Production of H-Y Antibody by Female Mice that Fail to Reject Male Skin

WHEN inbred mice are grafted with skin from inbred donors that differ from the recipients only by a single minor histocompatibility antigen, it is commonly observed that some recipients will retain their skin grafts while others will reject them. This is true of incompatibility for H-Y antigen, which is responsible for the rejection of male grafts by otherwise histocompatible inbred females of the same inbred strain¹. Thus in the DBA/2 (DBA) strain, male-to-female skin grafts are rejected by only some recipients; in the C57BL (B6) strain, females always reject male skin; and C3H/An (C3H) females usually accept male skin grafts indefinitely.     

SV40 T-antigen is a histocompatibility antigen of SV40-transgenic mice

Although the extensive family of non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens provides a formidable barrier to transplantation, the origin of their encoding genes are unknown. Recent studies have demonstrated both the linkage between H genes and retroviral sequences and the ability of integrated Moloney-murine leukemia virus to encode what is operationally defined as a non-H-2 H antigen. The experiments described in this communication reveal that skin grafts from an SV40 T-antigen transgenic C57BL/6 mouse strain are rejected by coisogenic C57BL/6 recipients with a median survival time of 49 days, which is comparable to those of many previously defined non-H-2 H antigens. The specificity of this response for SV40 T-antigen was demonstrated by the identification of SV40 T-antigen-specific cytolytic T lymphocytes and antibodies in multiply-grafted recipients. Although these cytolytic T lymphocytes could detect SV40 T-antigen on syngeneic SV40-transformed fibroblasts, they neither could be stimulated by splenic lymphocytes from T-antigen transgenics nor could they lyse lymphoblast targets from T-antigen transgenics. These observations suggest a limited tissue distribution of SV40 T-antigen in these transgenics. These results confirm the role of viral genes in the determination of non-H-2 histocompatibility antigenes by the strict criteria that such antigenes stimulate (1) tissue graft rejection and (2) generation of cytolytic T lymphocytes. Furthermore, they suggest that the SV40 enhancer and promoter region can target expression of SV-40 T-antigen to skin cells of transgenic animals.     

Inhibition of antiskin allograft immunity induced by infusions with photoinactivated effector T lymphocytes (PET cells)

Induction of tolerance for skin allotransplantation requires selective suppression of the host response to foreign histocompatibility antigens. This report describes a new approach which employs pre-treatment with 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) and ultraviolet A light (UVA) to render the effector cells of graft rejection immunogenic for the syngeneic recipient. Eight days after BALB/c mice received CBA/j skin grafts, their splenocytes were treated with 100 ng/ml 8-MOP and 1 J/cm2 UVA prior to reinfusion into naive BALB/c recipients. Recipient mice were tested for tolerance to alloantigens in mixed leukocyte culture (MLC), cytotoxicity (CTL), delayed-type hypersensitivity assays (DTH), and challenge with a fresh CBA/j graft. Splenocytes from BALB/c recipients of photoinactivated splenocytes containing the effector cells of CBA/j alloantigen rejection proliferated poorly in MLC and generated lower cytotoxic T-cell responses to CBA/j alloantigens in comparison with sensitized and naive controls and suppressed the MLC and CTL response to alloantigen from sensitized and naive BALB/c mice. In vivo, the DTH response was specifically suppressed to the relevant alloantigen in comparison with controls. BALB/c mice treated in this fashion retained a CBA/j skin graft for up to 42 days post-transplantation without visual evidence of rejection. These results showed that reinfusion of photoinactivated effector cells resulted in an immunosuppressive host response which specifically inhibited in vitro and in vivo responses that correlate with allograft rejection and permitted prolonged retention of histoincompatible skin grafts.     

