Elucidating the effects of postinduction glutamine feeding on the growth and productivity of CHO cells

Inducible mammalian expression systems are increasingly being used for the production of valuable therapeutics. In such system, maximizing the product yield is achieved by carefully balancing the biomass concentration during the production phase and the specific productivity of the cells. These two factors are largely determined by the availability of nutrients and/or the presence of toxic waste metabolites in the culture environment. Glutamine is one of the most important components of cell culture medium, since this substrate is an important building block and source of energy for biomass and recombinant protein production. Its metabolism, however, ultimately leads to the formation of ammonia, a well known inhibitor of cellular growth and productivity. In this work, we show that nutrient feeding post‐induction can greatly enhance the product yield by alleviating early limitations encountered in batch. Moreover, varying the amount of glutamine in the feed yielded two distinct culture behaviors post‐induction; whereas excess glutamine allowed to reach greater cell concentrations, glutamine‐limited fed‐batch led to increased cell specific productivity. These two conditions also showed distinctive lactate metabolism. To further assess the physiological impact of glutamine levels on the cells, a comparative ¹³C‐metabolic flux analysis was conducted and a number of key intracellular fluxes were found to be affected by the amount of glutamine present in the feed during the production phase. Such information may provide useful clues for the identification of physiological markers of cell growth and productivity that could further guide the optimization of inducible expression systems. © 2014 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 30:535–546, 2014     

Perfusion culture of hybridoma cells for hyperproduction of IgG(2a) monoclonal antibody in a wave bioreactor-perfusion culture system

A novel wave bioreactor-perfusion culture system was developed for highly efficient production of monoclonal antibody IgG2a (mAb) by hybridoma cells. The system consists of a wave bioreactor, a floating membrane cell-retention filter, and a weight-based perfusion controller. A polyethylene membrane filter with a pore size of 7 microm was floating on the surface of the culture broth for cell retention, eliminating the need for traditional pump around flow loops and external cell separators. A weight-based perfusion controller was designed to balance the medium renewal rate and the harvest rate during perfusion culture. BD Cell mAb Medium (BD Biosciences, CA) was identified to be the optimal basal medium for mAb production during batch culture. A control strategy for perfusion rate (volume of fresh medium/working volume of reactor/day, vvd) was identified as a key factor affecting cell growth and mAb accumulation during perfusion culture, and the optimal control strategy was increasing perfusion rate by 0.15 vvd per day. Average specific mAb production rate was linearly corrected with increasing perfusion rate within the range of investigation. The maximum viable cell density reached 22.3 x 105 and 200.5 x 105 cells/mL in the batch and perfusion culture, respectively, while the corresponding maximum mAb concentration reached 182.4 and 463.6 mg/L and the corresponding maximum total mAb amount was 182.4 and 1406.5 mg, respectively. Not only the yield of viable cell per liter of medium (32.9 x 105 cells/mL per liter medium) and the mAb yield per liter of medium (230.6 mg/L medium) but also the mAb volumetric productivity (33.1 mg/L.day) in perfusion culture were much higher than those (i.e., 22.3 x 105 cells/mL per liter medium, 182.4 mg/L medium, and 20.3 mg/L.day) in batch culture. Relatively fast cell growth and the perfusion culture approach warrant that high biomass and mAb productivity may be obtained in such a novel perfusion culture system (1 L working volume), which offers an alternative approach for producing gram quantity of proteins from industrial cell lines in a liter-size cell culture. The fundamental information obtained in this study may be useful for perfusion culture of hybridoma cells on a large scale.     

Feed development for fed‐batch CHO production process by semisteady state analysis

