion of D. subobscura in laboratory competition experiments with overlapping generations. Thus, if sexes are equal at birth and survival is similar, the preponderance of males of D. subobscura in our wild collections could indicate greater activity and probably greater chance of dispersal of males versus females especially under favourable conditions.     

Microscale Laser Surgery Demonstrates the Grasping Function of the Male Sex Combs in Drosophila melanogaster and Drosophila bipectinata

Male secondary sexual traits of animals are richly diversified in form and complexity, yet there are many species in which their precise function remains unknown. Within the genus Drosophila, species belonging to the melanogaster and obscura species groups have evolved a remarkable variety of sex combs, male‐limited secondary sexual traits located on the tarsi of both front legs. Information concerning sex comb function is minimal or absent, except for D. melanogaster, where previous studies indicate that the sex combs are used for grasping the female prior to copulation. These studies, however, do not unambiguously demonstrate comb function, because it has not been possible to ascribe observed behavioral outcomes of the various comb manipulations to changes in the combs per se. We used microscale laser surgery to manipulate comb size in D. melanogaster and D. bipectinata, and tested the hypothesis that the sex combs function as grasping devices in courtship, making them essential for copulation to ensue. Results of high‐resolution behavioral analysis in small observation arenas demonstrated that in both species in which sex combs were surgically eliminated, males were unable to grasp, mount or copulate. The combless foretarsi of these altered males slipped off the end (D. melanogaster) and sides (D. bipectinata) of the female abdomen when courting males attempted to grasp. In most cases, males whose sex combs were reduced but not completely removed exhibited similar copulation probabilities as surgical control males, a result we demonstrated in observation chambers as well as under more ecologically realistic conditions inside population cages where males and females interacted on the surface of fruit substrates. Thus, the sex combs in D. melanogaster and D. bipectinata are grasping devices, essential for mounting and copulation.     

INTROGRESSION IN THE DROSOPHILA SUBOBSCURA—D. MADEIRENSIS SISTER SPECIES: EVIDENCE OF GENE FLOW IN NUCLEAR GENES DESPITE MITOCHONDRIAL DIFFERENTIATION

Species hybridization, and thus the potential for gene flow, was once viewed as reproductive mistake. However, recent analysis based on large datasets and newly developed models suggest that gene exchange is not as rare as originally suspected. To investigate the history and speciation of the closely related species Drosophila subobscura, D. madeirensis, and D. guanche, we obtained polymorphism and divergence data for 26 regions throughout the genome, including the Y chromosome and mitochondrial DNA. We found that the D. subobscura X/autosome ratio of silent nucleotide diversity is significantly smaller than the 0.75 expected under neutrality. This pattern, if held genomewide, may reflect a faster accumulation of beneficial mutations on the X chromosome than on autosomes. We also detected evidence of gene flow in autosomal regions, while sex chromosomes remain distinct. This is consistent with the large X effect on hybrid male sterility seen in this system and the presence of two X chromosome inversions fixed between species. Overall, our data conform to chromosomal speciation models in which rearrangements are proposed to serve as gene flow barriers. Contrary to other observations in Drosophila, the mitochondrial genome appears resilient to gene flow in the presence of nuclear exchange.     

Chromosomal locations of actin genes are conserved between the melanogaster and obscura groups of Drosophila

The actin genes of D. subobscura and D. madeirensis were mapped by in situ hybridization, using a D. melanogaster probe. Six loci were detected, and they were strikingly similar in chromosomal location to the six actin loci previously characterized in D. melanogaster.     

Quantitative genetics of speciation: additive and non-additive genetic differentiation between <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila madeirensis</Emphasis> and <Emphasis Type="Italic">Drosophila subobscura</Emphasis>

The role of dominance and epistasis in population divergence has been an issue of much debate ever since the neoDarwinian synthesis. One of the best ways to dissect the several genetic components affecting the genetic architecture of populations is line cross analysis. Here we present a study comparing generation means of several life history-traits in two closely related Drosophila species: Drosophila subobscura, D. madeirensis as well as their F ₁ and F ₂ hybrids. This study aims to determine the relative contributions of additive and non-additive genetic parameters to the differentiation of life-history traits between these two species. The results indicate that both negative dominance and epistatic effects are very important in the differentiation of most traits. We end with considerations about the relevance of these findings for the understanding of the role of non-additive effects in speciation.     

Reproductive interference by male Drosophila subobscura on female D. persimilis: A laboratory experiment

While females often reject courtship attempts by heterospecific males, reproductive interference by harassment from such males can nonetheless occur, potentially reducing female fitness. Such effects may be profound following a range expansion, when males from a new species may suddenly encounter (and perhaps even become abundant relative to) females of related native species. Drosophila subobscura recently invaded North America and may impact native species through reproductive interference and other processes. We test for the potential for reproductive interference by D. subobscura males on D. persimilis females in the laboratory. D. subobscura males aggressively copulated with D. persimilis females, including many females that exhibit rejection behaviors. Despite females attempting to dismount the males, the heterospecific copulations are on average longer than conspecific copulations, and females exhibit some reluctance to remate with conspecific males following this harassment. Females confined with both conspecific and heterospecific males produce fewer adult progeny than those with either conspecific males only or with conspecific males and distantly related D. simulans males that do not engage in female harassment. Overall, our results illustrate how reproductive interference by an invasive species can have negative effects on resident natural populations.     