Immunodominance in the T cell response to multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility antigens. IV. Partial tissue distribution and mapping of immunodominant antigens

The immunization of C57BL/6 responder mice with spleen cells from H-2-matched BALB.B donors, which differ by multiple non-H-2 histocompatibility (H) antigens, results in the generation of cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) that are specific for only a limited number of immunodominant antigens. Previous analysis of the genes encoding these dominant antigens has not mapped these genes to any of the non-H-2 H loci defined by congenic strains. It would have been expected that the histogenetic techniques employed for congenic strain selection would have preferentially identified the "strongest" H antigens. Therefore, we have investigated the possibility that immunodominant antigens do not belong to the class of non-H-2 H antigens encoded by genes mapping to H loci defined and mapped by congenic strains. The first experiments were aimed at identifying antigens that were expressed by independently derived inbred strains and were cross-reactive with the immunodominant cytotoxic T cell target (CTT-1) antigen of BALB.B. Strong cross-reaction with the C3H.SW (H-2b) strain was observed; the C3H gene encoding this antigen was mapped with BXH recombinant inbred strains. Contrary to the mapping of the CTT-1 gene to chromosome 1 in BALB.B, the C3H gene was shown to map to either chromosome 4 or chromosome 7. This result indicates that identical, or at least extensively cross-reactive, non-H-2 antigens may be encoded by genes mapping to independently segregating loci in different inbred strains. The tissue distribution of immunodominant antigens was approached by determining the reactivity of CTL specific for these antigens with either lymphoid-derived or fibroblast-derived targets. These CTL effectively lysed lymphoblast and lymphoid tumor targets but did not lyse an SV40-transformed fibroblast line that was shown to be efficiently lysed by CTL specific for non-H-2 H antigens defined by congenic strains. Therefore, it was concluded that immunodominant antigens detected by B6 anti-BALB.B CTL have a restricted tissue distribution in comparison to non-H-2 H antigens defined by congenic strains. The implications of these results for our understanding of the origin and heterogeneity of non-H-2 cell-surface antigen recognized by effector T cells are discussed.     

Immunodominance in the graft-vs-host disease T cell response to minor histocompatibility antigens

Immunodominance controls the generation of CTL in the C57BL/6By (B6) anti-BALB.B H-2b-matched strain combination. Despite the potential of responding to numerous individual minor histocompatibility (H) Ag on BALB.B APC, the focus of the CTL response is largely specific for only a limited number of target Ag. These minor H Ag could be distinguished by their differential expression on a panel of target cells from the CXB recombinant inbred strains, the E, G, I, J, and K (all H-2b), which express different composites of the original BALB minor H Ag. A hierarchy was observed in which first-order immunodominant Ag were present on both CXBK and CXBG cells, whereas second-order dominant Ag were found on CXBE, CXBJ, and CXBI cells. To test whether immunodominance also plays a role in the development of lethal graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) directed to multiple minor H Ag, B6 T cells were transplanted along with T cell depleted bone marrow, to irradiated (825 rad) recipients of either the BALB.B or CXB recombinant inbred strains. The results indicate that a hierarchy of immunodominance does exist in GVHD, but it differs from that predicted from the in vitro CTL studies. GVHD was observed in BALB.B, CXBE, CXBI, and CXBJ recipients, but not in CXBG and CXBK recipients. Presensitization of B6 donor mice to CXBG or CXBK splenocytes 3 wk before transplant did not significantly increase the overall GVHD potential in the corresponding CXBG or CXBK recipients. Evidence for second-order immunodominance was provided by the transfer of CXBE T cells and ATBM to irradiated CXBG and BALB.B recipients with resultant, potent GVHD.     