Semisteady state cultures are useful for studying cell physiology and facilitating media development. Two semisteady states with a viable cell density of 5.5 million cells/mL were obtained in CHO cell cultures and compared with a fed‐batch mode control. In the first semisteady state, the culture was maintained at 5 mM glucose and 0.5 mM glutamine. The second condition had threefold higher concentrations of both nutrients, which led to a 10% increase in lactate production, a 78% increase in ammonia production, and a 30% reduction in cell growth rate. The differences between the two semisteady states indicate that maintaining relatively low levels of glucose and glutamine can reduce the production of lactate and ammonia. Specific amino acid production and consumption indicated further metabolic differences between the two semisteady states and fed‐batch mode. The results from this experiment shed light in the feeding strategy for a fed‐batch process and feed medium enhancement. The fed‐batch process utilizes a feeding strategy whereby the feed added was based on glucose levels in the bioreactor. To evaluate if a fixed feed strategy would improve robustness and process consistency, two alternative feeding strategies were implemented. A constant volume feed of 30% or 40% of the initial culture volume fed over the course of cell culture was evaluated. The results indicate that a constant volumetric‐based feed can be more beneficial than a glucose‐based feeding strategy. This study demonstrated the applicability of analyzing CHO cultures in semisteady state for feed enhancement and continuous process improvement. © 2009 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 2010     

Effect of initial cell density on hybridoma growth, metabolism, and monoclonal antibody production.

A murine hybridoma cell line (167.4G5.3) was cultivated in batch mode with varying inoculum cell densities using IMDM media of varying fetal bovine serum concentrations. It was observed that maximum cell concentrations as well as the amount of monoclonal antibody attainable in batch mode were dependent on the inoculum size. Specifically, cultures with lower inoculum size resulted in lower cell yield and lower antibody concentrations. However, in the range of 10(2) to 10(5) cells per ml, the initial cell density affected the initial growth rate by a factor of only 20%. Furthermore, specific monoclonal antibody production rates were independent of initial cell density and the serum concentration. Glutamine was the limiting nutrient for all the cultures, determining the extent of growth and the amount of antibody produced. Serum was essential for cell growth and cultures with initial cell concentrations up to 10(6) cells per ml could not grow without serum. However, when adapted, the cells could grow in a custom-made serum-free medium containing insulin, transferrin, ethanolamine, and selenium (ITES) supplements. The cells adapted to the ITES medium could grow with an initial growth rate slightly higher than in 1.25% serum and the growth rate showed an initial density dependency-inocula at 10(3) cells per ml grew 30% slower than those at 10(4) or 10(5). This difference in growth rate was decreased to 10% with the addition of conditioned ITES medium. The addition of conditioned media, however, did not improve the cell growth for serum-containing batches.     

Fed-batch cultivation of animal cells using different medium design concepts and feeding strategies

In animal cell cultivation, cell density and product concentration are often low due to the accumulation of toxic end-products such as ammonia and lactate and/or the depletion of essential nutrients. A hybridoma cell line (CRL-1606) was cultivated in T-flasks using a newly devised medium feeding strategy. The goals were to decrease ammonia and lactate formation by the design of an initial medium which would provide a starting environment to achieve optimal cell growth. This was followed by using a stoichiometric equation governing animal cell growth and then designing a supplemental medium for feeding strategy used to control the nutritional environment. The relationship between the stoichiometric demands for glutamine and nonessential amino acids was also studied. Through stoichiometric feeding, nutrient concentrations were controlled reasonably well. Consequently, the specific production rate of lactate was decreased by fourfold compared with conventional fed-batch culture and by 26-fold compared with conventional batch culture. The specific production rate of ammonia was decreased by tenfold compared with conventional fed-batch culture and by 50-fold compared with conventional batch culture. Most importantly, total cell density and monoclonal antibody concentration were increased by five- and tenfold respectively, compared with conventional batch culture. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Descriptive parameter evaluation in mammalian cell culture

Several methods exist for assessing population growth and protein productivity in mammalian cell culture. These methods were critically examined here, based on experiments with two hybridoma cell lines. It is shown that mammalian cell culture parameters must be evaluated on the same basis. In batch culture mode most data is obtained on a cumulative basis (protein product titre, substrate concentration, metabolic byproduct concentration). A simple numerical integration technique can be employed to convert cell concentration data to a cumulative basis (cell-hours). The hybridoma lines used in this study included a nutritionally non-fastidious line producing low levels of MAb and a nutritionally fastidious hybridoma with high productivity. In both cases the cell-hour approach was the most appropriate means of expressing the relationship between protein productivity and cell population dynamics. The cell-hour approach could be used as the basis for all metabolic population parameter evaluations. This method has the potential to be used successfully for both prediction and optimization purposes. This revised version was published online in August 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Design and performance of a trickle-bed bioreactor with immobilized hybridoma cells