Chromosomal inversions promote genomic islands of concerted evolution of Hsp70 genes in the Drosophila subobscura species subgroup

Heat‐shock (HS) assays to understand the connection between standing inversion variation and evolutionary response to climate change in Drosophila subobscura found that “warm‐climate” inversion O₃₊₄ exhibits non‐HS levels of Hsp70 protein like those of “cold‐climate” O_ST after HS induction. This was unexpected, as overexpression of Hsp70 can incur multiple fitness costs. To understand the genetic basis of this finding, we have determined the genomic sequence organization of the Hsp70 family in four different inversions, including O_ST, O₃₊₄ , O₃₊₄₊₈ and O₃₊₄₊₁₆ , using as outgroups the remainder of the subobscura species subgroup, namely Drosophila madeirensis and Drosophila guanche. We found (i) in all the assayed lines, the Hsp70 family resides in cytological locus 94A and consists of only two genes, each with four HS elements (HSEs) and three GAGA sites on its promoter. Yet, in O_ST, the family is comparatively more compact; (ii) the two Hsp70 copies evolve in concert through gene conversion, except in D. guanche; (iii) within D. subobscura, the rate of concerted evolution is strongly structured by inversion, being higher in O_ST than in O₃₊₄ ; and (iv) in D. guanche, the two copies accumulated multiple differences, including a newly evolved “gap‐type” HSE2. The absence of concerted evolution in this species may be related to a long‐gone‐unnoticed observation that it lacks Hsp70 HS response, perhaps because it has evolved within a narrow thermal range in an oceanic island. Our results point to a previously unrealized link between inversions and concerted evolution, with potentially major implications for understanding genome evolution.     

The banding pattern of polytene chromosomes of Drosophila guanche compared with that of D. subobscura

A detailed map of the salivary gland chromosomes of Drosophila guanche is presented and compared to the standard gene arrangements of D. subobscura. Generally, the polytene chromosomc banding patterns of the two species show a high degrce of homology. Only Segment I of the sex chromosome (Chromosome A) shows marked differences. The banding pattern proposed for this segment in D. guanche could have originated from a cluster of overlapping inversions including A₁ arrangement.     

The large X‐effect on secondary sexual characters and the genetics of variation in sex comb tooth number in Drosophila subobscura

Genetic studies of secondary sexual traits provide insights into whether and how selection drove their divergence among populations, and these studies often focus on the fraction of variation attributable to genes on the X‐chromosome. However, such studies may sometimes misinterpret the amount of variation attributable to the X‐chromosome if using only simple reciprocal F₁ crosses, or they may presume sexual selection has affected the observed phenotypic variation. We examined the genetics of a secondary sexual trait, male sex comb size, in Drosophila subobscura. This species bears unusually large sex combs for its species group, and therefore, this trait may be a good candidate for having been affected by natural or sexual selection. We observed significant heritable variation in number of teeth of the distal sex comb across strains. While reciprocal F₁ crosses seemed to implicate a disproportionate X‐chromosome effect, further examination in the F₂ progeny showed that transgressive autosomal effects inflated the estimate of variation associated with the X‐chromosome in the F₁. Instead, the X‐chromosome appears to confer the smallest contribution of all major chromosomes to the observed phenotypic variation. Further, we failed to detect effects on copulation latency or duration associated with the observed phenotypic variation. Overall, this study presents an examination of the genetics underlying segregating phenotypic variation within species and illustrates two common pitfalls associated with some past studies of the genetic basis of secondary sexual traits.     

Tracing the colonization of Madeira and the Canary Islands by Drosophila subobscura through the study of the rp49 gene region

Nucleotide variation at the nuclear ribosomal protein 49 (rp49) gene region has been analysed by fine restriction mapping in a sample of 47 lines from a population from Madeira. Five restriction-site (out of 37 sites scored) and 3 length polymorphisms have been detected, resulting in 14 different haplotypes. This population shows less variation than both continental and Canary Island populations. The population from Madeira shows some differentiation from mainland populations, which does not favor the idea of extensive migration between the continent and Madeira. Chromosomal and restriction-map variation of the rp49 region in D. subobscura populations, together with data on sequence comparison of this nuclear region in D. guanche and D. madeirensis clearly indicate that the Canary Islands underwent at least two colonization events from the nearby continent. Although the data for Madeira are compatible with a single colonization event by a continental sample polymorphic for gene arrangements O₃ and O_{3 + 4}, an alternative scenario with at least two colonization events seems more likely.     