Antigraft responses to the H-28c antigen by B6 and B6D2F1 mice

The survival of minor H antigen-bearing skin grafts from donors congenic with C57BL/6 (B6) was compared in B6, B6D2, and AB6 hybrid recipients. In a case singled out for further study, B6 mice were found to reject HW 110 skin (H-28^c antigen) rapidly, whereas B6D2 mice rejected HW110 skin much more slowly and variably. Both major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-linked and non-MHC genes appeared to affect the survival of HW110 strain skin grafts on B6 and B6D2 recipients. Results of several experiments appear to rule out the sharing of H-28° epitopes between donors and recipients as an explanation for the relatively poor response of B6D2 mice to HW 110 skin grafts. Experiments involving bone marrow chimeras produced by the reciprocal exchange of bone marrow between irradiated B6 and B6D2 mice suggest that bone marrow-derived donor cells and non-bone-marrow-derived host cells each contribute to the immune response phenotype with respect to the H-28° antigen. An attempt was made to determine whether B6D2 mice that failed to reject HW110 strain skin grafts possessed suppressor cells specific for the H-28^c antigen. Spleen cells from poorly responsive B6D2 mice failed to suppress the rejection of HW 110 skin grafts when assayed in immunodeficient mice that were provided with cells from immune 136132 donors that were highly responsive to HW110 skin grafts.     

Tolerance or immunity to a tumor antigen expressed in somatic cells can be determined by systemic proinflammatory signals at the time of first antigen exposure.

Mice transgenic for the E7 tumor Ag of human papillomavirus type 16, driven from a keratin 14 promoter, express E7 in keratinocytes but not dendritic cells. Grafted E7-transgenic skin is not rejected by E7-immunized mice that reject E7-transduced transplantable tumors. Rejection of recently transplanted E7-transgenic skin grafts, but not of control nontransgenic grafts or of established E7-transgenic grafts, is induced by systemic administration of live or killed Listeria monocytogenes or of endotoxin. Graft recipients that reject an E7 graft reject a subsequent E7 graft more rapidly and without further L. monocytogenes exposure, whereas recipients of an E7 graft given without L. monocytogenes do not reject a second graft, even if given with L. monocytogenes. Thus, cross-presentation of E7 from keratinocytes to the adaptive immune system occurs with or without a proinflammatory stimulus, but proinflammatory stimuli at the time of first cross-presentation of Ag can determine the nature of the immune response to the Ag. Furthermore, immune effector mechanisms responsible for rejection of epithelium expressing a tumor Ag in keratinocytes are different from those that reject an E7-expressing transplantable tumor. These observations have implications for immunotherapy for epithelial cancers.     

Incidence and phenotypic heterogeneity of Moloney virus-induced leukemias: a multigenic control

The incidence of leukemias was established in mice of different inbred strains inoculated with Moloney leukemia virus (M-MuLV), and a complex genetic control was found. To characterize the different steps of the host-virus relationship further, the degree of viremia, the appearance of leukemia, organ involvement, and the surface phenotype of leukemic cells were studied in individual mice. The results demonstrate that: a) The viremia was controlled by H-2 and non-H-2 genes. Three H-2 genes located in the I and D or T region of the MHC behave like immune-response genes controlling the specific antiviral immune response. Other gene(s) mapped outside the complex also affected the virus production. Both sets of genes influenced leukemia incidence, since leukemias were observed only in highly viremic strains. b) Additional non-H-2 genes, which were not involved in viremia control, were determinants in the induction of malignancies because some sensitive strains do not become leukemic despite high levels of viremia. c) The anatomical type of Moloney virus-induced leukemias varied according to the non-H-2 background. Most of the leukemias arising in B10 congeneic mice involved the thymus and were frequently limited to this organ, whereas BALB mice preferentially developed splenic leukemias. d) In a given inbred strain, the leukemias arising in different animals frequently expressed different phenotypes. It can be concluded that Moloney virus-induced leukemia is a multistep process, viral production being necessary but not sufficient in and of itself to induce a malignant transformation.     