A trickle-bed system employing inert matrices of vermiculite or polyurethane foam packed in the downcomer section of a split-flow air-lift reactor has been developed for hybridoma culture to enhance antibody productivity. This quiescent condition favoured occlusion and allowed the cells to achieve densities twelve fold greater (12.8×10⁶ cells/ml reactor for polyurethane foam) than in free cell suspension. The reactor was operated in a cyclic batch mode whereby defined volumes of medium were periodically withdrawn and replaced with equal volumes of fresh medium. The pH of the medium was used as the indicator of the feeding schedule. Glucose, lactate and ammonia concentrations reached a stationary value after 5 days. With vermiculite packing, a monoclonal antibody (MAb) concentration of 2.4 mg/l was achieved after 12 days. The MAb concentration declined then increased to a value of 1.8 mg/l. In the polyurethane foam average monoclonal antibody (MAb) concentrations reached a stationary value of 1.1 mg/l in the first 20 days and increased to a new stationary state value of 2.1 mg/l for the remainder of the production. MAb productivity in the trickle-bed reactor was 0.3 mg/l·d (polyurethane foam) and 0.18 mg/l.d (vermiculite) in comparison to 0.12 mg/l·d for free cell suspension. This trickle-bed system seems to be an attractive way of increasing MAb productivity in culture.     

Effects of cysteine,asparagine, or glutamine limitations in Chinese hamster ovary cell batch and fed-batch cultures

Amino acid availability is a key factor that can be controlled to optimize the productivity of fed-batch cultures. To study amino acid limitation effects, a serum-free chemically defined basal medium was formulated to exclude the amino acids that became depleted in batch culture. The effect of limiting glutamine, asparagine, and cysteine on the cell growth, metabolism, antibody productivity, and product glycosylation was investigated in three Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines (CHO-DXB11, CHO-K1SV, and CHO-S). Cysteine limitation was detrimental to both cell proliferation and productivity for all three CHO cell lines. Glutamine limitation reduced growth but not cell specific productivity, whereas asparagine limitation had no significant effect on either growth or cell specific productivity. Neither glutamine nor asparagine limitation significantly affected antibody glycosylation. Replenishing the CHO-DXB11 culture with cysteine after 1 day of cysteine limitation allowed the cells to partially recover their growth and productivity. This recovery was not observed after 2 days of cysteine limitation. Based on these findings, a fed-batch protocol was developed using single or mixed amino acid supplementation. Although cell density and antibody concentration were lower compared to a commercial feed, the feeds based on cysteine supplementation yielded comparable cell specific productivity. Overall, this study showed that different amino acid limitations have varied effects on the performance of CHO cell cultures and that maintaining cysteine availability is a critical process parameter for the three cell lines investigated.     

Chinese hamster ovary cell growth and interferon production kinetics in stirred batch culture

Summary Recombinant human interferon- production by Chinese hamster ovary cells was restricted to the growth phase of batch cultures in serum-free medium. The specific interferon production rate was highest during the initial period of exponential growth but declined subsequently in parallel with specific growth rate. This decline in specific growth rate and interferon productivity was associated with a decline in specific metabolic activity as determined by the rate of glucose uptake and the rates of lactate and ammonia production. The ammonia and lactate concentrations that had accumulated by the end of the batch culture were not inhibitory to growth. Glucose was exhausted by the end of the growth phase but increased glucose concentrations did not improve the cell yield or interferon production kinetics. Analysis of amino acid metabolism showed that glutamine and asparagine were exhausted by the end of the growth phase, but supplementation of these amino acids did not improve either cell or product yields. When glutamine was omitted from the growth medium there was no cell proliferation but interferon production occurred, suggesting that recombinant protein production can be uncoupled from cell proliferation. Offprint requests to: P. M. Hayter     

Changes in monoclonal antibody productivity of recombinant BHK cells immobilized in collagen gel particles