INTERSPECIFIC LABORATORY COMPETITION OF THE RECENTLY SYMPATRIC SPECIES DROSOPHILA SUBOBSCURA AND DROSOPHILA PSEUDOOBSCURA

Abstract.—Drosophila subobscura and D. pseudoobscura are closely related species coexisting on the West Coast of North America, which was recently colonized by D. subobscura. In competition experiments with overlapping generations, D. subobscura is eliminated by D. pseudoobscura in a few generations at all four temperatures and two initial frequencies tested. Yet in one-species cultures, D. subobscura thrives at all experimental conditions. Single-generation competition experiments reveal lower survivorship and productivity of D. subobscura at all temperatures and frequencies. Productivity per female is dependent on the initial frequencies: greater for D. subobscura as its initial frequency becomes higher, but lower for D. pseudoobscura as its frequency becomes higher. Strains of D. subobscura from three disparate geographic origins yield similar results.     

Gene activity of polytene chromosomes in Drosophila species of the obscura group

The polytene chromosome puffing patterns of Drosophila guanche were established and compared with those of Drosophila subobscura. A total of 150 loci, active in some of the 17 developmental stages studied, were described and 23 of them were found to form the characteristic puffing pattern of D. guanche. Taking into account the number of puffs as well as the gene activity of each chromosome and the total gene activity, D. guanche seems to be less active than D. subobscura. Although both species show a degree of homology in their puffing patterns lower than that found for sibling species, the degree of homology is stronger than that between species belonging to the same group but to different subgroups. Thus, D. guanche and D. subobscura must be considered as phylogenetically closely related species, belonging to the same subgroup.     

Long-term coexistence of a hybridization-derived population of Drosophila parapallidosa with closely related Drosophila ananassae (Diptera: Drosophilidae)

A 2012–13 survey on Penang Island, Malaysia, revealed the existence of both Drosophila ananassae and Drosophila parapallidosa, the latter of which carries chromosomes Y and 4 from D. ananassae and thus is of hybrid origin. We collected the flies again from the same location in 2018. The hybrid population remained present, which suggests that the D. parapallidosa of hybrid origin does not represent a mere transient population but is stable. Why do these two species coexist irrespective of gene flow? We realized that body size is generally larger in D. ananassae than in D. parapallidosa, which constitutes a new character with which to discriminate these species; previously the number of sex comb teeth was the only diagnostic trait. Character displacement was not detected, however, for those traits. We crossed these two species, which resulted in offspring that had an altered genomic constitution. The body size of D. ananassae was dominant, and the presence of chromosomes Y and 4 did not have a significant effect on body size. By contrast, the presence of chromosome 4 from D. ananassae significantly affected the number of sex comb teeth. Even flies having a genomic constitution similar to that of the Penang D. parapallidosa exhibited a number of sex comb teeth that was intermediate between the two species. We propose that the D. parapallidosa sex comb character underwent selection during evolution of the Penang Island population. Reproductive interference between the species, presumably caused by signal jamming, was detected.     

Variation in diapause and sex ratio in the parasitoidAsobara tabida

Asobara tabida Nees (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) is a widespread parasitoid, attacking larvae ofDrosophila (Diptera: Drosophilidae) species in fermenting substrates. In this species, geographic variation is found in the percentage of parasitoids entering diapause and in the sex ratio of emerging parasitoids. Percentage diapause appears to be influenced by host species (more parasitoids enter diapause inD. melanogaster Meigen than inD. subobscura Collin) and temperature. It is not correlated with any of the abiotic factors investigated, but is correlated with survival probability inD. melanogaster larvae and with the time of year in which the experiment was conducted (even though none of the parasitoids experienced natural day light). Sex ratio was only found to correlate with percentage diapause, suggesting that males enter diapause more frequently than females. It is concluded thatA. tabida uses diapause to survive both unfavourable abiotic and biotic circumstances.     

Gypsy homologous sequences inDrosophila subobscura (gypsyDS)

Summary Characterization of sequences homologous to theDrosophila melanogaster gypsy transposable element was carried out inDrosophila subobscura (gypsyDS). They were found to be widely distributed among natural populations of this species. From Southern blot and in situ analyses, these sequences appear to be mobile in this species.GypsyDS sequences are located in both euchromatic and heterochromatic regions. A completegypsyDS sequence was isolated from aD. subobscura genomic library, and a 1.3-kb fragment which aligns with the ORF2 of theD. melanogaster gypsy element was sequenced. Comparisons of this sequence in three species (D. subobscura, D. melanogaster, and D. virilis) indicate that there is greater similarity between theD. subobscura-D. virilis sequences than betweenD. subobscura andD. melanogaster. Molecular divergence ofgypsy sequences betweenD. virilis andD. subobscura is estimated at 16 MY, whereas the most likely divergence time of these two species is more than 60 MY. These data strongly suggest thatgypsy sequences have been horizontally transferred between these species.Offprint requests to: T.M. Alberola