Chromosomal mapping of four different integration sites of Moloney murine leukemia virus including the locus for alpha 1(I) collagen in mouse

Infection of mouse embryos with Moloney murine leukemia virus (M-MuLV) has yielded several mouse substrains with stable germ line integration of retroviral DNA at distinct chromosomal loci (Mov loci; Jaenisch et al., 1981). There is evidence that flanking DNA sequences can have an effect on virus expression and, conversely, inserted viral DNA may affect the expression of adjacent host genes. As part of our studies on the interaction of inserted M-MuLV with the mouse genome, we have chromosomally mapped four different Mov loci by hybridizing single-copy mouse sequences, flanking the proviral DNA, to interspecies somatic cell hybrids. Furthermore, these sequences were assigned regionally by in situ hybridization to mouse metaphase chromosomes. In Mov-13 mice, M-MuLV had inserted into the alpha 1(I) collagen gene leading to early embryonic death in homozygotes. We have assigned this locus to the distal region of chromosome 11. Thus, the alpha 1(I) collagen gene is part of an evolutionarily conserved linkage group with the homologous genes on human chromosome 17. Three other proviral integration sites were mapped to chromosome 1, bands BC (Mov-7), chromosome 11, bands BC (Mov-9), and chromosome 3, bands FG (Mov-10). The Mov-10-specific probe detects an EcoRI-specific restriction fragment length polymorphism, which can make this probe a useful genetic marker.     

Cardiac allografts in mice congenic at non-H-2 histocompatibility loci

Neonatal mouse heart fragments were grafted under the ear skin of adult recipients. Cardiac allograft survival was evaluated by visual observation of pulsation, electrocardiography, and histology. Employing a series of congenic resistant strains differing from C57BL/10Sn at theH-1, H-3,H-4, H-7, H-8, H-9, H-10, H-11, andH-12 loci, the median survival times of the heart grafts to and from C57BL/10Sn were obtained. The various interallelic combinations resulted in a wide variation of graft survival. Reciprocal transplants frequently showed different survival times.H-1 ^c grafts were rejected by B10.129(5M)/nSn female mice with a median survival time of 90 days.H-1 ^b grafts were not rejected by C57BL/10Sn mice for the experiment's duration of 200 days. The weaker the histocompatibility barrier, the more variable the survival times and the smaller the ratio of rejected to total grafted heart fragments. Female recipients were observed to reject their grafts more rapidly and to reject a higher proportion than males of the same strain. Although the strength of the different non-H-2 barriers generally paralleled that determined by skin transplants, the rankings of the strongest minor barriers were not the same for both tissues.     

Natural suppressor cell inhibiting T killer responses against retroviruses: a model for self tolerance

We previously reported the characterization of a spontaneous suppressor T cell population (NSC) present in naive mice and able to suppress the cytotoxic response (CTL) against tumor cells induced only by endogenous Gross virus (GLV). In this study we demonstrate the existence of such NSC inhibiting the CTL activity against tumor cells induced by the normally exogenous Moloney virus (M-MLV) in mice of the Mov-13 (V+) strain in which the M-MLV has been artificially endogenized and which express the virus during the embryonal life. These NSC are not found in other Mov strains in which the endogenized M-MLV is not expressed during fetal life. The implication of these data in the mechanism of self tolerance is discussed.     

Kidney transplantation between congenic versus standard inbred strains of rats: I The significance ofH-1 and non-H-1 gene differences

Concepts of “antigenic strength” in organ transplantation have been evaluated in relation to orthotopic kidney allografts inH-1 congenic strains of rats. Untreated recipients reject fully allogeneic kidneys possessing singleH-1 differences as acutely as kidneys displaying multiple histocompatibility differences. Heterozygozity for H-1 specificities as well as for H-1 plus non-H-1 specificities (semiallogeneic kidneys) favors long term survival (autoenhancement), especially when the specific immune response genes of the recipient lead to reduced reactivity. In active enhancement, the transplantedH-1 congenic kidneys, devoid of additional weak antigens, retain prolonged functional integrity. Weak non-H-1 antigens substantially influence the successful establishment of specific enhancement in an adverse way, either as additive immunogens or as target sites for the effector arm of the rejection response.     