Animal cell perfusion high density culture is often adopted for the production of biologicals in industry. In high density culture sometimes the productivity of biologicals has been found to be enhanced. Especially in immobilized animal cell culture, significant increase in the productivity has been reported. We have found that the specific monoclonal antibody (MAb) productivity of an immobilized hybridoma cell is enhanced more than double. Several examples of enhancing productivities have been also shown by collagen immobilized cells. Immobilized cells involve some different points from non-immobilized cells in high density culture: In immobilized culture, some cells are contacted together, resulting in locally much higher cell concentration more than 10⁸ cells/ml. Information originating from a cell can be easily transduced to the others in immobilized culture because the distance between cells is much nearer. Here we have performed collagen gel immobilized culture of recombinant BHK cells which produce a human IgG monoclonal antibody in a protein-free medium for more than three months. In this high density culture a stabilized monoclonal antibody production was found with around 8 times higher specific monoclonal antibody productivity compared with that in a batch serum containing culture. No higher MAb productivity was observed using a conditioned medium which was obtained from the high density culture, indicating that no components secreted from the immobilized cells work for enhancing monoclonal antibody production. The MAb productivity by the non-immobilized cells obtained by dissolving collagen using a collagenase gradually decreased and returned to the original level in the batch culture using a fresh medium. This suggests that the direct contact of the cells or a very close distance between the cells has something to do with the enhancement of the MAb productivity, and the higher productivity is kept for a while in each cell after they are drawn apart.     

A semi-empirical glycosylation model of a camelid monoclonal antibody under hypothermia cell culture conditions

The impact of cell culture environment on the glycan distribution of a monoclonal antibody (mAb) has been investigated through a combination of experiments and modeling. A newly developed CHO DUXB cell line was cultivated at two levels of initial Glutamine (Gln) concentrations (0, 4 mM) and incubation temperatures of (33 and 37 °C) in batch operation mode. Hypothermia was applied either through the entire culture duration or only during the post-exponential phase. Beyond reducing cell growth and increasing productivity, hypothermia significantly altered the galactosylation index profiles as compared to control conditions. A novel semi-empirical dynamic model was proposed for elucidating the connections between the extracellular cell culture conditions to galactosylation index. The developed model is based on a simplified balance of nucleotides sugars and on the correlation between sugars’ levels to the galactosylation index (GI). The model predictions were found to be in a good agreement with the experimental data. The proposed empirical model is expected to be useful for controlling the glycoprofiles by manipulating culture conditions.     

Computer programs for modeling mammalian cell batch and fed-batch cultures using logistic equations

A MATLAB^® toolbox was developed for applying the logistic modeling approach to mammalian cell batch and fed-batch cultures. The programs in the toolbox encompass sensitivity analyses and simulations of the logistic equations in addition to cell specific rate estimation. The toolbox was first used to generate time courses of the sensitivity equations for characterizing the relationship between the logistic variable and the model parameters. Subsequently, the toolbox was used to describe CHO cell data from batch and fed-batch mammalian cell cultures. Cell density, product, glucose, lactate, glutamine, and ammonia data were analyzed for the batch culture while fed-batch analysis included cell density and product concentration. In all instances, experimental data were well described by the logistic equations and the resulting specific rate profiles were representative of the underlying cell physiology. The 6-variable batch culture data set was also used to compare the logistic specific rates with those from polynomial fitting and discrete derivative methods. The polynomial specific rates grossly misrepresented cell behavior in the initial and final stages of culture while those based on discrete derivatives had high variability due to computational artifacts. The utility of logistic specific rates to guide process development activities was demonstrated using specific protein productivity versus growth rate trajectories for the 3 cultures examined in this study. Overall, the computer programs developed in this study enable rapid and robust analysis of data from mammalian cell batch and fed-batch cultures which can help process development and metabolic flux estimation.     

Comparison of a batch, fed-batch and continuously operated stirred-tank reactor for the enzymatic synthesis of (R)-mandelonitrile by using a process model

The suitability of a batch, fed-batch and continuously operated stirred-tank reactor for the enzymatic production of (R)-mandelonitrile in an aqueous-organic biphasic system was investigated by using a process model. The considered biphasic system is 10-50% (v/v) 100 mM sodium citrate buffer of pH 5.5 dispersed in methyl tert-butyl ether. The constraints were that 750 moles of benzaldehyde per cubic meter should react towards (R)-mandelonitrile with an enantiomeric excess of 99% and a conversion of 98%. A continuously operated stirred-tank reactor could not meet the constraints, but the production in a batch or fed-batch reactor was feasible. The choice for a batch or fed-batch reactor is dependent on the influence of the costs for reactor operation and for the enzyme on the product costs. The choice for operating at a small or large aqueous-phase volume fraction is dependent on the costs and reusability of the enzyme. The volumetric productivity is maximal when operating as batch. The enzymatic productivity and turnover are maximal when operating as fed batch. In the fed-batch mode, the enzymatic productivity increased by 24-37%, the turnover increased by 50-60% and the volumetric productivity decreased by 33-71% as compared to a batch reactor. By enhancement of mass transfer both the volumetric and enzymatic productivity can be increased considerably, while the turnover is only slightly decreased.     

The role of the cell cycle in determining gene expression and productivity in CHO cells

Understanding the relationships between cell cycle and protein expression is critical to the optimisation of media and environmental conditions for successful commercial operation of animal cell culture processes. Using flow cytometry for the analysis of the early phases of synchronised batch cultures, the dependency of product expression on cell cycle related events has been evaluated in a recombinant CHO cell line. Although the production of recombinant protein is initially found to be cell cycle related, the maximum specific protein productivity is only achieved at a later stage of the exponential phase which also sees a maximum in the intracellular protein concentration. Subsequent work suggests that it is the batch phase/medium composition of cultures which is the major determinant of maximum specific productivity in this cell line. Furthermore the effect of the positive association between S phase and specific productivity is subordinate to the effect of batch phase/medium composition on the specific productivity of batch cultures. This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Ammonia inhibition of hybridomas propagated in batch, fed-batch, and continuous culture

The nature and temporal development of ammonia inhbition were investigated in batch, fed-batch, and continuous cultures. Significant inhibition was observed when cells were inoculated in serum-containing or chemically defined medium containing more than 2 mM of ammonia. In contrast, no inhibition was observed at greater than 10 mM when the ammonia concentration was gradually increased over the span of a batch culture by feeding ammonium chloride. Strong growth inhibition was observed after each of five step changes (2.8 --> 3.7 --> 4.0 --> 4.9 --> 7.7 --> 13.5 mM) in continuous culture. Following a period of adaptation at each higher value, the viable cell density stabilized at a new lower value. The lowering in viable cell density was caused by an increase in specific death rate and a decreased cell yield on glucose, glutamine, and oxygen. Increased ammonia concentration had little or no effect on the steady-state specific growth kinetics or specific antibody productivity. (c) 1994 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Hybridoma growth limitations: The roles of energy metabolism and ammonia production

Energy metabolism and the production of ammonia in hybridoma cell culture and its inhibitory effects on cell growth are reviewed. The interactive roles of glucose and glutamine metabolism affect the rate of production of ammonia, and these interactions are described. It is shown that growth inhibition usually occurs between 2–4 mM ammonia although some cell lines have been shown to adapt to much higher concentrations, particularly in continuous culture. In batch cultures cell growth appears to be particularly susceptible to increased ammonia concentrations during the early stages of growth; ammonia increased the rate of cell death in the late stage of batch growth. The specific productivity of monoclonal antibodies is much less sensitive to the released ammonia than is growth; lower volumetric productivities relate to the lower viable cell concentrations which are achieved at the high ammonia levels. Techniques to prevent ammonia accumulation or remove ammonia selectively have been relatively unsuccessful to date.     

Optimization of reovirus production from mouse L-929 cells in suspension culture

Reovirus serotype 3 Dearing (T3D) has shown potential as a novel cancer therapy. To support the increasing demand for reovirus, a two-stage perfusion mode scheme is proposed for cell growth and reovirus production. Mouse L-929 cells were used as the host for reovirus infection due to their ability to grow well in suspension culture. Several L-929 cell growth and reovirus infection characteristics were investigated and optimized in spinner flask batch cultures. For the growth of L-929 cells, a balanced nutrient-fortification of SMEM medium increased the maximum cell density by 30%, compared to normal SMEM; however, ammonia and lactate accumulations were found to inhibit further cell growth. For the production of reovirus, approximately 90% increase in viral yield resulted when the infection temperature was reduced from 37 to 33 degrees C. Infectious reovirus particles were shown to be stable in conditioned medium at 37 and 33 degrees C. The final virus titer was dependent on the multiplicity of infection (MOI) and the host cell density at the time of infection. A combination of an MOI of 0.1 pfu/cell and an initial host cell density of 1.0 x 10(6) cells/mL in fortified medium resulted in a maximum virus titer of (4.59 +/- 0.16) x 10(9) pfu/mL and a specific yield of (2.34 +/- 0.08) x 10(3) pfu/cell. At an optimal harvest time of the infection process, 99% of the virus was associated with the cellular debris. Finally, the presence of 5.0 mM ammonia in the culture medium was shown to seriously inhibit the reovirus yield, whereas lactate concentrations up to 20 mM had no effect.     