Endogenous Moloney leukemia virus in nonviremic Mov substrains of mice carries defects in the proviral genome

Substrains of mice carrying Moloney murine leukemia virus as a Mendelian gene (Mov locus) have been derived previously. Some of these strains, i.e., Mov-3 and Mov-9, develop viremia, whereas others, i.e., Mov-2, Mov-7, and Mov-10, do not regularly activate virus. We previously have molecularly cloned the respective Mov loci and shown that proviral clones derived from the different viral loci were either infectious (Mov-3, Mov-9) or failed to induce infectious virus (Mov-2, Mov-7, Mov-10) in a transfection assay. To analyze the sites affecting infectivity of the latter clones, complementation assays, in vitro recombinations, and marker rescue experiments were performed. Our results show that the three endogenous Moloney murine leukemia virus clones derived from Mov-2, Mov-7, and Mov-10 carry different mutations in the gag-pol region of the proviral genome. No inhibitory effect of flanking mouse sequences on provirus infectivity was observed.     

Histocompatibility antigen changes associated with pink-eyed dilute (p) mutations

The tight linkage between the H-4 histocompatibility locus and the pink-eyed dilute (p) locus raises the possibility that a single gene is responsible for both a histocompatibility antigen and coat color phenotype. To examine this possibility, we have investigated the effects of a spontaneous coat color mutation, pink-eyed unstable (p ^un ), which occurred at the p locus in the C57BL/6J inbred strain, on histocompatibility antigen phenotype. Skin grafts were transplanted from two independently maintained B6 p ^un substrains to coisogenic, wild-type C57BL/6 recipients; graft rejection uniformly commenced at 6–7 weeks but did not culminate in complete graft destruction as observed in other cases of crisis rejection. Neither the onset of rejection time nor the intensity of rejection could be accelerated by introducing new H-2 haplotypes into the wild-type recipients. These results suggested that the p ^un allele was associated with a histocompatibility antigen not shared with C57BL/6. The p ^un allele is characterized by a relatively high frequency of reversion to wild-type. Therefore, skin grafts from B6-p ^un donors were transplanted to homozygous, revertant (+/+) recipients which were subline-matched with the donors; these grafts underwent crisis rejection with the same time of onset of rejection as observed with C57BL/6 recipients. These observations indicate that a new histocompatibility antigen is associated with the p ^un mutation and is lost upon reversion to wild type; this association is the first demonstration of a link between histocompatibility and coat color phenotypes.     

Review lecture. Immunology of H-Y antigen and its role in sex determination

H-Y was originally discovered as a transplantation antigen that caused female mice of certain inbred strains to reject skin from otherwise identical males. The ability to make the skin graft rejection response and, in vitro, cytotoxic T cell responses against H-Y is controlled by genes within the major histocompatibility complex, H-2, and by non-H-2 genes. H-Y belongs to a class of weak transplantation antigens characterized by an inability to elicit responses under many conditions. Although genetic factors are very important in determining responsiveness, their action can be modified by immunization procedures. H-Y has been proposed as the differentiation signal that causes the formation of the testes from the undifferentiated gonad in the developing embryo. This hypothesis has been explored by using a series of mice whose karyotype and phenotypic sex are paradoxical.     

Rejection of mouse cardiac allografts by costimulation in trans

The activation of T cells by B7 costimulation in trans has been demonstrated in vitro, but the in vivo relevance is unknown. To study costimulation in trans of CD4(+) T cells in vivo, we performed cardiac transplants from B7-1/B7-2-deficient mice to recipients that do not express MHC class II molecules on peripheral APCs, but do have functional CD4(+) T cells (II(-)/4(+) mice). This model restricts the B7-dependent activation of CD4(+) T cells to costimulation in trans and excludes any contribution from indirect Ag presentation. We find that II(-)/4(+) recipients reject B7-deficient grafts as rapidly as wild-type grafts, suggesting that costimulation in trans can mediate rejection as potently as costimulation in cis. Treatment of II(-)/4(+) recipients of B7-deficient grafts with depleting Abs to CD4 or CD8 demonstrates that indirect Ag presentation to CD8(+) cells does not significantly contribute to rejection. This is the first demonstration that costimulation in trans can mediate an immune response in vivo and has important therapeutic implications.     

Infectivity and structure of molecular clones obtained from two genetically transmitted Moloney leukemia proviral genomes.