Influence of Primatone RL supplementation on sialylation of recombinant human interferon-gamma produced by Chinese hamster ovary cell culture using serum-free media

Although serum-free media have been widely used in mammalian cell culture for therapeutic protein production, the effects of serum-substitutes on product quality have not been extensively examined. This study observed an adverse effect of Primatone RL, an animal tissue hydrolysate commonly used as a serum-substitute to promote cell growth, on sialylation of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) derived from Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell culture in both batch and fed-batch modes. In batch cultures, decreased sialylation was observed at each of the glycosylation sites (i.e., Asn(25) and Asn(97)) of IFN-gamma with the use of elevated concentrations of the peptone. Although poorest sialylation was obtained with the use of a growth-inhibiting concentration of Primatone RL, diminished sialylation was observed at the optimal peptone concentration for cell growth and product yield. Since incubation of the product in Primatone RL-supplemented acellular medium did not result in decreased sialylation, the negative effect of Primatone RL could not be attributed to extracellular desialylation of IFN-gamma by components of the peptone. In the fed-batch mode, a culture utilizing a serum-free feeding medium supplemented with Primatone RL demonstrated poorer sialylation than a similar culture not fed the peptone. The results of both the batch and fed-batch experiments indicate that the adverse effect of the peptone was not due solely to ammonia accumulation. (c) 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 56: 353-360, 1997.     

Light-dependent synthesis of glutamate inRhodospirillum rubrum

Summary The relative sizes of the macro amino acid pools inRhodospirillum rubrum, as measured by the incorporation of [¹⁴C]-carbon dioxide, were approximately the same in the four different cultures examined; mid-exponential phase and initial stationary phase batch culture organisms and two steady state turbidostat continuous cultures. Glutamate was the dominant amino acid labelled with lower levels of labelling in glutamine, aspartate, alanine and threonine to complete the major amino acid pools. Glutamine synthesis was a light-dependent process in the four cultures examined whereas the synthesis of glutamate was light-dependent only in the stationary phase batch culture organisms and in low cell density turbidostat organisms. These results are presented as physiological evidence for the activity of the ATP-requiring GS-GOGAT system for ammonia assimilation under certain growth conditions inRhodospirillum rubrum.     

Production of alkaline serine protease subtilisin Carlsberg by Bacillus licheniformis on complex medium in a stirred tank reactor

Bacillus licheniformis (DSM 641) was cultivated on complex medium in batch and fed-batch operations in a 20-l working volume stirred tank reactor. The medium composition (maltose, glucose, sucrose, fructose, ammonia, phosphate) and O₂ and CO₂ in the off-gas were monitored on-line; pH, pO₂, turbidity, culture fluorescence were monitored in situ; optical density, concentrations of sugars, amino acids, phosphate, proteins, DNA, protease activity and total solids content were monitored off-line. Problems of on-line sampling, cell concentration monitoring, and culture fluorescence measurements and the influence of medium components on the enzyme productivity are discussed. Close relationships between variations of pH, pO₂, O₂ transfer rate and CO₂ production rate on the one hand and cell mass and fluorescence intensity on the other were demonstrated in batch and in fed-batch cultures. Using suitable cultivation conditions, alkaline protease with high volume activity [15300 units (U)/ml] and specific activity (510 U/mg) was produced. By replacing the complex medium with a semisynthetic one, the volumetric activity was reduced by a factor of ten (to 1650 U/ml), but the specific productivity by a factor of only two (to 210 U/ml). Correspondence to: K. Schügerl