The Mov-2 and Mov-10 substrains of mice, each carrying Moloney leukemia virus (= M-MuLV) in their germ line at the Mov-2 and Mov-10 locus, respectively, do occasionally at a later age (Mov-2) or not at all (Mov-10) activate infectious virus. The M-MuLV proviruses with flanking mouse sequences corresponding to the Mov-2 and Mov-10 locus, respectively, were molecularly cloned. Restriction enzyme analysis revealed no major deletions or insertions in the proviral genomes of the Mov-2 and Mov-10 locus. Both cloned DNAs induced XC plaques in a transfection assay. The specific infectivity, however, was very low and 3T3 cells transfected with the Mov-2 or Mov-10 clone did not produce infectious virus. Removing part of the 5' cellular sequences from the Mov-10 clone did not increase the infectivity. The results suggest that the M-MuLV integrated at the Mov-2 and Mov-10 locus carry a mutation which prevents synthesis of infectious virus but permits XC plaque induction by partial genome expression or synthesis of non-infectious particles.     

Non-H-2-linked genetic regulation of cytotoxic responses to hapten-modified syngeneic cells. I. Non-H-2-linked Ir gene defect expressed on T cells is not predetermined at the stage of bone marrow cells

Spleen cells from C3H/He or BALB.K mice immunized to the newly synthesized amino-reactive hapten 5-sulfo-1-naphthoxy acetic acid N-hydroxysuccinimide ester (AED-NH2) were stimulated in vitro with AED-NH2-modified syngeneic cells. After 5 days of culture, effector cells were assayed for their cytotoxic activity against AED-NH2-modified target blast cells. C3H/He and BALB.K mice exhibited the respective high and low anti-AED-NH2 cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) responses. This contrasted with the observation that both of these H-2k strains generated potent CTL responses against aminoreactive haptens, e.g., trinitrophenyl (TNP). Because C3H.SW and BALB.B strains, which are the H-2b counterpart of the above two strains, also represented the respective high and low responders to AED-NH2 hapten, this hapten model enabled us to investigate cellular mechanisms underlying the above non-H-2-associated genetic regulation of CTL responses (C3H vs BALB non-H-2 backgrounds). The results demonstrated that there was no detectable difference between C3H/He and BALB.K strains in the lysability of target cells and the ability of stimulating cells to activate primed spleen cells. Anti-AED-NH2 CTL responses were only marginal when antigen-presenting cells (APC) were eliminated from the primed spleen cells of high responder C3H/He or (C3H/He X BALB.K)F1 mice. The addition of APC to cultures free of APC regained an appreciable CTL response in C3H/He or (C3H/He X BALB.K)F1 mice, irrespective of whether APC were derived from high (C3H/He) or low (BALB.K) responders. We have also demonstrated that allogeneic radiation bone marrow chimera (BALB.K----C3H/He) exhibited a CTL response comparable to that induced by C3H/He mice, whereas the reverse direction of allogeneic chimera (C3H/He----BALB.K) induced a marginal CTL response. These results indicate that this non-H-2-associated Ir gene defect is expressed on T cells (CTL precursors and/or helper T cells) rather than APC, and that this T cell defect is not predetermined at the level of bone marrow cells. The results are discussed in the light of the genetic and cellular mechanisms underlying non-H-2-linked Ir gene control.     

The influence of graft size on the induction of immunity versus tolerance to H-Y in H-2 k strains of mice

Unprimed female CBA mice do not reject large (10 mm²) syngeneic male skin grafts. However, a high proportion do reject small (4 mm²) grafts. Nevertheless, rejection does not invariably result in an anamnestic response. In some cases, the immunity induced by the rejection of a small graft was overcome, and tolerance was induced by a subsequent challenge with a large graft. This suggests that the transplantation response to minor antigens is subject to active regulation, and screening of other H-2 ^k strains indicates that the nature of the response (i. e., immunity or tolerance) is determined by a gene or genes mapping outside the major histocompatibility complex.